Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / A Farewell to Arms (1932)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. Have you ever read an Ernest
- 0:24Hemingway book? I think that I did it again.
- 0:29I think that I have read a short story or two
- 0:33of his. Okay. But not a Farewell to Arms. Yeah,
- 0:37I haven't read anything that he's done ever in
- 0:39my whole life. I watched movies where he was
- 0:41depicted. Oh, yeah. And I've watched other things
- 0:45that he wrote that were adapted to movies, I
- 0:48think. We're flying off the cuff here. Finding
- 0:50Forrester, the movie with Sean Connery, you know
- 0:55what I'm talking about? You're the man now, dog.
- 0:56That's 100 % where I was going with this. He
- 0:59doesn't play Ernest Hemingway in that, does he?
- 1:02Oh, I don't know. I've never actually seen it.
- 1:04There's a movie where he plays Ernest Hemingway
- 1:06for sure. I just can't imagine it's the you're
- 1:09the man now, dog movie. You're the man now, dog.
- 1:12So funny. I think it's really funny that that's
- 1:15like he he was Bond. Yeah. Like if someone's
- 1:18like, hey, Sean Connery, where do you know him
- 1:20from? Like, oh, you know, you're the man now,
- 1:22dog. Not the weirdest thing a Bond has done.
- 1:26That's so true. Yeah. So we're looking at you,
- 1:29Pierce Brosnan. Hey, this is the return once
- 1:31again of the first Best Director winner, Frank
- 1:35Borzaghi. Frank Borzaghi. You want to take that
- 1:37again? The return of the very first Best Director
- 1:41winner, Frank Borzaghi? Zeggy. Borzaghi. You
- 1:46know what we should do? We should have a soundboard
- 1:48of all the, like, Chevalier and Borzaghi. So
- 1:53whenever we're, like, directed by Frank and then
- 1:55press the button, Borzaghi. But, like, a speaking
- 1:57spell doing it? Borzaghi. Chevalier. That's what
- 2:02we need. We do 100 % need that. We're talking
- 2:05about A Farewell to Arms. Yeah, we are. This
- 2:07is the movie that was adapted from the, I almost
- 2:10said Sean Connery, the Ernest Hemingway novel.
- 2:14This was nominated for four things. Outstanding
- 2:17production for Paramount. Keep leading with that.
- 2:20That feels so bizarre to me. Like, it's okay.
- 2:23It felt like you were doing a little Princess
- 2:25Bride right there. Like, you keep leading with
- 2:26that. I don't think you know the intensity of
- 2:31that award. It was either that or the Mission
- 2:33Impossible 2 line reading from Tom Cruise where
- 2:36he's like, you keep calling me this name. You
- 2:38really shouldn't. That's for all my John Woo
- 2:41fans out there. All right, I'll close with it
- 2:44then. Oh, I'm sorry. No, no, it's ruined now.
- 2:47Best Cinematography, Charles Lang. Best Sound
- 2:50Recording, Franklin Hanson. Best Art Direction,
- 2:53Hans Dreher and Roland Anderson. And of course,
- 2:57finally, as we always do, Outstanding Production
- 2:59from Paramount. Not Paramount Publix. paramount
- 3:04this is true we'll get there uh we'll cover that
- 3:06in our ceremony episode but a big change and
- 3:09uh talk to me a little bit about the cast and
- 3:11direction so as i said at the top directed by
- 3:14frank borzaghi nailed it you did say that frank
- 3:17borzaghi helen hayes returns as catherine barkley
- 3:22yes and i also love how you said that like she's
- 3:24captain america she has returned gary cooper
- 3:28Also returns, we saw him in Wings. Remember that?
- 3:32That was a long time ago, it feels like. He plays
- 3:34Lieutenant Frederick Henry. And again, the return
- 3:38of Adolph Menjoo as Captain Rinaldi. I have some
- 3:42things that I'd like to say off the top about
- 3:44these people. Yeah. But real quick, also worth
- 3:48noting that although it was based on the novel
- 3:50by Ernest Hemingway, this movie was written by
- 3:53Benjamin Glazer and Oliver H .P. Garrett. Yeah.
- 3:56So... A couple things I want to point out. Gary
- 3:58Cooper's name is Frederick, but I do think that
- 4:03Adolph Menjoo is becoming a bit of a Louis Wilhelm
- 4:08slash, you know where I'm going with this, Wallace
- 4:10Beery, to where I think I'm kind of obsessed
- 4:13with him a bit. Yeah. His character in this movie
- 4:15is so funny. He's very good. He calls Frederick
- 4:19baby. Right. All the time. Adolph Menjoo plays
- 4:22an Italian soldier. Correct. So he's got like
- 4:26this heavy Italian accent. And it's very much
- 4:28like, baby. You're back from war, baby. And I'm
- 4:32like, wow, this rocks. Yeah. Two grown men just
- 4:34calling each other baby. This is cool. Which.
- 4:37I'll talk about that at the end. I'm very excited.
- 4:40I also want to jump to the end just a little
- 4:42bit here. One of his final scenes with Frederick,
- 4:45Rinaldi, says to him as he's going off on a boat,
- 4:49Ciao, baby. I need you to know that, unfortunately,
- 4:52that's a new stim for me. And I'm going to be
- 4:54saying ciao, baby like that so often. Dude, I
- 4:57would love if that became the way we said goodbye
- 5:00to each other. Ciao, baby. Yeah, just all the
- 5:02time. It's going to happen. I look forward to
- 5:05that. A farewell to arms. I think you're right.
- 5:08The way that we do this, we don't want to get
- 5:10too in the weeds with a synopsis. But essentially,
- 5:13what we see is we meet both Frederick and Catherine
- 5:19as they are involved in the war, right? On Frederick's
- 5:23side, he's an ambulance driver. And on Catherine's
- 5:26side, she's a nurse. And we see how they become
- 5:28connected in Italy during the war and how this
- 5:32ultimately... Brings them together and brings
- 5:35them apart or sets them apart. Yeah. Through
- 5:38the years or at least months. Actually, that's
- 5:40true. This only happens in one year. I think
- 5:42it's between June and September or October. Gotcha.
- 5:49Either way, it's a span of months. Yeah. And
- 5:52that's kind of like separated. The first half
- 5:53is in June and then the second half is like October,
- 5:57November. So we'll get into it here. I kind of
- 6:01want to go ahead and rip the bandaid off a little
- 6:03bit on this, if that's okay with you. Sure. I
- 6:05didn't love this. So here's the thing. We've
- 6:08seen Borzaghi now quite a few times. At least
- 6:11twice. Seventh Heaven, Bad Girl. Right. And now
- 6:15A Farewell to Arms. And I believe that's it.
- 6:17Certainly not the only movies he's done, but
- 6:19the ones we've covered on the podcast. Right.
- 6:20Right. And we've discussed how he deals a lot
- 6:24with like young love. Very much from like a melodramatic
- 6:29point of view. And I think that I'm starting
- 6:32to notice cliches in his work or just like an
- 6:37outline of things that like he has to tick boxes
- 6:40in all of his movies. And this is no exception.
- 6:44Correct. I think that Catherine and Frederick's
- 6:48romance here is very reminiscent to every other
- 6:53film of his that we've covered. At this point,
- 6:56there's a lot of Chico and Diane in them in the
- 7:00dynamics of that relationship. Yeah. And Helen
- 7:04Hayes and Gary Cooper together. I think they
- 7:07have great chemistry. They're very good. Just
- 7:09like I think Chico and Diane have great chemistry.
- 7:12Clara Bow and remind me. This is a test to you.
- 7:17No, you don't remember. Yeah, I don't remember.
- 7:19Give me give me 20 seconds. But slowly opening
- 7:23the book. Slowly. I'm trying. No, I think that
- 7:27their chemistry is fantastic. And I think that
- 7:31their on -screen romance is depicted very well.
- 7:35But I've kind of already seen this. And that
- 7:38seems unfair to say as this is an adaptation
- 7:40of a very, very popular and successful Ernest
- 7:44Hemingway story. The first Hemingway story adapted
- 7:47to film ever, which is kind of a big deal. But
- 7:50I think I'm just kind of getting tired of Borzaghi's...
- 7:53style here you know it's not bringing anything
- 7:56new to the table charles farrell that's him okay
- 7:59charles farrell sorry it took me a second that's
- 8:02okay yeah you know i think i'm gonna be a little
- 8:05i don't want to say like this is my like i'm
- 8:07cementing my place in history with this uh review
- 8:10of it or my thoughts i'm gonna be a little less
- 8:12forgiving to me this was just a very derivative
- 8:15of seventh heaven yeah and and what really is
- 8:19confusing is that I think, well, let's start
- 8:21at the beginning here. A Farewell to Arms is
- 8:23something that we both have heard plenty of times.
- 8:26If you've never read the novel, if you've never
- 8:28seen the movie, you have heard the prestigious
- 8:30nature behind something like A Farewell to Arms.
- 8:33So you have a little bit of an idea of what that,
- 8:35like, you know, okay, well, what am I in for
- 8:37with this? And ultimately, the story of, you
- 8:41know, how war can keep love between people together
- 8:44and apart, ultimately, in this movie, doesn't
- 8:47really go too far. It doesn't really do too much,
- 8:50and it doesn't really do too little. It's just
- 8:52somewhere right there in the middle. And that,
- 8:55to me, felt so similar to Seventh Heaven. There
- 8:58are scenes in the movie that are straight out,
- 9:00okay, well, we've seen this before with Seventh
- 9:02Heaven. Okay, you've done this before. This relationship
- 9:05and how war can keep you apart and how I really
- 9:07want to be with this person, but I can't because
- 9:09the war is keeping us apart just felt too similar
- 9:13to Seventh Heaven for me. And, you know, if it
- 9:15happens to be like, hey, this reminds me of a
- 9:17movie from like, you know, five years ago or
- 9:19so. Fine. So what? When it's the same director,
- 9:23it feels a little less, you know. Right. You've
- 9:26done this before. And there's a very direct connection
- 9:30there between Seventh Heaven and this. But I
- 9:32think even when you throw Bad Girl into the mix
- 9:35in the middle, like that's a very different movie
- 9:37as far as like the plot itself goes. There's
- 9:41no war involved in that. Yeah. But it is like
- 9:44a similar relationship of two characters that
- 9:47almost reluctantly end up together and then form
- 9:49a very passionate romance. But then there are
- 9:53outside forces and parties trying to separate
- 9:56them or cause divisiveness in their relationship.
- 10:01If not just to keep them focused on what they're
- 10:02doing. Exactly. Right. That's Rinaldi's case
- 10:05for Frederick is that he wants him to focus on
- 10:07the war. So he's keeping these letters from going
- 10:10out to Catherine. Yeah, it's... It's so weird
- 10:13because I feel like I'm being very critical of
- 10:16Borzegi and his stories now because I've seen
- 10:19them so many times. Sure. But like, this is an
- 10:21original book. Right. So it's almost like, well,
- 10:26sorry, Hemingway, that's not your fault. I kind
- 10:28of wish somebody else directed this. However,
- 10:31Ernest Hemingway has gone on record saying he
- 10:34is very vocal of his hatred for this adaptation.
- 10:37Really? This interpretation specifically. His
- 10:39quotes exactly are too romantic. And I see what
- 10:46he's saying. Like, you know, obviously when we
- 10:48see seventh heaven and bad girl, like he has
- 10:50the romance that he goes after. Yeah. And it
- 10:52sounds like he added more romance into this story
- 10:55than there was intended to be by the author.
- 10:57And that to me is why it leans too much like
- 10:59seventh heaven. We're like, why would you be
- 11:01adding romance where it doesn't need to be? So.
- 11:04It's interesting because I read that, and I don't
- 11:07have this written down, so forgive me for getting
- 11:09this wrong. But I read that Ernest Hemingway
- 11:11had like a little bit of, you know, concern about
- 11:13the movie with Gary Cooper. They ended up being
- 11:15really good friends. Oh, yeah. They were great
- 11:18friends. So, you know, some good came out of
- 11:20the movie in terms of Ernest Hemingway and what
- 11:22he got out of it. But ultimately, when the author
- 11:25of the book that this is based on isn't happy
- 11:28with the interpretation, it's one thing to be
- 11:30like Stephen King where it's like, yeah, I don't
- 11:32know if I'm a big fan of that one. To say you
- 11:34hated it, his words, like the vocal hatred of
- 11:38the movie, that's difficult. And to me, I take
- 11:41that on top of what I felt when I was watching
- 11:44the movie, and it just stopped me from really
- 11:47connecting with it much. That doesn't mean it's
- 11:50terrible, like, you know, zero star, half star,
- 11:52whatever, we'll get to our ratings later, but
- 11:54it did stop me from really enjoying it when otherwise...
- 11:58I really wanted to enjoy something that has as
- 12:00much of a prestige nature behind something like
- 12:03A Farewell to Arms. Right. No, I totally agree
- 12:06with you. It really is like I'm okay with the
- 12:09story and I'm okay with melodrama. I just don't
- 12:12know if I was tired of seeing it from the same
- 12:14person, Borzegi, or if I, you know, I just wasn't
- 12:19in the mood for it. It's hard to say. I think
- 12:21it might be more of the latter for me. Maybe
- 12:23a third option, which is... I need something
- 12:27to break up the melodrama. Now, we talked a lot
- 12:30about in I'm a Fugitive from a Chain Gang. That
- 12:34is a very melodramatic movie. I even said, like,
- 12:37technically, the movie should be called Aw, Man,
- 12:39of like, he just can't catch a break. Yeah. But
- 12:43the reason that the things that keep me from
- 12:46feeling that's just too melodramatic of a movie
- 12:49is that there are things that break that apart.
- 12:52And in I'm a Fugitive from a Chain Gang, similarly
- 12:55in Smiling Through, there's camera work. There
- 12:58are things like, you know, characters and dialogue
- 13:01that keep you from kind of, it breaks it up and
- 13:04makes it feel a little more energetic. I'll give
- 13:06you a perfect example. In this movie, A Farewell
- 13:09to Arms, one of the first things that we see
- 13:11is we see Frederick and Rinaldi agreeing that
- 13:15they're going to go out on the town. Let's go
- 13:16out in the town. Let's paint the town red. And
- 13:18the camera cuts and it's a window. And you see
- 13:22people walking by in the window. And then it
- 13:24pans back. And as it pans back, almost like a
- 13:26reverse wings, which I appreciated. As it pans
- 13:29back, people are coming into the frame. Yeah.
- 13:31And it's a woman on the left with her shoe and
- 13:34Rinaldi's in the background. And you can see
- 13:36Frederick on the right kind of flirting with
- 13:38her as like, you know, he's talking and admiring
- 13:41her feet and her shoe. Yeah. And he's clearly
- 13:44drunk. I really like this shot. And this is like,
- 13:46oh, like I'm leaning in. I'm really interested
- 13:48in what's happening with this. Another scene
- 13:51that I really appreciated, the shot at least,
- 13:53was Frederick comes back from war. Well, the
- 13:56ambulance. And he's trying to report in, oh,
- 14:00you need to talk to this specific, like, is it
- 14:02the English unit? Like, this is the Italian unit.
- 14:05So you need to go down the hall. And he's watching
- 14:07someone get reprimanded, clearly. One of the
- 14:10nurses getting reprimanded. And as he's trying
- 14:13to, like, leave the room. He walks into a room
- 14:16where all the other nurses are kind of spying
- 14:18on this happening. And specifically, it's Catherine
- 14:20who is spying, not just through a keyhole and
- 14:24not just through a window. My girl is on a ladder
- 14:27and she's all the way at the top looking through
- 14:30the window that is above the door watching them.
- 14:33And as he walks through the door, he notices
- 14:36her. What I love about this shot. is the camera
- 14:39is not just on the ground looking up at her.
- 14:41There is a camera angle like that. There is another
- 14:43camera angle that is over her shoulder. So presumably
- 14:47on another ladder. Over her shoulder or whatever
- 14:50it might be. Camera work. Looking over her shoulder
- 14:54and you can see through the window down into
- 14:57the room where she's being reprimanded. Yeah.
- 14:59There's a great focus shot in this. And again,
- 15:02you could have just done, you know, over the
- 15:04shoulder and then pretend that she's up there.
- 15:06No, they went up there and they got that shot
- 15:08with her. Yeah. Loved that. And then there's
- 15:11another shot of the camera on a ladder above
- 15:13Frederick. And he looks up and sees Catherine.
- 15:16And when he realizes what she's doing, he gives
- 15:18just a little like a tsk, tsk, tsk with his finger.
- 15:21A tut, tut. And then walks away. And to me...
- 15:25I really liked the intentionality of where the
- 15:28camera was of like, hey, it's not just we capture
- 15:30this on the ground. We need one camera down here
- 15:32and then another camera over her shoulder, but
- 15:34then another camera in place of her looking down
- 15:36at him. Yeah. And there are four different camera
- 15:38placements of this one interaction of the two
- 15:40of them that lasts maybe three seconds. And it
- 15:43didn't feel like, you know, whiplash of where
- 15:46am I right now? Yeah. But it felt like there's
- 15:48intentionality and there's like really like you're
- 15:50connecting with the characters through the camera
- 15:52work. And I didn't feel that. as the movie went
- 15:55forward. So as like the more melodramatic events
- 15:58happen and they're kept apart at war and they
- 16:00can't communicate with one another, I didn't
- 16:02feel that camera work in trying to like stand
- 16:04in for the characters to show how they're feeling.
- 16:07Right. So it really is just truly what is happening
- 16:10to the characters and nothing else. And that
- 16:12keeps me from feeling invested in the story.
- 16:15Yeah, no, I totally understand that. I think
- 16:18this is a movie where you can tell that they
- 16:20had a crane. On set. Oh, for sure. There are
- 16:23so many great crane shots. Another one that I
- 16:25really liked is when Catherine and Frederick
- 16:27are walking through the garden of the hospital.
- 16:30And the camera starts from way overhead and then
- 16:33comes down below this statue of a man on a horse.
- 16:36Yes. And it falls like right below the horse's
- 16:39hoofs. Yeah. Looking down at them. Just a really
- 16:43cool, unique, engaging shot. And there are a
- 16:46lot of tracking shots. There's some really cool
- 16:47camera work overall in this. But I do agree that
- 16:50after you reach a certain point in this movie,
- 16:53they kind of abandon that and they focus more
- 16:56on the melodrama. Which, again, as we've said
- 16:59multiple times now, we're just kind of losing
- 17:01interest in this particular tale, I think. So
- 17:06I was looking for more pizzazz from the cameras.
- 17:09And you do get plenty of it with Charles Lang
- 17:12and his cinematography in this. Yeah, absolutely.
- 17:14It's funny because... To me, it just feels like
- 17:18the adaptation wasn't done. And again, I haven't
- 17:20read the book, so I can't say this 100%. But
- 17:22clearly, Ernest Hemingway's thoughts, the adaptation
- 17:24wasn't indicative of the novel. It was a completely
- 17:28different interpretation. A couple things to
- 17:30learn. This was Ernest Hemingway's first adaptation
- 17:33into a film. So the first time one of his novels
- 17:35had been adapted into a film. So you learn a
- 17:38little bit from that of like, oh, maybe I need
- 17:39to have a little more. if I let this happen,
- 17:42I need to be more involved in this and like oversee
- 17:44the script. We now see like in a Stephen King
- 17:46scenario post the shining where he's like, I
- 17:49kind of have to have same cast and everything.
- 17:50Like I need to know what happens with this. So
- 17:53it's interesting to see how that evolves over
- 17:55time too. But clearly this is the, one of the
- 17:57first examples of this happening where they weren't
- 17:59very happy, at least vocally weren't happy with
- 18:02it. What I do want to make sure we talk about
- 18:04is the cinematography was very impressive for
- 18:06the first half. I didn't feel that as much with
- 18:08the second half. But I do want to talk about
- 18:11the art direction. One of the nominations here
- 18:13was for Hans Dreher and Roland Anderson. So I
- 18:17want to talk a bit about the art direction here.
- 18:19Obviously, we've talked with art direction about
- 18:21like, you know, the way they've designed certain
- 18:23scenes, matte paintings. There's an interesting
- 18:26use of miniatures in this movie. Yeah, yeah.
- 18:29And I think this is one of the first times that
- 18:32we've gotten to talk about miniatures in film
- 18:34for art direction. I thought this was incredible.
- 18:37I mean, so one of the miniatures is kind of like
- 18:40the ambulances, right? As the ambulances are
- 18:42driving through. Yeah. Sometimes you can tell
- 18:46a little more than others of like, oh, those
- 18:49are miniatures. But the idea is that it's supposed
- 18:52to kind of be like a wide shot. Like, hey, how
- 18:54do we get this insane shot of like these ambulances
- 18:56driving through a war zone? Right. And the answer
- 18:58is miniatures. Yeah. And I think it being obvious
- 19:01to us has to do with like the quality of the
- 19:03movies now. Surely when you were going to see
- 19:06these in the 30s. You weren't thinking, oh, that's
- 19:07a miniature. Yeah. You couldn't tell, I'm sure.
- 19:09Right. But I agree. When I saw that, I was like,
- 19:11huh. I love a miniature. It's so much fun. There's
- 19:14also... We're skipping ahead just a little bit
- 19:17here just for a reference. There's also puppets
- 19:19in this. They're not meant to depict any specific
- 19:22characters. But I really like this transition
- 19:24scene of when it shows the passing of time. You
- 19:28see the curtain before the puppet show starts.
- 19:30And then the letters that spell out the months
- 19:32come down almost in marionette fashion. Yeah.
- 19:35And like twist around to sometimes not say the
- 19:38month, but then it's July. It's August. It's
- 19:40September. Now it's October. I thought that was
- 19:42really cool. And then the curtain opens up and
- 19:44now it's a puppet. show that Frederick and Catherine,
- 19:48that Frederick and Catherine are watching together
- 19:50in Italy. Fantastic. Now, granted, I mean, that's
- 19:53not, again, supposed to like signify anything,
- 19:56but the use of puppets and miniatures in this,
- 19:58I thought was a nice touch. It added a little
- 20:01bit more to it. But unfortunately, to our point,
- 20:04with that happening in the middle of the movie,
- 20:05I think that's kind of where it lost me. And
- 20:08I just wasn't as involved anymore. Yeah, you
- 20:11know, it's interesting. Past the halfway point
- 20:14in my notes, I did write it shot incredibly well
- 20:18and every shot counts. And I think that I do
- 20:21feel that way overall. I think that like the
- 20:25mobility in the camera and kind of the uniqueness
- 20:27of shots goes away. But I do think like the choice
- 20:31in like shot composition and things like that
- 20:35is still very. Intentional? Intentional. Thank
- 20:40you. That's exactly the word I was looking for.
- 20:42Nailed it. Appreciate it. But yeah, I really
- 20:45think that the movie itself was kind of working
- 20:49against me of where I was just like, yeah, I've
- 20:51seen this. I get it. And I wonder if this was
- 20:56the first Borzegi we had seen. be as critical
- 21:00probably not i mean i think we'd still be like
- 21:03yeah this doesn't like it's not as exciting but
- 21:05you know i'd probably be like a star above it
- 21:07because i haven't seen this before yeah but in
- 21:09this case i have yeah that's fair and if anything
- 21:12it might be a little more infuriating that this
- 21:15is the third that we've seen infuriating might
- 21:17be too hard of a word but baffling that we've
- 21:19seen him do bad girl so we know that he's capable
- 21:22of doing something differently but i think now
- 21:25we're starting to see the trends in his filmmaking
- 21:28And unfortunately, when you revert back to something
- 21:31like Seventh Heaven after you've done Bad Girl,
- 21:33it just feels uninspired. You know, it almost
- 21:36feels to me like Wes Anderson, how Wes Anderson
- 21:39comes out with a movie and you know exactly what
- 21:42you're going to get as far as style goes. 100%.
- 21:45Formula style. And I think that Borzegi is very
- 21:48much that type of director. Although his style's
- 21:50not as unique and identifiable. No. I think it's
- 21:54more of like... Pacing. Pacing and character
- 21:57depiction, specifically. Because, yeah, I keep
- 22:00going to talk about the movie itself and, like,
- 22:02specific scenes, and it's more interesting to
- 22:05talk about the shots than, like, what actually
- 22:08transpires on screen. Yeah, I mean, well, so
- 22:12if you've never read the novel Farewell to Arms
- 22:15or seen the movie, spoilers ahead for what we're
- 22:18going to talk about. But we are going to try
- 22:19to avoid just telling you the synopsis. We can't
- 22:22not talk about what happens at the ending. i
- 22:26think is questionable about frank borzaghi and
- 22:29what he does is with bad girl we see the ending
- 22:32be that like quiet conversation between the two
- 22:35leads in the car on their way after like you
- 22:38know um the hospital right talking about their
- 22:41hey my kid's gonna this is the future president
- 22:43united states in the car we see like the humor
- 22:46and everything yeah What we see in a farewell
- 22:48to arms is more of a return to seventh heaven
- 22:50in the sense that the final shot of seventh heaven
- 22:52is the sun shining down on the two of them as
- 22:56they fully embrace. Is he really there? Are they
- 22:58really together? That's like, you know, up to
- 23:00interpretation. The ending of a farewell to arms
- 23:03is so like, in my opinion, needlessly romantic
- 23:07and not like maybe romantic is the right word,
- 23:09but like too, too romantic of a gesture of after
- 23:13Catherine's passing. And there's a whole scene
- 23:16with Helen Hayes that I want to talk about. But
- 23:18after her passing, you see like wedding bells
- 23:20and like the cuts of like, you know, these different
- 23:22sounds happening in the background. And then
- 23:24the next cut is Frederick has picked up Catherine's
- 23:28body as she's like draped in like this dress
- 23:31or like the blanket, the blanket and carries
- 23:34her to the window. And there's just such like
- 23:37a. It almost feels unearned, in my opinion. Like,
- 23:40that big romantic gesture of, like, well, this
- 23:43isn't as heartbreaking. Like, he's carrying his
- 23:45wife to, like, the sunlight after this happens.
- 23:47And to me, having seen Bad Girl, I'm like, you
- 23:49did this with Seventh Heaven. Like, even, like,
- 23:52into the light. Like, we've embraced in the light
- 23:54one final time. And granted, with Seventh Heaven,
- 23:56they might be alluding to whether or not he is
- 23:59really there. But in this, it's more the literal,
- 24:01I'm bringing her into the sunlight as she passes.
- 24:04And to me, I totally get what Ernest Hemingway
- 24:07is saying when he says it's too romantic, because
- 24:09that scene specifically was just like, all right,
- 24:11man, got you. This was filmed with multiple endings.
- 24:14Interesting. There is the death ending. Oh, I
- 24:17heard about the life ending and an ambiguous
- 24:19ending where you're not sure if she lives or
- 24:21dies. So I think that's really interesting because
- 24:23that, well, is Chico really there? Is he actually
- 24:27blind? Do they end up together? Right. You get
- 24:30more of that here. Obviously not in the final
- 24:33cut of the film. Like you have one very definitive
- 24:36ending. But multiple endings were filmed. So
- 24:39it's almost like Borzegi is like. This might
- 24:42be cool. Maybe. This could be cool. Maybe I'll
- 24:44let you think about it for a while. Which is
- 24:47what he did with 7th Avenue. Right. I don't know.
- 24:49I said that Gary Cooper and Helen Hayes in this
- 24:51have good chemistry together. But I don't think
- 24:54they are given enough. good scenes together to
- 24:58really build that romance and that relationship
- 25:00it feels like you get a lot of man i i really
- 25:04love that girl and i really love that man but
- 25:07they're like talking to other people like you
- 25:09see more of people trying to keep them apart
- 25:11than them actually being together which is interesting
- 25:13because behind the scenes helen hayes has said
- 25:15like she had a huge crush on gary cooper which
- 25:18you know of course there's a letterboxd review
- 25:21that i really liked that said um get in line
- 25:24Yeah. Get in line. But also Helen Hayes, I think
- 25:27is like five foot something. And Gary Cooper's
- 25:31like six foot two or something. And someone was
- 25:33like, get away from him. Yeah. Like you're not
- 25:35tall enough for him. Leave him to me. Right.
- 25:37I really love how much Letterboxd reviews are
- 25:39just thirsting over Gary Cooper at all times,
- 25:41which I get it. What I also like about this,
- 25:44and you know, I do want to give the movie credit
- 25:46where it's needed or where it's earned. The opening,
- 25:49the meet cute between them is twofold. I think
- 25:52there's two meet cute scenes. One is when he
- 25:54walks in spying her or walks in on her spying
- 25:57on her friend being reprimanded. Yeah. And. Makes
- 26:02the tut -tut look at her. And her thought at
- 26:04this point must be, oh man, this guy has some
- 26:06power over me in terms of his rank. He outranks
- 26:10me. And I kind of got shunned just now. I'm being
- 26:13reprimanded a little bit by him too, but very
- 26:15quietly. And now I'm kind of looking up to him
- 26:17because he has given his authority to me. Shown
- 26:22his authority. And then the next Miku they have
- 26:24is when she trips over his leg when there's a
- 26:27siren. A bomb siren going off for bombs being
- 26:30dropped. And she has tripped over his leg while
- 26:34he is drunk, still having a conversation in his
- 26:37head with the woman he was having a conversation
- 26:39with about her feet and her shoes. She trips
- 26:42over his leg and she's like, oh, wow, that's
- 26:43the guy who outranks me. I wonder what he's going
- 26:45to say. And he's like, you know, the arch of
- 26:47a foot is interesting. She's like, oh, never
- 26:50mind. You're just a regular guy. Yes. Who's talking
- 26:53about feet. It's a really interesting scene.
- 26:56It's the closest the camera has been to a foot.
- 26:59In the entire run of the podcast. Wow. I guess.
- 27:02Big foot movie. There's those milestones that
- 27:05you don't think about. Yeah. Like, yeah, this
- 27:07is the first time we've had close up on feet,
- 27:08I suppose. Yeah, it is. And I want to take a
- 27:12side detour here because they do have that the
- 27:15meet cute there, but it is cute. The feet cute.
- 27:18Yeah. Do you think Helen Hayes is on? What is
- 27:22it? Foot Finder? Is that what that's called?
- 27:25is this a can we put this in the podcast are
- 27:27we in a good space to where i can ask you what
- 27:29that is yeah isn't that the you know you can
- 27:32go look at feet i don't look at the feet uh -huh
- 27:36sure maybe i'll cut this from the podcast maybe
- 27:38give me your phone maybe give me your internet
- 27:41browser right now uh delete no you can't do that
- 27:45delete cute um But yeah, they have that meet
- 27:51cute and it does revolve around him being at
- 27:54a brothel. Again, we're seeing a lot of this
- 27:57in these movies, a lot of sex or sex workers.
- 28:01And this is another thing that the production
- 28:03code is like, wait a minute, what are we doing
- 28:06here? Yeah, because they never say anything.
- 28:08But like, of course, he's talking about a woman's
- 28:10foot. Like she's like, she's laughing almost
- 28:12kind of annoyingly. She's got this like. Oh,
- 28:15I'm going to laugh at anything you say and I'm
- 28:17going to giggle. Yeah, but it's almost like canned
- 28:18giggling. Yeah. Where she's like, um. I don't
- 28:22know. He's like, what do you mean you don't know?
- 28:23And it cuts to like over and over and over. But
- 28:26the thing that really sold it to me of like,
- 28:28okay, yeah, for sure it's a brothel. When the
- 28:30sirens are going off, people are jumping out
- 28:32of windows to get out of there. But also one
- 28:34guy's like running out the door and he's like
- 28:36putting his pants like back on kind of. So he's
- 28:38like fastening his belt. Yep. So I get it. Like
- 28:41there's things they can show but not say. And
- 28:44I think get away. I'm using quotations here.
- 28:46Get away with it. Yeah. Well, I think the first
- 28:49like 10 or 15 minutes, which is kind of where
- 28:51this segment ends, is is kind of littered with
- 28:55so much of this production code controversy.
- 28:58Yeah. Because the nurse you're talking about
- 29:02that's being reprimanded at the beginning of
- 29:03the film, it's because she is pregnant from from
- 29:06supposedly another soldier, which is obviously
- 29:09a big problem. Child out of wedlock out. I want
- 29:15to say it's being run by Catholic nuns as well,
- 29:19so there's that element of it as well. And once
- 29:23the movie started, I was like, oh, wow, we've
- 29:25got pregnancy out of wedlock. Oh, we're at a
- 29:27brothel. Oh, Gary Cooper is shirtless. The church
- 29:30is involved in some of the things going on here.
- 29:32Yeah, and it just kept going, and I was like,
- 29:35okay, here we are. Here are literally all of
- 29:39the elements of... A pre -code film just on full
- 29:43display here. And there's even an element of
- 29:46not directly anti -war, but the fact that Gary
- 29:50Cooper's character goes AWOL and runs away so
- 29:53that he can be with Catherine. Yes. I think any
- 29:55of that like going against your country and your
- 29:58duty to your country is pretty frowned upon by
- 30:01the code as well. Right. So I don't know. I feel
- 30:03like when this movie opened up, there was a lot
- 30:05that was really drawing me to it. And then it
- 30:08just kind of turned into this. big romance that
- 30:11i lost interest with yeah there's it's also kind
- 30:15of like you don't want to hear that the plot
- 30:17of the movie is this could or could not happen
- 30:20um and that's kind of the second half for me
- 30:23the second half of the movie is the Well, you
- 30:26know, we're together and we want to talk about
- 30:28having kids, but we can't really talk about having
- 30:31kids without being, you know, married. But we
- 30:33really can't get married until someone blesses
- 30:36us. But, oh, my God, look, we're being blessed
- 30:38right now. That's incredible. My least favorite
- 30:41part of the movie. Yeah. Right there. Frederick
- 30:44is in bed. He's injured. Bomb went off. His leg
- 30:48was like, you know, they listed off all the things.
- 30:50I'm like, okay, yeah, sure. Great line as well
- 30:53when they ask, wow. What happened to you? I was
- 30:56blown up eating cheese. Because it was. They're
- 31:00talking to him like he's a war hero. And Rinaldi
- 31:02specifically is like, you'll get a medal for
- 31:04this and be considered a hero for all time. Yeah.
- 31:07And in reality, he was sitting in his bunker
- 31:09and about to slice some cheese for all the men
- 31:11and drink some wine. And the bomb went off. So,
- 31:14you know, way to go, Gary. Yeah. I did like that
- 31:18line. It's a little tongue in cheek. Yeah. It
- 31:20was very funny. But it was that sequence where
- 31:23he's. In bed. Yeah. And Catherine has come to
- 31:27his side and... Okay, I will... I just thought
- 31:29of this. I will give Borzeghi another credit
- 31:32here, at least the cinematography. There's a
- 31:34sequence in which Frederick is in bed. And the
- 31:38camera takes the place of Frederick. The point
- 31:40of view. The point of view. And you see nurses
- 31:42come in and you see Catherine come in. And she
- 31:44even leans over and gives like a kiss underneath
- 31:47the camera or right above it. I can't remember.
- 31:49But she leans into the camera to give the kiss.
- 31:51And like you can still hear his dialogue perfectly.
- 31:54And I really like this because, again, it was
- 31:57like, oh, this is interesting. Yeah. But that
- 31:59happens before the time jump. And I think anything
- 32:01after the time jump, to me, it just wasn't as
- 32:04interesting. But so this is where. To me, I was
- 32:08starting to see Seventh Heaven of like, they
- 32:11haven't been kept apart from war yet, but they're
- 32:13the whole like, oh boy, marriage would really
- 32:15solve our problems here, wouldn't it? Yeah. And
- 32:18then another guy's like, well, hey, why don't
- 32:19I help you out with that? Yeah. And you cut forward
- 32:22in time. You're like, okay, great. So they're
- 32:23married. But then after the time jump, when they're
- 32:26watching the puppet show, they're like, yeah,
- 32:28this is great being engaged, huh? Or, like, soon
- 32:31to be married. And someone's like, you're not
- 32:33going to be married for long. Like, they're jaded.
- 32:36They're in a relationship. They're like, don't
- 32:38worry. Romance isn't what you think it is. Right.
- 32:40But then they allude to, like, not allude. They
- 32:42say out loud, like, yeah, we're not married yet.
- 32:44Yeah, what was that whole thing with the priest
- 32:46then? Yeah. So I think it was more like he's
- 32:48giving them a blessing to get married. right
- 32:50so then they can get married but they still haven't
- 32:54and it's not like they're planning a wedding
- 32:55or anything it's just yeah we're together right
- 32:57and it's better now i despised that scene with
- 33:01the priest though it drove me nuts because they're
- 33:04in bed and they're talking about marriage and
- 33:05then the priest turns his back and just starts
- 33:07like mumbling to himself well at first it looks
- 33:10like he's like not what's the word in shock And
- 33:14he's like, how could she be saying such things
- 33:16about having children in the future? Yeah. And
- 33:18you're not even married. Right. And then he turns
- 33:21his back and you're like, is he going to call
- 33:22the cops on them? No. And instead he's like,
- 33:25and they're like, hey, father, what are you doing?
- 33:32Is he blessing us? And you're like. answer them
- 33:37dude what are you doing the only thing that annoyed
- 33:40me more than that which is annoying is that the
- 33:44audio that they're using clearly does not match
- 33:46up with what he's doing yeah and i get it it's
- 33:49an older movie they're literally using exactly
- 33:51like you can't hear what he's saying but the
- 33:55the movements that his lips are making don't
- 33:57even remotely match what you're hearing drives
- 33:59me nuts and like if they do it for one scene
- 34:01fine but to your point you aren't exaggerating
- 34:04that cut is like three or four times on forever
- 34:06and it continues to be not synced up and the
- 34:09fact that it's not synced up makes it look like
- 34:11he's like casting a spell on them right i was
- 34:13like is he like cursing them right it drove me
- 34:17nuts but the thankfully i don't want to say thankfully
- 34:19because it lends itself to the scene being ineffective
- 34:22is the acting on helen hayes and gary cooper
- 34:27yeah in that they're like oh he's blessing us
- 34:31Well, this is great news, isn't it, honey? Like,
- 34:33have you seen those, the TikTok trend of like
- 34:37someone throwing out something that belongs to
- 34:39you and you're like, wait a minute. And then
- 34:41they start counting really fast. That's what
- 34:44this was. Yeah. It was just him like. And you
- 34:48can't even make out what he's saying after a
- 34:50while. Oh, it's so annoying. I think that was
- 34:51the beginning of the end for me where I was like,
- 34:53what's going on? Yeah. Because at that point
- 34:55you start to realize, okay, everybody in this
- 34:57movie who is not Helen Hayes or Gary Cooper is.
- 35:00The most annoying character of all time. Rinaldi
- 35:03took such a turn. I loved him at first. He's
- 35:07so much fun. He's like, hey, Frederick, baby.
- 35:10Chill, baby. Let's go out. Let's have a good
- 35:13time, baby. And then he's like, oh, you love
- 35:16this girl? No, absolutely not. You need to focus
- 35:19on your country. Focus on me, baby. And if this
- 35:23was a love triangle, then let's get into it.
- 35:25It would have been great. But then also Catherine's
- 35:28friend, Fergie. is the same way she's like you
- 35:31can't marry this guy he's a soldier that's you
- 35:34can't do that you can't have a baby with this
- 35:37guy just constantly everybody is like trying
- 35:40to tear them apart yeah in the most annoying
- 35:43way too like rinaldi being like hey you're my
- 35:47best friend baby i am going to hide every letter
- 35:51you get from the woman you love yeah it's it
- 35:54made for such an unenjoyable experience i'm very
- 35:59grateful that you brought up fergie um so her
- 36:01name is ferguson but she goes by fergie to catherine
- 36:04yeah i need you to know that the first time that
- 36:07i heard her referred to fergie that's not saying
- 36:09the first time it happened in the movie but the
- 36:11first time i heard it was when she is meeting
- 36:14catherine on her way to switzerland right she
- 36:17like brings her suitcase for her and she's like
- 36:19oh fergie thank you and i was like London Bridge?
- 36:22What do you mean Fergie? I had not heard Fergie
- 36:26in reference to anyone outside of, you know,
- 36:28the Duchess herself. Right. From Black Eyed Peas
- 36:31for anyone who's unknowledged on that. Yeah.
- 36:34And I got to say, this Fergie is not Fergalicious.
- 36:37She's not Fergalicious. I wouldn't even say she's
- 36:39glamorous. No. She's repetitious in her being
- 36:44annoying. Right. She says that, right? Sure.
- 36:47Fergie says that. And then Helen Hayes proves
- 36:48that big girls do cry. Yeah, they do. And they
- 36:51die. Okay. Thank you for saying that. I need
- 36:55to meet you somewhere with that. I have a new
- 36:57series, and I think that this movie falls into
- 37:00this series, as it well does with Aerosmith.
- 37:03And I'm introducing a new series called Helen
- 37:05Hayes Can't Not Die. Oh, yeah. Where she's featured
- 37:09in a movie where she's going to have to die.
- 37:11Yeah. And if your question is like, well, why
- 37:14does she have to? Because she does. Yeah. Both
- 37:16these movies just pause it. It's better for the
- 37:19story if she just dies. She's the Sean Bean of
- 37:21the 1930s. She is the Sean Bean. Maybe we'll
- 37:25call it the Sean Bean Honorary Helen Hayes Can't
- 37:28Die Award. Yeah, I like that. Who wins the Sean
- 37:30Bean Award for this decade? Right now, it's Helen
- 37:33Hayes. That's true. Sean Bean can't not die.
- 37:36We're copyright. Speaking of copyright, wow,
- 37:40look at me setting myself up for this. I want
- 37:42to point out here that the original copyright
- 37:44holder of A Farewell to Arms, the film adaptation,
- 37:47failed to renew the copyright, which resulted
- 37:51in like a ton of VHS and DVDs having extremely
- 37:55poor quality. So if you find some DVDs or even
- 37:58VHS of the 1932 Farewell to Arms directed by
- 38:01Frank Borzegi, there is a chance that unless
- 38:04you found like a, you know, a reputable brand
- 38:07that you're going to find a couple of like poor
- 38:10quality. Yeah. So my suggestion to you is this.
- 38:13Kino Lorber. released a blu -ray of farewell
- 38:16to arms looks fantastic what i love about this
- 38:19is it's not a perfect cut you still see some
- 38:21like burn marks and like you can hear a couple
- 38:23cuts here and there but ultimately it looks beautiful
- 38:26and that's just the film itself so uh keno lorber
- 38:29is the way to go just be wary if you're going
- 38:32out to buy dvds and vhs of farewell to arms because
- 38:35the copyright resulted in some poor quality well
- 38:37the interesting thing there too is this was reissued
- 38:41in 1938 but it was a 72 minute cut of the film
- 38:46so there's a lot the movie itself presumably
- 38:48after the production or the hayes code yeah yeah
- 38:51so the the film itself is 89 minutes but that
- 38:55was lost until 1999 so if you do happen to find
- 38:58a vhs copy of the film, it's probably that 72
- 39:02-minute cut, which would be very interesting
- 39:04to see, especially knowing that there were multiple
- 39:07endings shot for this. Wonder. I wonder what
- 39:10that would look like. Worth noting that the Kino
- 39:12Lorber edition, and I think what would be considered
- 39:14the theatrical version of this movie, is the
- 39:17one where Helen Hayes does pass at the end of
- 39:21the movie. That's the canon version of this film.
- 39:23Can you imagine Ernest Hemingway saying that?
- 39:25Like, this ending is canon. Yeah. Was the Kino
- 39:29Lorber version, did that have a color version
- 39:33as well? Not that I saw. Special features, there
- 39:36was like a few things. You know what's interesting?
- 39:37No subtitles. That's very interesting. Yeah,
- 39:40I couldn't turn subtitles on for it, and I checked,
- 39:41and it says no subtitles. I don't think I like
- 39:43that. I don't think I like that either. Good
- 39:45news is, as we move forward in time, you don't
- 39:47need it as much. We needed this a lot in like
- 39:491931, maybe like 1930. As we get in 1932, 1933,
- 39:54it's a bit easier to pick up the majority of
- 39:58the dialogue. Yeah, I just think for inclusivity,
- 40:01it's a little... True. Like, what are we doing?
- 40:03And also, I can't hear without my subtitles.
- 40:06Same. Agreed. Yeah, I watched this on Hoopla,
- 40:09the service connected to libraries. Uh -huh.
- 40:12And there was a color version of it as well.
- 40:15So at some point it received a color upgrade.
- 40:18I wonder if that was closer to the 1938 restoration.
- 40:20I don't know because it was the full movie. So
- 40:23I'm not sure what version that is. Yeah, it's
- 40:26interesting because same with Aerosmith. The
- 40:28Blu -ray cover is in color, right? Like they've
- 40:31colorized it, but then the movie itself is in
- 40:33black and white. I mean, that happens all the
- 40:35time. It's not like these two movies only did
- 40:37that. Yeah, but Aerosmith wasn't in color. No,
- 40:39but the cover is. The cover of the Blu -ray and
- 40:42DVD and everything is in color. But the other
- 40:45thing I want to mention about this while we're
- 40:47talking about behind the scenes before we get
- 40:48back into it. So Adolf Menjou, he was playing,
- 40:52I believe he was also an ambulance driver in
- 40:55the war along with Frederick. Fun thing, maybe
- 40:59not fun for him. He was an ambulance corps captain
- 41:01during World War I. So he had some knowledge
- 41:04on this. Now, granted, I don't know how much
- 41:07expertise and like, you know, authenticity you
- 41:09can bring to like, oh, that really was. He's
- 41:12behaving like a guy who was a corps captain in
- 41:14the war for ambulance driving. Yeah. But either
- 41:17way, it must have been nice to have someone on
- 41:19site to be like, oh, no, you would do this because
- 41:20that's what I did. Yeah. I was there. This is
- 41:22how you do it, baby. Here's how you drive the
- 41:25car, baby. That's going to go a long way. Lore
- 41:29has been unlocked. Last thing for me when it
- 41:32comes to behind the scenes. Fun thing about Farewell
- 41:34to Arms, two Oscar winners and an Oscar nominee
- 41:37in this movie. Two Oscar winners, Oscar nominee.
- 41:40Oh, in the cast. Yes. Yeah. So Adolph Menjoo
- 41:43is the Oscar nominee. Obviously, we talked about
- 41:46him as Walter Burns in the front page. Good to
- 41:49see him back. Helen Hayes also won two Oscars
- 41:52in this case. Yeah. Last year was The Sin of
- 41:54Madeline Claudette that we talked about. What
- 41:56was it afterwards? A little bit of trivia for
- 41:59you. Airport. It was Airport in 1970. Yeah. Look
- 42:02at you. Well done. And then Gary Cooper won two
- 42:05Oscars as well. These were all after Farewell
- 42:08to Arms. Of course. Yeah. Do you know what he
- 42:10won for? For Whom the Bell Tolls? Incorrect.
- 42:14Then I got nothing. Sergeant York in 1941. Yeah.
- 42:18And then High Noon in 1952. I knew Sergeant York.
- 42:21Covered it on the first iteration. Oh, look at
- 42:23you. But you did pull Airport out, and that was
- 42:25impressive. Yeah. Well, that's actually because
- 42:28we talked about Helen Hayes last year with Aerosmith.
- 42:32Oh. But still, interesting to see how many Oscar
- 42:34-winning performances or Oscar -winning actors
- 42:37we saw in the film. Yeah. And even with that,
- 42:40no acting nominations for Wild Arms. No, no.
- 42:43Do you think that that's like a missed opportunity
- 42:46there? Do you think anybody was deserving? I'm
- 42:49going to be honest with you. I was a little lukewarm
- 42:52on Gary Cooper. I think Gary Cooper is an incredible
- 42:55actor and he's incredibly attractive. He's a
- 42:58handsome man. Sure. But no, I didn't really think
- 43:01that there was a performance in this that was
- 43:03specifically like a standout. I did like Adolph
- 43:05Menjoo a good bit. How could you not? How could
- 43:08you not? Even with him, like that's why maybe
- 43:10it's betrayal that I also felt. My rating might
- 43:13be completely invoked by his betrayal. When he's
- 43:17like, he needs to focus on the war, baby. Baby.
- 43:19I was like, no, no, he wouldn't do this. Rinaldi
- 43:23wouldn't do that. Yeah, why would Rinaldi do
- 43:24this? Maybe that's it, too. But no, I mean, outside
- 43:28of, I think I liked his character. I don't know
- 43:30if I loved the performance. Yeah. So I think
- 43:32you're right. Yeah. Let's talk about the ending
- 43:36scene real quick before we get into ratings.
- 43:39Because I think that, I don't know, you said
- 43:41this was a little melodramatic for you. Yes.
- 43:44I do. Like the way it's done. At this point,
- 43:47Catherine is pregnant. She's pretty far along
- 43:50in her pregnancy. And she discovers that all
- 43:55of Frederick's letters and her letters have been
- 43:58returned to sender, basically. Neither one of
- 44:00them have been able to communicate with each
- 44:01other. And she learns this at the post office.
- 44:04And this reveal causes her to faint. I did like
- 44:07the comparison of the two where he found that
- 44:10all the letters had been returned. And he kind
- 44:12of like looks down a little bit and he's a little
- 44:13sad. And he's like, okay. And like turns around
- 44:15and leaves. Yeah. And with her, she's like, and
- 44:17like faints immediately. Which, you know, typical
- 44:211930s. Who's been there. Yeah. But because of
- 44:24this, she ends up in the hospital and Frederick
- 44:26decides at this point he's going AWOL so that
- 44:29he can get to Catherine and check in on her.
- 44:31Right. He shows up and this was kind of bizarre.
- 44:36He's speaking with the doctors and he's like,
- 44:39is she okay? And they're like, listen, she lost
- 44:42the baby. And he's like. But is she okay? He
- 44:45does say, like, it doesn't matter to me as long
- 44:48as she's okay. Exactly. I was like, well, that's
- 44:50messed up. Let's be a little more sensitive,
- 44:54Gary. I agree. But after that, a part that I
- 44:57did enjoy is because he was so, like, whatever
- 45:01about the baby being lost, he heads to the bar.
- 45:05to kind of relieve some of his stress. And there's
- 45:09a lot of symbolism here that kind of feels a
- 45:11little heavy -handed, but I like some of it on
- 45:13display. He walks past a dog in an alley that
- 45:16is looking at a pot, trying to find food, and
- 45:19it's a pot with a lid on it. And he walks by
- 45:21the dog, and he lifts up the pot to show the
- 45:23dog there's nothing in there. And he says, specifically,
- 45:27it's made me laugh a little bit, there's nothing
- 45:30in there, dog. And then he walks away. And that
- 45:33moment there is kind of a heavy handed way of
- 45:36being like, there's nothing in Catherine. Yes.
- 45:39The baby is gone. Then he makes his way to the
- 45:42bar. And I thought this was interesting, a way
- 45:46to kind of showcase the way he's going to miss
- 45:51Catherine being a mother. He walks up to the
- 45:54barkeep, who is a woman. And the camera is looking
- 45:57at her face, and then it slowly tilts down to
- 46:02focus on her breasts. And this is his way of
- 46:05seeing her as a woman, as a mother. Right. And
- 46:08I believe he asks her before he orders food or
- 46:12a drink or whatever. He's like, are you a mother?
- 46:15Have you been a mother? Making an assumption
- 46:17against her. And she's like, what? He's like,
- 46:20never mind, I'll take a beer. And you can tell
- 46:22that this is just very much on his mind, you
- 46:25know? But I liked both of those scenes, even
- 46:28if they did feel a little heavy handed because
- 46:30they were trying to do something. Yeah, it's
- 46:33just for me, I'm trying to think of the reason
- 46:35I laughed mostly at that is I'm trying to think
- 46:37of the alternative of what it would be for me
- 46:39if I go into a bar. Like, imagine I saw Michael
- 46:42in theaters, Michael Jackson biopic. Yeah. And
- 46:45I'm just sitting there like mad that the movie
- 46:47wasn't good. And then spoiler. And then I talked
- 46:50to a barkeep and I'm just like. do you like Michael
- 46:53Jackson? And they're like, what? I'm like, just
- 46:55a beer, please. I'm thinking of what the alternative
- 46:58would be for me, and it would certainly be that.
- 47:01It would be me being like, what are your thoughts
- 47:03on Christopher Nolan's filmography? And they're
- 47:05like, what? I'm like, just a Heineken. Have you
- 47:07ever looked up yourself on Foot Finder? What?
- 47:10Never mind. Just a beer. Yeah, we're going to
- 47:14have to... We're going to have to do some research
- 47:17into your search history. Well, you know. So
- 47:20after that, you do get to the finale of this
- 47:23movie, and this is a huge climax. I do want to
- 47:25make one big point here, and it's that Helen
- 47:27Hayes is still alive but knows that she's going
- 47:29to die. Right. And she tells the doctors and
- 47:32the nurses, she's like, please, I haven't seen
- 47:35my husband in forever. whatever he might be.
- 47:38I haven't seen my Frederick in a very long time.
- 47:41Just please don't tell him that I'm dying. I
- 47:43need him just come in and talk to me as me and
- 47:45not as his dying partner. Yeah. And they're like,
- 47:48yeah, of course. Don't worry. And as they walk
- 47:51out and they see him, I need them to do a better
- 47:53job. And because they walk out and they look
- 47:56at him and they just like look down and they're
- 47:58just like, what a shame. And like walk away.
- 48:00And I'm like, it's pretty indicative of what's
- 48:02going on. They walk by and they're like, dun,
- 48:04dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun. yeah i mean at
- 48:08least the nurse tried to have a little bit of
- 48:10like she was a little like couth with it and
- 48:12she was like okay she's ready to see you now
- 48:14um but the doctor was just straight up like yeah
- 48:17it's not looking good in there man like that
- 48:19was the the head shake and the look like priest
- 48:21walks out he looks directly in frederick's eyes
- 48:24and it's like okay and like walks away does the
- 48:26the knife to the throat like come on man be a
- 48:30little cooler than that yeah uh but yeah that
- 48:32leads to the scene you're talking about now Right.
- 48:34And they do have their romantic moment. They're
- 48:36finally seeing each other again for the first
- 48:39time in forever. And I think that Helen Hayes
- 48:42is the standout here. I think that her performance
- 48:44on her literal deathbed is very well done. The
- 48:49writing might feel a little melodramatic, but
- 48:54I think that's kind of a... from what we've covered,
- 49:05have been a little cheesy and cliche and not
- 49:08well done. And you could argue the cheesiness
- 49:10exists here, but it's also kind of unsettling
- 49:14at a point because she has that moment where
- 49:16she tells Frederick, I don't want to die. And
- 49:19it's spooky. It gave me, you know, that feeling
- 49:23of, I don't like that. Well, it was almost like
- 49:25a realization. Yeah. Like the way she said it
- 49:27was like, oh. I'm dying, aren't I? This is actually
- 49:30happening to me. So yeah, she has this really
- 49:34great performance, I think, here with Frederick,
- 49:37with Gary Cooper. And ultimately, she does pass
- 49:40away. And yeah, Frederick picks up her body,
- 49:43like you said earlier, and carries her to the
- 49:45window. And he kind of starts praying to God.
- 49:48And it's all just melodrama. I think visually,
- 49:52it looks pretty good. But again, we've seen this.
- 49:56We've felt these same emotions for this type
- 50:00of story, and I'm just kind of over it. One thing
- 50:03that I did appreciate about that scene was at
- 50:06one point, Gary Cooper lays his head on her shoulder,
- 50:09and his nose is on her cheek while she's talking.
- 50:13And I think this is the closest we've seen two
- 50:15actors in one scene, exchanging scenes together,
- 50:20lines of dialogue. And I thought that was like...
- 50:23probably the most romantic thing that we saw
- 50:25was like, there was no lifting. There was no
- 50:27like romantic gesture. It was just him leaning
- 50:29on her feeling emotional while she's talking.
- 50:32And I thought like that scene between them was
- 50:35very good with their acting, but ultimately it
- 50:38had just kind of been like, okay, so we're here
- 50:40now. Yeah. Like the same place where we were
- 50:43at minute 40. with his like leg being broken
- 50:47and ankle and everything him being bed bound
- 50:49and then be like oh i wish we were married is
- 50:52kind of mirrored here and it's yeah i wish we
- 50:54could have been married and now this would have
- 50:56been great i think that's why it cuts to the
- 50:58wedding bell the church bells to kind of show
- 51:00like their union in some sense uh as he carries
- 51:03her to the window for the sunlight yeah so yeah
- 51:06for me i just melodramatic is the right word
- 51:09but just also a little ham fisted a little bit
- 51:11of that but the acting is fantastic I agree.
- 51:13Specifically from Helen Hayes. Correct. I even
- 51:16think Gary Cooper, the way he's receiving it,
- 51:17like he's not trying to one -up her. He's not
- 51:19like taking the scene away from her. Yeah. But
- 51:21he's reacting, I think, perfectly. That's true.
- 51:23That's true. I should give him more credit for
- 51:26being able to like dial it back in while she
- 51:29gets her moment to shine. Right. But yeah, I
- 51:32mean, that's a farewell to arms. I think that
- 51:34we can both agree that the highlights here come
- 51:37from kind of the technical. categories to speak
- 51:40on charles lang a little bit he received 18 nominations
- 51:43throughout his career he's tied with leon oh
- 51:48i need to write better i'm gonna say leon shanzey
- 51:52i believe forgive me if my handwriting was terrible
- 51:56i was on set and delirious For most nominations
- 51:59in the cinematography category. So 18 nominations.
- 52:02As far as the art direction goes with Hans Dreher,
- 52:05he was Paramount's supervising art director until
- 52:081950. Oh, wow. And he received 23 nominations
- 52:11in the category. Wow. We'll see him return specifically
- 52:15with Sunset Boulevard. I really like how you're
- 52:17teasing this up like Palpatine. Yeah. Like somehow
- 52:20they will return. Somehow Hans returned 23 times.
- 52:25And... There was one other that I wanted to point
- 52:27out. In the sound department, Franklin B. Hansen
- 52:31had five nominations and one win. We saw his
- 52:35work in The Love Parade, which we were fans of.
- 52:38Yeah. And I think that's really cool because
- 52:40that was such an early sound film. So it's cool
- 52:42to see how far he's come with that. Right. The
- 52:44last thing that I'll say about this is Gary Cooper,
- 52:48probably going to be one of the... Biggest names
- 52:51we talk about for the next 30, maybe 40 years,
- 52:55probably like 30 years. How do you feel about
- 52:58Gary Cooper in general? Have you seen a lot of
- 53:00his films? I haven't. So my immediate knowledge
- 53:03of Gary Cooper is the Putting on the Ritz song,
- 53:06which I referenced earlier and you didn't cite.
- 53:10So I'm just a little spiteful on you on that.
- 53:13Oops. So that's about it for me. So this was
- 53:15my first introduction to him as an actor, at
- 53:18least that I'm aware of. I may have seen a movie
- 53:20he was in without knowing. But I'm excited because,
- 53:23again, I think he looks... He's got the look
- 53:27down for the major actor, big star. I liked him
- 53:31in this movie. And that's the thing that's really
- 53:33frustrating. I don't think the movie is their
- 53:35fault. No. I think it's the writing, maybe. It's
- 53:38the familiar territory that Frank Berzeghi has
- 53:41done previously with Seventh Heaven. And just
- 53:43feeling a little derivative of that and the melodrama
- 53:46aspect just was not interesting for me. Yeah.
- 53:48No, I completely agree. But I think he's great.
- 53:50I'm excited to see him in the future. Yeah, I
- 53:52don't think that this was the movie to really
- 53:54build up that excitement for me with him. But
- 53:56I've seen High Noon, and I really like when he
- 53:59kind of becomes his trademark, as Tony Soprano
- 54:03calls him, the strong, silent type. He does a
- 54:06pretty good job on this, too. Yeah, yeah. I think
- 54:09it takes away from his character at times for
- 54:11me, where I'm like, I wish I got a little more
- 54:13from you. I think when he's playing like the
- 54:15quiet Westerner, I like that a little bit more.
- 54:18But I agree. I'm very excited to see more of
- 54:20Gary Cooper. But yeah, farewell to ARMS. Farewell.
- 54:24Yippee. Let's get into ratings. So where did
- 54:28you land on this? I was very middle of the road
- 54:31with this, as has been alluded to. I gave it
- 54:34three stars. For all of the reasons previously
- 54:36mentioned. What about you? I was quite literally
- 54:40middle of the road. Two and a half. Show off.
- 54:42For me. Yeah. Just... You know, and it sucks
- 54:46because what I don't like doing is I don't like
- 54:48looking at these movies, seeing a general rating
- 54:50of 3 .3 and then being below that. Like, it makes
- 54:53me feel like I'm missing something in that. But
- 54:56for me specifically, you know, I got to be true
- 54:59to not just the 2026 perspective or perception
- 55:04of these movies, but also, you know, what this
- 55:07project is doing. And this project has us watching
- 55:10Seventh Heaven a couple months separated from
- 55:12watching A Farewell to Arms. So having that fresh
- 55:16in my mind is going to result in seeing a comparison
- 55:18in the work. And ideally, if your work is really
- 55:22good as a director or as an artist, that timing
- 55:25doesn't matter. And you can have it follow up
- 55:28immediately after and be like, oh, cool, I see
- 55:30the value in both of these. two and a half for
- 55:33me i could probably go lower honestly i don't
- 55:36really want to it doesn't feel respectful to
- 55:37the work ernest hemingway or the actors in this
- 55:41but yeah two and a half is where i stood and
- 55:44i i feel like that might be where i sit too okay
- 55:48the longer i sit on it so Well, that makes me
- 55:51feel a little bit better. I mean, I was happy
- 55:53to see you, Ziggy, and Bryce all at three stars
- 55:56with this. Yeah. Because like while I'm not where
- 55:59you are, I'm pretty close. You know, I think
- 56:01that a lot of the reviews that led to like a
- 56:043 .33 and a half, whatever it was, come from
- 56:06Gary Cooper fans. I think that most of the reviews
- 56:10I see are just kind of praising Gary Cooper,
- 56:12not even really for his performance in this,
- 56:14but just for being Gary Cooper. Yeah. People
- 56:17love that man. You're right, and I want to point
- 56:21that out with two reviews on Letterboxd. These
- 56:23are the top two reviews on Letterboxd. One, I'm
- 56:26going to edit this a little bit. Helen Hayes,
- 56:28back off my 6 '3 man with your short blank. Loving
- 56:32Gary Cooper is a tall people only event. Exclamation
- 56:35point, exclamation point. My favorite review
- 56:38is the top one. This was two and a half stars.
- 56:41This was not me. They said, tag yourself. I'm
- 56:44the guy who kept calling Gary Cooper baby. Oh,
- 56:46that's something I didn't even get a chance to
- 56:49talk about. I think that this is a really interesting
- 56:51film to look at through a queer lens. Because
- 56:55there is the potential there of Rinaldi being
- 56:58very, very romantically or sexually interested
- 57:02in Frederick. Yep. Well, that would make sense
- 57:05why he's, I think he, when he first meets, not
- 57:09meets Frederick, but when we first are introduced
- 57:11to the two of them together, Frederick's taking
- 57:14his shirt off. Yeah. Because they're in the washroom.
- 57:16Yep. He's washing his face. And then later on,
- 57:20that would explain him keeping the letters. Yes.
- 57:22Of like being vindictive. It feels like such
- 57:24a weird motivation for Rinaldi to just be like,
- 57:28oh, you don't need a woman. Focus on the war.
- 57:31Like if he's. Trying to get him to focus more
- 57:34on even like the bromance of them together, that
- 57:39makes more sense. But I would almost lean towards
- 57:42there being like a hidden romantic interest there.
- 57:46Interesting. And it kind of makes it a more interesting
- 57:48film for me. Well, he immediately, or instantly,
- 57:52not instantly, he initially wants to introduce
- 57:54Gary Cooper into Ferguson, Fergie. Right. So
- 57:58maybe there's the whole like, he's not going
- 58:00to get along with her. So I'm intentionally introducing
- 58:03him to someone he's not going to like because
- 58:05I don't want him with someone he doesn't like.
- 58:07A lot of that feels more coincidental than anything,
- 58:10but that's a really interesting lens to have.
- 58:12And I'm sure in 1932, they weren't writing in
- 58:15this queer character or this queer romance or
- 58:18anything like that. Maybe they were. And even
- 58:20if they aren't, I think that this does present
- 58:22an opportunity, maybe one of the first examples
- 58:25in the movies we've covered, where you could
- 58:27look at it through that lens and be like, hmm.
- 58:31Yeah. So I thought that was fascinating, and
- 58:35I'm glad you also found it interesting, baby.
- 58:38Well, I mean, look, the minute that Adolph Menjoo
- 58:40is saying, like, baby, I'm sad. I'm listening.
- 58:44Yeah. Which is why I should have loved this movie,
- 58:46but I just didn't get into it. There's always
- 58:48our next Menjoo. I'm looking forward to it. Let's
- 58:52talk about double features. Totally. So, incidentally,
- 58:56I have found myself in another pairing. Or theme,
- 58:59rather. Last recording session, you saw me pair
- 59:03two different movies with two different Richard
- 59:05Curtis films. And I did not intentionally do
- 59:08that. Once again, up until right now, I didn't
- 59:10realize that I had done this. I picked another
- 59:132013 film. Okay. This time, I looked at the relationship
- 59:16between Catherine and Frederick, Helen Hayes
- 59:19and Gary Cooper. And I kind of removed the war
- 59:23from it completely. And one thing that I liked
- 59:26was I liked the idea of an alternative. I liked,
- 59:29you know, obviously the ending of this is Catherine
- 59:32and Frederick unable to be together because Catherine
- 59:35passes. I like the graduate of it. I like the,
- 59:39hey, we got together. What does that actually
- 59:41mean? And what does the future hold for us? And
- 59:43I think a movie that. does this perfectly of
- 59:46talking about we want to be together so badly,
- 59:49but we can't. And what if we could be together?
- 59:51What does forever look like for us? The answer
- 59:54to that is Richard Linklater's 2013 third film
- 59:57in the Before trilogy, which is Before Midnight.
- 1:00:01This stars Ethan Hawke and Julie Delpy. And for
- 1:00:04anyone who's unfamiliar, this is one of the most
- 1:00:07romantic movies, at least in movie trilogies,
- 1:00:09with Before Sunrise, Before Sunset, and then,
- 1:00:13of course, Before Midnight. And I loved this
- 1:00:16movie because it answered the question of, like,
- 1:00:18we took the most romantic story that we have
- 1:00:21seen in a very long time, and we did a follow
- 1:00:24-up to it. I mean, this was the third, but we
- 1:00:26did a third movie to it. And what does that look
- 1:00:28like? And the answer is an imperfect marriage,
- 1:00:31an imperfect relationship. People who have, like,
- 1:00:34learned to hate the worst things about each other.
- 1:00:39are they a good fit? Is this something we want
- 1:00:41to see them together for? I thought this was
- 1:00:43a really nice swerve to the ending of Farewell
- 1:00:46to Arms in if they were able to be together,
- 1:00:48would that actually be a good thing for them?
- 1:00:51And people trying to keep them apart, people
- 1:00:53trying to like get them together. What does that
- 1:00:55look like? So I think Before Midnight is a really
- 1:00:58nice pairing to this in terms of where it could
- 1:01:00go. I like it. I like it. Yeah. I have not seen
- 1:01:04any of that trilogy yet. It's really good. Even
- 1:01:07knowing where that goes, ultimately, it's such
- 1:01:10like their connection as actors, Julie and Ethan,
- 1:01:14we're cool like that, is so good. Yeah, I think
- 1:01:19that that is a big contributor to why I'm not
- 1:01:22the biggest Ethan Hawke fan. I think it's because
- 1:01:26I haven't seen that tentpole film in his career.
- 1:01:29And I would say, I would say it's the before
- 1:01:31trilogy. Yeah. Before trilogy is probably, I
- 1:01:34have the criterions if you ever want to borrow
- 1:01:36them. I would say very easily, if we're doing
- 1:01:39a Mount Rushmore of Ethan Hawke movies, the before
- 1:01:41trilogy is up there. Yeah. Yeah. I need to check
- 1:01:44it out. I've been slacking. And then Black Phone
- 1:01:46and then Black Phone 2. And then Blue Moon. Oh
- 1:01:51my gosh. Well, I'm serious about before. I was
- 1:01:56kidding about the other three. No, for sure.
- 1:01:57I mean, all I hear is high praise for those movies.
- 1:01:59So one day, as far as my double feature, there
- 1:02:02is a very particular sequence in this movie that
- 1:02:06you talked about a little bit of the tail end
- 1:02:08of it. And it is the first person point of view
- 1:02:11of Frederick's character when he's being wheeled
- 1:02:13into the hospital. And I. Don't think that this
- 1:02:16is super effective in this movie. Like, I like
- 1:02:19it a lot. But as far as it playing a role in
- 1:02:23the narrative, I don't think it does. Can I take
- 1:02:25a guess? Sure. In what your pick is? Sure. Is
- 1:02:29it Diving Bell and the Butterfly? It is not.
- 1:02:31Okay. So he's being wheeled into the hospital.
- 1:02:34And because he's laying on his cot or whatever,
- 1:02:38being wheeled in, he's looking up at the ceiling.
- 1:02:40So you get to see, like, the chandeliers hanging
- 1:02:43in the hospital. And he makes his way to his
- 1:02:46bedroom. And that's when you have like different
- 1:02:48actors appearing in the shot looking down at
- 1:02:51him. So you'll see the doctor's faces, the nurse's
- 1:02:53faces, and ultimately Helen Hayes coming in to
- 1:02:56give him a kiss. And you get this almost like
- 1:02:58uncomfortably close image of her face right in
- 1:03:02the camera. And it's, you're almost thinking,
- 1:03:05oh, he's going to have suffered some injuries.
- 1:03:08That are like superficial injuries messing with
- 1:03:11his face. That doesn't turn out to be true, which
- 1:03:14is why I think this is kind of unaffected, ineffective.
- 1:03:16Where it is effective is in my double feature
- 1:03:19pick, Jacob's Ladder. Oh, yeah. Great. That is
- 1:03:22an iconic sequence in that movie where he is
- 1:03:25being wheeled through this nightmarish hospital.
- 1:03:28And there's like metal gratings above the ceiling
- 1:03:32and there's... bandaged figures like crawling
- 1:03:35around on the ceiling above him very much like
- 1:03:38a horror uh story i i thought like oh maybe i'm
- 1:03:43just taking this one shot and saying that'll
- 1:03:45be my double feature no but i think there's a
- 1:03:47lot i've done worse there's a lot in that film
- 1:03:50a story of a man who suffered from war and is
- 1:03:54now like trying to navigate his his life back
- 1:03:58home and there's a lot of complications with
- 1:04:01his love interest and again it does take more
- 1:04:04of a horror turn but i think there's like uh
- 1:04:07there are things in this man's life and and in
- 1:04:10his psyche that are kind of pulling him away
- 1:04:12from the thing that he really desires which is
- 1:04:14just peace and a normal life and that might be
- 1:04:17a little bit more of an obscure example of that
- 1:04:20than farewell to arms is but in a way they're
- 1:04:23both also kind of like hey these are the bad
- 1:04:25things that can come from war so Because of that
- 1:04:28shot and then those kind of loose themes, that's
- 1:04:31what led to that double feature. That's great.
- 1:04:33No, I don't think that there's anything wrong
- 1:04:35in seeing like that one scene and then taking
- 1:04:37the interpretation and moving forward. If anything,
- 1:04:40I think that's exactly what I did with this.
- 1:04:42And you look at the final scene and you're like,
- 1:04:44well, what if they could be together? And you
- 1:04:45start theorizing about what a movie looks like
- 1:04:47that does that. So, no, I think that's a fantastic
- 1:04:50idea. I also love the idea of a horror. paired
- 1:04:54with this yeah there's there's no uh lizard tail
- 1:04:57in a farewell to arms so you don't have that
- 1:05:00connection if it was it would definitely be with
- 1:05:02rinaldi right rinaldi would have a lizard tail
- 1:05:04hey bb how you like this lizard tail but uh but
- 1:05:11yeah that's a farewell to arms so like you said
- 1:05:15farewell to arms available As a Kino Lorber print,
- 1:05:19probably the best way to watch this film if you
- 1:05:21can. Next episode, we will be covering Cavalcade,
- 1:05:26the 1933 Frank Lloyd film. Oh, we're headed into
- 1:05:2933. Nice. New year, new me. Baby. Baby. This
- 1:05:34right now looks like you can rent it. video on
- 1:05:37demand and it might be available on no no it's
- 1:05:41video on demand it's video on demand so anywhere
- 1:05:44that you can rent your films streaming you can
- 1:05:48do so about three four dollars that you can rent
- 1:05:50this yeah so i guess i'm looking forward to it
- 1:05:54i don't know i looked at the synopsis and i'm
- 1:05:57like I've heard some unfortunate things. So we'll
- 1:06:01see. I guess we'll see. If you have thoughts
- 1:06:03about A Farewell to Arms, shoot us an email at
- 1:06:06outaopodcast at gmail .com. Check out the Patreon
- 1:06:10at patreon .com slash outaopodcast. Anything
- 1:06:14you would like to add? Closing notes? Nope. Perfect.
- 1:06:19All good. Thank you guys for listening. As always,
- 1:06:23I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan. And we'll see you at the
- 1:06:26movies. Thank you.