Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Punch Outs
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org, that's www.a.
- 0:12Me TT a gr, oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:22This is I love you. Keep going, it's January 26,
- 0:252023. It 7:39 p.m.
- 0:28Pacific time and I have finished a new book called punchouts.
- 0:34I think that you've probably heard me talk about Todd Japan,
- 0:38don t hardship and Auntie is a poly word.
- 0:42That means Taja means to reflect backwards or to reflect back and
- 0:48put on T is a poly word. That means conceptual Reality.
- 0:51So, to reflect back on the conceptual reality that you've
- 0:54created, To see if it accurately matches the Ultimate Reality
- 1:00that you've experienced. So Ultimate Reality is the raw
- 1:04sensing data that we take in, through our senses, touching
- 1:08seeing hearing tasting, smelling and mind in the west, we don't
- 1:13consider mind necessarily. And in the way that we construct
- 1:18these Concepts. This is quite different than the
- 1:25Western concept of the experience of reality.
- 1:29So going back to Aristotle. Who thought that if you're were
- 1:37seeing person or with what senses you have, you take in the
- 1:40experience of the outside world and you create internally, a
- 1:44working model of what that world represents in your taking in of
- 1:49that information from the outside world is pretty neutral
- 1:53and pretty complete. And so that we just all create
- 1:56these reliable working models of what's out there in front of us
- 2:01based on our sensory. Ants.
- 2:04And that, that we then operate from the internal map that we
- 2:07make about the outside world, but that the the experience of
- 2:13making that map is fairly accurate.
- 2:16Representation of what's out there?
- 2:19Which means that ordinarily. You have a fairly similar take
- 2:24on, what's Happening that other people have.
- 2:27We would call that a non mentalizing mode psychic
- 2:32equivalence. Later on about 300 years later,
- 2:36or so Epicure is modified that to say that if you had a strong
- 2:41emotional state happening, while you were taking in the material
- 2:46from the outside, informing your working model, it could have an
- 2:49effect on the way that you created the model but that it
- 2:52was still largely accurate. In Buddhist thought and in Asian
- 2:59thought this isn't actually what we're talking about at all, what
- 3:03we're talking about is the Mind Gathering bits of data from the
- 3:08outside world, evaluating them creating a model of what's,
- 3:14they're not based on a General survey in an accurate sampling.
- 3:20But on a very curated, sampling of what's meaningful to us and
- 3:26then assigning The meaning that we have for that curated list,
- 3:31creating a model and then projecting it outward and that
- 3:35it's actually our internal model that we've projected outward
- 3:38that we see as the world outside of us that making sense.
- 3:44So, the fundamental difference is in the west, we tend to think
- 3:47that we take in a General survey of what's out there and create a
- 3:51working model and so it's an outward in approach.
- 3:57Whereas, in Buddhist thought, it's we taken the data, we
- 4:01create the experience of reality, and we push it out.
- 4:04So it's an inward out model sometimes you hear expressions
- 4:11of live life as if it were a dream coming from the Eastern
- 4:18side of things to understand that we largely make up the
- 4:22experience that we're having and we assign the meanings that we
- 4:26have for the kinds of experiences that were having
- 4:30that. That's how we understand what's
- 4:33actually happened. When I encountered this as a
- 4:39teaching, it immediately resonated with me that I was
- 4:44creating this experience that I was having because my experience
- 4:49was so at odds with other people's experiences,
- 4:53particularly growing up in the household that I did.
- 4:57You know, I had a pair of gaslighting parents who both
- 5:01told me that my perception of what was happening was not real.
- 5:05Wasn't happening. And it created a very sort of
- 5:11choppy understanding of how to understand my experience.
- 5:19So, with this basic premise, we also often talk.
- 5:22And I know that when I teach for instance, loving-kindness
- 5:26practice, I talk about people who are auditory centered in
- 5:30terms of their understanding, things of things and Visually
- 5:35oriented. So auditory thinkers or visual
- 5:38thinkers. One of the things that I noticed
- 5:41in teaching meditation is. We're very auditory Centric in
- 5:47the way that We teach this and that we're not really attending
- 5:51to visual thinkers very well. We don't really have much in the
- 5:54way of material that that can be useful to somebody who's
- 5:58primarily a visual thinker and understanding this, they have to
- 6:02translate almost always an auditory or language-based
- 6:07system into a visual system to try and understand what we're
- 6:11talking about. So I thought that it might be
- 6:14interesting to try and take some photographs that were
- 6:19representative of the teaching in a way that would cause the
- 6:25understanding of this process to be described in photographs and
- 6:32that people could look at the photographs and then the Mind
- 6:36state of Taja pranati the mindset of this inquiry into the
- 6:40nature of reality would arise in the mind so that they could have
- 6:44a direct experience of that if they weren't able to and it
- 6:49through language only and then I was curious to see whether
- 6:56auditory thinkers could then investigate through Visual
- 7:00representations of what I was talking about in pictures that
- 7:07also then have the experience of that that making sense.
- 7:12So the experience of the Mind engaged actively and questioning
- 7:17whether or not the way that you've understood the visual
- 7:20experiences, actually, what's there?
- 7:23Taja pranati make sense So I thought I would test it out on
- 7:33you and see. Whether or not you can have that
- 7:39experience. This is the Opening photograph
- 7:51of the the book. What is that?
- 7:53Yeah. What is what?
- 8:01Can you see the picture that I'm sending?
- 8:03No. Yeah.
- 8:04We can see it or I can see it. Punchouts something.
- 8:09What is it possible? Attraction, you just lost
- 8:16charge? We did good.
- 8:19Let's see what's happening here. I'm back.
- 8:29Yeah. All right.
- 8:32Try and share this again. It worked in rehearsal doesn't
- 8:34seem to be working. Now, I was working for me.
- 8:42Yeah, I saw it. Here we go.
- 8:49Is this this part of your trick George?
- 8:53But the whole losing the signal. Not knowing what's happening
- 8:57thing? It's a part of the teaching.
- 9:02Can you see it now? What is this picture of?
- 9:11Oh, Color. Well, there's a hedge is a hedge
- 9:21in there and there's sorry about that for some reason, it's not
- 9:27liking this but we'll try one more time.
- 9:36That's great. So can I explain to you what it
- 9:39is? Yeah.
- 9:41This is a, a Del Taco. This is a stripe of neon around
- 9:48the edge of the Del Taco, and this is the roofline of the
- 9:54house next to it. you can even grab the rafters here and the
- 10:03the That making sense. What about this one?
- 10:17What's that? City is, is it a chemical plant?
- 10:23It is a refinery in Torrance. Torrance.
- 10:31Where's the south of? L.a. there's one big gasoline
- 10:37Refinery is very pretty. Thank you.
- 10:47So now, say go ahead. I was going to say it looks like
- 10:53a 90s album cover or 2000s. Album cover.
- 10:56I don't know what it is. This one is easier.
- 11:00What is that? I'm trees.
- 11:04Yeah. Looks like Echo Park.
- 11:08And then this, what do you notice about this?
- 11:11In comparison, comparing the images ones, foggy, foggy, air,
- 11:20and one screener They're both in La.
- 11:26Yeah. I don't know.
- 11:30Did one have a fire? No one is the there.
- 11:35They're largely the same image. This tree here is the same as
- 11:40this tree here. These pumps here are the same as
- 11:45these pumps here. This part is not included in
- 11:50this part. This, Photograph, and this part
- 11:52is included in this one. About this one.
- 12:00I feel like your commentary is starting to come through George.
- 12:08What do you make of this one? So it's the idea is like same
- 12:13place but different perspectives.
- 12:17Well, it can you can the mind make this into one building
- 12:21pretty easily maybe. But it's boring.
- 12:25It's boring. Why is it boring?
- 12:28It's just repetitive and not very creative or colorful.
- 12:36What would you like? So this is the the this is the
- 12:40statement that I made earlier that we look at the environment
- 12:43and we cherry pick things that are high on our preference list
- 12:47and if there isn't a lot of things that are high in our
- 12:50preference list, we tend to not be interested in the what's in
- 12:57front of us. So the mind is always grasping
- 13:00toward things that are of interest to us and rejecting
- 13:04things that are not of Interest. So it's a point of your art here
- 13:09to get us to see that like a how our own mind is kind of grasping
- 13:13and creating, or bored, or liking or disliking because it
- 13:17is your heart, kind of like a tool for that, an aspect of
- 13:21that. But what I really want you to
- 13:23notice is whether the mind can make that into one large
- 13:26building or do you see it distinctly as the same image
- 13:30repeated? That's it.
- 13:37I see two different ones, who different buildings.
- 13:41I see the image repeated in just with a slightly different Focus
- 13:48Oh, I see. Yeah, it's two different images,
- 13:50but from a slightly different whatever it's called photography
- 13:57to. This end of the images, one end
- 14:00of the building and this image is another end of the building,
- 14:04the whole length of the building is visible, but not in either
- 14:08one of the images. Right.
- 14:14What about this one? Is that a single panoramic view?
- 14:24or is it a repetition of three images and can the mind make
- 14:27that into one single panoramic view or do you see it distinctly
- 14:33as three images that are sort of repeated, repeated snapshots
- 14:40repeated The middle and the left one connecting, like the tree,
- 14:50on the right side of the left, one connecting a little bit into
- 14:53the tree on the left side of the middle picture, but I can also
- 14:58see that it seems to be the same group of trees in each photo.
- 15:03Don't touch it. Banane the word means that
- 15:06you're constantly comparing and making sure that the
- 15:08representation that you make of the visual experiences and
- 15:12accurate. Presentation.
- 15:14So in this particular series, if you follow the upper part of the
- 15:17photograph along, it's easy to make it into a continuous
- 15:21landscape. But if you notice that, the
- 15:24repetition of the trees is too similar, it causes the mind to
- 15:29actively engage in. The question of, is this a
- 15:32panorama or is this a single image repeated?
- 15:36Is that the experience that you're having?
- 15:41And what does that tell us about our perception?
- 15:46That the mind can create a uniform panoramic out of the
- 15:51same image repeated that it can be as convincing that.
- 15:56It's a single Panorama and not the repetition of three images,
- 16:02which is pointing to the nature of the mind to gather these
- 16:06snapshots these punch outside like to call them from the
- 16:10environment. Mint, and then assemble them
- 16:12seamlessly, so that it creates the perception of the the
- 16:16landscape in front of you, even though you're not doing an
- 16:21in-depth and neutral survey of what's in front of you, you're
- 16:25just collecting the things that are on your preference list.
- 16:33I have a bit of a oscillation from one to the other, you know,
- 16:36like separates. It's reminding me of here, your
- 16:39Twilight meditation that used to prescribe right?
- 16:44So good. It isn't that you're supposed to
- 16:47go one way or the other. It's supposed to you're supposed
- 16:49to get trapped in the process of constantly.
- 16:51Testing to make sure that the way that you've represented your
- 16:56experiences actually, what's happening?
- 16:59That's the idea. Anyway, have a look.
- 17:13So this one is more directly that experience.
- 17:16You're taking various snapshot. So in all of the imagery, you're
- 17:20Gathering different perspectives of the same experience, can you
- 17:25then assemble them into a wider experience of the whole image or
- 17:30does the Mind remain in the specific Expressions that making
- 17:38sense? So in this image, you have the
- 17:42building that's down here so that you have all of this data.
- 17:46This particular thing that you could then add over here.
- 17:51And you have the top of the tree here which is the same top of
- 17:54the tree here. The more central part which is
- 17:57giving the the data of above the capital tower building.
- 18:02So you have that there so in some sense, it's the way that
- 18:08the Mind moves Gathering its pieces of information and then
- 18:13coming together to form the image as a whole If you extend
- 18:21that out, so that it becomes a continuous landscape. even
- 18:27though the images are quite distinctly different because the
- 18:31colors are so similar to that, create the sense of panorama One
- 18:38thing that's throwing me is the gap between images.
- 18:43So that in my conceptualization ends up, forcing them to be
- 18:52separate images and it's harder. If I sit back, I can kind of let
- 18:57it blur out and imagine it's one Panorama but it's a hard hard
- 19:04because of the white line in the middle.
- 19:08Good. What's that?
- 19:21It looks like a large building under construction in back of a
- 19:27historic building. Hmm, yes, that's a church.
- 19:31That's quite that. That's totally right.
- 19:40Okay, then we have this five samplings or force and five
- 19:45samplings of the same Vista, each image, having a different
- 19:50set of information. Can the new create in your mind,
- 19:59a representation of the whole experience of the panorama?
- 20:06Or do they remain single images? They are they do see experience
- 20:13as sequential even though they're not sequential. like I
- 20:19like the dislocation of the rightmost, three images kind of
- 20:25keep implying that they're going to keep going and then there's
- 20:27like a dislocation with the leftmost to that's kind of cool.
- 20:39Again, these two things snapshots of the same view,
- 20:43really slightly different The tree is the same, this building
- 20:49behind the trees, the same, in the first image, it ends there
- 20:53and then you have all of this extra data.
- 20:55Can you then combine the two of them to create a wider panorama?
- 21:06Or this one. It's easy to allow that to blend
- 21:12in one long building. With three trees.
- 21:18I think I could do that if it weren't the white lines between
- 21:22that really make it separate like their slides.
- 21:27But if you have to wait line was gone, I could make it into one.
- 21:31But otherwise, from my perceptual mechanism, it always
- 21:36wants to see them as separate slides.
- 21:42After seeing a few of these, I'm, I'm like intrigued by the
- 21:45movement of the photographer, like the protective older
- 21:48itself, huh? What about this?
- 21:54One, Reese along the top Edge. Does that look like a continuous
- 21:59mountain range? Is it for the bottom?
- 22:03That one's easier to see as a continuous mountain range to me.
- 22:07Yeah, this seems like the most obvious one in those terms.
- 22:14Is it that you're trying to encourage us to see it that way?
- 22:19I'm trying to encourage you to question how the mind is
- 22:23assembling the visual experience that you can have the active
- 22:27experience of the Mind creating a reality, and pulling it back
- 22:31and create a reality and pulling it back.
- 22:33By the constant, the consequence training.
- 22:37Whether the way that you've created the experiences actually
- 22:40an accurate representation of what's Happening.
- 22:45Making sense a little bit. I would about to see that
- 22:54there's the same image or it's different images.
- 22:56Different Do you see them as this as the same view unfolding
- 23:07two aspects of the same who parts of them overlap but not
- 23:11the exact same. I spotted the this part of the
- 23:18image. Think, once I noticed that this
- 23:21weight on it, part of the image. Yeah, I saw that repeating.
- 23:36Again. Is it possible to connect the
- 23:39elements of this one? Two elements of that one?
- 23:42And imagine that it's a panorama that was all the way across the
- 23:46two images. Or do they look very distinct?
- 23:55Different. This.
- 24:11They look the same, but different frames and different
- 24:16Darkness. There's no way that the mind
- 24:21then connects. This is all a wide landscape it
- 24:28around Mike. Well I'm not getting that so
- 24:30far. That fast car.
- 24:43Or wind, I don't know. Wind and ocean on the fast car.
- 24:52reminds me of the bay, Lance What the bay lands up here in
- 24:58San Francisco Bay Area. This is actually the Presidio.
- 25:20And in this, can you assemble that as one compound?
- 25:28Mhm. Maybe a little easier with those
- 25:32three. This building the same as this
- 25:37one. Same as this one.
- 25:41Is there any skill to seeing is arlena?
- 25:43Is that a desirable quality from?
- 25:47Well. We have a tendency to get into
- 25:53the habit of saving things and making them solid.
- 25:56And so we rely and that sense of solidness.
- 25:59So we make a table and then we touch the table and then because
- 26:02the table feels hard reinforces our version that we've created
- 26:07the image, the experience that we're having as an accurate
- 26:11representation of what's there. And what we want to be able to
- 26:16do is pull that apart and bring it back and pull it apart and
- 26:20bring it back so that we can be actively engaged in.
- 26:23Checking the representations that were making are actually,
- 26:29what's their, you reference the Twilight meditation, where you
- 26:33allow the light to dim in the visual field.
- 26:36The first thing that you notice and that the way that magician
- 26:39goes, as you sit in a room that has natural light at dusk, Allow
- 26:44the light to diminish. The first thing that you'll
- 26:47notice, if there's no light source in there is that the
- 26:52image moves from a color image to a black and white image,
- 26:56because takes more light to activate the cones in the eyes
- 26:59than the rods and the cones the cone, see color the ROTC
- 27:03contrast and Edge. As the light dims and there's
- 27:08not enough quite to activate the rods, then the mind creates
- 27:13variations on the edges that had seen front of you, but it
- 27:17creates them as these representations of solid images.
- 27:21So what you'll notice is that the whole visual field goes in
- 27:25flux and of the mind is trying to figure out what's actually
- 27:31there. And so it keeps throwing up
- 27:33versions of what it thinks is there and creates these He's
- 27:36representations that look perfectly solid away, anything
- 27:39look solid and visual experience, even though, you
- 27:43know, that it doesn't represent the experience of the room that
- 27:46you're having. And so, what I was trying to do
- 27:50with these images is put these elements together so that the
- 27:53mind could flow in and out of these representations of
- 27:57individual images and then landscape.
- 28:01So that if your I think on the side where your habitually
- 28:05making things solid and not reinterpreting them, the take on
- 28:10the initial, take that you make of them will be pretty much what
- 28:13the experience of them is and that you want to then move to a
- 28:17place where you can open up. To a more flowy sense of the
- 28:21visual field. George.
- 28:25As the, as the artist yourself, do you find a certain tendency
- 28:30in the way that you see them or is the effect?
- 28:34Not really present because you, you know, you've seen behind the
- 28:38curtain. No, I actually picked them
- 28:42because it's easy for me to move back and forth between the
- 28:47connected and disconnected experience of them like this.
- 28:56So following this one, can you make that Hillside into one
- 29:00Hillside? That continues the whole way.
- 29:03Not runs a makes line continue all the way.
- 29:07Yes, that was easy to make this block of building connect to
- 29:11this block of building even though this is the same building
- 29:15repeated. Yeah, yeah that's the first one
- 29:20that I've been able to do it. Good.
- 29:25Am I improving my getting it? Anyway, do you imagine?
- 29:31This is three sailboats. On the bay.
- 29:36Can you or is it simply the same sailboat three times?
- 29:44It depends. Can you imagine that this is a
- 29:51continuous element here. These two blending into each
- 29:55other, creating one image here, then another coming back.
- 30:01So noticing that the Mind Blends these two and then there's the
- 30:04other element of information that comes in but it can carry
- 30:08through in this aspect of the visual experience and also tie
- 30:12into this aspect. So the whole thing can become a
- 30:15visual representation of a collection of information that
- 30:18we then have a meaning in an understanding of even though the
- 30:22images aren't connected in that way.
- 30:25Or this, what do you make of that?
- 30:32It's blurry. Is that flurry?
- 30:47What is it votes on a body of water by a volcano, right?
- 30:59It does, you know that this is about inside, even though the
- 31:01colors are a complete wrong to recognize that as a mountain?
- 31:04Does this look like it's in the water?
- 31:06Just floating in space, tacked, on there in the water.
- 31:10And then why do you assign information to it because of the
- 31:15color of the water? So none of these things are
- 31:21actually very representational of it.
- 31:23But you've you've created because this boat is clear
- 31:26enough that all of these spots here must be other boat.
- 31:28So your mind is manufactured, the experience boat out of this,
- 31:32very limited Vision. If you didn't have this, we
- 31:37can't see that. You didn't have the this boat.
- 31:40Would, you know what this was, or this?
- 31:44So the mind, he hates information and then assigns
- 31:47meaning to things in the rest of the image.
- 31:51And then you understand it. Based on them.
- 31:59What about this one? Can you see this is a continuous
- 32:03Hilltop that runs through the four Images you well.
- 32:10Then you check the sky. You see that?
- 32:12Actually that's not what's happening.
- 32:17This house is the same as this house is the same as this house.
- 32:22This house is the same as that house.
- 32:26So it's all the same image, but you can let the Mind created
- 32:30into a Hilltop pretty easily. This one's a little easier
- 32:37because if you follow the, the lot of the hills they line up.
- 32:43It looks like this Hilltop is Flowing across the whole image,
- 32:47so that you can imagine it as a panorama that exists there.
- 32:53But this image is the same as this image is the same as this
- 32:56image. His house is the same as this
- 33:01house. This.
- 33:06That making sense this bush here is actually this bush and this
- 33:11bush all the same. Does that make sense?
- 33:18And are you having the experience of Tasha, hockey
- 33:21where you were able to assemble it, and then the Mind picks it
- 33:24apart as checking to see whether it's an accurate representation.
- 33:33So you can learn something visually by looking at the
- 33:37images that would have that are intended to invoke an experience
- 33:41without the experience, having to be described to you in words,
- 33:45so I can sense. But the act of looking at the
- 33:49image is enough to create the experience, which is what we're
- 33:52trying often to describe, which is that you take in the
- 33:56information and then create the experience of the world from it?
- 34:03George. I don't know if this is jumping
- 34:05on the gun, but it, what? What's the connection to this
- 34:09recognition and understanding mentalizing?
- 34:13If that's what you're pointing at, maybe I'm actually pointing
- 34:17more at aspects of an enlightened or an awakened by.
- 34:22Okay. when we get these days, all of the identified with the
- 34:27version of reality that we are creating Based on the
- 34:31information that would take him and we come into a solid
- 34:36identification with the sense of self.
- 34:39Then we think that these things are real and need to be defended
- 34:42if we can have the Insight that we're taking in the data to data
- 34:48has we have preferences for data?
- 34:51And we don't take in the data that we don't like that.
- 34:54We don't have a preference for. In fact, we become almost
- 34:57aversive to it. We're only collecting the stuff.
- 35:00So that we like and the In This, Very curated cherry-picked
- 35:04sampling of what's there. We create an experience of
- 35:08reality from that. And if we don't constantly
- 35:13undertake challenging, the way that we create, that we can
- 35:16easily fall into the belief that what we've created is accurate,
- 35:22And that we can then understand our motivations based on our
- 35:27accurate perception of things and assign meaning to other
- 35:30peoples and actions and create an understanding of their
- 35:35motivations, which may or may not be what's actually
- 35:39happening. But because we don't because the
- 35:43habit of creating the solid sense of self and world is so
- 35:47great that we don't see into the nature.
- 35:52Of how we make things in each moment making sense.
- 35:59One of the, these insights that we want you to have, is that you
- 36:03really do assemble things, and make them up, and that you can
- 36:07make them, particularly, if you're cited, and you have a
- 36:10visual experience of things can become very compelling,
- 36:16particularly when you add to it, all of the stuff that reinforces
- 36:20your belief, in the version that you've created.
- 36:23If you touch, if you create a table and you touch the table on
- 36:27it and it and it has a hardness to it, that reinforces our image
- 36:31of it. If you have a cup and you put
- 36:33your hand on the the cup feels hard and you have a sense of
- 36:39this perception of the cup is actually accurate that making
- 36:44sense. Stacy.
- 36:50Thanks George. Following you I think but then
- 36:56it gets a little bit sticky and tricky.
- 37:00I know that if everything is like our perception and the spin
- 37:04that we put on things and what would you say to?
- 37:06Like what you said earlier about like growing up in a house with
- 37:11parents, that gaslighted you? So are you now saying that,
- 37:16that's just your Spin and the way that you saw things like Did
- 37:22they Gaslight you or not? That's the complication of
- 37:27gaslighting. Well, what do you see in this
- 37:34picture? San Pedro.
- 37:46And what color is it? Liu, why?
- 37:51Red brown. But if I were to that actually
- 37:54your perception that this is bluestack.
- 37:56Correct. It's not blue.
- 37:59I would be gaslighting you. It's not blue, it's purple.
- 38:03You can see very clearly, you mr.
- 38:05Fucker. How blue it is.
- 38:07All purple. And then when you begin to doubt
- 38:12your perception, that that's blue is when the gas lighting is
- 38:15having its effect of undermining Your Capacity to trust your
- 38:22perception of things. But do you make this into the
- 38:27new Auckland bridge and the old Oakland Bridge?
- 38:30Which let this is a picture of The Bay Area.
- 38:35You remember when they put the new Oakland Bridge up next to
- 38:39the old Oakland Bridge? Anybody hey, I remember that.
- 38:49Are any of you fans of Matisse? Do you have a disease?
- 38:56These little elements here that are actually boats on water.
- 39:03Or houses on the hillside. What do you think?
- 39:06Those are? They remind you of the way that
- 39:09Matisse paints wallpaper in his paintings.
- 39:15What are the association's when I first saw this?
- 39:17I thought it was very Matisse Ian because these reminded me of
- 39:20the wallpaper patterns that he painted in some of the paintings
- 39:26that did they liked it because there but TC and quality in my
- 39:32mind, what does it happen in your mind?
- 39:34They look meaning. Do you make of it?
- 39:35They look like floating spaceships in a cartoon.
- 39:42That's my first impression that keep pretty close to mine.
- 39:45Good. It was pretty tough steer
- 39:48somebody else. Yeah yeah I was thinking about
- 39:52The Great Gazoo that was that was a little flight of fancy.
- 39:59Huh. But this.
- 40:07That's not Matisse. That's not Van, Gogh.
- 40:17It's the Santa Monica Pier. Yeah.
- 40:22It's the big water next to the Golden Gate Bridge.
- 40:26Oh, these trees. That's a beautiful one.
- 40:50This image. I really like this image because
- 40:53it looks like the visual field. When you don't fixate it please.
- 40:57This is my experience of what the visual field looks like you
- 41:01don't fixate it. It's just pixelated dots of
- 41:05color. That's la.
- 41:18So how do you handle this one? Now that you have been looking
- 41:21at them, you recognize this tree is the same but can you carry
- 41:25this line of bushes all the way across and create a wider
- 41:29landscape? And you add this part of the
- 41:35picture to this part of the picture.
- 41:37So that you, you merge them and create a wider image of the two
- 41:41images together. How do you create visual
- 41:44experience? There we go. so, In my
- 42:01experiment. Was anybody able to have the
- 42:06experience of Taj upon a naughty experience of the mind checking?
- 42:15The questioning of what the visual experience that you've
- 42:18created is for, as the Habit energy of just fixating and
- 42:23making things solid. I think I was frequently wrote
- 42:28there in a couple of fixation possibilities, you know, second
- 42:33cycle for not another like breathing in and out.
- 42:39Good. So now the exercise is to take
- 42:43that recognition of what that investigation is and begin to
- 42:48make it the Habit that you're constantly.
- 42:50Checking the way that you've created the experience that
- 42:53you're having is an accurate reflection of the experience,
- 42:57that's there. Rather than relying on the Mind,
- 43:01simply fixating it with the habit of selecting things and
- 43:04making it based on the preferences, an active inquiry,
- 43:10really than a passivity of just being in the way that the Mind
- 43:15manufactures, things moment. That's what the awakened mind is
- 43:21doing. It's constantly evaluating that
- 43:25the way that you're experiencing things is actually the
- 43:28experience that's there. Makes sense, you're not relying
- 43:34on it, not passive in the way that you experience things.
- 43:45Make sense. Well, it seems like the ultimate
- 43:50in insecurities. Why if you have to continue to
- 44:00check. If you're talking about
- 44:04relationships, saying you have to keep on checking if your
- 44:07friend is reliable. I mean, that's kind of a little
- 44:13little example but if You're talking about having to check
- 44:19everything all the time. That's to me, that's the
- 44:22ultimate and insecurity you can't you can't fixate on
- 44:25anything because anything could be different than what you
- 44:27perceive it to be. Right, that's the ground was
- 44:32grown. How do you come into a place
- 44:35where you could be in Equanimity with that?
- 44:37The, the nature of the true nature of the experience that
- 44:41you have. Without it producing a sense of
- 44:44insecurity. Keep practicing.
- 44:54You know the answer to that question, such a good question,
- 44:58hard practices, the heart. Well, The fact of the matter is,
- 45:07if we can have these things called facts is that you're
- 45:11making it up in the same process, whether you rely on the
- 45:16image or you keep checking it. It's this reliability is
- 45:20unchanged. That making sense.
- 45:26In one way, you're accepting the way that it is an operating in a
- 45:30skillful way in relationship to that an.
- 45:33In another way, you're relying on a false sense of security to
- 45:38feel safe. Where is the safety in the
- 45:42actively? Checking comes from the actively
- 45:44checking and the experience of safety in the not checking comes
- 45:49from the not checking. Helpful.
- 45:56There isn't a less of a sense of safety in the, in the checking.
- 46:04And actually, what can happen, of course, is that you can
- 46:07constantly be goal. Correcting in relationship to
- 46:10what's happening. Can you be checking for the
- 46:17groundless ground? This is nothing to stand on,
- 46:23right? So that the creation of a solid
- 46:26world that you think is an accurate representation is,
- 46:28again, something that you can't stand on, it's a fabrication.
- 46:33So then, what is one checking for when when it's a fabrication
- 46:40and it's groundless, it's a groundless ground we're checking
- 46:44whether the fabrication that you've just made about the
- 46:47experience of the moment actually resembles. is the
- 46:52experience of the present moment.
- 46:56It isn't that there is into present moment is that there
- 46:58isn't an experience, it isn't. There's no meaning.
- 47:04It's that you interpreted based on your conditioning.
- 47:09And you want to evaluate whether or not, they conditioning is
- 47:14affecting the way that you understand what's happening.
- 47:19Yeah, we're meaning making machines.
- 47:21I realize that, but Where do we find any thing beyond that?
- 47:27If we're doing the checking, if it's all fabrication.
- 47:31Like what are we standing on? You're not standing on anything.
- 47:38We're floating. we're floating in our fix, a turn-on fixating
- 47:47of the experience that were having So attachment
- 47:51non-attachment in Buddhist terms means that you attach the
- 47:54particular sensing experience and you fixated in particular
- 47:57way. You cannot attach to it not
- 48:02fixated and then reattach Andre fixated in a different way.
- 48:07So we move one way. I like to say, we move from this
- 48:11dance of this is what's going on because I'm having this
- 48:14experience to, this is what I'm experiencing.
- 48:17This is what I think is going on.
- 48:19What do you think is going on? What's your experience of what's
- 48:22Happening? So that we're in a constant
- 48:24dialogue with the people that were in relationship to
- 48:28exchanging our interpretations of what's actually happening.
- 48:32And in some sense it reaching the experience because their
- 48:36perception of what's happening is going to be different from
- 48:38ours, because their conditioning is different from ours.
- 48:40They're going to be creating a different experience.
- 48:43So if we talk about the image of the new Auckland bridge in the
- 48:48old Oakland Bridge, When we got into the specific details of
- 48:53what the elements of the picture, where they were quite
- 48:56different person to person, there wasn't a uniform.
- 49:01Experience of it and it's in that exchange that we find this
- 49:08richness of intimacy that making sense.
- 49:12Ash. Yeah, I so what I think is
- 49:17happening, will you let me know if I'm closer wrong?
- 49:25I feel like you're presenting a really nuanced thing that I've
- 49:30heard explained and sort of much more Brash terms and other like
- 49:38at other times maybe even by you and I'm just like, I don't know
- 49:43if that's accurate. Ureter, something like I'm
- 49:46missing know, I teach this all the time in words but I often
- 49:51wonder whether people have the experience that I'm talking
- 49:54about are there just understanding it intellectually,
- 49:56okay? So what I wanted was to see if
- 49:59we could if I could create a a way that you could have the
- 50:04experience of watching your own mind, do this and understanding
- 50:09that that's the experience that we really need to reinforce.
- 50:14And pay attention to the constant checking of how we
- 50:20create the experience that we're having.
- 50:23Well, you're doing it carrying on.
- 50:25Don't mind me Christian. George what you're describing is
- 50:33really interesting because it, it to me, I think I get it.
- 50:38But also when I kind of stay in this groundlessness this like
- 50:42I'm fixated - it can have a very dissociative flavor to me,
- 50:49because I think I used to dissociate quite a bit and so it
- 50:54sometimes when I'm cutting it too long or like once in a
- 50:59while, if I take like some shrooms or something, I can get
- 51:03in theory, it can be very scary and be certainly.
- 51:08And the, I mean, the interesting thing about the shrooms is
- 51:11coming out of that experience and then the the world sort of
- 51:14coming back together and you piecing it back together and you
- 51:17going, oh, like all of this is kind of made up, which is the
- 51:24just something that a high person would say.
- 51:26But but is also True. So I guess I'm curious about how
- 51:33to explore it with the with the fear coming up, you know, or
- 51:39like what the line between dissociation and this kind of
- 51:43experience is, if that makes sense.
- 51:46Maybe that's really particular to my to my experience.
- 51:50Well, I think the use of psychedelics is meant to create
- 51:54the insight into the nature. That things are not solid that
- 51:57your version isn't the only version that you can make more
- 52:01than one version out of the same experience.
- 52:03That's the whole Gateway aspect of psychedelics.
- 52:08The problem with psychedelics that you're describing is you
- 52:13can create a fearful experience of that and because the the mind
- 52:18is altered not have control over, whether you can come out
- 52:22of the experience or not when you do it from a meditation
- 52:27perspective. It's much easier to control the
- 52:31fixating and Loving fixating and dissolving where you can
- 52:35actually get quite good at good simply fixating everything.
- 52:40When you need a sense of solid self and world when you need to
- 52:44interact on that level, but then when you don't not fixate it and
- 52:49just let it be soft is the way that I like to put it.
- 52:53The world is always kind of soft.
- 52:55It never really hardens in the way that that habit energy of
- 52:59fixating fixes. So you're always sort of moving
- 53:02in and out. A out of the fixated world into
- 53:04the flowing world. And then you get used to it yet.
- 53:10She continues to say, you don't understand this, you acclimatize
- 53:13to it. You get used to the way that
- 53:16this is how it really is not the other, which is that was
- 53:20actually not that accurate terms of how it is.
- 53:25Right. I guess in, I mean in my case I
- 53:29had these experiences dissociating even before any
- 53:32psychedelics so we'll disturbing part was that it would be like
- 53:37it was because of trauma, but our that's I guess my narrative
- 53:41about it. But the disturbing part, is, it
- 53:44would be a very discontinuous intrusion of this, kind of sense
- 53:51of unreality into what was a very fixated World in that.
- 53:55As I think the disturbing part and so as I kind of my
- 54:00meditation practice, I think I realized, oh, I'd associate
- 54:04quite a bit and that's not a great strategy for me, you know.
- 54:10So look, I like to be in a less dissociated world.
- 54:12So coming into this kind of practice, I guess how do I
- 54:18approach that less fixated view without without the sort of
- 54:23baggage of previous fierce. But let's also point out that
- 54:27what I'm asking you to do is the opposite of dissociation, I'm
- 54:31asked you to come fully into the experience of the present moment
- 54:35and not too excited, whereas in dissociation were withdrawing
- 54:39from the sensitivity of the world further and further away
- 54:41from it so that it's quite muted.
- 54:44You know, you'd withdraw the more you the more difficult the
- 54:48present moment is and if dissociation is the answer to
- 54:51that you withdraw more and more from an, until the experience of
- 54:54it is very indistinct, here is the opposite.
- 54:58You're pushing into the experience of the present moment
- 55:01as fully as you can and not fixating so that you allow the
- 55:08mind to play with the elements of the image, in form it into a
- 55:11particular View and then form it into a different particular
- 55:14View. And so that you get into the
- 55:17habit of making the views and check questioning them and then
- 55:21remaking them, questioning them and remaking.
- 55:24So that you're constantly in the experience of the present moment
- 55:28as its unfolding rather than but can often happen.
- 55:31When you fixate something is that you move out of the
- 55:34experience of the present moment and the stimulus of the present
- 55:37moment into the conditioned experience and then you're
- 55:41actually responding to what's already happened, not to the
- 55:45conditions of the present moment and then they are limited to the
- 55:49expectations of the outcomes that have already happened
- 55:51rather than open to the full range.
- 55:54Range of possibility that exists in the present moment.
- 55:58I'm making sense. So it's very easy when you
- 56:00solidify the world, you fixate the world to slip out of the
- 56:05experience of the present moment into the condition fixation of
- 56:09the world. And then in some sense replay,
- 56:13what's already happened, rather than being present for all of
- 56:18the options that are available. Now, the reason we get into this
- 56:22samsaric repetition because we're not actually in the
- 56:27present moment we're in the, the creation that we've made the
- 56:32conceptual reality and we attach all of the limitations of things
- 56:37that we've already experienced to the present moment and then
- 56:42all of the other possibilities are lost to us because we don't
- 56:45see them represented because we're not in the experience, any
- 56:49longer of the present moment but in in the, the construct of the
- 56:53Mind Is Made, That helping her making it worse.
- 57:00It's just thought it's interesting.
- 57:02I'll have to explore it more like because I it makes me and
- 57:06maybe this is a different concept.
- 57:08It kind of makes me think of when you describe a maybe a
- 57:12maybe it was shinzen or like these kind of no self States
- 57:17worth over. Like, you're not, you're not
- 57:21creating memories in these states, right?
- 57:23Are you like, what is the quality of awareness that you
- 57:27will take out of that moment and be able to reflect on?
- 57:32It depends how to how dissolve the self status.
- 57:35This usually memories are associated with the self State
- 57:39and not men, not with the not-self state.
- 57:42So if there's some, but most of the time for householders, it's
- 57:45not a complete absence of self State, and a completely fixated
- 57:50self stated some sort of dimmer rather than an on/off switch, is
- 57:53how I like to put it. So you can operate an example
- 58:00would be you play the violin. Do you ever get so concentrated
- 58:03at the music that you're going that the sense of self
- 58:06completely disappears. Yeah and then you come to the
- 58:09end of the piece but you don't have any recall really of each
- 58:12moment of playing the piece. Because there was no self there
- 58:18to monitor. And remember, it was simply the
- 58:21activity of doing it. Right?
- 58:24Yeah, you wouldn't be able to get through it.
- 58:26Really, if you had a strong sense of self the whole time, it
- 58:30would get in the ring because you'd be a half a second behind.
- 58:36You have to get into the flow. So the more that you're in the
- 58:38Flow State, the less strong, the experience is specific
- 58:44experience of it. You may remember the whole
- 58:46thing, but the individual elements are not so readily
- 58:51rememberable. And you notice the time is quite
- 58:58elastic. many, many minutes can go by and those High
- 59:04concentration flow States and there's no discomfort there's no
- 59:07anything because the sense of time is gone And then sometimes
- 59:13it's you know, I remember when I first started doing the pasta
- 59:17medicine, I would sit down and I would white-knuckle, as long as
- 59:22I could possibly stand to sit there with my eyes closed.
- 59:26And I would open my eyes and three minutes would have gone
- 59:29by, and I could not believe that was possible that the experience
- 59:35could be so intensely, awful and seemed like, it had gone on
- 59:39forever and it only be 3 minutes.
- 59:42It's but I would close my eyes and I would white-knuckle it as
- 59:46long as I possibly could. And then I would open my eyes
- 59:49and it would be another two minutes.
- 59:56The sense of the afflictive self experience was so intense to be
- 1:00:00with for that long. Now, we do for our sits as a
- 1:00:07routine on the Retreats, right? So everything can change way.
- 1:00:15This is the first time we've actually talked all the way
- 1:00:18through the meditation period. So that's kind of exciting that
- 1:00:23it actually was something that had that kind of residence.
- 1:00:33Anyway, I was I think because I'm primarily a visual learner
- 1:00:37and the the auditory stuff is harder for me.
- 1:00:40That it is that I thought I would try and make something
- 1:00:42that would be for visual Learners.
- 1:00:46So that's what this book is about really trying to learn
- 1:00:50that specific Insight by looking at pictures.
- 1:01:01Any questions about all of that? Maybe we'll wrap up a little
- 1:01:04early. What do you think?
- 1:01:10You're good. Not to sit.
- 1:01:11Or do you want to sit for 10 minutes?
- 1:01:15Sit for 10 minutes. Yeah, okay.
- 1:01:21Metaphor self. How's that?
- 1:01:25It will end the meditation period there.
- 1:01:27I'm continuously stunned by how the software filters out?
- 1:01:33The sound of the Bell. So, completely that you don't
- 1:01:35hear it but no, I rang it really loud.
- 1:01:42Could you relate that to touch touch upon naughty?
- 1:01:45You can because I'm having the experience of bashing the bell
- 1:01:49and I'm looking at all of your faces, completely undisturbed
- 1:01:59Took me a while to figure out that you were to hearing the
- 1:02:01bell. I just thought.
- 1:02:04Oh, they're so deeply embedded, Tatian, that they're just going
- 1:02:07to continue sitting even though the Bell has rung.
- 1:02:12So, thank you for coming. Let's see what's happening the
- 1:02:16last day of the What are those two things Hesh?
- 1:02:24Yeah let me know on Zoom. You can change your audio
- 1:02:29settings to sample for full range of audio.
- 1:02:33It's 100 usually for musicians because it captures subtle
- 1:02:36sounds. You could do that or you can
- 1:02:39share audio and just play a clip of a bell.
- 1:02:42They do that on some Retreats. Okay, good help you with either
- 1:02:47if you like So Saturday is the fourth day of the level 1 series
- 1:02:52that we're doing, and then we're starting a level 2 in.
- 1:02:57February think on the 16th will do another level 1 Series in
- 1:03:01March, we're actually going to do a an EU level 1 in April.
- 1:03:08So Central European Time For Us locally, it will be five in the
- 1:03:14morning until 9:00 in the morning, but on the East Coast,
- 1:03:24it'll be respectable 8 a.m. And then we'll do another level
- 1:03:32to toward the summer. All of that stuff is on the
- 1:03:36website. I'm planning to go to attract in
- 1:03:40June and teacher Retreat. There that's also on the website
- 1:03:44if you happen to want to go to Europe for something.
- 1:03:51I think that's, that's what's coming up in the next few
- 1:03:54months. I offer this teaching on a
- 1:03:57database's, Don is the Pali word for generosity but I do that.
- 1:04:02Hope you'll make a donation. If you can there's a link to do
- 1:04:05it on the website, it does support me.
- 1:04:08And also the the work that better group is doing really
- 1:04:11appreciate your practice. Thanks for coming.
- 1:04:13And I hope to see you soon somewhere on the path by