Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #211 - Sean Orr / Papa & Christine Boyle / Alex Hemingway
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. If folks, my name is Mohamir and this is band Color,
- 0:20British Columbia's Bonified culture and politics TV talk show. Tonight is all about
- 0:24housing. And I know we talked about housing all the time, but I
- 0:28want to find out if a landlord can actually legally tell a tenant that they're
- 0:33not allowed to have guests or even have a beer in the home that the
- 0:38tenant is paying money to live in. But first, for a housing crisis,
- 0:42have BC municipalities like Vancouver deployed every tool in the policy toolbox to make
- 0:47rents cheaper? You'll be shocked to learn that no, they haven't here to
- 0:51tell us more. As a former Vancouver City Council candidate and a writer for
- 0:55Scout magazine, backed by popular demand, he is Sean or On. Hello.
- 1:00Hello, thanks for returning to the program. So many people have been
- 1:03hounding me. Yeah, I can't control that. I'm sorry. Yeah,
- 1:06So you and I are on the same page when it comes to municipalities and
- 1:10what they can do with regards to the housing crisis. Oftentimes municipalities kind of
- 1:14shrug their shoulders and go, oh, it's a provincial thing, it's a
- 1:15federal thing. But I think of things like Airbnb where they can actually enforce
- 1:19the rules. They can maybe ban air and B and B or at least
- 1:23create more restrictions. You have some other ideas that they can really do,
- 1:26but they're not pursuing. What do you got in mind? Yeah? Absolutely,
- 1:32And again I just you kind of mentioned it off the top. You
- 1:34know, we have to act like this as a crisis, and by calling
- 1:38it a housing crisis kind of ignores the fact that it's a manufactured crisis.
- 1:42Like we know what to do, we just don't have the political will because
- 1:46it would mean lowering house prices for people. And as you put it so
- 1:52eloquently on your last segment, I got mine. But yeah, there are
- 2:00so many mechanisms that that cities can do. I even asked, you know,
- 2:04chat GPT for bold housing situations. Yeah, I need to tell you
- 2:07it's more it's more innovative and creative than any politician that I've heard other than
- 2:14myself myself. But uh, you know, yeah, it came up with
- 2:17a pretty comprehensive list of things that it could be doing, like a kind
- 2:22of like a tool kit of things that it could be doing that that we
- 2:25just aren't. Let's see, Sorry, I have to check my notes because
- 2:30uh so, community land trusts. I really like that one universal basic housing
- 2:37rent control, which we're sort of going to touch on in a second here
- 2:40empty homes taxes as we as we have here, but are like could be
- 2:46tripling them or what we're doing retroactive giveaways to developers, housing co op co
- 2:53ops, zoning, land use reform is a big one affordable housing vochers,
- 3:00you know, building public housing for example, Like, wow, what about
- 3:04let's rent control and specifically vacancy control. I'm a little curious about this one.
- 3:08Basically, if you are renting, you know, there's only a certain
- 3:10amount that they can increase. But if you move out, the new tenants
- 3:15would have to pay a lot more they can basically pay, or they would
- 3:17have to pay whatever, you know, the landlord wind set or whatever the
- 3:21market bears right, and that is looking like an average of about forty three
- 3:25percent that the tenant to a new ten from a tenant to a new tenant.
- 3:30And so what is vacancy control. The vacancy control ties the rent to
- 3:34the unit instead of to the renter. So when a new when a renter
- 3:37leaves the unit, kind of stays at the same Oh okay, yeah,
- 3:43so basically the same protection as renters currently have, but then just extending it
- 3:47for if the renter moves out exactly, and that affects everything. I mean,
- 3:52you get to a point where new buildings and older rental units are at
- 3:57the same price, right essentially. And you've also talked about the right of
- 4:00first refusal. What is that when it comes to municipalities. What kind of
- 4:04policy is that? Right first refusal is really interesting something I really like Montreal
- 4:09does it, and it's something where a municipality has the right to first refuse
- 4:15a building that comes up on the market. So an apartment comes up on
- 4:21the market, or a rooming house or an sroro comes up, and the
- 4:27city has the first right to say we want this and we want to include
- 4:30this in our public housing store. Oh okay, yeah, so that makes
- 4:33sense. And then aside from that, the city also has a lot of
- 4:39cities have public land, specifically Vancouver as well. That's true. I mean
- 4:45it can be a little controversial. I mean, we own public golf courses
- 4:48and that wasn't very popular during my campaign, but the Vancouver is still in
- 4:53some neighborhood to turn public golf courses into social housing. I'm sure was not.
- 5:00No. But aside from golf courses, are there other lands? Well,
- 5:02the Vancouver school Board owns I think it's two hundred and forty two hectares
- 5:09of land and that includes one hundred and twenty five individual buildings. And these
- 5:14are not schools, not schools, this is property in their portfolio that they
- 5:19own. I think it's I think it totals around seven billion dollars. And
- 5:24you know these some some of these properties have been earmarked, you know,
- 5:27for sale to give away to developers. And if we are going to tackle
- 5:32it like a crisis, that's land that we build on. Yeah. Absolutely,
- 5:36I'm sorry East Fan. I know Kingskate Mall is very popular, but
- 5:41you know, maybe make it into some houses, got it, like you
- 5:43know, forty stories of I think what's fascinating about all these things that you've
- 5:46talked about is that other jurisdictions are doing them, even vacancy control, you
- 5:50know, there is a form of that in US, Minister, and so
- 5:55even though we're looking at Vancouver, this has you know, this can resonate
- 5:58with other municipalities throughout BC. Absolutely and British Columbia had vacancy control in the
- 6:03seventies, and so when they're the argument is that you know, it'll detract
- 6:09from investors or whatnot. I mean, which is good. You want you
- 6:13want the definancialized out a financialization of housing in my opinion, certainly to bring
- 6:19down rents exactly right, But it didn't have the sort of effect that the
- 6:27landlord lobby would have you believe it was. You know, it was a
- 6:30fairly successful program in the seventies and we got rid of it. I mean,
- 6:33you talked to alex Emiway. I'm sure he talked about progressive property tax.
- 6:38We could have had that in nineteen ninety three, you know, but
- 6:42the housing lobby said, you know what, I'm not gonna say it again.
- 6:46I got Sean a pleasure. Thank you so much for illuminating us with
- 6:51these many policy options for sure time. Thanks for having me. Absolutely folks,
- 6:57you wanted more or you got more or of core he is Sean or
- 7:00Now after some business, there are rental listings with wild conditions for tenants beyond
- 7:05just the outrageous cost of rent. TikTok star Papa is going to tell us
- 7:11about them and Vancouver City Counselor Christine Boyle is going to explain whether these demands
- 7:15are even legal. That's up next. Welcome back to this as Van color.
- 7:27Vancouver has the highest rents in the entire country, with the current average
- 7:31asking price for a rental apartment listed at over thirty three hundred dollars a month.
- 7:38As market Rents throughout BC are up over ten percent in the last year.
- 7:42But sometimes what's worse than the sticker shock of a rental unit is the
- 7:46nightmarish conditions that landlords demand of tenants. Documenting some of these absurd rental listings
- 7:53is a local TikTok phenomenon at Melty Head Pats. She is Papa and returning
- 7:59to the show to explain if these type of listings are even legal. Is
- 8:01Vancouver City Councilor Christine Boile. Christine, Papa, thanks for being on the
- 8:07show tonight. Thank you, thanks for having us absolutely Papa. So you've
- 8:11been investigating these rental units. What are some of the weirdest conditions that you've
- 8:16seen on these rental listings? Yeah, so pretty common ones are like no
- 8:22noise, no party, no guests, sorry, no noise, noise.
- 8:26Yes, I've seen actually no noise and no guests. No guests, Okay,
- 8:33no cooking strong or pungent herbs, no cooking garlic or onion, no
- 8:37frying with oil. So they're like dictating your diet and culinary activities as well.
- 8:43Yeah, I've all seen no cooking in the room. Wow, Christine,
- 8:48that can't be legal, can it? So I think we know the
- 8:52rental situation is so desperate people sign these absurd leases because they just need a
- 8:58place to live. I am sorry to be the bearer of bad news and
- 9:03saying most of those are not illegal. What matters really is it written into
- 9:09the least, not just on the listing, but in the least, and
- 9:13then is it enforceable? So no cooking, no cooking, garlic, no
- 9:18noise. They are legal, Are they enforceable? It's really about is it
- 9:26doing harm? So you can imagine a situation where if there's an extreme allergy
- 9:31in the building, maybe there's a reason, or somebody works nights and they
- 9:35but for the most part they're they're not leading guests. You can have that
- 9:41into a No guests is the one exception. So actually the RTA is the
- 9:46rental tendency agreement very clear that you can't prohibit guests, And what I hear
- 9:54all the time is that is one of the rules that is most often broken
- 9:58by landl who do try to enforce that rule. It's illegal to say no
- 10:03guests. Your landlord cannot ban you from having guests, even if it's in
- 10:07the lease agreement. And you, yeah, absolutely not enforced. Okay,
- 10:13Papa. You've also brought up a lot of rental listings that basically barter rent
- 10:18in different ways. Can you can you talk about that? Yeah, I've
- 10:22seen some that are barter for rent. So it was a seventy five dollars
- 10:28a month discount for ten to twenty hours of a month, So ten hours
- 10:35worth of work and you get seventy five bucks off a month. Yes,
- 10:39so seven and a half dollars. But in the listing it said ten to
- 10:43twenty hours at minimum wage, but then was absolutely not reflected whatsoever in the
- 10:48discount of the of the rent. And also regular chores like vacuuming, taking
- 10:54the trash out, all that stuff that did not count wow at all for
- 10:58your ten to twenty hours. So Christine, is serfdom legal? Like,
- 11:03can you basically work off your your rent for less than minimum wage or at
- 11:07minimum wage. Again, I am very sorry to say it's not illegal.
- 11:13It's what very messy, you know, arguably unethical. Certainly if you're paying
- 11:20far below a minimum wage, you know, it brings up all sorts of
- 11:24issues about workplace safety. You know what if you get sick, are you
- 11:30are you going to get sick and lose your home? I mean, it's
- 11:31incredibly messy, but it is not illegal. And it goes back to the
- 11:37desperate situation. So many renters are in in just being able to find a
- 11:41place they can afford to live and then signing. And I can understand that
- 11:46there may be some occupations where you know, there is kind of a discounted
- 11:50rent situation if it's an a pair or you know, a live in made
- 11:54I suppose, but can you actually be bartering for less than minimum wage like
- 11:58that? That seems illegal based on labor laws, right, It is legal
- 12:07if that's the least agreement that you sign, because it's not it's not the
- 12:13type of job that would fall under labor laws unless you're running. It gets
- 12:16into a lot of details if if they're running a home business and you are
- 12:22functionally an employee of the business, then they're important questions. You should be
- 12:26asking about worker safety, worker compensation, and all of that, But household
- 12:31chores. It's really a massive gray area, Papa. When you go through
- 12:37these listings, did you assume that this stuff was illegal or did you actually
- 12:43think that You've seen it so many times that I guess probably it is legal.
- 12:48I thought it was. I mean, I thought if it's in writing,
- 12:52it could be held up as legal. I didn't agree with it,
- 12:56but I guess if it's in writing and you sign it, then it could
- 13:01hold up. But and you've seen some other weird conditions as well, with
- 13:05regard to even access to the unit as a tenant, right, Oh yeah,
- 13:11yeah, I've seen like to not be in the house between certain hours,
- 13:16or it'll say like tenant is expected to go to school or work Monday
- 13:20to Friday, nine to five. So tenants, So I get this straight.
- 13:26So tenants who are paying money to live in a basement, suite or
- 13:30a unit are explicitly told that on a weekly, regular, daily basis they
- 13:35cannot access their unit at in certain hours. Yeah, don't live there.
- 13:39This can't be It's not illegal. Again, it gets back to is it
- 13:48written into your lease? And is it enforceable. And I think the question
- 13:52to be asking is around harm. Is it causing significant harm to someone else
- 14:00in the building. So if you are home and making very loud noise during
- 14:03the day and somebody in another unit works from home, you know, maybe
- 14:09you can see there's something written in there for that reason. But for the
- 14:15most case, I would say something in your lease that says you can't be
- 14:20in the home. It's not illegal, but it's also not enforceable. So
- 14:24let's say someone has these conditions as a landlord to the tenant right and they
- 14:28say that you have to meet all these conditions. You can't cook, you
- 14:33can't be in your apartment or suite at a certain time, and the tenant
- 14:37breaks those conditions, the landlord that can then kick them out. Is that
- 14:43what I'm hearing, Like, I have one more terrible piece of news,
- 14:46please, which is if you live in a suite with your landlord. So
- 14:54if you're in a home, you're renting out a room, it's your landlord's
- 14:58play. And particularly what to note is if you're sharing a kitchen or washroom
- 15:05with the owner of the suite. With the landlord, you don't even the
- 15:11RTA doesn't even apply to you. So we've talked about all of the things
- 15:16that fall under the RTA, but if you're in one of those situations or
- 15:20you're subletting, that doesn't it doesn't apply to you anyway, So you have
- 15:24even fewer rental protections if you're just renting a room from a landlord or you're
- 15:30subletting from someone. Well, this has been eye opening and very depressing.
- 15:35Christine, thank you for providing us these very great answers. Papa, Thanks
- 15:39for everything that you do on TikTok to expose these apparently legal but very strange
- 15:43rental listings. And thank you both for your time tonight. Very appreciated.
- 15:48Thank you. Thanks absolutely, folks. What a duo that was Vancouver City
- 15:52councilor Christine Boyle giving us the alarming truth about what landlords can get away with,
- 15:56and of course that was TikTok Star Papa. Find her at melty Head
- 16:02Paths on TikTok. Now up next? Can we just like tax our way
- 16:06out of the housing crisis. Let's find out up next? Welcome back to
- 16:15this as Van Color. We've been looking at housing from alternative perspective, so
- 16:21let's talk to the senior economist and public finance policy analyst at the Canadian Center
- 16:26for Policy Alternatives. He is Alex Hemingway. Alex, thanks so much for
- 16:30being on the show tonight. Thanks for having me mo So, I got
- 16:33to ask you. We live in this weird environment when it comes to housing.
- 16:37A lot of people are making a lot of money off housing, or
- 16:38at least seeing their investment or asset appreciate you in crazy terms, And at
- 16:45the same time renters are struggling to find a place to pay an affordable rent.
- 16:51Can we just tax our way out of this? Is there a solution
- 16:52where we can just tax our way out? Well, actually no, we
- 16:56can't just tax our way out. Taxes can play a role. You know,
- 17:00there's a whole range of things we need to do to address the housing
- 17:03crisis. Two of the most fundamental other ones to me are we need to
- 17:07massively increase investment in not for profit and public housing. We need to significantly
- 17:12increase the overall supply of housing of all kinds. Address those municipal level roadblocks
- 17:18that are chronically blocking housing, exclusionary zoning that bans apartments in most of the
- 17:25land in most of our cities. Having said that property tax the focus of
- 17:29our recent report plays a related but a distinct role, and what it can
- 17:34do is help address the accumulated land wealth inequality that is taken off as housing
- 17:41prices have exploded in recent decades. It can also help raise revenue that can
- 17:47go towards investment in some of that affordable housing that I was talking about a
- 17:51moment ago, and I think I'm decoding this, and so what I'm getting
- 17:55at is you want to raise property taxes, which I feel like is probably
- 17:57not a very popular thing amongst homeowners. Am I right? Well? I
- 18:02think you are right. And what we've done in this recent report is lay
- 18:06out a menu of property tax policy options focus at the provincial level. Provincial
- 18:11policy. I thought property taxes are a municipal Well, it's actually municipal,
- 18:15regional and provincial. And the province LEVI is a significant portion of property taxes.
- 18:22And look, you know, the sheer level of property wealth in this
- 18:26province is staggering. So it's increased by one point seven trillion dollars in less
- 18:33than two decades just since the mid two thousands. That's just the residential property
- 18:37by way, And so what we wanted to do largely focusing on the top
- 18:42end of the property market. Is lay out a menu of policy options that
- 18:47could help address that extreme inequality, help tackle that and bring in some revenue
- 18:52that could go towards affordable housing. How do you sell this to the general
- 18:56public, because I feel like the general public is very resistant to any idea
- 19:00of property tax increases. Property tax policy can be very contentious, there's no
- 19:04question about that. In the report, we look at a range of options.
- 19:08Some of them are quite narrowly targeted. So for example, raising property
- 19:12tax rates just on the portion of the value above three million dollars, also
- 19:18adding a new bracket above seven million dollars. We could bring in substantial revenue
- 19:22with that type of policy that only affects two percent of the most expensive properties
- 19:26in the province. We look at broader based options too. There the politics
- 19:30are much more challenging, but I think it's a discussion we have to have.
- 19:34Even property rich British Columbians, I think, recognize that the huge land
- 19:40value gains that we've seen in this province have largely been a stroke of luck,
- 19:45and that's unintentionally from their perspective, come at the expense of others and
- 19:49this housing crisis is corroding our social fabric. So I think we have to
- 19:53face down the extent of the inequality that's been created, and we have to
- 19:59have a discussion about that. So really quickly, to summarize, you're proposing
- 20:03that, you know, restructure property taxes. Certainly, raise them, especially
- 20:06at the upper level, raise some revenue to invest in social housing. But
- 20:10then also, you know, have that create a bit of a deflationary effect
- 20:12on home prices as well. Is that is that correct? Absolutely? And
- 20:18and and for where I wanted to go with that is, I've heard you
- 20:21say that Vancouver in particular has very low property taxes, but I've heard other
- 20:23people say that property taxes are out of control. So, so, really
- 20:26quickly, which one is it? All? Property tax rates in Vancouver and
- 20:30adjacent municipalities are among the lowest in North America. And the reason for that
- 20:34is property taxes are a bit unusual. You know, with the income tax
- 20:38or the sales tax. We set tax rates and they stick whether your income
- 20:44rises or falls, or whether you buy more stuff or less stuff. Property
- 20:48taxes rates are actually adjusted every year, and as prices have skyrocketed, the
- 20:53tax rates are adjusted to make sure, we're not raising too much revenue from
- 20:59property taxes, so it's an unusual type of tax, and it creates an
- 21:02incentive to hold residential real estate as an investment because the carrying costs are very
- 21:07low. And just think you know what other type of investment is. They're
- 21:11out there as whereas the value of that investment rises, the property tax or
- 21:15excuse me, the tax rate applied to it is decreased year after the year.
- 21:18That's an unusual situation. Well, Alex, I appreciate the work that
- 21:22you've done. I feel like it's going to generate a little controversy, but
- 21:26I certainly think that we have to look at this in the overall toolbox of
- 21:30policy options. So thanks so much for your time tonight. Thank you absolutely
- 21:34folks, that is our show. I hope you learned something new. I
- 21:37certainly have a new found appreciation for just how little we're doing to protect renters
- 21:42and how little we're doing to address the housing crisis. So big thank you
- 21:47to Seawan or TikTok or Papa, Vancouver City Counselor, Christine Boyle and Alex
- 21:52Hemingway for tonight's show. Please send your complaints to the team at check media
- 21:56dot c A. Of course this is Van Color and i'm o mere telling
- 21:59you and of a province where you can be anything, becomeful peace,