Latest / Newcomer Pod / Tech Workers of the World Unite. Or Don't.
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome. Hey everybody.
- 0:14Welcome to this week's episode of dead cat.
- 0:16This is Tom do Tom coming to you here at the late-night, episode
- 0:19recorded on the weekend with Eric newcomer, and Katie better.
- 0:23We're all here, we're all here. We finally broke the seal and
- 0:26talking about crypto, which I gotta think will not Be the last
- 0:30time, by the way, on that topic. So you know, we tweeted out the
- 0:33episode and I said something to the effect of like I think every
- 0:36reporter probably needs to just like suck it up and learn at
- 0:38least the terminology and immediately.
- 0:41I was done by another reporter. I don't want to say his name
- 0:44because I didn't ask for his permission but he was like you
- 0:46coward. You coward.
- 0:47Are you bi? Are you buying into this?
- 0:49Like just goes into Spade. This is bullshit.
- 0:51No fantasy land this crate. Which, which, which part is the
- 0:56fantasy? Land is there's so much going on
- 0:58in the market. If I think the fact that I said
- 1:02crypto was worth taking seriously, enough reporters to
- 1:04at least understand the argument and the terminology, I thought
- 1:08it was a pretty Anodyne statement.
- 1:09How is it? That seems incontrovertible
- 1:12this? Well yeah, I mean people have
- 1:13made billions off of it. Like even if it was all like
- 1:18what a multi-level marketing scam or whatever, it's still
- 1:22just the scope of it. It feels like worth knowing and
- 1:25I obviously don't believe that's the case, but it feels like just
- 1:28the sheer money. It's crazy to me.
- 1:30My argument was just like what else you going to talk to people
- 1:32about right now? Like no one wants to talk about
- 1:34anything else. Let me go talk about just like
- 1:37uber pricing all day like no like it's you got to do
- 1:40something and so it's just like at the very least like develop a
- 1:43common set of terms that you can that you can engage on although
- 1:48the GM thing. The good morning thing is like
- 1:52in undeniably stupid. Yeah I mean it's stupid or not I
- 1:55think it's I agree that if you're going to try to debunk
- 1:59something, You need to actually speak the language of the thing.
- 2:03It is that you're trying to debunk.
- 2:04So if you want to poke holes into, you know something like
- 2:09residential mortgage-backed Securities, you should know what
- 2:12a residential mortgage-backed security is before you launch a
- 2:16full critique, right? With the very least if you don't
- 2:19believe in it. Then there's a lot of there's so
- 2:21much money invested in it. That's going to be a good story,
- 2:23one way or the other absolutely like people getting fleeced, if
- 2:27the whole thing is a crock of shit, so The very least prepare
- 2:31yourself for the stories of how it all fell apart.
- 2:32And then you can at least say how smart you were because of
- 2:34that. No.
- 2:35Yeah. And I mean, obviously the
- 2:36history of business reporting, you know, what?
- 2:39Junk bonds, I mean, you know, there's so much better than I do
- 2:42cable. Like, you know, there have been
- 2:44all these scandalous Financial tools that then go on to be
- 2:48useful, things in the economy or companies, like Amazon lie,
- 2:53absolutely. And you can't, and you can't
- 2:55talk about why they're scandalous and you can't explain
- 2:58to people what happened if you Use to learn the terminology of
- 3:01the product. You bought Bitcoin like a long
- 3:04time ago, right? I what you bought Bitcoin a
- 3:07while ago. You sold it.
- 3:10I did. I just it just sits there.
- 3:13How much did you buy? Just a Bitcoin.
- 3:17Look right here. Get because I thought because I
- 3:19think I bought it like $118. Oh my God.
- 3:23Wait. So it wasn't a full psych.
- 3:24Oh my God. By want to spend $200 on this
- 3:27thing? No, she bought a whole Bitcoin,
- 3:28right? Yeah.
- 3:30Yeah. That should be.
- 3:30That's tens of thousands. Oh yeah, myself.
- 3:37Well, it would be so stupid to spend more than $100 on this
- 3:41thing because it's gonna go to 0.
- 3:43But then I thought well, Maybe I should buy like 10 and I thought
- 3:47that's so stupid and I bought one.
- 3:49No, my god. I've never bought them because
- 3:51I've always had this terrible like purest reporter, Instinct
- 3:54that I'm slowly trying to shed? I clearly we first of all I
- 3:58should have been just be you left us for substance.
- 4:00I know, but I'm still a goody-goody in terms of like
- 4:03conflict. I made my first political
- 4:05donation the other day which I think you did.
- 4:07You disclose it on the show? Was it a conflict for me to buy
- 4:10a Bitcoin? I'm actually serious?
- 4:12I don't know. I was, that's what I knew.
- 4:14I was gonna B and H like I, you know, like was it a conflict?
- 4:19I donated to my to my friend, Ben Samuels, who's running for
- 4:23congress in a suburb of st. Louis, so, supporting your
- 4:28friend. What's avoid talking about on
- 4:30the show for your integrity? He's a Democrat.
- 4:33No, I just mean like you, I don't want you pumping up his
- 4:36numbers but I just want to show Tom and I do not endorse this
- 4:42Canyon. And by the way yeah, I have That
- 4:45made my selection yet, but I'll let you know, we'll have like a
- 4:47big, you know, New York Times Hulu, show the choice where we
- 4:51figure out who I'm endorsing in that race.
- 4:53But I do think I need to buy like a little bit of aetherium
- 4:57and Bitcoin. I mean I actually think the
- 5:00conflicts there are probably almost greater to an extent only
- 5:03in a company because I mean at least it's changed a bit now
- 5:06because there's so much more invested in it.
- 5:07But there was a time where an article about Bitcoin could
- 5:10materially influence the price. I think.
- 5:13Actually there was a reporter who right about now.
- 5:15I mean there's a whole there's no, I never wrote a publication
- 5:18that are set up to keep a lot of attention.
- 5:21Yeah, Jim Ledbetter. Jim Ledbetter has a whole
- 5:23publication. I think about, well, here's a
- 5:25letter. And then he works for somebody.
- 5:27But then there, you know, there's obviously coin desk has
- 5:29been around. There's yeah, there's a bunch of
- 5:34the block. I mean, they break news, I like
- 5:38some oh my follow them on Twitter, I mean it but yeah,
- 5:42there's plenty of they certainly own Do I mean there's obviously
- 5:46the counter-argument that not owning it is, I mean, not to
- 5:49parent their language but not owning and of it having all your
- 5:52money in dollars and traditional equities, you know, is a is a
- 5:58position, you know. They don't true neutral.
- 6:00The position is called being poor, I think that's silly.
- 6:03Yeah exactly like it's a lot of us just access.
- 6:06We should just divert what do you mean what?
- 6:08It's just access like you know I didn't not have stocks growing
- 6:13up and in college because I was Taking a position.
- 6:15It's because I was broke. Sure.
- 6:17Obviously, if you have no money, but once you have some money,
- 6:20you mean, like if you already have a portfolio to not
- 6:22diversify and agree. Exactly.
- 6:24Right. I would never want to be in a
- 6:26position where people would consider me outweigh in crypto.
- 6:29What's the requirement now? How about really did?
- 6:31I haven't really Diversified into private Equity Timber, you
- 6:36know, Venture and I just do whatever the harbor management
- 6:40companies. That's how I take my kids.
- 6:42Like I've taken my okay. And turn into a David Swensen
- 6:47style. That's it.
- 6:50I do think with Bloomberg, I got I mean like dodging cocks.
- 6:53I'm in some of the like managed but good at managing funds in my
- 6:57401 k because Bloomberg likes to have fancy stuff in there
- 7:01saying, we're kind of going far failed from crypto here.
- 7:03Now though, I would love to know what Bloomberg is.
- 7:06All right, well, Daniel and our conversation.
- 7:09The dispo co I very much enjoyed was a, you know, he sort of
- 7:13said, oh, seven percent or something.
- 7:15Krypto. That's not necessarily and that
- 7:17was a small. I mean he was you know, talking
- 7:20about somebody was 100% etherium, but I do think of a
- 7:24reporter where, you know, five to ten percent crypto, they
- 7:28wouldn't be conflicted Ness. Well they should I mean I do
- 7:33they ask you to do, they ask reporters to disclose it like at
- 7:35the times I haven't I haven't checked with The Insider if I
- 7:38mean request. Would they ask me to disclose a
- 7:40stock holding? I don't even cover business.
- 7:42I mean like if I went and bought like Bloomberg we couldn't own
- 7:44individual. Talks, we couldn't short.
- 7:46Yeah, I don't I mean I don't I don't know what or we could own
- 7:49individual stocks but it was a pain.
- 7:51You had to tell them which stocks and it couldn't be on
- 7:53your beat and then you probably couldn't write about it.
- 7:55So yeah, makes sense. I never write about stock in the
- 7:58company that you write about. What I feel like is thanks
- 8:00praying about tech. You're, you know, you're making
- 8:03implicit statements about tech relative to other Industries, I
- 8:07don't know. I mean, it was literally
- 8:08something I did at 2:00 in the morning after I had had a lot of
- 8:10drinks. It was, I didn't really think I
- 8:12was smart. Yeah, I just had And I think
- 8:16we're working with you at the time.
- 8:17Yeah. I just but I read prop.
- 8:20We had probably gone out for those drinks that I wasn't there
- 8:22for like the asset panic. I wish I had that we probably
- 8:27went out somewhere in the mission and have some cocktails.
- 8:30We're at the 500 Club or whatever.
- 8:32And then I went home and I was like, I'm buying a Bitcoin.
- 8:35Yeah, Kitty, neglected us you you were worldly, you knew
- 8:39things. I should have texted.
- 8:41You guys should have you just what I'm doing right now?
- 8:44Yeah. Yeah.
- 8:45Yeah God. I thought you guys were my
- 8:47friends but anyway I do think reporters should probably spend
- 8:51the time. Learning the language to be able
- 8:53to have at least semi coherent does very interesting
- 8:55controversial today in coherent people.
- 9:00But yeah, I'd be like if I was like I refuse to learn what an
- 9:05indictment is. I'm just going to do this job
- 9:09fucking not. Yeah.
- 9:11Early audience on this show is definitely reporters who Try to
- 9:15manage like what are, you know, 100 person audience will you.
- 9:21It's like, hey, how could you say that about me, or, you know,
- 9:25right, we're one step away from the call-in show, but I do want
- 9:29to, I do want to talk about Ben, Smith's column, okay?
- 9:31Yes, walk us through. What is the column?
- 9:33The column that Ben wrote? Which came out last Sunday was
- 9:37basically talking about why reporters have suddenly gotten
- 9:40so interested in labor and you know, that was very focused on A
- 9:45paper that I hadn't heard of in New York that was bought that
- 9:48was, you know, diving into a lot of the Union activity in New
- 9:52York City specifically. But, you know, we are in this
- 9:55period that, you know, we're in November now.
- 9:57But all the strikes that happened in October is something
- 10:00that has been heavily covered by a lot of the press.
- 10:02And I think the question that Ben was asking was like, you
- 10:06know why? Now is, you know, have reporters
- 10:08decided to jump on the story that some reporters have been
- 10:11covering for decades, but it hasn't gotten a ton of interest
- 10:13but it seems like it's caught on.
- 10:14Way now. And I think he's, you know, was
- 10:17drawing the comparison that reporters are in unions.
- 10:19There's a ton of digital media Outlets that have unionized.
- 10:21I work at one that voted to unionize, right?
- 10:24Right, when I joined. And for me, it was, it was
- 10:27personally interesting because I was on, I was at a company
- 10:31previously, that was not unionized.
- 10:32And I was on a beat that was completely uninterested in that
- 10:36particular, like the beat reporting in media, no one
- 10:39really cared about the Union's they do now, which is
- 10:41interesting. But at the time, it was all
- 10:42about, you know, what are the Solid ations and Acquisitions
- 10:46and shit shows that are happening at the corporate
- 10:49level. And I chose to leave to cover a
- 10:51beat, that is very much interested in labor.
- 10:54And so I thought there was going to be some discussion in there
- 10:56about like you know, what is change?
- 10:59That is caused reporters to take interest in something that is
- 11:02still, you know, low level compared to, you know, Ben had
- 11:06to deal with all the union negotiations at BuzzFeed and was
- 11:09on the side of management. So I did feel like he threaded
- 11:12his media story and this case As more about sort of these
- 11:17interesting weirdo Outlets, it wasn't so much about sort of the
- 11:22hip kids of digital media being obsessed with unionizing and
- 11:26those beat reporters, right? It went in a different direction
- 11:30but it just bring it to Tech specifically, you know, I mean
- 11:33Eric you wrote years ago at the information, a story sort of
- 11:37suggesting that Tech workers should unionized workers of the
- 11:40World Unite would attack workers of the world.
- 11:43Yeah. And I think that was a Jonathan
- 11:44web. Burr, who is our editor at the
- 11:47moment he definitely should have, you know, ghosts
- 11:50co-writing credit promotion, Evergreen Weber story as well
- 11:54because he he would love every industry to unionize.
- 11:59Sure. Well, I mean it was very
- 12:01prescient article I mean because it's just I mean made the point
- 12:05that software Engineers are so. In demand they should use their
- 12:08leverage to extract stuff but by large they have it from their
- 12:11employers but it was partially about you know, getting benefits
- 12:14for themselves. It was also, these companies are
- 12:17so powerful. They should use it to redirect
- 12:20those companies and we're sort of seen that.
- 12:21But again, it's like, and we've talked about, you know, the
- 12:24Apple employees protesting and the Apple employees.
- 12:29Really made it about their working conditions and not
- 12:33about, you know, factories, and in China.
- 12:36So I do think a lot of the, the labor movement from Engineers
- 12:40certainly has been around sort of diversity, equity and
- 12:43inclusion but Then sort of General working conditions, but
- 12:47it's outside of the process of a typical Union.
- 12:50Like the Google workers workers there there.
- 12:52Where there is a Google Union, I don't believe it has more than
- 12:551,000 members but aside from a lack of releasing statements
- 12:58here and there and putting some people on the record, they have
- 13:01no real power and I know like at a corporate level Google was
- 13:03very dismissive of them and then there's a few other startups
- 13:06that unionize Kickstarter and a few even less known ones, but it
- 13:11really hasn't taken off in any serious way, which I may be
- 13:14naive. We thought it was going to at
- 13:16the beginning of this year, but we're at a point and I don't
- 13:19know, I don't see it getting much better any time soon.
- 13:22And so as a reporter that's interested in labor and Tech,
- 13:25it's gone in a very different direction that I was the boss's
- 13:27one, they just fatigued. Yeah, I haven't honestly not
- 13:32covering the beat. There was, you know, you know,
- 13:34all this movement and you're right, it's been quiet.
- 13:37What is what is sort of the headline?
- 13:39It's hard to write the non-story but what is it?
- 13:42I think what happened is that people People that were upset
- 13:46about their jobs instead of trying to ban together to make
- 13:48their jobs better, they just left their jobs.
- 13:51They just decided to you know, freelancer or Cobble together,
- 13:56you know, up work like work or just bounce around for a couple
- 13:59of months from place to place. This is a controversial thing to
- 14:02say these days. But isn't that part of how
- 14:06American capitalism is supposed to work?
- 14:08You don't like your employer and you go to another company.
- 14:12Like I don't know that that Like a default reasonable way to
- 14:17correct corporate action. You know, if everybody's leaving
- 14:21is they don't like doesn't correct corporate action because
- 14:24the markets not tight enough for that to correct corporate
- 14:26accidently not intact. Now, it only correct corporate
- 14:28action if they're only 10 and jars.
- 14:30I mean, I don't know if you guys believe in them, but what
- 14:33hundred xers or whatever? I mean, the super talented
- 14:35employees where they go certainly, does have an impact
- 14:39on companies. Yeah.
- 14:40But they've all like they don't have connections to other, you
- 14:44know, their workers to a degree, right?
- 14:46Like they're not as interested in saying, like, hey, join with
- 14:48me, and I'll push for something better.
- 14:50That will improve the lot for everyone here.
- 14:52Like, they're more like shit. I'm a star.
- 14:54Let me see how much I can get from the company here, and, and
- 14:57maximizing that way. I mean, it's like the engineer
- 14:59version of joining a sub stack, right?
- 15:01I have a question, do you think that some of the reason why
- 15:05unionization didn't really take hold and tuck in the way you
- 15:08were anticipating is cultural. It's about how the employees
- 15:12view themselves and their jobs and their companies.
- 15:15And just as I will say, I'm just finishing the book uncanny
- 15:18valley. I know that I'm coming to it
- 15:20like a year after it came out. I haven't read it yet.
- 15:24Is it worth it? Did you like it?
- 15:25Sort of weird to read because we were all actually in San
- 15:28Francisco at the same exact time that Anna was, so her
- 15:31descriptions of the companies and the places are bringing back
- 15:35a lot of memories. But, you know, there's a scene
- 15:38where she talks about seeing somebody who's homeless, wearing
- 15:41a GitHub sweatshirt and she mentions it to 100.
- 15:45Colleagues and is really disturbed by it.
- 15:46You know, she's sort of sees it as this sort of like ultimate
- 15:49expression of how horrible the wealth Gap is become.
- 15:53And his he goes. Yeah, that's a bummer.
- 15:56And there's a long, pause things.
- 15:57Like I wonder who gave their sweatshirt away because we're
- 16:00really not supposed to do that, you know, misses the point where
- 16:04people love the imagery Gil, you know, when you're thinking about
- 16:07something when you're thinking about something like labor and
- 16:10you're and you're thinking about something like labor movements,
- 16:13The reason you join, you know, the idea you join you also
- 16:18sacrifice part of your paycheck. You become part of an entity is
- 16:23because you are thinking Beyond oneself.
- 16:27And because you are trying to think about how to make a
- 16:31company improve on a deeper cultural level.
- 16:33Yeah, I know is, I know a certain Union that had a little
- 16:37finagling about how much they wanted to give of themselves.
- 16:41But I'm just saying, like paying dues in All right thing, I'm
- 16:45just talkin New York Times Union, obvious like the that you
- 16:48pay dues and you become part of an organization.
- 16:52You only do that. You only go through the trouble.
- 16:54If you actually think there's kind of something wrong, you
- 16:57have to do it like once there's a human, right?
- 17:00We held, it's not like an individual Choice, your
- 17:03colleagues decide, and then you're probably right?
- 17:06But you need a mass of your colleagues to make that decision
- 17:08and it's not going to happen in a culture where people outside
- 17:11of diversity and inclusion is issues.
- 17:14It's not going to happen. If people are like, well, yes, I
- 17:16mean we should probably hire more black people.
- 17:19That's a bummer. But ultimately, we actually
- 17:21think that this relationship between the owners of the
- 17:25company and the workers in the company is just fine.
- 17:28How are you ever go? How will you never take off if
- 17:30that's the culture and that's the way people.
- 17:32What you're saying? You're saying, companies can
- 17:34still do diversity inclusion without unions, but otherwise
- 17:38there isn't the juice or I just want everything, like, beyond
- 17:41the question of diversity inclusion.
- 17:42Is there anything? Driving people in the valley to
- 17:45think. Oh my gosh, sickly yeah, intact
- 17:47to say right? Oh gosh, like I really don't
- 17:50like this arrangement for myself.
- 17:52I really feel disadvantaged and only by Banning together with my
- 17:55fellow workers. Can I can I rebalance this
- 17:59inequity? Well, it's a weird.
- 18:01If you're a white collar worker at Google, right.
- 18:04It's like obviously if you're the top person, you don't have a
- 18:06strong incentive and then if you're in the middle band of
- 18:09engineer or product manager, or whatever, maybe you have a In a
- 18:13financial incentive to improve the average, but then if you
- 18:17really embrace the ideology of the Union, you should be
- 18:20helping, you know, the contractors, the bus, you know,
- 18:23all of a sudden, it's like, oh, we're actually going to erode
- 18:26the nice white collar work. We have because if we really
- 18:28think broad, this is why I'm saying, it's a cultural
- 18:30question, right? Right.
- 18:32But I mean, a lot of unions are pitched.
- 18:34I mean, I'm not a scholar in the history of unions.
- 18:37Be. A lot of them are pitched is
- 18:38like self-interested, right? Like it's good for the specific
- 18:41workers who are Signing up. It's not some political project.
- 18:46Is that naive? Like isn't that nice?
- 18:48I know it's saying, yes, we have an interest in doing this but
- 18:51you yourself alone. Can't improve your situation.
- 18:54The only way for you. And but each individual voter
- 18:57who votes. Yes, is supposed to believe it
- 18:58will help them. You're supposed to get a
- 19:00majority. But what I'm trying to say is
- 19:02that the only way to pitch, basically, the union pitches
- 19:05you, the individual Eric, your work life, you don't like it but
- 19:10you the individual Eric can never change it because Total of
- 19:13power, but I have to believe that it helps me.
- 19:16So that is why you that is why you band together with others.
- 19:20So even though the pitch is even though the pictures, as you put
- 19:23it, self-centered it implies the only way to fix the problem is
- 19:27to not be self-centered, but I think culturally like, you're
- 19:30sort of circling around a lot of these people don't believe it
- 19:33will actually help. Well, that's them.
- 19:35That's what I'm saying. Or will ever help them?
- 19:37But I don't know if I think they're wrong.
- 19:39I mean, how much better off can they be?
- 19:41I mean. Well, this is the question.
- 19:43Because what it comes down to is not necessarily your state right
- 19:46now, but the state you could be in that if you're in a point in
- 19:49which you do not have, you're not an ideal situation.
- 19:52If you are, you know, threatening to be fired or your
- 19:55compensation, is what you think it should be.
- 19:57You have no recourse to push back on and all other than get
- 19:59another job, right? Like BuzzFeed is a great
- 20:01example, like there was a time when buzzfeed's valuation was
- 20:04really huge and there was no, you know, there, the idea that
- 20:08employees that would want to unionize when it was like the
- 20:10really fun Media Company. The interesting media Many, the
- 20:13media company is flush with cash.
- 20:14The media company with interesting stuff happening with
- 20:17money, where there were people making money to what's the
- 20:20incentive to unionize. And, of course, now years later,
- 20:23when fortunes took a turn, there's there it is.
- 20:26That's the insight. And I don't know with BuzzFeed
- 20:28specifically how much of them are compensated in stock that
- 20:31they thought like, oh, you know, we're going to the Moon here and
- 20:33everything's going to be great. But I think part of the issue
- 20:37that you're talking about is there's no historical connection
- 20:41to the union and the labor movement Within Tech that it's
- 20:43still a relatively new industry and with a lot of the, you know,
- 20:46like John Deere that's striking now.
- 20:48Yeah, there's been over probably 100 years or something of Union
- 20:51activity within like the tractor world but it's building up from
- 20:56such a standing start. Do you listen to the Chapo
- 20:58episode about the activism of John?
- 21:01Probably? Yeah, it was can't remember
- 21:03super interesting. I mean, yeah.
- 21:05Yeah, I mean, that's exciting. I mean, because they have
- 21:08exactly what you're saying, they have a legacy to it, they sort
- 21:12of really understand it. Are bought in, they see how it's
- 21:14going to help them. And I've seen, you know, I spent
- 21:16some time talking to the Google Union, the alphabet Union and,
- 21:21you know, they're interesting, they're nice people, they
- 21:23clearly care about this idea. I mean, there's a little out,
- 21:27their beliefs, on their part that they think they can
- 21:29influence like, who Google does business with, which I mean,
- 21:32that would be incredibly powerful if they could.
- 21:34I mean, that's the stuff that, you know, employees that are
- 21:38unhappy with their company. I mean, that's real chain.
- 21:40That's a lot more I think than just issues with diversity.
- 21:43And whatever, but they're never gonna be able to do that.
- 21:46There is no way that the Google Union and what company Can
- 21:48employees do that. Like I'm I don't think there is
- 21:51one and within Tech none. I mean I spoke to some banking
- 21:56know it like your teacher to school.
- 21:59You're an elementary school teacher.
- 22:01You can you can even get the the universities to divest from oil,
- 22:05right? I mean there's slowly doing it
- 22:07now that maybe it's a bad economic bet but if you can't
- 22:10get not a problem, nonprofit. Universities who are doing
- 22:15research to divest, the idea that you're going to get a
- 22:18company that you're going to get Google to not get million, do
- 22:21military contracts. I mean, it's it's a heavy lift
- 22:25just on the media side. I mean, I do think one way the
- 22:28unionizing fits into the text or is just I think, you know, there
- 22:33are people in Tech not these workers unionizing but, you
- 22:37know, sort of the leaders who see reporters like being active
- 22:43Organizers and just very on one side of the labor movement at a
- 22:48time. When part of the story of tech
- 22:50is tech companies, fighting with their own labor organizers.
- 22:55And I do think it feeds into the notion that reporters are, more
- 23:00and more willing to just pick a side that they're expressly
- 23:04pro-labor, which makes them right Pro worker who's
- 23:07protesting against their employer.
- 23:10And that just means that on every one of these These sort of
- 23:14anti Apple Google Facebook Stories, you know, reporters are
- 23:20clearly on this side of the Whistleblower or the word, which
- 23:22is where, I thought Ben's column was going to go, it didn't
- 23:25really in the end. But yeah, there's no question in
- 23:27my mind that reporters are trying to like gun it a bit on
- 23:31the labor side and and Juice these kinds of spaces, it's
- 23:34really an aesthetical to what reporting supposed to be.
- 23:37Like I realized that part of forming labor unions is to bully
- 23:41people into posting like Pictures or apparently, that's
- 23:44what common labor organizing is now, right?
- 23:47I mean, you have to literally scold people into like, putting
- 23:50your union in their Twitter Avatar, but it just seems
- 23:54reporters are supposed to be sort of individual thinkers
- 23:57people, you know, unaligned necessarily and then the unions
- 24:02are demanding that they participate in this movement,
- 24:04with all sorts of ideological commitments.
- 24:08Katie, please push back on me if you disagree, I just like I'm
- 24:13Saying that labor is this issue. But at what point does it just
- 24:17make sense for reporters and Mass to make some decisions
- 24:20about how they cover an issue and come down on a side.
- 24:25So for example, when reporters were covering, you know, the
- 24:28march across the Pettus bridge and they're watching, you know,
- 24:31people get their shit beat out of them by cops because there
- 24:33are trying to, like a take in a Civil Rights march, you know,
- 24:38there was a reason why the coverage wasn't like, well, on
- 24:41the one hand, right? Cops.
- 24:43The cops do this, but on the other hand, civil rights
- 24:47Marchers are doing this. There was a reason why the
- 24:50coverage was. John Lewis just almost died on
- 24:52this bridge. And if he does, he'll be a
- 24:53martyr. For one of those Noble causes
- 24:55that's happened in the country and decade, I do think to
- 24:57counterbalance that if you're going to take a stance, it's
- 25:00good to be sort of open with what your values and sort of
- 25:04approach is. And I don't think the view from
- 25:07nowhere like journalism is willing to really admit.
- 25:10I was just saying, I don't think that is the view from nowhere.
- 25:12I don't think you can have you from know.
- 25:13We're on some issues by the way, even though I do think, you
- 25:16know, a lot of reporters are juicing the labor issue in Tech,
- 25:19more than the momentum actually allows for.
- 25:22I don't think it's gotten that extreme except when you just
- 25:26flat-out miss the story and that to me is like the biggest
- 25:28problem you have. When you're, you know, your bias
- 25:30is push you towards thinking, something is bigger than it is,
- 25:34and like me, there's no better example of that than the Amazon
- 25:36warehouse. Absolutely like, if you read the
- 25:39coverage, and basically, every mainstream publication, it was
- 25:42like, Amazon's going to have a you 100%.
- 25:44But you might have got like this thing was gonna be an
- 25:46overwhelming slam-dunk thing. And where's the recrimination?
- 25:49Everybody just fucking moves on with their life.
- 25:52It was a big Miss II. Do think that's the reporters
- 25:55should get things right on their beat and and you can tell when
- 25:59they're cheering, when they don't care about getting it,
- 26:01right? They want to help out come
- 26:03along. But there was an excellent story
- 26:05about that after the fact that the media side of things, but
- 26:07Harper's actually randomly did it earlier periods because there
- 26:11again, they're free of the narrative.
- 26:13I mean it Not always good but we ignore them when they're bad and
- 26:16when they're good they penetrate.
- 26:17Well, the story was written very, you know, from a very
- 26:19pro-labor reporter. Like I'm sure he's someone who's
- 26:21like submitted pieces to Jack event or something, right.
- 26:23But the story actually took time to like go to the warehouse and
- 26:29Alabama and talk to some of the people that were against it and
- 26:32that were for it. And the big takeaway from that
- 26:34piece, was that the younger people who've never been in
- 26:37unions? They didn't really grow up in
- 26:39that environment, didn't understand the value of it, and
- 26:42they don't view of working at Amazon.
- 26:43Permanent job. And so for them it's like why
- 26:45should I invest you know my time lose a little bit of my income
- 26:49in furtherance of a union working at a company that I
- 26:52don't really want to be on, you know, be out in a couple years
- 26:54because I really want to be like a you know an influencer and and
- 26:57start my like Instagram makeup label or something and Amazon.
- 27:01By the way, completely benefits from that, you know, like they
- 27:04run ads constantly talking about like work at Amazon will help
- 27:06you. You know, go to college, get a
- 27:07degree and and that theoretically would mean you
- 27:10don't have to work there anymore but yeah I mean like the real
- 27:13reporting About that, after the fact explained extremely well,
- 27:16what happened there? But I think Amazon was freaked
- 27:19out by it to write. Like they read the Press
- 27:21coverage. They saw all the stories talking
- 27:23about like the rising anger at this Warehouse.
- 27:26Well, they know it's existential.
- 27:27I mean if you read Brad's book, Amazon imbalance or the sequel,
- 27:31to The everything store, very enjoyable.
- 27:35If you if you care about Amazon it's like a great book to read
- 27:38and maybe I was naive going into it but coming out of that book
- 27:43if I Pick one major theme. It is just like Amazon is in
- 27:46every way set up to avoid unionization, and from top to
- 27:51bottom, that company is like will do everything they can to
- 27:54kill Union, which, you know. Yeah.
- 27:57It is pretty dark and speaks to the power of unions for lubbers
- 28:01the same way, right? I mean you know from covering it
- 28:04during its earliest, right. It's and then we stayed here
- 28:06until I mean it's existential for them tubers such a I mean I
- 28:12was four The California Proposition.
- 28:14I mean, Ubers a Marketplace. I mean that's inherent to the
- 28:18biz. Anyway, that's a long.
- 28:20Yeah, fight. We built a lot of these tech
- 28:22companies are I guess my point was that they are existentially.
- 28:25You know, connected to the need to not have a union among their
- 28:29large labor workforce, right? But yeah, I do think Amazon was
- 28:33misled almost by the reporting that happened because member
- 28:36there was that period where you know, the head of Amazon's
- 28:40Warehouse divisions was out there.
- 28:42Tweeting like in It's to Bernie Sanders which apparently other
- 28:46stories were saying was after being, you know, pushed by Bezos
- 28:49to do this because he was worried that they were losing
- 28:51like the Battle of public opinion on this front.
- 28:54And I just think ultimately, they don't care that much about.
- 28:57They don't need to care that much.
- 28:58About public opinion. Like the the momentum is so much
- 29:01both a to, I mean, Amazon's more popular than the media than
- 29:05Congress. I mean, it is one of the most
- 29:06popular institutions in the United States.
- 29:10So they definitely need to care about public opinion.
- 29:13They Not necessarily need to care.
- 29:14I mean, on this issue, the media is opinion, right?
- 29:16And they need to understand that people's assessment of Amazon is
- 29:20as much shaped by going to amazon.com as it is what they
- 29:24read in the New York Times. And so right, they have a lot of
- 29:26control, right? And sometimes getting drawn into
- 29:29the fights that the media wants them to is probably a losing
- 29:33proposition and that's extremely frustrating for reporters who
- 29:38want to frame The Narrative. Yeah, my last thoughts on this
- 29:41is just that I would have thought after the Which has been
- 29:44over a year now, since, since the Amazon warehouse vote that
- 29:46they could you know this could have been a time for reporters
- 29:49to recalibrate the way they cover labor and and try to at
- 29:53least accurately conveyed a readers where what the
- 29:55temperature actually is and what most people want to do and, you
- 29:59know, I guess I theoretically am included in that group.
- 30:01I'm curious. What is your position on the
- 30:03beat? I mean, obviously, you've gone,
- 30:05strong on, go puff, and it's like, okay, we have this sort of
- 30:08bubbly new, emergent startup world that's going to have some
- 30:11of the same excesses of Of logistics and food delivery of
- 30:15the past. So that's like a clear thesis
- 30:18that comes through and is smart. But I do feel like you're sort
- 30:20of in this tough position where you're not going to be the raw
- 30:25Union partially because you're expressing this thesis, that the
- 30:28real reporters have overstated it, but you're not really,
- 30:32you're not going to take the pure.
- 30:34What's the? I mean?
- 30:35Not like it's pure narrative-driven.
- 30:38But like, do you see like a through line or Direction?
- 30:42I think the There is no and I think but because it's know, it
- 30:46really just means that it's going to be status quo and and
- 30:49Status Quo is to not have any large cohesive at least in the
- 30:53u.s. movement of organization among like gig workers.
- 30:56You know drivers and delivery workers.
- 30:58And and I think that is, you know, if it's incredibly hard I
- 31:02find not to complain or why but it's hard to report on because
- 31:06it's even hard to get a fair sampling of workers at this like
- 31:09one of the typical things that reporters do if you want to like
- 31:12interview, Dr. Ivers is you you can go to a male Harry camera.
- 31:17Yeah, this guy runs the Rideshare guy blog, and he, yes,
- 31:21yes, yes. Oh, there's there's guys like
- 31:23Harry Campbell. Who's really nice and I email
- 31:24him. I like him lie.
- 31:26I try not to go to him to get drivers.
- 31:29I will say he's better than going to like Cal Rideshare dot
- 31:32org and all these other you know driver advocacy groups.
- 31:34Because they you know, literally put the same people on the phone
- 31:38in multiple articles which if you think about is, he's insane
- 31:41risers. So many Drive.
- 31:42There's so many Drive. Driver should turn so much.
- 31:45Like how can you yeah, yeah, or you go to What's even worse I
- 31:48think is go to Uber Lyft. They like you classic reporter.
- 31:52Your strategy is like hey Advocate on one side you give me
- 31:55six drivers and hey boober you give me six or whatever.
- 31:59I mean, I'm yeah, I mean, you know, I did a story about driver
- 32:02sleeping their cars and their we literally went to a grocery
- 32:04store and talked about drivers and there is a degree to which I
- 32:08mean, obviously if you're taking a lot of Ubers you can talk to
- 32:10drivers and it's it's super interesting to get it.
- 32:13The ranch of points of view. Well that to me is the best way
- 32:16to do it. I mean, it's very anecdotal.
- 32:18You're literally I was in the zubur with a guy who's literally
- 32:20like yeah, all the other Ubers aren't working because they're
- 32:23getting unemployment and like they're lazy it whether it was
- 32:27even their lazy. They're just like they're making
- 32:28an economic calculus. They're making more in
- 32:30unemployment and you know, like no leftist reporter wants to
- 32:34really put that right print but I was is from the mouth of an
- 32:37Uber driver. I mean that I think was uberX.
- 32:39It wasn't like uber black or anything.
- 32:41It was just sort of like I'm out here hustling.
- 32:43Like I had a failed business, you know, other people aren't
- 32:46working, right now, I'm still working like, you know, they're
- 32:49getting on. What?
- 32:50Yeah, I mean, that was his point of view.
- 32:51And it's, I mean, drivers are not, I mean, this is sort of a
- 32:56through line of Democratic Party politics throughout like, you
- 32:59know, the Working Class People in the party or aligned, with
- 33:03aren't don't necessarily share the same values as the media.
- 33:07Yeah, because they haven't worked in unions.
- 33:09A lot of them in the past or if they have, they didn't have a
- 33:11good experience with it for some reason or another Other and
- 33:14yeah, I agree with you. I think it's probably the best
- 33:18way that I've found to get any sort, at least for Uber drivers
- 33:21is to just go in and talk to one and it's anecdotal and it's just
- 33:25one sampling, but it's much better than going to the
- 33:28advocacy groups, or the companies and saying give me
- 33:30someone who's going to give me a quote, but that's what most
- 33:32reporters do. Isn't it completely the problem
- 33:34of politics today? Which is why people are
- 33:36mystified when they see that minorities who voted for Trump
- 33:40are there, like confused about why women who voted for Trump
- 33:43are there? Not understanding why blue
- 33:44collar workers don't want to support Democrats.
- 33:46When Democrats have always owned blue collar workers and it's
- 33:49like, maybe it's because you don't talk to anybody, right?
- 33:52Because we only talked to Consultants, maybe it's good.
- 33:54You have no ground game where the advocacy groups that the
- 33:57Consultants put you in, you know, in contact with to get to
- 34:00the workers themselves. I didn't I didn't rank.
- 34:02Eric Adams, I wouldn't have voted for Joe Biden.
- 34:05You know, it's just like, I'm so disconnected.
- 34:07Now, I don't like, oh, Eric Adams is an exciting mayor, but
- 34:10it's like it just fast. Well, Eric Adams is going to
- 34:12make near Big city, the best story.
- 34:14I know it's the next few years. My temptation to go to the Metro
- 34:19desk is huge huge. He's he's fascinating.
- 34:24Is is going to be an amazing person, the cover.
- 34:27I'll put it that way. I just went to Sergio.
- 34:29My girlfriend has a film coming out about Andrew Yang.
- 34:33I just went to the premiere today.
- 34:35How was it? I'm so excited.
- 34:36Notice great thing to get into. It's amazing to see, you know,
- 34:40I've seen lots of the cuts along the way but to see a finished
- 34:43Product and then lat, you know, any theater, it's good and it's
- 34:48fun to listen, you know, to the, the audience laughs at the right
- 34:51things and sort of. So I'm excited.
- 34:54I think it goes on online for a real December but you know Eric
- 34:58Adams it's a big character is the second time we mentioned on
- 35:01the podcast to I'm not really he's like all over my life.
- 35:04I mean it's fat. It's nice to have a mayor that
- 35:06feels like New York. I mean to bother was just so
- 35:08bad, you know. It just you want like this sort
- 35:11of cultural standard Bearer. In a mayor and Eric Adams was
- 35:15like, oh yeah, I went to two clubs, you know, they already
- 35:18got them like parking on the sidewalk blocking traffic there.
- 35:22They're tracking, he's gonna be an extraordinary, interesting
- 35:26person to cover, I'll put it that way, but I think that one
- 35:29of the reasons why a lot of Institutions especially
- 35:32mainstream institutions are surprised by how people behave,
- 35:36whether its workers at companies wanting to, or not wanting to
- 35:39unionize, whether it's how people vote whether it's how
- 35:41people feel about, The issues is because they already presume
- 35:45that they know based on Market Research style data about
- 35:50demographics, that that continues to make less and less
- 35:54sense every day as the country changes.
- 35:56You know, this idea that by 2048 the country would be there, be
- 36:00more minorities in the country than people who are white.
- 36:03The presumption was, that that would mean that we would have
- 36:05this, like, really liberal country demographics are
- 36:08Destiny. Obviously, that's not right,
- 36:10because it presumed that people weren't white cannot be
- 36:12conservative. Which is one of the dumbest
- 36:14things I've ever heard in my life, right?
- 36:16Like, hello. Because I have melon, it means I
- 36:18can't have a conservative point of view, there's literally
- 36:21insane especially when you look at who emigrates here and you
- 36:25look at, if you spoke with people, you might understand
- 36:27that their values, they come to the United States with values
- 36:31based on their own beliefs, not based on the color of their skin
- 36:35and how that's supposed to fit into some sort of like,
- 36:37demographers view, who people are inside a land of opportunity
- 36:41messages, very popular with people.
- 36:44Don't have religious message, right?
- 36:46You know, also it was also the belief, I think not.
- 36:49I think it was the belief on the Democrats part or their
- 36:52Consultants part that like, well, the Republicans are so
- 36:54racist that there's no way they would ever want to support them.
- 36:57You kidding me. And it was like, it's like,
- 36:59well, if people are a little complicated and like plus to do
- 37:02anything than that. Yeah.
- 37:04Also like if your policies aren't going to directly benefit
- 37:06their lives on a regular basis, like I think they can or if your
- 37:10economic benefits come with a system of values in Imposed cram
- 37:14Downs cram down people's throats that they just don't agree with.
- 37:16They're not going to care about the economic benefits.
- 37:19But I think that one of the reasons why it is hard to pin
- 37:23down where Tech is going to be on labor issues is because we
- 37:28have a really limited view of why people would or would not
- 37:32right to unionize the issue and the issue is they actually care
- 37:34about which can actually only be discerned by doing what you guys
- 37:38are doing, which is actually talking to people on the ground
- 37:40who are working these jobs. You know, the idea that they
- 37:42think of the jobs is A short term is an extremely compelling,
- 37:45reason not to unionize like when my dad worked in unionized
- 37:49Industries, he worked in factories this because people
- 37:53thought they were going to work those jobs for their entire
- 37:55lives, right? And they had reason to.
- 37:56And so they were like, if I'm going to be in this for the Long
- 37:58Haul, I want to make sure that I get pay increases and that it's
- 38:02safe. And job swapping is, in some
- 38:05ways, an alternative to a union because you're absolutely,
- 38:09they're competing for you and you can practice tomorrow
- 38:12Market. Right?
- 38:13And a couple ways to deal with disempowered already be so
- 38:16straightforward. It's such a we obviously, if
- 38:19people move jobs every two years, do they need a union?
- 38:21If you're mobile and people who are just staying at a company,
- 38:25where everybody who's skilled is moving around, it's like while
- 38:28you're staying there, you know, I just think go to a new job.
- 38:32I know the job hopping is another form of empowerment that
- 38:35if you don't think you're going to get it from a union or if you
- 38:38don't think a union is necessary or you don't believe in the the
- 38:41purpose of a union. Yeah.
- 38:43Leaving your job, every couple of years and negotiating to go
- 38:46from, you know, Google to Facebook.
- 38:49Apple Uber is another way of empowering yourself.
- 38:54What was the last thing I wanted to talk about?
- 38:56You know, the Verge came out with a piece.
- 38:59A we're going to push back what, you know?
- 39:00Well, here's here's the red M. Audience loves on background.
- 39:04I mean, this is who's listening this by cast.
- 39:07Certainly, no. No, I'm not joking before
- 39:08letters are for our young people and yeah, everybody in this
- 39:12story shaping and Founders who want to know how it's how these
- 39:15things actually get talked about.
- 39:18Yeah, explain explain what the verge's stance was and they're
- 39:21very little diverges, basically. I mean like every reporter wants
- 39:26to have more official company statements on the record and
- 39:30less sort of with weird on background attribution and then
- 39:35it basically had a list of absurd cases, Tom, do you want
- 39:40to pull it up and read a few? Okay, so the Article is headline
- 39:44updating The Verge background policy and it's nilay.
- 39:47Patel, who is the editor-in-chief go, he's the
- 39:49main guy, he's the main guy at the Verge and he basically is
- 39:52saying we as a company or as a media organization have made the
- 39:55decision that we will no longer allow companies to comment on
- 39:58background quoted as a source familiar with the matter or a
- 40:01person close to the company. I don't even think they want to
- 40:03do spokesperson if they just want to name the name and it's
- 40:07as the examples that he gives in here a major car companies head
- 40:12of communications Has told us in April Fool's joke was actually
- 40:15real on background. The joke was not real, that's
- 40:17just lying. Yeah, that's the music, man.
- 40:20That's not a good example. A food delivery company insisted
- 40:22on discussing the popularity of chicken wings on background and
- 40:26these are pretty stupid, right? I have you like my big beef with
- 40:30them. Is it agree with you?
- 40:31Look dumb example, right? They trivialize the real.
- 40:34They don't really give you the plausible case for, why
- 40:38backgrounds good why companies would want to do it.
- 40:41And, and the Very Just how one-sided and sort of laughable
- 40:47and seemingly like inarguable their post is to me is exactly
- 40:52the reason background is good because companies can't trust
- 40:55reporters all the time to fairly construe their argument but
- 41:00still feels entitled to defend themselves.
- 41:02So if you're in a case where you don't trust a reporter but you
- 41:05still feel like you should be able to be heard, you talk to
- 41:08them on background and say listen here's the argument you
- 41:12misuse my Words, whenever I give you something on the record, but
- 41:15here it is. Yeah, I thought that post was
- 41:18sort of, just like a classic argument for why I wouldn't
- 41:22trust reporters for just like every word I'm saying, on the
- 41:26record, I guess where I come down on this is you as a
- 41:30reporter are I guess a media organization should just make
- 41:33whatever decision that makes the story as transparent as possible
- 41:37as who you were talking to you for it and if you're talking to
- 41:40sources, that can't be named because they would be fired
- 41:42then. You make that clear in the story
- 41:44which a lot of organizations do, and if it's a company, you
- 41:47should just afford them the same level of transparency.
- 41:50And I do think it's annoying and probably misleading to
- 41:54audiences, or to readers to say a source close to the company
- 41:58when it really should be the company.
- 41:59And I think as reporters you should push back as much as
- 42:02possible to not use that language when it comes to using
- 42:05their name. Specifically, I don't really
- 42:07care that much. I mean my big issue with the
- 42:09Verge is like yeah it's purely from a reporter's point of view
- 42:12on something that has a lot. Lot to do with PR and it doesn't
- 42:15really surface what PR people think, which is bad reporting.
- 42:19Well sometimes it's like, oh, I won't attribute that because I
- 42:22sort of know. I know, I know it 90% from
- 42:26something else, but I might not have done it.
- 42:27If the pr person was like, yes, you're right on that, right?
- 42:30But then you're not actually attributing it because now
- 42:32you're sort of and you're not attributing it to them, or their
- 42:34times a, we give people that benefit of the doubt because we
- 42:37need them for something else, right?
- 42:39Be realistic or there, sometimes we don't give people the benefit
- 42:41of the doubt because they've screwed us.
- 42:43Right. So, I mean, so I just think that
- 42:45this, this idea that you're either presenting wreck
- 42:49information on the record you're presenting on the background and
- 42:52then is simply a transparency issue as a little bit
- 42:55simplistic. I just think we're in a case
- 42:56where companies like to say no comment and then they want to
- 43:00include within the story. Something that doesn't sound
- 43:03like it's coming from the company that clearly is and what
- 43:06you want. There's so many ways to get that
- 43:07information out those. Not the company, you know, get
- 43:10one of your gajillion board members to say something or get
- 43:12some Buddy, who was in the meeting and question to say
- 43:15something, you don't have to write and it gets it.
- 43:17What is it? What?
- 43:17I call the journal, the Barney rule would but reporters like to
- 43:19play all sorts of, I mean, reporters, love to play naive
- 43:23when it's like, oh, this executive at Facebook is talking
- 43:27me on background, that's not authorized, that's a source but
- 43:30come on, like it. Like, it's got to be coordinated
- 43:33with the company in some cases and they're not going to stop
- 43:37taking that information and putting in the store.
- 43:38So, I, I just think a lot of these Tech reporters.
- 43:41It's not, they're just mad that it's Sloppy on the that is
- 43:44coming from calms. I'm actually agree with you.
- 43:47I'm just saying that, exactly, I think that Communications
- 43:51departments if they're good, get lots of information to reporters
- 43:54that don't come from the company, right?
- 43:57You have you have you ever written a profile of someone
- 43:59before? Right?
- 43:59All right. Let's just, let's just insist
- 44:01the dark arts, you know, get a little more Savvy, you know,
- 44:04just they can't have columns in the title they if you were in a
- 44:07profile, you know, you call the company or like, I want to write
- 44:10a profile of Jamie dimon. It's like, you don't talk But
- 44:13all I can do for comment and then somebody get called out of
- 44:16the blue. Random people who may have known
- 44:17Jamie dimon. His art teacher likes it like
- 44:20that. That's a right.
- 44:22But I like that version of the Arts.
- 44:24It's not some purists sure. I guess if you take it as total
- 44:27like realpolitik, it's like yeah, we're pushing back against
- 44:30lame background information from Commerce department.
- 44:34So that's really what we mean. We want you to really work for
- 44:36it. Makes it seem like it's, we want
- 44:38it spicy. So we have the artifice to give
- 44:40our readers like a seemingly. Well, reported Worried that was
- 44:43actually assisted by company. I have a feeling we're going to
- 44:47revisit this issue with the pr person and you can on the record
- 44:50and we'll take him to, we'll take him to the wood shed on
- 44:53this particular practice, and they can tell us their dark arts
- 44:56and how they get all of their cool friends to call us.
- 44:58And we suddenly have board members that never wanted to
- 45:00return a folk before sink very positive things.
- 45:14Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 45:17goodbye. Goodbye.
- 45:14Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 45:17goodbye. Goodbye.