Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / The Crunch with JJ McCullough: Is "The War on Christmas" real?
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. The climate denialism of the Conservative Party of Canada is putting future
- 0:22white Christmas is at risk. And that's why on this side of the house,
- 0:26ope we stand for christ. But hey, folks, my name is
- 0:31Mohameir and this is Van Color, British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk
- 0:35show. I hope you've been celebrating a very festive holiday season, because tonight
- 0:40we're all about Christmas. My friends Tamara Taggart and Kyla Lee will be here.
- 0:44They're going to tell you who's on their nice list and who's on their
- 0:47naughty list. But first, whether it's talking heads blathering on about the war
- 0:52on Christmas, or the Prime Minister making climate change action a matter of standing
- 0:57up for Christmas, or a House of Commons motion that I had to declare
- 1:00that Christmas is not discriminatory. Christmas feels increasingly politicized. So is Christmas under
- 1:07attack? Here to discuss is my friend, a political commentator and YouTuber based
- 1:11right here in Vancouver. He is JJ McCullough. And this is the crunch,
- 1:22Jj. How real is the war on Christmas? Is this a real
- 1:26war? Well, I feel like when we say war it implies hostility to
- 1:30an enemy, right, And I don't think that anybody is really hostile to
- 1:34Christmas. I mean except for maybe like a few like lonely hipsters who think
- 1:38it's kind of fun to talk about how much they don't like Christmas. But
- 1:40in the sense that there's like no organized movement opposed to Christmas per se.
- 1:45But I do think that there is a significant sort of cohortive people, you
- 1:48know, particular people in sort of you know, elite positions in that that
- 1:49are maybe a little embarrassed by Christmas, or at least kind of feel like
- 1:53Christmas is a somewhat discriminatory or politically sort of incorrect practice, and that's something
- 2:00that we should be maybe a little wary of, a little sort of standoffish
- 2:04words. But that is a different disposition than being like Christmas is an enemy
- 2:07that must be eradicated from the face of the earth. But we see this
- 2:09in news headlines, we see this in programs like this, where people are
- 2:13chatting about it. And I do think that it is a minority of people
- 2:16that kind of engage in this thought exercise about Christmas. Because I know people
- 2:21that celebrate Christmas religiously. I know lots of people who celebrate Christmas culturally,
- 2:25and I know a lot of people who don't celebrate Christmas at all. As
- 2:28you said, none of them are you know, adamantly defending Christmas or going
- 2:32to war against Christmas either. So it just seems to be this weird conversation
- 2:37that perhaps people like you and I might be a I mean, I think
- 2:39that there is like a cohort of sort of like right wing sort of Christian
- 2:44types who can view this as a sort of proxy for kind of a larger
- 2:49form of Christian identity politics that they own. So this is like coded language,
- 2:53you think, I think, so I dog with perhaps, Yeah,
- 2:54I mean, I know, I think that when people talk about a war
- 2:58on when a certain type of sort of like right wing kind of Christian political
- 3:00person talks about a war on Christmas, they're using that as a proxy for
- 3:04the idea that, like, you know, this country is no longer hospitable
- 3:07to the one sort of dominant kind of Christian cultural majority, and thus we're
- 3:12being sort of like displaced and marginalized and that's sort of like a bad thing.
- 3:15And Christmas is just like the thin edge of the sphere, and this
- 3:17kind of stuff. But you know, I think that that's a kind of
- 3:21minority opinion, and I do think that some of that language has just kind
- 3:23of sort of permeated into sort of like broader right of center discourse where it's
- 3:27just something, you know, it's just one more thing to complain about the
- 3:30sort of wokeification of modern Canada, the fact that you're not seeing, you
- 3:32know, Christmas decorations, you're seeing holiday decorations and that kind of stuff.
- 3:37Okay, so let's go down that rabbit hole then for people who are woke.
- 3:42You know, we're using that term very broadly because I don't like that
- 3:44term either. Yeah, but perhaps be able to push back on Christmas a
- 3:46little bit. Is there anything that is inherently discriminatory about Christmas as we know
- 3:53it? Don't? I don't think so that much these days, just because
- 3:57it really does. And I feel like I'm not making a revelatory statement here
- 4:00that so much of the sort of like the explicitly Christian dimension of Christmas has
- 4:03been extracted over the decades. Right, Like, maybe once in a while
- 4:08you'll see, like, you know, this city council has a Nativity scene
- 4:11on public property, and that sort of scene is somewhat shocking. And I
- 4:14guess like you can accept that that. Okay, maybe that is a step
- 4:16too far or in sort of principles of freedom of religion and that kind of
- 4:20thing. But like, by and large, I think that when we look
- 4:23at like, you know, Christmas decorations, Christmas shirts, there's nothing about
- 4:26it. We don't even say it like christ Mass, we said Christmas.
- 4:29It's been so heavily secularized into something distinct. But what you're describing is really
- 4:32a problem that people who celebrate Christmas on a religious basis have with people who
- 4:38celebrate Christmas on a cultural basis, right, Because even when you say holiday,
- 4:42you know, happy holidays or seasons greetings, I mean that is still
- 4:46somewhat celebrating Christmas, but perhaps more culturally than religiously. Yeah, and like
- 4:49that's a good point, right, And I feel like that that is a
- 4:51criticism that perhaps maybe some of the Christian political identity politics Christians can maybe take
- 4:59to mind a little bit, is that in some ways the bigger issue is
- 5:01not the war on Christmas per se, because no one is clearly Christmas is
- 5:04a huge commercial holiday, like no one's getting rid of Christmas, right,
- 5:08But the bigger problem from a sort of Christian perspective is the idea that Christmas
- 5:11has been so thoroughly like secularized, that it's like, you know, the
- 5:15true reason for the season has been forgotten and all that kind of stuff.
- 5:17Right, So I think that, you know, maybe if some of the
- 5:18Christians kind of want to guilt us more for just kind of like taking the
- 5:23cheap material side of Christmas and then sort of forgetting you know, what the
- 5:27roots of it are and that kind of thing. Isn't this the nature of
- 5:30a multi cultural society, where holidays or cultural touchstones may evolve over time as
- 5:35the face of society changes. Like you know, I'm thinking about Chinese New
- 5:40Year or Diwali. You know a lot of people that don't belong to those
- 5:43ancestral groups still celebrate it, but it's not seen as like watering down the
- 5:47occasion, right, Yeah, yeah, no, And I agree, And
- 5:49so I have no problem with modern secular Christmas. I think it's a kind
- 5:53of like foulk holiday in the way that folk holidays often emerge, right,
- 5:57Like we think of a holiday like Halloween, you know, and it's just
- 5:59kind of like weird amalgamation of a bunch of different traditions from different you know,
- 6:02parts of Britain and all that that kind of came to the New World
- 6:04and became its new thing, and now we all love Halloween. And I
- 6:08think that, you know, as much as I don't want to offend the
- 6:10Christians by saying this, I think that, you know, the Christmas that
- 6:13we practice today is contrasted to the Christmas practice in previous centries. It is
- 6:15a distinct holiday, but it's a good holiday, and it's sort of a
- 6:18tribute to the sort of the modern Western secular culture that has arisen over the
- 6:23years. And I think we should be proud of that, and I think
- 6:25we should defend it. It's worth defending on its own merits. And it's
- 6:28not a deformation of something more pure and more you know, correct, It's
- 6:31just something different, and I think the difference is worth celebrating in a society
- 6:36that is trying to be more inclusive accessible. Why is it so bad to
- 6:41say happy holidays or season greetings, Because, to be honest, I don't
- 6:45really think about it. I say Merry Christmas all the time, but I'm
- 6:46sure I let out a happy Holidays, and I've never had anyone directly offended
- 6:50as a result. So what is so wrong or is there anything wrong with
- 6:55using those those terms? I would say probably not, just because it reads
- 7:00the same way, right, Like even if even if you're not explicitly saying
- 7:03it, we all know what you're actually saying, So it more just kind
- 7:06of feels like a diversification of vocabulary as opposed to like a conscious kind of
- 7:12censorship. I mean there are, though, I will say, in defense
- 7:15of this, there are circumstances in which using holiday is so awkward that it
- 7:18becomes kind of virtue signally, Like I thought, I saw a thing at
- 7:21the mall the other day where it was like countdown until Holiday, only twelve
- 7:26shopping days left, and it's like, when you're making it that convoluted,
- 7:29it's like, come on, you know, they just wanted to spend money.
- 7:31Jay, JJ A pleasure as always, Thanks so much for your contributions
- 7:36throughout this year, and I look forward to seeing a lot more of you
- 7:40in twenty twenty four. I as well, Thanks mom, folks. If
- 7:43you haven't already, find him on YouTube to learn more about countries, cultures,
- 7:47and Canada in a fun, accessible way. He's JJ McCullough. Now
- 7:51after some business, when we think about all the big newsmakers over the last
- 7:56year, who would make the cut for your nice list and who would you
- 7:59put on on the naughty list? Tamara Taggart and Kyla Lee will be here
- 8:03to share their list with you. Up next