Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / Burnham's Britain: EVOL Special
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome. To energy voice out loud.
- 0:05The weekly news podcast that keeps you up to date on the
- 0:08hottest. Stories from the UK energy
- 0:10market. We've got a new energy
- 0:40secretary, we've got a new chancellor and we've even got a
- 0:43new Prime Minister. That's an awful lot to talk
- 0:45about if you're just me. Aberdeen features lead Ryan
- 0:47Duff, but thankfully I'm joined by near enough everyone in The
- 0:51Newsroom. Starting us off Erica Askland,
- 0:54News editor How are you? Doing this week, Erica.
- 0:57Well, you know, it's just been such an exciting week.
- 1:00It kind of feels like, you know, once again, being at the hot
- 1:04coalface of energy news has just been kind of exciting.
- 1:08Although are we really, you know, considering energy news
- 1:11coal power fired anymore? Because, you know, that's like
- 1:15pretty hydrocarbonate, right? Yeah, we're we're.
- 1:17Electrifying the news, that's what I'm hearing here, but you
- 1:20know what we moving moving from our.
- 1:23Fearless leader to our. King in the North.
- 1:25As we've been thinking about a different king in the north
- 1:27Northwest. Correspondent Floyd.
- 1:29March, how are you doing this week?
- 1:30I'm doing well. I'm loving this King of the
- 1:32North chat. It's been like 4 or five times
- 1:34past couple weeks. So yeah, I'm, I'm here for it.
- 1:36Maybe I'm not quite the levels of Andy Burnham yet, but I'm
- 1:39still about 30 years younger than him, so I've got time
- 1:42there. You are, maybe.
- 1:43Who knows? The political aspirations are
- 1:45still. Alive.
- 1:46But you know what? I'm.
- 1:47Campaigning to see A to see a sort of.
- 1:49Picture of you added as a Robb Stark.
- 1:51From Game of Thrones, let's just hope that things end up there
- 1:54for you. And dead for him.
- 1:56We're gonna send you one of those furry, kind of like,
- 1:59shoulder coats, you know, that Robb Stark wore when he was, you
- 2:03know, kind of working, you know, at the Wall.
- 2:06Some say it's Devil W Prada 3. Matt.
- 2:11Perry News reporter, You are joining us this week.
- 2:13You've been. You've been.
- 2:15Keeping on top of all things, how are you doing?
- 2:18It's felt a little bit like a a World Cup draw equivalent for UK
- 2:22political journalists this week. It's all been happening so I
- 2:25hope the The King in the North chat has Speaking of the other
- 2:28World Cup cheered you up a bit from the the disappointment of
- 2:31the three lines. Floyd is that is that too soon?
- 2:34I. We already did this last
- 2:35podcast, Mark. Well, I have to get my digs in
- 2:38as well. Can we rub it in just a little
- 2:39bit more? And finally, renewables has been
- 2:44the topic of conversation this week.
- 2:46You know, we've seen the new Energy secretary is very keen on
- 2:49net. Zero.
- 2:51So we've obviously got our renewables.
- 2:53Reporter our our head. Honcho of Clean Energy, Michael.
- 2:57Baer, how are you? Doing this week it's been.
- 2:59Exciting. Normally summer it's, you know,
- 3:01it's the, the lull season, but then we just have this and it's
- 3:05been spectacular Newsweek for us.
- 3:08Good, good. So.
- 3:09I think, I think we've, we've kind of.
- 3:10Danced around the topic. Throughout all of our.
- 3:13Intros just now about you know what's happening this week I
- 3:16feel like everyone listening to this knows what's happening this
- 3:19week they've been. Keeping up with it, it's.
- 3:21Kind of difficult to mess. The the political.
- 3:24Changes the the sort of reshuffling of the cabinet.
- 3:28And so on and so forth. So let's dive straight into.
- 3:32Things I think Floyd would have come to.
- 3:33You because you. Were Johnny on the spot?
- 3:36You were there at 10. O'clock at night.
- 3:38I think it was when FanDuel finally got announced as as the
- 3:43the new Energy Secretary. After Ed Miliband was shunted
- 3:47over to foreign minister. Foreign Secretary, sorry.
- 3:50So tell me. What's What was the immediate
- 3:53reaction? What's?
- 3:54Tell us what happened. Yeah, so not a lot happened for
- 3:56quite a while. Erica could probably butt me up
- 3:58on that. So Erica stayed online with me
- 4:00and she's got no credit this week from anybody.
- 4:03So. So yeah, I'll share the love
- 4:05with you, Erica. Floyd.
- 4:07Thanks, Floyd. It was fun staying up late with
- 4:08you, you know? It was.
- 4:10It was. Remotely.
- 4:11Obviously that. Implies you wouldn't want.
- 4:14To share a room with Floyd and I don't know how I feel about.
- 4:16That moving swiftly on. Yeah, yeah, of course.
- 4:20So, yeah, there's a lot of guessing, which is quite fun.
- 4:22Like I saw West St. in walking into down the street.
- 4:25I was like, oh, like surely not like Mel abandoned Mahmood
- 4:29walked in at the same time. And then I was thinking, oh, is
- 4:31there going to be some kind of like joint treasury Desnas thing
- 4:35going on where like energy is more tied closely with the
- 4:38treasury? And then there was a big lull of
- 4:41like nothing happened happening. So I was watching the coverage
- 4:44on BBC and I was like, oh, like has had the person updating
- 4:47their live blog, like fallen asleep.
- 4:49And then I checked as Guardian, the Times and they were all the
- 4:52same as well. So I was like, and then our
- 4:55reporter Jess popped in the chat with her guests that it'd be me
- 4:59after. And then she was correct.
- 5:01So yeah, we just ran with it. But yeah, it was.
- 5:02It was a long night of nothing and then everything happening
- 5:05all at once. Yeah, it was, it did feel very
- 5:09stop start because obviously it was about what about 10:00 that
- 5:14we we got the. First, sort of certain first
- 5:16murmurings. We got Keir Starmer, you know.
- 5:19Giving his. Speech and that started a.
- 5:21Long day in which, yeah, as you say.
- 5:24Miata ended up. Getting the job and the
- 5:26following. Morning Matt and I.
- 5:28We were up at half 6. Ready to file the newsletter and
- 5:31Matt? Jumped on the opportunity.
- 5:33To write a Sir who is who? Is this new energy secretary and
- 5:36sort of? Gave some background.
- 5:38Yeah, I think it's certainly because we had a bit of
- 5:40speculation because obviously all the talkers about who would
- 5:42be the chancellor beforehand, but turns out everyone got that
- 5:46one wrong. And and I think all of our
- 5:48speculation about who might be the energy secretary of Ed
- 5:52Miliband was moved out was also wrong.
- 5:54I don't think anyone had pegged me Artifamulla as the the next
- 5:57energy secretary, but in hindsight it's sort of a pick
- 6:00that does make a lot of sense. She was the first government
- 6:02minister to step down and resign, calling for Keir Starmer
- 6:06to go. Obviously potentially some
- 6:08reward there for her from Andy Burnham.
- 6:11And I guess it's interesting as well that they're both members
- 6:13of the Labour and Cooperative Party rather than sort of the
- 6:16the Labour proper. So I guess a bit of background
- 6:20on Miata Van Woola for anyone who hasn't been reading our
- 6:22coverage. She was born in Liberia and her
- 6:25family came to the UK after fleeing a civil war in the West
- 6:28African country. And she was elected at the 2024
- 6:31general election to represent Peckham, which is a constituency
- 6:35in the London. Prior to that, she worked with
- 6:38the New Economics Foundation, which I think could, you know,
- 6:40reasonably described as a fairly left wing think tank.
- 6:44She holds a PhD in economic development from the London
- 6:47School of Economics. Interestingly, I looked up her
- 6:50PhD thesis and it's on industrial policy and I think in
- 6:53Kenya and Ghana. So she does have a bit of
- 6:56industrial policy background there.
- 6:59And she served as a senior economic adviser to Angela
- 7:01Rayner and Ed Miliband during the 2024 election campaign.
- 7:04So she's quite well connected and she was pretty quickly
- 7:07promoted to the ministry after the general election.
- 7:09She initially came into Disney as as minister for energy
- 7:13consumers. So a lot of focus on bills and
- 7:16things like the warm homes plan, heat networks, that sort of
- 7:20thing. And then during a bit of a
- 7:22reshuffle following the departure of Angela Rayner, she
- 7:25moved across to the the housing ministry.
- 7:27So I think that's probably why none of us had sort of pegged
- 7:30her as as coming back to energy because she'd sort of moved
- 7:32pretty quickly into the housing. And that seemed where kind of a
- 7:35lot of her her focus had been while she'd been energy as well.
- 7:38But I think potentially this could show maybe where Burnham
- 7:42is wanting to focus the Energy Department in his term.
- 7:46He's talked a lot about, you know, cost of living.
- 7:49He's talked a lot about, you know, helping out people who are
- 7:52struggling. And so I think having Fambula as
- 7:55the energy secretary probably signals a lot of focus on, you
- 7:58know, continuation, continuation of sort of domestic energy
- 8:02measures cutting bills. We saw that with his first
- 8:04measure was to cut VAT on electricity bills from October.
- 8:07We'll probably see a lot more things around, I guess what Ed
- 8:12Miliband had kind of and Rachel Reeves had signaled before of
- 8:15trying to delink energy prices from gas prices.
- 8:18Probably more work on things like heat networks, heat pumps,
- 8:22plug in solar panels, community energy, that sort of thing.
- 8:25Because I think a lot of people have sort of framed this for
- 8:28Miliband as putting out to pasture in the foreign
- 8:32secretary. I don't know if he'll see it
- 8:34that way. I think he might see it as, you
- 8:37know, 11 Mahaden. He has done a lot of work in the
- 8:41at Disney's to get the kind of infrastructure side of the
- 8:45energy transition going with, you know, allocation rounds to
- 8:49strategic spatial energy plan. That's a mouthful and all this
- 8:52sort of other work around, you know, the infrastructure side.
- 8:55And I think he might be thinking that's in pretty good nick and a
- 8:58safe pair of hands. Now I'm going to head over to
- 9:00the foreign role and I'm going to be start, you know, I'm sure
- 9:03we'll see Ed Miliband at a lot of cop summits and trying to
- 9:05get, I guess, you know, more maybe European and wider, wider
- 9:11and sort of the global S work being done on energy stuff.
- 9:14So, you know, maybe he's that's kind of where Burnham's sort of
- 9:18thinking as well. And, you know, obviously having
- 9:21Miliband focused on the international stuff will also
- 9:23keep him away from domestic politics, which is, I'm sure a
- 9:27not a, you know, a problem for, for, for Burnham either.
- 9:31Yeah, maybe, maybe welcomed by the the oil and.
- 9:34Gas sector, who has been, you know, which has been.
- 9:36Sort of calling for. Tax reform over the past few
- 9:39years, or ever since 2022 when when the the Energy Profits Levy
- 9:43was first introduced. And that might be something that
- 9:47the new chancellor. Would be looking at John.
- 9:49Healey, you know he's he's. Served.
- 9:52With the Treasury in the. Past, as Erica, you pointed out.
- 9:55I was speaking. To Professor of petroleum
- 9:58economics at Aberdeen University.
- 10:00Alec Kemp yesterday. And he seemed largely.
- 10:03Positive about the whole appointment?
- 10:05He was. Sort of.
- 10:06He sort of. See saw as well.
- 10:09Healy's been in. In the.
- 10:11Treasury before he's dealt with the oil and gas.
- 10:13Industry before he sort of. Worked with them.
- 10:16And he understands the the. You know, intersection between.
- 10:21Oil and gas investment and tax taken sort of the the.
- 10:23Finances for for the country. But Erica, you pointed out
- 10:28something quite interesting. Before I spoke to Alec.
- 10:30Which was about his his. Involvement in the in previous
- 10:34governments and that sort of. Regional, regional sort of
- 10:38plans. That he was.
- 10:39He was. Part of introducing.
- 10:42Yeah. So I mean, from what I
- 10:44understand, there was a big move, you know, in the late 90s,
- 10:51I think it was more of, you know, the first kind of new
- 10:55Labor government under Blair, which established regional
- 10:58development agencies. And they then also, you know,
- 11:03kind of like solidified the, you know, new government changes
- 11:08kind of carving up England into the regions that we now know
- 11:12northwest of England, you know, Yorkshire and Humber, northeast
- 11:16of England and, you know, the East and West Midlands and
- 11:20etcetera, etcetera. So and that was, you know, a way
- 11:24to really kind of pump, you know, money into the regions in
- 11:28a way that, you know, kind of was regionally based.
- 11:30I mean, you know, it was one of those things where, you know,
- 11:33they thought it was a good thing that, you know, regions had, you
- 11:36know, more control over their fiscal, you know, powers.
- 11:40I think maybe, you know, the sense though that, you know,
- 11:43regional development agencies were of course dismantled by the
- 11:47Tories and the Lib Dems when, you know, that era came into
- 11:51power and then were they were kind of like undercut and you
- 11:54know, kind of turned into something kind of smaller and
- 11:56perhaps less effective. So I mean, were those regional
- 12:00developments agencies give them a report card in terms of like
- 12:04how they were able to deliver? Well, I think actually, you
- 12:08know, what they delivered, they delivered a system whereby it
- 12:12also kind of suggested that there should be, you know, city
- 12:16mayors in England, which of course gave us Andy Burnham.
- 12:20So you know what, it's a nice little circular thing, right?
- 12:23So. Interestingly, you know, who
- 12:25else was central to that sort of regional economic devolution
- 12:29strategy? You know, the precursor to my
- 12:31least favorite British political term, levelling up.
- 12:34Don't know how that got through the the marketing agencies, but
- 12:38Miata Fambula was also critical during that time as she worked
- 12:41at the Cabinet Office during that period.
- 12:43So she played a central role in that regional devolution
- 12:45strategy as well. So it, I guess it'll be
- 12:47interesting to see how her and Healy worked together on, on
- 12:51sort of regional devolution when what might might we see?
- 12:55Because Burnham has talked about more power to the regions, and
- 12:57that's been great by a lot of skepticism in the likes of
- 13:00Scotland and Wales. But you know, obviously the S&P
- 13:03has been vocally calling for the evolution, greater devolution
- 13:06and energy powers. Might we see something along
- 13:09those lines from Burnham? Who knows.
- 13:12But it kind of, I think it's not out of the realms of
- 13:14possibility. Floyd, did you go pop by the,
- 13:18the new #10 of the North the other day just to kind of see
- 13:20what was going on or, or, or have you have you maybe kind of
- 13:24like saved, you know, the waiting for the golden invite to
- 13:27come through your letterbox? No, I, I don't get invited to
- 13:29many things. So I took myself there and
- 13:31there's 22 big buildings. I was like, which one's which?
- 13:34And then the closer I got, there was like a massive police force,
- 13:38like around the whole building. So I was like, oh, this is most
- 13:40likely to be that one. Yeah.
- 13:43But I think I think the where it's placed was actually quite
- 13:47funny because Burnham would know if he plonked #10 N right next
- 13:52to Piccadilly Station. Like everyone must say, it's so
- 13:55he can get to London as fast as possible.
- 13:57And it kind of makes it look even more of a gimmick than what
- 13:59critics were saying. But at Saint Peter's Square, it
- 14:02is literally just outside of Piccadilly Gardens essentially.
- 14:07So he's like literally on the boundary of it, like still being
- 14:12close enough to getting on the train to London, but far enough
- 14:15away to beat the allegations that it's like a gimmick to just
- 14:18have a building in the North rather than like an actual like
- 14:22strategy about what it's going to look like in the North.
- 14:25Well, you know, I think. That's, that would be quite
- 14:27fair. And you know, I was looking at
- 14:28the map of the map of Manchester.
- 14:31Around where the the new number 10 in the north is.
- 14:34And there's plenty of bus. Stops outside of there, so I
- 14:36mean, maybe he's. Planning on using that.
- 14:38Cheap Tupane bus fares. To jump to jump to.
- 14:41Piccadilly Station. But you know, Speaking of that.
- 14:44Of that kind of #10 in the North and that sort.
- 14:48Of involvement of. Two major folks that are.
- 14:51Involved in the energy sector sector as are.
- 14:54Being instrumental in that regional.
- 14:56Development plan. From government's gone by.
- 15:00Floyd, you know you've, you've. Been sort of keeping keeping.
- 15:02Tabs on Burnham as a whole over the past few weeks as we as we
- 15:07were except for him to to take over over government.
- 15:11Do you, do you sort of feel that there's a sentiment in the
- 15:14region of, oh, there's actually going to be change?
- 15:16Or is it very much a? Case of well, you know.
- 15:19We'll. We'll have to wait and.
- 15:20See. Because we've heard this.
- 15:21Before. I mean, it's not the first.
- 15:23Time that we've heard government, you know,
- 15:25governments say that. Regions will get cash injection
- 15:28and we're going to reindustrialize and, you know,
- 15:30build industry, create jobs. What's What's the sentiment?
- 15:33I guess it it kind of feels a bit more authentic, like
- 15:37naturally, just by the fact that like Burnham's been great in
- 15:40Manchester mayor for a while now and like he's got like a track
- 15:43record on specific things. So like, it's it's kind of like
- 15:46maybe it's easier to fall into the trap depending on your
- 15:50political persuasion. But you know, high net came out
- 15:53pretty quickly afterwards. Like Burnham's been a massive
- 15:57like fan of high net if you like.
- 15:59He signed a letter to Desnes a few months back with 40 other
- 16:04like people working across high net to to ensure that the
- 16:07Northwest becomes the first hydrogen networked region with
- 16:11all the stuff that's happening in Trafford Energy Park as well
- 16:13with Carlton Power. So in the Northwest
- 16:17specifically, Burnham's got that track record of being on the
- 16:21side of these infrastructure projects as great in Manchester
- 16:24mayor. So I feel like it maybe perhaps
- 16:26feels a little bit more authentic that re
- 16:29industrialization could happen in the North.
- 16:31But and then obviously the Department of Business and Trade
- 16:34is one of the first apartments moving up to the north and
- 16:37they're in charge. They look after the industrial
- 16:39strategy so that without energy being brought here, you know,
- 16:46there's that like sign of goodwill, I suppose that that
- 16:49business and trades heading this way and they're going to be
- 16:51looking after the industrial strategy.
- 16:52You know I. Fear we, I fear we also, you
- 16:54know, sort of brushed Miliband under the rug a little bit.
- 16:57We kind of touched on him earlier.
- 16:58But I do want to do want to address, address him.
- 17:01Matt, you obviously addressed, you know, the sort of the, the
- 17:04moves he made for for renewables.
- 17:06And I feel like Matt. Mike, Michael, sorry, you'd be
- 17:09good to jump in on that. You know, like looking back at
- 17:12his his legacy, obviously we've had two allocation rounds under
- 17:17under Miliband 1 was significantly more successful
- 17:20than the other. But AR 6 was always going.
- 17:23To look like a win compared to AR5I suppose.
- 17:26What? What's your?
- 17:27Kind of reflections on Miliband because I know when when.
- 17:30You wrote Roots or Starmer is leaving peace, you kind of said.
- 17:34Do you know what like? All in all, there's some.
- 17:36Largely good stuff here that, you know, kind of, you know, he
- 17:39got a lot of kick insurance, but you know, you sort of pointed to
- 17:41some good things that happened under Starmer.
- 17:44Do you feel that way reflecting on Milliband or do you feel
- 17:46that? It's, you know, the oil and gas
- 17:49industry. Was justified.
- 17:50What's going on? I feel like we'd overuse the
- 17:53term mixed, like a mixed bag for him.
- 17:56I think for someone who's obviously the renewals reporter
- 18:01that, you know, I've generally had a positive view of Miliband.
- 18:04I think that for a government as well, that generally has been
- 18:10hard to work out where it stands that it's generally been a sort
- 18:13of quite a bland administration. He was definitely a point of
- 18:18someone with a clear plan and a clear ideology.
- 18:21And that translated quite well into delivery because obviously,
- 18:25you know, I mean, look, let's just say AR 7 was a success.
- 18:29So we're not kind of over wrecking AR 6, but AR 7 was a
- 18:33considerable success in terms of the amount of capacity brought
- 18:35through. He came in saying he's going to
- 18:37drive renewables and essentially did obviously oil and gas much
- 18:43less of a a positive sport for Miliband.
- 18:46I think Matt, you'd agree there. Yeah, I think we, we talked
- 18:49about this sort of mixed legacy. And I think it's only mixed in
- 18:51the sense that if you, it depends on who you're asking.
- 18:55So if you're asking someone who's in the renewables
- 18:57industry, they'd probably have a lot of positive things to say
- 19:00about Ed Miliband. If you're asking someone in the
- 19:02oil and gas sector, they would have probably words to say that
- 19:06we wouldn't be able to air on this podcast.
- 19:08So I think that's a sense that. Yeah, and it'll be interesting
- 19:13to see see as well as to how much, you know, I guess by going
- 19:16back to Famwella, how much pragmatism she brings into the
- 19:20the role in the sense that, you know, she's been very outspoken
- 19:22in her past writings before entering Parliament about sort
- 19:26of oil and gas and not wanting to see any more drilling.
- 19:29And you know, she she called in 2019 for the UK to reach net
- 19:33zero in 10 to 15 years. So, you know, around mid twenty
- 19:3730s, considerably ahead of what the current trajectory is.
- 19:40So, you know, but we saw the same with Ed Miliband, right.
- 19:43So we saw with Ed Miliband, he described Rose Bank as economic
- 19:47vandalism and then it went in the role he was much more
- 19:51measured in his talking about. But I think, well, I think the
- 19:56problem I had with the Labour Party's kind of energy strategy
- 20:01is, is that they really didn't articulate a clear vision for
- 20:06the oil and gas sector. You know they'd say one thing.
- 20:09To sort of the the the climate focused side of the UK politics
- 20:14and another thing that the oil and gas said, you know, just
- 20:16turning out the line, oil and gas will be with us to decades
- 20:18to come. But what does that mean and in
- 20:20what capacity? Was never really spelled out.
- 20:22Don't, don't you think? That was, you know, that that
- 20:25that. Kind of uncertainty there is
- 20:28also what the what causes issues.
- 20:30You know, if you're absolutely energy sector, if oil and gas
- 20:33sector knew where they they were going, then that would have at
- 20:35least. If they had.
- 20:36Something concrete to complain. About that, wasn't Rosebank and
- 20:39Jack Doyle not being approved, which again was another point of
- 20:42contention under under Miliband that.
- 20:44You know, you, you sort of say that.
- 20:46Yourself understands, but you know action speaks louder than
- 20:50words and. You know, at the end of the.
- 20:53Day we've we've sort. Of we're still waiting on.
- 20:56Decisions for those projects which you know.
- 20:59Will be a litmus test. For how the the scope?
- 21:023 emissions sort of legislation. Is going to is going to sort of
- 21:07play. To to be fair to Miliband, you
- 21:11know, that was something that you know was unexpected.
- 21:14You know, there's not the Labour Party's fault that there was a
- 21:17court case in the legal challenge to those consents that
- 21:20was overturned. The department did have to do a
- 21:22considerable amount of work to put in that updated guidance.
- 21:25There are processes that operate has to follow now that the
- 21:28consensus. So it's not as if, you know, Ed
- 21:31Miliband and Michael Shanks have been, you know, twiddling their
- 21:34thumbs going la di da di da, like, let's let's see how long
- 21:37we can keep this down the road just to piss off the energy
- 21:39sector. You know, there's there's red
- 21:42tape that needs to be worked through to get these things
- 21:45approved. But I think that's something I
- 21:47would like to see from fine Buller coming into the role is
- 21:50obviously now these decisions on Rosebank and Jackdaw come to her
- 21:53desk, not Ed Miliband. So that will be, I think, the
- 21:56clearest sign as to what trajectory she plans to take.
- 22:00If she, you know, approves Rosebank and Jackdaw, that will
- 22:05obviously, you know, we've already seen some climate
- 22:07protesters in in London holding up, you know, signs calling for
- 22:11Miata stop Rosebank. If she approves those projects,
- 22:15you know, it'll be a sign that she is charting a different path
- 22:20to maybe what she advocated for before entering the role.
- 22:24But yeah, so I think this is what what we need to see is not
- 22:28just decisions on these projects, but a clear vision as
- 22:30to what decades to come means for the the North Sea oil and
- 22:34gas sector. And I think the Labour Party
- 22:36really needs to reckon with that.
- 22:37And I think under Andy Burnham, it gives them a chance to, well,
- 22:43they've not done so so far, but it gives them a chance to chart
- 22:46out a, a clearer plan than than what we saw, I think.
- 22:49I think Starmer and Miliband got themselves sort of stuck.
- 22:52You know, they've been very outspoken against the likes of
- 22:55Rosebank in opposition and then coming into government they
- 22:57thought, oh, well, it's already been approved.
- 22:59We can just slide that to the one side.
- 23:02We don't have to worry about it. We just blame it on the
- 23:03Conservatives. But yeah, then it fell back in
- 23:06their laps. And I don't think they ever
- 23:07really had a, A political strategy to, to get out from
- 23:12there without alienating a lot of their their voters who they
- 23:15were terrified of them running off to the Greens, you know, I
- 23:18mean. I think, I think actually I'm,
- 23:21you know, kind of the energy and industrial policy for Scotland
- 23:26is now kind of like serious in play, seriously in play.
- 23:29We see that Anas Sarwar, Labour, Scotland Labour leader, is
- 23:35leaving Holy Rood and taking up a mantle in the House of Lords
- 23:38in order so that he can join the business team in Westminster,
- 23:44which is a very interesting move.
- 23:46But I also think, you know, that And of course, like, let's put
- 23:48out put it out there to Mike Shanks, who's still a survivor.
- 23:52We still get the toys of Mike Shanks, you know, kind of doing
- 23:55that kind of two sided approach to communications about, you
- 24:01know, the North Sea and the industry in Scotland.
- 24:05You know, just saying, you know, when he's up in Scotland, he's
- 24:06like, yeah, of course we're going to be having, you know,
- 24:09oil and gas for decades to come. And then kind of going down
- 24:12South and saying, oh, but of course we have to get off this,
- 24:15you know, hydrocarbon roller coaster, just depending on of
- 24:18course, which audience he's looking for.
- 24:20So, and I kind of think also too, you know, we have to kind
- 24:23of factor in, you know, the relationship between John
- 24:28Swinney and Andy Burnham. Well, you know, with regards to
- 24:32the whole. Yeah.
- 24:33Yeah, because today Burnham's Burnham's up in holy rood.
- 24:36He's going to be meeting. With Swinney and predominantly
- 24:39to. Speak about his devolution plans
- 24:41I believe and the sort. Of the the idea to sort of give
- 24:43the give each region. Slightly more power, but.
- 24:46Energy will definitely. Be a talking point, right?
- 24:48John Swinney has basically said he wants control of, you know,
- 24:52the Scottish Power policy. I mean, you know, as, as we all
- 24:55know, you know, there's been very little, you know, almost
- 24:58that they can do because, you know, they don't have tower
- 25:01powers over tax, you know, which is the hated thing that seems to
- 25:05be, you know, the biggest burden on the North Sea.
- 25:08And then, of course, you know, the very little to do with, you
- 25:10know, the allocation rounds, you know, let alone grid build out,
- 25:14you know, that's, you know, SSE of course, is based here, SSE
- 25:17and transmission, but you know, that's kind of largely driven by
- 25:20national policy as well. So who knows, you know, what
- 25:23they can do. And of course, Burnham's a fan
- 25:25of, you know, devolution and more powers, but he's not a fan
- 25:28of Scottish independence and, you know, just handing that
- 25:30stuff. I think there's a lot of horse
- 25:32trading to do. And then it's really useful to
- 25:34kind of contrast and compare. I think, you know, certainly
- 25:37what's going on in the Northwest and the Northeast, you know,
- 25:40because, you know, those, you know, projects, the CCS and
- 25:44hydrogen clusters are really powering forward.
- 25:47But of course, we know that in Scotland, you know, the CCS, you
- 25:50know, cluster in Peterhead is languishing and, you know, we're
- 25:55seeing a lot of like issues there.
- 25:57So, you know, they're not needs to be, you know, a tough nut
- 26:01that needs to be cracked there. You know, I just in terms of
- 26:05policy. No, it's.
- 26:06And you know what we should also probably mention?
- 26:08If we're speaking about folks. Being up in in Scotland,
- 26:11apparently. Fanbulla.
- 26:12'S going to be. Up in Aberdeen on.
- 26:14Thursday it wasn't going to be up in Aberdeen on Thursday as
- 26:16well, speaking to Offshore Energy's UK's David Whitehouse
- 26:20at their their offices. In the Granite City so.
- 26:23I mean as, as Matt sort of jumped in there to say, you
- 26:26know, it is, it is a. Strong signal to the.
- 26:28Couple of days in. Government and.
- 26:29Already sort of heading up to Scotland, already engaging with
- 26:32the the the energy sector here as well, so.
- 26:36Interesting, interesting times. And so I guess that leads to the
- 26:39question of was the reaction of industry justified because, you
- 26:44know, as when. Yeah, as is when?
- 26:46The case whenever sort of big changes happen.
- 26:49Everyone claims over. Each other to to have.
- 26:51Their their say and congratulate the new appointments and make
- 26:55their. Calls for what they believe.
- 26:56Government should do, and this time was obviously no exception.
- 27:00But Erica. You've been down in Glasgow this
- 27:02week. You spoke to a couple of folks.
- 27:03Tell me what's what's happening? What's what's the?
- 27:06What's the? Vibe.
- 27:07Well, the vibe, you know, was quite interesting.
- 27:10So I was at an Energy transition Summit Co hosted by Scottish
- 27:16Renewables and so and I caught up there with a friend of energy
- 27:22voice, Paul Dileo from RG use Energy Transition Institute, and
- 27:28he's taking a very, you know, kind of measured, welcoming, you
- 27:31know, approach. But you know what, you know, the
- 27:33messaging is pretty much the same, you know, which is, you
- 27:36know, make sure that when you're approaching the energy system
- 27:40that you do it in an all energy manner.
- 27:42And you know, that's really important.
- 27:44And then you know what I was, it was interesting because I also
- 27:47caught up with Paul Wheelhouse, who is a former Scottish
- 27:52Government energy minister and he's now working at South of
- 27:57Scotland Enterprise and he's their head of energy transition.
- 28:00And he kind of came up with like a new word that I suppose, you
- 28:03know, we all kind of need, you know, to kind of the quad
- 28:06dilemma because of course for, you know, his remit, he's
- 28:10looking at how, you know, kind of rural households and
- 28:14communities power themselves. Of course, you know, they're all
- 28:20quite reliant on off grid, you know, sources of like oil and
- 28:24heating and whatnot, which is really expensive.
- 28:26So that's something that he'd like to, you know, see tackled.
- 28:29And of course, you know, he's still, you know, pretty much,
- 28:33you know, down with what, you know, the SNP would like to see
- 28:35in terms of energy transition. But he also is pragmatic about,
- 28:41you know, the need for oil and gas and would be just
- 28:45interesting to maybe hear what he has to say next.
- 28:48I think the main thing it is any economy in the world with low
- 28:51energy prices tend to have good economies.
- 28:53So low lowering the energy price for both domestic consumers and
- 28:56for industrial users is going to be critical.
- 29:00So lower the cost is going to be key.
- 29:01Having the right energy mix is going to be critical.
- 29:04So indeed have a mix between renewables, but also continued
- 29:08oil and gas because it's going to be part of the energy mix for
- 29:10years to come. Also build the network and the
- 29:13infrastructure to support us. So I think there's going to be a
- 29:15pretty full agenda for the the new Secretary of State and the
- 29:18minister to to work on. It's a very exciting agenda.
- 29:21Get it right, we get in the UK, we'll be a powerhouse.
- 29:23Get it wrong, we'll have a real issue in terms of international
- 29:26competitiveness. I mean, I think maybe and what
- 29:31do you think? You know, an an industry,
- 29:35Reindustrialization probably needs affordable power.
- 29:39Is that something that you think you know kind of can be
- 29:41delivered? Yeah, I think absolutely right.
- 29:43You look at any country in the world where they have low input
- 29:46cost in terms of energy, the economy tends to do well.
- 29:49The country with high energy costs don't tend to do so well.
- 29:52UK is very high energy costs in the moment and there's a very
- 29:55big competitive disadvantage. So I think the government needs
- 29:59to get it right. If they want to industrialize
- 30:00the country, they need to lower the energy cost.
- 30:03Well, I think it's too important a challenge to to perhaps have a
- 30:07party political fighting over this.
- 30:09I think there's room for consensus and collaboration.
- 30:12I think important message is that we know where the angle has
- 30:15to be. It's about how you manage the
- 30:17transition fairly and justly for those within the existing
- 30:20workforce, unlike what we did in the past with with Co workers.
- 30:24We see the scars in our region of that that industry and what's
- 30:28left and it created enormous damage for generations.
- 30:31So we need to avoid that in the future.
- 30:32So it's about getting around the table and actually finding
- 30:35consensus on the way forward. And that might be perhaps not
- 30:38popular enough for, for a politician to because obviously
- 30:41used to, yeah, be politics and fighting with handbags,
- 30:45etcetera. But it's, it's actually too
- 30:47important. So I think it's about, and I
- 30:49think there has been a good track of record in the last
- 30:50three or three years of the government's working together.
- 30:53And I think that's a positive thing for both renewables and
- 30:55for oil and gas. But having a narrative that that
- 30:59that sees both as equally important and that there is a
- 31:02transition that will benefit to oil and gas workers by boosting
- 31:05renewables and that we need oil and gas in the short term, it's
- 31:08probably a sensible place to be. But you know, it was, it wasn't
- 31:12just the jewel of polls that you were speaking to there in
- 31:15Glasgow. That had their had their.
- 31:17Two cents this year, Erica. We, we had, yeah, an influx of
- 31:21comments, you know, I think. Possibly the punchiest 1.
- 31:25Would have been from Ashley Kelty the the Analyst.
- 31:29From Panmure Liberum. Who was maybe a little bit more
- 31:32disparaging, maybe a little bit. More sort of cynical.
- 31:35About about the new energy secretary's previous stances on
- 31:41on oil and gas. Specifically.
- 31:45But. You know the.
- 31:46Overall lying he was the. Most most sort of argumentative.
- 31:50If we wanted to put it that. Way and.
- 31:52Sort of, you know said. That you know, but he.
- 31:54Did say investors will keenly await approvals.
- 31:56For Jagged on Rosebank. But he said if they don't, then
- 32:00Mr. Milivand will be off to Norway.
- 32:02To explain to the Norwegians why they've they've wasted £2
- 32:05billion in development that Kier Starmer had.
- 32:08Promised. So, you know, that was, I think
- 32:10that was possibly the punchiest line that came out of, of, of
- 32:13Tuesday. Afternoon.
- 32:15Tuesday morning, Tuesday afternoon.
- 32:18But you know, we had an. Influx we had Stuart Paine.
- 32:21From the from. The NSTA, The chief executive.
- 32:25Of the regulator. Explaining that it is a crucial
- 32:27time. For the oil and gas industry as
- 32:29well as. The Energy Transition Space and
- 32:32of course Offshore Energies UK was urging urging for support.
- 32:36Specifically on tax. But you know, it wasn't, it was,
- 32:40it was slightly more welcoming. There wasn't any examples.
- 32:43That I could see from the renewable side of things that
- 32:45was as punchy as Kelty's. Stance on.
- 32:49Fan Bulla's oil and gas background I saw Tara Singh the
- 32:54sort of arguing for removal of certain.
- 32:57Costs. From from this sort of network
- 33:01for I think she said unnecessary.
- 33:03Costs out of the system. So she called for that, you
- 33:06know, at a time when transmission charges are a big
- 33:08deal, as well as various other. Things are sort of impacting.
- 33:12Offshore wind projects and other renewable projects that we
- 33:15discussed. But Floyd?
- 33:17You wanted to speak about hydrogen and hydrogen.
- 33:19U KS chief executive Claire. Jackson also highlighted an
- 33:23issue, which is Where the hell is that hydrogen strategy?
- 33:28Yeah, I mean, we also won't be thanking Ed Miliband for too
- 33:30many things I can imagine in the oil and gas sector.
- 33:33And that will probably like transcend into hydrogen to like
- 33:36she's got tons of homework to do now, like hydrogen strategy
- 33:40refresh, which obviously was funny that it's delayed because
- 33:43they didn't even need to like announce that they was doing a
- 33:45refresh. Like they could have just
- 33:46dropped it when it was ready. That's LED into delays of
- 33:49obviously the cash for hydrogen allocation round two winners.
- 33:53It's delayed the third's allocation round.
- 33:56But also there's further delays to the hydrogen business
- 33:59transport model, which the likes of Caden are relying on to build
- 34:02into the like CCS and hydrogen projects like high net.
- 34:07So yeah, she's got a lot of homework to do.
- 34:09I think Hydrogen UK basically had like a massive sign saying
- 34:13like we are here, like, please look at us.
- 34:15Like we're not forgotten. But obviously they've they've
- 34:20put positive spin on it, like trying to pair the hydrogen roll
- 34:25out with reindustrialisation. So they'll be hoping that that
- 34:29that sticks. But yeah, plenty of work to do
- 34:32for Miata on the renewables front in terms of hydrogen.
- 34:35One thing I'd like to get everyone's thoughts on as well
- 34:38is what we think the, I guess the, the media's kind of how the
- 34:43media will handle Fambulla compared to because obviously Ed
- 34:45Miliband has a lot of history in British politics, you know, Red
- 34:48Ed, the bacon, Sannie, all all that.
- 34:50So I think we are coming into energy secretary role in 2024.
- 34:53People already had preconceived notions about Ed Miliband.
- 34:56But I thought it was interesting, you know, the PNJ,
- 35:00our sister publication in Aberdeen, went with Burnham puts
- 35:03the fate of North Sea in rookie MPs, these hands, which, you
- 35:07know, I think that was probably a bit of a rough headline.
- 35:13Actually, I think, I think, I think so.
- 35:14I think that I was actually going to call attention to that
- 35:17in the oil and gas section. As well, because obviously the
- 35:20PNG has been has. Campaigned in the past as.
- 35:23Well, about the windfall tax, as we've seen in the northeast of
- 35:26Scotland, you know sort of job cuts as a as a result of
- 35:29companies sort of reduce sort of reducing investment and so on
- 35:32and so forth, things that we've spoken.
- 35:34About in the past. But yeah, I do think that was a
- 35:36maybe. A little bit of a.
- 35:37Slightly slightly too. Punchy line?
- 35:40Maybe if I was. Going to if I was going to
- 35:41criticize my colleagues and I. Do wonder if, you know,
- 35:47obviously we've now got two women on the front benches for
- 35:50energy who've got me out of a bullet and Claire Cantino, I
- 35:53wonder if a, you know, a male MP coming into the role would be
- 35:56described as a rookie or would he be described as a rising
- 35:59star, you know, So I just think it'll be interesting to see how
- 36:03the media actually, you know, down down South in, in London,
- 36:07who've obviously some of the newspapers down there have been
- 36:10very, very critical of Ed is a Miliband is a net 0 zealot.
- 36:14So it'll be interesting to see how they they handle.
- 36:17I believe. I you know, I believe, and maybe
- 36:19this is me being naive, but I think that.
- 36:22Largely the the papers that you would have seen sort of
- 36:26lambasting Ed Miliband on the front page.
- 36:29We'll continue to. Do so with Fambulla.
- 36:31But maybe it'll be moved back a couple of pages.
- 36:33Because less people know who she is, is maybe the thing.
- 36:36Like you say, Miliband had that sort of had that sort of
- 36:40celebrity status status run for run in a general election.
- 36:46As leader of the as leader of the Labour Party, he obviously
- 36:50had that slight political rivalry with his own brother and
- 36:53bacon. Sandwiches and so on and so
- 36:54forth. We've seen we've seen him plenty
- 36:57of times. Before people knew who.
- 36:58He was the average. Person walking into I.
- 37:01Was going to say WH Smith's it's now TG Jones to pick up.
- 37:05A newspaper would. Would recognize his face.
- 37:08It might take a. Bit of time.
- 37:10For people to associate Fanbulla.
- 37:12With. Who?
- 37:13What she actually is. I, for one, am hoping, you know,
- 37:16kind of for perhaps less patronizing coverage of the
- 37:21Energy secretary, but just to, you know, put it out there.
- 37:26We've also issued an invitation to her to perhaps if she wanted
- 37:30to join us for the 2027 Women in New Energy.
- 37:35That's what we're aiming for. So I just thought I'd like
- 37:38mention that we're really kind of thinking that this would be a
- 37:40good thing to do. Well, that's.
- 37:42Maybe that's a positive note to end on.
- 37:44We've, I think we've had a well-rounded.
- 37:45Discussion today we've. Spoken about the good.
- 37:47The bad and the ugly of the Wild West.
- 37:51That is Westminster so. Thank you very much, everyone,
- 37:54for joining me. That's Matt.
- 37:55Erica. Floyd, Michael, and thank you.
- 37:57Very much. For listening, you'd like to.
- 38:00Stay up to date with everything that's happening in Westminster.
- 38:02And across the energy sector. Throughout the week, well,
- 38:05energyboys.com is the place to go and if you want to hear from
- 38:08us again. Well, we'll see you same time,
- 38:10same place next week.