Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Rejects Feedback
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot in this series about the employee who always has something to say — the interrupter, the know-it-all, the person who says 'I already know that.' But there's one specific behavior that I think stumps managers more than almost any other. Luna: Which one? Lucas: The employee who just flat out rejects feedback. Not by arguing, not by deflecting — they simply say 'I don't need feedback' or 'I'm fine.' And they mean it. They genuinely don't see the point. Luna: That is a tough nut. Because feedback is kind of the engine of growth for any team. If someone won't even open the door to it, how do you help them improve? Lucas: Exactly. And it's more common than you'd think. Gallup published a study earlier this year — I'm going to say 2025 — and they found that 42 percent of employees actively avoid feedback. Not just ignore it, but avoid situations where they might receive it. Luna: Forty-two percent? That's almost half the workforce. And I bet that number is even higher for certain personality types or in certain cultures. Lucas: Right. So the first thing we need to understand is why. Why would someone reject feedback? It's rarely arrogance. More often it's fear — fear of being judged, fear of failing, or sometimes just a belief that they've already peaked and don't need to change. Luna: That last one is dangerous. The 'I've got this' attitude. Especially with senior employees who've been around a while. Lucas: Yeah, and that's where many managers trip up. They try to force feedback, which only makes the employee double down. So the first strategy is: make feedback routine, not a verdict. If feedback only comes during annual reviews or after a mistake, it feels like judgment. But if you're giving small, frequent input — like 'Hey, that presentation had a strong opening; maybe tighten the middle section' — it becomes normal. Luna: Normalize it. So it's not a big deal. That reminds me of a line I read in a book called 'Thanks for the Feedback' — they say feedback is like learning a new sport. You don't expect to get it right the first time. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the second strategy — shift from evaluation to curiosity. Instead of saying 'You need to improve X,' say 'I'm curious about your approach to X. What was your thinking?' That opens a dialogue, not a defense. Luna: So you're lowering the threat. You're asking a question rather than making a statement. That feels more like coaching. Lucas: Right. And the third strategy is to use peer-based input. Sometimes the manager is the last person an employee wants feedback from. If you can set up a culture where team members give each other constructive input — even anonymously — it can bypass the defensiveness. Luna: I've seen that work. At my old company, we had a weekly 'grow and share' where people submitted one thing they appreciated about a colleague and one suggestion. It started awkward, but within a month it became the norm. Lucas: That's a great example. And it ties into something else — the manager's own willingness to receive feedback. If you're the boss and you ask your team for feedback on your own performance, you model the behavior. It becomes bidirectional. Luna: That takes guts though. Asking your team 'What could I do better?' — especially if you're a first-time manager. Lucas: It does. But it's the most powerful way to lower the barrier. So those are the three strategies: make it routine, be curious, and leverage peers. But let's talk about a real case. I was working with a mid-stage tech startup about a year ago — they had a senior engineer, let's call him Mark. He was brilliant, shipped code fast, but he hated feedback. Every time his manager tried to give him input on architecture or style, Mark would say 'It's fine, I've been doing this for ten years.' Luna: Classic. And how did the manager handle it? Lucas: She started by reframing feedback as a tool for growth, not a critique. She said, 'Mark, I'm not saying you're wrong. I'm saying we have a chance to make the code even more maintainable. Help me understand why you chose this approach.' That curiosity switch opened him up. Over time, she also paired him with a junior dev for code reviews — Mark ended up giving feedback, which made him more receptive to receiving it. Luna: That's clever. He became the mentor, so he saw the value from the other side. Lucas: Exactly. And within a few months, Mark was actively seeking feedback. He even started a Friday lunch and learn where the team shared best practices. It was a total turnaround. Luna: That story is inspiring. And it reminds me that sometimes the employee who rejects feedback is actually just lacking a safe environment to receive it. Which brings up another point — how much of this is on the manager to create that safety? Lucas: Almost all of it. Especially in a one-on-one setting. If you come in guns blazing, they'll shut down. But if you start with something like 'I want to help you succeed, and to do that I need to understand your perspective first,' it changes the dynamic. Luna: I think a lot of managers avoid giving feedback to this type of employee altogether. They think 'they won't listen anyway' and just let it slide. Lucas: That's a common trap. And it's bad for the team. Because if one person isn't growing, the whole team can stagnate. So managers need to lean in, not back off. Luna: And that's the thing about feedback — it's a gift, but only if someone is willing to receive it. And speaking of gifts, I want to mention something that keeps this show going. We're ad-free, and that's because of listeners who support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. If you've found value in these conversations — maybe you've applied a tip and seen a change in your team — consider throwing a coffee our way. It really helps us keep doing this. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small gesture that goes a long way. And we're grateful for every bit of support. So back to the strategies — there's one more thing I want to flag: timing. If you try to give feedback right after a stressful meeting or during a deadline crunch, you're almost guaranteed to get resistance. Luna: Good point. Pick your moment. Maybe even schedule a separate 15-minute check-in just for growth conversations. Lucas: Exactly. And never surprise them. Say 'Hey, I'd like to share some thoughts on the project later. When's a good time?' That gives them a chance to prepare mentally. Luna: That's respectful. And it reduces defensiveness. So to wrap up, what's the one takeaway you'd leave managers with? Lucas: I'd say: don't assume resistance is arrogance. It's usually fear or a lack of safe habits. Your job is to make feedback so normal and low-stakes that the employee starts to crave it. And if you've tried everything and they still won't engage — that's a performance issue, and you may need to escalate. But try curiosity first. Luna: I love that. Curiosity first. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. And thanks to all of you for listening. Until next time, keep leading with empathy.