Latest / Property Investment & Wealth Creation Australia | The Michael Yardney Podcast / Melbourne Property is 21% Undervalued - Here's Why | Stuart Wemyss
Transcript
- 0:00Melbourne property investors have endured almost a decade of disappointing growth,
- 0:03and the usual explanations are taxes or debt or government policy.
- 0:08But what if the biggest cause of this flat period was the extraordinary
- 0:1220 year boom that came before it?
- 0:15By the end of today's show, you're going to understand exactly
- 0:17why Melbourne has underperformed for the best part of a decade,
- 0:20why the usual suspects like land tax and state debt and poor sentiment probably
- 0:25aren't the real culprits, and why the length of Melbourne's flat
- 0:28Patch might actually be the strongest signal yet that a powerful new growth cycle
- 0:34is coming. Today, my guest, Stuart Wemyss,
- 0:36has crunched 45 years of data across every capital city in Australia,
- 0:40and what he's found flips the whole Victoria's broken narrative on its head.
- 0:44Now, Stuart, a regular on the show,
- 0:46is director of ProSolution Private Clients,
- 0:48he's a financial advisor, a mortgage broker,
- 0:51and author of several books, including his new book,
- 0:54Wealth by Design. And he's also published a piece of research that I think every Melbourne property
- 0:59owner and honestly every property investor around Australia needs to hear.
- 1:03Hi, I'm Michael Yardney and welcome to the Michael Yardney Podcast.
- 1:06After 40 years property investment,
- 1:08I've seen every cycle, the booms,
- 1:10the busts, the so-called crises.
- 1:12And that's why twice a week I cut through the clutter to share proven property
- 1:15strategies and insights from Australia's leading experts,
- 1:18like we're about to do today. So let's get on with the show.
- 1:28Hi Stu, good to have you back on the podcast.
- 1:31thanks for having me back, Michael.
- 1:32Always enjoy our catch ups.
- 1:33Well, I also enjoy getting your articles every Monday and reading your recent book
- 1:38also, which we're going to have a little bit of a talk about.
- 1:41But one of the topics that you recently wrote about that I wanted to discuss
- 1:46was the Melbourne property market.
- 1:47And you wrote an article saying,
- 1:49blame the twenty-year growth cycle,
- 1:51not the government. At the moment there's a lot of people pointing fingers.
- 1:55but Melbourne's median house prices have risen, well, really only grown.
- 2:00Around, I don't know, one point eight percent a year since twenty seventeen.
- 2:04That's almost a decade, while inflation's averaged around three percent
- 2:08in that time. how unusual is it for a major capital city like this
- 2:12to go backwards in real terms for so long,
- 2:15Stu? Yeah, it's I mean it's not unusual for it to go sideways or backwards slightly.
- 2:21And I guess we've got to put it in context because I always love
- 2:25to read those articles, you know,
- 2:27that you know, property dropped one percent or median house prices dropped
- 2:31one percent last month, according to CoreLogic, or Cotality they're called now.
- 2:35it's funny because you know, the share market can drop one percent
- 2:38in literally in an hour.
- 2:40Yes.
- 2:40Let alone let alone a day and it's and it's barely you know newsworthy
- 2:44and when that happens. So I guess we'll put it in context.
- 2:47I mean it's a decline, it's not it's not ideal,
- 2:49of course, but it's not as big a decline as you tend to see in share markets,
- 2:54which is not an argument for property,
- 2:55but it's a highlight of volatility more correctly.
- 2:58when you look at the average flat cycle,
- 3:01I like to call them flat cycle,
- 3:02whether they're slightly in decline or
- 3:05Marginal growth, let's just call it flat cycle.
- 3:07The average flat cycle since 1980,
- 3:09median average, about seven years.
- 3:12So for it's And you're talking
- 3:13nationally now, not just Melbourne, is that correct?
- 3:15Yeah,
- 3:15correct. Across Australia. Yeah,
- 3:17a hundred percent. So, you know,
- 3:19we're from seventeen including early seventeen,
- 3:22we're getting close to almost ten years as a flat cycle.
- 3:26And you could probably extend it beyond that just slightly.
- 3:29So it's unusual and i it's persisted longer.
- 3:33But I think we've had pr some pretty unique events during that time,
- 3:37notwithstanding the government and government debt and all those sorts of things.
- 3:41But you know, we've had COVID.
- 3:42We've had some interest rate shocks,
- 3:44you know, both zero interest rates and then a significant hiking cycle.
- 3:49And then we've had a re-acceleration of inflation,
- 3:52which is obviously what we're dealing with today.
- 3:53So there are some unique things that have happened that have probably drawn
- 3:57out this cycle longer than than history,
- 4:00but it's unusual. And in a way,
- 4:03I think it adds to the thesis because it is unusual.
- 4:06Okay, let's deal with the obvious suspect first.
- 4:08Everyone's blaming the Victorians well land tax and tenancy reforms.
- 4:14Is that fair? Because that doesn't affect homeowners, does it?
- 4:17No, it doesn't, but it affects sentiment and sentiment certainly drives all markets,
- 4:22including the property market in the short term.
- 4:24And sentiment, both positive and negative,
- 4:27can drive markets much longer than we expect as well.
- 4:30So in the long run, fundamentals drive very long multi-decade performance.
- 4:35but sentiment can certainly drive things.
- 4:37the land tax argument is kind of an interesting one.
- 4:41I mean, I remember doing analysis a couple of years ago for a client that already
- 4:45owned an investment property in Brisbane.
- 4:48And so we were tossing up, we'll buy another investment property,
- 4:51do we buy it in Brisbane or do we buy it in Melbourne?
- 4:54And we when we did the land tax calc,
- 4:56the land tax in Brisbane, if he added a second property,
- 4:59because obviously it's a marginal rate system,
- 5:01it would give rise to substantially more.
- 5:04Land tax. And so just purely from a land tax perspective,
- 5:08not only forecasting what would happen next year but also longer term,
- 5:13he was actually better off. This client was actually better off
- 5:15to invest in Melbourne than Brisbane.
- 5:17And then the other thing, Michael,
- 5:19is land tax is only one of those costs.
- 5:21We both own assets in Brisbane.
- 5:23I don't know what your view on Brisbane City Council's council rates costs are,
- 5:29but they're pretty significant and they're they're they're more costly.
- 5:32per unit in Brisbane than say say Melbourne.
- 5:35Very interesting that you say that because I just recently looked at
- 5:39the rate certificates for Brisbane as opposed to my Melbourne properties
- 5:43and they were significantly more.
- 5:45You're right. Yeah. And so we can't we can't just look.
- 5:48I mean, it's a it's a good news story,
- 5:50you know, Victoria's hiked land tax or at least spread the land tax burden across a
- 5:54Done.
- 5:55lot more investors in Victoria.
- 5:57And I'm not gonna push away from that.
- 5:58That's happened, and that's a negative thing for investors,
- 6:02but there's so many things that go into a informed decision about whether to invest.
- 6:08and land tax might only be one of them.
- 6:10And as the example that I gave you.
- 6:11It might actually be cheaper to go to Victoria than invest in the
- 6:16the existing state that you already hold assets in.
- 6:18And I guess it's a good cautionary tale for everyone listening to say,
- 6:22well, do we follow the headlines?
- 6:24Because if you read the headlines and Melbourne's no good,
- 6:27you wouldn't invest here, or do you dig a bit deeper and understand
- 6:31how these things affect your individual circumstances?
- 6:34I think it's a really good example of,
- 6:36you know, ignoring the noise in the media.
- 6:38And really focusing on the facts.
- 6:40Well, the noise in the media is also mentioning that the Victorian government
- 6:45is basically broke with all the debt that's been taken on by
- 6:49the Labour government over the last years.
- 6:51what's your thought about that?
- 6:53look, it's it's interesting. I would I would put the question
- 6:56to a property investor, how does higher state debt impact future property returns?
- 7:03Like build a case for me. Tell me how that's actually going to work.
- 7:07and the argument might be well,
- 7:09if there's higher debt, there's just got to be higher taxes,
- 7:12and that's gonna be negative, negative for the state.
- 7:15It's true that Victoria is borrowing about twenty five percent or its total debt.
- 7:19Is equal to about 25% of its economic pro productivity,
- 7:23which is substantial compared to other states.
- 7:25I mean, you look at WA, it's zero.
- 7:27but not at that substantial compared to sort of global benchmarks.
- 7:31And I'm not trying to justify it.
- 7:33the federal debt's around 20% of GDP,
- 7:37so certainly Victoria is elevated compared to.
- 7:40the federal government, you don't get the same rhetoric necessarily about federal
- 7:45government debt as you do state government debt.
- 7:47I think the issue is, and the reason why it irritates so many many people,
- 7:51is not necessarily the quantum,
- 7:54it's the wastage. You know, what did you actually get for that debt?
- 7:58and I'm not going to dig into that.
- 7:59We don't need to talk about the political elements here,
- 8:02but I think that's really what's driving the sentiment conversation around debt.
- 8:06Now, I guess if you've got very large debt as a as a state,
- 8:10what do you do? You've got to try and repay it at some point.
- 8:13the good thing is that Victoria has the second highest population growth
- 8:18in percentage terms and the highest in absolute terms.
- 8:21So really what Victoria needs to do is they need to grow the economic pie.
- 8:25To do that, you need more people,
- 8:27you need to grow the population.
- 8:29The And it also has the highest participation rate,
- 8:32employment participation rate of all the states as well.
- 8:35So in a way, I don't think it's going to be difficult,
- 8:38too difficult to move the dial economically from deficits to surpluses,
- 8:44budget surpluses, because we already have the population growth.
- 8:47We just need to incentivize productivity and business and these sorts of things.
- 8:52And finally, there's only so much you can tax the
- 8:56You know, you can raise taxes in property,
- 8:58so land tax and stamp duty, that's a large portion of the revenue,
- 9:02more than fifty percent. And then you've got payroll tax.
- 9:05and the Victorian government certainly has got some punitive payroll tax rates.
- 9:09But beyond that, there's not much else you can do.
- 9:11So I would argue that Victoria's already probably explored as much of
- 9:17the tax r revenue element to get in control of the debt.
- 9:21As they can. I think any successive governments are going to have to turn their mind
- 9:25to growing the economic pie. And that's good for property investors.
- 9:29Also they're gonna have to learn to be more productive because at
- 9:32the moment they've done it the lazy way by growing the pie by having more people
- 9:36rather than having the people produce more.
- 9:39But that's a whole different topic we could spend a whole show on.
- 9:43But so if it's not tax and it's not debt,
- 9:46what actually explains Melbourne's decade of stagnation in property values?
- 9:51Well,
- 9:51I think we're gonna cast a wider lens,
- 9:54Michael, when we look at sort of market performance,
- 9:57because you know, blaming one element,
- 9:59I think almost never works for property or never explains property performance.
- 10:06and actually I was talking to a journalist yesterday and they were talking about
- 10:10unemployment, you know, how unemployment can have an impact on property prices and property growth.
- 10:16Yes.
- 10:16and obviously unemployment tends to be I mean it doesn't really Victoria's
- 10:20unemployment rate is only marginally higher than the federal unemployment rate.
- 10:25Yes.
- 10:25It's not ideal, but it's it's
- 10:27it's not huge. So unemployment doesn't really change that much in Australia.
- 10:30but the point is that interest rates are a good example.
- 10:33Come back to unemployment. Interest rates are good example because
- 10:35it the interest rates are federally set, right? But
- 10:38Adelaide and Perth and Brisbane and Melbourne and Sydney
- 10:42all are behaving differently as different property markets.
- 10:45So sometimes we like to point to one or two things that to explain performance.
- 10:50But with property, it's almost always a number of different factors that
- 10:54are conspiring to produce either positive or negative forces.
- 10:58So the best thing then to do to sort of take your cue in terms of
- 11:03Assessing what future performance might be is to really look at cycles
- 11:07and look deeper at cycles. And really between 97 and 2016,
- 11:13almost a 20-year period, Melbourne had a above-average growth,
- 11:18around 8% compounding in terms of property price growth,
- 11:22and that's houses specifically.
- 11:24when you look at you know other capital cities and very long term data last
- 11:2945 years, the trend has been so six and a half,
- 11:32seven percent, you know, in terms of longer term performance.
- 11:35So we had 20 years of an additional 1% growth at a median house price level.
- 11:41so anyone that invested in 2017 did so after a 20 year growth cycle.
- 11:48and so I would argue that's probably
- 11:51The bigger contributor to performance or underperformance over the last 10 years,
- 11:56not necessarily interest rates,
- 11:59government debt, all these sorts of things.
- 12:01And remember, actually, because the counter-argument would be there's
- 12:04so much government debt. Well,
- 12:06surely that's gone into the economy.
- 12:08Surely that would be good for house prices.
- 12:11Surely it's it's underpinned and buoyed house prices.
- 12:14Well, it hasn't. Some of it's been wasted,
- 12:16but it's gone somewhere.
- 12:17So it has gone into the economy.
- 12:19So arguably you could say that the high debt levels now should have contributed
- 12:24to property prices, but of course it hasn't.
- 12:26Now, I remember when I was listening to your podcast,
- 12:30and I do listen to the Investopoly Podcast. I can't even
- 12:33say Investopoly Podcast. I'm going to leave a link in the show notes because
- 12:36I think others should be listening as well.
- 12:38I was walking my dog Lincoln in the park just at the end of the street.
- 12:41and I heard you explain this.
- 12:44You explain your articles every week on the podcast about the 20-year boom that
- 12:49led to the decade of pain afterwards.
- 12:52And I thought That's right, that makes sense.
- 12:54And that's why I love having you on this podcast because
- 12:57you give good evidence-based information.
- 13:00And this was actually based on a model that you built comparing actual prices
- 13:05to long-term trend lines.
- 13:06We can't show that here, but I'll give a link to this article in the show notes
- 13:10so people can see it. But can you just explain it in plain English to us?
- 13:14Yeah, sure. I mean, obviously property charts tend to sort of curve upwards because
- 13:19the same percentage increase adds more in terms of dollar returns.
- 13:24And this is important as we get on to explain sort of the approach.
- 13:27But by that I mean that if in the nineteen eighties the median house price
- 13:32was eighty five thousand and prices increased by ten percent,
- 13:36that's a eight and a half thousand dollar increase.
- 13:40So that's you know relatively affordable and more affordable relative to incomes.
- 13:44But of course, when a million dollar house increases by 10%,
- 13:49that's a hundred thousand dollars.
- 13:50So, you know, more than ten times the in dollar value that what it
- 13:54was in the eighties. So of course prices tend to sort of go up a like
- 13:59a hockey stick, even if you hold the percentage returns the same.
- 14:03So what I did is just build a long-term benchmark using
- 14:0745 years of data and assume that if we had even growth throughout that period,
- 14:13where should, and that's my trend line,
- 14:15where are property prices today?
- 14:18So if they're above the benchmark,
- 14:20it means that they've kind of outperformed that average.
- 14:23If they're below the benchmark,
- 14:25then of course they're it means they're below that average.
- 14:28Doesn't necessarily mean they're undervalued,
- 14:30or it doesn't necessarily mean in the next couple of years they get there's going
- 14:34to be an uptick. All it does show is
- 14:36relative to if property had have grown consistently along the long term trend,
- 14:43what should the price be today relative to what it is today market value wise?
- 14:48And what did you find from Melbourne?
- 14:50Well, it i found that houses were about twenty percent below where they should
- 14:54be from that long term trend and apartments about thirty percent below that long
- 14:59term trend. Again, it doesn't mean you can turn around and say the argument
- 15:03is well houses are twenty percent undervalued.
- 15:06I think when you look at relative values and you look at values in other states,
- 15:10you look at particularly apartment values versus houses both in Victoria,
- 15:14so comparing Victorian houses and apartments,
- 15:16but also interstate as well.
- 15:18I think you can probably mount a case and find enough evidence to
- 15:22say that they're probably undervalued on a relative basis.
- 15:26But this log linear regression,
- 15:28which is this statistical analysis,
- 15:30all it's trying to do is look at what was the value at each point
- 15:33on a quarterly basis, because the these are published at end of each quarter
- 15:37on a calendar year, over the last 45 years,
- 15:39and then just extrapolate a six or seven percent long-term growth rate.
- 15:43And so there's a lot of data there that sort of gives us a good sense
- 15:47of where should prices be today,
- 15:50if as I said, if they hadn't been growing at a that steady, consistent rate.
- 15:54Now, I recently read a report from valuers Charter Keck Cramer
- 15:58who said something very similar,
- 16:00but not in the plain English that you did and was much harder to understand.
- 16:05But what they were saying was something very similar that if and they weren't just
- 16:10using Melbourne as an example,
- 16:11but if Melbourne, for example,
- 16:13was usually the second most expensive city in Australia,
- 16:17all else being equal, it's and it's now for a decade gotten out of its
- 16:21normal alignment that over time and they've shown each city,
- 16:25just like you have in the past,
- 16:26each capital city has had long flat periods,
- 16:29that they eventually turn around and catch up,
- 16:32don't they? But you've actually lowered your long term growth assumptions moving
- 16:37forward. Why was that?
- 16:38Yeah, and I'll get to that, Michael,
- 16:40but let's talk to that point in what Charter Keck Cramer was sort of making,
- 16:44is that, you know, there will be arguments out there that
- 16:48by commentators to say, look, Melbourne's house price is lower because of
- 16:52Yeah.
- 16:52debt, because of the government,
- 16:54because of this and that and whatever,
- 16:56all the strength, or, you know,
- 16:57Brisbane's far ahead now because of the it's gonna have the Olympics
- 17:01or these sorts of things. And there's always gonna be that sort of commentary.
- 17:05But the thing we've got to always keep,
- 17:06I was gonna say the back of our mind,
- 17:08but really the front of our mind,
- 17:09is that be careful to think this time is different.
- 17:13You know, quite often and in the media,
- 17:15quite often that's the theme of the comment commentary.
- 17:20Yes.
- 17:20This time is different, it's unique, and this is why you should react to it.
- 17:24but you've always got to suspend belief in that regard.
- 17:28Almost nothing changes. Like in terms of fundamentals,
- 17:31fundamentals never change, almost never.
- 17:34You can never say never, of course,
- 17:35but almost never. So the fact that Melbourne isn't the second most expensive
- 17:41capital city is unusual. And I would almost bet my children on the fact that
- 17:47it will change. That one day again,
- 17:49and certainly over on average over the long run,
- 17:52it will be the second most expensive capital city.
- 17:54It has to be.
- 17:55Just because of laws of supply and demand.
- 17:58And that's always the way it's been.
- 17:59So, this sort of analysis, when you look at those sort of longer-term trends,
- 18:04and what we're trying to do is spot something that's unusual.
- 18:06And what we're trying to do is spot something that it where
- 18:10is the investment opportunity here?
- 18:12And the good investment opportunities are tied
- 18:15to long-term evidence-based assumptions,
- 18:17not opinions. Governments change.
- 18:20We've had capital gains tax introduced in 85,
- 18:23we had GST introduced in 2000,
- 18:26we've had a lot of successive governments,
- 18:28we've had wars, we've had all these sorts,
- 18:29these things happen, but there's some consistency and uniform behavior amongst
- 18:36the over those multi-decade periods that we just can't ignore.
- 18:39So now getting back to your question is
- 18:42looking at percentage growth rates.
- 18:44So I think and this is a really good thing that people should investors should
- 18:48really consider. Because when we look at,
- 18:50you know, the last say forty-five years of data,
- 18:54or we hear stories about, you know,
- 18:56our parents bought properties in the eighties or seventies and you know,
- 19:00this is what they paid for it,
- 19:01and then you extrapolate a growth rate out of that.
- 19:05We've got to be careful not to think that the past will repeat itself.
- 19:09In terms of those percentage returns.
- 19:11It will, in terms of good quality assets,
- 19:13will always outperform, but in terms of percentage returns.
- 19:17And it sort of goes back to the point I was making previously that
- 19:20a ten percent increase in $85,000 property,
- 19:23$8,500, relative to incomes in nineteen eighty,
- 19:27you know, was still a substantial increase,
- 19:29but it was affordable. Whereas in Sydney,
- 19:32for example, median house price two million bucks increases by
- 19:3610%, that's $200,000 after tax.
- 19:38That's far less affordable. So I think the reasonable assumption has to
- 19:43be a falling percentage growth rate.
- 19:46So in my analysis, what I did is assumed it fell on a straight line from
- 19:527% starting in 1980 down to 6% today.
- 19:56And I think that percentage growth rate will gradually continue
- 20:00to decline just because mathematically
- 20:03it can't hold at the same level because the dollar value return starts
- 20:08to become just unaffordable to a shrinking proportion of the population.
- 20:14and so I think this is a good thing for people to keep in mind because
- 20:18you know if they've heard or listened to experienced professionals that they might
- 20:22have said look property should double in value every ten years.
- 20:25That's a seven point two percent growth rate.
- 20:28That might be still achievable in the future if you buy well and you select well
- 20:32and you buy just before a growth cycle.
- 20:35but the average property isn't probably gonna grow at seven point
- 20:39two percent anymore. It's probably somewhere closer to six percent.
- 20:43And then maybe if we're having this conversation in twenty years,
- 20:45Michael, hopefully we're not still talking about the same topics in twenty years, but
- 20:49you know, maybe it's going to be closer to five percent.
- 20:51But I like to take at least a conservative but defensible approach
- 20:55to some of these th these sort of data assumptions,
- 20:59b you know, to make sure that what it's telling us is
- 21:01is reliable and reasonable.
- 21:03Well, we've had a flat period in Melbourne and as we said,
- 21:07this too shall pass. So what do you think would actually trigger
- 21:11the next growth cycle in Melbourne?
- 21:14Yeah, that's a million dollar question.
- 21:15You know, there's been a lot of studies and articles written about what triggered
- 21:19the global financial crisis back in seven,
- 21:22eight. and look, some articles point to a very negative article in New York Times
- 21:27on the Sunday, just before the Monday when markets crashed.
- 21:31It's a bit difficult to really point to one thing.
- 21:34and sometimes it's just the weight of numbers and the weight of evidence
- 21:37and the market eventually turns.
- 21:39There might not necessarily be one thing.
- 21:42I'd be interested to see what happens after November if there is
- 21:44a change of government in Victoria.
- 21:47Will that be the thing the event that sort of starts to push sentiment more
- 21:52negative? I think it will be more subtle than that,
- 21:55Michael. I think for example, I saw a comment by a listener to my podcast that this gentleman
- 22:03just purchased a three-bedroom apartment in Hawthorn East on Toorak Road.
- 22:09Now, I don't think this is an investment great asset.
- 22:11there's a lot of units in the one development,
- 22:14but he bought it for six hundred and sixty-five thousand and believes
- 22:17the other three bedders in that.
- 22:19block rent for a thousand dollars a week.
- 22:21So that's a 7.8% gross rental yield.
- 22:24You know, at some point you start to get transactions like that.
- 22:28And then more and more people will take notice and then more and more people will
- 22:32take notice and all of a sudden the tide turns and sentiment really turns positive.
- 22:37So I don't know if it's going to be one thing,
- 22:39but I think eventually prices will get so low and so attractive
- 22:43and yields will become in percentage terms,
- 22:46so attractive that, you know, the people start thinking,
- 22:49well, there's almost nowhere else to invest.
- 22:52I want to invest in Melbourne.
- 22:53Well, if somebody's out there looking to buy now,
- 22:55considering the negative sentiment,
- 22:57interest rates, and the tax changes,
- 23:00does the math still stack up to buy in Melbourne?
- 23:03What would you suggest?
- 23:04There's a couple of things that you can do to offset the impact,
- 23:08the negative impact financially of quarantine negative gearing.
- 23:12Now, of course, quarantine negative gearing isn't ideal because it helps
- 23:17us reduce the amount of cash that we've got to put into a property.
- 23:20Most investors go and borrow the full cost initially and the costs.
- 23:23And really their only capital contribution is the ongoing running costs,
- 23:27you know, the difference between the net rental income and the interest that they have to pay.
- 23:32In respect to the loan. Now, negative gearing helped us with that because
- 23:35the government would pay, you know,
- 23:3740 to 50 percent of that negative cash flow in the way in the form
- 23:41of a tax deduction, which means that what meant we had to put less capital into
- 23:45the property. Unfortunately, now we've got to put more capital into the property,
- 23:49but we're we're conceivably gonna get the same return.
- 23:52Just because we don't get negative gearing doesn't mean magically
- 23:55the capital growth rate increases or anything like that.
- 23:58There's no necessary compensation.
- 24:01And also we've got to understand the time value of money.
- 24:03So if I'm on the second highest marginal tax rate,
- 24:06I get a 39% deduction for every dollar that I lose.
- 24:10So every dollar I lose on a property,
- 24:12the government pays 39 cents, I've got to pay 61 cents.
- 24:16But if I've got to wait 10 years to get that deduction,
- 24:19the deduction with the time value of money is only worth 15 cents to me.
- 24:23So certainly Quarantine negative gearing does hurt the numbers.
- 24:28But there's a couple of things that you can do to offset it.
- 24:30The first one is if you get a higher starting rental yield.
- 24:33So those numbers that I just produced were based on a 3% starting yield.
- 24:37But if your starting yield is 7.6%,
- 24:40the amount you've got to put into that property is greatly reduced.
- 24:43So in that example that I just gave you of that person that bought that
- 24:48three-bedroom apartment, I worked out that the negative cash flow.
- 24:52even though you don't get negative gearing benefits,
- 24:54is less than $10,000 a year. Doesn't,
- 24:56relatively speaking, doesn't cost that much to hold.
- 24:59and you've bought in at a really attractive price point,
- 25:02I would argue, even if we don't think that's an investment great asset.
- 25:05I'm not advocating buying an asset like that,
- 25:07but just as a as an example.
- 25:09Yeah, a good example though.
- 25:10Yeah. So I looked at the if your starting rental yield is five and a half percent,
- 25:15circa five and a half percent or more.
- 25:17Then on an internal rate of return perspective,
- 25:19that offsets the lack of negative immediate negative gearing benefit.
- 25:24The other thing, Michael, is a cycle story.
- 25:27the reality is that as I said,
- 25:29a flat cycle tends to last for seven years,
- 25:31a growth cycle tends to last for ten years.
- 25:34So just roughly, if you hold a property for 30 years,
- 25:38you're probably going to get two growth cycles and two flat cycles.
- 25:41And if you do that, your growth rate's probably going
- 25:44to equal the average. However,
- 25:46what happens in that 30-year period if that first part of that 30-year journey
- 25:51is a growth cycle? Well, what happens is that instead of getting
- 25:54a six percent average return, your average return is seven percent.
- 25:59So you get to add, if you buy well, as in
- 26:02you buy just before a growth cycle,
- 26:04you get to add an extra percent on average over that 30-year period.
- 26:09And that will go a long way to offsetting the impact of quarantine negative gearing.
- 26:15So I think there's two things.
- 26:16It's starting rental yield and really being selective about which market
- 26:20you invest in and try and give yourself the greatest opportunity
- 26:25to enjoy an initial growth cycle.
- 26:27Well, there's lots more we could talk about,
- 26:29Melbourne, but we've virtually run out of time.
- 26:31But I do want to actually say congratulations on the publication of your well,
- 26:36I know you've written a number of books,
- 26:37but your latest book, Wealth by Design,
- 26:39which I enjoyed reading, because what you're actually sharing in that
- 26:42is eight rules for smarter investing and financial freedom.
- 26:46Now we've discussed that in a previous podcast.
- 26:49So if you enjoyed listening to Stuart Wemyss and you would like
- 26:53to understand more about
- 26:54what he's got to say and what he's changed in his most recent book.
- 26:59Go back to wherever you're listening or watching this and you'll actually
- 27:02be able to hear an episode where we talked about that.
- 27:05By the way, if you don't currently follow or subscribe to this podcast,
- 27:09please click the follow button and hey,
- 27:12the algorithm will then send you all our best episodes.
- 27:14There's also probably people who you know who are concerned about Melbourne.
- 27:19They own properties in Melbourne, worried about it.
- 27:21Why not share this episode with them as well?
- 27:23But Stuart, you actually rewrote your book because the world changed in many ways.
- 27:29what would you suggest to somebody who says,
- 27:32I don't be I can't be bothered reading a book?
- 27:35I'm just listening to the free podcast.
- 27:37I'm gonna leave a link to where they can buy it and you get it on Amazon,
- 27:41but with it you've actually given some real bonus reasons for people to buy it.
- 27:46Maybe you can tell us a bit about that too.
- 27:47Yeah,
- 27:48so I built an AI companion tool with the book,
- 27:50Michael. So, you know, one of the big challenges when you get a book
- 27:53is you understand the concepts,
- 27:55but then how to apply those concepts to your personal circumstances.
- 27:59That tends to be the difficult bit to bridge.
- 28:01So we've got a Google Notebook tool,
- 28:04which is an AI tool. It's trained on the book,
- 28:06which means that you can go in and say,
- 28:09explain this section to me a bit clearer,
- 28:11or even better, you can ask it, how does this
- 28:15concept apply in my circumstances or even broader than that you can say here
- 28:19are my circumstances using the information in the book what would my next best move
- 28:25be in terms of investment wise now of course there's no replacement
- 28:28for personalized advice but it does help and similarly another one you could
- 28:33say is here's my properties and property attributes draft me a prompt that
- 28:38I could then paste into Claude or Chat GPT
- 28:41to do an analysis on my property portfolio because the tool is still locked down
- 28:45on just the information in the book,
- 28:47but you can draft prompts out of it and use it in other AI tools.
- 28:51So I think it's a bit of a game changer,
- 28:53Michael, because as I said, when I read books about particular topics,
- 28:57I can certainly grasp and understand the principles,
- 29:00but there there's always that challenge of yes,
- 29:02but my circumstances are slightly different.
- 29:04So how does it apply to me? and hopefully that helps people
- 29:08you know, apply that information to their personal circumstances a bit better.
- 29:11Well,
- 29:12that's a really good reason to buy the book.
- 29:14Now I'll leave a link in the show notes.
- 29:15I just had a quick look. You can get it on Kindle for less than twenty dollars.
- 29:19And Stuart, I'm not sure why, but Amazon are actually giving
- 29:22a twenty percent discount. So it's twenty- six dollars
- 29:25Yeah.
- 29:25for the for the hard copy book.
- 29:28I have it on my bookshelf and I recommend you get it as well.
- 29:31So as I said, I'll leave a link in the show notes.
- 29:33Now, I think it was been a worthwhile discussion today,
- 29:37Stuart, because there's people here
- 29:40Who have been sitting on a flat property market in Melbourne for over
- 29:43a decade wondering, what did they do wrong?
- 29:46And
- 29:46Well.
- 29:47the answer is probably nothing.
- 29:49It's likely you bought near the tail end of the longest,
- 29:53strongest growth cycle of any Australian capital city that's ever actually been
- 29:57recorded. And what followed was the market just working off that excess.
- 30:01Not a punishment for state taxes or government debt.
- 30:04By the way, some of the people who've recently bought in Perth after a long flat period
- 30:09got real benefit, and they're probably going to now go through a flat period
- 30:13as Brisbane will as well. So what I found compelling about Stuart's analysis
- 30:17is that Melbourne is now the clear outlier amongst the five large capital cities,
- 30:22sitting well below its long-term trend.
- 30:25and history suggests that gap's not going to stay open forever.
- 30:29So if you own a Melbourne property,
- 30:31I don't think you should jump in and s sell at the moment,
- 30:34assess whether the asset's likely to deliver in the future what you want it to,
- 30:39what you expect it to. if you bought it a while ago,
- 30:42you're probably gonna have tax benefits that you would not get if you swapped
- 30:46to a different property. if you're looking to buy at the moment,
- 30:48remember some of the best opportunities appear when the story surrounding
- 30:51the market is uncomfortable like it is.
- 30:54So both Stuart and I believe that Melbourne's on sale at the moment and will pick
- 30:58up in due course. Of course that's not a reason to buy anything blindly
- 31:02or hold on to a mediocre asset,
- 31:04a bad asset just out of stubbornness,
- 31:06but it is a reason to be strategic,
- 31:08to focus on investment grade properties in the right locations,
- 31:11and make your decision based on where the market's genuinely heading over
- 31:16the next decade. Not the noise from the last decade we've had.
- 31:20By the way, if you want help working through whether your Melbourne property
- 31:23or your broader portfolio is positioned for what comes next.
- 31:26That's exactly what we do at Metropole.
- 31:28I'll leave a link in the show notes to metropole.com.au and have a chat with
- 31:33one of our wealth strategists.
- 31:34So I look forward to catching up with you again for our monthly chat when we'll
- 31:38work through one of your other articles.
- 31:41Thanks, Michael. It's been fun as always.
- 31:49More than 20 years ago, I wrote the first edition of my best-selling book,
- 31:53How to Grow a Multi-Million Dollar Property Portfolio in Your Spare Time.
- 31:56Now, since then I've updated it several times as our markets changed,
- 32:00as the finance system changed,
- 32:01as the tax rules evolved. But this time I had no choice to bring out
- 32:05a new edition because the 2026 federal budget changed some of
- 32:09the fundamentals that serious property investors have relied on for years.
- 32:12So this new edition's got new chapters, updated numbers.
- 32:15And a straight assessment of what these changes actually mean
- 32:18if you're thinking about buying,
- 32:20holding or selling property. Now,
- 32:22to explain it all, I'm holding a series of seminars in Sydney,
- 32:25Melbourne, and Brisbane where Brett Warren and I are going to unpack the changes,
- 32:29discuss the opportunities that still exist,
- 32:31and answer your questions. So when you purchase a copy of this new book,
- 32:35your seminar admission is included for free.
- 32:38Now I haven't done anything like this for years and I don't plan to again,
- 32:41and we're deliberately keeping the rooms small.
- 32:44Because I want these events to be like a genuine conversation.
- 32:47I want to be able to look you in the eye,
- 32:49hear your questions, and talk openly about what's really happening
- 32:52in property and what these new rules could mean for you.
- 32:55Of course, a small room means limited seats,
- 32:57but I'm going to leave a link to this at the top of the show notes.
- 33:01So just have a look wherever you're watching this or listening to this
- 33:04and secure your place. A lot has changed in property,
- 33:07and I'd love to discuss that with you in the room.
- 33:16Each show I leave you a trivia question,
- 33:18a chance to win one of three books that I give away each week,
- 33:21and everyone who enters at propertytrivia.com.au gets a new updated report.
- 33:27True or false question today. After inflation,
- 33:30Melbourne's median house price has grown over the last decade.
- 33:35True or false? After inflation,
- 33:38Melbourne's median house price,
- 33:39you know, in real terms, has grown.
- 33:41True or false, go to propertytrivia.com.au,
- 33:46leave your answer. Doesn't matter if you've listened to the show a bit late,
- 33:49your entry will still count.
- 34:01I'd like to share a little story with you today,
- 34:03but there is a lesson behind this.
- 34:05The story goes back to the audience at the 1968 Olympic Games
- 34:10who didn't know it at the time,
- 34:12but they were about to witness not only an Olympic record,
- 34:15but a complete revolution of a particular sport.
- 34:18Now, as a long, lean teenager, Dick Fosbury was just another kid interested
- 34:22in track and field. He wanted to compete in the high jump.
- 34:25You know, athletes jump over a bar,
- 34:27whoever jumps the highest wins the event.
- 34:29Usually each athlete would toss their body over the bar and crash onto
- 34:33the padded landing pit on the other side.
- 34:35Now, the story goes that like most schools in the nineteen sixties,
- 34:39the landing pit in Fosbury's High School was made of wood chips and sawdust.
- 34:43Before his junior year, however,
- 34:45Fosbury's High School became one of the first to install a foam landing pit.
- 34:49Hey, that makes sense to me. But that gave him a crazy idea.
- 34:53What if instead of jumping the conventional way with his face towards the bar?
- 34:57Dick Fosbury turned his body, arched his back,
- 35:00and went over the bar backwards,
- 35:02landing on his neck and shoulders.
- 35:05Now people laughed at Fosbury's new style.
- 35:07One local newspaper said he looked like a fish flopping in a boat.
- 35:11Anyway, others called him the world's laziest high jumper and ran a photo
- 35:15of him sliding over the bar backwards.
- 35:17But in nineteen sixty eight Dick Fosbury was the only one laughing as
- 35:22he used his new unconventional technique to
- 35:25To win the NCAA championships and then qualify for the Olympic Games in Mexico City.
- 35:31By the time the games were finished,
- 35:33Fosbury not only set a new Olympic record by jumping two point two four meters,
- 35:38he also changed the entire philosophy of that particular sport.
- 35:42Within ten years his technique became th the new standard
- 35:45for high jumpers everywhere. Nearly every gold medal winner and major record holder
- 35:49in the last decades has used this
- 35:52Fosbury flop. Okay, what's the lesson of this?
- 35:55Why am I telling you this? I guess the lesson is to be unconventional.
- 35:58Fosbury's story offers a major lesson that extends far beyond sport
- 36:02and high jumping. His success came during a period when the environment
- 36:06of sport had changed, but everyone was still focusing on old patterns of behavior.
- 36:11Even though the switch to foam landing pads allowed athletes to experiment with
- 36:16a wider range of jumping techniques, no one questioned.
- 36:19Hey, could this be done better?
- 36:20Until Fosbury challenged the status quo.
- 36:23So, my message to you today is remember when the environment around a task changes,
- 36:28a new and better way to do things is usually possible.
- 36:31I'm a big believer in being the scientist and the subject.
- 36:35Simply put, you have to be willing to experiment with new ideas
- 36:38if you're serious about discovering what works best for you.
- 36:41So my take home message is start experimenting today.