Latest / The Sticky From The Inside Podcast / Hospitality's Leadership Crisis: Building From Within
Transcript
- 0:10Hello and welcome to Sticky from the Inside, the employee engagement podcast that looks at how to build stickier, competition-smashing, consistently successful organisations from the inside out.
- 0:22I'm your host Andy Goram and I'm on a mission to help more businesses turn the lights on behind the eyes of their employees, light the fires within them and create tonnes more success for everyone.
- 0:39This podcast is for all those who believe that's something worth going after and would like a little help and guidance in achieving that.
- 0:46Each episode we dive into the topics that can help create what I call stickier businesses, the sort of businesses where people thrive and love to work and where more customers stay with you and recommend you to others because they love what you do and why you do it.
- 1:03So if you want to take the tricky out of being sticky, listen on.
- 1:10Okay then, I think hospitality as an industry is in crisis, globally.
- 1:17Not the kind of crisis where people aren't eating out or travelling because they are, no matter how hard this or any other government in a country tries to make it harder.
- 1:31But I think it's a leadership crisis, particularly in this country.
- 1:35In this country, in the UK, Brexit ripped a hole in the recruitment and management pool.
- 1:43COVID-19 shut down the industry and we saw a mass exodus of experienced middle managers leaving and leaving behind skill gaps, knowledge gaps and a whole lot of businesses scrambling still to find their footing today.
- 1:59And now, in the UK, the National Insurance Threshold increase, due in April, is adding greater costs to business and making some businesses question the policy of recruiting younger, less experienced people into their business.
- 2:14But while some of the symptoms may be unique to the UK in domain, the hospitality industry in many other places around the world is facing similar issues.
- 2:24So what's the solution?
- 2:26Many businesses have pulled in managers from other industries to bring fresh perspectives and ideas.
- 2:33But without deep hospitality knowledge, that could also bring its own set of problems.
- 2:38Meanwhile, younger, ambitious, eager employees who are full of potential stepping into the industry are often frustrated by low wages, long hours and a lack of clear career progression.
- 2:51They want to grow fast, but are they getting the right support?
- 2:55So today, we're tackling this big question.
- 2:58How do we stop treating hospitality as just a job and start building it as a career?
- 3:04And more importantly, how do we develop leaders from within so the industry doesn't just survive but thrives going forwards?
- 3:11To help us explore this, I'm joined by someone who knows this world inside out, Michelle Pascoe.
- 3:18Michelle is a hospitality specialist and team and customer retention expert and a fierce advocate for leadership development in an industry that desperately needs it.
- 3:28Based in Australia, and growing up on a turkey farm, her journey has taken her from being educated in a one room Bush School to building one of Australia's most respected training and research businesses.
- 3:40She's spent decades working with hospitality businesses to build stronger teams, create better customer experiences, and most importantly, develop the kind of leaders who stick around and make a real impact.
- 3:53So who better to have with me than discuss all of this stuff that's going on?
- 3:58Michelle, welcome to the show.
- 4:00Thank you so much, Andy.
- 4:01I'm really going to enjoy our conversation.
- 4:03We've had a few in the past few months.
- 4:09And I can hopefully share some insights with your wonderful audience and listeners.
- 4:13Oh, well, I know you will be able to.
- 4:15You've said we've spoken before we this is maybe our third conversation in about as many months, which is which is just lovely.
- 4:22And I mentioned very briefly your background, Michelle, which it mean that is a whole podcast in itself.
- 4:28And can you just share a little bit of background with where you've come from what you get up to and what you're focused on today?
- 4:36Yeah, happy to.
- 4:38So my background, yes, you know, growing up on a turkey farm, I've got very strong roots with the Scottish grandparents.
- 4:46And, you know, this hard work ethic of growing up on a farm, and then, you know, being told by a vocational guidance at school, oh, you're not smart enough to go to university.
- 4:57So you think to yourself, well, what can I do?
- 5:00And, you know, I went into secretarial college started in the hospitality industry back then, but not outpouring beers or serving plates, hardly can do that.
- 5:12But more of the typing in the background and building the brands through the customer service and, and that connection.
- 5:19And then rightly so, you know, over a number of years of experience, starting my own company back in 1994, and then quickly getting into the hospitality industry.
- 5:28I love the people that I work with.
- 5:31I predominantly work with the registered club industry here in Australia.
- 5:35So I know it's very different to what you had there in the UK.
- 5:39But if you look at some of your private clubs, or if any of your listeners have been to America, and you've gone to a Native American casino, is that sort of size of club, they're usually connected to our rugby league groups, or our return service league.
- 5:56So the men who particularly came back from our World War Two, they started these clubs, and they've grown and they support our community strongly.
- 6:06But as we're going to discuss today, we've got a lot of all at this point in time, we have four generations in the workplace, and six generations of customers that are coming into the hospitality, whether it's serving a coffee at your local cafe, or serving a beautiful fine dining experience.
- 6:24I think that's going to definitely form part of this conversation today.
- 6:29Because I've in the intro talked about a lot of our lived experience here in the UK with a lot of stuff going on.
- 6:35I mean, that itself could almost feel like a crisis.
- 6:38But we're sort of really trying to focus on the, well, I've positioned it as a sort of leadership crisis, you started to bring in stuff around generations and what have you, this whole topic of trying to sort of like build strength from within.
- 6:51Now, that's not just a UK thing, right?
- 6:53You must see this in a lot of your work today.
- 6:56Oh, look, definitely.
- 6:57You know, it's quite, when I say it's funny, it's, you know, over the last 30 years, I'm sure I've looked a lot older.
- 7:04But you know, I go in and I see the CEOs, I'm thinking, geez, you're looking a bit old.
- 7:08I'm thinking, I'm probably looking the same.
- 7:10And the fact is, you know, I've seen them grow up from young boys.
- 7:14And, you know, I have been very fortunate, Andy, that some of those young, you know, guys and girls, you know, who I trained all those years ago, have taken me on their personal journey, you know, going from cleaning ashtrays and sharpening the Kino pencils, you know, and the bingo blotters, right through to now being CEOs.
- 7:32But they're also at that point in their lives, you know, I've seen them, you know, get married, have children, and now moving on to grandchildren, that they're starting to look at retirement.
- 7:42And I, you know, we're talking about the generational leadership crisis we have now, you know, with the younger ones coming in, because of that middle management that we've lost so many during COVID.
- 7:53But my real concern, apart from that, is we're going to learn, we're going to lose a lot of that real top heavy end, definitely in the next five, certainly in the next 10 years of those retiring.
- 8:08And it's that institutional knowledge that they'll be going away with.
- 8:11And that's where I see this, this, we need to bridge this gap between those that have been in the industry, hospitality industry for a long time, have sharing that information to a really good, strong, middle management team now, because they'll be quickly into that role of CEO.
- 8:28And then it will be, you know, drip feeding all the way through.
- 8:31So you know, that that to me is a big concern, because I said, you know, I look at them and they'll say to me, Oh, Michelle, you're looking forward to retirement.
- 8:37I'm thinking, Oh, my goodness, who's the next one who's going to be taking your place?
- 8:42You know, I think we've got this thing of trying to balance the need for the experience, the experience leadership with the reality of the talent shortages we've probably got within within hospitality.
- 8:58So let's dig into that a little bit more.
- 9:01You started to talk about this kind of middle manager group often refer to those as the frozen middle, when I talk to people, because bless them, these are the guys who are trying to interpret the stuff that's coming down from on high.
- 9:13And then they're trying to get the guys on the floor to actually do stuff.
- 9:17And often, they are the guys just sort of trapped in the middle, sometimes overlooked, sometimes jumped over.
- 9:23But we've seen quite a few of them opt out of the industry.
- 9:27Over here.
- 9:28What do you see as the biggest consequences that we've got of losing that, that middle management band or weakening it perhaps over the last few years?
- 9:35Yes.
- 9:36And I think, you know, we just like yourselves there in the UK during COVID, hospitality was the first to shut.
- 9:43And the last to close, you know, in Victoria, which is one of our big hospitality states here in Australia, they closed and opened 10 times in 18 months, it was just terrific.
- 9:56So with that opening and closing, you can't blame middle managers.
- 9:59Because if you if you look at a generational thing, and this is
- 10:03just a generalisation here, but for many of them, they're now at that point in time, they're in that mid to late 30s, they're perhaps, you
- 10:10know, got a mortgage, maybe having a child, and suddenly think that, you know what, I don't know whether this hospitality industry is
- 10:17going to reopen, I really need to get into something that's a solid background, go into finance, go into government department, go into
- 10:25insurance, all those sort of safe, secure entities, you know, and health was another area.
- 10:31By losing them, we lost this beautiful group that had been trained and was starting to be nurtured, and was starting to be seen as you're going to be my next person who I'm going to tap on the shoulder of the CEO, to them, but they went.
- 10:48And so what we then started to see was this panic, in a, you know, inverted commas, because people started to think that, well, okay, who are we going to get to start leading our team?
- 10:59So I started, you know, I called them the green teams, because we were hiring people.
- 11:04And within six weeks, they were now made a supervisor.
- 11:07Yeah.
- 11:07And so that was trying to learn the ropes of being in the hospitality industry.
- 11:11Well, you know, they had that little bit of initiative.
- 11:13So well, they're pretty good.
- 11:14So let's, let's move them up.
- 11:16But what we then started to find out was that burnout, because they moved up so quickly, that they didn't have that good, solid foundation of skill set, and that ability to make those mistakes and learn from them.
- 11:30Instead, it was making mistakes and learning, but also being seen by, you know, younger ones or newer people coming in that they were also trying to train.
- 11:39So, you know, it hasn't been easy for this group at all that are coming into this middle management group in the last few years, you know, some have taken it on really well, but others that just said, well, this is either too much, or they're just bunkered down into the doing instead of the showing.
- 11:56I think that's right.
- 11:57And there's a knock on effect to this as well.
- 11:59Because look, we all, whether we're doing it consciously or not, we all end up looking up to our own managers and leaders and mostly following the example that they set, unless we wake up and do something different or better.
- 12:15But if you're experiencing that kind of migration of people, inconsistency of management and leadership, are we at risk of losing the next generation of leaders before they even get going, looking at what they're experiencing, let alone the environment that in the main, the hospitality industry can give out?
- 12:38Look, I think we've shot ourselves in the foot, to be honest, for about the last hundred and something years, because, oh, yeah, hospitality, oh, it's hard work, it's long hours, I'm in the kitchen, I'm being screamed at.
- 12:53And it's always been this, I don't know, it's like this badge of honour of, oh, it's a hard job, you know, I have no personal life.
- 13:02And so instead of going out and saying, gee, this is great, this industry, you know, I get the opportunity to learn from the best in that kitchen.
- 13:10And I get to meet all these different, but we've never talked it up.
- 13:13And that's probably the biggest thing we've been seeing since COVID here, particularly in the register club industry, talk about the positive things we do, talk about how we connect with the community, because that's how you're going to connect with the Gen Zs in particular.
- 13:27And of course, our Alphas that will be coming through in the next four years, because they're very community minded.
- 13:32It's not just about work and a dollar, it's about work, community, and of course, we all need money.
- 13:38But to me, it's we've got to be thinking more positive.
- 13:42And I think, you know, we've, we've done too much of, oh, it's a hard job to have Andy, but working in the hospitality industry, instead of flipping it and going, yes, it is hard, but you can have a lot of fun.
- 13:53And that's where I think we've lost this, this this group, because people now go, well, do you really want to work in that industry that has always been negative?
- 14:01It's always been hard?
- 14:04Well, who's gonna vote for that?
- 14:07Who's gonna vote?
- 14:12Just not gonna, I have to say, there's a couple of things in all of this, you know, I'm a, I'm a passionate hospitality guy, you know, I cut my teeth in that in that industry, you know, linked to hospitality, my first job was in a bakery, and getting my backside kicked around a very small kitchen by some, some incredibly dedicated, brilliantly talented, older females.
- 14:35And I learned work ethic, I learned joy at work, I learned new skills, I learned teamwork, I learned so much.
- 14:45And all the weird things that we do wear as a badge of honour, like long hours and unsociable hours, I actually enjoyed, I loved that I voted for that maybe I'm, maybe I'm a bit weird, you know, but when I worked in America in hotels and stuff, you know, I had those kind of like finish at midnight shifts, occasionally.
- 15:05But then my social life took on a whole different time of day.
- 15:08And it was a very, very different world is fantastic.
- 15:11In here in this country, you know, UK hospitality, are trying to work on something called hospitality rising, which is trying to create this positive image of hospitality, which is great, right?
- 15:24But I'm not quite sure a flashy ad is going to convince somebody that hospitality is the thing, we're only as strong as the weakest operators out there.
- 15:33And so I think we have a big job to do with with hospitality, and this this badge of honour that you're so right, that we sort of wear to sort of say, yeah, yeah, yeah, it's really, really tough.
- 15:44I mean, why would you engage with that?
- 15:45I don't understand it.
- 15:47Yes, yes.
- 15:48So let's get out there.
- 15:49Let's be positive.
- 15:50But you know, this is not wearing the rose tinted glasses either.
- 15:53I mean, yes, we are doing the midnight, you know, shifts on the 3am.
- 15:59And you know, somebody does have to clean up, you know, some other person's left in the bathroom, or, you know, they had to separate people that are getting a little bit hot under the collar, or, you know, you're going to have that meal sent back because they don't like it, because they believe you haven't cooked it the right way.
- 16:14That's just humans.
- 16:16We have, you know, it's just the way people get agitated.
- 16:20Not everybody's polite.
- 16:22However, there are so many positive things.
- 16:25And to me, it's looking at those, it's those sharing the stories.
- 16:28I think that is the biggest thing.
- 16:29You know, I started with a new leadership program on Monday with this fantastic team of 16 of them, and, you know, a variety of ages.
- 16:38And some of them have been in this venue for 25 years.
- 16:41And I said, "Yeah, it's the stories, I could come in here and just give you the six points of blah, blah, blah."
- 16:46But I said, "Share the stories."
- 16:48And it's the stories and the impact that we have as leaders that make a difference.
- 16:54And there was one lady in there.
- 16:55And she said, "When I started here 20 years ago," and tears started to form in her eyes, she looked across the table, and she said, "that lady there, she at the end of every shift, came up and said, thank you to every one of us."
- 17:11And she goes, "I remember that she would stand at the door, and she would say, thank you."
- 17:15And the young one said, "Oh, my goodness, we can picture her in that, in that at that door."
- 17:21And I think that's the biggest impact.
- 17:23That's how we connect with people, we can go in, and we can say, this is the way you've got to do it.
- 17:29Yes.
- 17:29And as you said, Andy, your butt was kicked.
- 17:31But it was kicked for a reason to show you like, you can't go do the whole six steps at once.
- 17:39There's got to be a certain I think that's what we're seeing a lot of this pushback where, you know, some people are going all these young ones, they want everything straight away.
- 17:47Well, they do, they're not going to wait the 10 year tenure.
- 17:50And I don't think they should.
- 17:51Why should they wait 10 years to get the next roll up, just because although the next in line, instead of going, you're showing initiative, do that.
- 18:00But it's getting them and showing them and that story of, yes, you could do that.
- 18:07But this is what could happen if you do it, because that's, that's the pushback we're getting, you know, young ones to go, Oh, yeah, but I think you could do it this way, that way.
- 18:15And the CAO goes, yes, we could.
- 18:17But if we did that, let's just keep going along that line.
- 18:22And where would it end up?
- 18:23And you've literally got to take them on their own path, you know, on a little bit of paper and having a conversation there.
- 18:29Oh, yes, I see what you mean.
- 18:31It's not going to work out.
- 18:32But they've got to work through that themselves, instead of just going, that doesn't work, have a conversation, say, okay, let's look at that way.
- 18:40And where will we end?
- 18:43And is it going to be the best thing for the business and yourself and the crew, whatever it might be?
- 18:47So, yeah, absolutely.
- 18:49I also think when it comes to this generational thing, if we're honest with ourselves, and I put myself in the slightly older bracket, right, I'm an Xer, is that I reckon there's a certain amount of jealousy from some of the older generations.
- 19:05But when we see the younger generations, either not doing something or asking questions or wanting to understand why I've got to do something, or choosing to do something differently, I think there's a little bit of disgruntlement.
- 19:18Occasionally, from the older generation say, well, hang on, we had to do this, we were told to do this.
- 19:24But I think the kind of resentment or the jealousy or whatever the word really is, is that we go, yeah, blimey, I wish I'd kind of pushed back, back in the day, maybe, or been braver to offer my opinion, or, or maybe look at it a different way.
- 19:39And there's less stigma for that for some of these younger generations.
- 19:42And maybe there's a bit of, you know, argy bargy going on there.
- 19:47I agree.
- 19:48And you've got to think about with those, like you were saying, Gen X, you were taught by people that were pre veterans.
- 19:54So you've got to think about what each generation, how they're being, you know, brought through the actual, you know, their first job.
- 20:03And so when we look at the young ones, I agree, they are asking questions.
- 20:09But let's put it this way, I think we had an opportunity as Gen X and baby boomers, to come from a generation where people had to have used their initiative.
- 20:21Even if they weren't working on a farm, they weren't able to go to the shop and buy that new cord or buy that new something you had to use that I remember, you know, my father, because my parents were a lot older, and I had three much older brothers.
- 20:34But I know my father said, well, you know, if the car broke down, you could use a pair of women's stockings to, you know, for the fan belt.
- 20:40And he showed me how to change the fuse in a fuse box, and change tires of cars and things like that.
- 20:47Because and we just knew that because that was the generation that they come from, like my father, come up during the depression, that you had to do things.
- 20:55So when we got the young ones asking questions, and this is the same as my own children and grandchildren, it's because they haven't had that opportunity to learn how to use a stocking as a fan belt.
- 21:06I know your audience is probably thinking what am I talking about?
- 21:08But they don't have that natural initiative, or that intuition to say, "Ah, yes, I know how we could fix this."
- 21:20So we've got to help them.
- 21:22Don't you think?
- 21:23I think so.
- 21:24But yeah, I think so.
- 21:27But I think there's also the fact that a lot of their world has been they've been brought up with everything being on demand or get it get access to, and certainly getting access to answers to things.
- 21:36You know, the day that I got my first set of encyclopedias, they were out of date.
- 21:41You know, researching bits and pieces for school, you know, you get a book, no, that's out of date.
- 21:46There's only so much you can fit in there.
- 21:47But today, they can get hold of an answer anything, you know, I could be in a, in a facilitation talking about a topic or a concept or a model, I'll get fact checked in the room on someone's phone, because they can find the answer.
- 22:02So if they can find the answers to anything that they like, and they're in a business, and they ask questions, and they don't get the answers, well, why is that you don't you not trust me did what's going on, there's a relationship problem here.
- 22:13There's all sorts of things that can frame, I think, a broader perspective on on things, you know, and I think this is where the generational bit has to come from it is both sides of the spectrum, whatever generation you're sitting in, I think open mindedness and looking at different perspectives can only help us get better.
- 22:31I think what's really interesting from the generational stuff, is we're seeing bigger gaps, I think, in the, in the millennials, and in the Gen Zs, that we've ever had before within the generational cohorts, the change the nuance between the two, mainly made driven by environment and technology, perhaps, I don't know, but that's going to have an impact on how we set people up for success, how we take them through, through growth inside a business, whether they're open for
- 23:01that growth inside a business, all those sorts of things.
- 23:04Very, very much so.
- 23:05And, you know, as you rightly said, those millennials, those Gen Ys are now in their early 40s.
- 23:10And for many of those, they are certainly in that middle management category.
- 23:15They're the parents of our alphas.
- 23:17And those little beaters are also as well.
- 23:20So you know, they're, they're looking at a world where they ask those questions about why, and a lot of those sacred cows were removed.
- 23:27But once again, they're now at a level where they are taking on these roles.
- 23:34And they've got in the back of the mind how they were taught in their early years of hospitality, but also realising through Gen Z, who, you know, for many years, their Gen Z, particularly if you look at research in the USA, they were actually leapfrogging Gen Y in hospitality, because some of them or many of them were happy
- 23:57to actually stand beside a chef, if you look at research in a back of house, to soak up the knowledge, weren't getting paid, but they wanted to soak up that knowledge.
- 24:09And we see that time and time again with Gen Z, that they may be for many of them highly educated, but they don't have that knowledge.
- 24:18And they're seeking that desperately.
- 24:20So they're soaking it up like a sponge.
- 24:22So we look at that Gen Y now that are leading this group, who with Gen Z, that they have that ability, but they just don't have that wisdom and knowledge.
- 24:33So how do Gen, well the Millennials, Gen Y show that to them, when they're trying to now be the leaders?
- 24:41So it's not easy for any of them.
- 24:43And I think that's where it comes at, these conversations.
- 24:46It's having these conversations, it's letting people know where you are on this journey.
- 24:51And it's not just putting people in generational brackets that, you know, they can't hold a certain position because they're not a certain age.
- 25:01Yeah, I think this is what's really interesting.
- 25:03Because if we link what we just talked about from generations, and we think about this sort of tough job of being in the middle.
- 25:11Maybe, maybe this is why some of the internal leadership pipelines are a bit broken or fractured.
- 25:18Because we've got we've got lots of things going on all over the place.
- 25:22From your perspective.
- 25:23And I mean, I know you do a lot of work in this area.
- 25:26So I expect we're going to hit another common viewpoint here.
- 25:32But I'm going to ask the question anyway.
- 25:34But in the hospitality industry, globally, let's let's put it in that in that perspective.
- 25:40What do you think is preventing us from developing stronger leaders from within today?
- 25:47Is it a combination of the things we've talked about?
- 25:50Is it is it something else that's that's going on?
- 25:52What do you see?
- 25:53Are we have we not got the right focus on the right skills when it comes to sort of development for leadership in hospitality?
- 26:00It's hard to it's really hard to say.
- 26:03But I think it is a combination of what we've already mentioned.
- 26:08But I think it's it's, we have to change our mindset, Andy, that nobody wants to work every weekend, or every public holiday, or Sunday for for additional money.
- 26:18It's not about that.
- 26:20It is about having this balance in their lives.
- 26:23And you can't blame them.
- 26:25And I think that's where we do have the older generations, rather than envious and jealous, because, well, maybe we should have stepped up.
- 26:33But how do we how do we develop these leaders that they feel confident in a world that is changing so fast?
- 26:41You know, I was on a webinar last Saturday, and it was for three hours just about AI.
- 26:49And you know, AI is now 70 years old globally, you know, a lot of people think it's just happened the last few years with chat GPT.
- 26:55But the rapid change that is happening in a workplace And I think, you know, for some of these, you know, Gen Z's, they may be thinking to themselves, well, how is technology going to impact and particularly AI going to impact on the hospitality industry?
- 27:12We will use it, and we need it.
- 27:15And there's lots of roles that we can have, but we will never lose that human connection in hospitality, we will always be seeking that, because people need each other.
- 27:25So when we look at those roles, as managers coming to those managers roles, to me, it is, we can use the resources of technology, we can utilise the knowledge of the younger ones coming through that, you know, technology is just wired into them.
- 27:42But we've also got to show them that skill of, well, how do we have those conversations with people?
- 27:47How do we connect?
- 27:48And I think that's where we can marry beautifully, the multiple generations and the leadership styles, because there is that technology and the AI and the resources and the processes and the systems marrying beautifully with, well, how do we talk to somebody?
- 28:05How do we make that connection?
- 28:08Because a lot of them, it's very easy just to text and not pick up the phone and talk or have that meeting with someone.
- 28:15And I think that's where we need to really focus in the hospitality.
- 28:19It's all about being hospitable, isn't it, Andy?
- 28:22That's the whole point.
- 28:23And hospitality and being hospitable is talking to somebody, not just texting them or sending them an email.
- 28:30It's actually getting in there, standing at the end of the table, talking to them about the projects, asking them about how their day is.
- 28:38And yes, you may have heard that it's rained 100 times today, but you still go, oh, my gosh, that is so interesting.
- 28:45You've got, you know, you've got to put your heart in it.
- 28:47And I think the people that hospitality attract, and I know, you know, I think we've mentioned this before, Andy, that we've got a lot more people in our industry now that, and I know, that leaders would not have looked at before COVID.
- 29:04And it's not saying that they were scraping at the bottom of the barrel.
- 29:07That's not at all.
- 29:08But they're looking at people that see things differently, that may process things differently, that have a beautiful smile, they love to have a chat, or they're really good at just one or two particular things.
- 29:21And it's this blend of people in hospitality.
- 29:24And, and to me, that's where we'll see the growth in our industry.
- 29:28Because through our leadership, it's acknowledging that we're different, but it's connecting.
- 29:34And it's that feeling of belonging.
- 29:36But it's everybody on the journey, but they've got to know what that vision and that journey is.
- 29:41I think so.
- 29:43And I actually, I love the fact that you keep talking about connection, because I think that's the difference between service and experience.
- 29:50And I think we are far more focused on experience today.
- 29:55And the difference is, is connection, you know, you can pick out great hospitality experiences, I suspect most of them aren't about the amazing process that happened behind the scenes.
- 30:06I don't think I've ever gone home after an experience in hospitality.
- 30:10And then waxed lyrical about the process behind it.
- 30:14Although I'm a geek, so there's every chance I might have done to somebody.
- 30:17But in the main, it's going to be about human interaction that I've had with somebody, it's going to be about somebody who for 30 seconds, I felt that they put like a spotlight on me, and that I was all that mattered to them for a minute.
- 30:31I think that's what we're looking for.
- 30:33I sometimes think that's what newer people into the industry, like this, like you say, of a slightly different perspective, sometimes struggle with.
- 30:43And they want to go through, you know, the process bit, but we've got to make the human connection is it most of the time in hospitality, it's an exchange of two humans or a group of humans, right?
- 30:54So we've got to do that.
- 30:55And which is why I think that the bit I want to sort of make sure we do discuss today is this challenge of maybe having to reframe or rethink about our career development paths that we take nowadays, because the old sort of like step one, step two, step three process stuff, I don't think that's valid anymore.
- 31:17And actually, I think we need to maybe start introducing the whole concept of teamwork and leadership a lot earlier into people's time with us.
- 31:28So, you know, yes, combining the steps of service, but really trying to get under the skin of these human skills that we need to.
- 31:36What's your thought on that?
- 31:37Because I know you do a lot of learning and development and program work.
- 31:40So what's the future look like for you?
- 31:43I agree.
- 31:44I think it's showing them that there's a pathway.
- 31:48I think we've got to stop this conversation or have more conversations, but it's not just a stopgap job in hospitality.
- 31:57You know, I think there's always been this perception that it's, you know, it's your job while you're going through uni or you're doing your apprenticeship or you're saving for a car or your overseas trip or your gap year or whatever it might be, instead of, you know, and I think this is where we really need to step up really quickly and be saying to them, you know, whatever your role is, you're doing it really well.
- 32:19I just want to have this conversation with you because you may be just doing this as a job now to, you know, as a second job or whatever.
- 32:26But I want to show you, are you aware of the different paths there are in hospitality?
- 32:31I think people know.
- 32:33Like I've had chefs on my podcast, Andy, that have gone from being these chefs and like back house cooks, you know, when they were 14, 15, and they're now traveling around the world, they're judges in food competitions or the, you know, they're with winemakers.
- 32:47And there's so many different things that people can do.
- 32:50But I don't think people know how expansive our industry is.
- 32:56There is, you could be on a, you know, working in a resort, you could be with, you know, a restaurant, you could be in a small cafe.
- 33:04I've had people that have worked and they build sustainable furniture for restaurants by using different products from old restaurants.
- 33:12And people just don't realize how wonderful this industry is.
- 33:17But if we don't get in there and tell them, then they're never going to know.
- 33:20They're just going to be there for the couple of years for the pay the car off, had their holiday, got through uni and off they go.
- 33:26But if we start to show them, which is lovely, and I've always, I'd rather have two good years out of somebody than somebody stuck on oxygen for 20 years and you think, gee, why wouldn't they leave?
- 33:36But that's a whole other conversation.
- 33:38But I think we just need to show them because they don't know.
- 33:41They honestly don't know where hospitality could take them.
- 33:46You know yourself, Andy, if you can pour a beer and the biggest thing for Australians, I know when I came to the UK in 1982 and I was very young, it was like everybody loved Aussies because you could get a job in a bar and then you get a feed and you'd have accommodation and it was great.
- 34:04And that's the same thing.
- 34:05If you can pour a good beer, you can work anywhere.
- 34:08If you can carry a couple of plates, hold a decent conversation, turn up clean, people will love you in hospitality.
- 34:16There's so much more.
- 34:17There is so much more.
- 34:18And there are those that will just continue travelling the world and loving hospitality and they can go wherever they want to because we all need to eat no matter where we are.
- 34:29It's definitely a lot of that.
- 34:31I mean, I think that whole breadth of opportunity within our industry is huge and really quite possibly underplayed and not even understood.
- 34:40So I think there's definitely that side of it.
- 34:42I think in terms of the leadership capability, because we started this conversation talking about the gaps that are being left behind by some of the generational migration, behind that sort of like the different, I guess, approaches or mindsets or expectations of people coming through.
- 34:58We've talked about the skill gaps being left behind, not just the number of people, but the real skill gap and that kind of deep hospitality knowledge.
- 35:06And we're looking for people who get hospitality, want hospitality and understand what it takes to lead people and very often get people who are maybe less motivated than we'd like them to be to get stuff done.
- 35:23And so when we think about that, do you think there's an opportunity to integrate some of these leadership skills far earlier into hospitality training as well as combine the perspective of breadth and opportunity?
- 35:38Yeah, I definitely do.
- 35:40Now, I'll give you an example.
- 35:42I said I'm working with this new leadership team.
- 35:44You know, we've only just started like five days ago.
- 35:46Very different to any other venue that I've worked with in three decades.
- 35:51And why that is, is because the leadership team also do frontline work.
- 35:57So they may be a duty manager, a supervisor for half of their shift, maybe for four hours, and then they go into the role of being a frontline person and pouring beers.
- 36:11And so what, and at first I thought, my goodness, my head would be going all around the place.
- 36:16But they said it's great because whoever that duty manager is on the day, they know when those other managers and supervisors are in that frontline role, they don't have to be going over there and micromanaging them.
- 36:32They know that it's going to work really well.
- 36:35But they also, that person who's in that frontline, who's also a manager, respect that role of the duty manager and know the work that they have to do.
- 36:44So as I said, it's very unusual, but it's this beautiful combination that works.
- 36:49And it's some of them, as I said, have been there for nearly 20 years on this same way that they're doing things.
- 36:54I think it's very interesting.
- 36:56So it lessens that us and them, but it also connects them as leaders with actually working side by side with their frontline team.
- 37:08So the frontline teams are seeing them not micromanaging them, but working alongside them.
- 37:16So it's that to me, particularly for Gen Z, it's this real unusual connection of we're doing this together, we're growing together, we're managing, we're leading.
- 37:26And you can be in this role now, and you can be in a leadership role tomorrow in a very short space of time.
- 37:36I think that is interesting.
- 37:38That is interesting, because maybe traditionally, when we're dealing with that employee manager piece, there's a danger sometimes that if you are always jumping in to sort of like, roll your sleeves up and do the work, you become the default for that.
- 37:58So the employees kind of like don't do what they need to do, because well, they'll pop in, they'll sort it out, they'll roll the sleeves up.
- 38:06But when you talk to people, they're like, I don't know, it's a good thing, right, me jumping in, that shows I'm one of the team.
- 38:12Great.
- 38:12When this works, and when you can actually separate the things you need to do from a management leadership perspective, and be there and support and role model, all the other great stuff, fantastic.
- 38:22It's where people struggle blurring the lines between the two, and then don't do the management leadership stuff.
- 38:28So it's really interesting to sort of see it is really working.
- 38:30So there must be some clear understanding and some great framework behind that to make that work.
- 38:35Yeah, and it's very clear on the roster.
- 38:38You did this for four hours, and you did that for four hours, you know, so to speak.
- 38:42So it's very, very clear understanding of what their roles are.
- 38:47So yeah, look, I'm sure we'll have further conversations, but this is just my first week with them.
- 38:54And look, I was honest, because a young chap said to me, have you seen this anywhere else, Michelle?
- 38:59And I said, no, I haven't.
- 39:01And I'm not saying that it's wrong.
- 39:03I'm just going to, I'm going to really be fascinated in seeing how you work as this team, going from that role of leadership, and then to that role of being your peers.
- 39:14But as I said, some of them have been doing it for many, many years, and it works very, very well.
- 39:18So I thought, once again, Andy, this is just showing you, they've got, you know, it's a CEO who came in, who introduced us to a young team, you know, you know, he'd be a, I'd say he'd have to be a Gen Y, you know, that customer.
- 39:32So he's brought in this idea, and I'm thinking, that's a challenge to what we've done in the past in hospitality.
- 39:39That's what we need to look for, don't we, Andy?
- 39:41Those people that will challenge those sacred cows, well, this is always the way we've done it.
- 39:47And let's have a go and see if it works.
- 39:50Now, it may not work for everybody.
- 39:51But I think in anything in life, you've got to give it a go.
- 39:55Absolutely.
- 39:56I think we have to.
- 39:57I think that would be a really interesting thing to sort of see how that plays out, and whether that would clearly, clearly, it's going to be a different way of doing things.
- 40:05And last sort of thing I just want to cover before we think about summarising up.
- 40:11You mentioned the younger generations wanted to progress more quickly, or at least quickly, shall we say, in their careers and sort of be seen to move on.
- 40:24And be seen to take the next sort of role.
- 40:27How do you think hospitality can balance this kind of the need for experience and skill growth, but still get this sense of opportunity and opportunity for quick progression, maybe?
- 40:40Yes, yeah.
- 40:41And I think it comes down to that support of the senior leadership team, you know, as they're sharing their journey, but giving them opportunities to learn, shadow them.
- 40:51So, you know, be happy that, you know, they may be doing this role today, but it may be that the owner or a senior leader says, look, I'm going down into the cellar.
- 41:00Let's just use that as an example.
- 41:02You know, it's a bit of a quiet time.
- 41:05So and so can look after the bar.
- 41:06Come down and let me show you.
- 41:08You're up there with the lovely cold taps pouring the beer.
- 41:11Let's go downstairs and see how that beer gets to there.
- 41:16And I'm using the cellar as an example, because it's usually not many people go into.
- 41:21It's the same as the back of house, you know, in the kitchens.
- 41:23But if you use that cellar and then they get to see the journey of the beer, how they prepare, how that cellar, you know, some cellars I've been in, you could lick and eat off the floor.
- 41:36They are so spotlessly clean and they need to be.
- 41:40But it's that hygiene.
- 41:41It's about cleaning those beer lines.
- 41:43It's about how you roll those kegs in, where you place those kegs, all those.
- 41:48And to me, that's an education where they go, oh, you know, I never thought about this.
- 41:53I've only thought about pouring the beer.
- 41:56But now I know if this happens up there, has something gone wrong, not worked down here.
- 42:01Now I can understand about why we have different kegs in different spots with different lines.
- 42:06And so to me, it's that education piece, because they want that wisdom.
- 42:11They want that knowledge.
- 42:12It's not just about how to be, you know, the beer comes out.
- 42:16But how does the beer get that?
- 42:18And then it could be when you're having a conversation, if you're in a restaurant, you've got a grower or producer coming in with the produce, get the young chefs and even the front of house people, bring them out the back and get that grower to share their story.
- 42:35And then they go, wow.
- 42:37And I know this takes a little bit of time and people go, oh, my goodness, Michelle.
- 42:40But you know what?
- 42:42Maybe five, 10 minutes is worth and make such a difference for those frontline people out there.
- 42:47And they're going to sell that special because they've spoken to the actual farmer.
- 42:52And when that person is, you know, that young chef is preparing those vegetables or cooking that piece of meat, they know where it's come from.
- 43:00I think that little bit of investment up front is all about giving people the opportunity, yes, to learn, but also to maybe find and uncover some enthusiasm or some passion they weren't aware of.
- 43:16Just by showing stuff.
- 43:18You can't force that stuff in people, but by just opening up and showing them, maybe there's some opportunity.
- 43:23Maybe that is the trigger to finding more people who want to spend more time in this wonderful industry that we work in and lead others.
- 43:30And show them that it can be a hugely rewarding, fun and exciting industry to work in.
- 43:36Michelle, this conversation has rushed by as always.
- 43:40We've got to the point in the show that I call sticky notes, which is my lazy attempt to summarize everything that we've talked about.
- 43:47It's so lazy.
- 43:47It's your job to do it.
- 43:49So if we're thinking about leaving some advice for listeners here, as a hospitality industry, how can we better prepare or start developing leaders for tomorrow, today?
- 44:03What three little bits of advice would you fit on your sticky notes today, Michelle?
- 44:07Right.
- 44:09Number one, be a positive leader and show them what a leader is.
- 44:14Have those boundaries in place.
- 44:17Don't be the first to arrive and the last to leave and tell everybody, oh, you know, don't work so hard.
- 44:22Be a really good role model.
- 44:26Ignite the potential of those in your team.
- 44:28Not everyone, Andy, sees the potential within them because of maybe who's in their family or who are their friendship groups or who that last employer was.
- 44:38So you always ignite some of this potential.
- 44:41To me, that is the number one beautiful thing a leader can do.
- 44:46And the third one is, let's get out there and connect.
- 44:50Connect with your schools.
- 44:51Connect with your community.
- 44:53Go out there.
- 44:54Talk about what it's like being a leader in the hospitality industry and all the jobs that are in there.
- 45:00Because if we're not talking about it, then they're not hearing it from the people who it means so much.
- 45:07Oh, love it.
- 45:08Love those sticky notes.
- 45:09Love talking to you, Michelle.
- 45:11Always a pleasure.
- 45:12I'm sure it won't be our last conversation.
- 45:14Before I let you go, my lovely, where can people find out a little bit more about you and maybe some of the things you've talked about?
- 45:22I know we're going to put one of your generational PDFs in the show notes so people can sort of read in and find out a bit more information.
- 45:29But where's the best place to find out about you?
- 45:32Well, look, I'm on LinkedIn.
- 45:34I love LinkedIn.
- 45:35So it's really simple.
- 45:37Just Michelle Pascoe.
- 45:38So you can find me there.
- 45:40My website is michellepascoe.com.
- 45:42I also have a podcast like you, Annie, which you are my guest on, which is the Michelle Pascoe Hospitality Podcast.
- 45:49But yeah, look, look me up on LinkedIn.
- 45:52Let's connect.
- 45:53Let's have a conversation because, you know, it doesn't matter how many miles are between, you know, the UK and Australia.
- 46:01We globally need to shout out loudly, hospitality, the place to be.
- 46:09What a wonderful way to finish.
- 46:10Michelle, thank you so much for coming on, my love.
- 46:13I've really enjoyed our conversation and you take care.
- 46:17You too, Annie.
- 46:18Thank you so much and take care to all your listeners.
- 46:20All the best.
- 46:22OK, everyone, that was Michelle Pascoe.
- 46:24And if you'd like to find out a little bit more about her or any of the things we've talked about in today's show, please check out the show notes.
- 46:34So that concludes today's episode.
- 46:36I hope you've enjoyed it, found it interesting and heard something maybe that will help you become a stickier, more successful business from the inside going forward.
- 46:47If you have, please like, comment and subscribe.
- 46:51It really helps.
- 46:53I'm Andy Goram and you've been listening to the Sticky from the Inside podcast.
- 46:58Until next time.
- 46:59Thanks for listening.