Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Brian Benstock’s Mid-Year Check In: Busy, Lousy, but Always Great
Transcript
- 0:01All right, we have a very special day because we are doing a mid-year check-in with the one and only Brian Benstock. Brian, thanks so much for joining today. Great to be here, man. Good to see you.
- 0:12It's good to see you, too. Halfway through the year, it's nice and hot in New York City where you're at.
- 0:17Uh, I'm sure you're enjoying it and getting out on the water and all that, but what I really wanna know is how do you feel like the first half of the year went? Was it what you expected?
- 0:26And what is your perspective and your purview on what you think the second half of 2026 is gonna bring for us? So let's start and talk about the first half of the year. It's been great- Big surprises or what?...
- 0:36it's been busy, it's been lousy, it's been all of the above. [laughs] The economy's going in this direction, we got a war over here, a war over there, gas prices all over the place.
- 0:45Uh, I'd say it's pretty much as expected. [laughs] Yeah, yeah. It's situation normal, right? [laughs] Yeah.
- 0:51Uh, we also have, like, these tariff conversations, we have Chinese vehicle conversations, we have SC- you know, the FTC conversations. Great conversations to have, yeah. But, but- So why are they great conversations?
- 1:02Let's talk about that... well, well, where, where are we going with the FTC? I love the FTC. Can we get the OEMs involved with the dealers so we can get our stuff together?
- 1:10Because I still see pricing from various OEMs that talk about down payments, and, you know, you know, that's not what's supposed to happen, right? It's supposed to be total out-of-pocket. Mm-hmm.
- 1:20And so if the, if the OEMs are not aligned with the dealers, you're gonna have a recipe for disaster there. That means we're gonna have different pricing than our, than our manufacturers.
- 1:29So I, I'd like to see some assistance there in, um, uh, getting the, the pricing and the way we do pricing, uh, uniform.
- 1:37Uh, that's n- next to impossible because many different states have different allowances for different fees and, uh, that are, that are charged.
- 1:44So we've gotta find some way to standardize that so that the dealers that are on a border state of, uh, uh, another state where the, the, the various fees are different, uh, don't have a disadvantage.
- 1:56You know, Paragon here, where I guess as the crow flies about five miles away from New Jersey, and as the crow flies probably about eight miles away from Connecticut, and both of those states have different guidelines, uh, than we have.
- 2:06Not necessarily FTC guidelines, but, uh, their doc fees are significantly different.
- 2:12So, uh, you know, in the past, those dealers were able to advertise a very low price, and then at the last minute add a big, uh, doc fee.
- 2:21And while that's a t- it's a terrible practice, it would get them, uh, the lead over the, the New York's, uh, dealer. So hopefully if the enforcement's uniform, uh, we'll all benefit from that. So let me ask you this.
- 2:33Um, you are now in an environment over the last couple years where you have multiple locations- Yeah... and you now, uh, your s- your stores are about what? Not even two hours apart? No.
- 2:43The, uh, the White Plains store is about an hour away from us, yeah. An hour away. Uh- Depending on the traffic. [laughs] Yeah, of course. Always the big asterix in- Mm-hmm... in that area.
- 2:51But, um, what I wanted to ask you is what are some ways that you've now been leveraging multiple locations to increase your efficiency across the group with used cars, with new inventory?
- 3:01Because I think a lot of dealers across the country, groups are expanding, we're starting to see this more and more. So what are some of the things that you're doing, implementing, and learning?
- 3:09I didn't understand it when Paul Singer told me, now, now Paul passed 20 years ago, so I'm quoting o- over 20 years- And he was your mentor.
- 3:16For pe- for the few people that don't know, he was your mentor in this industry... well, was, was and is.
- 3:20But, you know, he said, "It'll be more difficult for you to go from one to two stores than it will be to go from two to 10 stores." And I did- I didn't understand that, but I, but I do now.
- 3:29It's really learning how to replicate yourself in another location.
- 3:32And I think what you're talking about, streamlining operations, we're starting to look at the stores as an enterprise, and, and to act as an enterprise and get that, uh, uh, the scale and the critical mass that you can get.
- 3:44You know, let, let's find the best way to do business and then do that across multiple platforms, and I think that's what we're endeavoring to do.
- 3:51And as we do that, you know, somebody, m- let's say Jason up at White Plains comes up with a great idea, well, then we can easily input it here.
- 3:58Uh, you know, independently owned and operated, yes, but doing business one way, and that's, uh, the best and the right way. So th- that's, that's kinda great.
- 4:05And we've kicked off a couple of things, you know, going back to the basics. You know, what's your constitution? What's your constitution look like? How do you do business?
- 4:13And this little book has every employee of the three operations listed in there and the year that they started, and to really start getting into that and developing the talent so that we have the fuel, uh, for future growth, and I think that's really the initiative right now.
- 4:27I've taken a couple of short steps back, uh, in the day to day to work on the bigger operational opportunities. What would you say is the, the most difficult part of culture to scale across locations?
- 4:39'Cause even an hour apart could be worlds apart. Like, we see this in, in a lot of businesses that are maybe franchised, other types of stores, not automotive.
- 4:47You go into the one business and you have one experience, you go into one that might only be a few miles away and you can have a different experience.
- 4:53It- What is the most challenging part of keecher- keeping culture aligned? It, you know, the culture has to be allowed to be, uh, unique to the store.
- 5:00I think, you know, the, the spe- speed of the boss is the speed of the place, and I think Jason has a very dynamic culture up at White Plains.
- 5:07It's very different than the culture that we have here at Paragon, but the strategy's the same. And I think s- uh, strategy comes after culture. That culture has to be there.
- 5:17So for me to try and import the culture at Paragon up at White Plains at, when I'm not gonna be there the amount of time to make sure that that culture is nourished, it, it's, it's a failed strategy.
- 5:28So Jason does a great job for us up there with the culture, and it's somewhat different, but the strategies that we're using that are proven strategies are giving us those, those results cross depart mentally and cross s- location- Mm-hmm...
- 5:41which is really the exciting part. You know, our certified business here is super healthy, top in the sto- in the country, and Jason's, uh, uh, is the certified business there in, in, in, in our district up there.
- 5:52We finished first in the district in- Hey... certified used cars. Hey, we beat, we beat Paramus, man. [laughs] That's a big store. That's right. That's a public corporation.
- 6:02They got their ass kicked by the Bad News Bears- [laughs]... up in White Plains. [laughs] And, and we're excited about that, man. A- and so that was, uh- [laughs]...
- 6:11the strategy was ours, the culture was theirs, so it's got their flavor to it. It's gotta have their fingerprints on it. And, and we wanna do that across departmentally, of course, and we wanna do that cross-location.
- 6:24And then the thing to do is to, to, to do as many locations as the good Lord will let us do. You know, I think that's, that's a, a huge takeaway from this because culture is how things get done, basically. Yeah.
- 6:36And you can say that inside a business, or you could just say it inside a community, and there's no doubt, like, New York City has a culture on how things get done. Yes.
- 6:44There's, there's a vibe, there's a swagger, there's an attitude to it, and you try to export that- To ano... Like, I, I'm, I'm from the Northeast, and when I go visit Kyle down in Nashville, right?
- 6:53We were doing these man on the street interviews, and I was like, "Man, I'm having a hard time getting people to talk to me." He goes, "'Cause they know you're from New York." I was like- [laughs] "What do you mean?"
- 7:00Well- He's like, "It's just the way you approach-" What do you mean, man? [laughs] What'd I ask him? "Can I ask you a question? What?" [laughs] Yeah. Yeah.
- 7:07And, and so, like, I think that is a great point, like the strategy being the same, implemented through the lens of the culture that you're in.
- 7:13And I, I, I think we even see some like, um, you know, like even some really large group do, do this well because they understand they're across multiple states- It, it-...
- 7:21and without a doubt I, I think Lithia's done a, a good job. Yes. And I'm not actually pro-Lithia- I was just gonna bring them up... but they keep the owner-operators in the store.
- 7:29And, and so what made the store a store that they'd wanna buy and viable is kept alive and well, you know? Yes.
- 7:35And, and the guys over at Planet, I know Bill, Bill over there, he's still involved in the store, and the store's still, still doing really well.
- 7:42And g- uh, take a look at what the opposite of that, when some of the large DMS companies, who will remain nameless, buy a great product, right?
- 7:51And they take it over, and it's where technology goes to die because the culture, the entrepreneur that has that product- That's suffocated. Yeah... g- is, he's cashed out.
- 8:02He's good, and the product, the strategy, is now in this new environment where the people there don't get it. Mm-hmm. And when they don't get it, that culture is such a driver.
- 8:11So in the past, I would've told you strategy usurps everything. But I, I think culture comes first. And again- Mm-hmm... there's some shout-outs that I'd give.
- 8:20You know, I think Anthony Petito, my service director here, culture and the service, well, it's great.
- 8:24You know, anything I ask Anthony, I say, you know, "Let's expand the hours, uh, uh, of operation," and I don't get pushback. He goes, "Yeah, let, let me come back to you with a plan." And i- in... We expanded the hours.
- 8:34We expanded to Sundays a million years ago, and then we expanded to seven days a week, and then we expanded to 24 hours a day. [laughs] Wow. And that's, that is not possible without culture. That's right.
- 8:45You can try and, uh, legislate hours that we're gonna be open, and you're gonna tell everybody, and you're gonna force them, but they're gonna resist, and you're not gonna do the proper business. That's right.
- 8:54But when the team is excited about being a part of it, uh, breaking some ground that nobody's done, uh, before, and that culture is strong there, and there's a culture of trust, right?
- 9:02When they as- they assume when you're talking to them, uh, that, that comes from a base on a, "I trust you. Let's listen to what you have to say," that, that's really the starting point of everything great.
- 9:11A culture of trust, I think, is a great way to sum it up because- Yeah... every store's got a culture, right? Sometimes they're terrible.
- 9:17Like, I'm getting my vehicle fixed right now at a Ford dealership not too far from here, and you can tell immediately when you walk in, like, as a consumer. Like, and I know a lot about service.
- 9:26I've been to the, the hundreds of dealerships, [laughs] right? And I immediately know when I walk in, like, "This culture is in that lane or this lane." So a culture of trust, I like how you just put it that way. Yeah.
- 9:35Yeah. 'Cause if you have a culture of trust, you can accomplish anything, right? You, you, you really can. You can get buy-in, and you...
- 9:40Like, the, the new people learn from the people that are in there, whether or not... Really quickly, day one, a new person is gonna understand whether or not you can trust the leadership, day one.
- 9:48Yeah, and, and if, if the leader's job is vision, right? There's gotta be a, a, a, a, you know, and you have that vision, you share it with everybody. If they don't trust you, you know, good luck pulling that vision off.
- 9:58You know? That's right. You, you wanna have that culture of trust. And again, if you've been let down by management before or leadership before, it, it's really tough to get that back.
- 10:07So, you know, it, it's a, it's a, a great- Yeah... environment that we've got in a couple of the rooftops here, and it gives us, uh, a lot of hope for the future. All right, we got just under six months left in 2026.
- 10:18Uh, where should dealers be focusing their effort and energy heading into the second half of this year now that we know what we know about the year?
- 10:26I think align- aligning with the OEMs and the OEMs aligning with the dealers is really important. You know, the, the EV, uh, debacle failed. "Hey, help us get out of these cars that are here."
- 10:35We're, we're still leading the nation in EV sales. Go figure. It's not in California- [laughs]... uh, where the environmentalists are. It's not in Oregon. It's in Woodside, New York, uh, where, where- Baby, yeah.
- 10:46[laughs]... the EV charts. There's no place to plug them. [laughs] But that doesn't stop the team at Paragon 'cause that culture is in place. The strategy's in place.
- 10:54Uh, but the, but the OEMs being aligned with us, saying, "Okay, hey, we understand what happened before. Let's make up for lost time."
- 11:01I wanna remind everybody this is still the year of the horse, and we've gotta be running. You've got to drown out the noise. There's a lot of noise, political noise. The people on this side of the aisle- Yes.
- 11:12Tons of it... are saying, "The sky's on fire. The roof is falling down." And the guys over here are saying, "Don't worry about anything."
- 11:17You gotta keep focused on what's important to you, what's important to your customers. Affordability is still a, a, a big concern. Uh, you know, thankfully Honda's answering this.
- 11:27We've got three of our most popular vehicles under $300 a month- Wow... on a current lease, and that's, that's pretty spectacular. The Accord, the HR-V, uh, a- and the Civic are all under $300 a month.
- 11:39A- and so, you know, that's, that's nine bucks a day for, for some of the best transportation you can buy. And I, I think what's, what's your OEM's message?
- 11:47The other thing we have to concern ourselves with is what's happening with the used car market and the pricing on used cars. We're seeing some, uh, ups and downs, some fluctuation.
- 11:56How about we get serious about leasing used cars? The cars last longer than ever before. Every damn car has a residual. If every car has a residual, then you can lease it.
- 12:05And, and so let's, let's get into these, uh, uh, the affordability for used cars and give customers the opportunity to lease a car and to keep that transportation value at a very low price point, you know, instead, instead of letting the F&I guys slam customers into an 84-month finance contract on a used car.
- 12:23Right. Come on, guys. I mean, we were talking about that. Come on. Even the average new car, average used car financing is over 70 months right now across the country.
- 12:31And, and, and, and, and I hate to say this, and I love F&I teams, and I love the F&I department, the dealership, and few, if any, dealerships could survive without the income from it, but who, whose name is on your building?
- 12:43Is, is your, is your F&I m- uh, manager's name on the building? Is it his or her store, or is it your store? And we've gotta stop letting these guys control what's going on.
- 12:53It, the, it's, it may be good for the short-term profit, but it's not good, uh, for the long-term health- Of your business, uh, and- Or the industry, honestly...
- 13:02or, or, or, well, you know, let's not try and save the industry. I mean, I agree with you. It's terrible for the industry. But, but let's talk about the individual store.
- 13:09You know, the frequency is the best way to make profits. You know, and, and look at these guys over here.
- 13:15Look at the f- you know, they, they, they, they make their money based on the frequency, the, the trade cycle management that we should own. But Apple has done the best job of trade cycle management.
- 13:26When's the last time you bought an Apple phone because you needed a new one, other than dropping it or crushing it? I definitely don't need one, but I'm ready- Yeah... to buy the next one.
- 13:34You're ready to buy one because it's better. I'm gonna tap a couple buttons and it's gonna be, show up, and I'm gonna send this one back, and we're done.
- 13:39And I got news for you, Paul, is the automobiles that your manufacturer, your respective manufacturer's making each year is better than the predecessor.
- 13:46So h- how about we do a better job talking about here's what's in it for you, here's what's in it for you to, to upgrade. And y- you get the residual value of the car. You pay just for what you use.
- 13:56You put the car in a used car lot. You sell, you know, in a 10-year trade cycle, you could sell, uh, let's see, three times at least in the cycle and get two trades. It's five transactions- Mm-hmm...
- 14:06versus one with the, with the F&I guy that put your guy in an 84-month transaction, and you don't see that customer ever again. What's the data say on return to the dealership for somebody that's in an 84-month loan?
- 14:19Right. We truly don't know the a- Nobody knows that nu- right. Nobody knows that answer. We don't, we don't know that answer.
- 14:23But I can tell you that, that with Honda, if I lease you two cars, I've got a 70-plus percent chance of leasing you a third. Is that an unbelievable statistic? Who wants those odds? Everybody. I... Everybody. Everybody.
- 14:37A- a- and by the way, you're, you're reducing the downside, uh, for the customers 'cause they're not gonna have to pay for repairs if it's under a 36-month lease. You've got a warranty for that.
- 14:46You're gonna minimize their maintenance costs. So it's a great experience for the customer, right? Economic certainty. And, and I have a great experience with this thing. Uh, they don't wear out.
- 14:55Well, 'cause I've never owned one long enough to know whether or not it'll wear out. [laughs] That's right. Right? That's just a great phone, right? It's, it's, it- It always works. It always works.
- 15:03A- and maybe it doesn't work. Maybe after 60 months, this thing's garbage. Yeah. I'll never know. You'll never know, right? Yeah. If anything goes wrong, you got AppleCare, it's getting fixed or whatever.
- 15:12Yeah, and, and I, and I think it's, it's, it's really important for us as the customers need less servicing, for us to find ways to service those older cars that are on the road.
- 15:22I think the average car on the road now is, is close to 14 years old. And maybe even- Older and longer than ever... o- and maybe older than that. So where is that service opportunity?
- 15:31And that service opportunity is leaking out to those pesky independents. So we've gotta spend a lot of time going after the, um, 80 pers- 80% of the people that are servicing not with a dealer.
- 15:43And I, and I think, um, that's an initiative we started a number of years ago here, and we're still working on it every single day. How do we... I don't wanna take...
- 15:52We have a, Hillside Honda's about six miles away from us. Love those guys. They're great dealers.
- 15:56I don't want one of their service customers, but I want all of the ones that are defecting in our marketplace to the independents, you know? And, and that's the battle we should be fighting.
- 16:07It's not for me to look at their oil change price at, at Hillside and undercut them.
- 16:13No, it, it's for me to look at what's going on in the marketplace with the independents and find ways to out-service them, um, out- out-convenience them- Yes... and, and to outperform them.
- 16:21Uh, and I, and I think, um, we're working really hard at doing just that. [upbeat music] Well, I don't think there's any better way to end this episode, Brian. Thank you so much for giving us a few minutes of your time.
- 16:31And always, I leave these conversations fired up, ready to go run through a wall, kick down a door. Thank you so much. Keep doing what you're doing. We'll see you soon. Thanks.
- 16:39[upbeat music]