Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How Managers Stifle Innovation By Overcorrecting
Transcript
- Lucas: There is a very specific kind of panic that sets in when a first-time manager makes a public mistake. It is not just about the error itself. It is about the sudden, overwhelming urge to prove they are still in control. Luna: Right, because they think if they don't tighten the screws immediately, everyone will see them as weak. So they overcorrect. Lucas: Exactly. And what happens next is usually a disaster for team morale. I have been thinking about a case from last month involving a software engineering lead named David. He made a small error in a budget forecast during a meeting with senior leadership. It was a rounding issue, really. But instead of moving on, he spent the next two weeks micromanaging every line item his team submitted. Luna: That sounds exhausting for everyone involved. Did anyone call him out on it? Lucas: Not directly. But within three weeks, two of his top developers had already updated their LinkedIn profiles. One of them told me later that they felt like they were being treated like children. The damage wasn't to the budget. It was to the trust. Luna: So the reaction to the mistake ended up costing more than the mistake itself. Lucas: Precisely. This is what I call managerial overcorrection. It is a defense mechanism. When leaders feel exposed or vulnerable, they often swing to the opposite extreme of their usual style. If they were previously hands-off, they become hands-on. If they were collaborative, they become authoritarian. Luna: It makes sense psychologically. You feel unsafe, so you try to control the environment completely. Lucas: But the problem is that teams do not respond well to sudden shifts in behavior. Consistency matters more than perfection. When a manager swings wildly, the team starts guessing which version of the boss they are dealing with today. Luna: And that uncertainty kills productivity. People stop taking risks if they don't know where the boundaries are. Lucas: Let us look at David again. After the budget error, he started requiring approval for every single email sent to clients. Even routine ones. His team was spending forty percent of their week just waiting for his sign-off. The work didn't get better. It just got slower. Luna: That is a classic example of trading speed for perceived safety. But isn't there a risk that the manager looks incompetent for changing course so abruptly? Lucas: Actually, no. The incompetence comes from failing to recover. Most managers think they need to hide their vulnerability. But the most effective leaders acknowledge the slip-up, explain what they learned, and then explicitly state how they will adjust their approach going forward. Luna: So transparency is the antidote to overcorrection. Instead of hiding, they own it. Lucas: Yes. For example, David could have said in that next meeting, 'I realized my focus on those numbers was too narrow. Going forward, I want us to prioritize accuracy in the quarterly projections, but I will not be checking daily emails unless there is a critical issue.' That sets a clear expectation. Luna: It gives the team permission to return to normal operations without feeling like they are walking on eggshells. Lucas: Exactly. It shows that the manager has a calibrated response, not a panicked one. The team sees that the leader can handle stress without losing their cool. Luna: I wonder if this happens more in high-pressure industries like finance or tech. Lucas: It happens everywhere, but it is amplified when stakes feel high. In October of twenty twenty-six, we are seeing many companies facing economic uncertainty. Managers feel pressure to demonstrate efficiency. That pressure often leads to these overcorrection cycles. Luna: So the external environment fuels the internal panic. It becomes a feedback loop. Lucas: It does. And the irony is that overcorrection often creates the very inefficiency the manager was trying to avoid. By slowing everything down to prevent errors, they create bottlenecks that cause new problems. Luna: Which means the original mistake was just the spark. The real fire is the management style. Lucas: That is a sharp way to put it. Let us talk about how to break this cycle. First, managers need to recognize their physical cues. Are they speaking faster? Are they sending more messages? Those are signs of anxiety, not leadership. Luna: Self-awareness is key. If you notice you are spiraling, take a step back before making decisions. Lucas: Second, communicate the correction to the team. Do not just change your behavior silently. Explain why. Say, 'I noticed I was being too strict on X yesterday. Here is what I am adjusting.' It builds trust. Luna: It turns a negative event into a teaching moment. It shows humility. Lucas: Third, establish clear boundaries for accountability. Not every mistake requires a full team reset. Some issues are individual. Some are systemic. Distinguish between them. Luna: So you coach the individual privately, but you only change team processes if the process itself is broken. Lucas: Correct. If David had pulled his developer aside to discuss the budget error, rather than shutting down the whole department, the relationship would have survived. The developer would have felt supported, not policed. Luna: And the rest of the team wouldn't have felt collateral damage. Lucas: Right. They would have seen that mistakes are handled professionally. That is how you build psychological safety. It is not about avoiding errors. It is about how you respond to them. Luna: This is such an important distinction. Many new managers think they need to be perfect to be respected. Lucas: They do not. They need to be reliable. Reliability comes from consistent, thoughtful responses. Not from frantic corrections. Luna: If you are a first-time manager, ask yourself: am I reacting to the problem, or am I reacting to my fear of looking bad? Lucas: That question alone can save a lot of relationships. It forces you to pause and evaluate your true motivation. Luna: And if the answer is fear, you know you need to step back. Lucas: We deliberately do not run ads on these episodes because we believe in providing high-quality, ad-free content for our listeners. If you want to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, your support helps us keep this space independent and focused on real management insights. Lucas: Back to the topic, though. There is one final thing I want to leave you with. It is about patience. Overcorrection is often a race against time. You want to fix things now. But good management is a marathon. Luna: So let the dust settle before you make big changes. Lucas: Exactly. Give yourself forty-eight hours to reflect after a mistake. Then act with intention, not impulse. Luna: Intention over impulse. That is a mantra worth remembering. Lucas: It is. Because in the end, your team is watching how you recover, not just how you perform.