Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Demographics, Deposits & the Consolidation Wave — With Dan Prezioso of Olden Lane
Transcript
- 0:00treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trifle with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited to be here today with Dan Preso of Olden Lane.
- 0:07Dan, how you doing today?
- 0:09prezioso: I am doing great, mark.
- 0:10Good morning.
- 0:10It's good to chat with you.
- 0:11treichel: Yeah, good to catch up with you.
- 0:13You've been on the podcast, I think maybe this is the third
- 0:15year in a row, maybe fourth year that I've had you on the podcast.
- 0:18But for those listeners or watchers who haven't seen the older episodes, could
- 0:23you give a little bit of your background and olden Laden's background and what
- 0:26it is you do in the credit union space?
- 0:29prezioso: Sure.
- 0:29I'm a partner at olden Lane and our firm is a investment banking boutique
- 0:34that is dedicated to credit unions.
- 0:37We formed ourselves and started focusing on credit unions about around 2017.
- 0:43We were a group of.
- 0:45Capital markets professionals, financial engineers that didn't have a very long
- 0:49background with depository institutions, but but a long one in capital markets.
- 0:53And we formed a group that was looking for gaps in certain markets where a
- 0:57small firm could make a big impact.
- 0:59And one of our thesis.
- 1:00At the time was that credit unions were underserved from a capital markets
- 1:04and investment banking standpoint.
- 1:06And one of the things we were observing that we formed that thesis
- 1:09around was that credit unions were not by and large raising capital
- 1:13in the form of subordinated debt.
- 1:15Even while at the time, about half the industry had the low income designation
- 1:19in the ability to do that market was very still and had very little
- 1:22activity, so we started to probe there.
- 1:25And long story short a lot's transpired in that market.
- 1:29You and I discussed it in September of 2022.
- 1:31As you mentioned on this podcast we've been able to help credit
- 1:35unions issue over a billion dollars.
- 1:37Subordinated debt and supplemental capital.
- 1:40Of course, a lot of our clients that are interested in supplemental
- 1:43capital are looking for growth.
- 1:45That was, one of our thesis is that this capital could be used by strong credit
- 1:49unions and wanted to grow for a period of time faster than maybe their ability
- 1:53to retain earnings in that period.
- 1:55And acquisitions is a classic use case for supplemental capital.
- 2:00So we also assist clients.
- 2:02With mergers and acquisitions and the last time we spoke was about
- 2:06two years ago, December, 2023.
- 2:09And what we'd spoke about at that point was our.
- 2:12Expectations coming out of the small banking crisis after Silicon Valley
- 2:18bank and signature bank blew up and the rate hiking the very aggressive
- 2:22rate hiking cycle caught a lot of banks and credit unions off guard.
- 2:26And as well as a lot of trends that accelerated during
- 2:30the pandemic, including.
- 2:32This shift in consumer taste to really advance digital banking
- 2:36capabilities the aging of leadership.
- 2:39In addition to all those earnings pressures at the time, we prognosticate
- 2:43on your podcast at the end of 2023 that there was gonna be a more
- 2:48interesting consolidation cycle.
- 2:50That was, we were gonna see more credit unions that were.
- 2:55And able to exist independently, actually choosing to combine for
- 3:00strategic purposes to reach for scale.
- 3:03And that is something that that, that was good products.
- 3:07Prognostication, of course, we've seen that.
- 3:09We've seen the strategic merger activity, which I define as mergers between
- 3:14credit unions where both sides have at least a hundred million in assets.
- 3:18Really at a higher level and with more frequency than we've seen before.
- 3:24And I could just show you a little chart what the NCA merger
- 3:27approval activity looks like with respect to strategic mergers.
- 3:32And, right after we spoke in 2024, there was 18 which was
- 3:36almost a a several year high.
- 3:38There was 19 prior in 2022.
- 3:41But then this year.
- 3:43We're gonna break a record in the middle of the year.
- 3:46We already, the NCA has already approved 14 of them.
- 3:49Of course, everyone's seen the headlines.
- 3:52We've seen some massive mergers, first Tech and digital
- 3:56Boeing and Safe Wings and End.
- 3:58And so it's obviously a a trend and a fashion now, and it's
- 4:03something that we expected.
- 4:05I think the next era is gonna be interesting.
- 4:08It's what I'm interested to talk to you about today.
- 4:11We've seen some of those factors.
- 4:12Ab bait earnings are rebounding now.
- 4:16They're almost back to where they were before the rate hiking cycle.
- 4:22And and their interest rate environment is now very benign.
- 4:25In fact, the net interest margin is a 20 year high.
- 4:30So that's gonna alleviate some pressure on credit unions.
- 4:33But we do think that there's challenges ahead that will definitely
- 4:38be a factor in consolidation.
- 4:40And I know our clients, and I think the market generally is interested
- 4:44in consolidation and inorganic growth opportunities that come from it.
- 4:48So I think, this discussion is one that those sorts ought to pay attention to.
- 4:52treichel: Got it.
- 4:53Got it.
- 4:53Yeah, it looks when you hear you rattled off the names of the big mergers out
- 4:56there, two or three of the biggest ones.
- 4:58But when you see that chart and that by the middle of the year
- 5:02they've almost matched last year as far as these strategic mergers.
- 5:05If, as you call them.
- 5:07Fas fascinating.
- 5:08A you predicted where it was going and b, to see the data picking up steam
- 5:12and seeing that chart is eye-opening.
- 5:14You and I chatted a little bit before the show about different things that
- 5:17you think might impact those strategic mergers and credit unions in general.
- 5:22What do you want to tee up first in that regard?
- 5:25prezioso: So now o obviously we're always trying to look at this market
- 5:29and kind of position ourselves a little a little bit ahead of things to come.
- 5:33And one thing that we're aware of, and I think everyone in the industry
- 5:37should be aware of is the fact that significant demographic transitions
- 5:43are, really powerful currents that that shift markets and shape economies.
- 5:50And if you think about where we are today we are at the inflection point
- 5:56of a very significant demographic transition, which is the succession
- 6:01of the baby boomer generation.
- 6:04And what I mean by that, if you think about it just this year.
- 6:08The most senior baby boomers that were born in 1946, which is
- 6:12generally considered the the first year of the baby boomer generation.
- 6:17They turned 79 this year, which is the average US life expectancy.
- 6:24Wow.
- 6:24The most junior baby boomers who were born in 1964 turned are turning 62 next year.
- 6:33Last year MassMutual did its retirement happiness survey,
- 6:38national survey of retirees.
- 6:41And it concluded as part of that survey that the average retirement age
- 6:45in the United States is actually 62.
- 6:48So we have a situation now, demographically where this very
- 6:53significant generation, both in terms of size and its economic impact, is now
- 6:59at a point where they're going to be transitioning assets to beneficiaries
- 7:04and reaching a point of full retirement.
- 7:08So their their impact in banking and the economy is gonna shift
- 7:13profoundly in these years to come.
- 7:16Where they're not gonna be as prominent as savers.
- 7:20And of course we're seeing their activity in terms of their total
- 7:24outstanding debt shrink considerably.
- 7:26And that's to be expected.
- 7:29Another thing that is gonna be interesting about that transition is that baby
- 7:35boomers are not measuring very strongly when it comes to retirement readiness.
- 7:41So about half of them according to analysis by Vanguard, are actually not
- 7:47very well funded for their retirement.
- 7:49If you think about them as savers and depositors, it may be a situation
- 7:54where as they get older and really age into their latest years.
- 8:00They may start drawing down their savings quite considerably.
- 8:04And you'll rate shopping quite aggressively to make the most outta
- 8:09the savings that they do have.
- 8:11So that's gonna be a significant shift for banking, and that's one that I think
- 8:18this industry has to position itself for.
- 8:22And it begs the question how well positioned.
- 8:26Are we right now for that?
- 8:28And, the data doesn't look great on that, but I'll pause and allow you to
- 8:34treichel: Yeah.
- 8:35So prompt me.
- 8:36So 62 is the average retirement age and half of those that retire.
- 8:43Don't have enough saved up to achieve that.
- 8:45And taking an average in a, in another number of half you can't, you can
- 8:50draw some conclusions tied to that.
- 8:53And thinking about what you just unpacked on credit unions
- 8:56is these folks aren't gonna be borrowing they are your big savers.
- 9:00They are your big depositors.
- 9:03But since they're not.
- 9:05As ready as they might need to be, they might burn through some of
- 9:08those savings a little quicker.
- 9:10Setting aside, do you take social security at 62, 65, 67, all
- 9:14those things that, that people.
- 9:17Have to start thinking about.
- 9:18And then you throw in, the one thing we didn't, you didn't mention is we've gone
- 9:21through this inflationary period, right?
- 9:23Maybe they've always planned on retiring at 62 or 63 yet what is it?
- 9:29Sequence risk, right?
- 9:30What the, your, the market's high right?
- 9:32Now you, you walk out and decide you are ready to retire, and
- 9:35then the market gets hit by 20%.
- 9:37And oh, by the way, we've had this huge inflation.
- 9:39You could see credit unions challenged to grow, right?
- 9:43Through just maintaining their own member balances.
- 9:47prezioso: Yeah.
- 9:48That's absolutely true.
- 9:49The sort of the fiscal dominance, which is this overarching theme of
- 9:53the macro environment, in combination with this demographic transition
- 9:58is I think gonna be the story.
- 10:01And what.
- 10:02Credit unions need to appreciate as they think about how to engage
- 10:07their markets, in terms of, the baby boomers in their transition, the
- 10:11baby boomers have really dominated the economy for the last generation.
- 10:15And I just pulled up a chart for you and I to look at that just shows the
- 10:19distribution of household wealth.
- 10:22The baby boomers have been the majority of it for, dating back since before 2010.
- 10:27But it peaked in 2016 at 58%.
- 10:31Baby boomers are 58% of household wealth in this nation.
- 10:35As it's 2016, it's down to 51%.
- 10:39Now, and it will be less than the majority, probably
- 10:43next year I would expect.
- 10:44If not then definitely the year after, and then.
- 10:49So now we have to look to the rising generations.
- 10:52And, baby boomers obviously were born born during a very significant spike
- 10:57in birth rate after World War ii.
- 10:59They are thought of as a, a giant population.
- 11:03But in fact as of 2019, millennials are the largest.
- 11:07Part of the US population and at 22% almost, and gen Z which is
- 11:14the, younger than millennials, they're actually the second largest
- 11:18cohort of the population at 21%.
- 11:20The baby boomers are shrinking their less than 20 now.
- 11:24And Gen X is is the smallest generation between the four of them.
- 11:28They're almost at 19.
- 11:29So just from a sheer standpoint of the number of individuals out there.
- 11:34The baby boomers are shrinking.
- 11:35They're gonna shrink from a standpoint of the number of consumers as well as
- 11:40the amount of assets that they control in the economy, and they're really gonna be,
- 11:45migrating their assets to millennials and Gen Z, and we're gonna see a significant
- 11:50rising of those generations from the standpoint of, who influences the economy.
- 11:56And I think banking needs to consider that.
- 11:58And when you think about inflation, it's gonna be a struggle for
- 12:00both those generations and it's gonna impact their behavior.
- 12:05But I think we need to really focus on how millennials and Gen Z are
- 12:09reacting to it, because that's gonna be from a banking standpoint.
- 12:13What's gonna start driving performance and balance sheets.
- 12:16Yeah.
- 12:17And that's where I think credit unions need to assess where they
- 12:20are relative to those generations.
- 12:23And one of the things that I would say concerns us is that is that
- 12:29some of the survey data doesn't look great and just to emphasize.
- 12:36Reasons to expect this rising, and I think they're intuitive, so I don't
- 12:39think I need to harp on it that much, but just to show you that these things
- 12:44are, transpiring this year in front of our eyes in terms of savings.
- 12:48Santander Bank just did a survey, came out in August and they determined that
- 12:55the majority of Gen, Zers and millennials have increased their savings this year.
- 13:00Through the first half of 2025, about 58% of Gen Zs and 54% of
- 13:05millennials increase their savings.
- 13:07Conversely, gen X and baby boomers, a majority did not increase their savings.
- 13:13In fact, only 39% of baby boomers increase their savings.
- 13:1760 presumably have declining savings and that's what we're.
- 13:22What we're cautioning here is that's probably gonna
- 13:25accelerate in the years to come.
- 13:28And then when you look at total debt balance by age millennials and
- 13:32Gen Z are driving all the growth.
- 13:34Total debt balance of Gen Z in 2025 so far compared to last year is up 32%.
- 13:42Wow.
- 13:42And millennials, a strong growth rate over 7%.
- 13:46Gen X is mostly flat, a little less than 2% growth, and baby boomers
- 13:49are shrinking as you would expect.
- 13:51And of course the, silent generation over 80 years old, shrinking even
- 13:55more and those are be the trends now.
- 13:57I think that growth rate on Gen Z is quite eye topping.
- 14:00Whether or not it's a.
- 14:02It's too much growth, I think is something to consider.
- 14:06But this is where banking is going.
- 14:08It's going to have to focus on these generations in order to generate
- 14:15growth and performance going forward.
- 14:18They are where the action is.
- 14:20treichel: And when I, again, when I think through with my lens as a baby
- 14:24boomer on the young end of the baby boomer side and the frequency at which
- 14:28I used to walk into banks versus today when everything's online, and even me
- 14:34in that generation having embraced.
- 14:37Technology, every generation that follows that is more into technology,
- 14:42is more into FinTech, is more into less traditional type of banking,
- 14:48if you will, credit Unioning.
- 14:50So what are, what, where do you the Wayne Gretzky and, the credit unions
- 14:55want to skate where the puck's going?
- 14:57Where do you.
- 14:59What should credit unions be thinking about in that regard with
- 15:01the younger generation and what are the risks that, that are out there?
- 15:05If they don't, you got a board of directors that, that looks
- 15:09like me, that is my age or older.
- 15:11You got management that that, that is my age or slightly younger than
- 15:16me, or slightly older than me.
- 15:18And none of them are borrowing and they're not saving as much.
- 15:21What what should those credit unions be thinking about?
- 15:23And where might you, where might these other generations be taking credit unions?
- 15:29prezioso: Sure.
- 15:29Let's start with, there's a lot there.
- 15:31I said a lot there yeah.
- 15:32No.
- 15:33Great question.
- 15:34That is the question.
- 15:35Let's start with what are the risks?
- 15:36And that conversation I think starts with, how are credit unions positioned for this?
- 15:42And I've alluded to, my concerns that that they're not positioned well.
- 15:46So let me support those concerns.
- 15:49We've seen survey data in the last couple years that are concerning on this point.
- 15:53In 2023.
- 15:55McKinsey did their consumer life study.
- 16:00And they looked at banking and banking by household primary
- 16:05financial institution type.
- 16:07And what they determined as part of that study was that.
- 16:11Credit unions had really concentrated between 2015, which was the point
- 16:15when they did their last study in 2023, credit unions significantly
- 16:19concentrated their membership in baby boomers, so that baby boomers.
- 16:24Whereas in 2015 comprised 28% of credit union memberships by 2023, they were 39%.
- 16:31Wow.
- 16:31Whereas millennials actually shrunk during that period from 24% to 21%.
- 16:36And Gen Z members didn't budge or grow whatsoever.
- 16:39If you compare that to banks in 2023 bank customers, 29% were
- 16:44boomers, and 29% were millennials.
- 16:47That's a better alignment, and I think where you'd want to be,
- 16:51credit unions look misaligned here.
- 16:53Then when when they looked at recently opened a deposit account,
- 16:57market share, those numbers were concerning as well for credit unions.
- 17:02'Cause in 2023, and that's something they look at more frequently on
- 17:06almost an every two year basis.
- 17:08It was a multi-year low in 2023 when McKinsey looked at this for
- 17:12credit unions with 10% market share compared to 15% market share in 2021.
- 17:18And it had been about 15% market share dating back to 2015.
- 17:22It showed that this, the credit unions have been perhaps too reliant
- 17:27on baby boomers and it was starting to show as an engagement deficit.
- 17:33Relative to younger generations, which was impacting recently
- 17:38opened account market share.
- 17:41That data is from 2023 last year, aperture which is a digital banking tool provider
- 17:48for credit unions and banks commissioned Harris polls to do some surveys.
- 17:53And that also found that when it came to primary financial institutions,
- 17:58millennials and Gen Z were less likely to less often utilizing credit unions
- 18:03as a primary financial institution, millennials, about 10% less Gen Z, about
- 18:0735% less than the rest of the population.
- 18:12And then, this year.
- 18:14Payments intelligence did a survey.
- 18:17I think this one had about 16,000 consumers as part of the survey.
- 18:22And they looked at Gen Z credit union members members of credit unions that are
- 18:27Gen Z, and they found that 37% of them in their survey were at least somewhat likely
- 18:33to switch to another financial institution over the next year compared to 15%.
- 18:39Of other credit union members saying the same thing.
- 18:42So more than twice as many Gen Z members that were already banking with credit
- 18:46unions were looking to switch and a far lower number of Gen Z compared to
- 18:51other credit union members were certain that they would stay about 42% of Gen
- 18:56Z relative to 74% of other members.
- 18:59And, numerous conversations that we've had in the market validate these numbers.
- 19:04We've seen several.
- 19:05Calculations of average age of credit union members show that
- 19:08they're drifting up into the fifties.
- 19:11And these numbers don't look good when you consider, the demographic
- 19:16transition that that we're talking about.
- 19:19So that's a concern.
- 19:21It's something I expect to see.
- 19:24In the numbers, but a, as I said, the performance numbers look
- 19:27good because of the net interest margins being so benign, right?
- 19:31But you can see in the data some hints at this engagement deficit.
- 19:36One thing I like to look at is growth, but I'm starting to
- 19:38look at real growth more often.
- 19:41Just because I, with the fiscal dominance and the, the money
- 19:44circulation and the inflation, real growth is an interesting measure.
- 19:49So I pulled up a couple charts here that show, real growth
- 19:53of total member deposits.
- 19:55Alongside nominal growth as well, and not ignoring nominal growth, but looking
- 20:00at the real growth story as well.
- 20:02And then the growth of the average member relationship versus the
- 20:05nominal growth of that relationship.
- 20:07And that's total balances of deposits and loans.
- 20:11And as you can see, the real growth looks very constrained, very, and it, it's
- 20:17barely recovered to positive territory when it comes to deposit growth.
- 20:22When it comes to the average member relationship, we're still negative
- 20:26from a real growth standpoint, and we've been negative since 2021, and Dan
- 20:32treichel: so real growth would be deducting out the cost of
- 20:35funds that you're paying, right?
- 20:36So if people it's deducting out CPI, it's
- 20:39prezioso: conducting out the rate of growth in the consumer price index.
- 20:42So we're taking inflation out because.
- 20:45Some growth.
- 20:46Got it.
- 20:46Nominal growth, inflation driven growth is going to, is just gonna
- 20:50increase money everywhere essentially.
- 20:53Sure.
- 20:54So I want to see what that looks like.
- 20:55And the reason why I look at that is 'cause this OPEX ratio and where we
- 21:00think about what the consolidation pressures are now, I think it is this Inc.
- 21:04Expenses, the increase of expenses in this OPEX ratio.
- 21:08And when you have a real growth deficit.
- 21:11You would expect to see some pressure on opex ratios, and that's exactly
- 21:14what we're seeing where, during the pandemic opex ratios collapsed
- 21:18because of the surge of asset.
- 21:20Of asset growth and, and we got a lot of efficiency producing technology.
- 21:25So you would like to see the industry harness some of that efficiency.
- 21:30But what's happening is at that OPEX ratio on average across the industry,
- 21:35is drifting right back to where it was.
- 21:37But what's also interesting is this incline, as you can
- 21:39see, we're looking at a chart.
- 21:41And I know a lot of your audience is probably audio only, but this chart shows
- 21:45the opex ratio is bottoming in 2022, and then it takes off like an airplane,
- 21:50leaving the runway and and you rarely see.
- 21:54A line that's over so many quarters this smooth.
- 21:58It's not really bouncing at all.
- 21:59It flattened a little bit in 2023, but then it just steepened again and
- 22:04it just looks like it's taking off.
- 22:06And I think that's the consequence of the real growth challenge that we were
- 22:10looking at on those previous charts.
- 22:12Sure.
- 22:12And then another thing that, may hint as well at this engagement deficit with
- 22:17the younger generation is the fact that.
- 22:20We're not really seeing credit unions showing a lot of evidence that they have
- 22:24pricing power in the deposit market.
- 22:26The Fed has started to cut rates.
- 22:28They started to cut rates in the middle of last year, and.
- 22:32Of course it's, you're gonna see a lag.
- 22:34The cost of funds is not gonna reprice in lockstep.
- 22:37It's going to lag those cuts.
- 22:40But we're not seeing any evidence that the cost of funds is budgeted up.
- 22:44It hasn't budgeted at all.
- 22:45It's exactly where it was in the first quarter of 2024, but before they
- 22:50started reducing rates which suggests that there's really no pricing.
- 22:55Power that credit unions have, they're still having to to offer
- 22:58generous rates to get deposits.
- 23:01And I think that's an indication of the engagement deficit as well.
- 23:05But my expectation is that we haven't really seen anything yet.
- 23:09We're just seeing hints at things.
- 23:12Perhaps, but this is going to get more problematic if that survey data
- 23:18is is a, is an accurate depiction of where credit unions are relative
- 23:22to these rising generations.
- 23:24And it doesn't improve it's going to, these issues are gonna get more more
- 23:29apparent and more difficult to manage
- 23:32treichel: And three things kind are running through my head that, the
- 23:35younger generations are saving more.
- 23:37The baby boomers are saving less and tapping into their savings.
- 23:41Yet over the last 10 years, the concentration of deposits
- 23:45in baby boomers has gone up.
- 23:47Despite the fact that they're saving less than the other
- 23:49generations are saving more.
- 23:51The older generation is stickier in that they'll stay with their institution.
- 23:56The younger generations aren't as sticky.
- 23:58They're more likely to move which.
- 24:01It can be a glass, it can be glass.
- 24:03Half full is the, if you market to them and if you embrace this and you figure
- 24:08out how to bring them into the credit union they may be willing to come.
- 24:12So there's that opportunity.
- 24:14But if you don't embrace that, they're also, the ones you have could be going
- 24:17to the banks or to the non-banks, to the other FinTech o options
- 24:21out there that are, that might be
- 24:22prezioso: brewing.
- 24:24That's exactly right is I think credit unions have an opportunity here.
- 24:27I don't think that there's any reason why credit unions can't be
- 24:30a fan finance fantastic financial partner for millennials and Gen Z.
- 24:35I'll say this though.
- 24:37They're not presenting themselves as a one now.
- 24:39I could say that as someone who is a millennial, I was born in
- 24:421982, I'm a senior millennial.
- 24:45The team that I'm working with at to research this subject are mostly
- 24:50very smart analysts that are Gen Z.
- 24:53All my friends are millennials, all their friends are Gen Z.
- 24:55I think we know something about what appeals to our generations
- 25:01and, credit unions, are not.
- 25:03Delivering on that.
- 25:05And I don't think it's 'cause they can't but for whatever reason, we're
- 25:09not really seeing a really compelling set of offerings from credit unions
- 25:15that are gonna drive that engagement.
- 25:16I believe the data because, it's the best information we have, but also
- 25:21it aligns with what I'm just feeling, qualitatively as, one of the consumers
- 25:26that is, part of this subject here.
- 25:29Now let's talk about those that you know, that are engaging with
- 25:33millennials and Gen Z and, what are they doing and what's their.
- 25:39Experience and what are they in terms of a competitive pressure
- 25:43relative to credit unions?
- 25:44One of the things that I think credit unions have to appreciate about these
- 25:48younger generations is their challenges.
- 25:51What are their financial challenges?
- 25:53We've talked about the cost of living severe increase in cost
- 25:57of living and in particularly the cost of housing so that the.
- 26:03Average median first time home buyer is now 40 years old.
- 26:08A 40-year-old person, a 40-year-old home buyer is not someone that
- 26:14you know, has been saving for a down payment for a few years.
- 26:17A 40-year-old home buyer is someone who's been working 15 years and investing the
- 26:23entire time for that home ownership dream.
- 26:26So I would ask credit unions listening.
- 26:28What are your investment options that you're offering to those?
- 26:32To those aspiring home buyers in these generations they perceive
- 26:36that their savings are being eroded by the cost of living increases.
- 26:43What are, and they want to invest those savings to keep up.
- 26:46What are your offerings?
- 26:48And if your offering is LPL financial advisor, that's not
- 26:53what the generation wants, right?
- 26:55That's not what they're looking for.
- 26:56That's not where they're going.
- 26:57Where are they going?
- 26:58If they're going to Robinhood And what's Robinhood doing?
- 27:03Robinhood is now offering mortgages through Safe Home.
- 27:08Safe Home Mortgages, which is a digital mortgage origination.
- 27:12They have a partnership.
- 27:14If you are a Robinhood Gold subscriber, you get.
- 27:19Below market mortgage rates at least 75% below the national average
- 27:24through Safe Home, and you get a $500 credit on closing costs.
- 27:30So these platforms are getting into banking.
- 27:34They also issue their gold subscribers credit cards with 3%
- 27:39cash back and high yield savings.
- 27:43And we can look at.
- 27:46Their performance.
- 27:47It's pretty fantastic.
- 27:48That gold subscription, let's look at its growth.
- 27:52In 2023 Robinhood Gold subscribers, they had a hundred and 1.4
- 27:57million subscribers in, at the end of 2023.
- 28:01At the end of Q3 of this year, they had almost 4 million.
- 28:07It was a 77% increase.
- 28:10Since 2024, the deposits, the bank deposits that are on their platform
- 28:19is up to 35 over 35 billion.
- 28:23Wow.
- 28:24Which is a 44% increase year over year.
- 28:30And if we look at their August operating report, which shows us a breakdown
- 28:35of those deposits, 95% of it almost is from those gold subscribers.
- 28:43So these investment platforms are are offering banking and are banking.
- 28:52Their clients.
- 28:54SoFi is another, and my partner Mike Ola just this month published a op-ed with
- 29:00typhoon called SoFi versus Credit Unions.
- 29:04SoFi of course known as a student lender.
- 29:06They opened a bank in 2022.
- 29:09And they've been growing just, it's amazing, their growth very
- 29:14prodigious and in fact, last quarter.
- 29:17They, I think it was their best growth quarter yet.
- 29:21They grew deposits by 3.4
- 29:24billion.
- 29:26And the entire credit union industry in total grew deposits by 7 billion.
- 29:32So this one bank, which is not a large, it's not a behemoth it,
- 29:36as of the middle of this year, it wasn't even among the top 50 banks.
- 29:40It wasn't even in the top 60 banks.
- 29:44The bank only started three years ago, but it is a bank that has a very modern
- 29:50investment platform like Robinhood and has a business model that is very
- 29:55focused on being the lifecycle financial partner from Gen Z and millennials.
- 30:03And you're seeing, the power of that model.
- 30:08They, they also, grew loans even more, even faster.
- 30:13Their loan growth was about 55% of the entire loan growth
- 30:16in the credit union industry.
- 30:18And in terms of customer acquisitions, they grew mere about as many new
- 30:22customers as credit, as the entire credit union industry grew, new members,
- 30:28and again, this is not a top 50 bank.
- 30:31They're growing like a behemoth, but they're not it's not a very large bank
- 30:35comparably, it's a small regional bank essentially, but they're a national
- 30:39digital bank that has a great model for engaging millennials and Gen Z.
- 30:46And they're getting all the benefits of that.
- 30:49Then there's, there's other out there like Coinbase which is,
- 30:53strictly a crypto investing platform.
- 30:57But they they're issuing credit cards now, and I'll give you a personal anecdote on
- 31:02that, I, I learned about blockchain in 2017 from, colleagues of mine that were
- 31:07in finance that were excited about it.
- 31:09And I thought Bitcoin was cool back then.
- 31:11And I bought one one Bitcoin 2017.
- 31:14It was only about $2,000 back then.
- 31:17Obviously, when you buy Bitcoin 2017 you a little hooked.
- 31:21So obviously I like it.
- 31:22I still have Bitcoin and I've accumulated some more, but.
- 31:26Blockchain for me, I don't entirely understand all of that.
- 31:30So it's not like a big part of my financial life.
- 31:34But I've always kept a, what I would describe as a material,
- 31:38but modest exposure to that asset class in that industry.
- 31:43And I've done it through Coinbase, where I have some very passive investments there.
- 31:47Bitcoin mostly, but some others.
- 31:50I just consider my my material, but modest exposure to that asset class.
- 31:56But Coinbase this year issued a credit card that has Bitcoin rewards, and based
- 32:02on my customer status, I'm entitled to 3% Bitcoin back on all my purchase.
- 32:08I liked that, I liked the idea of stacking more Bitcoin, especially how
- 32:13that that asset has rose in so much prominence over the time since I learned
- 32:18about it and got involved and also more recently so I have the card now and,
- 32:24my, my top of wallet card used to be a Amazon rewards card, which is, nice.
- 32:30Everyone shops Amazon, very simple to redeem the rewards.
- 32:34But now I'm splitting equally between between the Coinbase
- 32:38card and my Amazon rewards card.
- 32:41So they've become, a top of the wallet card for me.
- 32:44But what's even more interesting is, this is very recent.
- 32:47I've only had the card a couple months when I went to make my first payment.
- 32:51Obviously I use their mobile app.
- 32:52I'm not the most tech savvy millennial.
- 32:55I'll be the first to admit I've a hard time using the printer in the office.
- 32:59So it was late, my payment was due, I clicked some buttons.
- 33:02I made a payment, but I realized I made the payment from my Bitcoin, right?
- 33:07Holdings, pay the balance with Bitcoin, which was not exactly
- 33:11what I was going for, right?
- 33:12I was trying to add to my Bitcoin position, right?
- 33:15These rewards.
- 33:16Fortunately Bitcoin, the price of Bitcoin's been going down.
- 33:18So I was able to move money into my Coinbase account and buy it back.
- 33:23But I had to, look more closely after that and decide, how
- 33:27I'm gonna make these payments.
- 33:29And you can you can connect the a banking account to it.
- 33:32But then as I'm looking at it, I see that Coinbase is paying 4% on stable coins.
- 33:40I've never really used stable coins.
- 33:42'cause as I said, for me, blockchain is just, some of these more interesting
- 33:45assets as a way to get exposure.
- 33:47I'm not doing any gymnastics on the blockchain where I need to, do dollar
- 33:51transactions on it outside of just, using some cash deposit at Coinbase to
- 33:55maybe buy Bitcoin or something like it.
- 33:58So stable coins have never been interesting to me, but.
- 34:02Now I'm looking at it, why don't I just move some of my checking account
- 34:06balance to Coinbase, keep 'em in stable coins, earn 4%, and now I could pay
- 34:12my credit card balances with them.
- 34:14So now I get the stable coin.
- 34:16And it's interesting to me that Coinbase is not a platform, is a
- 34:21platform I used, but I never had any inclination that it would ever
- 34:26be part of my everyday finances.
- 34:30Never, but they've drawn me in to the point where now they're
- 34:34capturing, my top of wallet, credit card activity and deposits from me.
- 34:40Sure.
- 34:41That's how these platforms.
- 34:44Integrate themselves into the lives of their customers.
- 34:49So I just want credit unions to appreciate, when you decide not to
- 34:53offer self-directed investments, not to offer, fractional shares,
- 34:57the ability to self-direct ETF investments, at your institution.
- 35:02Or you decide, crypto is just not something that we want to be involved in.
- 35:08You're telling the younger generations that.
- 35:12That you don't care about that part of their financial life and you can't help
- 35:17them, and they need to go somewhere else if that's what they want to do.
- 35:22And the places that they're going for that activity are saying the opposite.
- 35:29They're saying, we want to be part of your everyday banking activity.
- 35:34We want to be part of your everyday payments.
- 35:37We want your.
- 35:39Deposits.
- 35:40We want to be part of your home ownership dream.
- 35:43We wanna finance it.
- 35:44We want to be there to support you through all of it.
- 35:49And that's the difference in the growth story.
- 35:53That's the engagement deficit.
- 35:56These are the platforms that are resonating and credit unions
- 36:00are struggling relative to that.
- 36:01And I and I think losing the challenge here, and they don't have to.
- 36:06There are a few credit unions that are beginning to offer, most are
- 36:10everything that Robinhood can offer and these platforms can offer.
- 36:15One that I'll mention is, frankenmuth credit union in Michigan where
- 36:20you know they have a platform.
- 36:21You can buy ETFs, you can buy stock fractional shares, crypto right from your
- 36:27checking account, right from your check.
- 36:29You don't have to move money.
- 36:30You don't have to aach H dollars anywhere.
- 36:33Buy it right from your checking account.
- 36:34They have a platform where you can invest in fractional real estate.
- 36:38If the home ownership dream is too outta reach, but you still wanna invest in real
- 36:43estate, or if it's, or if you want to invest in fractional real estate as you
- 36:47build up your savings to get to your own home, they have that available as well.
- 36:52And and they have digital tools for budgeting and saving.
- 36:57Planning, they have it all.
- 36:59And I was interested to join them.
- 37:01They're a community credit union in Michigan, so I don't know if
- 37:04someone from Frankenmuth has a advice for me if if I'm eligible to join.
- 37:07But, that's, I think what credit unions ought to be doing.
- 37:12But by and large, they're not.
- 37:14And I think that it, it doesn't surprise me to see, these firms do so
- 37:20well and, relative to credit unions and just on the Coinbase story, just
- 37:24to, close the loop in terms of, their growth, their stable coin balances
- 37:30increased 9% quarter over quarter.
- 37:33That's a 36% annualized growth.
- 37:36In the, in Q3 it's up to 15 billion.
- 37:40So we're seeing deposit gathering is difficult.
- 37:45Everyone's saying especially in community banking.
- 37:48There's one influencer an ex called community Bank guy.
- 37:53He seemed to be a anonymous CFO at a community bank.
- 37:56He said something that made me laugh a little bit the other day.
- 37:58He said I don't know how to get deposits other than to.
- 38:02By the people and institutions that have them.
- 38:05And I think obviously our m and a practice is very busy.
- 38:09There's a lot of appetite to grow through acquisition because organic
- 38:14deposit gathering is so tough.
- 38:16But I would just say it's not tough for everybody.
- 38:19There are firms that are growing deposits very rapidly look at their model.
- 38:25Look at how they're engaging and I would say, be a fast follower relative
- 38:30to these platforms would be my advice.
- 38:34treichel: Couple general, the that Coinbase card, when you had it up on the
- 38:37screen, that was a very attractive card.
- 38:39I could see how it can get to the top.
- 38:40The marketing that goes behind that I, I is fascinating and if
- 38:45I'm thinking of the Robinhood.
- 38:48I listened to some podcasts about that Robinhood card and
- 38:51that tremendous growth they got.
- 38:52I also think there was like a waiting list to get in to get that card.
- 38:56So not only were they going exponentially, they were growing so
- 39:00fast that if you got in line you were queued up and you couldn't get it
- 39:04the next day just because it, that, that growth has been so powerful.
- 39:08And then what the 4%.
- 39:10Rewards or crypto that you get back on that Coinbase card?
- 39:14I've listened to a few different podcasts tied to the stable coin, the Genius Act.
- 39:21The ability to pay those rewards.
- 39:23And there was a lot of discussion now how the bankers are trying to
- 39:27get that carved back out because they missed it when it got put in.
- 39:31They didn't comment on it to the point of how it might impact them.
- 39:34And they're starting to see this, these exact things that you're pointing
- 39:37out that it's pulling away deposits.
- 39:40And then lastly, on a brain dump here the banking with interest, which the host
- 39:45of that podcast formerly was the editor of the American Banker, and he had a
- 39:51guest on who made reference to a treasury survey of some sort that talked about.
- 39:57The risk of Coinbase actually eating up a third of deposits.
- 40:01And if you think about that while you're trying to grow while you're while you're
- 40:05having challenges getting the younger folks into the credit union and the
- 40:09money's transitioning from the baby boomers who are passing it on literally
- 40:15to, to the younger generation you, you don't wanna to quote, mark McWaters, a
- 40:20former board member credit unions don't wanna be like the horse and buggy, right?
- 40:24Everything's fine.
- 40:25These automobiles aren't gonna turn into anything that we have
- 40:29to really worry about, right?
- 40:30Lot of pressures out there.
- 40:31And that merger thing, you can stay away from having to be
- 40:33one of those strategic mergers.
- 40:35But if you don't pay attention and get in the game you might find yourself having
- 40:39to be one of those strategic mergers.
- 40:41prezioso: Yeah, I mean that, that's my merger consultations with clients now.
- 40:45What I'm advising is if you look ahead, you need to position this industry is
- 40:52gonna consolidate along this challenge.
- 40:55Who is solving this next gen gap and who is struggling to, so
- 41:00if you want to be a successful acquirer, I think looking forward.
- 41:04You need to show that you have a mix of products and services that is
- 41:10resonating with younger generations.
- 41:14You need to show that you've made progress with that engagement and
- 41:17that will make you an attractive acquirer and chip filson.
- 41:21Chip Filson and I are on different sides of this issue, obviously.
- 41:24I I am someone that supports strategic consolidation and tries
- 41:28to make deals happen in this market.
- 41:29He's someone that seems to be very critical.
- 41:32Of the industry's consolidation and encouraging them to resist it.
- 41:36But I take a lot of his criticisms to heart.
- 41:38And I do think he has some good ones.
- 41:40And he is out here today, not to name names, but he's criticizing one where
- 41:44he feels like the it's being marketed to members of the emerging credit union as
- 41:49they're getting some sort of products and services, pickup through this combination.
- 41:55And the fact is, when you take it, when you take it apart, it's the same
- 41:58products and services they already have.
- 42:00Sure.
- 42:00And I've seen that in some of my discussions where that
- 42:04products and services discussion.
- 42:07Is not really that apparent in terms of the combination generating actually new,
- 42:12different or better products and services for the emerging credit unions members.
- 42:17I think that the combination often results in an institution that's more
- 42:21stable, that is got more efficiency, and the ability to be more profitable.
- 42:28From a member experience standpoint, it's not always completely evident.
- 42:33I think it needs to be going forward on this issue.
- 42:36Do, does the combination form a a combined institution that's
- 42:42gonna be more successful.
- 42:44Reaching out and engaging to millennials and Gen Z and it has to
- 42:49have products that speak across a range of the needs of those generations.
- 42:56And if I could sum up what those needs are.
- 43:00It's, personal financial management tools.
- 43:03Not, YouTube videos about making a budget, but actual tools that are
- 43:09tracking across accounts, including external accounts that are showing you
- 43:13your spending, that are showing you, your subscriptions that you're spending
- 43:17on, that are showing you your trends.
- 43:20What, when you might be spending more in a given month or period of time
- 43:24than you historically have been, and losing track relative to your goals,
- 43:29helping you keep track of and calculate the progress of your net worth.
- 43:33Giving you encouragement when you're, showing when it can, when
- 43:38the system can see you demonstrating good financial habits and giving
- 43:42you warnings when you're not.
- 43:45Those type of things are out there.
- 43:47Some credit unions are deploying them.
- 43:49Any credit union that wants to be successful with these generations
- 43:52needs to, in my opinion, I've talked about the investment offerings.
- 43:56I just think if you're not willing to give these generations the ability to control
- 44:01their investments at your financial institution and access to a number of
- 44:06different assets on those platforms.
- 44:08I think you're gonna lose to these firms that we've been talking about.
- 44:12These generations are heavily debt burdened.
- 44:14The student loan burdens are very significant, especially for Gen
- 44:18Z, more significant than any other generations had to deal with.
- 44:22The mortgage balances are gonna be higher.
- 44:24We can see that.
- 44:25Buy now, pay later is creating a really fragmented system of
- 44:30liabilities that need to be managed and are easy to lose track of.
- 44:34Debt advice management and consolidation tools, the top that
- 44:38are available, ought to be provided.
- 44:41First time home buying programs very important.
- 44:44But also programs that help them plan and navigate that journey.
- 44:50'cause it's a longer one.
- 44:52And if you let them work with another group in terms of, how they're gonna
- 44:57save to get there, how they're gonna budget to get there, you really don't
- 45:01have a good claim to the financing.
- 45:04When they get there, sure.
- 45:05You can show up and say, we're people helping people, they're
- 45:08just gonna ask, how did you help?
- 45:10And I think, credit unions need to get into the lives of these
- 45:15generations in a really active way.
- 45:17With good tools.
- 45:18With good systems.
- 45:21And then you need to build a community as well.
- 45:24And the communities that these generations are building are on social media.
- 45:29I, I got inter I interested in financial social media during the meme stock
- 45:35phenomenon, the game stock phenomenon.
- 45:37I didn't participate in it, but I certainly, obviously watch markets
- 45:41closely and, to see these young retail investors squeezing these
- 45:47hedge funds and pumping this obscure stock to the moon, it just was such a.
- 45:53Curiosity for me that I started to pay attention to their networks on
- 45:57social media to see what was going on.
- 46:00And I've been watching, I've been watching it with respect to the blockchain
- 46:03and the assets that trade there.
- 46:05And what they do is they form communities around this activity.
- 46:09Now, I'm not suggesting credit unions should be promoting these
- 46:12sort of hyper speculative activity, but what I am pointing out is.
- 46:16If they're going on platforms like Discord, like Reddit
- 46:20like X Instagram, TikTok.
- 46:23And they're creating communities where they're talking about their finances.
- 46:27And I think credit unions ought to think about something as well, where
- 46:31they are basically hosting chats.
- 46:34They're, certified financial counselors are taking questions.
- 46:38Interacting, their staff are adding to the community discussion and they're
- 46:43creating interactive communities.
- 46:45I think that's what you need, that, the community formation is not gonna
- 46:50be as much in the branch, although I don't think branch networks are
- 46:53irrelevant even to these generations.
- 46:55I think they like to know that it's there, even though they don't use it.
- 46:58If you want community at your credit union among your members, social media
- 47:03is a great tool to get there, and other industries are using it and they're
- 47:07not big, the latest meme, coin or, blockchain asset is not a big enterprise.
- 47:14It's a very homegrown grassroots one, and credit unions should look at that
- 47:19model and start to participate in it.
- 47:22And then the younger generations love rewards.
- 47:24So give them, they want to be rewarded for their business and their loyalty.
- 47:29So give them reward programs.
- 47:32Gamify it a little bit.
- 47:33So as they get closer to a reward, they're getting, instant gratification.
- 47:37The dopamine.
- 47:38treichel: Yeah, the dopamine, yeah.
- 47:40prezioso: One of the things about that Coinbase card mark that I like is every
- 47:44time I buy lunch, by the time I sit down to eat it, I have a notification my phone
- 47:47with how much Bitcoin I, I stacked, 40 cents a Bitcoin, but, but I like that.
- 47:52I noticed.
- 47:52I like that.
- 47:53Yep.
- 47:53And my, my Amazon points, they just accumulate somewhere and, once a
- 47:58couple times a year I log onto Amazon.
- 48:00I actually don't shop that much.
- 48:01And and I see, oh, I don't have to pay for anything basically that I buy on Amazon.
- 48:05'cause based on my shopping, I always have points covered, which is nice.
- 48:08Sure.
- 48:09But it's very much in the background for me.
- 48:11I know it's there, but I'm not really seeing it on a day-today basis.
- 48:14Yep.
- 48:15Yep.
- 48:15Coinbase is putting their rewards, in front of me every
- 48:17time I get one and I like it.
- 48:20It's a good feeling.
- 48:21So I think that you gotta take some cues from that, and
- 48:24those things are all doable.
- 48:25There's no reason any credit union can't do them.
- 48:28It's just, you gotta have the awareness of what these generations want.
- 48:31You gotta have the willingness.
- 48:32My suggestion would be, if you're listening to this, you're a credit
- 48:35union and you want to take this subject seriously, I'd ask you, who are those
- 48:40voices of these generations in your.
- 48:43In your management meetings, in your boardroom, do you have one?
- 48:47Is it a token voice that's, being polite relative to the others in the room, or
- 48:52are they really asserting themselves?
- 48:55And if you don't have that voice, you ought to get it, bring it in externally.
- 48:59And I guess that's me raising my hand and my team raising our hand.
- 49:03We're looking to talk to our clients about this next year.
- 49:06I think this is gonna be, this is a challenge that's gonna divide this
- 49:10industry between between those that thrive and those that don't and
- 49:14is gonna direct the consolidation.
- 49:16Listen I understand people don't like when there's fewer
- 49:19credit unions, but the fact is.
- 49:21If you're serving fewer members, you don't need as many credit unions,
- 49:24and half the credit unions in this industry are serving less members
- 49:28today than they did five years ago.
- 49:30The market's gonna rationalize that.
- 49:31You Yeah, you can complain about it, but that's just, yeah I don't
- 49:35know how you expect otherwise.
- 49:37treichel: Yeah.
- 49:37That's a great summary.
- 49:38There's been a lot of fun.
- 49:39Dan, if so if someone has listened to this and they want.
- 49:43Talk to you and your team about, how they can tap into some of these
- 49:46things, or if they're looking to, they feel they're already positioned to do
- 49:50some of this and they're looking to.
- 49:51To grow through mergers and things.
- 49:53What's the best way for someone to, to connect with you and your team?
- 49:58prezioso: Yeah, you could reach out to us on our website info dot at old lane.com.
- 50:02We'll go to all the partners.
- 50:03Of course, you can reach out to me directly.
- 50:05I'm at d preso@oldelaine.com.
- 50:08You can reach out to us on LinkedIn.
- 50:09We're very active on LinkedIn.
- 50:11I myself am on LinkedIn as well as our company.
- 50:13We post very frequently.
- 50:15About the industry.
- 50:16So follow us and and reach out.
- 50:18And yeah, we love to talk to credit unions.
- 50:20Obviously we have a lot of passion for these subjects and I think
- 50:23we're pretty well researched on it, and we have a good track record
- 50:27prognosticating the next trend here.
- 50:29Reach out, talk to us.
- 50:30We'd love to have these conversations.
- 50:32treichel: That's great.
- 50:33I really appreciate your time today, Dan.
- 50:35Thanks, mark.
- 50:36We'll be in touch.
- 50:37Have a good one.
- 50:37Bye.
- 50:38You got it.
- 50:38And listeners, I want listeners and watchers, I wanna thank you for listening.
- 50:41As always, this is Mark TriCal signing off with flying Colors.