Latest / Consumerpedia / 76 - Fake Reviews Are Everywhere
Transcript
- 0:02You're going to buy ATV or need to find a vet for your new
- 0:05puppy, or looking for the right hotel for your next vacation.
- 0:08So what do you do? You jump online and start
- 0:11searching, checking the reviews and ratings to help guide your
- 0:14decision. Whether it's a new pair of jeans
- 0:16or a neighborhood nail salon, we all rely on reviews and
- 0:20testimonials when shopping for products or services.
- 0:23But can you trust those reviews? I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 0:27Man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:30Welcome to consumerpedia@checkbook.org.
- 0:33We're the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:36trouble and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:39advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:43can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:46objective. Now here's the host of Consumer
- 0:49Pedia America's consumer expert, the consumer man, Herb Weisbaum.
- 0:54Just like everything else on the Internet, reviews can be faked
- 0:58at all. Too often, they are.
- 0:59Some companies create their own glowing reviews or pay others to
- 1:03do it for them. Some post fake negative reviews
- 1:06to hurt the competition. In this episode, how companies
- 1:09create fake reviews, tips on how to spot them.
- 1:12Plus, a new federal rule designed to crack down on the
- 1:15growing problem. Up first, Jason Brown, the
- 1:18founder of Review Fraud, a company with a very simple
- 1:21mission statement to find, identify and expose businesses
- 1:25that are lying to the general public and taking advantage of
- 1:27consumers. Review Fraud lists thousands of
- 1:30businesses across the country suspected of having fake
- 1:33reviews. Jason is joining us today from
- 1:35Pasadena. Hello there.
- 1:36Yeah, it's my pleasure to be here.
- 1:37Happy to speak about my favorite subject online reviews.
- 1:40Well, you've been in the search engine optimization industry for
- 1:43about 18 years now. What made you decide to start
- 1:46calling out companies that use bogus reviews?
- 1:48Well, I kind of got a little bored one day.
- 1:50I had a colleague of mine say that a business showed up at her
- 1:53house over a negative review that she left on Yelp.
- 1:55I looked it up and found the two companies she left one star
- 1:58reviews for and then when I found the business on Google,
- 2:01they had a 4.7 rating and I realized that they were
- 2:03falsifying reviews. Unfortunately, our industry has
- 2:06completely perverted the ideology behind reviews,
- 2:10reviews, our feedback. It's our clients and customers
- 2:12telling us areas that we do well in and areas that we need to
- 2:15improve. And instead what I see happen is
- 2:18a business gets a negative review and then a company
- 2:20reaches out to them and says, hey, we can help you with your
- 2:22online reputation. And all they do is just put fake
- 2:24positive reviews to bury the negative and it never works.
- 2:27I've seen businesses go out of business because they didn't
- 2:29address the negative feedback they're getting from the clients
- 2:32that was leading to the negative reviews and said all they did
- 2:34was just post fake positive reviews.
- 2:36So how are phony reviews created?
- 2:38Does a company just get the family to sit around the table
- 2:41and start posting reviews or is it more sophisticated than that?
- 2:44No, it's more sophisticated than that.
- 2:45So what we know is there's a bunch of shady marketers based
- 2:49out of India and Malaysia and Indonesia that are getting paid
- 2:53to sit there and create fake profiles and load up fake
- 2:57reviews for businesses. People can go do Google search
- 3:00to buy fake reviews. They could go on Facebook swap
- 3:03groups and do review exchanges. There's all sorts of ways that
- 3:06people can do it. Usually what happens is a
- 3:09business starts out and they'll go, OK, you know what, I want my
- 3:11family and friends leave us reviews.
- 3:13We can get jump start, but there's sophisticated networks
- 3:15out there of people that are buying and selling and trading
- 3:18online reviews. So what's the name of your dog
- 3:20in the background? Well, I've got Tina Turner.
- 3:23She just turned 4 this month. And then I've got Crystal Blue,
- 3:26who's standing on top of the couch.
- 3:28And then I've got Caitlin Clark, who's on the Ottoman.
- 3:31Well, you got to be a good guy if you like Critter, so I
- 3:33appreciate that. So how does your company review
- 3:36fraud, spot fake reviews? Oh.
- 3:38It's very easy. I look for patterns because
- 3:40everybody's got to tell. So like right now I'm looking at
- 3:42nail salon and up in Apple Valley and they had 27 reviews
- 3:47views posted within 3 weeks and all the reviewers had only left
- 3:51one review and set all their profiles to private.
- 3:53Well, most people don't know how to make their profile online
- 3:57private. So when you see 27 reviews and
- 3:59they've only left one review and they're all set to private,
- 4:01that's my giveaway. And then the other 52 reviews
- 4:04that I looked at were all left one review and their profiles
- 4:08were public. That's your giveaway.
- 4:09Or if I look at a review profile and say they're reviewing 18
- 4:14roofing contractors throughout the United States, well, that's
- 4:16not normal. Most people don't have 18 homes
- 4:18and 18 states. I look for those types of
- 4:20patterns and it's easy for me to spot it because I've been doing
- 4:23it for, gosh, seven years now. I noticed that some of the fake
- 4:26reviews you spotted over the years have nice images of the
- 4:29reviewer, but in many cases they're also bogus.
- 4:32Do you do a reverse search on the image to see if that's
- 4:34really just a PR shot that's been gone around the Internet or
- 4:37whatever? Oh yeah, I've found celebrities
- 4:41at Abigail Breslin, the guy from Super Size Me, Reporters,
- 4:46regular people. Yeah, they'll go steal it.
- 4:49Now what they've been doing is they're using AI to generate
- 4:52those images and you can generate any photo you want.
- 4:55So just because there's a photo with a review does not mean
- 4:57that's a legitimate person. That's correct.
- 5:00It could be one of these farms out of India or Asia.
- 5:03Jason. The big websites such as Amazon,
- 5:05Google, Mehta and Yelp say they're working hard to spot and
- 5:08remove fake reviews. For example, Amazon reports that
- 5:12it proactively blocked more than 250 million suspected fake
- 5:16reviews in 2023. Based on your experience, do you
- 5:19believe these sites are doing enough?
- 5:21Do they respond when you contact them about something you found?
- 5:24No, not at all. Google is very slow.
- 5:27Yelp does a little bit of a better job.
- 5:29Meta doesn't even do anything. So Meta doesn't remove reviews
- 5:33or fake profiles. And I've reported a lot.
- 5:35It takes a lot of work to get Meta to do something.
- 5:38You know, Meta did a whole sweep where they removed all these
- 5:41fakes, but they're still there. I monitor a lot of these groups
- 5:44and they just keep popping back up.
- 5:46So Meta doesn't do enough. Amazon knows there's issues.
- 5:48So no, they're not doing enough to police it and crack down,
- 5:51which is why the FTC came up with new rules so they have more
- 5:54teeth to go after visitors that are falsifying reviews.
- 5:57And we're going to talk to the FTC in just a minute.
- 5:59How do you deal with reviews? When you go online to check out
- 6:02a product or service, what do you do?
- 6:04I look at the five star reviews to see if they're actually legit
- 6:07and then I start looking at the one star reviews to see, you
- 6:11know what people's pain points. But I really hone in on the
- 6:14three star reviews. People that are going to be
- 6:16super, super happy are going to leave a five star.
- 6:18People are going to be super upset, are going to leave a one
- 6:20star review. But if you start looking at the
- 6:21three star reviews, you can get a better sense of what the
- 6:24company is really doing and what's going on there.
- 6:27But if I see like recurring themes that they don't respect
- 6:30their customers or they don't respond to their customers, then
- 6:32I'll go to the next business. I'm like, I'm not going to do
- 6:34it. How can our listeners use your
- 6:36website? Reviewfraud.org.
- 6:38Sure. They can come to me and report
- 6:40their competitors or businesses that they suspect or falsifying
- 6:43reviews, and then I'll do an investigation into it and work
- 6:47with the platforms to get the reviews taken down.
- 6:50I also work with the FTC. I work with local news stations,
- 6:53you know, to expose these bad businesses or if they just want
- 6:56to come and read information on how to protect themselves
- 6:59because there's a lot of fraud online.
- 7:01Jason Brown, founder of Review Fraud.
- 7:03Keep up the good work and thanks for spending time with us today.
- 7:06Oh, it's my pleasure. I always love talking about
- 7:08online reviews and protecting consumers, so I love the work
- 7:11that you guys are doing. A new federal rule, it's
- 7:13designed to reduce the volume of phony reviews and testimonials.
- 7:16We're going to talk to the Federal Trade Commission about
- 7:18that next. I'm Herb Weisbaugh, and this is
- 7:21Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 7:24No need to worry about fake reviews from Checkbook because
- 7:27Checkbooks ratings are based on subscriber feedback.
- 7:30We have trusted ratings for a variety of service providers
- 7:33including electricians, plumbers, dentists, eyewear
- 7:36stores and more. So if you live in or around one
- 7:39of these seven cities, Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle,
- 7:43San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul and Washington DC and
- 7:47haven't joined checkbook yet, check us out.
- 7:49Get a free 30 day subscription to all our ratings by going to
- 7:52checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. No one knows for sure what
- 7:58percentage of online reviews are bogus, but according to the
- 8:00website Fakespot, it's 30 to 40%.
- 8:04All of this deception makes it hard for you to get objective
- 8:07information about the products and services you plan to buy.
- 8:10Of course, fake reviews have always been illegal.
- 8:12It's an unfair, deceptive practice.
- 8:14But the Federal Trade Commission recently issued new rules that
- 8:17make it very clear what is prohibited and the stiff
- 8:20financial consequences for breaking the rules.
- 8:23Let's talk about that with Michael Oztheimer, a senior
- 8:25attorney in the Federal Trade Commission's Advertising
- 8:28Practices division. He worked on the new fake review
- 8:31rules. So I've dealt with the FTC long
- 8:33enough to know that this agency doesn't come up with rules Willy
- 8:36nilly. You issue them when you become
- 8:38aware of serious problems in the marketplace.
- 8:40So what's happening in regard to fake testimonials and reviews
- 8:43that spurred the Commission to create this rule?
- 8:46People often rely upon reviews and testimonials, and it's hard
- 8:49to tell whether they're fake or false or manipulated.
- 8:52It's very difficult for the average consumer to tell, and we
- 8:55saw that there was abundance of fake and false reviews and other
- 8:59egregious review practices. And you believe this is
- 9:02distorting the marketplace? Yes, we believe it's distorting
- 9:05the marketplace and we thought it was appropriate to address it
- 9:07by enacting a rule. So this new rule is designed to
- 9:10try to clean up the marketplace, and one of the key provisions
- 9:13seems fairly obvious. No fake or false reviews or
- 9:16testimonials. Maybe you can give a few
- 9:18examples of the ways reviews can be faked.
- 9:21We brought cases against companies that made-up fake
- 9:23consumer testimonials. For example, in a case called
- 9:26Welco, a company made deceptive claims about his television
- 9:29antennas and has simply copied the testimonials from its
- 9:32competitors websites. The rule prohibits creating
- 9:36writing, selling reviews or testimonials.
- 9:39I mean that could be a company that sells fake consumer reviews
- 9:42or the writes fake consumer reviews for its own products.
- 9:45The rule could also apply to a business that makes up celebrity
- 9:47testimonials. For example, last year scammers
- 9:50were using fake Shark Tank celebrity testimonials to sell
- 9:54their products. It could also apply to a paid
- 9:56influence who lies about having used a product or service or
- 9:59about their experience with it. In such cases, the influencer
- 10:02could be liable. Provision would also prohibit
- 10:04testimonials that they know or should know are false.
- 10:07For example, a couple years ago we brought a case against Google
- 10:11involving iHeartRadio DJ's who recorded scripted ads talking
- 10:15about their use of a Google Pixel 4 phone that they'd never
- 10:19used. When the ads were first
- 10:20recorded, the phones hadn't even been released yet.
- 10:23Furthermore, when DJ's asked for the phones so they could
- 10:26actually use them and say they use them, Google said no.
- 10:29Finally, the provision about fake and false reviews also
- 10:32prohibits businesses from buying consumer reviews that they know
- 10:35or should know are fake or false and prohibits them from
- 10:38procuring consumer reviews from certain company inside for
- 10:42posting on 3rd party sites when the business knows whether
- 10:44they're fake or false. We've brought multiple cases
- 10:47like that and a case against Sunday Riley Cosmetics.
- 10:50The CEO asked her staff to set up multiple fake accounts to
- 10:54write reviews of their products on the Sephora website.
- 10:57This rule is incredibly extensive and I want to go over
- 10:59a few of the key provisions. You said that there are no
- 11:02buying reviews, and that includes positive or negative
- 11:05reviews. Why would someone want to buy
- 11:07negative reviews? Because someone might want to
- 11:09have negative reviews of their competitor.
- 11:12For example, they might pay someone to write a one star
- 11:15review over their competitor on Google or on Yelp.
- 11:17The new rule also prohibits suppressing reviews.
- 11:20Clearly this skews the marketplace.
- 11:22How's the Commission dealing with this?
- 11:23Well, there's two different types of suppression the rule
- 11:26talks about. One would be suppression on a
- 11:28company's own website. The rule prohibits a business
- 11:31from misrepresenting that the reviews and a portion of its
- 11:34website dedicated to receiving and displaying reviews represent
- 11:37most or all of the reviews submitted.
- 11:39For example, a company could set its review management program to
- 11:43only post four or five star reviews.
- 11:45That's what a fast fashion company called Fashion Nova once
- 11:47did. And any reviews that were less
- 11:50than four stars just sat in purgatory and consumers didn't
- 11:53see them. So people going to the website
- 11:55only saw four and five star reviews.
- 11:56That's one type of review suppression.
- 11:58The other type of review suppression usually involves
- 12:01third party websites, where someone could go to people who
- 12:05posted reviews on 3rd party websites such as Yelp or Google
- 12:11or TripAdvisor and threaten them.
- 12:14The rule prohibits businesses from using unfounded or
- 12:18groundless legal threats, physical threats, intimidation
- 12:21or certain false public accusations to prevent the
- 12:23posting or cause the removal of all a part of a consumer review.
- 12:27So the goal here is to make sure that if you're going to post
- 12:30reviews or if reviews are posted somewhere else, people get the
- 12:33true picture of what the reviewers thought about the
- 12:35product or service. Absolutely.
- 12:37And if you're going to accept reviews on your website, you've
- 12:39got to accept all reviews, the good and the.
- 12:42Well, you have to treat the reviews that are good and bad
- 12:44equally. There are legitimate OK reasons
- 12:47for not posting certain reviews. For example, the reviews could
- 12:51contain content that's defamatory, harassing, obscene,
- 12:55vulgar, sexually explicit. And all of those reasons might
- 12:58be fine for not posting certain reviews.
- 13:01But you need to treat reviews that are positive and negative
- 13:04equally. And you can't just single out
- 13:05negative reviews for suppression.
- 13:07Could you explain to me the part of the rule that says no?
- 13:10Misrepresenting the popular priority on social media through
- 13:13followers or views generated by a bot.
- 13:15Consumers and other people make decisions based upon people's
- 13:20influence, these metrics. They make decisions whether to
- 13:23hire someone, whether to invest with the business, whether to
- 13:26purchase, whether to listen to music based on whether a person
- 13:30or a song has lots of followers, has lots of likes, where lots of
- 13:35listens, and it misleads people. So basically, the rule prohibits
- 13:41either buying or selling fake indicators generated by bots, by
- 13:46hijacked accounts, or that otherwise do not reflect their
- 13:49real individuals or entities, activities or opinions.
- 13:52So these are social media influencers who buy or use bots
- 13:56to drive up the people that are supposedly following them, when
- 13:58in fact they don't have that much influence.
- 14:00It's not limited to influencers. I mean, somebody who's a
- 14:03musician might buy plays of their song to make it look like
- 14:07their song is more popular. A motivational speaker might buy
- 14:10followers to make it look like they are more popular.
- 14:13A lawyer might buy LinkedIn connections to make themselves
- 14:15look like they have Better Business connections and
- 14:18connections in the real world. So if a social media influencer
- 14:21or celebrity is paid to provide a testimonial, as we know many
- 14:25are, does the FTC require disclosure?
- 14:28And how prominent or how obvious must that disclosure be?
- 14:31Sure, that's not covered by the rule, but social media
- 14:34influencer, celebrity, or individual who's paid to provide
- 14:36a testimonial should disclose the payment if a significant
- 14:40portion of consumers wouldn't expect the payment and if
- 14:42knowing about it would cause them to give the testimonial
- 14:45less weight of credibility. If a disclosure is necessary, it
- 14:48should be clear and conspicuous, meaning that it's hard for
- 14:51people to miss it and easy for people to see it and understand
- 14:54it. Depending on the circumstances,
- 14:56they might be able to use the disclosure like hashtag ad or
- 14:59sponsored by XYZ company, but it would really depend upon the
- 15:02circumstances. So getting back to the rule,
- 15:04what sort of penalties are involved for violation the?
- 15:07Penalties can be up to $51,744.00 per violation.
- 15:12Fairly significant. That is significant.
- 15:14Yes, it can add. Up quickly, Michael Oztheimer is
- 15:16with the advertising Practices division of the Federal Trade
- 15:19Commission. Michael, thank you for spending
- 15:21time with us today. Thank you.
- 15:22You'll find a link to the FT CS new reviews and testimonial rule
- 15:26in the show notes. You know, there are some things
- 15:28you can do to spot fake reviews. We'll share some of those tips
- 15:31straight ahead. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 15:34man, and you're listening to Consumer Pedia Power
- 15:37bycheckbook.org. Consumer PDF Fast Facts
- 15:42According to a survey by Power Reviews, a business software
- 15:45development company, most shoppers 92%, submit reviews at
- 15:50least once every six months. 60% write multiple reviews each
- 15:54month. The top three motivations for
- 15:56submitting ratings and reviews are a positive experience,
- 15:59receiving free product samples and a negative experience.
- 16:04Higher star ratings significantly impact products
- 16:06sales, research by McKinsey and Company finds.
- 16:09Products with three or four stars have three times higher
- 16:12sales in similar products with only one star.
- 16:18The FTC's new rules should help clean up the marketplace, but it
- 16:21won't stop all fake reviews and testimonials.
- 16:23Glowing reviews move merchandise, So it's fair to
- 16:26assume that some companies and fraudsters will continue to
- 16:29create fake reviews and testimonials.
- 16:31And because of AI, it's not always easy to spot them.
- 16:34But there are some things you can do.
- 16:36Our good friend Teresa Murray, the consumer watchdog at US
- 16:39Perg, is here to explain. Hi there, Teresa.
- 16:42How's everything in Cleveland? Hello, Herb.
- 16:43Cold. Just as we'd expected, it's not
- 16:46always easy to spot. Not the fake review, but
- 16:49sometimes you can sort of figure it out.
- 16:50And I'm going to go over 5 tips that you have.
- 16:52Tip #1 is look at the dates of the reviews.
- 16:56How's that work? Yeah.
- 16:57I mean, if you're say you're looking at a product and you're
- 17:00looking at the reviews and there's this flurry of reviews
- 17:04in a very short period of time. Maybe the product's been
- 17:06available for three years, five years, and there's just been
- 17:09this flood all of a sudden in a short period, then that might
- 17:13raise a flag. It might seem like one person or
- 17:16one entity is producing all of those fake reviews and just
- 17:20uploading them to the website with AI.
- 17:23Who knows how these reviews might be getting written?
- 17:25So if a product's been on the market for a while and you see
- 17:28reviews scattered throughout time as you would expect it to
- 17:30be, that's a sign that they might be more reliable than a
- 17:33whole bunch all posted at the same time or within the same
- 17:36time of time frame. Yes, yes, absolutely.
- 17:38If there was a whole bunch that were posted in the last month or
- 17:41so for a product that's existed for five years, that would
- 17:44arouse suspicion. Your second tip is watch out for
- 17:47reviews that you similar language like and maybe it's cut
- 17:50and paste or something like that.
- 17:52Yes, exactly. I mean, sometimes some companies
- 17:54have been accused of paying people or enlisting their
- 17:58friends and relatives and neighbors to post reviews, but
- 18:01they don't get creative enough to actually, like, change the
- 18:04language up a little bit. So you might see very similar
- 18:07language repeated on review after review after review.
- 18:11And that is a red flag. Tip #3 See whether the
- 18:14reviewer's purchase was verified.
- 18:16Can you explain that? Sure.
- 18:17I mean, not every website does this, but those that do, they
- 18:20will often say whether it was a verified purchase and when the
- 18:23purchase was. And if you're seeing a bunch of
- 18:27reviews that it doesn't say whether or not the person
- 18:30actually bought the product or used the service, then that
- 18:33might mean it's not legitimate. It's not a guarantee that just
- 18:36because XYZ Company says that Bob Smith was a verified
- 18:41purchase, that's actually true. Tip #4 is beware of reviews that
- 18:45sound too good. This kind of varies.
- 18:47I mean, if you visited a resort or you bought a new piece of
- 18:52technology or a new pair of tennis shoes, you might say,
- 18:55hey, you know, these shoes, this thing that I bought, this is so
- 18:58much better than the last thing I bought.
- 19:00This is great. It works well, it charges
- 19:02easily. It's, you know, the shoes are
- 19:04comfortable. You may not necessarily write a
- 19:08long enough review to offer some critiques, but say if you go to
- 19:13an all inclusive resort, you're probably going to say OK.
- 19:16The staff was really polite, the rooms were clean, the activities
- 19:20were great, but sometimes the food was cold.
- 19:22So you might find something that you wouldn't give an A+ plus
- 19:26rating to. If it was just one review that
- 19:28was that way, that was just glowing with nothing negative,
- 19:31that wouldn't necessarily by itself be a reason for concern.
- 19:35But if alls you're seeing are just these gushing over the top
- 19:39reviews and nobody has anything bad to say, then you might be
- 19:43suspicious. And not so long ago if these
- 19:46reviews were written by AI, it might stick out because of the
- 19:49the skewed language or whatever. But AI models have gotten so
- 19:52good now you may not be able to spot if they write something in
- 19:55typical English or whatever. Oh yeah, you're absolutely
- 19:57right. I mean, it's entering whole new
- 20:00land for us because you can't tell.
- 20:03And tip #5 you have, and this is maybe the most important one,
- 20:06beware of social media reviews. Yes, a lot of people, especially
- 20:10younger people, they just put too much stock in what they see
- 20:13on social media, especially like Instagram and TikTok.
- 20:16And you have sometimes celebrities or people who are
- 20:19actually paid to promote these products.
- 20:22And I mean, a lot of times people are just not very
- 20:24discerning. But again, there are so many
- 20:27influencers on social media who may sneak it in or not really do
- 20:30what they're required to do. It's pretty possible for you to
- 20:33miss that. Or just assume that this is my
- 20:35friend who wants to share the best makeup with me and not
- 20:38really let it sink in that they're getting paid to tell me
- 20:40this is the best makeup or the best food package or the best
- 20:43piece of clothing or whatever. Yeah, all of that is true.
- 20:46And then sometimes you might look at like how many views a
- 20:49particular post has had and say, Oh, well, this has had 5 million
- 20:52views and this person has X number million followers.
- 20:55But some of that could actually be generated by a bot.
- 20:58So not everything is as it seems.
- 21:00Quite frankly, if I were considering a product or a
- 21:03service, so, you know, whether it's makeup or tennis shoes or
- 21:06some kind of electronics, I'm not going to look on social
- 21:09media to find out which ones to buy.
- 21:11I'm going to talk to friends. I'm going to talk to trusted
- 21:13colleagues. I'm going to talk to people like
- 21:15you, real people, to find out what their experience has been.
- 21:19If I buy something and I know it's reviewed by a reliable
- 21:22source, maybe Consumer Reports or PC magazine or CNET or
- 21:25something like that, I'll go to reviews from people who are
- 21:28independent and not getting paid, as opposed to just looking
- 21:31at reviews or seeing what somebody who I know possibly is
- 21:34getting paid to pitch the product.
- 21:35That's how I make my decisions. Is that how you do yours?
- 21:38Well, that makes a lot of sense. The whole thing about people who
- 21:40were paid to give reviews, that is now one of the things that's
- 21:44not allowed if it's not disclosed.
- 21:46But you know, you're always better talking with somebody
- 21:49that you know then all of this anonymous junk online.
- 21:53Let me ask you personally, if you're about to buy something,
- 21:55do you check reviews and do you look at the stars?
- 21:58Because that's all added up on these reviews.
- 21:59It could be fake. How do you use these things?
- 22:01Yes, I do look at reviews for most of the things that I buy.
- 22:06It doesn't matter whether it's $2.00 or $20.00 or $200 because
- 22:10even the two dollar thing, even though it doesn't cost that much
- 22:12money, that may actually be unsafe.
- 22:14And so I don't want to buy that. I mean, I start off with looking
- 22:17at the number of stars. I start off 4 1/2 is good.
- 22:20That's a starting point. If it's like 3 out of five,
- 22:23Nope, I'm out. If it's only got like 17
- 22:26reviews, Nope, that's not enough, I'm out.
- 22:29But then if it passes those two things and then I start reading
- 22:32the reviews, I usually look at the negative reviews 1st.
- 22:35And sometimes the negative reviews would be like, oh, hey,
- 22:38this thing took two weeks to get to me and it was too late to
- 22:42give it as a gift. So that's a legitimate issue,
- 22:44but it doesn't necessarily speak to the quality of the product.
- 22:47So I kind of tossed that aside. But I also read if there are a
- 22:50lot of people who are just like hopping up and down mad,
- 22:54sometimes you'll see people say, I gave this one star only
- 22:57because I couldn't give it zero. And here's why.
- 23:00And so if you read a lot of those, again, we have so much
- 23:03choice on the marketplace. So if I read a handful of just
- 23:07really scathing reviews about a product, I'm moving on.
- 23:11I have other choices. And again, if it only has a
- 23:13handful of reviews, you know that I can count on my fingers
- 23:17and toes. That's not a good enough number
- 23:19of reviews to use to evaluate what could be either what's good
- 23:22for my wallet, what's good for my health.
- 23:24And if it's a super expensive product, if it's like a new
- 23:28television or an appliance, I'll obviously do more research
- 23:32there. I'll look at multiple sources.
- 23:34If I'm going to buy a television at Best Buy, I'm going to look
- 23:38at reviews for that television also at other stores, you know,
- 23:41Target and so forth, because that way I'm getting a fuller
- 23:45picture. That's some really good advice,
- 23:47Teresa. Thank you.
- 23:48Teresa Murray is a consumer watchdog at US PERG.
- 23:51They're online at Perg PIR g.org and you will find a link to her
- 23:57tips on how to read reviews in the show notes of this podcast.
- 24:01Teresa, thanks for being with us.
- 24:02Thanks for having us. Here's something else you might
- 24:04want to do. Use Fakespot, an app and browser
- 24:07extension that's now part of the Mozilla family of trusted web
- 24:10tools. Go to Fakes spot.com Fake Spots
- 24:13algorithms analyze patterns and online reviews to identify the
- 24:16ones that are more likely to be untrustworthy.
- 24:19It then adjusts the rating and provides you with review
- 24:21highlights, pros and cons, price history, and alternative
- 24:25products from reputable brands. Before we go, let me share a few
- 24:28other consumer pedia episodes you might want to check out #36
- 24:32Dark patterns, Sales Tactics Designed to deceive #49 Shop
- 24:36like a pro, Checkbooks, Top shopping tips, and #58
- 24:40Misleading marketing that gets you to buy now and pay more.
- 24:44A lot of great information and good listening there for you.
- 24:47And with that, we come to the end of this episode.
- 24:49We hope you'll rate it for us. Checkbook does value honest
- 24:52reviews. Remember, you can follow us on
- 24:54Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your
- 24:57podcasts. We release new episodes every
- 25:00other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 25:02show is to follow us on Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 25:06Instagram and at my Consumerpedia on X, formerly
- 25:10Twitter. I'm Herb Weisbaum.
- 25:12Thanks for listening. Consumerpedia is a public
- 25:15service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 25:18helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 25:21You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 25:24and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 25:27unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 25:30seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 25:34Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 25:38Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC.
- 25:41To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 25:43checkbook.org/consumer Pedia. If you like what you've heard,
- 25:47we hope you'll become a supporter by using the link at
- 25:50the bottom of the show notes to make a small contribution each
- 25:53month. Consumer Pedia.
- 25:55Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.