Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #64 🎙️|Public Inquiry Week Impact on Community Beginning 19th May 2026 | Day 4
Transcript
- 0:05Today I was at the public inquiry until around midday
- 0:10before I had to leave for Belfast, which I'll explain more
- 0:13about later during the session. Dalradion and FODC legal teams
- 0:20asked the Commission to adjourn, so they could consider comments
- 0:24made during the previous day's hearings that they felt could
- 0:29impact the judicial review due to take place on Friday. There
- 0:34was already a growing sense of frustration around the lack of
- 0:37certainty and constant changes to the timetable, and throughout
- 0:41the day, the hearing was repeatedly adjourned. By the
- 0:45time I'd reached Belfast, I was getting updates that the
- 0:48commission had been delayed again and again. Eventually,
- 0:53word came through that the landscape hearings would no
- 0:56longer go ahead next week. To be honest, that was something I had
- 1:00expected, it seemed increasingly likely that the commission would
- 1:05have to back down under the pressure of the judicial review.
- 1:10Later in the afternoon, our solicitor confirmed that the
- 1:13judicial review had been withdrawn after the lead
- 1:16commissioner announced the decision to postpone the
- 1:19landscape topics. In the end, there was no longer any need for
- 1:24the legal challenge. The roads topic, however, will continue as
- 1:29originally scheduled next week. The reasoning behind postponing
- 1:32the landscape hearings was fairly clear. The roads
- 1:36discussions were already running longer than expected. They were
- 1:39concerned about the fairness, duplication, and practical
- 1:43problems that not all expert witnesses would be available at
- 1:47the same time. There was a real risk that some parties would be
- 1:52present while others wouldn't, leading to evidence having to be
- 1:56repeated further down the line. Aside from the inquiry itself,
- 2:01Sylver Spence was invited to speak at a meeting on the
- 2:04indigenous strategies for climate justice, and there was
- 2:08only one person left standing to do, and that was me. Everyone
- 2:11else was at the public inquiry. The keynote speaker was Ariel
- 2:15Deranger, founder of Indigenous Climate Action and the Woven
- 2:19Project. Listening to her speak was genuinely fascinating. She
- 2:25talked about growing up in Northern Alberta, where her
- 2:28family's traditional hunting lands were disrupted by uranium
- 2:33mining. Her upbringing was shaped by activism,
- 2:38environmental protection, and indigenous rights, and she spoke
- 2:42openly about witnessing the destruction caused by industrial
- 2:46extraction. What struck me most was how familiar much of her
- 2:52experience sounded. Sitting there, listening, I couldn't
- 2:55help but thinking about how closely it mirrored what we're
- 2:58experiencing in the Spurns, whether it's indigenous
- 3:01communities elsewhere in the world or rural communities here
- 3:05at home, the pattern feels exactly the same. People who
- 3:09have lived on and cared for a place for generations suddenly
- 3:12find themselves treated as obstacles to development rather
- 3:16than as people with deep knowledge, history, and
- 3:18connection to the place that really resonated with me,
- 3:23because the land here is not just about a location on a map
- 3:26or a mineral deposit in a report, it's our home, it's our
- 3:30memory, our identity, our history, and our belonging. One
- 3:34thing the whole process has been made increasingly obvious to me
- 3:37is how systems can strip the humanity out of communities,
- 3:41people stop being people and become receptors. Landscapes
- 3:45become impacts to be mitigated. The lived reality of local
- 3:49communities disappears behind technical language, consultants'
- 3:53reports, and endless paperwork. Another thing that stood out
- 3:57from Ariel's talk was the imbalance of power. Rural
- 4:00communities are expected to stand toe to toe with
- 4:02corporations and government departments, planning systems,
- 4:05and legal teams, and endless resources that ordinary people
- 4:09simply don't have. Most people involved in Save Our Spurs never
- 4:14expected to become campaigners. We simply found ourselves trying
- 4:16to protect the place we love, and for me, that's the important
- 4:20point. This has never just been about opposing something; it's
- 4:24always about protecting the air, the water, the landscape,
- 4:29communities, future generations, and increasingly it feels like
- 4:34we're now protecting democracy itself. Going through the
- 4:38planning and public inquiry process has left many of us
- 4:41feeling being allowed to speak is not the same thing as being
- 4:45heard. At the core, this struggle is about dignity. It's
- 4:49about recognising that community lives matter, that people who
- 4:53live in a place have the right to shape its future, and that
- 4:56decisions about our lives shouldn't simply be a. Imposed
- 5:00on us in the name of economics or progress. We'll see you all
- 5:05next week.