Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 7)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter seven in our deep dive on the
- 0:05Dugger family and a lot of ancillary topics like the ethics and the legality of
- 0:11using children in social media, the prentification concept, and other kinds of things
- 0:18that we've already gotten into and we will get into. Welcome to the Psychology
- 0:22and Seattle Podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkanda. I'm a therapist and
- 0:25a professor. Who are you, Burrow? My name is and I unfinished
- 0:29basements. Okay, So to catch you up regarding the timeline, we've talked
- 0:33about the beginnings of the Dugger family, possibly the trauma that both Michelle and
- 0:40Jim Bob went through when they went through a difficult miscarriage experience. We talked
- 0:45about the possibility how that could have affected them emotionally and benefactor in them developing
- 0:52into the quiver full movement where they want to never not be pregnant kind of
- 0:58a thing, or never be unappreciative of the ability to have kids or something
- 1:03hard to know, but we went into that. We talked about how in
- 1:08two thousand and two, way before they were on television at all, the
- 1:12parents discovered that Josh was abusing the younger girls, including a babysitter. We
- 1:19talked a lot about how most parents usually don't tell anyone about it because they're
- 1:26terrified, so there wasn't really that much of a difference with the Dugger parents.
- 1:30Of course, we would wish that they would have done more, but
- 1:34most parents don't for a variety of I think understandable reasons, mostly because our
- 1:38system is not set up to be very welcoming or safe for families to step
- 1:46forward with this information. So, you know, because it's not hard to
- 1:49imagine that if this information got out, like if your daughter were to do
- 1:56something like this and tell you about it, I'm sure you would think,
- 2:00my god, what if this gets out there, and once it's out there,
- 2:05it's on the internet, anyone can post it right for the rest of
- 2:08eternity, and you could potentially alter the course of your future life to something
- 2:15that was very, very difficult, one filled with oscratization and bullying and never
- 2:22being able to get a job, being put on some sort of list where
- 2:25all your neighbors know who you are, no one would ever want to be
- 2:29your friend, no one would ever want to date you or marry you.
- 2:32You know, like it literally that could be the course of your life.
- 2:37So you know, you could imagine being a little concerned about that information getting
- 2:42out there. Now we can talk about the ethics of that. You know.
- 2:47On one hand, of course, we want to be able to protect
- 2:51our kids against these kinds of predators, and they should be known to us.
- 2:57You know, if one lives next door, particularly if they're at risk
- 3:00of abusing and and they're being friendly with us and our kids are around,
- 3:06and they seem to be a really good, kind of fun uncle sort of
- 3:09character, you would want to know. So where's the line there between putting
- 3:15someone on public notice within reason versus ruining people's lives and maybe even setting them
- 3:23up for recidivitization because they're completely ostracized and they might not have anything to lose.
- 3:30And it's well known that for perpetrators of these kinds of horrendous crimes,
- 3:36when they go through treatment and they get support, then they're much less likely
- 3:39to commit these kinds of crimes. Part of the things what you're bringing up
- 3:43is there is no at least well understood gradient of engagement and response. It's
- 3:50basically in one's mind, it's all or nothing, like basically, either I
- 3:53just keep quiet, or my child will spend a lifetime in jail, even
- 3:58though that's not technically right, like mental, I feel like that's what it
- 4:00feels like. And and there's no publicized or understood gradient of response, like
- 4:05actually, no, here's some guidelines if your child is over this age,
- 4:09and if there's if the action has been this, if others are involved,
- 4:13here's what you call, here's what you do. None of that, right,
- 4:15So it feels not only overwhelming, but it does feel like if you
- 4:17pull a trigger, which first of all, you're not even sure which trigger
- 4:21that, it's like the end, right, yeah, And that's a total
- 4:25lack of awareness, education and everything, right, And to be clear,
- 4:29the right thing to do is to contact a specialist because they're not going to
- 4:35publicize this information unless it's criminally necessary for some reason. They're certainly not going
- 4:42to just start blabbing about it or tweeting about it. And these individuals are
- 4:46perfectly situated and trained to treat the perpetrator such that they are much less likely
- 4:55to do this again, which is usually what the perpetrator wants. Psychopaths maybe
- 5:00not so much, but the average abuser of children is not a psychopath.
- 5:05They have a condition and they're making justifications in their minds, and they might
- 5:12have been modeled this sort of behavior or something, and there is a path
- 5:15to not doing this in the future. There are many people even without treatment,
- 5:20there are many minor attracted individuals who choose not to offend. So,
- 5:28you know, the Dugger parents didn't report it at first, but they did
- 5:31eventually report it. It should be noted they did go to family friends,
- 5:39which isn't a specialist, but it's something it's probably anecdotally more than average in
- 5:45terms of what people will do, although I will say that anecdotally, if
- 5:49parents do one thing, they'll go to a family friend. You know,
- 5:55you could imagine that, right. And the other thing they did is they
- 5:57did again this is not the right response based on what we've discussed, but
- 6:00they did go to the hierarchy of structure that they were within. They are
- 6:06supposed to talk about things with their elders in the church because that's the hierarchy
- 6:11they're in. Again, that's not what they should do in reality, but
- 6:14in their minds they're like, well, I don't know were I called my
- 6:15cop friend. I did tell people that needed to know. I told the
- 6:19church what else am I supposed to do? Yeah, And we don't know
- 6:23the motivation. They could have been saying, well, we'll go through the
- 6:28motions and then we'll not have to face this anymore. Or were they legit
- 6:32concerned about their younger daughters and other kids for that matter, and were doing
- 6:40what they thought was what you're supposed to do. Yeah. So they eventually
- 6:45do go to the church, and that involves a lot of people. I
- 6:47think they went to like central headquarters with this information, So that's a lot
- 6:54of people that they went to who have access to the internet that sort of
- 6:58thing. They, as you say, went to a family friend who was
- 7:01a police officer. It seemed well, honestly, and we don't know,
- 7:08but I can imagine that happening. You know, like someone's like, well,
- 7:10let's talk to Bobby. Bobby is in the force, maybe he can
- 7:13advise us, Right, And why go to a stranger police officer when you
- 7:18can go to someone that you know. Plus they live in rural Arkansas,
- 7:23so there might only be three police officers anyway. Well, it turns out
- 7:27that that police officer has been convicted and incarcerated twice. After the Duggers went
- 7:34to this police officer for child pornography. So did they know that, I
- 7:41don't know, but so we have no way of really knowing their true intentions,
- 7:46motivations, boundaries, Like for all we know, it was always a
- 7:49concern about hurting his political career and later hurting their their show and stuff.
- 7:55But like you pointed out, and at first, when you first said this
- 7:58in one of the previous episodes, I was like, wait what because you
- 8:01said, like, you know, a lot of families would react the same
- 8:03way, and I was kind of shocked by that. But then as we
- 8:05talked about it and I thought about I'm like, yeah, I guess you're
- 8:07right. Which family would immediately call the cops on their on their kid?
- 8:11It's hard to imagine. Yeah, nearly impossible. I mean, unless you've
- 8:16been having ongoing problems with the child that we're highly concerning than maybe, but
- 8:24it's not usually the case. I think it's really easy to be on a
- 8:28soapbox from the internet and be like, the parents are monsters, We're not
- 8:31protecting their younger kids. And you know, because you've never been in that
- 8:35situation as a person who has observed many families going through this sort of thing,
- 8:41at verious different points. Sometimes I'm literally in the room with the parents
- 8:46and the kid when I discover this, when the information comes out, like
- 8:50one of the other siblings will reveal it in a family session or the perpetrator.
- 8:54I've had even a child perpetrator just volunteer the information in session. And
- 9:00then other times I'll be the one that they call once it's been reported to
- 9:03child protective services. So you know, I've been at all different points in
- 9:07the timeline, and I can tell you that the Duggers, anecdotally, we're
- 9:13responding above average in terms of what I would see. The one part that
- 9:18I do think from the documentary and whatnot where they completely dropped the ball.
- 9:22In my opinion, trying to protect the younger, especially the victims, is
- 9:26like parading them in the can't say yeah, it's fine to get them in
- 9:30front of the cameras to defend their older brother and stuff like that. Is
- 9:33that is really bad and damaging, right, And we'll get into the specifics
- 9:37thing the specific things that they said now. I want to be clear,
- 9:41I'm not saying that Duggers did a good job. I'm just saying they did
- 9:43an above average job. The average job that parents do is terrible, and
- 9:48that's a result of lack of education, lack of awareness, and a system
- 9:52that is not set up to, like I said, be very welcoming to
- 9:56not only families, but also perpetrators. The system should be well welcoming to
- 10:00perpetrators to step forward because they often do want help and they can get help,
- 10:05and there's not a lot of education around that. Plus sometimes if they
- 10:07do step forward, they might be outed in ways that are not necessary and
- 10:13punitive and they know that. So there's the system has a problem. I
- 10:18always just use the analogy of if you had an older sibling that was beating
- 10:26the younger sibling, right, you know, although still stigmatized and worrisome to
- 10:31parents, the pathway to treatment or even the police would be much faster and
- 10:39expedient and without all the fraught issues that we've been talking about. So there's
- 10:43not even an expression like he's a beater, he's a sibling beater. I
- 10:48mean there's stigma, but it wouldn't at last the rest of your life such
- 10:54that you'd never be able to get married or get a job or anything like
- 10:58that. And the stigma is a lot more are understood. Well, they
- 11:01are kids and that sucks. But he's got to get correct that behavior has
- 11:03got to get corrected out of him. Right, he has an anger problem,
- 11:07whereas you are an evil devil monster. I mean, that's what people
- 11:11believe about perpetrators. And to be clear, I've treated some of these evil
- 11:16devil monsters. They exist, but among perpetrators, they are a small minority
- 11:22of those intors. They're actually like psychopath statistic Yeah, early in my career,
- 11:26I mean yeah, it's I mean it's hard to know if they got
- 11:31better later on because I didn't work with them for decades. But I get
- 11:35chills just thinking about how obsessed they were with any sort of harm of another
- 11:43human being. I mean it, and the amount of I mean just obsessed,
- 11:48and they couldn't control themselves. And that's the other part of this is
- 11:50that, unlike Hannibal Lecter, these individuals are caught very easily because they have
- 11:56a personality disorder that gives them a compulsion or a tendency or a distortion of
- 12:07perceptions that very quickly lands them in trouble and often in prison. Any like
- 12:11Bundy reoffending within minutes of magically escaping, right, right, So I mean
- 12:20he's sort of a special case because of the nature of the crimes, the
- 12:24just demonstrating that the even though he seemed like an intelligent individual and stuff,
- 12:30none of that guarded him from the compulsions, right yeah. I mean the
- 12:33most poignant example is he is incarcerated twice, escapes twice. Upon a second
- 12:41escape, he actually manages to get away and get all the way from the
- 12:46West United States all the way to Florida and back. In the seventies,
- 12:52that's basically like you made it, you escaped. You're basically like across the
- 12:56Mexican board, you know what I mean, Like there's no tracking of individuals,
- 13:00there's snow security cameras everywhere. You know, you're basically off the map.
- 13:05So he waited a decade, right too. I think he waited a
- 13:07week or something. Yeah, and and just walked into a sorority house I
- 13:13like a block from where he lived and killed I think four girls and was
- 13:18seen by some other of the potential victims that could I d him later,
- 13:24And so at least that's my memory. Yeah, it's almost as trivial in
- 13:28his brain triggering these compulsions as like I've already had six springles, I should
- 13:31probably stop. I'm gonna have a seventh one. Not a big deal.
- 13:33I'm just having pringles, but I'm compulsed to have it. And then his
- 13:37brain is like, yeah, wait, so the pringles are the horrific murders.
- 13:43Like how I'm saying, how like for quote unquote not psychopathic statistics,
- 13:48you're trying to make it relatable. Yeah, Like, for the first time
- 13:50in my life, I now can relate to tech. If you look at
- 13:54a thing of p you can't have just three prings, but you want to
- 13:56stop. But it's so you never like agonize that much over In fact,
- 14:01it's kind of autonomic. It's like, oh, another pringle. In his
- 14:05case, it's like, oh another murder. Yeah yeah, yeah, I've
- 14:07had six, but I'll have to. I mean, if I went to
- 14:09prison for pringles, eating and escape escape magically, the second to the first
- 14:15thing I would do is you know, what are they? What's the commercial
- 14:18pop you can't can't stop or something anyway, So we talked about that,
- 14:24and I want everyone if you have anger about the Dugger parents or Josh Dugger
- 14:31himself, the social answer is to advocate for changing our society and awareness and
- 14:37helping the experts in this field to have a voice in the conversation, because
- 14:43when you talk to specialists and ancillary specialists like myself, it changes the narrative
- 14:50a little bit, gives you a more broad understanding, accurate understanding of what's
- 14:56really happening and how we can treat these people and reduce the likelihood of these
- 15:01things, because you know, another problem that this creates is that when there's
- 15:05this black and white very there's very few topics in our society that are as
- 15:11black and white as this when you talk to people about you know, like,
- 15:16say you have a friend who you're like, yeah, so just let
- 15:18you know he's on a list for sexual offenders and fifteen years ago he abused
- 15:26three little girls, but he went through treatment and he's better. How many
- 15:31people would would be like, oh yeah, and invite him over to my
- 15:33house. I know they wouldn't. They would hate me for even having a
- 15:39friend. Yeah, that must mean I'm a they would think they would all
- 15:43support this. Obviously, Obviously you're a predator yourself for being so like,
- 15:50there's very few things that are as black and white in our society about this.
- 15:54So the answer is to make it more accurate and not as black and
- 16:00white. Now, like I said, there are situations where it is black
- 16:03and white, but those are rare, but we need to acknowledge it.
- 16:06Well, and here's what I'm not doing. I'm not letting this individual babysitting
- 16:10my kids. Sure, but that's not that That's but one of thousands of
- 16:15decisions or interactions you could potentially have with someone that's in that situation, you
- 16:22know. So so anyway, and the system acknowledges the gray, the experts,
- 16:29the law. There's a lot of nuance within the system, within the
- 16:33experts, but society doesn't know this because it's so rarely talked about because who
- 16:38you know, where's the me too movement for perpetrators? Essentially? Is what
- 16:42it is? You know, like, hey, I mean it's it's kind
- 16:45of a weird parallel, But where's the movement or the ribbon for saying,
- 16:52hey, we need to have a more nuanced position on sexual abuse in our
- 16:56socist is your Pringles moment? Well? Where? But where who's the what
- 17:00politician? Right? What you tu be bad position to take? Yeah?
- 17:03What I'm what YouTuber is going to I'm here to stand for perpetrators, right,
- 17:10I mean not stand for p but there's a different angle to take,
- 17:12because certainly, I do think that's a kind of a losing proposition to say
- 17:17I'm here to defend. But really, and I think what you're getting at
- 17:19and what I would be getting at two is no, no, no,
- 17:22there's gonna be more perpetrators and it's gonna be bad, and no one's gonna
- 17:25know what to do because we're not changing the way we talk about it,
- 17:27the way we deal with it, the way I see it, I'm standing
- 17:30up for victims and future victims because when we have a rational approach and a
- 17:36more welcoming approach to all those involved, guess what, the victimization goes down.
- 17:42But it's like having as. That's a good parallel. It's abstinence.
- 17:47Only you see a problem like teenage pregnancy and you're like as and sdis and
- 17:55you're like, okay, abstinence problem solved. And then you look at this
- 18:00to sticks. Guess what increased STIs increased teenage pregnancy. So alcoholism, just
- 18:06stop drinking, yeah, just don't drink, yeah, or we won't talk
- 18:08about it. We won't talk You can't talk about it in school because that
- 18:12promotes those kinds of things. So we'll just act like it doesn't exist.
- 18:17Guess what, more problems. So if we're actually going to lower the rates
- 18:21of victimization and pain and agony and trauma, then we have to acknowledge that
- 18:26these things are happening and also just have a more nuanced position on these sorts
- 18:33of situations anyway, including the parents such as such as I'm not I don't
- 18:37care. I don't give a shit about the Duggers. What I care about
- 18:41are all the families that might be listening or people out there listening right now
- 18:47who might hear of another family who has a problem like this. My hope
- 18:52is that people will not just jump down these individuals throats, that they'll actually
- 18:59be more rational about it. Now, if the individual is a true monster
- 19:03monster, then yeah, go for it, because I said, these are
- 19:07chilling individuals that probably should be in prison for a very long time. But
- 19:11those are rare individuals, and I don't think Josh Dugger is one of those
- 19:15people, honestly, given the presentation that we've heard, and if after being
- 19:18rational about it, like you're saying, contacting the right folks and stuff,
- 19:22the family or the people in question are not protecting the victims then you know
- 19:26that does require escalation and condemnation too, because ultimately, at some point,
- 19:32like you were saying in earlier shows, protecting the victims has to be the
- 19:34first priority. But yeah, it's one of these things we've also talked about
- 19:38before. How if you're growing up and you start having weird feelings about something,
- 19:42there are some categories that you can talk freely about and some that you
- 19:45should never mention to anyone, And those are the problems. Like, for
- 19:49example, you're growing up and you're like, uh, you know, you
- 19:52start feeling like, I don't know, I you know, I like watching
- 19:56a lot of TV late at night, so I stay up late, and
- 19:57that's probably something you can bring up to your parents or maybe a friend or
- 20:02something. But if it's like, yeah, I'm I'm starting to be attracted
- 20:06to young kids, that's not something you could ever bring up. And so
- 20:10since you can't bring it up, you're going to stuff it down in there
- 20:12until it either you know, you do something or you take your life or
- 20:17something you know really bad. And so again none of us would ever say
- 20:22like, it's cool love children. No, no, no, it's actually
- 20:26you need to be able to talk about it with the right folks, and
- 20:27everyone needs to be able to be receptive to it and point those folks to
- 20:30the right folks, so otherwise you bury it and then it explodes. Right,
- 20:36ninety five out of one hundred cases where someone realizes that, I mean,
- 20:40I don't know if that's the exact stat It's hard to know because the
- 20:42gathering of data regarding this is extremely difficult, obviously, but anecdotally and according
- 20:48to the I mean, some experts will say ninety nine point nine percent,
- 20:52but I don't necessarily anecdotally experience that. But a very high number of individuals
- 20:59that realize is when they're young, that they are attracted to miners are treatable
- 21:03and the marker for those out there who might be looking for something in the
- 21:10future to take note of to indicate that we have succeeded, which I don't
- 21:14imagine happening in my lifetime. So this is for the younger people that will
- 21:18outlive me. Is to look for the is in schools when they have a
- 21:26program, an awareness program where they have education around like hey, if you're
- 21:33attracted to children, we are here to listen. And everyone out there who
- 21:38isn't attracted to well, you know, I don't know exactly how you word
- 21:41it, but but for those of you who don't have this problem or this
- 21:47issue, and one of your friends does and they tell you about it,
- 21:52here's who you can talk to. And we should actually be very warm and
- 21:56welcoming and rewarding those individuals for stepping forward because they're doing themselves a favor,
- 22:03they're doing society a favor. And so when we see in the future after
- 22:08I'm dead, I'm thinking a program in school that actually and maybe all schools
- 22:14across the United States, that actually addresses this in a rational way to raise
- 22:18awareness and to have an open door policy to teachers or counselors on campus that
- 22:26actually works where people actually step forward. Because in the average elementary school or
- 22:32middle school or high school, there's probably at least a handful, if not
- 22:37more, of individuals that absolutely know that they have this attraction to younger children
- 22:45and are suppressing it or something. So it begins there, right, it
- 22:51begins in schools, it begins at home. And so when you see that,
- 22:56now, that's not the only measure is having a program in schools.
- 22:59It would also be a program for parents and churches and police, and you
- 23:03know, society in general, there might be TV shows, you know,
- 23:06maybe that would be actually mark Another marker is when you have a very special
- 23:11episode of Full House and the main characters has this yeah and goes through the
- 23:18process of treatment or something, and it's like primetime seven o'clock on a Thursday.
- 23:23Then you'll know that we have arrived. But can you fucking imagine Berto?
- 23:29No? Right? Right? Well, and so because the problem is
- 23:32so bad, I know that you've you've previously used the examples. How when
- 23:36it comes to violence, there's there's fewer taboos than sex. But even with
- 23:38violence, like take bullying in schools, the response if at all. First
- 23:44of all, you as a child are not very encouraged to tattletale on other
- 23:47kids. Right, so if you're getting bullied, you have this pressure like
- 23:51I shouldn't be I shouldn't rat him out whatever, Right, but let's say
- 23:53you you do, right, So the next step is the common conception is,
- 23:57oh, that's a bully, bad evil bully. You're a victim.
- 24:03And it occurs to me like, actually, that's all perpetuating this thing of
- 24:07like, the only possible response is this all or nothing? And granted,
- 24:11way less stigma when it comes to that than what we were talking about.
- 24:15But still, why about that bully? Why are they a bully? Aren't
- 24:18they going through pain and struggle? What is going on? And we don't
- 24:21have to talk about schools. Just look on the internet, right, the
- 24:25whole Karen phenomenon. Every time I see a quote unquote Karen video, I
- 24:30am at least most of them, I'm thinking, Okay, yeah, that
- 24:33individual seems unhinged, and from the looks of it, they're being very unfair
- 24:37and that person is struggling, right, there's something going on with that person.
- 24:42This is not an isolated event. They don't go home and smile and
- 24:48have a wonderful life outside of whatever was happening in that home depot as they're
- 24:52yelling for the manager this this individual has probably a lot of trauma that's being
- 24:57triggered. Yeah. So, and it's not just Karen, But sometimes they'll
- 25:03call them male Karen's, which is just evidence of how sexist that that term
- 25:07is. Sometimes they'll call him Kevin's I think, or something ken that doesn't
- 25:11really you'll literally most of the time. Anyway, point is is that you
- 25:15just have to look at even mature quote unquote adults who are on the internet
- 25:22and just black and whiting these situations all the time. We're just looking to
- 25:26ostracize people because we're all walking around with tremendously low self esteems and we need
- 25:32to compare ourselves to others and push other people down to temporarily make us feel
- 25:37like we're worth it, you know, And that is just the cause of
- 25:41so many problems in our study. But anyway, especially if you can intervene
- 25:44when you're chilling when they're kids, you know. Yeah, So let's take
- 25:47a break and we get back. Let's get back to my notes. What
- 25:49do you say, Bert, Let's do it. Okay, we're back from
- 25:56the break. So we talked about that and we just again talked about it.
- 26:02I think we further think conversation there. We also went into the specifics
- 26:06on the timeline regarding who was told what and when. We talked about how
- 26:11the Duggers rose to prominence with TLC in the mid oughts. We talked in
- 26:18depth about prentification and you made some discoveries for yourself about your pathway to prentification
- 26:25and your adult struggle with the syndrome. We also talked about how the letter
- 26:33in the book was found by someone outside of the family that was a crazy
- 26:37story man, and how that letter was circulated through the church and someone in
- 26:41the church called a hotline, but also they called the Oprah Winfree Show,
- 26:47and then the Duggers were canceled from going on that show, and then that
- 26:52led to a police investigation. But apparently nothing happened because the statute limitations and
- 26:59there was no editor evidence that CPS was called or a treatment specialist or called.
- 27:03It just seem like it was just swept under the rug. But there
- 27:06was a police report that will come to roost later on. Then we went
- 27:11into a long discussion about the ethics and legality about children being not only in
- 27:19the workplace but on television and in reality TV. And the long and the
- 27:25short of it is is that the laws and the regulations regarding children being in
- 27:30movies and TV is not as robust as it probably should be, but it's
- 27:34at least present in most states the United States. But for kids in reality
- 27:40TV, there is only one law that was recently passed in Illinois, and
- 27:45long story short, it's basically useless because of this one requirement. For the
- 27:52child to be protected, they need to not only be in a significant amount
- 27:56of the videos, but they need the videos need to make ten cents per
- 28:00view, which is unheard of unless you're maybe one of the top three YouTube
- 28:06influencers. As a child, you know what I mean, it's like you
- 28:10can't have child labor. You have to be you know, sixteen or over
- 28:14unless you pay them less than fifteen bucks an hour. Right, Yeah,
- 28:18it's it's kind of funny. It's like, yeah, actually it's not even
- 28:19fifteen bucks an hour. It's like, there's no protections for your underage workers.
- 28:23Yeah, unless you pay them a million dollars an hour. If you
- 28:26pay them literally a million dollars an hour. Because these there are there are
- 28:32a few kids on YouTube that are ginormous and just making millions of dollars a
- 28:37year. Unless you're one of those folks, then you have no protection.
- 28:44You have no protection. Yeah, and uh, it's it's pretty awful.
- 28:48We went into detail, i think, in the Patriots section about some very
- 28:51famous cases of children being harmed on social media on YouTube. Family of Five,
- 28:57Daddy O five, Mika Staffer, Jordan Cheyenne, the video of the
- 29:03dog you know crime or that kind of thing, Toddler's and Tiaras Dance moms.
- 29:08You know a lot of different stories, but I wanted to conclude that
- 29:12whole discussion of children on reality TV with the following question burto, so should
- 29:18it be illegal to have children on reality television and in social media? What
- 29:26do you think? Yeah? I mean, so making something fully illegal is
- 29:32a high bar. So for example, if that meant that in a reality
- 29:37show a child couldn't even appear on a frame of the of the of the
- 29:41show, you know that that's extreme. I feel like it needs to be
- 29:45more nuanced than that. You know, essentially, you know how Idaho's law
- 29:48is it? I like it. It's crappy because Illinois, Illinois, but
- 29:52it starts heading in the right direction if you fix all the bugs with it.
- 29:56So, like, I think some nuanced laws is what we need,
- 30:00not an all or nothing. I think what's there for Hollywood is probably not
- 30:03enough. But yeah, so no, I don't think it should be fully
- 30:07illegal, but it needs a hell of a lot more protection and more than
- 30:10Hollywood because, as we discuss before the when you're actually showing quote unquote your
- 30:15real life, that has bigger, broader, longer term implications for your own
- 30:19life than when you're portraying a character in a movie or show. Right,
- 30:23You're not playing Frodo Baggins, You're playing yourself. And if Frodo Baggins does
- 30:32something silly or evil, then most rational individuals. Although the Game of Thrones
- 30:38actor who played Jeoffrey was being attacked by a lot of people, but that
- 30:45does happen. Presumably it's less than if you literally were Joffrey in these videos.
- 30:52So yeah, well, I gave it some thought and this is just
- 30:56my unrefined take on the matter, and it'll be in line with a lot
- 31:00of the other measures that I think would be able to solve these problems.
- 31:04And when I came up with this, I thought, oh, this would
- 31:08be so great and everyone. It'd be a win win for everybody except I
- 31:15guess the taxpayer. I suppose, because it would have cost a lot of
- 31:17money. But we spend a lot of money on a lot of other kinds
- 31:19of regulation and other kinds of measures to protect the public. You need a
- 31:23license to drive a car, and there are police officers and other measures like
- 31:30cameras that are out there being paid for by tax dollars to find individuals and
- 31:36keep them driving under the speed limit. You know, there's but We have
- 31:37a whole system in place regarding traffic and automobile regulations and laws and practices that
- 31:47is very elaborate and very invasive in our lives, but ultimately set saves a
- 31:53lot of lives. We have laws about seat belts. You have to wear
- 31:56your seat belt, and that's an infringement on your freedom. I remember when
- 32:01that law was passed in the eighties and or early nineties and thinking, how
- 32:06dare they like force us to do something. I mean, if if I
- 32:12want to wear a seat belt, it's it's for my own benefit, you
- 32:15know, it's it's It felt really invasive. Now it seems ridiculous because it
- 32:19just seems like why not, But and that it costs money to the taxpayer
- 32:22when you have to get taken to the er and treat it. So you
- 32:28know, I'm for it. But I grew up in the seventies and early
- 32:30eighties with literally no one wearing seat belts at all. In fact, we
- 32:35had a friend that had a mom that would make us all wear our seat
- 32:37belts in her car, and everyone made fun of her. I think I
- 32:40think even adults made fun of her. You know what I mean? Bad?
- 32:44Yeah, So, uh, now we were wrong. But but you
- 32:49know, my point is is that in the absence of regulation and law,
- 32:52it feels like it shouldn't happen because it's too elaborate, it's too invasive.
- 32:58But once those things happen and you see the benefits of it, then you're
- 33:00like, oh, it is good that government because it's you know, it's
- 33:04government reducing our freedoms and government imposing fines and you know, annoyances in our
- 33:10life that we're not there before, even though it should be our right to
- 33:16choose, you know, that kind of thing, but within reason. So
- 33:20what my solution is to children in reality TV and social media, it should
- 33:23either just be illegal just flat out like for example, there are laws that
- 33:30regulate the release of information from schools like elementary schools or my university called FURPA.
- 33:38You've heard of HIPPA, but there's also FURPA that regulates the release of
- 33:44information because there, I believe we're cases where a stalker called a university or
- 33:51a high school or something and wanted information on a on a student and got
- 33:54the information and use that information to I think kill somebody, Oh my god,
- 33:59something like that. I don't quote me on that, but the point
- 34:01is is that there are certain things in our society where you're just like,
- 34:06you can't do this to children. I mean, aren't there laws about putting
- 34:10children in news stories and this sort of thing? There must be I don't
- 34:15know, but no, there are obviously. Look, you can't go into
- 34:19a bar if you're a minor, you can't be in the front seat,
- 34:22if you're under a certain weight or age, you have to be in a
- 34:25booster. Like. There's all sorts of rules about what kids can and can't
- 34:29do. They probably can own guns in certain guns are well, yeah,
- 34:35so they can't drive a car, but before a certain age. So either
- 34:38it just needs to be completely illegal, like you can't have children in reality
- 34:45TV shows. You can't have Maybe sixteen or something would be the cut off
- 34:50date, but I would even argue that eighteen is maybe a little young.
- 34:53Because the point is is that can we be assured that a child, even
- 35:00a sixteen year old, knows what they are consenting to when they are consenting
- 35:06to being on a reality TV show? I would say not. I mean
- 35:09so that there's a parallel to this, that there should be a lot of
- 35:13regulations on reality TV, even for adults, that there should be advocates and
- 35:16laws in place such that, like, for example, on Love Is Blind,
- 35:21they have this clause that you sign in the contract that says if you
- 35:24walk off the set at a certain point, once you cross a certain line,
- 35:30we can automatically find you for like one hundred thousand dollars or five some
- 35:36some large amount of money. And that is unfair because for people that are
- 35:42essentially labor, you know, it's you wouldn't have if you signed up to
- 35:46work at McDonald's and there was a clause that says, if you get injured
- 35:51on the job or you're being yelled at by your manager, you can't quit.
- 35:55You can't quit, You can't walk off the job because you will be
- 35:59automatically be fined, not just sued, because suing requires actual going to chord
- 36:07and approved stuff. Yeah, ye, automatic, this is automatic. It's
- 36:09just it's just going to happen. There should be laws against that because for
- 36:15cast members, they don't exactly know what they're getting into. They're reading a
- 36:19contract. They've watched reality TV themselves, but they have no idea what goes
- 36:23on behind the scenes. Like I was saying about working at McDonald's. Most
- 36:28people can intuit what it's like when they sign up to work a shift at
- 36:31McDonald's. Right, it might be surprising in some ways, but it's not
- 36:35going to be shockingly different than yet. You can still quit, right,
- 36:39So there should be laws for that. But anyway, so if children are
- 36:44going to be allowed to be in these reality TV shows or on these influencer
- 36:49YouTube channels, this kind of thing, then the following measures I think should
- 36:52be in place. One is that, well, the first thing I'll say
- 36:55is that parents should be allowed to post pictures and videos of their kids on
- 37:01Facebook, if it's relegated to a small audience. You know, I think
- 37:06people understand the line, and maybe it's a little squishy at times, but
- 37:09I think most people understand the line between posting to three hundred Facebook friends and
- 37:15trying to get a YouTube channel going that's public to everybody. If you're going
- 37:20to write it into a law, you could do something like, if it's
- 37:22an open network, you can't do it. If it's a close network of
- 37:25no more than blah number a million and a thousand, whatever, then you
- 37:30can do it right. And there would be oversight to tell the difference,
- 37:36because you might have someone that has, say three thousand friends on Instagram and
- 37:40it's a closed network. But the nature of the content is exploitative to the
- 37:46child, So you need oversight. You need some sort of government body to
- 37:52oversee this. So let's say that you have a YouTube channel with children on
- 37:55it, because that's the main issue. I mean, reality TV also is
- 37:59a big but the freedoms that these families take on YouTube because with reality TV,
- 38:05at least you have the production team will temporarily make content for their reality
- 38:12TV show and then the kids and the families go off on their own for
- 38:15eleven months out of the year. For these YouTube influencers, it's twenty four
- 38:19seven three sixty five and quote producers might be their parents, right, So
- 38:23there's no advocate for the kids. So for those kinds of situations, there
- 38:29would be a clear disclaimer by law that these channels would need to have upfront,
- 38:34maybe at the beginning of every video that says, if you believe as
- 38:37a viewer that there's a problem, here is the number that you can call.
- 38:42It's essentially CPS, you know, So there's a clear government body that
- 38:46has been designated, that has been informed to the public that they can essentially
- 38:51report things. Of course, you need a lot of tax dollars to be
- 38:53allocated so that individuals would work in these call centers. Sure, And the
- 38:58other thing you could also require licensing fees that would pay for this sort of
- 39:02thing, like if you're going to have a channel that has underaged kids,
- 39:06yeah, you gotta get licensed. You gotta pay attacks on it, right,
- 39:07and that that maybe not funds it completely, but it helps fund it,
- 39:10right, So that would be one thing. Then you have basically the
- 39:17ability for child protective services and various different look jurisdictions are trained and also allowed
- 39:23to investigate these kinds of situations much more readily, because I'm guessing that CPS
- 39:30child Protective Services is trained kind of in situations like this. But you know,
- 39:35it's kind of different because the typical things that CPS get reported to them
- 39:39that you cross the threshold for them to act are allegations of abuse to children,
- 39:45right, So those are pretty intuitive. They've been around for decades in
- 39:51terms of the culture and the awareness at CPS. But what sort of things
- 39:55are you looking for as CPS when you're watching one of these videos because the
- 40:00kid could not the kid in the videos could not be being abused. It
- 40:06might look happy it might look fine, right, but you might be able
- 40:08to see signs of like if you see the child, evidence that the child
- 40:14is being filmed a lot throughout the day, or the topic is questionable as
- 40:21to whether or not the kid really wants to be talking about that, even
- 40:24though their quote unquote willingly talking about it and maybe smiling. They're put in
- 40:30dangerous situations. Yeah, any number, Yeah, totally. So CPS would
- 40:35be trained and would be would there you know, jurisdiction would be expanded.
- 40:39I suppose also CPS would conduct random on site audits in the same way that
- 40:45you have a health inspector come into a restaurant. You know, when I
- 40:47think about other government regulations that taxpayers pay for for the protection of the public,
- 40:55it just seems obvious that something like that should happen right on you and
- 41:00I depend on this system being a place, you know, like in Washington
- 41:05State or at least in Seattle, when you walk into a restaurant, they
- 41:07have to have this post, you know, this flyer or this thing that
- 41:13says they're grade as to the last time they had an audit, that someone
- 41:16just showed up and did a health inspection. You know. The top is
- 41:20excellent, and then there's good good, and then there's fair, and then
- 41:23there's poor really easy, and it's it's big, and there's a there's a
- 41:28letter grade. And every time I walk into a new restaurant, I look
- 41:32at that and I go, Okay, we just Stacey and I just walked
- 41:36into a Vietnamese restaurant on Ara and we I had never been there before,
- 41:40and you just never know. But they had an excellent rating. So I
- 41:44just feel a little better. I like that I pay tax dollars to pay
- 41:47for that service. It's probably not cheap to have that system. So you
- 41:52could absolutely have that system in place for these kinds of YouTube channels. But
- 41:57then that's that doesn't scale well if it's for I feel like for that,
- 42:00it has to be the platform's responsibility and you're gonna have to automate it with
- 42:06AI and other things, because like you have how many restaurants in a city,
- 42:10but you were going to have you know, ten x maybe one hundred
- 42:14x people producing content. Well, you know, it could be worked into
- 42:17the licensing fees, like I said, and if you only did it to
- 42:21big channels, then you run into the same problem that we were talking about.
- 42:23Ido it wouldn't be just big channels, I know, right, But
- 42:25if it's not only big channels, yeah, you can't scale that problem.
- 42:30Well, maybe it wouldn't be elaborate in terms of the allocation attack dollars,
- 42:35but it would be enough of a concern because most people don't want to break
- 42:40the law, you know, right, and so they would just be a
- 42:45little bit more incentivized to make sure that. You know, like most restaurants
- 42:49don't want to make food that is going to harm their patrons, but that
- 42:52threat of the audit probably just keeps them a little bit more conscientious rights.
- 42:57That's why I think like it should be it should be required of the platforms
- 43:00like Instagram, YouTube, whatever where if you're gonna if you have a channel,
- 43:04that the people putting content on that channel include children. Because you know,
- 43:07when you upload a YouTube video, one of the things you mark is
- 43:09whether this is for children, but it also includes whether the video includes children.
- 43:14So if your video is going to include children, then maybe part of
- 43:16the thing is that it's YouTube or Instagram Whoever's responsibility to audit those things.
- 43:22Yeah, and if they don't, they get fined by the government, they
- 43:27get shut down. They can't host those channels whatever. Yeah. The economics
- 43:30of that though would be a little funny because say your YouTube and say there's
- 43:37there's no family channels, no kid channels currently, and someone wants to sign
- 43:42up for one, Well, they have no audience, meaning they'll get no
- 43:45views yet you don't know, and there's no revenue coming in that YouTube,
- 43:50you know, because YouTube gets about half of the revenue on the advertisements that
- 43:53play in these videos. So they as YouTube, they're like, well,
- 43:58so we're just going to roll the dice and spend a bunch of money looking
- 44:01into this family. No. No, but the government wouldn't either because like,
- 44:06you're not gonna I someone uploads a to YouTube video on Saturday night,
- 44:09what the government inspector shows up Sunday morning. No, No, it doesn't
- 44:13scale whether it's government or well, I'm just saying it would be one element,
- 44:15you know. The other checks and balances would be the reporting. And
- 44:21then if CPS gets there's a certain threshold of the types of reporting that it
- 44:25gets or something, and then they literally just go to the channel, the
- 44:29CPS worker and just starts watching the issue of concern and because they're experts on
- 44:35these sorts of things, there's different measures. They might call and say,
- 44:38hey, what's going on over there? Let me know, or fill out
- 44:43this form because you've had a report and you know, assurist that yet all
- 44:47the way up to you literally just go over there and knock on the door
- 44:51and say, well, we're here to interview the kids for the next month
- 44:54and we're going to actually observe you making content. You know, there's there's
- 45:00things that you know. I'm not an expert on these kinds of implementations of
- 45:02agencies, but I can see it working, you know, I can.
- 45:06I can see it. At least we have CPS right now. It's underfunded,
- 45:09but it does work to help a lot of people, and it's in
- 45:15place to protect children. Thus we have lower rates of child abuse. Presumably
- 45:19it's hard to measure these kinds of things, but presumably because of CPS,
- 45:22we have a lower rate of child abuse than what we would have otherwise.
- 45:28Have we eliminated child abuse? No? But with this program, would you
- 45:32eliminate children being abused on influencer channels on reality TV? No? But the
- 45:37rate would go down, you know what I mean. And again, I
- 45:40think this is where AI could really help, because you could you could do
- 45:44things like automatically like train models on detecting red flags and yellow flags. Things
- 45:51like how many cuts in the video might indicate that they're filming a lot,
- 45:54how long the child children appear, what kind of actions there to any number
- 45:58of things? Right, Yeah, I mean a couple of years ago,
- 46:01or even just six months ago. If you said that, because you'll sometimes
- 46:06talk about that, you'll raise that possibility of machine learning in AI, I
- 46:09would have been like, yeah, but the way AI is working right now,
- 46:15they could help. Maybe I could see it working. In fact,
- 46:17just side note, I am talking with various different people about using AI to
- 46:27for the podcast and the YouTube channel because I get a lot of questions.
- 46:30People email DMI you know, hey, have you talked about prentification or have
- 46:36you talked about and meshment or have you talked about you know, skizoid personality
- 46:39short And I'll be like, I think and I probably have. But unless
- 46:46I have an episode that is literally titled in meshment, which I don't think
- 46:51I have, then you're you just have to listen to my entire catalog and
- 46:55maybe look for a title that is kind of related. But especially when you're
- 47:00talking about my reaction videos. Those things are titled often of the individuals in
- 47:06the it's just like Ed and Liz number fifty or something, and there won't
- 47:10be any indicationists or very little indications. What I'm talking about, whereas AI
- 47:15right now is at the point where they can go through my entire catalog of
- 47:22four thousand episodes or something, when you include all the reaction videos and not
- 47:27only just look for words and phrases, but also look for concepts. Right,
- 47:31it doesn't just look for the word. It looks for like, well,
- 47:36he's not saying the word in meashment here, but he's talking about the
- 47:38concept of end measurement. And then and actually one of the fans actually made
- 47:46a tool that actually does this right now. They said they didn't want me
- 47:50to share it with the world because it's on their own private server anyway,
- 47:53So that's another measure. Also, tax dollars obviously would have to be raised
- 48:00to pay for this expansion of child protective services. There also does have to
- 48:05be nuance. For example, I was thinking about how you might be your
- 48:08your kid might be doing really well in basketball, so you're, you know,
- 48:13you're putting up some videos of some of their games right, is that
- 48:15a YouTube channel focused on kits. Well, it does have an underage person
- 48:22who is the focus of the videos, but you know, right, so
- 48:27you know, it's similar to like with copyright law fair use, right.
- 48:31I lament this that for me on my channel. The line between fair use
- 48:37and not fair use it is extremely squishy and variable. I've watched a lot
- 48:45of YouTube videos ironically about fair use. I've also talked to lawyers about fair
- 48:51use and what they'll say as well. It kind of depends. It's in
- 48:53the eye of the beholder. One jury or judge might rule this way.
- 48:59You know, here's the general role guidelines. But if someone really wanted to
- 49:02make it. It's sort of like when Ed Scharon gets sued for for copying
- 49:07a song and someone else who was it was it Katy Perry or someone and
- 49:14one tryer of fact will find that the artist was in fact copying and the
- 49:19other one will be like no. So it's kind of in that zone.
- 49:22It's like the Blurred Lines was a Marvin Gay song. The Martin mcgay State
- 49:25sued Robbie Whatever and Farrell or whoever about Blurred Lines. Yeah, they lost
- 49:31the suit, I meaning they won the suit. So they Robbie and Farrell
- 49:35lost and they had to pay some royalties. But in uh in the last
- 49:40case he won at Charon right. So it would probably be something like that.
- 49:46But the example that you gave most people, similar to with fair use
- 49:52and other kinds of legal lines, most reasonable people, including most triers of
- 49:58fact juries and judges, would not consider a parent filming a soccer game posting
- 50:05it on YouTube for the other parents and kids to watch. Maybe friends of
- 50:08friends like grandparents that weren't there. Most people would understand that that's not the
- 50:14sort of thing that needs to be looked into. What if it's Lebron's dad
- 50:17when he's coming up or Lebron, you know, someone's filming their kid that's
- 50:21actually getting a lot of media attention, so the YouTube channel blows up,
- 50:23but it's still just games. Then you're starting to look at an exploitative because
- 50:30the question is is a risk of exploitation and harm there? Like you're making
- 50:37a million dollars a month because people are watching your kids, right basketball,
- 50:42Yet when you film a soccer game of your kids and post it and there's
- 50:46literally seventeen views, most people would understand that the motivation was not to make
- 50:51money. The motivation was just to share it with random people. The chance
- 50:53that other people would want to watch it. Now if you filmed, say
- 51:00close ups of their bottoms or something, or what if that channel, what
- 51:04if my channel which I'm going to create, me finish that so that people
- 51:07don't and you it seemed even if it was inadvertent, right, if you
- 51:12would inadvertently sexualized and it wasn't your fault, it was just circumstances, and
- 51:17it maybe gets five hundred views or something, and you bring that to the
- 51:22regulating body, they'd be like, yeah, because of this one angle,
- 51:27you can't do that. This needs to be taken down or maybe you're fined
- 51:30for that. And as a parent, you would know that. You would
- 51:32know like, well, I can shoot this kind of footage of children and
- 51:37post it on a public site, but I can't shoot this kind you know.
- 51:42I think most people understand. And if you had specifics regarding the regulations
- 51:45and that was made public, then you know it would help guide that because
- 51:49no one wants to post a video of your kids and have predators not only
- 51:54identifying a potential victim, but also just getting off if you will, and
- 52:00creating inadvertent child porn, which does happen currently, but there's not a lot
- 52:05of regulations or government agencies that have the time because of tax dollars that are
- 52:10paying for their time to actually look into these things and educate the public.
- 52:15You know. I was going to give a similar example in the sense that
- 52:16what if I just have a channel I only have like friends and family watch
- 52:21it, but it's me be rating my kids while they're playing their soccer game.
- 52:24Well, then you're getting into not the influencer side of regulations, but
- 52:30into the current standard of child abuse. Verbal emotional abuse is considered childhood.
- 52:37But if that YouTube channel starts gaining traction, then now we well, then
- 52:42you have two regulating areas that you're getting into. One is just flat out
- 52:46abusing a child, whether it's on the Internet or not. And two is
- 52:50you're actually exploiting that for your own It's all these new ones. Why I
- 52:54think that, ultimately, I don't think the right answer is like, yeah,
- 52:58it's banned, you can't have children in YouTube videos or whatever, but
- 53:00you do need regulation. I like your ideas regulating body licensing. Now clear
- 53:07numbers, you can call, websites, you can go to report blah,
- 53:09blah blah. I mean, arguably it's just as dangerous as driving a car,
- 53:14you know what I mean, Like, there's a lot of damage that
- 53:16you can do as a reality TV show and as a parent that is exploiting
- 53:22your kids for money on YouTube. There's a lot of incentive to the parents
- 53:27to exploit you know. That's another factor here is when you're making millions and
- 53:31you're getting all these demands from from fans, it's really easy to lose sight
- 53:36of the core of your soul of parenting, which is to protect your children
- 53:42and raise them right. And especially if you've been compromised yourself, you were
- 53:45abused growing up or something. And I hadn't thought about this, but imagine
- 53:50the next generation of parents who were exploited on YouTube by their parents, and
- 53:55the standard or the normalcy will shift such that it's like, well, doesn't
- 54:00every parent exploit their children? Or even if you weren't personally exploited, what
- 54:04if you were a consumer of that content and you basically got sort of traumatized
- 54:07by it to believe that that's okay, I feel that that's okay. Right.
- 54:10The other thing is that the current laws that are being the one law
- 54:15that was proposed in Illinois regarding reality TV and influencers, and all the laws
- 54:21that are around for kids on TV and movies generally focus on the money.
- 54:27They focus on what. Sorry, I just realized that the second time I
- 54:31mentioned Illinois, I still said Idaho the second time after you had told me
- 54:36it was Illinois, because I'm like, wait, it's Illinois. I can't
- 54:40get those states. Have you been to Illinois and or Idaho are in the
- 54:45United States? Yeah? Yeah, I mean have you been to Idaho or
- 54:47Illinois? Which one has Chicago? That's Illinois, So I guess I've stopped
- 54:52in the airport in Illinois. You haven't been to Idaho? I mean it's
- 54:54right next door to Washington. Well, I have been to Idaho. Okay,
- 54:58I was there when the smoke was really bad a years ago. Okay,
- 55:00it was like three hundred and fifty or something. Yeah, you couldn't
- 55:02go outside. It's I don't know if right now, but it was really
- 55:07bad in Idaho and spook can you know? Anyway, So, the current
- 55:13law in Illinois, and a lot of the laws in TV and in movies
- 55:17for children trying to protect them, a lot of it focuses on the money.
- 55:22Putting the money aside and a trust fund. In Hollywood, you could
- 55:27argue there's more protection. It's like making sure that they don't work a certain
- 55:30amount of time, making sure they're not doing dangerous things, schooling right,
- 55:35make sure they have schooling. So there's there's a little bit more there,
- 55:38but there's still insufficient oversight on the pressure that a producer could use on children
- 55:49and on the parents. Also, the kids are often left alone with people
- 55:54adults, and sometimes they're predated upon. So but the one thing that the
- 56:00court does oversee is making sure that that fifteen percent of the revenue is put
- 56:06aside and a trust fund for the kid. So that's a problem. You
- 56:09know, in our materialistic, capitalistic society's it's always about the money, and
- 56:15certainly we should have regulations about that, but we really should be focusing on
- 56:19how these children are being actually treated on the ground level in Hollywood and in
- 56:23reality TV and on YouTube and these sorts of things. But anyway, so
- 56:30so let's take a break. The rest of this will just be for patrons
- 56:32of the podcast. We're going to in the Patriots section continue with the timeline
- 56:37and maybe even get into the current scandals. I'm not sure if we'll have
- 56:40enough time for that, but we'll see, and so become a patron if
- 56:44you want to hear the rest of this episode. Otherwise, take care of
- 56:46yourself because you deserve it,