Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Cost per closing: the metric that cuts ad spend
Transcript
- 0:00Host: This is Leader's Insights.
- 0:07Host: On the table, switching to cost per closing cuts your real estate ad budget by a third.
- 0:11Host: A restaurant that judges itself on how many people walk through the door.
- 0:16Host: Not how many actually order dinner.
- 0:18Host: That's most real estate marketing teams right now, and the CFO has finally noticed.
- 0:22Expert: And the CFO is right to be irritated.
- 0:25Expert: Teams have spent a decade bragging about lead volume, while the people signing contracts
- 0:29Expert: stayed flat.
- 0:31Expert: The bragging metric and the paying metric stopped talking to each other.
- 0:35Host: The article makes a hard claim.
- 0:37Host: Switching to cost per closing cuts your ad budget by a third.
- 0:41Host: That sounds like the kind of number someone made up to sell a playbook.
- 0:44Expert: It sounds inflated until you see where the waste hides.
- 0:47Expert: When you optimize for cost per lead, the price of getting one person to raise their
- 0:52Expert: hand, you reward the cheapest channels.
- 0:55Expert: Cheap channels bring cheap leads.
- 0:57Expert: When you find out a third of your spend was feeding a pipeline that never converts, and
- 1:01Expert: you can cut it without losing a single closing.
- 1:04Host: Define the two terms cleanly, because people throw them around loosely.
- 1:09Expert: Cost per lead is what you pay for one inquiry.
- 1:12Expert: Cost per closing is what you pay, across all your marketing, for one deal that actually
- 1:17Expert: settles.
- 1:18Expert: The gap between them is the whole story.
- 1:20Expert: A lead at $14 can cost you $1,100 per closing if it never converts.
- 1:26Expert: And a lead at $90 can cost you $600 at closing, because those people are serious.
- 1:31Host: Give me the numbers the article actually leans on.
- 1:34Expert: The core figure is that one-third budget reduction.
- 1:37Expert: But the more useful number is conversion spread.
- 1:41Expert: HubSpot puts the average lead-to-customer rate in real estate at around 2 to 3 percent,
- 1:46Expert: though they sell marketing automation, so read that as a floor, not gospel.
- 1:51Expert: Cross-check it against your own settled deals.
- 1:54Expert: HubSpot's independent work on B2C attribution lands in a similar range for high-consideration
- 2:00Expert: purchases, which is the honest version.
- 2:03Host: 2 to 3 percent.
- 2:04Host: So 97 leads out of 100 are noise you're paying to attract.
- 2:08Expert: Correct.
- 2:09Expert: And here's what that changes for your next decision.
- 2:11Expert: If you allocate by lead volume, you pour money into the channel, producing the most hands
- 2:16Expert: in the air.
- 2:17Expert: SEMrush data.
- 2:19Expert: And they sell SEO tools.
- 2:21Expert: So I take their organic traffic optimism with salt.
- 2:24Expert: Shows search bringing enormous lead counts for property firms.
- 2:28Expert: Huge volume.
- 2:29Expert: But when you tag those leads through to settlement, portal referrals and agent referrals close at
- 2:34Expert: two or three times the rate.
- 2:36Host: So the cheap channel that looks like a hero on the lead dashboard is actually the villain
- 2:41Host: on the closing dashboard.
- 2:42Expert: The villain wearing the hero's costume.
- 2:45Expert: I worked with a mid-size brokerage last year that was spending 40 percent of budget on
- 2:49Expert: broad social ads because the leads were four dollars each.
- 2:53Host: Four dollars!
- 2:54Host: Beautiful on a slide.
- 2:56Expert: Their cost per closing on that channel was over two thousand.
- 3:00Expert: They moved that money into retargeting past inquirers and local search intent.
- 3:05Expert: And closings held while spend dropped 28 percent.
- 3:08Host: 28, not 33.
- 3:10Host: You're undercutting your own headline.
- 3:12Expert: I'd rather quote the deal I actually saw than the round number in a title.
- 3:17Expert: A third is the ceiling.
- 3:18Expert: Somewhere between a quarter and a third is what most teams find once they wire closings
- 3:22Expert: back to source.
- 3:24Host: Which is the part everyone skips.
- 3:26Host: You need the closing data to flow back to the ad.
- 3:28Host: Most teams can't do that.
- 3:30Expert: That's the real work.
- 3:31Expert: And it's unglamorous.
- 3:33Expert: MIT Sloan has written about this for years.
- 3:37Expert: Attribution fails not because the math is hard, but because the sales system and the
- 3:41Expert: marketing system never share a record.
- 3:44Expert: Your agents close a deal in one tool, your ads live in another, and nobody stitches the
- 3:49Expert: two.
- 3:50Expert: Fix that pipe first.
- 3:51Expert: Or the whole exercise is theater.
- 3:53Host: So for the person listening who runs a ten-person marketing team, what do they do Monday morning?
- 3:59Expert: Pull your last hundred closings, tag each one to the channel that originally sourced
- 4:03Expert: it, and divide total channel spend by closings, not by leads.
- 4:08Expert: You'll find one channel with a beautiful cost per lead and an embarrassing cost per
- 4:12Expert: closing.
- 4:13Expert: Set its budget by half this quarter and watch your closings not move.
- 4:17Expert: That's your proof and your raise.
- 4:19Host: What we read for this one, Forrester Research, Adweek, DigiDay, Semrush, Vendor, SEO Analytics
- 4:26Host: Tools, HubSpot, Vendor, CRM, Marketing Automation, MIT Sloan Management Review.
- 4:32Host: We'll stop there.
- 4:33Host: The whole CMO track in order is waiting at MBA-training.com.