Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 244- Making A Bridge To Far
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with doug Hess here on Jiljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcast and memories of Yesteryear. My
- 0:26name is doug Hess, and if you're tuning in Forgotten Hollywood for the first
- 0:29time, what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey back
- 0:32in time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may not
- 0:36know about. And in this episode we have a very special guest with us
- 0:39today, Simon Lewis, with his latest book, Making a Bridge Too Far.
- 0:45Simon, Welcome to Forgotten Hollywood. Welcome Doug Yeah, thank you,
- 0:50thanks for going. Ah well, thank you so much, and thank you
- 0:52for spending a few minutes of your time to be on to talk about your
- 0:56book, A Bridge to Making a Bridge Too Far. I'll get that right
- 1:00there. And what we always do is kind of start off by allowing the
- 1:06author to kind of give a quick overview of what the book is about.
- 1:11Right well, it's about the nineteen seventy seventy the war epic British bar which
- 1:15is based on Cornelius Ryan's best selling non fiction account of operations Market Garden,
- 1:23which was I think, up until the book's publication almost unknown in the States.
- 1:29It was quite a big story in the UK. In very simple terms,
- 1:34there was a whole series of bridges behind German lines, and the Allies
- 1:38perhaps this extraordinary, daring plan to parachute three divisions to American one British who
- 1:45sees a whole series of bridges while the British Armored Corps basically thrust up a
- 1:52sixty four mile highway to link up with them. I mean, incredibly audacious,
- 1:57and it almost succeeded. Arnham is obvious was basically where it all went
- 2:01wrong, and that's always been a very very big part of kind of British
- 2:06history and the rest of it. But I think the American side was largely
- 2:08unknown until Ryan's book. But since the book and obviously the film, I
- 2:14think you know that the American end has been suitably recognized, you know,
- 2:19and that was it basically is sort of Yeah, it's a multinational story,
- 2:24basically, absolutely, And that's not really uncommon, whether it's especially in history
- 2:31in general, but in World War Two, a lot of these battles and
- 2:36events kind of go unnoticed or are not remembered until somebody either writes a book
- 2:43and or makes a movie about it, and then it kind of brings up
- 2:46this new interest or desire to learn more about something fatally. I mean,
- 2:53my previous book was about the nineteen seventy film Waterloo, and so absolutely love
- 3:01I've always been attracted to historical epics, and I think my interest in history
- 3:07totally derives from movies, and as I sort of, you know, initially
- 3:14when I was young, the interest was primarily primarily in the history, and
- 3:16then as I sort of a few years later, I started getting more interested
- 3:20in the film and then generally in cinema in general. So probably my cinema
- 3:25is kind of my biggest passion. But something I very I feel very sort
- 3:30of passionate about, and there's something I'd be quite angry about is the sort
- 3:34of nitpicking that historians and sort of those with a little bit of knowledge have
- 3:38on historical movies. And there is a line, there's a definite line,
- 3:44I think something. Some films cross it, some don't, but you know,
- 3:47I felt like I Bridge Too Far was made with very best of intentions
- 3:52and saying, with Waterloo, an awful lot of efforts, allful of money
- 3:57that basically doesn't actually generate in to the financiers who was spent. You didn't
- 4:02need to spend that amount of money, didn't need all those extra uniforms and
- 4:09tanks and all the rest of it. But they did it. They wanted
- 4:11to get it right. And I think I don't have a lot of time
- 4:14for nitpickers. I really don't you know that. I mean, I think
- 4:15Bridge too Far has one perhaps major, not major, one irritating issue,
- 4:20which is unfortunately Robert Redford taking that Maban bridge on his own. But it's
- 4:25a it's a minor, it's a mind detail from what I can gather,
- 4:30it's not Robert Redford who was behind it. I think it was sort of
- 4:33more a sense that we're paying the start two million dollars, which was an
- 4:36astonishing amount of money for the time, and we need to give him something
- 4:41to do. I think that's essentially what that was about. But but but
- 4:45sort of ring fence that and forget about that. You know, overall,
- 4:47it gets it most of it right, most of it right. And I
- 4:50think we can forgive those little paths absolutely and you know, and just take
- 4:56down kind of a little a step further. In my person opinion, I
- 5:00agree with you, you know, especially when you're taking a massive event and
- 5:05you're trying to condense it into an hour and a half, two hours,
- 5:09three hours, whatever it is. You can't do every single little detail.
- 5:15Sometimes you have to speed things up in order to get it to fit in
- 5:18a certain time crunch. And for those that, like you said, want
- 5:24a nitpick with everything, it's like, this is entertainment too. You have
- 5:29to take it for what it's worth. Yeah, and it's interesting, very
- 5:32slight side. You see people sort of saying, oh, well, you
- 5:36know, the great thing with them that the new concept of miniseries that we
- 5:42get a lot of. Now we do things in detail, we can be
- 5:45much more accurate. But I think they misunderstand that screenwriters and dramatists basically interested
- 5:50in drama. They're not going to say, oh, we've got eight hours,
- 5:55we can make it more authentic and historical. They're not going to do
- 5:59that. They're going to say, oh, we can explore the characters,
- 6:02we can actually push the drama. That's what they'd be thinking. They wouldn't
- 6:05be thinking, all, right, yes, we can get these six characters
- 6:10who actually did much the same thing right, confusing and it was interesting with
- 6:15Goldman's script. For instance, there's a German character called General Ludvik who is
- 6:19his fictional but he's actually an amalgamation of two German generals who basically had virtually
- 6:26the same name. It was Harmle and Harser. Now, if you're being
- 6:30authentic, can you imagine having two German actors basically two characters Harvel and Harser,
- 6:36and they were both blonde and blue eyed areans. I mean, they
- 6:40would just confused the hell. So that's a great example of a screenwriter,
- 6:45a dramatist absolutely working the material for in the best possible way. And I
- 6:50have a huge respect for Goldman. I think he's one of the great screenwriters
- 6:55that you know, HOLLYO was ever produced, and I think it's one of
- 6:59his finest achievements. And he recognized that himself, and I think you know,
- 7:02quite rightly, really yeah no, And I think us as the audience
- 7:08appreciate that as well, because nobody wants to be confused when they're watching a
- 7:12movie. I mean that that's probably one of the big sins if you will
- 7:16trying to watch a film and then you're confused on is it him or is
- 7:20it the other guy? And that can be really confusing. This September will
- 7:27mark the eightieth anniversary of the event, is that correct? Yes, yes,
- 7:33yes, And you know, we were talking a little bit about history
- 7:40and some of the controversy. What were some of the controversies with making this
- 7:46the way I understand it is there were some people who didn't like some of
- 7:49the actors kind of walking around trying to imitate Germans. Did I understand that
- 7:59right? No? I think I think the main issue and it was entirely
- 8:03in the sort of a certain section of sort of the British kind who had
- 8:11a problem with Dirk Bergart as Boy Browning. I think he was unfortunate for
- 8:18the movie that almost all the leading historical characters, General Gavin, were all
- 8:28alive, and most of them took part in the film. They were invited
- 8:33to take part in the film and they did. Unfortunately, the boss of
- 8:35the whole thing, and the man that basically carried the can for the disaster,
- 8:41Browning was dead. He died about ten or twelve years ago, and
- 8:45his wife was Daphnie Demurray, the very famous writer of Rebecca and you know,
- 8:52not unreasonably, she was concerned about how he was going to be presented
- 8:56and although she didn't say it publicly, there was a feeling that she wasn't
- 9:01happy about Bogart because of his sexuality. I think, certainly in this day
- 9:07and age, I find that quite I find that quite balling, you know
- 9:09that you would even sort of view that kind of thing, because an actor
- 9:13should be quite rightly able to play anything. I'm hands pay to get a
- 9:18managed, so that that shouldn't that shouldn't really come into it. But so
- 9:22there was some criticism about him. What also didn't help was the whole tenor
- 9:30of the script, the original draft that she read. She felt that Browning
- 9:35was kind of he was aware of the disaster, so the had thing of
- 9:41sort of saying, you know, we're going a bridge too far, and
- 9:45she wanted, she originally wanted a scene created where he would say that beforehand
- 9:50to Montgomery and all the rest of it, and an Attenborough you know,
- 9:54quite unreasonably, quite reasonably, Sam, well, look that's not the story
- 9:56we want to tell. We we don't want to do that kind of thing.
- 10:00So they slightly tweaked it at the end the way very last line of
- 10:03the film where he says, as you know, I think we went to
- 10:07bridge too far, the suggestion being that he'd actually flagged it up. So,
- 10:11you know, I think that I think on the whole he was kind
- 10:16of Browning is presented fairly evenly. You know, Burger basically plays a role,
- 10:24you know, and I don't really think a lot of the criticism is
- 10:26that valid. What is interesting is that none of the characters, the historical
- 10:31characters that took part in the film, got embroiled in the in the sort
- 10:35of debate in letters to the Times. You know, there was a lot
- 10:37of letters to the Times by you know, other figures really, So I
- 10:41think I think it was it was always going to be a bit controversial.
- 10:45I mean, if if it had been a huge success and Browning and died
- 10:50and the rest of it, and I don't think it would really matter,
- 10:52people might have grumbled about. I think I think it was the fact that
- 10:56it was quite a sensitive issue and a book that felt quite let down by
- 11:03atam. Bradley felt that he would hadn't been properly supported, although Attainbridge did
- 11:07write a very beautiful letter kind of apologizing and saying it's all my fault for
- 11:13how I didn't want to upsess in your body and yeah, I mean,
- 11:16Ashma is quite an extraordinary character. Really, I think he you know,
- 11:20he did his best, you know, sure, Yeah, No, I
- 11:24also understand that obviously there was a lot of soldiers, a lot of actors
- 11:26that were playing soldiers in here, and so something that was determined is they
- 11:33wanted them to go through training so they could be more realistic as soldiers.
- 11:39Not only did they go through kind of like the book camp, I understand,
- 11:43but also weapon training, et cetera. Can you talk a little bit
- 11:46about that and how that impacted some of the acting on the set. Oh
- 11:52yeah, well, I would actually say, and I said my book,
- 11:54I think actually the kind of the real heart of a Bridge too Far,
- 11:58not fourteen stars or anything else. I think it's these fifty young men who
- 12:03were basically predominantly British actors. I mean, and I think I could be
- 12:09wrong, and I'm sure some of you might point out I don't think this
- 12:13has ever been done before, which seems incredibly obvious thing to do that only
- 12:16perhaps an actor like Astenburough would have understood. He just thought, well,
- 12:22I've seen so many war films where you know, you get these incredibly big
- 12:26dramatic scenes, you've got the star actors acting, and then you pan over
- 12:31to the right and there's some very bored looking extras, clearly not at the
- 12:35moment, and he didn't and you thought, well, I don't want that.
- 12:37So he came up with this incredibly simple idea. I think the original
- 12:41plan is original plan was to hire soldiers, and I think they I think
- 12:46he even approached the British Ministry of Defense and they just said absolutely, you
- 12:50know, so I don't know how far that idea was taken. But then
- 12:54the thought, well, why don't we just get a bunch of young men
- 12:58actors and trey them. And of course now that is the standard. There
- 13:01isn't a single war film made in the last forty years that doesn't do that.
- 13:05I mean Platoon is a good example, sure, and I think films
- 13:09war films are so much better for it. So these guys are given proper
- 13:13boot camp, they're treated like soldiers, they're given the weapons. So and
- 13:18they are and I think that being actors, they were sort of encouraged.
- 13:22They weren't necessarily given a lot of direction. It was kind of assumed that
- 13:26when you were in the background, you would come up with your own stuff.
- 13:31And there's lots of little stories of the guys sort of let's say one
- 13:33was a paratroop and one was a German. They said, well let's have
- 13:37a let's get into a grapple, so I'll go for you with a Bennett
- 13:41and all this kind of thing. Sure, and so they Attamborough kind of
- 13:45trusted them to do all this sort of thing. The thing that was quite
- 13:48funny to that, I mean any actor ever, basically, what does an
- 13:54actor want? An actor wants the lime light, they want the scene.
- 13:58But these eyes didn't because if they were seen, they'd have to go home.
- 14:03So they would come up with all sorts of So basically, if if
- 14:07Assamber pointed say right, I want you to I want I'm going to give
- 14:11you a line general they're over here, they would know that they'd be on
- 14:16me at the next eraplane back home. So the guys would duck and dive
- 14:20and they can avoid thatparately. But I think there's a thing if you watch
- 14:26the film carefully, and it's only when the chats pointed out, they you'll
- 14:31see people die a couple of times, then pop up in different sort of
- 14:33places really, and the most prominent I don't know how well you know the
- 14:39film. There's there's a great line where Sean Connery has been imprisoned self imprisoned
- 14:45in this in this house in Arnhem, and this paratroopers come out and they
- 14:48shoot the Germans, and Sean Connery comes out and there's this corporal and he
- 14:54says, oh, it's a general. That's Tim Morand and he was one
- 14:56of the he was one of the APAs. So he got this life norm
- 15:01that he would that he didn't. He managed duck and dive and apparently he's
- 15:05in about half a dozen scenes where he and he said, a lot of
- 15:07it is just the back of my head or my hand, all this kind
- 15:11of thing. So yeah, but they are the heart of the movie.
- 15:13And I think in my book, I've got a photograph and both think about
- 15:18thirty of them. And it is quite fun if you can be bothered to
- 15:22go through and say, oh, that's him, that's him, that's him.
- 15:24But they are definitely the heart of the film, without a doubt.
- 15:28You know, it makes it a little bit more interesting. Every time you
- 15:31watch a film and then you you kind of know a little bit behind the
- 15:33scenes or some stories behind it, and then you rewatch the film. It
- 15:37always gives it something a little extra, a little extra when watching the films,
- 15:43and I think that makes it a little bit more enjoyable as well for
- 15:48some of them. I think that's my goal with these sort of books read.
- 15:50And also it's sort of it's fun finding out yourself. I mean,
- 15:56obviously I was fairly I you know, fair amount a reasonablemount about the bridge
- 16:00you felt, but not that much. But of course once you start talking
- 16:03to people and you hear stories and you get the back, that is fascinating.
- 16:07I love that journey. Yes, that's what I love about research.
- 16:11And besides, I remember somebody there was another book project I won't say what
- 16:14it was that I was proposing doing, and I said I didn't know a
- 16:17great deal about it, and basically I got this rather snoothy message on Facebook,
- 16:22so well you shouldn't do it then, and I said, well,
- 16:25how do you write? Anything? Said right? I said, it's it's
- 16:27being called research, and he said, well unless you are, unless you're
- 16:30an absolute passionate expert, you shouldn't bother. And I thought, okay,
- 16:36fine, I guess that's your take on it. Right, that's one take,
- 16:38but perhaps more of a challenge. I might go back to that,
- 16:47Simon, did anything surprise you during your research of this book? But not
- 16:55particularly. I think I think it's more about I mean, I've known a
- 17:00lot about you know, Richard Ashenburg is very large life personality and very big
- 17:08in some of British culture right up and died. So certainly for anybody like
- 17:14myself interested in film and culture and half and things like that, he figured
- 17:18quite quite quite large, and so very aware of his personality, very aware
- 17:22of the way he worked. I think what really impressed me researching the book
- 17:29was just his extraordinary leadership skills. Extraordinary leadership skills. So they were made
- 17:34this film so shot over six months, big budget but incredible in friendibly long
- 17:41hours, and I can't really find almost any kind of conflict or you know,
- 17:48irritation. You know, I'm sure they were sure there were short,
- 17:52sharp words and all that kind of stuff, but I can't. I have
- 17:56yet to find any any single piece of evidence of people falling out or personalities
- 18:03so in that way, you know, normally in some books you want that
- 18:07kind of friction. There wasn't any. So I thought, well, actually
- 18:11I'm just going to go with it, you know, And it is very
- 18:12much everyone is prettily polite and very incredibly complimentary of each other. And I
- 18:19think a lot of it is that sort of thing. Most of these guys
- 18:22they worked predominantly guys were absolutely the top of their game. They were the
- 18:26most experienced people. They had nothing to prove, they were very professional when
- 18:32they got on with it. And I think that's what impressed me about a
- 18:37production. And I think that's why I was very keen to bring out characters
- 18:41behind the scenes, not necessarily the creative things like David Tomlin is a good
- 18:48example, who was considered one of the world's top first assistant directors. I
- 18:52just thought, I really want to celebrate this personality, I mean, a
- 18:56legend inside the industry but not very well known outside. And I thought,
- 19:00no, I want to make sure these people I want to Actually, I
- 19:03think these people were celebrating, you know, Like you said, it's kind
- 19:08of unusual, especially in today. And maybe it's unfair to compare twenty twenty
- 19:12four to you know, the seventies eighties in terms of that, but I
- 19:18find the later or the earlier the films are the more professional Some of the
- 19:25actors and actresses and the cast were compared to today, that's not a criticism
- 19:30of today, it's just the way that we have evolved, totally, totally,
- 19:37well, I mean, I don't get me started on the difference in
- 19:38modern films. I massive disappointment. I love what I mean. Britgish Boy's
- 19:45Antas is a sort of gold noldy plastic, isn't it. But ieh pretty
- 19:48much anything from the sort of I'm basically found at twentieth century cinema. I
- 19:52would say, I think I'm most that's wonderful films this century. But sure
- 19:57I'd be struggling to I would struggle to put a list of ten great films
- 20:02in the last twenty five years. I would struggle. Put a gun to
- 20:04my head. I could probably do it. Pick out any year of the
- 20:08twentieth century, any year, and I could rear off twenty fantastic right easily.
- 20:15I agree with you, and I think it's a shame. But that's
- 20:19for another day, right, for another discussion. Well, Simon, thank
- 20:23you so much for coming on and spending a few minutes with us today.
- 20:26And I definitely want to encourage our listeners to go out and get a copy
- 20:32of Simon's book, Making a Bridge Too Far. It's out on Amazon,
- 20:40Books, Books a million, Barnes and Nobles wherever, by your books.
- 20:44Don't forget our local your independent bookstores as well. And I believe the publisher
- 20:48is good Night Publishing. That's right, good Night book. Yes, yes,
- 20:53we want to make sure that we give a shout out to them for
- 20:56that. And again, Simon, we wish you nothing but the best,
- 21:00and thank you again for coming on and spend a few minutes with us today.
- 21:03Pleasure, pleasure, yes, well, thank you for listening to this
- 21:07episode of Forgotten Hollywood. You search for Dougcaster or Forgotten Hollywood. You can
- 21:11also find me on Twitter, Instagram at hestog fourteen. If you listen to
- 21:14this podcast on iTunes another podcast service, please subscribe or rate and review this
- 21:18episode. Tune in next time for late this episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Thank
- 21:22you for listening and we will see you then