Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep6: GRD006 - Should I Pay Off Debt Before I Retire?
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you the saver so that you can make better
- 0:10decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes, and here's
- 0:14how we're going to do that each week.
- 0:16Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular retirement strategy
- 0:21or topic with the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a.
- 0:30Winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to
- 0:33argue and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respective positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:43You a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:47each side of the debate to your own personal situation, to decide
- 0:50what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:02Ed Slott: Welcome everyone.
- 1:03I'm Ed Slott here with Jeff Levine on the great retirement debate.
- 1:07Jeff, what are we discussing on this new episode?
- 1:10Jeff Levine: All right, today, I've got a hot topic for us to discuss
- 1:14one that comes up all the time.
- 1:17Uh, should I pay off my debt before I retire.
- 1:21In other words, should I go into retirement debt free?
- 1:24And just to clarify here, Ed, we're not necessarily talking about, like,
- 1:28you can never use a credit card again.
- 1:30What we're talking about is
- 1:30Ed Slott: Right.
- 1:31Jeff Levine: You know, coming into retirement with no mortgage you've
- 1:34paid down or paid off your car.
- 1:36You're, you're not carrying a debt from month to month.
- 1:40In other words, if you use credit cards, you're paying that off each month.
- 1:43So you're not carrying debt forward from, from month to month, you're
- 1:45still allowed to go use your credit card at the store from time to time.
- 1:49So should I pay off my debt before I retire is what
- 1:52we're going to debate today.
- 1:55All right.
- 1:55So let us, uh, flip a coin and see which side of the debate we are on
- 2:00Ed, would you like heads or tails?
- 2:04Ed Slott: The winning side, heads.
- 2:05Jeff Levine: All right.
- 2:06Heads for ed once again, once again, here we go.
- 2:09All right.
- 2:10And the answer is tails so I will pick ed at, I, I will take these, the side of
- 2:19having debt into retirement is, is okay.
- 2:21Carrying debt.
- 2:22And, um, I'll let you take the, the side of pay off your mortgage, pay
- 2:26everything off before you get there.
- 2:28Does that work for you?
- 2:29Ed Slott: Oh wow.
- 2:30You're a better man than me.
- 2:31I don't like debt in retirement.
- 2:33So I'm gonna be interested in what you're saying, your arguments to pile up debt.
- 2:37And as you said, make it clear.
- 2:39Well,
- 2:39Jeff Levine: I didn't say pile up that I said not have to pay off all the time.
- 2:44Ed Slott: Uh, you know, it's interesting when I do programs for consumers,
- 2:49I always ask them, uh, how many of you are debt free in retirement?
- 2:54Most of them raise their hands on.
- 2:55It's good in my opinion.
- 2:56I think it's good to be debt free in retirement.
- 2:59Uh, so you don't have obligations that's so that's why you retired.
- 3:03And then I'll ask, uh, some of the people who raised their
- 3:06hands, which is almost everybody.
- 3:08Mainly they are retirees.
- 3:10And I'll say, what does it mean?
- 3:11Why did you raise your hand?
- 3:12What does it mean to you that you're debt free?
- 3:14They said, well, I paid off my home.
- 3:16I don't have any mortgage.
- 3:17There have no credit card debt and I don't owe anybody any money.
- 3:21So I'm debt free.
- 3:22And then of course I add.
- 3:23Well, not if you have an IRA, that's a different topic.
- 3:27Jeff Levine: That's a, that's a topic for another day.
- 3:29Yeah.
- 3:29Ed Slott: That's a topic for another day because there is
- 3:32debt in a tax deferred account.
- 3:34But I like that.
- 3:35I mean, who wants, we always talk about simplicity, not worry about paying bills.
- 3:40Uh, this is why you retired to put all that behind you.
- 3:44So I like the idea of not having to worry about owing and building
- 3:49interest and owing bills in retirement.
- 3:52I just don't think it's a good thing.
- 3:54Jeff Levine: Now I, I understand that.
- 3:56And there is a sense there is a, a good point to simplicity and
- 3:59certainly paying down debt will have, you know, that many fewer things
- 4:02you have to deal with in your life.
- 4:04But I think of debt as a tool.
- 4:07Right.
- 4:07And I, I don't hate screwdrivers.
- 4:09I don't hate hammers.
- 4:11I don't hate saws.
- 4:11Like when I need one, I use it.
- 4:13And so if I've got a situation where I'm thinking.
- 4:17Uh, you know, for instance, the last few years, mortgage rates
- 4:21have been historically low.
- 4:22We're starting to see that reverse now in 2022, but for years we have been
- 4:27at, you know, rock bottom mortgage rates for those in retirement.
- 4:32I mean, debt, in some cases almost could be an asset.
- 4:35Right.
- 4:35And think about someone who a few years ago, bought a retirement home and they've
- 4:41locked in a mortgage at 3% or 4% when inflation today is closer to seven or 8%.
- 4:49Even if that calms down a little bit, you know, they are actually paying, you
- 4:54know, the, the fact that they have debt at 3% or 4% could actually be an asset.
- 4:59Someone if they could, would, would actually want to buy that debt from
- 5:03them because it's so inexpensive
- 5:06Ed Slott: well, I've had clients over the years, that kind of make that argument.
- 5:09They'll say, look, if I could get, and I, I used to agree with them.
- 5:12They, they would, uh, set this premise if I could borrow at 2% or 3% and invest.
- 5:18I mean, this goes back, shows how old I am.
- 5:21Uh, I have clients that used to complain how come, uh, I don't get 15% on my CDs
- 5:27anymore, these are from the eighties.
- 5:29Uh, I'm waiting till it goes up to 18%.
- 5:32Well, we don't have those kind of rates, uh, unless you can really
- 5:35make a killing in the market.
- 5:36So they might say, well, if I could borrow, and this is just
- 5:40pure math, three, four, 5% and make 10% a, a year R and I up.
- 5:46As you get closer to retirement or you're already there.
- 5:49I don't think what if the tax, what if the stock market crashes and all
- 5:54your projections are off, you may not have the years to recover from that.
- 5:59So that's one of the reasons I don't like that argument.
- 6:02The argument mathematically makes sense.
- 6:04Sure.
- 6:05If you could buy dollars at 3% and settle, sell them at
- 6:0810%, I'd do that all day long.
- 6:11Jeff Levine: Well, I mean, the other thing that using debt does, it
- 6:14allows you more flexibility because if you have debt, it means, uh,
- 6:19well let me put it a different way.
- 6:21If you've paid down your debt, it means you have used
- 6:24up some of your other assets.
- 6:27Right.
- 6:27And so having like doesn't mean you can't do it again.
- 6:30For instance, let's say you have a.
- 6:32That's worth, you know, $500,000 and you had a $300,000 mortgage against
- 6:36it, and you took $300,000 from your bank account to go put it into, uh,
- 6:42you know, to pay off your mortgage.
- 6:43It is true that you have no longer have the interest rate, but a, uh, you know,
- 6:47that you're paying interest, but, one, you're not making money with that 300,000.
- 6:52I agree with your point, you don't know what the future holds.
- 6:54What if you lose money if you're investing it, but beyond that, what,
- 6:57what if you need those dollars again?
- 7:00What if you run short because you, you you're, you're out of assets
- 7:04or you're running low on assets.
- 7:05You don't feel comfortable anymore because you don't have as many liquid assets.
- 7:09When people see dollars in the bank, they feel comfortable.
- 7:13They know they can go out and spend it.
- 7:14When people have a house worth a lot of money.
- 7:17Even though the house may have a ton of equity in it.
- 7:20They don't think about the ability to tap it in the same way.
- 7:24And in fact, even if they do, it might become more expensive.
- 7:26For instance, if interest rates continue to rise taking, uh, you know,
- 7:30the only, the, the thought that you had of what we don't know what the
- 7:32markets will do, or we don't know what interest rates will continue to do.
- 7:35If they continue to rise.
- 7:37If we go back to a scenario where you were anywhere close to, you know, 15% back in
- 7:41the eighties, but even if it was seven or 8%, that's a lot more expensive if you
- 7:46have to take a home equity loan down the line than it would be today, just to leave
- 7:50your mortgage and continue paying it.
- 7:52And with a lot of types of debt, whether it be student loan interest,
- 7:57or uh, home interest, uh, there are tax benefits associated with it.
- 8:02So it may not even be the true cost of the debt that you're paying because
- 8:05you get a tax break for some of it.
- 8:07Ed Slott: Right.
- 8:08Uh, but many people are not getting the tax break due to the limitations
- 8:13of the most people take, especially older retired people over 65
- 8:17have largest standard deductions.
- 8:19So they may not get that, uh, that tax benefit.
- 8:23But going back to what you said, you know, if there's a need for it.
- 8:26Like I remember a client years ago had this decision and I like the idea
- 8:30actually that you said to lock it in.
- 8:33But it may, you may be better off if you really wanna lock in the ability
- 8:36to access money when you need it, you might be better off with a, a credit line
- 8:41or even a reverse mortgage where, you know, the money is there if you need it.
- 8:45And so that takes that worry away.
- 8:47That's that was one of your points without, uh, having the
- 8:50big mortgage or the big interest payments and the money is there.
- 8:54If you need it, you only pay interest, obviously if you tap into it.
- 8:58Jeff Levine: Well, I'm sure we'll cover this on a, on a future episode.
- 9:01In fact, I know we will, uh, at some point, but one of the big differences,
- 9:05I agree with you on the reverse mortgage there, a lot of people hate
- 9:08reverse mortgages, whether that's right or wrong is, is for another day.
- 9:12Ed Slott: Yeah I don't wanna go there because a lot has changed
- 9:15in that marketplace and, uh,
- 9:17Jeff Levine: A lot, yes.
- 9:18Ed Slott: And there are advantages, but I just used it as an example of
- 9:22having access to money without sort of paying for it with monthly payments.
- 9:27Jeff Levine: And I think that was a good point.
- 9:28The, the one where I, where I would disagree with on the home equity
- 9:31line is a bank can call that in.
- 9:33Right.
- 9:33So where.
- 9:34One of the real benefits.
- 9:35Again, I don't wanna go into that today too much, but one of the
- 9:38benefits of like the reverse mortgage style of, of home equity line, right?
- 9:43Uh, it's not a home equity line of credit, but effectively functions in a very
- 9:46similar way is that if it's a reverse mortgage, the bank can't call it in.
- 9:51Whereas a home equity loan, if you look back for like, let's say 2008, 2009, Banks
- 9:56just started saying, Nope, you know what, no more home equity loan, or we're scaling
- 9:59it down or we're taking it away from you.
- 10:01Ed Slott: That's right.
- 10:01Jeff Levine: And, uh, and, and so again, that let's, that's an
- 10:04unknown, just the same way you're saying the market is unknown.
- 10:07That home equity line of credit could be an unknown too.
- 10:09If things are really bad and you need to get that money, is it because things
- 10:14are just really bad for you personally?
- 10:17Or is it because things economically have gone really bad for everyone?
- 10:20And if that's the case, the bank may just take away your line of credit
- 10:24and you're back to the same situation.
- 10:25What do I do?
- 10:26Ed Slott: Well, again, I still don't like debt for that when you need something.
- 10:31Uh, but there's a different kind of debt.
- 10:34I was saying before I had a client that wanted something and they took
- 10:37money equity out of their home because they wanted to buy, I don't even
- 10:40know what to call all those big, uh, I, I don't know, you know, those
- 10:44big wagons, there's a name for it, where they were big trailer things.
- 10:49What are those called?
- 10:50Jeff Levine: Uh, are you talking about an RV.
- 10:51Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 10:52Okay.
- 10:52But a big one.
- 10:53Is that the name of them?
- 10:54Jeff Levine: Yeah, an RV.
- 10:55Yeah.
- 10:55Recreational vehicle.
- 10:56Yeah.
- 10:57Like one of the bus style ones where
- 10:58Ed Slott: Right, right.
- 10:59You know, you could live there, you could stay overnight and they traveled all over.
- 11:02Jeff Levine: I believe they're technically known as class a
- 11:05RVs or class, a organization.
- 11:06Ed Slott: All right.
- 11:07Whatever class.
- 11:07Jeff Levine: You know, in my spare time, ed, I'm also a, an RV specialist.
- 11:11Ed Slott: Yeah, well obviously I am not a big, a very big car
- 11:15that goes up high and long like a truck except you could live in it.
- 11:20And uh, this client, they decided that's what they wanted to do in retirement and
- 11:25they took about 300,000 out, bought one of these huge things that had everything.
- 11:29And for years they just traveled around the country.
- 11:32So they were getting use out of it.
- 11:34To me, that's probably a good use of debt because they were using it and
- 11:38enjoying it in, in their retirement years.
- 11:40And they had the income to cover the payments of course.
- 11:44Jeff Levine: That's fair, but you use your house in retirement and a lot of people
- 11:47think about paying off that debt too.
- 11:48All your clients were thinking about in that case was taking their
- 11:51house on the road quite literally.
- 11:53Right?
- 11:53Ed Slott: Literally that's what they did.
- 11:55And I think eventually I lost touch with them over the years, but I think
- 11:58they eventually sold their house.
- 12:01Jeff Levine: Well, and I would also say that, you know, there's other
- 12:05times when, if you're looking at debt as a, as a possibility, yes.
- 12:12The market can do worse than zero.
- 12:14We know that, but there are some things in which you can invest that are at least
- 12:17have some sort of reasonable guarantee.
- 12:21For instance, a treasury bill offered by the federal government, right.
- 12:24Theoretically America could go broke, but we can always add another,
- 12:27like the, the fed can make money.
- 12:28We've seen that in recent history.
- 12:31Right?
- 12:31So what if you are buying, let's say for instance, you know, In
- 12:35the process of building our home, we're shopping for furniture.
- 12:38There are a lot of times where we go out and we look at a sizable purchase
- 12:41and they'll offer us 0% financing for, you know, for three years or five years.
- 12:46Well, I, I, even if I wanna remove all market risk from my, from
- 12:50my life, I can take the dollars that I would pay and cash today.
- 12:54And I could turn around and put them in a, a treasury bill or a CD or
- 12:58something else that has some sort of, uh, guaranteed rate of return.
- 13:02Even if it's nominal or even if it's small, it's still something
- 13:06and it's money in my pocket as opposed to the company's pocket.
- 13:08Ed Slott: But it would have to exceed the interest rate you're paying
- 13:11to make it mathematically viable.
- 13:14Jeff Levine: Yeah, but there are a lot of in, well, at least, uh,
- 13:17until recently there have been a lot of interest free promotional.
- 13:19Like you wanna go by furniture, for instance, you can see that on almost, uh,
- 13:23you know, many furniture stores, right?
- 13:25They'll have five years interest free financing.
- 13:27They just bake it into the cost of their product.
- 13:29They know that it's not, you know, it's not really interest free for them.
- 13:32They're just selling something at $3,000 that they probably
- 13:35could have sold at 2,500.
- 13:37But they've got this financing element baked in there to them.
- 13:40So why, why not take advantage of that?
- 13:42Why, why prohibit yourself from all debt?
- 13:44I'm not, I'm not saying that you should come into debt trying
- 13:47to accumulate as much debt.
- 13:49Ed Slott: No, no, definitely not.
- 13:50But you know, goes back to the feeling.
- 13:52Think about the people that are approaching retirement
- 13:56listening today are already there.
- 13:58They spent maybe 30 years of their life paying off a mortgage.
- 14:02And the day they paid it off was like the holy grail.
- 14:06I mean, they used to have parties and mortgage burning parties years ago
- 14:10that I finally paid off my mortgage.
- 14:12Most people don't wanna go back there.
- 14:15Uh, most people don't want debt.
- 14:17They, they did that during their working years.
- 14:19It took a chunk of their paycheck.
- 14:21Now they have maybe a fixed income in retirement.
- 14:24They don't wanna use that going back and paying off debt again.
- 14:28Now mathematically using some of the tools that you're talking about.
- 14:32It might pay, but I don't think it it's good for people just psychologically.
- 14:36They wanna be free of debt going into retirement years, having debt like a whole
- 14:41mortgage to them would be going backwards.
- 14:44Jeff Levine: Well, I think that's one area where we can absolutely
- 14:46agree on ed is that psychologically.
- 14:50Uh, it may feel good and that your feelings matter, right?
- 14:55Like, right.
- 14:55The reason you work hard over the course of your lifetime
- 14:59is so that you have freedom.
- 15:00And if that freedom means you're willing to, to leave a little potentially
- 15:04on the table to enjoy peace of mind.
- 15:07I can get behind that.
- 15:08You wanna enjoy your retirement a hundred percent.
- 15:10That's why you work hard all those years.
- 15:12No question about it.
- 15:14Ed Slott: And the reason I love a debt free retirement, it's the same reason.
- 15:17I love a tax free retirement, cause as I said up front, uh, taxes are a debt
- 15:22and nobody wants to deal with that.
- 15:23Most people going into retirement don't want added expenses.
- 15:30Jeff Levine: Ed, would you, would you sum up maybe some of the key points here
- 15:33for, for listeners so that if they're thinking about this, they could walk
- 15:36away with, with some key takeaways here.
- 15:39Ed Slott: All right.
- 15:39So I'll give you the, the, the scenario, which happens a lot, not so much lately.
- 15:44Uh, when I used to see more clients that would come in.
- 15:46And I remember this one banker client and he gave me the argument you gave.
- 15:51No, no.
- 15:51If I can get a, a mortgage, you know, 3% and invest at 10%, uh,
- 15:57I'm going to come out ahead and he would say, don't you agree at?
- 15:59Yeah.
- 16:00But what if the market, you know, uh, then you have market risk.
- 16:03Now you are saying, uh, maybe you can get more guaranteed and not
- 16:07guaranteed, but less risky investments.
- 16:09They may pay a lower return and maybe you're still, uh, maybe you're still
- 16:14ahead and your points also were that you can lock in the availability of money.
- 16:19My points is, uh, most people in retirement.
- 16:22I think my opinion and I've met a lot of them just don't want added
- 16:26debt in retirement, cause they spent their whole life getting
- 16:29rid of debt, mainly home debt.
- 16:30And that's what we're talking about.
- 16:32And just to make it clear, uh, we said this up front, we're not
- 16:35talking about the regular credit card debt and all of that stuff.
- 16:38That's fine.
- 16:39If you pay the bill every month.
- 16:41Jeff Levine: Agreed.
- 16:41Yeah, right.
- 16:43Make sure you pay that.
- 16:44That's another one where we definitely agree.
- 16:45Don't carry credit card debt.
- 16:47That is, that is probably, it's hard to find a scenario where paying credit card
- 16:51debt with an interest rate associated with it is a good move because those
- 16:55credit card companies, they charge an arm and a leg for that sort of interest.
- 16:59Well, Ed, you know, there are two sides to every coin, but our listeners
- 17:04lives and retirement decisions are too important to leave up to a coin flip.
- 17:09That's why the one thing that you and I always agree on is that it's important
- 17:14to make sure you're talking through any big decision with a knowledgeable
- 17:17financial advisor or tax professional so that you can weigh the pros and
- 17:21cons of different options against your specific set of goals and circumstances.
- 17:26So if you'd like to reach.
- 17:29To ed and I to continue the discussion.
- 17:31You wanna tell us something we missed?
- 17:33Wanna tell us why you really love carrying debt into retirement or why you're happy.
- 17:36You paid it off.
- 17:37You got a topic for a future debate.
- 17:39We'd love to hear from you.
- 17:41You can reach Ed on Twitter at @TheSlottReport that's at.
- 17:44The Slott with two T's report and you can reach me at @CPAPlanner.
- 17:48That's @CPAPlanner.
- 17:50Let us know, reach out to us.
- 17:52We'd love to hear from you Ed as always an insightful and informative and fun debate.
- 17:57Look forward to our next discussion real soon.
- 18:00Ed Slott: Okay, Jeff.
- 18:01See you on the next episode of the great retirement debate!
- 18:04OUTRO: Jeffrey levine is chief planning officer for Buckingham wealth partners.
- 18:07This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 18:11not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 18:14Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 18:17which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 18:20Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's.
- 18:23And completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 18:25The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 18:28and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham wealth partners.