Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q3] JD.com Deep Value Investment or Political Trap?
Transcript
- 0:00So. Welcome to the Deep Dive.
- 0:03Today we are tackling a really complex 1A full financial
- 0:08journey into jd.com Inc. Yeah, we've got a whole stack of
- 0:11research here, and you know, the picture it paints is a classic
- 0:14study in paradox. And that's really the mission
- 0:17for us today, right? It's it to unpack why JD is a
- 0:20classic deep value investment? I mean, you look at the numbers,
- 0:23it's statistically inexpensive, it looks.
- 0:26Cheap, but that's where the story starts, not where it ends.
- 0:28Exactly that wonderful price is sitting right next to these huge
- 0:32non diversifiable risks. We're talking a low margin,
- 0:36capital heavy business model and of course all the geopolitical
- 0:40baggage that comes with China. So we're really looking at a
- 0:42company at a major inflection point.
- 0:44It's trying to pivot from that whole hyper growth at all costs
- 0:48mindset. Something much more disciplined.
- 0:50Sustainable profitability. That's the new mantra.
- 0:52OK, so let's unpack this structurally.
- 0:55What is jd.com? Well, it's really a hybrid
- 0:58model. You have to think of its revenue
- 0:59into two big streams. The main one is product
- 1:01revenues, what we call 1P or first party.
- 1:05That's JD acting like a traditional retailer.
- 1:07They buy inventory, they stick it in their warehouses, over
- 1:101600 of them, and they sell it directly to you.
- 1:13And that was what, 80% of their revenue in the 1st?
- 1:16Quarter a massive 80.2%. Yeah, it's the core of the
- 1:19business. And that one P model, that's
- 1:21where their competitive advantage comes from, isn't it?
- 1:23That whole integrated logistics network.
- 1:26Precisely. That's their Moat.
- 1:28Owing all that infrastructure is why they can make that promise
- 1:31of same day and next day delivery.
- 1:33It makes them the gold standard for quality and speed in Chinese
- 1:37e-commerce. But.
- 1:37There's a catch. A huge catch.
- 1:39It's a classic Catch 22. That infrastructure, all those
- 1:43warehouses and trucks, it's immensely capital intensive.
- 1:46So it cost billions to build and cost a ton to maintain.
- 1:49Right. And historically that is just
- 1:51crush their profit margins and their return on invested
- 1:54capital, the ROIC. So for every dollar they poured
- 1:57into the business. They were barely getting 2
- 1:58pennies back in profit over the last decade.
- 2:01It's a huge structural headwind. OK.
- 2:03So that's the historical problem, but you mentioned
- 2:05pivot, The Q12024 results suggest they're finally getting
- 2:09serious about this. They are.
- 2:11The big signal was promoting the CFO, Mrs. Sandy Ranju, to CEO.
- 2:17I mean, when you put your CFO in the top job, you're basically
- 2:20declaring war on inefficiency. And the numbers back that up.
- 2:24They do look, the revenue growth was pretty modest, just 7.0%
- 2:28year over year mature. But then you look at the profit
- 2:32metrics, OK, Gap operating income shot up 20.3% and non JAB
- 2:37net income was up 17.1%. So profits are growing way
- 2:40faster than revenue. That's operating leverage.
- 2:43They're finally making the model work efficiently.
- 2:45No, hold on. You said gap versus non gap for
- 2:47listeners who aren't deep in the finance weeds.
- 2:49Why is that distinction so important for a company like JD?
- 2:52That's a great question for tech companies especially.
- 2:55Non gap often gives you a cleaner picture of the core
- 2:57businesses health. How so?
- 2:59It strips out non cash expenses like stock based compensation
- 3:02for employees or depreciation so it gives you a better sense of
- 3:05the actual cash the operations are generating.
- 3:08Got it. And the key to this whole margin
- 3:10expansion story, it's in that smaller slice of the pie, right,
- 3:14the service revenue. Exactly.
- 3:15That's where the magic is happening.
- 3:16Service revenue is things like the fees from other sellers on
- 3:19their marketplace. That's the three P side.
- 3:21And crucially, revenue from JD Logistics serving external
- 3:25clients. And that part is growing much
- 3:27faster. Yep, it grew 8.8% and the JD
- 3:31logistics part specifically grew almost 15%.
- 3:33So let me get this straight. The low margin retail business
- 3:36built this gigantic expensive Moat and now the high margin
- 3:40service business is finally starting to pay the rent, so to
- 3:43speak. They're monetizing that Moat.
- 3:45That's the flywheel. It's finally kicking into high
- 3:46gear. But we can't just look at the
- 3:49good numbers. We have to address why the stock
- 3:52is still so cheap. The risks.
- 3:54The deep multifaceted risks, the valuation is a direct reflection
- 3:58of them. OK, so let's break it down.
- 4:00First up, the immediate stuff competition and the macro
- 4:03environment. Right.
- 4:05The Chinese economy has been sluggish and that's led to a big
- 4:08consumer trade down. People are just more price
- 4:10sensitive, extremely, and that directly challenges JD's whole
- 4:14identity as the premium, high quality player.
- 4:18And it fuels price wars, I imagine.
- 4:20Ruthless margin roading, price wars.
- 4:22You've got pinned to a DO on one side, which is all about low
- 4:25price and then you have the live streaming commerce platforms
- 4:28like DO in which is a whole other structural threat.
- 4:30So JD is forced to fight back with.
- 4:33They have to they launch their own RMB 10 billion discount
- 4:38program. It's a necessary defensive move,
- 4:41but it puts direct pressure on those already thin retail
- 4:44margins. OK, now for the part that's
- 4:46frankly terrifying for investors, the political and
- 4:49governance risks, the China discount.
- 4:51Yeah, this is where it gets really interesting and you're
- 4:53right, terrifying. The core of the problem is the
- 4:56legal structure itself, the variable interest entity, the
- 5:00VIE. So just to simplify, if I buy a
- 5:02share of JD on AUS exchange, I don't actually own a piece of
- 5:05the Chinese company? Not directly, no.
- 5:06You own shares in a shell company, usually in the Cayman
- 5:09Islands, that has a contractual claim on the Chinese company's
- 5:11profits. A contractual claim.
- 5:13So if the Chinese Communist Party just decides one day to
- 5:18invalidate that contract. What do you hold?
- 5:20Effectively paper. Worthless paper.
- 5:23That's the chilling part. It is a permanent,
- 5:25unquantifiable legal risk hanging over the stock.
- 5:29It exists in this legal Gray area that Beijing can control
- 5:33arbitrarily. And that's before we even get to
- 5:35the threat of regulatory crackdowns or being delisted
- 5:39from US exchanges. Right.
- 5:40The HFCAA, the Holding Foreign Companies Accountable Act.
- 5:43That's a constant threat. The stock carries headline risk
- 5:46every single day based on decisions made in Washington and
- 5:49Beijing, completely separate from how the business is.
- 5:51Doing And then there's the internal governance.
- 5:53The company is basically a founder dictatorship.
- 5:56That's a good way to put it. The founder, Richard Liu,
- 5:59controls about 76.1% of the total voting power through a
- 6:03dual class share structure. So minority shareholders have
- 6:07what, 0 say? Zero influence and that creates
- 6:10profound key person risk. You're talking about the
- 6:12incident back in 2018. Exactly.
- 6:15His personal conduct incident caused the stock to collapse.
- 6:18It was a harsh reminder that your investment is tied not just
- 6:22to the business, but to the personal decisions and actions
- 6:25of one single, extremely powerful individual.
- 6:28OK, so with all that on the table, let's turn to valuation.
- 6:32How do all these risks and rewards balance out?
- 6:35Well, if you look at the 10 year data, you see the classic S
- 6:38curve growth was a staggering 66% back in 2014.
- 6:43And now it's slowed too. About 3.5% over the trailing 12
- 6:46months. Let's pause on that TTM trailing
- 6:4812 months. Why do we use that?
- 6:50It just smooths out any weird seasonality, gives you a cleaner
- 6:53picture of the companies current performance, and that TTM data
- 6:56shows that real sustainable profitability is a pretty new
- 6:59thing for them. Only since about 2019.
- 7:01So when we run this through our Deep Value investing scorecard,
- 7:04how does JD measure up? The scorecard gives a really
- 7:08starkanswerjd.com fails the tests for a high quality
- 7:11company, so it's. Not a Buffett stock.
- 7:13Not at all. The gross margin is structurally
- 7:15low at 14.5%. The 10 year average ROIC is just
- 7:19awful. It's not an elegant high profit
- 7:21business, but where it fails on quality, it aces the value Test
- 7:25test. The gram style cheapness.
- 7:27Emphatically, it passes all the statistically cheap tests.
- 7:30I mean APE ratio of around 10.2 a price to book of 1.1.
- 7:34You're basically buying the company for the value of its
- 7:37physical assets. And the balance sheet is strong.
- 7:40Rock solid, low debt, great interest coverage.
- 7:43It's the definition of a deep value play.
- 7:46And management seems to agree, given their capital allocation,
- 7:49they've got a new share buyback program.
- 7:51A big one, $3 billion, valid through March 2027.
- 7:56At today's prices, that's enough to buy back almost 7% of the
- 7:59company. Which provides a sort of soft
- 8:00floor under the stock price. It's a strong signal from the
- 8:03company that they also believe their stock is deeply
- 8:05undervalued. OK.
- 8:07To really quantify this, we have to look at the discounted cash
- 8:10flow valuation, the DCF and this is where that risk premium
- 8:13really bites. It have to For ADCF on a Chinese
- 8:17company to be remotely realistic you have to use a high discount
- 8:20rate. We added a specific 4.0% China
- 8:23specific risk premium just for those political and governance
- 8:26nightmares. Wow, a 4.0% premium?
- 8:29What does that actually mean for an investor?
- 8:31That high discount rate gives us a WACC of 12.2%.
- 8:36What does that tell you? It tells you that you demand a
- 8:38huge annual return, 12.2% just to be willing to take on this
- 8:42specific investment. It's the price you require for
- 8:44taking on all that catastrophic traffic, legal and political
- 8:47baggage. You need a massive potential
- 8:49return just to compensate for the massive risk.
- 8:51Precisely. And when we run the DCF with
- 8:54that high hurdle rate, the value range is wide.
- 8:57The basement a no growth scenario gives you about $12.00
- 9:00a share. The nominal case gets you up to
- 9:02almost $22.00. So where does the current price,
- 9:05around $14.50, fit into all this?
- 9:08Here's the key take away. The current market price is
- 9:10trading almost exactly at our conservative case intrinsic
- 9:13value of $14.74 and that. Conservative case assumes.
- 9:17It assumes only 2% annual growth and free cash flow basically
- 9:20nothing. So the market is pricing in a
- 9:22future where JD barely grows at all.
- 9:24It is. It's completely ignoring the
- 9:26potential upside from that whole profitability pivot we talked
- 9:29about. It means if management can just
- 9:32execute on monetizing that logistics network, the upside is
- 9:35substantial. So to sum up the central finding
- 9:38here, an investment in jd.com is a pure statistical value bet.
- 9:42You're buying a decent business with a real Moat at a wonderful
- 9:45price, and you're specifically gambling that the market has
- 9:48gone way too far in discounting the future value of that
- 9:50logistics infrastructure. And the whole thing hinges on
- 9:53your belief that those catastrophic political risks,
- 9:57the vie the CCP, will not actually stop the company from
- 10:00generating cash, which to be fair, just hit a TTM high margin
- 10:04of 4.4%. Which brings us right back to
- 10:06the governance risk. So let's leave you with a final
- 10:08thought to Mull over. Given Richard Liu's overwhelming
- 10:12voting power, that 76.1% control you aren't just buying a stock,
- 10:16you're buying a minority stake in what is, for all intents and
- 10:19purposes, a private enterprise controlled by one man.
- 10:22His financial interests seem aligned with yours right now,
- 10:25with the stock so cheap, But how would you know when that
- 10:28changes? When his personal goals might
- 10:30diverge from yours as a minority shareholder?
- 10:33What's the metric that would signal that shift before it's
- 10:35too late? A fascinating and I think
- 10:38critical question for anyone looking at this space.
- 10:41Thank you for joining us on this deep dive into jd.com's very
- 10:44complex profile. We'll catch you next time.