Latest / The Vegan Report / Why Vegans Are Smarter. With Chris Bryant | Ep. 111
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening
- 0:03to The Vegan Report. Today we're asking a fun
- 0:07and maybe slightly provocative question. Are
- 0:11vegans smarter than most people? You've probably
- 0:15seen those articles listing brilliant minds who
- 0:19were vegetarian for ethical reasons. People like
- 0:23Einstein, Tolstoy, Mary Shelley or Leonardo da
- 0:27Vinci. And if you've been with us for a while,
- 0:31you might remember episode 37, where we talked
- 0:35about one of those great minds, the literary
- 0:39genius Al -Ma 'ri, often considered the first
- 0:42vegan in recorded history. So today we're wondering,
- 0:47did their intellect lead them to the ethical
- 0:51principles we hold? And beyond these outliers,
- 0:55Do we see the same pattern in the general population?
- 1:00To explore this topic, I'm joined by Chris Bryant.
- 1:04Chris is a social scientist and an expert on
- 1:07meat reduction and alternative proteins. He leads
- 1:11Bryant Research and he's also a prolific creator
- 1:14on YouTube. I actually joined him during one
- 1:18of his livestreams to record this episode. It
- 1:21was my first time doing a livestream, so that
- 1:25was an adventure in itself. You can find links
- 1:29to connect with Chris in the episode notes. In
- 1:33our conversation, we talked about the relationship
- 1:36between intelligence and veganism. We got into
- 1:41talking about psychopaths, the dangers of animal
- 1:44activism, cannibalism, his experiences debating
- 1:48the meatheads of the internet. and a whole lot
- 1:52more. Make sure to follow and subscribe to the
- 1:55show so you never miss an episode, and share
- 1:58this episode with the smart vegans in your life.
- 2:02If you enjoyed the podcast, leave a 5 star review,
- 2:06it really helps. And feel free to email me your
- 2:09thoughts or reactions at theveganreportpodcast
- 2:13at gmail .com. I read every message. Someone
- 2:17recently emailed that the mid -episode ads were
- 2:21too annoying, so I turned them off. Always happy
- 2:25to make your listening experience better. Thank
- 2:29you all so much. Enjoy the conversation. The
- 2:45first one was co -authored by that Gale professor
- 2:50who I tried to get on my podcast. I messaged
- 2:53her, I sent her like a thousand emails, but she
- 2:56never responded. And I feel like there was some
- 2:59tension between the researchers in doing that
- 3:02research. I don't know why. I'm reminded of reading
- 3:07something about how there was tension between
- 3:10those researchers, how they did not agree on
- 3:14lots of things about animal rights and veganism
- 3:18and all of that. Anyway, so maybe that's because
- 3:23that's why she never replied to my emails. And
- 3:27then you also shared a study about cognitive
- 3:30decline or something like that related to meat
- 3:34consumption. So yeah, maybe to start, you could
- 3:38maybe discuss, we could discuss those two studies.
- 3:42How did they come? on your radar and why did
- 3:46you decide to share them on LinkedIn? Yes. All
- 3:51right. Yeah, let's get into it. Yeah, the last
- 3:53part of the question is an interesting one. There
- 3:55was definitely some people who were pleased to
- 3:58see this news and some people who are certainly
- 4:00not pleased to see this news of the association
- 4:02between a higher cognitive function and likely
- 4:05to being vegetarian, basically vegetarian or
- 4:07vegan. So there was two, there was So I shared
- 4:11three studies and then I also commented on a
- 4:14fourth, which I think is what we were talking
- 4:15about with the cognitive decline, which somebody
- 4:18else had shared. So the first two that I shared
- 4:22were associations between meat consumption and
- 4:28lower cognitive function, as the authors gently
- 4:32put it. And those are just correlative and showing
- 4:36that generally people who were self -identifying
- 4:39as vegetarian or vegan performed better at various
- 4:44cognitive challenges that are given. So there
- 4:48was some, almost like a test within the survey
- 4:50that people took and the people who self -identify
- 4:53as vegetarian or vegan did better in the test.
- 4:56Now, funnily enough, a lot of people, I connect
- 5:00with a lot of what I call meatheads. on the,
- 5:03on LinkedIn, just because I like a bit of back
- 5:05and forth and I like a bit of debate on the posts.
- 5:07I see them in your comments. Yes, indeed. Yeah.
- 5:11Yeah. And so there was a lot of them coming on.
- 5:14And the main thing that they seem to be commenting
- 5:17was that this is correlative and it's not proof
- 5:21of causation, which to me was strange because
- 5:24I had never interpreted these as being, you will
- 5:28become more intelligent if you go vegetarian
- 5:30or vegan. That's not. what I ever thought of
- 5:32it. I always assumed that if anything is probably
- 5:35the opposite, right? You have some level of intelligence,
- 5:39which is largely genetic. And if you have a higher
- 5:42level of intelligence, you're more likely to
- 5:44go vegetarian or vegan. So I was always thinking
- 5:47of it as the other way around. So the main bit
- 5:50of criticism that I was getting from, from the
- 5:52meatheads that I didn't really think was particularly
- 5:54relevant. Yeah, that's so weird because When
- 5:58we, when it comes time to define intelligence,
- 6:02we don't agree on much, but we do agree that
- 6:05it is biological. It's genetics. It's you're
- 6:09born with a certain level of intelligence and
- 6:11it's a constant in your life. There isn't much
- 6:14you can do about for increasing IQ points or
- 6:18sometimes there's a decrease too, but it's marginal.
- 6:21So yeah, you can't become more intelligent by
- 6:24eating a vegan diet. Yeah, that should be a given.
- 6:29That's super interesting. Okay. I'd assumed there's
- 6:31probably some things that you could do to move
- 6:34it a little bit in either direction, but you're
- 6:36saying it's pretty marginal compared to basically
- 6:39a genetic baseline, hey? Exactly. Yeah. You inherit
- 6:42that from your parents. That's a immutable trait,
- 6:46your height or the color of your eyes. Okay.
- 6:50Yeah, yeah. Makes sense. So yeah, that main criticism,
- 6:54and I think a lot of the pro -meat people are
- 6:59used to and programmed to make that criticism
- 7:01because that's what they say to a lot of the
- 7:06health evidence that's shared where vegetarians
- 7:09and vegans have lower risk of cancer and heart
- 7:11disease and overall mortality. And they like
- 7:13to say this is associative, it doesn't prove
- 7:15causation, which is true in a sense. But if you
- 7:18have a ton of epidemiological evidence showing
- 7:20that there's these associations with living longer,
- 7:23basically, and eating a plant -based diet. And
- 7:25then you have some also some plausible mechanisms
- 7:27by which that happens with LDL cholesterol and
- 7:30stuff like this. And you do have some randomized
- 7:34studies where you see eating meat or eating plant
- 7:37-based meat instead of meat. low LDL cholesterol
- 7:41and lower BMI and stuff like this over a relatively
- 7:43short period, it starts to build a pretty solid
- 7:47case that, okay, there probably is some causation
- 7:49going on here. So those are all things which,
- 7:54yeah, again, I think that the pro -meat people
- 7:56are quite reflexively make that criticism, oh,
- 7:59you can't prove causation from this. And in this
- 8:02case, we're not saying that going vegan is going
- 8:04to make you smarter. You're more likely to go
- 8:06vegan if you are smarter. That's the claim. And
- 8:09someone said to me, in that case, what's the
- 8:12point? Like, why is this compelling? Why is this
- 8:14something worth sharing? And I said, I think
- 8:17it's like, it ought to give people pause to think.
- 8:22If vegetarians and vegans tend to be smarter
- 8:23on average, maybe they've got a point. And the
- 8:27example I gave was to say that if I read a study
- 8:30that said, flat earthers have 10 IQ points more
- 8:34on average. I might think. Maybe I should have
- 8:37another look at that Flat Earth stuff. They seem
- 8:39to know what they're talking about. So those
- 8:43are the first two and then the third study was
- 8:45really more likely showing causation in the other
- 8:49way as we discussed where children with higher
- 8:52IQ were more likely to grow up to be vegetarian.
- 8:56I think there were IQ tests at the age of 10
- 8:58and then those with higher IQ were more likely
- 9:00to be vegetarian at the age of 30. So again,
- 9:03it's the intelligence causing the vegetarianism,
- 9:05veganism, not the other way around. So those
- 9:08were in line with what I had theorized about
- 9:11intelligence. And then I saw that other study
- 9:13about cognitive decline, which did seem to be
- 9:16saying that there's more something going in the
- 9:19other direction. I guess cognitive decline in
- 9:21older age is probably a bit of a special case
- 9:24because clearly you are having some change in
- 9:27IQ, which presumably is influenced to some extent
- 9:30by environmental factors. And this was shared
- 9:33by somebody on LinkedIn just like a week after
- 9:37I had been doing my own IQ posting. And that
- 9:40did seem to suggest that basically plant -based
- 9:42diets have some sort of protective factor for
- 9:45against cognitive decline in old age. So it's
- 9:49possible that there is some sort of causation
- 9:50going in that direction, particularly when it
- 9:52comes to old age. But yeah, that was a novel
- 9:55angle on it for me. I don't know how much we
- 10:00can differentiate intelligence and certain cognitive
- 10:04functions like memory. I think it's expected
- 10:07that you will lose certain abilities going up
- 10:11because of aging and also environmental factors.
- 10:14If you hit your head, or if you decide to make
- 10:18a career out of boxing, then expect to lose some
- 10:23cognitive abilities. But then does it affect
- 10:26your intelligence per se, like your intellectual
- 10:30potential that I don't have an answer to that
- 10:33question. Yeah, interesting. And there's a bit
- 10:38of different types of intelligence and different
- 10:41types of cognitive functions that, from my understanding,
- 10:44they tend to correlate together such that like
- 10:47higher IQ people tend to have better memories,
- 10:50although they're distinct functions. I'm interested
- 10:54to hear more from you about what you think of
- 10:56all of this as the intelligence expert here.
- 10:58I'm not an intelligence expert, but I've read
- 11:02more about this topic than most people. And yeah,
- 11:07I think there are so many preconceived ideas
- 11:11around intelligence. The reason why that association
- 11:16I mentioned earlier, the Quebec Association for
- 11:18Giftedness exists is because many people who
- 11:22are born gifted are not born with the psychosocial
- 11:27framework to manage their giftedness and their
- 11:31cognitive abilities. What do I mean by that?
- 11:34I've seen so many cases of, let's say, school
- 11:39children getting bored out of their mind in the
- 11:43classroom and developing some behavioral issues
- 11:47from that. And so they can't follow what the
- 11:51teacher is saying because they are already 10
- 11:53steps ahead. and so they start doing other things
- 11:58and then the teacher notices that behavior doesn't
- 12:03know a thing about intelligence or giftedness
- 12:07and so recommends the child to a psychologist
- 12:09who also doesn't know a thing about giftedness
- 12:12and the child gets diagnosed as ADHD or I've
- 12:18seen schizophrenia, I've seen a dissociative
- 12:21disorder. There's a long list of false diagnosis
- 12:26that are put on gifted people and it's damaging.
- 12:31They carry that their entire life, ignorant of
- 12:34their own self. And so yeah, there is that. I've
- 12:37seen so many cases of self sabotaging. So you
- 12:41have school children who are trying to fit in.
- 12:45And in order to do that, they stop using big
- 12:48words. They put the wrong answers in exam questions
- 12:52because they don't want to be the child with
- 12:55always the A+. They feel like that would ostracize
- 12:59them even more. In some schools, they will take
- 13:03the child and put that child in a higher grade.
- 13:06And that may be damaging to the development of
- 13:10that child because all of a sudden you're with
- 13:12another age group. And so it is a struggle. It's
- 13:17an incredible struggle when you start getting
- 13:19into the nuances of what it feels like and what
- 13:23is it like to be a person with a giftedness or
- 13:27higher intellectual potential. By the way, the
- 13:31definition for that, the clinical definition
- 13:36for that is basically being, if you have a curve
- 13:40in IQ distribution curve, the bottom 2 .5%. Here
- 13:46in Quebec, Canada, the number that we have selected
- 13:49is 2 .5%. In France, it's 5%. But 2 .5 % at the
- 13:55bottom are considered what we call intellectual
- 13:57disabled people. It's an official diagnosis,
- 14:01they get support from the government, including
- 14:02financial support to go through life. There are
- 14:06some institutions that, you know, screen for
- 14:09that, for instance, the army, you cannot, you're
- 14:11not admitted in the army if you're considered
- 14:14intellectually disabled, but then there's the
- 14:17top of that curve at the top 2 .5%. And that's
- 14:21what we consider being gifted or having high
- 14:25intellectual potential. And that's where it gets
- 14:28tricky because if you look at the difference
- 14:31between the bottom of that curve and the average
- 14:34IQ, it's the same difference as the average IQ
- 14:37and the top of that curve. And so you understand
- 14:40how those people live Bit in a different world
- 14:45bit in a different dimension. So they're very
- 14:48much part of that of what we call the neurodivergent
- 14:52spectrum yet, I think Society has the wrong reaction
- 14:58to intelligence. They think of it When you say
- 15:02my child is gifted you get some bad looks from
- 15:06people around because it feels like you're bragging
- 15:09about your child. You're not bragging. It's actually
- 15:12the cognitive reality of your child. Again, it's
- 15:17just like any other trait. Your child is tall.
- 15:20He's also gifted. He was born like that. We're
- 15:25also in a culture, Christian culture, where humility
- 15:29is really important value. Talking about being
- 15:34gifted is not very popular. So it's not a very
- 15:37popular thing to highlight the struggles of gifted
- 15:42people, but it's essential because there are
- 15:46some theories that have been studied and people
- 15:53have been writing about that since the 1800s
- 15:57of how The average IQ in a society is the greatest
- 16:01indicator of the success of that society, of
- 16:04that country, how it is related to wealth production
- 16:08of higher standards of living. And so you need
- 16:12to value the smartest people in your society
- 16:15and give them a space where they can be themselves
- 16:19and not feel like doing self sabotaging stuff
- 16:24and in order to fit in. Yeah. That's how I would
- 16:29summarize the current state of intelligence and
- 16:34high intellectual potential. And so what got
- 16:38me interested going back to the topic of vegetarianism
- 16:42and veganism is you see so many of those outliners
- 16:46like Einstein, Newton, Mary Shelley, and also
- 16:50I've seen people who were officially diagnosed
- 16:54as gifted in the community of that association
- 16:57and so on, being interested or being vegetarian,
- 17:02being vegan or being interested in that. And
- 17:06the reaction I generally I get from those people
- 17:10is different from that of the average person,
- 17:14which is a reaction of openness to the idea of
- 17:18becoming vegan or vegetarian. usually people
- 17:21are defensive but those people have already thought
- 17:25of it and have considered becoming and actually
- 17:29you don't need to argue with them because they
- 17:31feel that you're right and so yeah it's easier
- 17:34to make the case for vegetarianism or veganism
- 17:37like with that crowd. That's so interesting.
- 17:42Yeah. There's so many, there's so much in there.
- 17:44I'm sure people listening will be pleased to
- 17:47know people with all their various mental health
- 17:49diagnoses will be pleased to know they're in
- 17:51fact just gifted. That might be the case. Yeah,
- 17:56that could well be the case. They're so interesting
- 17:58thinking about like the different mechanisms
- 18:01by which these things might be connected. Cause
- 18:03it feels intuitive to me that There is a connection
- 18:08between high intelligence and being vegetarian
- 18:10or vegan that seems like it makes sense. It maps
- 18:14onto the reality of what I see around me. Like
- 18:18the, all of the vegans and vegans I know tend
- 18:21to be pretty smart people. I'm a little, there's
- 18:24a little bit of selection effects. I've worked
- 18:25in the field and so they're all professionals
- 18:26and stuff like that. But certainly if I think
- 18:29of the stupidest people I know, that's a very
- 18:32low rate of veganism amongst them. The openness
- 18:35thing is definitely. There's something that's
- 18:38been proposed as a, as a mechanism for that critical
- 18:42thinking also where it's much easier to accept
- 18:49for it's true. You've got to be careful with
- 18:52the polite words to speak about this way. Average
- 18:55intelligence people that say there's lots of
- 18:57signals that everybody else eats meat. And so
- 18:59it must be fine. That's a midway of thinking
- 19:03about it, right. And that seems to be correct
- 19:06and doesn't like you have to be a little bit
- 19:08smart to think that you know, that doesn't follow.
- 19:09That's not how that works. Sensitivity also somebody
- 19:13has proposed like more intelligent people tend
- 19:15to be more sensitive, more sensitive people to
- 19:17tend to be more, more empathetic, I guess, more
- 19:20like to be vegetarian and vegan. So there's all
- 19:22of these potential like plausible mechanisms
- 19:26that connect the two. I've also heard it said
- 19:29that I don't know how true this is, but higher
- 19:32intelligence people can actually be better at
- 19:37doing cognitive dissonance and motivated reasoning.
- 19:39Because if I want to think of a reason why it's
- 19:41okay for me to eat meat, I can think of loads
- 19:43of them straight away because I'm smart. So there
- 19:46could be some things going in the other direction,
- 19:47but it's not like what you reflect in the data
- 19:49where you'd see all the intelligent people less
- 19:51likely to be vegetarian. But yeah, there's all
- 19:53these things, openness, sensitivity, critical
- 19:56thinking that appear to be. Ways that could happen
- 20:00and does seem to happen. Yeah. And we should
- 20:04say being smarter doesn't mean that everything
- 20:07you do or say is smarter. Yep. But the thing
- 20:12is most smart ideas out there innovations and
- 20:16so on usually come from smarter people. That's
- 20:22a bit of adding some nuance to, to all of them.
- 20:25And yeah, the point about hypersensitivity. Yes,
- 20:30definitely. It's a kind of a defining characteristic
- 20:34of being having a higher intellectual potential
- 20:38is hypersensitivity. And that means a greater
- 20:42connection to the realities of other people around
- 20:46you, including animals. There's also a definition
- 20:49of intelligence as greater ability to adapt.
- 20:53to different realities, conditions, environments.
- 20:58That's interesting. That means there's more flexibility
- 21:01and more space for change in your life. It's
- 21:05not very rigid. You can definitely switch to
- 21:09a vegan diet easily than maybe a person with
- 21:14less of that intellectual, cognitive flexibility,
- 21:19adaptability. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense.
- 21:23Yeah. More, you'll be more able to actually deal
- 21:26with it and do the things that are necessary
- 21:28to live in a different way and stuff like that.
- 21:31One thing that I noticed on those posts and related
- 21:34to something that you said, a lot of people were
- 21:38very, I don't know if defensive is the right
- 21:41word, but critical of the idea that IQ or intelligence,
- 21:46let's say IQ. the idea that IQ is relevant or
- 21:50like maps onto anything that we care about. It
- 21:52seems to me obvious that it would, right? You're
- 21:56going to tend to be able to have a higher income
- 21:59and have like pretty more able to maintain social
- 22:01relationships and stuff like this. I would have
- 22:03thought that IQ is awfully well correlated with
- 22:07a lot of the different outcomes that we might
- 22:09care about, but a lot of people seem to contend
- 22:11that's not the case. I don't know if that's just
- 22:13cope or what do you think of that? I think it's
- 22:17a stupid idea. That's what I think as a baseline
- 22:21SAT scores. I don't know if you have that in
- 22:23the UK, a version of that, but academic success,
- 22:27most exams in the academic field are basically
- 22:30IQ tests. If you do good in those exams, you
- 22:34get better grades and better chances in life
- 22:36because you have a higher degree. So just as
- 22:39a baseline, we can agree that is a true sign
- 22:42of success. If you're able to succeed in school
- 22:46and succeed in completing those little IQ tests,
- 22:50then yeah, you will get better prospects in life.
- 22:54And then yeah, there is a lot of pushback against
- 22:57the IQ tests. but there are also lots of myths
- 23:00around IQ and it's a whole history and I think
- 23:05the IQ test has been misused in the past in so
- 23:10many contexts. There are qualified psychologists
- 23:14and neuropsychologists that specialize in giftedness
- 23:18and that can basically administer IQ tests to
- 23:24patients who might be gifted. And I think that's
- 23:29the best. If we want to talk about IQ tests,
- 23:33that's the best IQ test that we have out there.
- 23:36Those tests done under the supervision of those
- 23:41qualified professionals, health professionals.
- 23:44That's the golden standard. And then anything
- 23:48else, there is a subject for debate. Mensa has
- 23:53an IQ test. Mensa is this organization where
- 23:56I think you need 130 IQ to get in or something
- 24:02like that. So they have an IQ test. Their members
- 24:05have to complete successfully in order to get
- 24:09in. But again, that's not a test done under the
- 24:13supervision of health professionals. That's not
- 24:16a test that was crafted by experts in the field.
- 24:21There is skepticism around those kinds of IQ
- 24:24tests and of course there are so many IQ tests
- 24:27online that you can try for free. Now it has
- 24:32become common to administer IQ tests to potential
- 24:36employees for potential job prospects. Again,
- 24:41I feel like that those kinds of tests have no
- 24:45legitimacy to them. They're not a real indicator
- 24:49of intelligence and intelligence is cannot be
- 24:55only captured by a test. It's also creativity.
- 24:59How do you measure creativity in someone potential
- 25:03to imagine and be innovative? That's IQ tests
- 25:09are not designed for that. Yeah. I would say
- 25:13some words of caution about IQ tests, but let's
- 25:16not reject them completely. Yeah, that makes
- 25:22sense. And I can see why people would, I can
- 25:27see the motivation to be skeptical of it. Like
- 25:29it's not a particularly comforting story, particularly
- 25:33if it is like largely genetic and there's not
- 25:36much you can do to change it. I can see why people
- 25:39would not want to believe that this is something
- 25:40that's going to be heavily correlated with all
- 25:42sorts of success in your life. But yeah, you
- 25:44mentioned about the school tests and the military
- 25:47tests and everything like clearly this is something
- 25:50that's considered by institutions to be of relevance.
- 25:53So yeah, I think I would be terribly surprised
- 25:55if IQ is not important in a lot of things that
- 25:58we care about in life. But it's also I can see
- 26:00why it's fraught to talk about. I can see why
- 26:03it's like not politically correct to talk about
- 26:06like me teachers having a lower IQ, for example.
- 26:10I agree. And the thing is, again, those preconceived
- 26:13Notions about intelligence is just a trait. It's
- 26:16more fundamental to your identity than height,
- 26:20because it's your cognitive structure. It's deeper
- 26:25than that. But what are your priorities in life?
- 26:31Do you want to be happy? Because being intelligent
- 26:34is not a guarantee of happiness. Far from it.
- 26:38There's so many studies that show how Smarter
- 26:42people get more depressed, more anxious and the
- 26:46list goes on. So why? Yeah. Yeah. And even the
- 26:53flavor of depression that smarter people experience
- 26:56is one of the worst ones, which is existential
- 26:59depression. How do you address existential depression?
- 27:03So hard not to crack. So yeah, it's just one
- 27:06other trait of your identity. And I think we
- 27:09put too much emphasis on that. Yeah, that's interesting.
- 27:15Actually, that's interesting to mention because
- 27:17I've seen research talking about the link between
- 27:20vegetarianism and depression. And I think that
- 27:23is the likely mechanism. I don't think it's ever
- 27:27been proposed that is some sort of nutritional
- 27:29deficiency that makes you more likely to be depressed
- 27:31or something like that. It's more both of those
- 27:34things are correlated with higher intelligence
- 27:36or higher sensitivity. Yeah, if you are, if you
- 27:40have that kind of mind, you're more likely to
- 27:43be vegetarian and you're also more likely to
- 27:44be depressed. And that's like the link between
- 27:46those things rather than anything else, which
- 27:49people like to suggest all sorts of reasons why
- 27:51that might be. But yeah, that makes a lot of
- 27:53sense. Do you think that bottom line talking
- 27:57about veganism and vegetarianism as something
- 28:02adopted by more intelligent people, do you think
- 28:06that harms the cause? or will get more positive
- 28:10attention around the cause? Yes, good question.
- 28:15I'm open to being either way on this. Somebody
- 28:19said to me, vegetarians and vegans already suffer
- 28:23a bit from their reputation of being holier than
- 28:25thou and higher mighty and stuff like this. Maybe
- 28:28this is not really something like an idea that
- 28:31you want to be popularizing, which certainly
- 28:34could be true. I think from my perspective, the
- 28:39most likely effect, if there is one, and I think
- 28:43it's probably pretty marginal, is this idea that,
- 28:49hang on a minute, if that's what the smart people
- 28:51are doing, maybe there's something to it, right?
- 28:53And like I said, if there was a higher IQ amongst
- 28:56flat earthers that might give people reason to
- 28:59think twice about that. So I think to me, that
- 29:02seems like the most intuitive thing. Really,
- 29:05if there's any pattern of beliefs that are associated
- 29:10with people from our IQ, I would think that's
- 29:13worth having a look at. But yeah, who knows on
- 29:17like aggregate, is this just something that will
- 29:21upset people more and make people dislike vegetarians
- 29:24and vegans more? It's worth saying as well. I
- 29:28think that people can put too much stock in what
- 29:32makes veterans or vegans more likable. Like certainly
- 29:36that's relevant to some degree. You do want to
- 29:41be the type of person that people want to be
- 29:44like, I suppose, is how that translates onto
- 29:46kind of advocacy. But I really think that people
- 29:49can do that too much to the detriment of other
- 29:54things. If you're encouraging people to look
- 29:58at factory farming and slaughterhouse footage,
- 30:00People don't like that and people won't really
- 30:03appreciate if you hold that up to them while
- 30:05they're eating their dinner But that will make
- 30:08them more likely to get vegetarian or vegan if
- 30:09they are forced to look at it Likeability for
- 30:12if you're vegetarian or vegan can only get you
- 30:14so far. I think and there's People It's nice
- 30:20to be liked right people like to be liked and
- 30:23people it's nice to be nice and stuff like this.
- 30:25I think that especially probably vegetarians
- 30:29and vegans tend to be, I actually haven't looked
- 30:32at data on this, but I imagine more agreeable
- 30:34and more wanting to be, have peaceful interactions
- 30:38and stuff like this. So I actually don't think
- 30:40that it comes very naturally to the type of person
- 30:43who goes vegetarian or vegan to do the confrontational
- 30:47kind of activism, for example. And certainly
- 30:50it doesn't probably make you more likable, but
- 30:52I do think that it's a good thing from the perspective
- 30:55of animals. And yeah, I think it's If I had to
- 30:58bet, and again, I'm guessing here, if I had to
- 31:01bet it would be a similar thing on pointing out
- 31:03that vegetarians and vegans tend to be more intelligent,
- 31:06that it may not make you the most popular person
- 31:08in the room to say that, but it might well be
- 31:10giving people pause for thoughts and thinking
- 31:12maybe that's something else to think about more.
- 31:15Interesting, because I know that the other side,
- 31:18big ag or pro meat people, they often use intelligence
- 31:23as an argument to promote meat eating. and they
- 31:28use it to disparage, basically becoming vegan
- 31:31or vegetarian. They talk about eating plants
- 31:34as a trigger for reduced cognitive abilities.
- 31:39The Jordan Peterson of this world talk literally
- 31:42about brain shrinking. I've heard that a lot.
- 31:46Interesting. So they are using intelligence against
- 31:50us. So why not fight fire with fire? Yeah, a
- 31:55hundred percent. So as you haven't heard too
- 31:57much of that version, I've heard people say meeting
- 32:00me to enabled us to evolve our brains and stuff
- 32:03like that, which okay, that's not going to be
- 32:06that relevant for today's context or like on
- 32:09an individual level. This is going to make you
- 32:11more intelligent or something. People often try
- 32:14to make that inference, but yeah, but yeah, I
- 32:20think I agree with the spirit of what you're
- 32:22saying. There's definitely all sorts of things
- 32:27in this category where the idea is tell vegetarians
- 32:32and vegans shut up about that. And we know that
- 32:37we can get you to shut up about it if we give
- 32:39you the idea that it will be bad and her vegetarianism,
- 32:42right? People say, Oh, if you show me the slaughterhouse,
- 32:44I'm going to eat more meat. It's like, are you
- 32:46really going, presumably you're eating as much
- 32:47meat as you want to eat. Are you going to now
- 32:50eat more meat than you wanted to eat because
- 32:52of the vegan upset you? Probably not. So I think
- 32:55that more often than not, those like hypothetical
- 32:59dangers of bringing up a sensibly pro vegetarian
- 33:02or vegan talking points are just that like efforts
- 33:06to put you off from talking about it. I've seen
- 33:10a bunch of evidence that looking at slaughterhouse
- 33:12and factory farming footage makes people more
- 33:14likely to go vegetarian or vegan. Like it seems,
- 33:16it seems too obvious to say. And yet, it's not
- 33:21a rare idea that, oh, actually that's going to
- 33:24make people dig in and give people cognitive
- 33:26dissonance, and they're going to be more likely
- 33:27to eat more meat and stuff like this. That's
- 33:29just bollocks. And that is exactly what I would
- 33:31say if I was trying to get vegetarians and vegans
- 33:33to shut up about that, because I don't want them
- 33:35to say that, because I want my meat company to
- 33:37sell more meat, for example. So I always try
- 33:40and think about what the other side do, what
- 33:42the other side is saying, exactly as you mentioned.
- 33:44And yeah, I think it's too easy sometimes to
- 33:47put off vegetarians and vegans from doing the
- 33:49thing that is very effective by just lying and
- 33:52saying that it's not effective or that it's counterproductive.
- 33:55That's such a relevant point because we behave
- 33:58too much as if the enemy, so to speak, is inactive,
- 34:03is passive, completely passive and is not listening.
- 34:06Like I've had the discussion with a guest once.
- 34:09I feel torn about having those all of those great
- 34:13animal rights activists on my podcast, including
- 34:15you, to discuss animal rights activism, because
- 34:18I know that Big Ag might be listening to all
- 34:22of those conversations and taking notes as they
- 34:25should be doing. And so am I helping the enemy
- 34:28by putting everything on public display? Am I
- 34:31doing more wrong than good? I don't think so.
- 34:37I think certainly once you get to a certain size
- 34:41of audience, it's sensible to assume that the
- 34:46enemy is listening to anything that you're doing
- 34:48publicly. There ought to be a lot of stuff that
- 34:53we don't necessarily say publicly that is useful
- 34:57for us to know inside the animal movement, but
- 35:00that we wouldn't publicize or want to make a
- 35:03headline out of, for example. We had hoped that
- 35:06your guests are exercising some discretion and
- 35:08not saying those things publicly. But yeah, I
- 35:10think they're, they're certainly, they ought
- 35:13to be listening if they're not right. It would
- 35:15make sense. It's going to be, maximize their
- 35:17goals. But that said, I think that there are
- 35:23some things that are worth communicating anyway.
- 35:28And yeah, we get, we're speaking more to the
- 35:31people on our side and it's, we're speaking in
- 35:34mind with the enemy might be listening, but we
- 35:37can't let that. stop us from speaking to each
- 35:40other at all publicly there's a bunch of stuff
- 35:43that's useful for us to say publicly and useful
- 35:45for us to promote and pay for posters and get
- 35:48the message out as far as we can then there's
- 35:50a smaller set of stuff that's useful for us to
- 35:54say to each other in private but not on a live
- 35:56stream so yeah then there's stuff that you should
- 36:00probably keep between yourself and your guard
- 36:04Animal Liberation Front Press Office, North American
- 36:08Press Office. If you visit their website, they
- 36:10have a whole section dedicated to online privacy
- 36:14and how to stop some prying party from stealing
- 36:20data from you or surveilling you or spying on
- 36:23what you're doing. And I haven't found that anywhere
- 36:28else through those steps we could take of cybersecurity,
- 36:32for instance, to just protect ourselves against
- 36:35the big ag hackers out there who might be interested
- 36:40in our data, what we're sharing in our group
- 36:43conversations and all of that. And so maybe that's
- 36:47something we should put in place more widely
- 36:49the movement. Yeah, that's a good point. I think
- 36:55it's prudent to assume like in vegan Discord
- 36:59servers and stuff like that, for example, be
- 37:01aware that the enemy might be listening. I've
- 37:04always considered that it would be a great honor
- 37:06to be on some sort of list, some sort of hit
- 37:08list for the for the animal egg industry. If
- 37:10I start seeing Cars with blacked out windows
- 37:13parked down my street. I'll go good. I'm doing
- 37:14the right I'm doing I'm upsetting the right people.
- 37:17But yeah, that's I haven't got to the level yet
- 37:19I don't think where security is a concern like
- 37:22that, but i'm guessing that it must be for Some
- 37:25of the top guys some of the gary erofsky's nerfling
- 37:27heads and stuff like that. They must be It's
- 37:31prudent to take some amount of security concerns,
- 37:34right because again our enemy is killers We know
- 37:39that I don't have one side was going to be more
- 37:42likely to just flat out murder the other. It's
- 37:44not going to be the peaceful vegans doing that,
- 37:46is it? Yeah. Hopefully I'll get to the stage
- 37:48where that becomes a concern. That'll be an honor.
- 37:51I've asked that once to Dr. Crystal Heath, who
- 37:54is behind Our Honor. And yeah, she said, I'm
- 37:57scared of getting attacked or followed or she
- 38:01was assassinated or something. I'm reading right
- 38:03now the autobiography of Gale. Sorry, I'm forgetting
- 38:08her last name. She was an undercover investigator
- 38:11for so many years. She wrote the book Slaughterhouses,
- 38:16and she mentioned how in many occasions she was
- 38:20scared for her life. Some slaughterhouse owner
- 38:23would find an opportunity to kidnap her or something.
- 38:28So yeah, those are concerns in our movement,
- 38:31definitely. And there are, of course, instances
- 38:33of assassinations and kidnappings and so on that
- 38:37were documented that happened to some activists.
- 38:42Reagan, something from Canada more recently was
- 38:45rolled over by a trucker who was transporting,
- 38:49I think, pigs. The guy did not go to prison for
- 38:54that. I don't think so yet. I don't know too
- 38:59much about that. I assume that was more of an
- 39:00accident than an assassination, right? Yes, you're
- 39:04right that it's, it is an accident. It was an
- 39:08accident, but was it really like, yeah, she was
- 39:12in the middle of the road. So yeah, that makes
- 39:15a wonder. Yeah, for sure. There's a couple of
- 39:18things to say on that. One is that I think it
- 39:22would be a great shame if people were to not
- 39:26speak up for fear of this kind of stuff. and
- 39:31self -censor for the remote possibility that
- 39:33there could be the wrong person from Animal Ag
- 39:35trying to get your address or whatever else.
- 39:38I think that the other side would love that and
- 39:40they would probably not grow too much cold water
- 39:45on the idea that was a deliberate murder, for
- 39:47example, because they might think it's going
- 39:50to benefit us if vegans think that we might bloody
- 39:52murder them and then they'll shut up a bit. So
- 39:55probably they wouldn't mind that idea being out
- 39:57there. And of course it would be A great shame
- 40:01to have people self censoring for fear of that
- 40:04kind of thing. I, for me, I think I would, what's
- 40:08the thing I'd rather live on my feet than die
- 40:10on my knees, that kind of thing where you don't,
- 40:12I don't think there's any, I think the threats
- 40:15would have to get pretty severe before I would
- 40:17even curtail at all what I, what I talk about.
- 40:20So that's one thing. And the other thing is it's
- 40:25pretty. If you try to think about what, occupy
- 40:32the mind of somebody who wants to do something
- 40:34nefarious to someone on the other side, right?
- 40:36Maybe we, if we were to hatch a plan to go and
- 40:38get Mr. Tyson or whatever, right? One of the
- 40:40top, one of the top dogs, we would probably quite
- 40:43quickly find that it's not really worth us going
- 40:46down that road at all, because we're going to
- 40:48take immense legal risk for some pretty marginal
- 40:53benefit really. If you would take out the top
- 40:55guy. There's going to be another top guy waiting,
- 40:58right? It's not going to be anyone. The incentives
- 41:01are not aligned for anyone, even if they're like
- 41:04paid and work for one of these companies. Why
- 41:07do I want to take the risk to go and kill some
- 41:08activist that is having a negative impact on
- 41:13my industry broadly? Like, why am I going to
- 41:16be the one to go and take that risk? It's not,
- 41:18it's almost like a tragedy of the commons thing,
- 41:20right? Let someone else do that, right? It's
- 41:22affecting us all. Why should I take the legal
- 41:24risk? So I don't think that. Realistically, it
- 41:27is quite difficult, and it's fortunate this is
- 41:29the case, it's quite difficult in a developed
- 41:32society to actually be doing anything that illegal
- 41:38or nefarious. Now, they do lots of nefarious
- 41:41stuff within the bounds of the law about spreading
- 41:44disinformation and lobbying and all this kind
- 41:47of stuff that anyone would say on reflection,
- 41:50this is bad, but it's very carefully done within
- 41:54the bounds of the law. there's no legal risk
- 41:57for these people to take basically. Yeah, I would
- 41:59be surprised if it would be worth any paid hitman
- 42:02or anyone paying a hitman to do this kind of
- 42:05thing for activists. There are some other things
- 42:07that we might be concerned about. I think that
- 42:09there probably are saboteurs and like undercover,
- 42:16like fake animal welfare activists or fake animal
- 42:19activists. And one thing I like to think about
- 42:22that is If you were going to go to the vegan
- 42:27conference or be in the vegan community and be
- 42:30trying to disrupt and create bad outcomes of
- 42:35veganism or create good outcomes for animal ag,
- 42:38what might be the ways that you would do that?
- 42:40Now, you'd have to be subtle. You have to avoid
- 42:42detection. So you can't just say, hey, everyone,
- 42:45let's forget about veganism. You have to be subtle.
- 42:49You'd have to do things that could... conceivably
- 42:53be something that a vegan might say or think,
- 42:56but that would in fact be bad for vegans and
- 43:00bad for animals, good for the industry. I think
- 43:03one example of that is anti -welfarism, for example.
- 43:08I don't know if you have particular views on
- 43:10that, but I think that it's quite easy seemingly
- 43:14to have a lot of vegans saying, our bollocks
- 43:17to any sort of welfare reforms or like cage -free
- 43:19commitments or anything like that because it's
- 43:22still bad the animals are still being exploited
- 43:24and we should basically be against this and it's
- 43:27actually quite easy to whip up a decent part
- 43:30of the animal movement to being extremely counter
- 43:33productively opposed to welfare reforms which
- 43:35are going to be expensive for the industry to
- 43:38implement and put up the price of animal products
- 43:40and make plant -based products more competitive.
- 43:42So that's something that you could do. Another
- 43:44one is this idea about like saying It's bad to
- 43:48show slaughterhouse footage. That's not going
- 43:49to make people go vegan, stuff like that. There
- 43:51seems to be a decent amount of, I don't know,
- 43:56people like to think that things are more counter
- 43:57-intuitive than they are sometimes. Oh, you would
- 43:59think this is helpful, but it's actually no,
- 44:01it is helpful. It is helpful. And there's a couple
- 44:03of others that I could think of as well that
- 44:05are like, plausibly a vegan would say this, but
- 44:09it's actually very counterproductive. The thing
- 44:11is, if you come across these ideas, if you find
- 44:14people who are Like anti -welfareism, for example.
- 44:20The chances are they're not a saboteur. The chances
- 44:22are they are probably an earnest vegan who has
- 44:26the wrong ideas. And of course, if you were a
- 44:28saboteur and you're doing your job right, there
- 44:31should be 20 times more earnest vegans who you
- 44:33managed to persuade and repeat the ideas, right?
- 44:36Plant -based meats are processed. That's another
- 44:37one that a lot of vegans are fond of saying.
- 44:40Plant -based meats are all processed foods. That's
- 44:41like a hobby horse of mine. where yes, okay,
- 44:44they're in this category called ultra processed
- 44:45foods, they're also healthier than meat. That's
- 44:47the main thing that we should all be saying plant
- 44:49based meats healthier than meat. There's a lot
- 44:50of evidence on that point now. So yeah, there's
- 44:53a few of these ideas around that are unhelpful,
- 44:58but plausibly something that a vegan might say.
- 45:01And I think disruptive and I think can be cause
- 45:03for division and stuff like this. But yeah, that's
- 45:06what I would do if I was a meat industry saboteur.
- 45:10On that on the website of the ALF press office
- 45:14and North American press office. They actually
- 45:17have another section called, I think, snitches
- 45:20something, just exposing the many FBI agents
- 45:24that went undercover to infiltrate ALF cells.
- 45:29Now, that's interesting. The whole conversation
- 45:33about sabotaging this movement is incredibly
- 45:37interesting. I think at the very least. we should
- 45:42have some strong cyber security rules, standards
- 45:47put in place. Have you read about the construction
- 45:50of, I think, the African Union headquarters?
- 45:56I think they're based in South Africa. I'm not
- 45:58sure. But it was built by a Chinese company and
- 46:02the members of that union, of that assembly political
- 46:07institution have found at some point mics inside
- 46:12the walls, potentially coming from Chinese spies.
- 46:16So when they built the building, they added mics
- 46:20everywhere behind the walls. And I would be just
- 46:24terrified to think that Mercy for Animals or
- 46:29PETA or whatever organization is being listened
- 46:33to by big PR agencies or whatever organization
- 46:39exists out there. And so I think that at the
- 46:43very least, we should just make sure that our
- 46:46cybersecurity measures are in line with industry
- 46:51standards. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. No, I haven't
- 46:56heard of that case. But yeah, that makes that
- 46:58make sense. Countries do be spying. Yeah. So
- 47:02I guess there's something that happens. And I
- 47:04do I like to put my conspiracy hat on and think
- 47:07about there could well be plants within animal
- 47:11organizations that again this is something that
- 47:13would totally make sense to do if you're the
- 47:16president of tyson or whatever right like big
- 47:19meat it would totally make sense you want to
- 47:22like plant people within organizations and i
- 47:24think the key thing is the ideas and that's why
- 47:27it's so important to have clear thinking on what
- 47:30ideas are helpful for animals and what ideas
- 47:32are not helpful for animals because The way that
- 47:35you would do it, I think, is just to try to infiltrate
- 47:39with bad ideas, try to get the animal movement
- 47:42to misspend its resources, right? They've got
- 47:44a limited amount of resources. Let's get them
- 47:46all thinking that this is like some really impactful
- 47:49thing to do. And so that they waste their resources
- 47:50on that. That'd be a great strategy if you're
- 47:53the animal industry. Yeah. Like putting them
- 47:56off the ideas that are helpful. deliberately
- 47:59holding up organizations. Like there's, yeah,
- 48:02we should read about this. I'm sure there's resources
- 48:05on what a spy would do, what a saboteur would
- 48:07do. We can be on the lookout. Yeah, that is,
- 48:12it reminds me of the tree body problem book theory.
- 48:15The aliens are listening. Yeah, a tricky situation.
- 48:19And I want to add something about the danger
- 48:23aspect of being in this movement. Yeah, I do
- 48:26believe that it's rare that you're attacked or
- 48:29something like that. But I think it's also context
- 48:33dependent. If we're talking about ecologists
- 48:37in Brazil, opposing ranchers, then yeah, you're
- 48:42going to get murdered. I'm sorry, but there are
- 48:45like thousands of them that have been found assassinated
- 48:49with their entire family. It's horrible. So yeah,
- 48:53if you're an undercover investigator, you should
- 48:56be careful again. It's riskier. But if you're
- 49:00just on social media or attending a protest or
- 49:03doing some more safer stuff, I think you can
- 49:09just be can be effective at that, make an impact
- 49:12and still make sure to be safe in a safe, safer
- 49:17context. I want to, how much time do we have
- 49:20left? All the time in the world. I've got nothing
- 49:23but time. I'm going to carry on streaming after
- 49:25we finish speaking. So yeah, we can go and go
- 49:27as long as you've got time. Let me bring back
- 49:30the conversation to intelligence. Another aspect
- 49:33of it is how so many people have titles like
- 49:38special titles, PhD and stuff and use that as
- 49:42a way to discredit this movement. medical doctor
- 49:46at distance nutrition, and I'm here to tell you
- 49:49that eating plants is really bad for you for
- 49:53this and that reason. And I think it's another
- 49:56way of using intelligence against this movement,
- 49:59finding the intelligent people out there and
- 50:02making them say that veganism is silly and bad
- 50:06and the animal cost is stupid. So yeah, what
- 50:10do you make of that? Yeah, there's definitely
- 50:14a phenomenon that you've seen. We've watched
- 50:15a couple of debates from Sean Baker, who's an
- 50:18MD in a carnivore. And there's that Paul Saladino
- 50:21guy as well, who's also an MD. And I guess quit
- 50:24being a carnivore because you had health problems.
- 50:27Jordan Peterson, you could put into another example
- 50:29of this, like in the meter sphere, who I believe
- 50:32also has health problems from being carnivore.
- 50:35So yeah, their credentials. It is true what you're
- 50:37saying. And that's why I have PhD in my YouTube.
- 50:39channel name, it gives you a bit of credibility,
- 50:42doesn't it? It makes people listen to what you're
- 50:44saying a bit more. So it's really interesting
- 50:46because it seems obvious to me as a person who
- 50:49is doing that, that doesn't necessarily mean
- 50:51I'm right about any given thing. Like I could
- 50:53totally be wrong about some of the stuff I'm
- 50:55saying. I have frequently discovered things in
- 50:57which I'm wrong through doing this. And actually
- 51:00I maybe have the same thing with the vegan report.
- 51:02Like it's quite good having these conversations
- 51:05in public. Sometimes the critical comments are
- 51:08the most useful because you say, oh yeah, I didn't,
- 51:10I've been saying this thing. And now if you're
- 51:12only saying in private conversations, it's quite
- 51:15rare that someone's going to say to you in the
- 51:17conversation, no, you're wrong about this. But
- 51:18if you have a comment section, people can say
- 51:21that. And sometimes it's useful. Oftentimes it's
- 51:23not, but sometimes it's useful. Right. But yeah,
- 51:27there's definitely the phenomenon of like borrowed
- 51:30credibility being weaponized. against the animal
- 51:35movement. And I think, I don't know how much
- 51:38of that is orchestrated and bought and paid for
- 51:41by the industries. Again, I would think that
- 51:44it's something worth them doing if they don't
- 51:46have Paul Zaldino on their payroll. They probably
- 51:51should, right? It would be seen well worth investing
- 51:55like the cost of a few PhDs or MDs to repeat
- 52:01their propaganda. And so yeah, I think that's
- 52:04certainly something that you see. But yeah, I
- 52:07think coming from somebody who does this to some
- 52:11extent, it's just obvious that doesn't mean that
- 52:14they're right. So I think that's something to
- 52:17really keep in mind with that. I think, yeah,
- 52:20I don't know what else to say about that really,
- 52:22but yeah, clearly having those credentials is
- 52:24no guarantee of being correct. Yeah, and it's
- 52:28not necessarily correlated with higher intellectual
- 52:32potential. There is a rule of thumbs in psychology.
- 52:37I'm not sure how solid that is in terms of data
- 52:41and evidence and studies, but it says that one
- 52:45third of high intellectual, high potential intellectual
- 52:49potential people do great in academics. They
- 52:54become high achiever. The other third are leave
- 52:59school. and become entrepreneurs and go on being
- 53:03successful at whatever independent lane they
- 53:07have chosen. And the last chunk of gifted people
- 53:12end up homeless and basically failing at life
- 53:19in the most tragic ways possible. And yeah, it
- 53:25doesn't mean being very smart. doesn't mean that
- 53:29you're going to be great at school. Maybe school
- 53:32is not the right institution for you. And I have
- 53:37many problems with school, but just think about
- 53:41the quality of the schooling you get. Maybe you're
- 53:45very smart, but you live in an area where school
- 53:49education is very low quality and so it's not
- 53:52very stimulating. What if the structure of school
- 53:56of schools itself is not a match with your personality.
- 53:59It's too authoritative, too hierarchical, too
- 54:03rigid to allow you to truly blossom. So school
- 54:10itself and diplomas, I don't think it's, we should,
- 54:13we give too much importance to that. And with
- 54:17AI and everything that's happening, I think it's
- 54:21losing a lot of importance. Like colleges have
- 54:24lost lots of importance of society and legitimacy,
- 54:27I feel, because so many people are succeeding
- 54:30without college degrees and also so many people
- 54:34with college degrees are making a fool of themselves
- 54:38publicly. And so, yeah, it's that people should
- 54:41be aware of that, should be cautious. Yeah, that's
- 54:45a good point. The other thing I would say on
- 54:47the borrowed credentials point You can find an
- 54:52expert to take any opinion basically, right?
- 54:55And the existence of one or two carnival remdes,
- 55:00that doesn't really tell you anything about their
- 55:02tendency to follow that lifestyle, right? It
- 55:07can well be the case that there's a correlation
- 55:09between higher educational achievements and more
- 55:13plant -based diet, but somebody has been motivated.
- 55:17And on the nefarious level, maybe some organization
- 55:19has paid Sean Baker and the others to be like
- 55:22doing the propaganda, but also just on is demand
- 55:26led, right? If there is, if there's like consumer
- 55:29demand for a doctor to say, Hey, you can eat
- 55:31loads of meat and there's no problem, which clearly
- 55:33there is demand for that. Then some idiot will
- 55:37rise up and start saying it and using their credentials
- 55:39for that. So yeah, I think if you can point to.
- 55:44particular examples of someone with a PhD who
- 55:47says it's okay to eat meat. That doesn't really
- 55:49tell you anything about the tendency on general.
- 55:52If you are, if you were to use that as a proxy,
- 55:54like all of the evidence that I've looked at,
- 55:57we do a ton of surveys where we ask about diets
- 56:00and also educational attainment and consistently
- 56:03you see higher percentage of vegetarians and
- 56:05vegans amongst those with more advanced degrees
- 56:08and lower percentage amongst those who are like
- 56:11some high school level. I think that that's what
- 56:14I mean by the exception that proves the rule.
- 56:16And I should mention an organization they're
- 56:18called, let me just confirm the name, changing
- 56:21markets. They have released a few reports and
- 56:25I think they have confirmed that Sean Bakers
- 56:28and his gang of meatheads are on the payroll
- 56:33of Big Ag. Yeah, it's incredibly interesting
- 56:37to read those reports. I've welcomed on the show
- 56:40the person that works. focus. You should invite
- 56:45her on your show. But yeah, very interesting.
- 56:50And I wish we had like animal rights organizations
- 56:53doing that type of investigative work, not just
- 56:57environmental organizations like changing markets
- 57:00are their concern is the environment less than
- 57:03animal welfare. Another thing on that, sorry,
- 57:08just while we're on the point of the credentials.
- 57:10It's very easy to say things when you're not
- 57:17being challenged. It's very easy to speak to
- 57:21whatever kind of agenda that you want to try
- 57:24and promote. So I have a Google sheet of meat
- 57:28industry professionals who have refused to debate
- 57:31and a couple of names from that changing market
- 57:34reports. That you mentioned Frederick Leroy,
- 57:37he's a big purveyor of misinformation on meat
- 57:40and the environment. Frank Mitlona as well as
- 57:43a guy at UC Davis who does the GWP star like
- 57:46some, some made up metrics so that they can say
- 57:49that cows are not bad for the environment. And
- 57:51I've challenged these people like, let's come
- 57:53on then let's have a conversation about it. Let's
- 57:54have a debate. And they didn't want to do it.
- 57:57They run away because they know that actually
- 58:00if you're in a conversation where somebody can.
- 58:03point out the flaws in what you're saying and
- 58:05hold your feet to the fire and force you to make
- 58:08sense, then it's not so easy just to just to
- 58:13say your talking points and leave it at that.
- 58:15And I searched the other day on YouTube for Frank
- 58:17Mitlona debate, and there aren't any he hasn't
- 58:20done any debates. And if you search for Frederick
- 58:23Leroy debate, he's done one in which he and against
- 58:27a lady called Irina Herson. in which he ends
- 58:30up giving at least two major concessions that
- 58:34are never things that he would want to say when
- 58:36he's just on his own talking to his audience
- 58:38on Twitter or whatever. Like she got him to say,
- 58:41we do need to reduce the scale of livestock production,
- 58:44which he must have ended that debate and go,
- 58:46oh my God, I can't believe she made me say that.
- 58:48He's never done debate before or since, as far
- 58:50as I can tell. I actually have a website, which
- 58:53is, let me screen share this with you real quick.
- 58:57Oh, I have your Map Your Health website here,
- 58:59but I just want to show as well. Whoops. I'm
- 59:03going to call back here. That's what I want to
- 59:04do. This is my website for how long has Frederick
- 59:10Leroy avoided Chris Bryant dot com. That's so
- 59:16funny. So there you go. There's my counter since
- 59:20I first asked him to debate in November 20, 24.
- 59:25And he's now blocked me on LinkedIn. And yeah,
- 59:28this will probably count up to infinity now.
- 59:32My one regret with this website is that I could
- 59:34have got three years of this domain at a discounted
- 59:39rate, but I only bought one year and now I'm
- 59:41paying the yearly rate. So there you go. We live
- 59:43and learn. I don't know how you would debate
- 59:45him because you don't agree on the facts. You're
- 59:49living in alternate realities. How can you debate
- 59:52someone who, you know, it is disconnected from
- 59:57reality. So the trick is, so the, this is a lot
- 1:00:05of the pro meat stuff, a lot of the carnivore
- 1:00:07stuff. It's all the same kind of trick. You have
- 1:00:11a narrowly constructed sentence, which is technically
- 1:00:15true, but ignores all of the context of what
- 1:00:21is actually important. So To give an example
- 1:00:24from Frederick Leroy, he wrote a document called
- 1:00:26the Dublin Declaration, which is a very misleading
- 1:00:29document in defense of meat. And they've published
- 1:00:32it in a journal and they take it and do the lobbying
- 1:00:34with it and so on. And they have a few great
- 1:00:37phrases in there, which are good examples of
- 1:00:39this. They have a phrase in there that says,
- 1:00:41animal products are a source of essential nutrients.
- 1:00:46And you read that in isolation, you think, okay,
- 1:00:50that probably means we have to eat animal products.
- 1:00:52They're not saying animal products are an essential
- 1:00:55source of nutrients. They have nutrients in them
- 1:01:00and some of those nutrients are essential nutrients.
- 1:01:03They're not actually saying you need to eat animal
- 1:01:05products to be healthy, but that's what people
- 1:01:07are reading and they know that. So animal products
- 1:01:10are a source of essential nutrients and if you
- 1:01:12don't have anyone sitting opposite you to push
- 1:01:14back and say, yeah, that's true, but that's not
- 1:01:16really relevant. Like you don't need animal products
- 1:01:18to get those nutrients. The gravel on my driveway
- 1:01:20is a source of essential nutrients because it's
- 1:01:22got iron and zinc in it, right? It's such a stupid
- 1:01:24thing to think of. Another one that I came across
- 1:01:29a bunch of these when I was researching for a
- 1:01:31carnival debate that I did recently. One of their
- 1:01:35narrow, we should come up with a phrase for this,
- 1:01:37something that's narrowly true, but it implies
- 1:01:40something that is not true. Fiber is not an essential
- 1:01:44nutrient. Now, again, that's narrowly true in
- 1:01:48the food science definition of essential nutrient
- 1:01:51is something that we can't synthesize in our
- 1:01:53bodies and there's a specific deficiency for
- 1:01:55not having enough of it. And fiber, there's not
- 1:01:58a specific deficiency disease for fiber deficiency.
- 1:02:02So fiber is not an essential nutrient. And that
- 1:02:05makes you think, wow, we don't need to be consuming
- 1:02:07fiber. It's also true that not consuming enough
- 1:02:10fiber is going to massively increase your risk
- 1:02:12of getting cancer. So it is like true in isolation
- 1:02:16and like plants contain toxins. This is another
- 1:02:19one that was a big phrase that they have to say.
- 1:02:20They have these like bits of language on the
- 1:02:23hard drive, like just these very narrowly true
- 1:02:25sentences, which don't mean what they think it
- 1:02:28means. Or in the case of someone like Frederick
- 1:02:31Leroy, there's the difference between disinformation
- 1:02:33and misinformation, right? There's the disinformation
- 1:02:36people like Frederick Leroy. He knows what he's
- 1:02:38doing he knows he's being misleading when he
- 1:02:40writes that. And that's disinformation is created
- 1:02:43this meme now which other people are going to
- 1:02:45believe and repeat uncritically and then the
- 1:02:48misinformation is the people who are repeating
- 1:02:49uncritically and they don't really know they
- 1:02:51don't really understand. Okay five is not an
- 1:02:54essential nutrient but it's still doesn't mean
- 1:02:56that it's not healthy to eat it and it's going
- 1:02:58to increase your risk of a bunch of diseases
- 1:03:00if you don't have enough fiber so. Yeah, there's
- 1:03:03these things which are like narrowly true, but
- 1:03:05it's so simple. It's just the one question away
- 1:03:09from collapsing on it by just saying, Oh, okay.
- 1:03:12So does that mean that we need to eat animal
- 1:03:13products to be healthy? No, actually that doesn't
- 1:03:16mean that's not the case. Livestock systems can
- 1:03:19provide ecological services. That's another phrase
- 1:03:23that they have. Well, that makes you think, Oh,
- 1:03:26wow. It's really important to have livestock.
- 1:03:27This is an intuitive thing about symbiotic relationship
- 1:03:30with the animals and the plants and stuff like
- 1:03:31that. livestock can provide ecological services.
- 1:03:35Again, that's true in a narrow sense, but there
- 1:03:40are no livestock production systems which are
- 1:03:43net carbon negative, for example. They're providing
- 1:03:46some narrow services, but they're providing much
- 1:03:48more harms over here. And it's not the case that
- 1:03:51we need livestock in these systems. There's all
- 1:03:53sorts of these silly things which are narrowly
- 1:03:57true sentences. craft them and present them in
- 1:04:01a certain way. So you give a certain, certain
- 1:04:04picture of the world, but it's just completely
- 1:04:08pulse. If you scratch at it and ask like a very
- 1:04:11simple question to them. So they're all sneaky
- 1:04:14lawyers. It's interesting that kind of stuff.
- 1:04:17I would not expect like gifted people or people
- 1:04:22with a higher IQ to fall for that. There are
- 1:04:25so many survivors of cults that have started
- 1:04:29podcasts or doing conferences and they always
- 1:04:32say intelligence is not a guarantee of being
- 1:04:36protected against the cult or against fraud and
- 1:04:39all of that. And I would push against that. I
- 1:04:42think, yes, I agree with them, but I think that
- 1:04:45higher intelligence is actually a form of protection
- 1:04:48against those forms of manipulation. And one
- 1:04:55argument for that is there are studies showing
- 1:04:58that people with a higher IQ tend to be less
- 1:05:01religious. They are unable to enter into dogmatic
- 1:05:07thinking and adhere to some strong dogmas and
- 1:05:12group think. So yeah, and that's another relation
- 1:05:16to this movement. Most vegans out there, vegetarians,
- 1:05:20I think would consider themselves as non -religious.
- 1:05:24And so maybe That has to do with intelligence
- 1:05:27again. Yeah. Yeah. I've seen evidence on that
- 1:05:31points to a higher proportion of atheists or
- 1:05:34agnostics amongst vegetarians and vegans compared
- 1:05:36to the general population. And yeah, again, it's
- 1:05:38going to be, and you do see some religious justifications
- 1:05:41of meat eating, of course. Guy debated a couple
- 1:05:43of weeks ago has. We didn't get on to talking
- 1:05:47about this in the debate, but some of his views
- 1:05:48are around meat as a blessed food in the Bible
- 1:05:51and stuff like this, which. Honestly, I didn't
- 1:05:54really even know how to engage with that because
- 1:05:56it would require a whole other conversation about
- 1:06:00religion. I'm not going to, I'm not going to
- 1:06:02persuade him out of being religious presumably,
- 1:06:04but yeah, it's just one of the many things that
- 1:06:07is not, not getting you to the conclusion that
- 1:06:10you think is getting you to. Don't get me started
- 1:06:12on that because that's what I'm. doing right
- 1:06:14now, faith -based activism. And I think that's
- 1:06:17a lane that's such an unexplored lane. We have
- 1:06:21so much work to do with religious communities
- 1:06:23and we're not able to connect with them. I think
- 1:06:26because of that, because we are mostly non -religious
- 1:06:30and so it's difficult to ask a vegan to go and
- 1:06:36advocate for veganism to a priest when they don't
- 1:06:39even believe in God, when the vegan doesn't even
- 1:06:41believe in God. So there needs to be some common
- 1:06:44ground in order to establish communication and
- 1:06:47then try convincing that religious institution
- 1:06:51or religious leader to make positive changes.
- 1:06:55To finish our discussion, I want to talk about
- 1:06:59the link. I want to talk about animals and the
- 1:07:03link between intelligence and animals. That's
- 1:07:05an argument we often hear that animals are not
- 1:07:08intelligent and that justifies all the harm and
- 1:07:12exploitation that is done against them. I would
- 1:07:15love to hear your thoughts about that and also
- 1:07:18about how that hypersensitivity aspect and that
- 1:07:23capability of adapting to different environments
- 1:07:29and people helps IQ people, gifted people to
- 1:07:36better connect with animals, to understand them
- 1:07:40better, to have to be able to establish a relationship,
- 1:07:44an actual relationship with animals when other
- 1:07:47people will only see a toy. Even if they have
- 1:07:51an emotional connection with that toy, it's just
- 1:07:54a toy at the end and are not able to perceive
- 1:07:57so much the personhood of that creature. When
- 1:08:03I've noticed, I don't think there have been any
- 1:08:06studies on that from personal experience. So
- 1:08:09many gifted people just are invested so deeply
- 1:08:14in the relationship or their perception of animals
- 1:08:18and of cruelty against animals. It touches them
- 1:08:21deeply. So yeah, we'd love to hear your thoughts
- 1:08:24about that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Really interesting.
- 1:08:30A couple of thoughts on that. I used to speak
- 1:08:33to this guy who goes by ask yourself on YouTube
- 1:08:37and he, I don't know if you've come across this
- 1:08:39person, he has, he's YouTube famous for an argument
- 1:08:43that he calls name the trait. And the challenge
- 1:08:46to the meat eater is to name the traits that
- 1:08:51makes it acceptable to name the traits that is
- 1:08:56Absent in animals that if absent in humans would
- 1:08:59make it acceptable to kill humans for food and
- 1:09:01I think intelligence is probably the most common
- 1:09:04answer that people first give to that and then
- 1:09:07of course the reply the entailment of that is
- 1:09:11if you have a human with the same level of intelligence
- 1:09:14as a cow for example, and there are disabled
- 1:09:17intellectually disabled people who to whom that
- 1:09:19might apply Do you find it acceptable to kill
- 1:09:22them for food? And of course everyone says no
- 1:09:24And then, okay, but it can't be that intelligence
- 1:09:27is the trait, right? And you go around again
- 1:09:29and people come up with different things and
- 1:09:30they say, they say all sorts of things, ability
- 1:09:33to form civilizations and language and stuff
- 1:09:36like this. You can say, okay, if you have a person
- 1:09:37who can't speak, okay, no, it's not acceptable
- 1:09:39to kill them. But yeah, intelligence seems to
- 1:09:42be like the level one answer that people give
- 1:09:45to that. That's the intuitive thing that people
- 1:09:47think, yeah, it's because we're more intelligent.
- 1:09:50So yeah, I don't know. Yeah. Only amenities would
- 1:09:56think that's a bad thing to say, right? We were
- 1:09:59cannibals a minute ago in human history. That
- 1:10:02was not like a shocking idea, eating your neighbor.
- 1:10:06There were rituals around it. There was a whole
- 1:10:08community spirit built around eating your neighbor.
- 1:10:12So yeah, the intelligence is certainly not the
- 1:10:15trait that stops us from eating someone. Yeah,
- 1:10:19yeah, I guess so. Yeah. So there's all sorts
- 1:10:22of, I don't know, there's all sorts of things
- 1:10:24that could be said about that. And of course
- 1:10:25there's presumably more and less intelligent
- 1:10:29animals in the animal kingdom and people don't
- 1:10:31seem to make much differentiation on that. Now,
- 1:10:34some people might say, okay, you don't want to
- 1:10:36eat dolphins or monkeys because they're too close
- 1:10:38for some sense of intelligence. But yeah, I think
- 1:10:41people would, maybe people would be surprised
- 1:10:44by the cognitive abilities that actually are
- 1:10:46demonstrated by a lot of the animals that we
- 1:10:47do eat. Like the problem solving capacities of
- 1:10:50chickens or the emotional relationships and friendships
- 1:10:53of cows. The very blatant similarity of pigs
- 1:10:58to dogs who we love. So yeah, I think that there's
- 1:11:02all sorts of dissonance and confused thinking
- 1:11:06going on there when it comes to thinking about
- 1:11:09the intelligence of animals. It's also occurred
- 1:11:11to me before that we assume that humans are the
- 1:11:15most intelligent animals. But there are animals
- 1:11:17with much bigger brains that just don't have
- 1:11:20opposable thumbs. Like whales have brains like
- 1:11:24the size of a double decker bus, but they live
- 1:11:26underwater, so they can't have computers. Do
- 1:11:29you know what I mean? Elephants have bigger brains
- 1:11:32than humans as well, but they've got these big
- 1:11:34flat hooves, so they can't type anything else.
- 1:11:38And who says that we're the most intelligent
- 1:11:39animal? Yeah. And who is qualified to discern,
- 1:11:44understand what... higher intelligence means.
- 1:11:47It's how, what kind of measures are we going
- 1:11:51to put in place in order to define that higher
- 1:11:55intelligence and who is qualified to make that
- 1:11:59assessment? You need, basically what I'm saying
- 1:12:02is you need to be smart or as smart or smarter
- 1:12:05to decide that your fellow person is of that
- 1:12:09intelligence or lower. Yeah, for sure. And then
- 1:12:14I like what you said about the hypersensitivity.
- 1:12:17It almost feels like more imagination seems like
- 1:12:22too loose a word for it, but like you can simulate
- 1:12:26what it might be like to be in the consciousness
- 1:12:31of another type of animal. Like when I think
- 1:12:33a lot of people have this probably intuitively
- 1:12:35with their dog, oh, he's hungry or he's bored
- 1:12:37or whatever he's scared. So a lot of people have
- 1:12:41it on some basic level, but to really spend a
- 1:12:44minute like inhabiting that and imagining it
- 1:12:47at length and say, for example, a pig who is
- 1:12:50in a farrowing crate and can't turn around for
- 1:12:53weeks and weeks at a time. What was I doing eight
- 1:12:56weeks ago? I can't even remember. It's such a
- 1:12:59long time to be trapped in that situation. And
- 1:13:02it just goes on and on. I might stream for another
- 1:13:05hour now, then go have some food and then blah,
- 1:13:08blah, blah. There's so much that I'm going to
- 1:13:09do in the amount of time that this animal is
- 1:13:11just there in the cage, just trapped. It really,
- 1:13:15you need a bit of imagination or just willingness
- 1:13:22to stick with that thought, I guess, to properly
- 1:13:25simulate anything like what it might be like
- 1:13:28to be in that kind of situation. So yeah, I think.
- 1:13:32I imagine that low intelligence probably also
- 1:13:35correlated with selfishness, where it's just,
- 1:13:36I've only really got the capacity to think about
- 1:13:38my needs and I'm hungry right now and I'm late
- 1:13:40for whatever. But yeah, thinking about the experience
- 1:13:43of others and what that must be like for them,
- 1:13:46let alone thinking about how our actions impact
- 1:13:48on the abilities of others and stuff like this.
- 1:13:51A lot of this seems like quite basic, though
- 1:13:53you might tell your young child, but many adults
- 1:13:57don't seem to have ever had that lesson. Yeah,
- 1:14:00I agree. You need some cognitive power to be
- 1:14:05able to give life to that kind of scenario, to
- 1:14:08that kind of story. And that's why another defining
- 1:14:12trait of higher intelligence is again, creativity,
- 1:14:17innovation. Most innovation comes from that 2
- 1:14:20.5 % at the top of the IQ curve. So yeah, it's
- 1:14:26a fascinating thing to consider. We depend so
- 1:14:30much on that crowd of people for humanity's progress.
- 1:14:36Yeah, it's stunning. Chris, I'll just, I would
- 1:14:40love to talk about map your health before. Yes,
- 1:14:43we didn't get to the map yet and the Dharma stuff
- 1:14:45that you're doing as well. Yeah, of course. Do
- 1:14:48you want to start with map your health? Yeah,
- 1:14:51let's do, I can screen share the website here
- 1:14:54so that you can talk to us about it. Oh, here
- 1:14:57we go. Wonderful. Yeah. Basically this is the
- 1:15:03waiting list. This is the webpage to sign up
- 1:15:05to the waiting list for map your health. And
- 1:15:09this is the web version of map your health. Now
- 1:15:13it needs some updates, including that updates.
- 1:15:17Some of them will happen actually tonight and
- 1:15:21in the following days, a lot will happen on that
- 1:15:24front. But yeah, so Basically, the concept is
- 1:15:28to track and monitor environmental health risks
- 1:15:31in your surroundings. That includes virus outbreaks,
- 1:15:37that also includes pollutants emitted by your
- 1:15:40local industries, the quality of your tap water,
- 1:15:45the quality of your air, and so many other aspects
- 1:15:50of environmental health. I think that We put
- 1:15:54lots of emphasis and for the right reasons on
- 1:15:57physical health, staying fit on diet, very important
- 1:16:01to, but on mental health, another important one,
- 1:16:06but what about environmental health? That's our
- 1:16:09blind spot. Yet it is such a big player in our
- 1:16:14health, big factor in influencing how long we
- 1:16:18are going to live and what kind of quality of
- 1:16:22life we're going to enjoy and so yeah this is
- 1:16:25the first and only tool to offer that kind of
- 1:16:30information that exists so very excited about
- 1:16:33this project and to connect it maybe with animal
- 1:16:38rights as some of the listeners know factory
- 1:16:43farming is linked to lots of detrimental effects
- 1:16:47on our health. Usually we talk about cancers
- 1:16:52and diabetes and other chronic illnesses, but
- 1:16:56what about public health? What about zoonotic
- 1:16:59diseases? What about resistance to antibiotics?
- 1:17:03This is just as much important, if not more than
- 1:17:07those chronic illnesses that develop at the later
- 1:17:10stage of life. And I think we need a tool to
- 1:17:15let people know that there are factory farms
- 1:17:18and slaughterhouses around them, and that those
- 1:17:21places are actively impacting their health and
- 1:17:26their quality of life. And so, yeah, that's basically
- 1:17:31the concept of map your health. Nice, that's
- 1:17:35super useful. And yeah, we've done a project
- 1:17:38before where we've looked at evidence on negative
- 1:17:41health outcomes associated with living near to
- 1:17:43factory farms, essentially. A lot of it is ammonia
- 1:17:45pollution, and that has an effect on people with
- 1:17:48asthma and COPD, like a lot of respiratory conditions
- 1:17:52that can get a lot worse if you're living near
- 1:17:54to a factory farm with all of the air pollution
- 1:17:56coming from that. So yeah, I tried to bring a
- 1:17:59couple of places in the UK, but it didn't come
- 1:18:01up. But do you have any? areas that are online
- 1:18:04for this or this is waiting for the update? This
- 1:18:06is waiting for the update. Basically, you subscribe
- 1:18:08to the waiting list for the app, which is the
- 1:18:11final version of this. But yeah, I have a web
- 1:18:14version available that is going to be updated
- 1:18:17with more locations and more data points than
- 1:18:20it currently has. Yeah. Awesome. Awesome. Okay.
- 1:18:27Nice. We'll look out for that. That's mapyourhealth
- 1:18:28.info. If people want to check that out, I'll
- 1:18:31put that in the chat as well. So people can sign
- 1:18:33up for the waiting list. And yeah, hopefully
- 1:18:36this is going to be something that brings delight.
- 1:18:41Yeah. A lot of the health, negative health impacts
- 1:18:44of living close to factory farms, basically.
- 1:18:48Yes. And I think we are ill prepared for the
- 1:18:51next pandemic, which is going to happen. Like
- 1:18:54people are in denial. But there's a big one coming
- 1:18:57at some point. Could be 10 years, 20 years, hopefully
- 1:19:0150, 100 years, but it's coming sooner than later,
- 1:19:06sadly. And we need to be prepared for that. And
- 1:19:10we're not ready. I think that COVID -19 was a
- 1:19:13disaster in terms of communication, of risk communication
- 1:19:18from authorities, from media outlets. That was
- 1:19:22a complete circus. and we played a lot with people's
- 1:19:27lives because of political agendas and all sorts
- 1:19:30of private interests and so on. And yeah, I think
- 1:19:34we need a tool, an independent platform to communicate
- 1:19:38truthfully, rightfully, and in real time, those
- 1:19:42kinds of environmental health risks. Yeah. Do
- 1:19:46you ever worry, like speaking about intelligence,
- 1:19:49because it seems to be, if you'd look at social
- 1:19:50media, you would... be forgiven for thinking
- 1:19:54that the vaccine was a disaster and that the
- 1:19:58vaccine didn't really work and it gave people
- 1:20:00health problems and all this kind of stuff. The
- 1:20:02COVID vaccine did work. It does work. Like it
- 1:20:05reduced the rate of COVID transition. It ultimately
- 1:20:08enabled many of our societies to open back up.
- 1:20:11If you look on social media, you think that the
- 1:20:13opposite is the case. It's crazy. Do you ever
- 1:20:16worry? And now, you know, I've just been reading
- 1:20:18in my, I suppose in my country, broadly in the
- 1:20:20UK, I was going to say my local area. Like anti
- 1:20:24-vax is on the rise more and people there's a
- 1:20:28lot of kids in the schools getting measles now
- 1:20:30for that We've had a vaccine for this for ages
- 1:20:31It's been near universal coverage now people
- 1:20:35are suspicious about vaccines again And so vaccine
- 1:20:37coverage is going down and now there's measles
- 1:20:39outbreaks in schools. It's never worry that We
- 1:20:43there are some things where we are by the mercy
- 1:20:45of stupid people. Oh, yes all the time I think
- 1:20:50One of my favorite critique of politics and society
- 1:20:54is the movie, Idiocracy. It's so funny, but it's
- 1:21:00such a reflection of reality. And actually worldwide,
- 1:21:05we have a lowering of average IQs across the
- 1:21:09US, Canada, and so on. So people are really,
- 1:21:12yes, they are getting dumber. Oh no. That's not
- 1:21:17good news, is it? That's not good news. And again,
- 1:21:21it's worrying because if higher IQs are related
- 1:21:25to correlated or cause greater production of
- 1:21:29wealth and better living standards, then that
- 1:21:31means we're looking at such a bleak future ahead.
- 1:21:37I think it's not only about intelligence, it's
- 1:21:40about distrust of authorities. I think that people
- 1:21:44witnessed a lot of dumb things happening from
- 1:21:47authorities. bad policies, bad communication
- 1:21:51around COVID -19. And that has caused a lot of
- 1:21:57distrust from the population. And that distrust
- 1:22:01is cancer spreading to different areas of healthcare,
- 1:22:06including then vaccines. If they lied, if they
- 1:22:09were stupid enough to say this, if they lied
- 1:22:11about that, then maybe they also lied about the
- 1:22:16vaccines. They also lied about those more fundamental
- 1:22:19stuff. And so I think it's natural instinct from
- 1:22:22people to become distrustful of authority. But
- 1:22:28yeah, I blame the politicians. I think the politicians,
- 1:22:32our politicians are so stupid, truly are that
- 1:22:36pandemic happened and they just were not thinking
- 1:22:41long term. They don't have a They think about
- 1:22:44their career. They think about their next campaign.
- 1:22:48They think about outside perspective and how
- 1:22:52to have great positive public relations. But
- 1:22:56they don't think about civilization. They don't
- 1:23:00think about existential threats and how to go
- 1:23:05forward as a society in 10, 50, 100 years. They're
- 1:23:11trapped in that ego mindset, and those like very
- 1:23:15small political calculations. And that does a
- 1:23:21big disservice to all of us. Yeah, yeah, I agree
- 1:23:26about those grades, like case study for a lot
- 1:23:28of this stuff, because there was so many things
- 1:23:31in there where you can see it's almost like short
- 1:23:36term benefits of Lying basically like the mark
- 1:23:41the masks was the big one right that is obvious
- 1:23:43that you want health professionals to have enough
- 1:23:46access to medical masks and that if everybody
- 1:23:49like rushes the market and buys up all the medical
- 1:23:51masks not gonna be a good thing for the health
- 1:23:53care system and so early on there was like The
- 1:23:57advice was don't wear masks and masks are ineffective
- 1:23:59and maybe that should make it worse because then
- 1:24:01you're gonna be touching your face more is Even
- 1:24:03at the time I was like that doesn't make sense
- 1:24:06We're wearing masks. I'm going to do this. And,
- 1:24:10but then that became so, yeah, again, there were
- 1:24:14clear incentives why you wouldn't not want to
- 1:24:16have all of the public knowing the actual truth
- 1:24:19about that. But again, if you think critically
- 1:24:22about it, you can think, okay, I can understand
- 1:24:23why they're saying that advice, but that if I'm
- 1:24:26interested in my own protection, I'm still going
- 1:24:27to wear a mask. Another thing was panic buying
- 1:24:30food. Of course you want to tell the public don't
- 1:24:33panic buy food. there's going to be enough food,
- 1:24:36food supplies not going to be a problem and so
- 1:24:37on. Of course, that's what you want to say to
- 1:24:38the public. And I was like, no bollocks of that.
- 1:24:42We're getting tinned food. We're filling up the
- 1:24:43garage with tinned food. And of course, like
- 1:24:44a week later, all the supermarket shelves are
- 1:24:47empty now. Now, there's a little bit of chicken
- 1:24:49and egg there, right? Because of course, people
- 1:24:51do panic buy and that's kind of what caused it
- 1:24:52to some extent. But yeah, there was a couple
- 1:24:57of instances where that trust was lost where
- 1:25:01I don't want to say that they needed to lie,
- 1:25:03but you could see their incentives for lying
- 1:25:06in that sense. And the long -term cost was so
- 1:25:09much worse. I remember that. I remember the masks
- 1:25:12episode. It happened in Quebec, Canada, where
- 1:25:15I live. The government made it clear, like very
- 1:25:19clear that masks were ineffective and don't go
- 1:25:23purchase masks. And then they did a 180 without
- 1:25:26any explanation and justification. and started
- 1:25:30saying that masks were essential to protecting
- 1:25:33yourself. Like, how do you explain that? And
- 1:25:37I think the biggest sign of just stupid policies
- 1:25:41coming from the government was how they closed
- 1:25:45down all of the mom and pop shops around because
- 1:25:50of sanitary reasons to stop the spread of the
- 1:25:55virus. But then... Costco was open and you had
- 1:26:00this huge crowd in Costco. That was such a blatant
- 1:26:07nonsense. What are you doing? This is like mad
- 1:26:12scientist stuff, like just putting out like the
- 1:26:17craziest policies. Restaurants, so many of them
- 1:26:20disappeared completely. Montreal used to be amazing.
- 1:26:24It's improving. It used to be amazing in terms
- 1:26:27of food that was available. The restaurant quality
- 1:26:30was amazing. After COVID, it became horrible.
- 1:26:35It became very boring. Now it's improving. But
- 1:26:39so many restaurant owners took their life because
- 1:26:43of financial despair. Who was held accountable
- 1:26:47for that? no investigative commission or something
- 1:26:52to examine what we've done in terms of policies.
- 1:26:57And why did some people push certain agendas
- 1:27:00on us? If you're not doing that, then how are
- 1:27:03you going to reestablish trust in the government?
- 1:27:06And then their solution is to enforce limitations
- 1:27:10on free speech. That's how we're going to put
- 1:27:13back. We're going to shut them up and that's
- 1:27:19how, you know, they're going to trust vaccines
- 1:27:21again. I'm sorry, but you've just made yourself
- 1:27:24even more untrustworthy. Like now you're becoming
- 1:27:27a hostile entity to your people. So yeah, I don't
- 1:27:32know who is advising them, but it's not a smart
- 1:27:36person. Yeah. That short -term thinking, I think
- 1:27:41about that with respect to a lot of the meatheads,
- 1:27:44the Freddie LeRoy's and Frank Mitt learners and
- 1:27:46so on. They have some sort of short -term incentives
- 1:27:49to be spreading disinformation that kind of implies
- 1:27:53that there's no need to reduce our meat consumption.
- 1:27:56But then I think, do these people not want a
- 1:27:59habitable planet for their children? Do you know
- 1:28:02what I mean? It's so short -term. Do you not
- 1:28:05care if you're increasing the chances that there's
- 1:28:07going to be another pandemic? Do you not care
- 1:28:09if like you're Sean Baker and you are like definitely
- 1:28:16increasing the risk of heart disease amongst
- 1:28:18all of the young men who listen to you and stuff
- 1:28:20like this? It's a combination of like selfishness
- 1:28:25and just short -term thinking. I'm particularly
- 1:28:29for the environmental guys, because Frank Mitlohner,
- 1:28:31who does the methane cycling and all of the disinformation
- 1:28:35around that, like implying that, oh, maybe cows
- 1:28:38are actually good for the environment. Like he's
- 1:28:40a smart guy. He knows what he's doing. Does he
- 1:28:44not think about what the actual implications
- 1:28:47of me doing this in 50 years time? or a hundred
- 1:28:49years time. My kids and grandkids are going to
- 1:28:52have to live on this planet that I'm teeing up
- 1:28:54for them. It's so short -sighted, surely. It's
- 1:28:56mental. I don't know what to say about that.
- 1:28:58It's just, yeah, its own form of stupidity. Yeah.
- 1:29:03Or maybe they just don't care. And it's a form
- 1:29:07of psychopathy. That's something else that deeply
- 1:29:10fascinates me. How many psychopaths are out there
- 1:29:13and why, as a society, haven't we done our homework
- 1:29:17of just detecting them. Just as we filter out
- 1:29:21people with intelligence disability from the
- 1:29:25army, we should look at the healthcare world
- 1:29:28and filter out psychopaths from there. Like a
- 1:29:32psychiatrist should not be a psychopath. Yeah,
- 1:29:35that seems like a good rule. They should not
- 1:29:38be in contact with vulnerable populations. They
- 1:29:42have predatory behaviors that It's just reality.
- 1:29:45We understand that we've studied that in depth.
- 1:29:49And I think that as a society, we should come
- 1:29:52up with some kind of policy to, to manage that.
- 1:29:56But we're just, we're just in denial of that.
- 1:30:00We pretend that psychopaths do not exist and
- 1:30:04that they're not actually influencing how things
- 1:30:07go in our society. And we're made. stupider for
- 1:30:12that and in dangerous situations because of that.
- 1:30:16Because those people genuinely don't care. It's
- 1:30:19not their fault. I'm not saying they should be
- 1:30:22punished for that. Absolutely not. It's just
- 1:30:25how their brain is wired. Yeah, that is frustrating
- 1:30:30to ponder on that. Yeah. How easy is it to avoid
- 1:30:34it? If you're stupid, it's not that easy to avoid
- 1:30:38detection. If you open your mouth, you're pretty
- 1:30:41good. I was going to reveal it. Like if you're
- 1:30:43a psychopath, is it easier to avoid? You can
- 1:30:46act like a non psychopath or no? They say you
- 1:30:51have met at least a few psychopaths in your life,
- 1:30:54every one of us. And there are people when I
- 1:30:57think about it, I think we're pretty much psychopathic
- 1:31:01in their behaviors. So yeah, I guess that answers
- 1:31:06the question. They're really good at disguising
- 1:31:08themselves, really good at fitting in and manipulating
- 1:31:12us. And also they're not, I think they're not
- 1:31:16wired for deep committed like relationships.
- 1:31:20I think that it's always short term with them,
- 1:31:23romantic relationships and also like friends,
- 1:31:26friendly relationships. And so you don't have
- 1:31:29much time to examine closely that person. It's
- 1:31:34always so shortened that they got what they wanted
- 1:31:38from you and that's it. It's very transactional
- 1:31:41and they're gone from your life after that, hopefully.
- 1:31:45How many slaughterhouse Tizen people executives
- 1:31:50are actually psychopaths? That's a question that
- 1:31:53is, I think, worth asking. I think there are
- 1:31:58activists out there. who think we can gain them
- 1:32:00to our cause and think that those big industries
- 1:32:04are just looking for profit or something like
- 1:32:07that. What if they enjoy inflicting pain and
- 1:32:11that much death? What if that brings them joy?
- 1:32:14I've heard one activist talk about how people
- 1:32:18who own humane operations, like little farms
- 1:32:22where they raise a few animals, they slaughter
- 1:32:26them themselves. They, some of them are actually
- 1:32:30very sadistic about this and enjoy the experience
- 1:32:33of owning that animal and slaughtering it while
- 1:32:37presenting themselves as humane. Now, is it too
- 1:32:43far -fetched to suggest that some of the big
- 1:32:47executives that in big arc world get some enjoyment
- 1:32:52from inflicting that much pain and destruction?
- 1:32:55Maybe not. That's yeah, that's another question
- 1:32:58worth asking. Yeah, no, I can well imagine it.
- 1:33:03Yeah, that's very troubling to think about. But
- 1:33:04yeah, I think that's totally true. I think I
- 1:33:07vaguely have it in my mind that a lot of CEOs
- 1:33:10and stuff are psychopaths, right? I think that
- 1:33:13there's some sort of correlation there. They
- 1:33:15say that? Yes. Yeah. Actually, I work in the
- 1:33:18nonprofit world and I've, I was expecting to
- 1:33:22work with angels. I was expecting that everyone
- 1:33:25would be this wholesome and dedicating their
- 1:33:28lives to advancing goodness in society and making
- 1:33:31this world better place. I know how cheesy that
- 1:33:35sounds, but then I met so many people in positions
- 1:33:38of leadership in the nonprofit world that are
- 1:33:41very predatory, like extremely. And I realized
- 1:33:46that they are attracted to the nonprofit world.
- 1:33:50because they want to be close to vulnerable populations.
- 1:33:54It's looking for jobs at the school or wanting
- 1:33:57to become a scout monitor or something. Same
- 1:34:02thing. Yeah, it is worrying that there is no
- 1:34:06tracking system, monitoring system, public health
- 1:34:09policy to track those personality types in our
- 1:34:14society. Yeah, yeah. Damn. Well, that seems like
- 1:34:21a problem too long, trust me. Do you want to
- 1:34:24talk a bit about the Dharma stuff? Sure, I could.
- 1:34:26I've been here for nearly two hours, so I won't
- 1:34:29keep you too much longer, but I'm interested
- 1:34:30to hear about what you're doing on that side
- 1:34:32as well. Of course. Thank you for asking. Dharma
- 1:34:34Voices for Animals was created by a bunch of
- 1:34:37Buddhists who were wondering how come there aren't
- 1:34:40more Buddhists who are vegan? And basically,
- 1:34:44We make the Buddhist argument for veganism. We
- 1:34:48inform Buddhist publications, institutions, and
- 1:34:51leaders of what's happening with factory farming.
- 1:34:54And we convince them to transition their institutions
- 1:34:59to plant -based only model and to support advocacy
- 1:35:05work related to passing animal welfare legislations
- 1:35:10and so on. It's faith -based advocacy, not very
- 1:35:14popular in the movement, but extremely impactful.
- 1:35:19Like I've become convinced that this is the way
- 1:35:23to make real lasting change. It's to change religious
- 1:35:28institutions. Like we're spending so much time
- 1:35:32and resources on street outreach, but we should
- 1:35:36be reaching out to the religious leaders who
- 1:35:39have a whole load of people that follow their
- 1:35:43every word and look at them as a moral example.
- 1:35:49Most people don't look at Peter Singer as a moral
- 1:35:53compass. They look at the rabbi, their imam,
- 1:35:57and their Buddhist monk. And that's, I think,
- 1:36:00the most impactful way we can make a difference.
- 1:36:05I truly believe that. So if we gain religious
- 1:36:09leaders to our cause, it's a permanent thing.
- 1:36:11It's not political advocacy. And they will speak
- 1:36:15to a wider audience. And they are the ones that
- 1:36:20set moral standards in society for most people.
- 1:36:23So they should be the prime target of our advocacy
- 1:36:26work. And we should, at the very least, hold
- 1:36:30them accountable to animal welfare issues. All
- 1:36:33of that, they should not be permitted to stay
- 1:36:36silent on that very pressing issue. And now I
- 1:36:41invite everyone to follow my example and look
- 1:36:44into who are the religious leaders in your town
- 1:36:47or neighborhood, like church leaders or who knows
- 1:36:51who, and give them a copy of Animal Welfare and
- 1:36:57World Religion from, what's her name, Joyce De
- 1:37:00Silva. or start a conversation about factory
- 1:37:04farming and try to convince them to maybe do
- 1:37:07a screening of dominion in one of their church
- 1:37:11gathering community event. Yeah, I think that
- 1:37:14would make an enormous impact. And yeah, that's
- 1:37:18what I'm doing. I'm doing what I'm preaching
- 1:37:20and reaching out to Buddhist leaders and advancing
- 1:37:23animal welfare through that. Yeah, that makes
- 1:37:27so much sense. And I agree with you. It's a really
- 1:37:32underrated like leverage points or bottleneck
- 1:37:35you could think of because I feel like there's
- 1:37:40a decent amount of now let's have doctors talking
- 1:37:43about the health stuff. People trust doctors
- 1:37:45to be authorities on what is going to be healthy
- 1:37:47for you. And we do actually have figures who
- 1:37:50people trust to be an authority on what's going
- 1:37:52to be the right or moral or ethical thing to
- 1:37:55do as well. But it's not really something that
- 1:37:58we've done too much advocacy on it seems. Buddhism
- 1:38:03seems like a good fit for it. It's like a lot
- 1:38:06of this vegetarian at least already and Hinduism
- 1:38:08as well, right? It's a tenet of the religion
- 1:38:10almost. And I guess Jainism and there might be
- 1:38:14another couple of other like typically Eastern
- 1:38:16religions that are like this. Do you think it's
- 1:38:20as tractable for Christian or Jewish or Muslim
- 1:38:23communities? From my perspective, it seems like
- 1:38:26there's a decent amount of justifying eating
- 1:38:29meat with a religious basis from the Abrahamic
- 1:38:32religions. Yes, I do believe so. And there are
- 1:38:36so many incredible, passionate leaders out there
- 1:38:41who, let me give you an example, Daniel Mascarenas,
- 1:38:45that's someone I interviewed a couple of times
- 1:38:47on my podcast. He's a Jesuit priest in training
- 1:38:52based in Boston and a passionate vegan. and he
- 1:38:56actually created the website called vegancatholic
- 1:38:59.org where he presents the Catholic argument
- 1:39:03for veganism. Now, he's really passionate about
- 1:39:08this. He has done his homeworks. Like he knows
- 1:39:11all about why Christianity goes hand in hand
- 1:39:15with veganism and not exploiting animals. Who
- 1:39:19is talking to him? What organization is featuring
- 1:39:22him? Who is giving him funding? And the answer
- 1:39:26is no one. Like that movie, Christspiracy, that
- 1:39:30I won't call it a documentary. It's a docus fiction.
- 1:39:34I think the technical term is for that kind of
- 1:39:37media stuff. Never reached out to Daniel to talk
- 1:39:41about what would be appealing for Catholics to
- 1:39:46hear about veganism. went on and presented some
- 1:39:52very unattractive arguments for Christians to
- 1:39:56go vegan. Truly, that documentary is a huge indicator
- 1:40:01of where we are as a movement because it was
- 1:40:04celebrated by everyone, yet it missed the point.
- 1:40:09It should have been made to appeal to the Christian
- 1:40:15population, but it's not appealing to the Christian
- 1:40:17population. And people like Daniel could have
- 1:40:21been perfect to give their insight into how to
- 1:40:26best convince Christians to consider veganism.
- 1:40:30There are a hundred more people like Daniel out
- 1:40:33there in Judaism with the Unitarian Church. I
- 1:40:38don't know about the Catholic Church. I know
- 1:40:41a teacher at Stanford who is doing some work
- 1:40:44with different Catholic institutions and They're
- 1:40:49receptive to him and his message. And so yeah,
- 1:40:52the, it's just that you don't hear about it.
- 1:40:56And I think it has to do with that bias of most
- 1:40:59vegans, animal rights activists are not religious
- 1:41:02or not interested in talking about religion.
- 1:41:05And if they talk about religion, it's to talk
- 1:41:08about how religion has participated in creating
- 1:41:12this culture of exploiting animals, which is
- 1:41:17true. But how is it productive for this movement
- 1:41:21to keep religious people out of it and make them
- 1:41:25the scapegoat for animal exploitation? Not productive
- 1:41:29at all. So I do think there are powerful arguments
- 1:41:35to present to Jews, Christians, and Muslims to
- 1:41:40invite them to become vegan. There's another
- 1:41:43book I could recommend. called Animals in Islam
- 1:41:46was written by an imam who I think was based
- 1:41:50in the UK. We lost him. I think he died now,
- 1:41:54but he had a level of success. He was invited
- 1:41:57to a few mosques where he gave presentations
- 1:41:59about it. We have Zahra Abbas, another one who
- 1:42:04is active on the Muslim front. who has founded
- 1:42:07Green Islam, another great initiative. We have
- 1:42:11Animetrix who is studying everything that has
- 1:42:13to do with halal and how it aligns with animal
- 1:42:18welfareism. And I mentioned Islam because most
- 1:42:22people think that's the furthest religion from
- 1:42:26the animal welfare message. Yet you have all
- 1:42:30of those peoples, those people and active advocates
- 1:42:34in that space. And so yeah, there is potential
- 1:42:39the material is there we know what to say We
- 1:42:42know what to do. We know who to target. We just
- 1:42:46need support like financial support resources
- 1:42:48and more media coverage Yeah, that's really good
- 1:42:55news because yeah, of course Islam is the biggest
- 1:42:57religion as well, right? I think it's 20 % of
- 1:42:59people in the world or something crazy like that.
- 1:43:00Like it's huge So yeah, really good to know that's
- 1:43:04tractable and that there are people working on
- 1:43:06it. And I agree with you, it's definitely going
- 1:43:09to be an under explored area and an under financed
- 1:43:14area and something that could do with a lot more
- 1:43:16resources going into that kind of initiative.
- 1:43:19Your organization's Dharma Voices for Animals.
- 1:43:22Yes, Dharma Voices. Give that a Google. Yes,
- 1:43:25please. And consider donating to the organization.
- 1:43:29Always appreciated. Yeah, the employees are amazing
- 1:43:32too. A good sign that an organization is in good
- 1:43:35health is that is when their employees give back
- 1:43:39to the organization. I give back to DPA even
- 1:43:41though they are my employer and client and I
- 1:43:44know the other employees too. And so that shows
- 1:43:47you how much we believe in that mission and its
- 1:43:51impact. So yeah, consider making a donation.
- 1:43:56Awesome. Awesome. I just put the link for dumbvoicesforanimals
- 1:43:58.org in the chat so people can check that out.
- 1:44:02Awesome. Brian, thanks so much for the conversation.
- 1:44:04This was excellent. We did two hours in the end.
- 1:44:07Yes. Thank you so much, Chris. This was my first
- 1:44:09live stream and I had a great experience. Yeah.
- 1:44:12Invite me back whenever you want. Absolutely.
- 1:44:14I'd love to have more of those conversations.
- 1:44:18Awesome. Thanks so much for your time. I really
- 1:44:20appreciate it. Wonderful. See you soon. Thank
- 1:44:27you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you
- 1:44:30to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:44:33Let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 1:44:37thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 1:44:40next Tuesday for a new episode.