Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Conservatorship 101: Navigating the System for Older Adults and People with Special Needs
Transcript
- 0:02I am Rosita Yacoby, Assistant Program Co -Chair
- 0:07of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's Trust
- 0:10and Estate Law Section. The Trust and Estate
- 0:13Section is sponsored by Bond Services of California,
- 0:18Liberty Mutual Surety, California Tidal Company,
- 0:23Pickford Escrow Company and the Sanborn Team.
- 0:27I'm delighted to introduce our speaker, Cynthia
- 0:31Cox. Cynthia Cox is the founder of the Cox Law
- 0:34Group. Cynthia advises clients on conservatorship,
- 0:40public benefit programs such as SSI and MediCal,
- 0:44and planning for elderly individuals and those
- 0:47with special needs. She also frequently consults
- 0:51with older with other elder law attorneys on
- 0:55special needs and disability matters. Cynthia
- 0:59is a certified elder law attorney through the
- 1:02National Elder Law Foundation and a professor
- 1:05of elder law at Loyola Law School. She's a member
- 1:09of the Council of Advanced Practitioners through
- 1:12the National Academy of Elder Law Attorneys,
- 1:16one of only 10 such members in California. And
- 1:21now let's get started. Thank you, everyone. And
- 1:28thank you so much for joining our webinar today.
- 1:31I'm really excited to be here to talk to you
- 1:34about California conservatorship. It's one of
- 1:37my favorite areas of practice. It's kind of a
- 1:41love -hate relationship, as I'm sure all of you
- 1:44are aware who are also acting in these spaces
- 1:48and representing people on perhaps both sides
- 1:53of the conservatorship. The developments in conservatorship
- 1:57are very exciting. They're ever changing. And
- 2:01we're going to talk in just a moment about how
- 2:04conservatorships are generally becoming more
- 2:07and more disfavored. But there's been some backlash
- 2:13to this as well. So just being aware of this
- 2:16can make this a very interesting area of practice.
- 2:21For example, there is some legislation that's
- 2:24pending right now called the Veterans Care Protection
- 2:28Act, which is a draft bill that allows the VA
- 2:30to put veterans under conservatorship. So, NALA
- 2:34has joined with, NALA is the National Academy
- 2:37of Elder Law Attorneys, excuse me, has joined
- 2:40with the Consortium for Constituents with Disabilities.
- 2:44I'm just giving everybody a background thing
- 2:47here. to authorize the U .S. Department of Veterans
- 2:51Affairs to initiate a conservatorship or guardianship
- 2:55proceeding in state court for certain veterans
- 3:00whom the VA determines need a guardianship because
- 3:06they need placement or they can't manage their
- 3:09own benefits, and it will control where the veteran
- 3:12lives, control of their finances, and fundamental
- 3:15civil rights and gives the VA standing in state
- 3:20court. So this is really a major piece of legislation
- 3:25and a very concerning piece of legislation with
- 3:29laws of civil rights. using basically a placement
- 3:34tool for involuntary institutionalization. And
- 3:39as usual, it fails to address the root causes
- 3:42that were the reasons we're having these problems,
- 3:45such as lack of supportive housing, insufficient
- 3:48mental health services. And obviously, these
- 3:53systems where you can do conservatorship more
- 3:58easily obviously is going to conflict with our
- 4:01less restrictive alternatives. So with that long
- 4:07introduction we'll look at the agenda items and
- 4:10what we're going to look at today. So we'll go
- 4:13through an overview of conservatorship mostly
- 4:17from the standpoint of these policy decisions
- 4:20rather than rather than the legalities of how
- 4:24you establish a conservatorship. So we're going
- 4:28to be looking more philosophically at the impact
- 4:31of ageism and ableism on conservatorship decisions.
- 4:35We'll explain a little bit about that. We'll
- 4:38talk about the statutory and judicial requirements
- 4:42for conservatorship as well as some oversight
- 4:46misuses and practical challenges once you're
- 4:49in that conservatorship space. We're going to
- 4:52talk quite a bit about supported decision making
- 4:55as an alternative to conservatorship. and a little
- 5:00bit more about that supporter and what their
- 5:02eligibility is when they are supporting an adult
- 5:06making decisions, what their duties are, and
- 5:09what is required in an SDM, which is the supported
- 5:14decision making agreement. We're going to look
- 5:17at some practical considerations and other alternatives
- 5:20to conservatorship. including supported decision
- 5:23-making and other alternatives. And we're going
- 5:26to talk quite a bit about family dynamics, conflicts,
- 5:30and core considerations. Because if we really
- 5:33want to minimize or get rid of how many conservatorship
- 5:42cases we have, we have to look at what's really
- 5:47bringing those cases into the court system so
- 5:51that we can fashion some practicalities. So next
- 5:54slide. Okay, so overview of conservatorship.
- 6:03Go ahead. So when you're understanding conservatorship,
- 6:11you're... probably well aware that it is a court
- 6:15appointed arrangement for managing the affairs
- 6:17of an adult needing protection. In some jurisdictions
- 6:21throughout the country, they're more general.
- 6:26all -inclusive sort of arrangements. But in California,
- 6:31we're very specific as to our arrangements and
- 6:34we're very specific as to the orders that come
- 6:37out of those arrangements. They can be extremely
- 6:40tailored arrangements. We have a growing amount
- 6:44of scrutiny nationally and also in California
- 6:49and quite a bit of criticism, concerns over civil
- 6:53rights, due process violations in conservatorships.
- 6:57And there's been a lot of advocacy groups pushing
- 7:00for less restrictive alternatives that preserve
- 7:03more autonomy and protect folks that have disabilities
- 7:09as also agitness. Next slide. So the ACLU has
- 7:18been extremely involved in this process. And
- 7:21if you read some of the ACLU's information about
- 7:25conservatorships, it is very far to the point
- 7:32of not wanting conservatorships to be an available
- 7:37alternative whatsoever. What they're touting
- 7:43as part of the problem is that we have an overuse
- 7:47of conservatorships, that conservatorships are
- 7:50kind of a go -to familiar place, but it's often
- 7:54imposed without exploring less restrictive alternatives
- 7:57first. And again, this is a nationwide sort of
- 8:01problem. It does violate self -determination
- 8:05because it can infringe on an individual's rights
- 8:08to make decisions for themselves. And it conflicts
- 8:11with the rules under the American Disabilities
- 8:15Act. It unnecessarily segregates and restricts
- 8:19people. And many conservatorships really lack
- 8:24clear procedures for restoring those rights.
- 8:28and ensuring some fairness. And we're going to
- 8:31talk a little bit about the Britney Spears case
- 8:35because it was so pivotal in California and now
- 8:39it's really having a national implication and
- 8:42people are looking at how that conservatorship
- 8:45played out and some of those allegations there
- 8:47to see why did California pivot its laws and
- 8:53what other people nationwide can start to be
- 8:58thinking about towards making sure that people's
- 9:01civil rights are not infringed upon. So next.
- 9:11So California coming out of Britney Spears and
- 9:16other high profile cases. had a dramatic shift
- 9:26towards autonomy. So we had a conservatorship
- 9:29reform law that came out of that, which was a
- 9:32law that mandated courts to really explore these
- 9:35more least restrictive alternatives. So there's
- 9:39always a balance between autonomy and protection.
- 9:43Persons with capacity are allowed to self neglect.
- 9:47So short of self harm, adults are presumed to
- 9:51have capacity. And so if you think about some
- 9:55of these cases that people may have brought you
- 9:57over the years, my child has a substance abuse
- 10:02problem, and I need them conserved immediately.
- 10:05Or my husband has a gambling problem, and he
- 10:08needs to be conserved immediately. But adults
- 10:11that have capacity have a right to make bad,
- 10:15unsafe, and irrational decisions just like all
- 10:19of us. And indebtedness, that's another one where
- 10:23people can become quite indebted. That's not
- 10:27an indicia of incapacity, just very bad judgment.
- 10:31It can be an indicia of incapacity coupled with
- 10:35other things, but the court in general cannot
- 10:38substitute its judgment simply because the decision
- 10:41appears to be harmful or unwise. Incapacity is
- 10:47often very hard to prove. It's an expensive proposition
- 10:50for families attempting to bring protection to
- 10:54their loved one. And as some of you may have
- 10:57experienced, alleging and proving undue influence
- 11:01can be even worse. And there is really a lack
- 11:06of understanding in general about the differences
- 11:11between capacity and undue influence and how
- 11:15one can actually have capacity and still be subject
- 11:20to undue influence and still be under those things.
- 11:24So what would be a viable shift? Supported decision
- 11:29making is a legally recognized standard. And
- 11:33for the first time in California, it's supporting
- 11:36greater autonomy as an alternative to conservatorship.
- 11:41So Disability rights advocacy and high profile
- 11:45conservatorship cases have really raised awareness
- 11:48and have influenced a lot of legislative change
- 11:52in these areas. Next slide. We're going to think
- 12:03about some philosophical discussions about ageism
- 12:07and ableism on conservatorship decisions, this
- 12:11in and of itself would be an hour -long presentation.
- 12:15So we're going to just touch on some of this
- 12:17just so that people are aware of some of these
- 12:21biases. Next slide. So ageism has a lot of effect
- 12:36on legal outcomes for older adults. There's a
- 12:40bias certainly in our society that old people
- 12:44are unable to manage their affairs. And what
- 12:47do we even mean by old people, right? That's
- 12:51very interesting. Aging is linked in our culture
- 12:56to decline and failure rather than perhaps wisdom
- 13:01and reverence, as you see in some other cultures.
- 13:06When I adopted my daughter from China, for example,
- 13:11and I went to mainland China, was there for three
- 13:14weeks, the person that I was with had gray hair.
- 13:21And so without exception, everyone who was younger
- 13:27than that and didn't have gray hair, was bowing
- 13:30and very reverential to the person that was with
- 13:34me that had gray hair. And it just showed that
- 13:39there was certainly a cultural difference in
- 13:41how people look at aged people. I've noticed
- 13:46also in my practice that sometimes people with
- 13:51geriatric diagnoses such as dementia are sometimes
- 13:56placed in psychiatric situations. due to ignorance
- 14:01related to a dementia diagnosis. So there are
- 14:05over 100 causes of dementia, some of which are
- 14:09medical and temporary and driven by adverse reactions
- 14:13to medications and so on. So it may also be helpful
- 14:17to think of senility or dementia or some of those
- 14:21more old fashioned words as more like a spectrum
- 14:24disorder. And I think that it's best for us all
- 14:29to focus on what a person can do, again focusing
- 14:34on personhood, competently rather than the negative
- 14:38of what cannot be performed. So when we're trying
- 14:41to preserve these functionalities, a decline
- 14:45is going to be potentially accelerated by saying,
- 14:49taking away too many things too quickly. I find
- 14:54this often with the children of senior parents
- 14:57when they'll come in and they'll say, oh, mom,
- 15:01give that to me. I can do that much faster. It's
- 15:05important to let mom try to work the phone, try
- 15:09to use the phone, even though it may be exasperating
- 15:13and you may be in quite a big hurry. it's better
- 15:17for the person to continue to use their brain,
- 15:21continue to learn new things and increase that
- 15:25functionality. The more you take away, the more
- 15:29someone sits sedentary or in front of the television,
- 15:33the more decline you're going to see. And I see
- 15:37that with my own mother who had a stroke recently.
- 15:41And if she sits in front of the television a
- 15:44little too much, her short -term memory just
- 15:47goes to pieces. Whereas if my brother's over
- 15:51there engaging her, they're going out to eat,
- 15:55they're going on walks, she can track things
- 15:58much more readily. And you can't even hardly
- 16:01tell that she has a memory impairment. So just
- 16:05thinking through those things and how you would
- 16:07like to age as well, I think is very important.
- 16:11Judges and attorneys often assume that older
- 16:13age means incapacity as a matter of course, even
- 16:18when supported management is possible. So I've
- 16:23seen people 97 who are sharper than I am, 100
- 16:26years old who are sharper than I am. So we can't
- 16:31make those assumptions without being exceedingly
- 16:35unfair. to the person that you're making those
- 16:38assumptions about. And the court will frequently
- 16:41impose total conservatorships unnecessarily just
- 16:45because someone is aged. And when you combine
- 16:49that bias with ageism, combine it with racism,
- 16:56sexism, or ableism, then it's going to further
- 17:00marginalize older adults and limit their support
- 17:04access. Next slide. Ableism likewise is a presumption
- 17:23of incapacity against someone who has a disability.
- 17:30and this we see quite often when I'm representing
- 17:36someone in a special needs trust and a sort of
- 17:41situation and a personal injury attorney will
- 17:44call for example and say I have someone who's
- 17:47on SSI and Medi -Cal and we have to have a special
- 17:50needs trust and we need a conservatorship so
- 17:54that we can get the funding properly done and
- 17:58I start to really dig into the situation and
- 18:01realize that the person has complete capacity.
- 18:05But because they were physically limited, everyone
- 18:09in the situation presumed that that person was
- 18:13intellectually limited. So again, we are required
- 18:18to presume capacity under our probate code. Some
- 18:24benefits have presumptive disability attached
- 18:28to them, like there's social security disability
- 18:34that will apply to someone. And just realizing
- 18:39that just because someone has been judged disabled
- 18:43by social security, that only means that that
- 18:46person cannot sustain substantial gainful activity.
- 18:50That person can't be employed on a I mean, on
- 18:54enough of a full -time basis. And so that person
- 18:57is presumptively disabled. It has nothing to
- 19:00do with cognitive ability, though. So we have
- 19:05to try to not put on these labels, avoid these
- 19:10stereotypes, and just bear in mind that those
- 19:16things may be happening. Next slide. Again, for
- 19:25older adults, it's going to be easier to apply
- 19:29restrictive conservatorships, which are familiar
- 19:31to the courts, rather than exploring new alternatives
- 19:35like supported decision making. I see supported
- 19:39decision making rarely applied with older adults
- 19:43with some sort of cognitive decline. And I think
- 19:47that that is an area where we can really start
- 19:50to look at how do we apply supported decision
- 19:53making in the aged environment. Because most
- 19:58of the time, it's in the environment where someone
- 20:02has a disability, usually a developmental disability.
- 20:11If you are really looking at what a person can
- 20:14do and what a person is having concerns doing,
- 20:19then perhaps that person in those areas of concerns
- 20:23can enlist a supporter and can fill in the gaps
- 20:27such that a conservatorship may not be necessary.
- 20:32Next slide. Now we're going to talk a little
- 20:39bit about statutory and judicial requirements
- 20:42for conservatorship. Next slide. So again, we
- 20:52need to think about California law mandating
- 20:55the least restrictive alternatives. Again, California
- 21:01law discourages conservatorships unless there's
- 21:06no less restrictive alternative that can meet
- 21:09the person's needs. So the statutory requirements
- 21:13under probate code 1800 .3 mandates that the
- 21:17court consider all less restrictive alternatives
- 21:20before imposing a conservatorship. And it states
- 21:25that a conservatorship should only be imposed
- 21:28and provide care only when necessary. And so,
- 21:33The probate code really looks at a task -specific
- 21:36analysis. And that task -specific analysis has
- 21:42to look at what the person is able to do and
- 21:45what the person is not able to do. So often in
- 21:49my conservatorship practice, we'll have a situation
- 21:53where someone has been taken advantage of, for
- 21:59example. Right around Valentine's Day, there's
- 22:03a lot of romance scams, right? And so I don't
- 22:06know if you've had experience with people who've
- 22:08had romance scams, but it can be exceedingly
- 22:12convincing. And a person will send. a message
- 22:16to someone on an older adult dating app or whatever
- 22:21it might be. They send a picture of themselves,
- 22:25which is basically taken off the Internet and
- 22:28they say, Hey, I'm a veteran. That's always a
- 22:30good line. I'm a veteran and I saw your picture
- 22:35and you look amazing and I would just like to
- 22:39enter into conversation with you because I'm
- 22:41lonely. And then from there it grows and grows
- 22:44until the person is stuffing $100 bills into
- 22:48a teddy bear and sending them off to New York
- 22:50City or whatever the situation might be for that
- 22:55particular situation. So if you look at... at
- 23:01those kinds of things. And you say, well, perhaps
- 23:05a conservatorship is required over this area
- 23:08of finance. But the person can certainly continue
- 23:12to make all decisions related to housing and
- 23:17to ability to authorize medication. and perhaps
- 23:24manage their own checking account and have some
- 23:28autonomy there, or have a card that is monitored
- 23:34by the conservator that allows economic autonomy.
- 23:38And just to think about those things and have
- 23:41a balance. That's really, really important. Next
- 23:46slide. So again, looking at all of these trends,
- 23:55the courts are looking more and more for evidence
- 23:59of failed alternatives. So they want us to demonstrate
- 24:03efforts that decision making, supported decision
- 24:07making in particular has been tried and failed,
- 24:10sometimes tried multiple times and failed. And
- 24:14so there's proof that's needed that conservatorship
- 24:17is truly the least restrictive alternative and
- 24:20the least intrusive option. This shows respect
- 24:23for autonomy. It shows respect for the person's
- 24:26self -determination. It doesn't violate civil
- 24:29rights and so forth and so on. And what I've
- 24:34also noticed is that even when someone is under
- 24:38conservatorship, based on a lot of those legislative
- 24:43changes that were made coming out of the Britney
- 24:46Spears case and other cases, when someone is
- 24:49even under a conservatorship, that person's wishes
- 24:53are taken into account. So for example, if that
- 24:57person wants their conservatorship terminated,
- 25:00then they can petition for that to happen. That
- 25:04person is entitled to a right to their own counsel
- 25:09and to hire independent private counsel. We've
- 25:14seen cases where, for example, uh the conservator
- 25:18wished to remodel the conservatees residence
- 25:22and the conservatee wasn't living there anymore
- 25:26wasn't necessarily expected to return but the
- 25:30conservatee really wanted to weigh in on the
- 25:34design because if they did come back they maybe
- 25:37didn't want gray carpet in their living room
- 25:40right they And they didn't want it to be like
- 25:43a rental. They wanted it to be their home. So
- 25:48that conservatee was allowed a tremendous amount
- 25:54of autonomy weighing into the decision making.
- 25:58And I think we are definitely going much more
- 26:01towards this. All of this, by the way, you need
- 26:05to warn your folks that you're representing when
- 26:09you're trying to establish a conservatorship,
- 26:13results in a lot more expense. But it's expense
- 26:17at the because we want to respect autonomy, respect
- 26:25self -determination, and so forth. So we have
- 26:30decided as a state that that's a good trade -off.
- 26:37What if we have a situation though, and there's
- 26:41always a way of playing devil's advocate here,
- 26:44where there's an undue influencer or a suspected
- 26:48abuser? And the conservative, for example, wishes
- 26:51to change their estate plan to disinherit their
- 26:55family and benefit the suspected abuser or allow
- 26:58that person to help making decisions. It takes
- 27:03years for these cases to come to trial and to
- 27:06establish that the suspected abuser is really
- 27:09an abuser, right? And so, and that that influence
- 27:13that's being wielded is truly undue influence.
- 27:17So not all influence is created equal. There
- 27:21could be a good child or a good influencer who's
- 27:26telling the individual you really should be doing
- 27:30this because it benefits you, it protects you.
- 27:34That's not necessarily undue influence, right?
- 27:38So the documentation that you're going to need
- 27:43is showing that the conservatorship is the least
- 27:47restrictive alternative. conservatorship documents
- 27:51that you have to file are very good at fleshing
- 27:55that out. They're going to ask you, have you
- 27:58tried this? Have you tried that? And you have
- 28:01to honestly look at whether those things have
- 28:04been tried before you even get to filing the
- 28:08conservatorship. And even when a conservatorship
- 28:11is granted, again, the conservatorship is going
- 28:14to encourage preserving as many rights and as
- 28:17much autonomy for the conservatee as possible.
- 28:22Next slide. Recognizing that there's a loss of
- 28:31fundamental rights associated with conservatorship
- 28:33is very important. So conservatorship can remove
- 28:38the individual's right to make their own medical
- 28:40decisions, for heaven sakes, to impact their
- 28:43own personal autonomy in that way, which is a
- 28:47core constitutional right, may lose their right
- 28:51to decide where to live, limiting personal freedom,
- 28:55may restrict the ability to manage personal finances,
- 28:58affecting financial independence, may also even
- 29:03limit the right to marry or contract or vote.
- 29:06restricting basic civil liberties. It can result
- 29:11in someone being put in a locked facility if
- 29:14there's a diagnosis of dementia, for example.
- 29:19So that can be very alarming and should be alarming.
- 29:25Next slide. So what is happening also related
- 29:35to challenges in the conservatorship arena, talking
- 29:39about oversight and misuse and practical challenges.
- 29:43Next slide. Conservatorships once established
- 29:56can result in a variety of ills. So there can
- 30:01be a misuse of authority that can prolong a conservatorship.
- 30:06This was alleged in the Britney Spears case,
- 30:09self -enrichment, and then due to court overload,
- 30:14lack of oversight sometimes. We all know that
- 30:18our Los Angeles court system is dramatically
- 30:21overburdened at the moment. coupled with the
- 30:27fact that conservators themselves might be quite
- 30:30inexperienced, such as a family member that's
- 30:33trying to act for the first time and doesn't
- 30:36understand complexed accountings and so forth.
- 30:42Or if it's a professional fiduciary, sometimes
- 30:44our professional fiduciaries are extremely overloaded
- 30:48and may not have their own business system where
- 30:54oversight and management is in place properly
- 30:59to be able to self monitor. Next slide. As we
- 31:09said, the courts are very overburnt right now.
- 31:13Court investigators face an extremely heavy workload,
- 31:17causing a lot of delays in the required reviews.
- 31:21And the investigators are now required to really
- 31:26look into possible alternatives and what the
- 31:30conservatee wishes and so on. Again, the accountings
- 31:35are often incomplete and difficult for families
- 31:39to understand and difficult if there's a family
- 31:43member who's trying to challenge an accounting
- 31:46effectively. It can be difficult to understand
- 31:50the numbers in the way that the numbers are presented.
- 31:56And these other items we already discussed. Next
- 32:00slide. So let's talk a little bit about supported
- 32:07decision making since it's the new kid on the
- 32:10block. Next slide. So, supported decision -making
- 32:17allows the adult to make a decision with support.
- 32:21It's recognized in California law and it validates
- 32:24the individual and an individual's ability to
- 32:27make choices. Courts must now consider it as
- 32:30an alternative to conservatorship and it enables
- 32:34a person to retain their legal rights and self
- 32:37-determination, unlike conservatorships. So,
- 32:42the idea of supported decision -making is that
- 32:46you are going to be providing assistance if you
- 32:49are a decision supporter instead of substituting
- 32:55your own decision making. So the terminology
- 33:00they use is adult. So the adult is the person
- 33:05who's seeking support and the supporter is the
- 33:11person who's supporting that decision making.
- 33:14The adult is always making the decisions himself
- 33:20or herself themself, right? So it promotes individual
- 33:25empowerment in that way. When there have been
- 33:29concerns raised about whether you are acting
- 33:32as a fiduciary under the supported decision -making
- 33:37process, the answer has seemingly been resoundingly
- 33:43no if you're a supporter because you're not making
- 33:46the decision. You are simply lining out options,
- 33:52lining out alternatives, gathering facts, discussing,
- 33:56and so forth. So supported decision -making aligns
- 34:01with the ADA and its mandates, and it supports
- 34:06integration and individual rights. And courts,
- 34:10again, are going to consider these alternatives.
- 34:15And court -appointed counsel must look into this
- 34:18also. All of the counsel must discuss these options.
- 34:23When someone comes into you seeking a conservatorship,
- 34:27this is the first thing that you should be exploring
- 34:30is whether this would be a possibility. Next
- 34:35slide. So as you can see, there have been a number
- 34:44of reforms that came primarily out of the Britney
- 34:46Spears case with ABA Assembly Bill 1663 being
- 34:52the supported decision making bill. Next slide.
- 35:04So defining supported decision making. What is
- 35:09happening under this is the person is making
- 35:12an independent decision, but with support. So
- 35:17it sounds a little bit like an oxymoron, I know,
- 35:19but the scope of the decision is up to the adult.
- 35:23And it can include medical, financial, housing,
- 35:27education, social, religious, or legal matters.
- 35:34The ADA actually has some really helpful templates
- 35:39that have a very simple kind of questionnaire.
- 35:45And the questionnaire says, medical decisions.
- 35:49I can make these decisions myself. I can make
- 35:52these decisions with support. And I need help
- 35:56making these decisions all the time. And I don't
- 35:59feel I can make this decision. So a person can
- 36:02actually choose how they feel about what they
- 36:06can do on that spectrum. And the same for financial
- 36:11and housing and education. Once that is complete,
- 36:15then one can sit down with the supporter and
- 36:20come to an agreement. And I've been party to
- 36:25a number of these supported decision -making
- 36:28agreements where each person is represented by
- 36:31separate counsel and an agreement is actually
- 36:35drafted and executed. It's completely voluntary.
- 36:40It does not and it cannot imply incapacity. And
- 36:45the adult retains full legal decision -making
- 36:47authority. Next slide. So of course we have some
- 36:58concerns about these supporters. Who are these
- 37:02supporters and can this person be a bad actor?
- 37:07Next slide. So as you can see, the eligibility
- 37:14of the supporter, they must be chosen by the
- 37:18adult and they must comply with disability protection
- 37:22laws. And so there's a number of things that
- 37:25can disqualify a supporter. A supporter can be
- 37:29disqualified if they're under a restraining order,
- 37:33liable for any sort of abuse, if they've been
- 37:37removed as a conservator, or if there's allegations
- 37:40of elder or dependent adult abuse. Supporters
- 37:55must respect the adults values. So what does
- 37:59that mean? Oh, once in a while you'll have someone
- 38:03that comes along that has an extremely strong
- 38:07personality and really would just like to run
- 38:12the show right over the adults head, right? And
- 38:17so that's possibly not the best supporter because
- 38:21if you have someone who is supporting, they have
- 38:25to be in a beta role instead of an alpha role.
- 38:30They have to respect that person's values. They
- 38:33have to maintain confidentiality, act honestly
- 38:36and diligently in good faith, and so on. And
- 38:43they cannot make decisions, sign documents, or
- 38:47substitute their judgment unless that person
- 38:51is legally authorized to do so. Next slide. So
- 39:01what is required in an agreement? A supported
- 39:04decision -making agreement has some required
- 39:07components under the law. And so the required
- 39:11components are that the supported decision -making
- 39:14agreement must be in very plain language. It
- 39:18must list all of the support areas that the person
- 39:22desires. It must have a certain amount of disclosures
- 39:27and signature of the adult and the supporters.
- 39:33It has to be before two disinterested witnesses.
- 39:37or a notary to be valid and the agreement can
- 39:40be terminated by the adult or the supporter at
- 39:45any time upon death or by destroying the agreement.
- 39:50And if you want to know where this law is located,
- 39:55I did do an appendix that has all of assembly
- 40:00bill 1663, all of the changed California codes,
- 40:05which codes were changed, and the summary of
- 40:07the impact. I'm sure that will be helpful if
- 40:10you're looking for that. Next slide. So let's
- 40:19look at some practical considerations and a few
- 40:25more alternatives to conservatorships. Next slide.
- 40:39So practical takeaways and challenges under supported
- 40:43decision making. Again, the fact that it's legally
- 40:48recognized and supports capacity without delegating
- 40:52authority. is a very good thing for the person
- 40:58who is the adult. However, it can have some real
- 41:03practical challenges because third parties can't
- 41:07ignore these agreements entirely. So you can
- 41:10imagine if you take this supported decision -making
- 41:14agreement to a bank and say, I'm trying to get
- 41:18some information to help my sister make some
- 41:21decisions. Can you please provide me with her
- 41:24banking information? Absent power of attorney
- 41:29or a conservatorship or something else that the
- 41:33bank understands and is going to recognize, you're
- 41:36probably not going to get very far. Further,
- 41:40if you have to make a very quick decision, This
- 41:44is a slow process because what you're required
- 41:46to do under supported decision making is to lay
- 41:49out all of the information and all of the options
- 41:53for a person to be able to make a decision. And
- 41:57so that in and of itself is going to slow down
- 42:00the decision making process. And sometimes a
- 42:05decision has to be made very quickly to avoid
- 42:07financial loss and some other things. So that's
- 42:10a consideration. there might be a potential conflict
- 42:14of interest. So if you've named a supporter,
- 42:16for example, who's also the downstream beneficiary
- 42:20of your estate, they may not be in favor of you
- 42:24spending money for these various purposes and
- 42:27may try to influence you to do something different.
- 42:32So conflicts of interest are to be avoided, but
- 42:35a lot of the time the supporters by definition
- 42:39already have a conflict of interest. The attorney
- 42:43role in ethics is very interesting in this space
- 42:46because the attorneys have to balance attorney
- 42:50-client privilege and vet supporters and also
- 42:55include the chosen team in the decision -making
- 42:58process. This is part of the law if you look
- 43:01at it. So it says unless the attorney believes
- 43:06that this person is a suspected abuser or otherwise
- 43:09disqualified, you have to figure out how we're
- 43:11going to vet that particular thing, then the
- 43:15attorney must, and it's mandatory, include the
- 43:19chosen team in the meetings and in the discussions.
- 43:22So thinking about how that's going to impact
- 43:25attorney -client privilege, how we're supposed
- 43:28to vet supporters, and who we're going to include,
- 43:33if they're wielding too much influence. Do we
- 43:37have the power to ask the adult to exclude that
- 43:41supporter? There's all kinds of implications
- 43:44that can come up in these spaces. Supported decision
- 43:49making does work well though for intellectual
- 43:53developmental disability communities as a less
- 43:56restrictive alternative. Been really great in
- 43:59that space. Next. Slide. As we're running kind
- 44:05of short on time, I'm just going to go over this
- 44:08quickly because I'm sure that you're aware that
- 44:12if you have estate planning in place, that can
- 44:14be a less restrictive alternative. So why do
- 44:18you need to have the court manage finances if
- 44:21you have a trust and you have powers of attorney
- 44:24and you have health care directives in place?
- 44:26Why do you need the court to help with medical
- 44:29issues? Or we can use special tools like special
- 44:33needs trusts or CalABLE accounts to provide financial
- 44:37management, benefits protection, and things like
- 44:40that. Next slide. In the space of conservatorship,
- 44:48you're always going to be looking at balancing
- 44:52autonomy and safety. Autonomy and safety requires
- 44:58choosing options that empower adults to live
- 45:00as independently as possible, yet we're trying
- 45:03to get some level of security. You're not going
- 45:06to have a perfect world. No one has a perfect
- 45:09world where they're completely safe no matter
- 45:13what. But the goal is to minimize the harm as
- 45:16much as possible while maximizing independence
- 45:19and personal empowerment as much as possible.
- 45:22And the advocacy principle that comes out of
- 45:27persons with disabilities, nothing about me without
- 45:32me. What that means is these secret conversations
- 45:37where people are going off to the side and saying,
- 45:40hey, I really need to tell you some things about
- 45:42my brother. He really needs help in these areas,
- 45:46but I don't really want you to tell him that.
- 45:51brought that up, those kinds of things, really
- 45:55are not respectful of the individual and their
- 46:01ability to actively participate in decisions
- 46:03that really are core to their own lives and affect
- 46:07their own lives and their own care and their
- 46:09own autonomy. So just bearing that in mind, nothing
- 46:14about me without me. Next slide. dynamics, conflicts,
- 46:23and court considerations. We're going to talk
- 46:25a little bit about why we end up in conservatorship
- 46:28anyway. Next slide. So when are conservatorships
- 46:36really necessary? So I have to say that I disagree
- 46:40with the theory that conservatorships are never
- 46:43necessary, and there has to be something better
- 46:46that we can do, and all conservatorships should
- 46:50be taken off the books and defeated. When someone
- 46:53is truly unable to meet their needs or make safe
- 46:57decisions, then It seems to me that a conservatorship
- 47:02just has to be necessary. We have to try and
- 47:05preserve rights, preserve assets so that that
- 47:08person can be taken care of. And when someone
- 47:13is really being abused, if someone is in the
- 47:20midst of having elder abuse leveled against them,
- 47:24physical or financial, or Undue influence is
- 47:28being wielded where there's rapid asset loss
- 47:32and financial exploitation by individuals that
- 47:36that person trusts. A conservatorship may be
- 47:39one's only option. Often, family conflicts trigger
- 47:45conservatorships more often than not. And this
- 47:49is an area where perhaps there can be some discussion
- 47:54about some real viable alternatives. So disagreements
- 47:59about how a relative is caring for an elderly
- 48:04person or a person with disability can escalate
- 48:08conservatorships to resolve disputes usually
- 48:11over control or over isolation. Lack of transparency
- 48:18makes people worried about what's really going
- 48:21on in the home and so forth and so on. So that
- 48:26really does become a very frequent trigger as
- 48:31well as fostering a lot of litigation around
- 48:35the conservatee and can be extremely harmful.
- 48:41Sometimes it gets to the level where the family
- 48:45conflict is going to really start harming the
- 48:49elder and a neutral professional conservator
- 48:53is often appointed to provide unbiased care and
- 48:57management. Next slide. So the court is really
- 49:03going to look at this and if someone is applying
- 49:08to be a conservator in one of these situations
- 49:12where there's a lot of family conflict, they're
- 49:15going to prioritize individuals who can cooperate
- 49:18with relatives and share information, de -escalate
- 49:22family conflicts effectively over folks who are
- 49:25continuing isolation, who are saying, my brother
- 49:29doesn't have any right to that information. I'm
- 49:32not going to give it to him because he's just
- 49:33going to fight with me or whatever the situation
- 49:36might be. So we're going to always be looking
- 49:40to preference to those people who have been in
- 49:45a position of providing care for some time and
- 49:49are the closest, most supportive relationships
- 49:52rather than people who come in and are talking
- 49:56mostly about finances, less about the focus on
- 50:01the person whom we're trying to help. So they'll
- 50:06also look at who's been managing the finances
- 50:09responsibly and also looking at people who are
- 50:12not managing finances responsibly. And that person
- 50:16is probably not going to be appointable. They're
- 50:20also looking at neutrality and the lack of self
- 50:23-interest as key traits to avoid conflicts of
- 50:28interest in conservatorship appointments. Next
- 50:31slide. So here are some of the warning signs
- 50:41that you'll see if it's a conflict -driven conservatorship
- 50:46petition. You'll see disputes over spending,
- 50:50someone who dislikes the person acting as a caregiver
- 50:54or dislikes the caregiver that that person has
- 50:58had in place. Sibling accusations back and forth
- 51:04will sometimes indicate this. And sometimes people
- 51:10are not talking a lot about incapacity. They're
- 51:13mostly talking about my brother did this, my
- 51:16sister did that, my sister's always done this,
- 51:18my brother's always done that, or whatever the
- 51:21situation might be, which shows that this is
- 51:25not really so much about mom and dad or about
- 51:29the person with a disability. This is vying for
- 51:34control and those sorts of things. Isolation
- 51:37tactics, you'll often see in these sorts of things
- 51:40too. Blocking visits, controlling visits inordinately.
- 51:45You have to give me a week's notice if you're
- 51:48going to come over and visit. Controlling communications
- 51:52that isolate the elder. And it can be very insidious.
- 51:58You can isolate an elder or a person with disabilities
- 52:02simply by taking their glasses and putting them
- 52:06just out of reach and saying, oh, you don't need
- 52:08those, dad. Let me read this for you, or whatever
- 52:11the situation might be. So just watching for
- 52:15those things. Petitioners may also seek a conservatorship
- 52:20to control the inheritance or property. there
- 52:26isn't a good alternative or if they don't like
- 52:29the way that a sibling is controlling the property
- 52:33or so on. And elders who are going to object
- 52:39to this or function well with support are going
- 52:44to have to suggest very strongly through council
- 52:47and otherwise that a conservatorship in these
- 52:50sorts of situations is simply unnecessary. Next
- 52:55slide. Okay, so again, we've summarized the changes
- 53:05to AB 1663 in the table that's attached to your
- 53:10outline. It talks a lot about less restrictive
- 53:15alternatives, about new documents that are necessary.
- 53:20preferring conservative choices and allowing
- 53:23easier termination and review. A big component
- 53:27is the recognition of supported decision making.
- 53:31And regional centers were restricted from serving
- 53:36as conservators under the new legislation. There
- 53:39was a number of new rules that came into play
- 53:44for professional fiduciaries as well. Next slide.
- 53:51So again, in conclusion, we looked at the complexities
- 53:56of conservatorship, which involve a lot of challenges
- 54:00related to civil rights concerns, ageism, ableism,
- 54:04impacting decision -making and autonomy. We looked
- 54:07at supported decision -making and it offers a
- 54:11promising alternative. that enhances individual
- 54:14autonomy in conservatorship frameworks. I want
- 54:18you to take it a step further, though, and say,
- 54:20even if supportive decision making is not appropriate,
- 54:24let's really look at our conservatorship orders
- 54:27that are coming out of this and tailoring it
- 54:30so that the individual that is going to be continuing
- 54:36to operate under this conservatorship as the
- 54:39conservatee has as much ability as they can possibly
- 54:44handle on their own to avoid degradation. And
- 54:50then we're always looking at balancing safety
- 54:53versus freedom. So if we can get effective family
- 54:58involvement, some practical tools to help balance
- 55:02that safety with personal freedom and decision
- 55:05making, then possibly will come a lot closer
- 55:09to really cutting down on the conservatorships
- 55:13that are having to be filed in our court systems
- 55:16that are already overburdened. Next slide. OK,
- 55:24thank you very much for your attention. I'll
- 55:26give a shout out to Rena Shaw, my associate,
- 55:29who also helped me with these materials. Thank
- 55:33you very much, Rena. And we have a question and
- 55:35answer place that you can post questions. And
- 55:42let me see. The first one says, has anyone succeeded
- 55:48in moving an individual within a limited conservatorship?
- 55:52developed a DD to a self -decision mode, essentially
- 55:59less court oversight. No, I have not moved someone,
- 56:06but I have not tried. And I do think that it
- 56:11would be absolutely a possibility. So I think
- 56:17what I would do in order to try and get that
- 56:19done is to Try the self -decision mode in tandem
- 56:25with the conservatorship. And if you do a trial
- 56:30run, seems to be working well, then petition
- 56:33to terminate the conservatorship and see what
- 56:36happens. Can you explain how mental health decisions
- 56:41are treated when someone is conserved? That is
- 56:45an interesting question. Mental health decisions
- 56:50are under a complete different type of conservatorship
- 56:54in California. It's known as an LPS conservatorship.
- 56:59A normal, regular old everyday attorney cannot
- 57:02start an LPS conservatorship. It has to be started
- 57:06through, in general, through a psychiatrist on
- 57:11some type of referral. So usually a 5150 hold
- 57:17or something like that. And then one goes into
- 57:21an LPS situation. So that LPS situation then
- 57:27can become a 14 -day hold into. from 72 hours
- 57:33into a 14 -day hold and then referred for conservatorship.
- 57:38Public guardian is usually appointed and then
- 57:40a family member can step in. If someone has mental
- 57:45health decisions that don't rise to the level
- 57:48of gravely disabled, sometimes it can be dovetailed
- 57:53into a general conservatorship, but you always
- 57:57have this situation of You might end up in a
- 58:005150, and you might end up with both conservatorships
- 58:04happening at the same time. LPS conservatorship
- 58:07is considered to be quasi -criminal. It only
- 58:11lasts for a year. The person has a... And then
- 58:15it... can potentially be renewed. The person
- 58:18has a public defender that's in defending, and
- 58:21it's a completely separate courthouse. So it's
- 58:25a very separate system, and we have some wonderful
- 58:29mental health attorneys who operate exclusively
- 58:34in that space, and some that operate in both
- 58:37spaces. So that would certainly be where I would
- 58:40go there. Care court as an alternative to conservatorship.
- 58:47Care court is a very interesting alternative.
- 58:51It's basically a voluntary alternative. It's
- 58:54narrowly drawn and it's for folks who have substance
- 58:59abuse issues. And so that person can voluntarily
- 59:03go and say, I'm going to get treatment. I'm going
- 59:08to have this structure and this sort of check
- 59:14-in system as an alternative to conservatorship.
- 59:17100 % voluntary. Again, it's kind of outside
- 59:22the scope. But John, if you want to talk more,
- 59:26I have tons of materials on care court. I find
- 59:29it to be very, very fascinating. There are some
- 59:32people who are very concerned that people might
- 59:36not be understanding that there are civil rights
- 59:38limitations related to that. But it is very interesting.
- 59:47Where did it go? I lost it. If I take over a
- 59:55special needs trust already established, should
- 59:58I give notice to SSA and Medi -Cal, even though
- 1:00:02notice has already been given? The answer is
- 1:00:04yes. You should always give notice. And I'm assuming
- 1:00:08you're taking over as the attorney representing
- 1:00:12the same trustee. I don't know. I take that back.
- 1:00:18If you're just the attorney representing the
- 1:00:21trustee, then once the notice has been given,
- 1:00:26if a copy of the trust has already been given
- 1:00:31to that person, the SSA and Medi -Cal, then I
- 1:00:36wouldn't think it would be necessary again. If
- 1:00:39you're taking over as a new trustee, it's definitely
- 1:00:42going to be required. under 16 .061 normal noticing.
- 1:00:49If you're before the court, the notice will be
- 1:00:54required every time you do accountings and so
- 1:00:58forth and so on. What is my approach with dealing
- 1:01:01with GELs or CACs who are clearly wrong about
- 1:01:06certain items or just a problem in general? Wow,
- 1:01:11we have... We have some of this as well. You
- 1:01:16always want to treat people with civility and
- 1:01:18with respect because you never know whether they're
- 1:01:21going to be on the next case that you're involved
- 1:01:25with and try to treat people that have a divergent
- 1:01:32opinion as respectfully as possible. If you have
- 1:01:36a CAC that is that is adverse, that could be
- 1:01:42expected because they have to take the position
- 1:01:45of the conservatee, which might just be not in
- 1:01:52keeping with what you're trying to get. And you
- 1:01:55may want to go in and try to get a GAL appointed.
- 1:01:59If you have someone who's completely off the
- 1:02:02rails and attacking your person unnecessarily,
- 1:02:09I have had one time in 32 years where I sought
- 1:02:13to remove a CAC from the case, and that was successful,
- 1:02:18but that was really exceedingly unusual circumstances.
- 1:02:24What if a conservatee has mental issues and won't
- 1:02:27see a doctor? can't do LPS, how likely will you
- 1:02:32be successful in a probate conservatorship, any
- 1:02:35tips? This is one of the most difficult situations
- 1:02:39because if the court appointed counsel is also
- 1:02:45fighting your ability to get any sort of doctor's
- 1:02:50declaration, You might be able to get a temporary
- 1:02:54conservatorship in place because you don't necessarily
- 1:02:59need a capacity declaration in order to provide
- 1:03:02temporary support. However, the conservatee having
- 1:03:11mental issues won't see a doctor, that can also
- 1:03:16be indicia that a conservatorship is necessary.
- 1:03:21And I think there's some old case law on point
- 1:03:24there. Sooner or later, you're going to be looking
- 1:03:29for the court to hopefully put a 730 expert in
- 1:03:35to be able to do that assessment because the
- 1:03:37court will not be able to go forward without
- 1:03:40some sort of assessment. Sometimes you can talk
- 1:03:45the conservatee into doing it either through
- 1:03:49the guardian ad litem or through CAC simply because
- 1:03:53they think they have plenty of capacity. So all
- 1:03:57you have to say is please prove it. And sometimes
- 1:04:01you can get it done that way. But that is an
- 1:04:03extremely, extremely difficult situation. Individual
- 1:04:09with schizophrenia leaves a very crummy life.
- 1:04:12presents well in court, conservatorship denied.
- 1:04:18Oh, National Shattering Silence Coalition is
- 1:04:21screaming for legislative action and SB 403 failed
- 1:04:26to advance. All right, John, talk to me later
- 1:04:31because these mental health issues are really,
- 1:04:34really tough. And just because someone has schizophrenia
- 1:04:38does not mean that conservatorship is warranted.
- 1:04:44And sometimes it just breaks the heart of the
- 1:04:47people who are trying to protect that person.
- 1:04:51But protection may or may not be available because
- 1:04:55you may not really have gravely disabled. You
- 1:04:59may not have an incapacity and other things.
- 1:05:03Are long -term LPS conservatorships subject to
- 1:05:08the new least restrictive standard? It's a completely
- 1:05:13different system. I would assume that all conservatorship
- 1:05:17is subject to the least restrictive standard,
- 1:05:20but once you're already in that system where
- 1:05:23someone is in a 5150 hold, if that person is
- 1:05:29not simply released, which by the way, a lot
- 1:05:33of people are simply released and unless you
- 1:05:36go on an extreme letter writing campaign to the
- 1:05:40psychiatrist because you're not going to be able
- 1:05:43to talk to this person and the loved one is in
- 1:05:46lockdown, right? So unless you're able to really
- 1:05:50speak to that by tons of letter writing, your
- 1:05:55person may be gravely disabled and simply released
- 1:05:58by the psychiatrist happens all the time. And
- 1:06:02then they bounce back into the system and they're
- 1:06:04simply released again. So this is where you really
- 1:06:07need to talk to one of these mental health folks.
- 1:06:10And I will right now at least take the moment
- 1:06:14to say what my email is so that you want to if
- 1:06:18you want to reach out to me, I can give you a
- 1:06:21little more information about it. It's kind of
- 1:06:23a long email. It's Cynthia, spelled traditionally,
- 1:06:26C -Y -N -T -H -I -A, at CoxLawGroupInc .com,
- 1:06:33C -O -X -L -A -W -G -R -O -U -P -I -N -C .com.
- 1:06:41And she put it in the chat as well. Thank you
- 1:06:44so much, Susie. Okay, I am a fiduciary who's
- 1:06:49going to manage a trust from now on. You poor
- 1:06:52thing. That is the hardest job on earth. Bless
- 1:06:59you. That's crazy. Oh, thank you very much. Someone
- 1:07:04just said thank you. Who makes the decisions
- 1:07:07on behalf of a dependent adult whose parents
- 1:07:10have never sought a conservatorship? If the dependent
- 1:07:13adult remains residing with the parent, does
- 1:07:16the parent automatically assume rights? The answer
- 1:07:19is absolutely no. Once the child in this situation
- 1:07:26turns 18, they are presumed to have their own
- 1:07:30abilities. and their own decision -making authority.
- 1:07:35So what you will often see is people will start
- 1:07:40to look towards that 18 -year -old related to
- 1:07:44medical decisions, kicking parents out of discussions
- 1:07:49on health that they've always been in. Sometimes
- 1:07:53it happens, sometimes it doesn't. it's what the
- 1:07:56law requires, is that 18 -year -old has the ability
- 1:08:00to make decisions for themselves. So at that
- 1:08:03point in time, a lot of people in the developmental
- 1:08:05disability space either look to support decision
- 1:08:10-making and HIPAA waivers, powers of attorney
- 1:08:14for financial matters and health care, if that's
- 1:08:17appropriate, or they petition for conservatorship.
- 1:08:23So let's see, it says, Does the parent automatically
- 1:08:30assume, yeah. So that one had another nuance
- 1:08:36that basically said, should we seek conservatorship
- 1:08:39over the parents? And that is a. Do you have
- 1:08:49experience with contested conservatorships by
- 1:08:51Regional Center? Yes, I had one long trial with
- 1:08:55Regional Center one time. It was a lot of fun.
- 1:08:58You can definitely talk to me offline and I'll
- 1:09:05give you all of the rundown of how that went.
- 1:09:08I do have a good checklist for supported decision
- 1:09:12making agreement. It comes from several different
- 1:09:17sources. I know AHRQ has a lot of information
- 1:09:20on Supported Decision Making, ARC. NAYLA will
- 1:09:25have some information on that too. But John,
- 1:09:28if you want to reach out to me, I can do that.
- 1:09:34Yes, and I think we already answered this one
- 1:09:36on whether the least restrictive standard applies
- 1:09:40to LPS conservatorships. But again, it's not
- 1:09:43my area of expertise, so I would certainly reach
- 1:09:46out to me if you don't have a mental health sort
- 1:09:50of background and maybe we can get someone with
- 1:09:52more expertise to help. Okay, I think I have
- 1:09:57answered all of the questions. And I can't tell
- 1:10:00you how much I appreciate your attention this
- 1:10:03afternoon. I am available if you need anything
- 1:10:08further and thank you very much.