Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 41: Ceasefire Fractures | Israel Strikes Lebanon, Hormuz Dispute, Islamabad Talks Loom
Transcript
- 0:16The cease-fire is less than 24 hours old, and it is already
- 0:20fracturing. Israel launched its largest
- 0:22coordinated strike on Lebanon since this war began, killing at
- 0:26least 182 people and wounding hundreds more.
- 0:30Iran's IRGC responded by claiming it had halted oil
- 0:33tanker traffic through the Strait of Hormuz.
- 0:36The White House denied the Strait was closed and JD Vance
- 0:40called the ceasefire A fragile truce from Budapest, where he
- 0:43was briefing allies before flying to Islamabad.
- 0:46It is Wednesday, April 9th, 2026, day 41 of operation in
- 0:51epic Fury. The ceasefire is in place.
- 0:55The guns have largely paused over Iran.
- 0:57All markets are recovering. Iranians who celebrated in the
- 1:01streets of Tehran on Tuesday night woke on Wednesday to news
- 1:05of Lebanon burning and the straight contested again.
- 1:08The most important diplomatic process of this war is about to
- 1:11begin in Pakistan. But every element of the
- 1:14agreement is already being contested, reinterpreted or
- 1:18challenged, depending on who you ask.
- 1:20And the ceasefire is less than a day old.
- 1:22This is episode 41 of Epic Fury, the US Iran War podcast.
- 1:28Follow on Spotify and Apple Podcast to stay with this story
- 1:31as it develops. Let's get into it.
- 1:34Start with Lebanon. Because it is the fault line
- 1:37that could collapse the ceasefire before Islamabad even
- 1:40begins. And because what happened on
- 1:42Wednesday morning was not a minor irritant or a
- 1:44misunderstanding. It was the single most serious
- 1:47test the ceasefire has faced, and it arrived within hours of
- 1:50the agreement being signed. Israel launched what the IDF
- 1:54described as its largest coordinated strike on Lebanon
- 1:57since the war began overnight on Wednesday local time.
- 2:01The Lebanese Health Ministry confirmed at least 182 killed
- 2:04and hundreds wounded, adding to a Lebanon death toll that had
- 2:08already exceeded 1500 before the ceasefire was announced.
- 2:12The IDF said it struck Hezbollah targets including
- 2:15infrastructure, weapon storage and command facilities in
- 2:18southern Lebanon and the Beirut suburbs.
- 2:21The strikes represent Israel exercising the freedom of action
- 2:24it had explicitly reserved when Netanyahu said Lebanon was not
- 2:28included in the ceasefire. Israel is not wrong, legally or
- 2:32militarily, to argue that Hezbollah remains a threat and
- 2:35that the ceasefire with Iran does not obligate Israel to stop
- 2:38defending itself in Lebanon. But the moral and strategic
- 2:42weight of launching the conflicts deadliest Lebanon
- 2:44strikes in the immediate hours after a ceasefire announcement,
- 2:48while the world's attention was focused on the relief in the
- 2:50diplomacy is a choice that will be scrutinized.
- 2:53The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Volcker Turk
- 2:56condemned the strikes, saying such carnage defies belief.
- 3:00He said the scale the killing and destruction in Lebanon today
- 3:04is nothing sure of horrific. He added that the strikes,
- 3:07coming within hours of a ceasefire agreement with Iran,
- 3:10place enormous pressure on a fragile peace which is so
- 3:14desperately needed by civilians. Iran's IRGC responded swiftly.
- 3:19It announced that oil tanker traffic through the Strait of
- 3:22Hormuz had been stopped, citing the Israeli strikes on Lebanon
- 3:26as a ceasefire violation. Iran's ambassador to Pakistan,
- 3:30Reza Miri Mogadam, said parts of Iran's proposal had been
- 3:34violated before the Islamabad talks had even begun.
- 3:37The speaker of Iran's parliament made a similar allegation.
- 3:41The IRGC statement was a direct invocation of Iran's 10 point
- 3:45proposal, which includes a necessity of ending the war
- 3:48against all components of the resistance axis, meaning
- 3:51Hezbollah. The White House immediately
- 3:53pushed back. Press Secretary Caroline Levitt
- 3:56said the reports of Iran closing the Strait were completely
- 3:59unacceptable and call them false.
- 4:01Defense Secretary Hegseth told a press briefing the Strait is
- 4:05open, Joint Chiefs Chairman General Dan Kane said.
- 4:09I believe so, based on the diplomatic negotiation.
- 4:12Levitt added that Trump wants to straight open immediately
- 4:16without limitation, including tolls, a direct rebuttal of
- 4:19Iran's plan to charge transit fees during the ceasefire.
- 4:23The problem is that both sides are correct about the factual
- 4:25situation and both sides are wrong about the legal situation.
- 4:30Israel did strike Lebanon. The UN confirmed it.
- 4:34The death toll is real. Iran's 10 point proposal does
- 4:38include Lebanon, but the Trump administration explicitly told
- 4:42Israel before the ceasefire was announced that Lebanon was not
- 4:45included. Netanyahu's office confirmed
- 4:48that explicitly. Pakistan's Prime Minister Sharif
- 4:52said Lebanon was included. He announced the ceasefire.
- 4:55All four of those statements are simultaneously on the record.
- 4:59The Lebanon question was not resolved before the ceasefire
- 5:02was announced. It was papered over senior U.S.
- 5:06officials, speaking privately, acknowledged to multiple news
- 5:09organizations that the Lebanon carve out was a deliberate
- 5:12ambiguity, a concession to Israel's insistence that it
- 5:15retain freedom of action against Hezbollah dressed in language
- 5:19that was vague enough for Pakistan to present to Iran as a
- 5:22comprehensive ceasefire. That is the architecture of a
- 5:25diplomatic fudge, not a diplomatic resolution.
- 5:29Fudges of this kind can hold when the underlying parties have
- 5:32a shared interest in pretending they don't see the
- 5:34contradiction. They collapse when one party
- 5:37like the IRGC decides to act on what was actually written rather
- 5:41than what was diplomatically implied.
- 5:44And on Day 41, the IRGC is acted.
- 5:47And on Day 41, that paper has already torn.
- 5:51VP Vance, speaking to reporters in Budapest on his way to
- 5:54Islamabad, said if Iran wants to let this negotiation fall apart
- 5:58in a conflict where they were getting hammered over Lebanon,
- 6:01which has nothing to do with them, and which the United
- 6:03States never once said was part of the ceasefire, that is
- 6:06ultimately their choice. He added that fundamentally, we
- 6:10are in a good spot. They are reopening the straits,
- 6:14we have a ceasefire, and frankly, if they break their end
- 6:18of the bargain, they're going to see some serious consequences.
- 6:22That framing that Lebanon has nothing to do with Iran is not a
- 6:25position that any Iranian government of any political
- 6:29stripe could accept publicly. Iran created Hezbollah in 1982.
- 6:34It has funded, armed, trained and directed Hezbollah for four
- 6:38decades. It has described Hezbollah as
- 6:41part of the axis of resistance that constitutes Iran's primary
- 6:44strategic deterrent against Israel.
- 6:47Telling Tehran that Hezbollah's fate has nothing to do with Iran
- 6:50is not a negotiating position. It is a declaration of the gap
- 6:54between the two sides that the Islamabad talks will need to
- 6:57bridge. The question is whether Vance,
- 6:59Witkoff and Kushner understand that the path to a durable
- 7:02nuclear settlement runs through a Lebanon arrangement and
- 7:05whether they have the authority from Trump to negotiate. 1
- 7:08Despite the Irgc's halt announcement, ship tracking data
- 7:12told a more complex story. Marine Traffic confirmed that
- 7:15two vessels the Greek owned in Jay Earth and the Liberia flag
- 7:19Daytona Beach, had transited the Strait of Hormuz overnight since
- 7:22the ceasefire was announced. Both were bulk carriers carrying
- 7:26dry cargo, not oil tankers. Overall, traffic through the
- 7:30waterway had not picked up beyond the slow trickle scene
- 7:33throughout the war. Before the war, between 100 and
- 7:37120 commercial vessels transited the straight daily shipping.
- 7:41Executives were blunt, 1 executive with boats currently
- 7:45stuck in the Persian Gulf told CNBC.
- 7:47We have no information about how we could transit the Strait of
- 7:50Hormuz during the ceasefire. We are not in contact with
- 7:54Iranian authorities. The most important thing for us
- 7:58is the safety of our crew members.
- 8:00If we were deciding to transit, we need absolute guarantees
- 8:04about the safety of our crew members.
- 8:06That statement captures the practical reality of the
- 8:09ceasefire's most immediate economic test.
- 8:12The oil market fell 13% on Tuesday night on the news of the
- 8:15ceasefire. If the straight does not begin
- 8:18flowing with oil within days, that relief will partially
- 8:22reverse. Roberto Janetta, chairman of the
- 8:24Hong Kong Liner Shipping Association, was also blunt.
- 8:28If he were a ship owner or operator stuck in the Persian
- 8:30Gulf, he would wait a few days to see how the US, Israel and
- 8:34Iran respond to the ceasefire. If it looks likely to be
- 8:37sticking, he said he might try moving vessels in the second
- 8:40week or in a cluster or convoy with other ships.
- 8:44Tim Huxley, chairman of Mandarin Shipping, said it is too early
- 8:48to tell. He noted that for sure, some
- 8:50ships will now exit the area, but it remains tense.
- 8:54Underwriters describe the truce as a positive development
- 8:56overall, but one that carries a number of risks, including a
- 8:59lack of clarity over which Iranian authority is in charge
- 9:03of approving transit. That last point, which Iranian
- 9:06authority is the ceasefire's entire practical problem in
- 9:10microcosm. Vance said Wednesday that the
- 9:12administration saw an uptick in traffic, adding they think
- 9:16they're seeing signs the Straight is starting to reopen.
- 9:19Hours later, Iran announced it had stopped tanker traffic again
- 9:23over Lebanon. The market, watching all of this
- 9:25in real time, is trying to price in a ceasefire that is
- 9:28simultaneously being announced as open and closed by different
- 9:32authorities in different capitals.
- 9:34The Islamabad talks are where the answers must come from.
- 9:38Trump confirmed Wednesday that the US negotiating team will be
- 9:41led by Vice President JD Vance with special envoy Steve Witkoff
- 9:46and Jared Kushner. The talks are scheduled to begin
- 9:49Saturday morning Islamabad local time, not Friday as originally
- 9:53announced. That one day delay is worth
- 9:56noting. In the context of a fragile
- 9:58ceasefire already under strain from the Lebanon strikes and the
- 10:01Hormones disagreement, a 24 hour delay in getting the delegations
- 10:05to the table is not reassuring. The composition of the American
- 10:09delegation is itself a statement about what Washington is
- 10:12prioritizing. JD Vance leading the delegation
- 10:15is an extraordinary deployment of the Vice President of the
- 10:18United States on a bilateral diplomatic mission.
- 10:21It signals that Trump regards this as potentially the most
- 10:24consequential diplomatic process of his second term.
- 10:28Steve Witkoff has been involved in every major Middle East
- 10:31negotiation of the Trump administration.
- 10:33Jared Kushner's presence as a direct family link to Trump that
- 10:37no other envoy can provide. His word carries presidential
- 10:40authority in a way that career diplomats words do not.
- 10:43Whether this team can navigate the nuclear question, the
- 10:46sanctions question, the reparations demand and the
- 10:49Lebanon dispute in the time available is the defining
- 10:52question of the next 10 days. Whether the delay reflects
- 10:55logistical scheduling or a diplomatic complication relating
- 10:58to the Hormuz and Lebanon disputes is not confirmed.
- 11:01But the timing is uncomfortable. Trump added his own commentary
- 11:05on Wednesday with a characteristically optimistic
- 11:08social media post. He said big money will be made.
- 11:12Iran can start the reconstruction process.
- 11:15He called the ceasefire a big day for World Peace.
- 11:18He finished with this could be the golden age of the Middle
- 11:21East. Those statements sit in unusual
- 11:24tension with what is actually happening on the ground.
- 11:26Lebanon burning, the straight status contested and Vance
- 11:30describing the ceasefire as fragile.
- 11:32The gap between Trump's social media framing and the
- 11:35operational reality of the first day of the ceasefire is not
- 11:39merely rhetorical. It reflects A genuine divergent
- 11:42within the American position itself between the maximalist
- 11:45optimism of the president and the more cautious assessment of
- 11:48his own vice president. At a Wednesday press conference,
- 11:52Trump was asked about uranium enrichment.
- 11:55His answer was the clearest public statement he has made on
- 11:57the nuclear question since the war began.
- 12:00There will be no enrichment of uranium and the United States
- 12:03will, working with Iran, dig up and remove all of the deeply
- 12:07buried nuclear dust. He was referencing the hardened
- 12:10underground facilities for Dow Natan's Others that USB-2
- 12:15bombers had struck with bunker busting munitions during the
- 12:17campaign. Trump's framing was that those
- 12:20sites must not merely be closed, but physically emptied of
- 12:23nuclear material with American involvement in the process.
- 12:27That is a significantly more specific and more demanding
- 12:30position than anything Trump has said publicly on a nuclear
- 12:33question during the 41 days of this war. 0 Enrichment, full
- 12:38removal of nuclear material, working with Iran on the removal
- 12:42process. That formula will be the
- 12:45centerpiece of whatever the Islamabad talks produce or fail
- 12:48to produce. Iran's 10 point proposal
- 12:51includes a formal endorsement of Iran's nuclear rights under the
- 12:54Non Proliferation Treaty, which explicitly gives NPT member
- 12:58states the right to enrich uranium for peaceful purposes.
- 13:02Iran has been an NPT member since 1970. 0 Enrichment versus
- 13:07the NPT right to enrich is not a bridgeable gap through creative
- 13:10language. It is a binary disagreement
- 13:13about whether Iran retains any nuclear program at all.
- 13:17How Vance, Witkoff and Kushner navigate that specific binary in
- 13:21Islamabad on Saturday will be the most consequential
- 13:24diplomatic moment of this entire conflict.
- 13:27Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer used Wednesday to
- 13:29deliver one of the most comprehensive Democratic
- 13:32critiques of the war yet. He said the conflict was one of
- 13:35the very worst military and foreign policy actions that the
- 13:38United States has ever taken. He argued the war left the US
- 13:42worse off in global credibility, left Iran's nuclear ambitions
- 13:46unchecked, increased gas prices, and handed Iran leverage over
- 13:49the Strait of Hormuz that it did not have before February 28th.
- 13:53His argument is pointed and politically significant that the
- 13:5740 Day War achieved the opposite of its stated objectives on
- 14:00several key dimensions. Iran's nuclear program was
- 14:04damaged but not destroyed. Iran's leverage over global oil
- 14:07markets was demonstrated rather than eliminated.
- 14:10The world now knows that Iran's control over Hormuz translates
- 14:14directly into a global energy crisis. 13 Americans are dead.
- 14:19373 more were wounded. The US spent 10s of billions of
- 14:24dollars and the United States is now negotiating an Islamabad on
- 14:28the basis of a 10 point Iranian proposal, which is to say on
- 14:32Iran's terms as a starting point, not its own 15 point
- 14:35framework. Iran expert try to Parsi offered
- 14:38a measured assessment. Trump's failed use of force has
- 14:41blunted the credibility of American military threats.
- 14:44The terrain has shifted, he said, but he added that the
- 14:47Islamabad talks could still fail.
- 14:50Schumer announced that Senate Democrats will force another war
- 14:53powers vote when Congress returns.
- 14:56The war powers fight did not produce a result before the
- 14:59ceasefire. Whether it produces 1 during the
- 15:01ceasefire window or whether the Islamabad process renders it
- 15:05moot is one of several domestic political questions that date 41
- 15:09leaves unresolved. China's involvement in the
- 15:12ceasefire negotiations was confirmed by the White House on
- 15:15Wednesday. Press Secretary Levitt confirmed
- 15:18Chinese participation in the truce negotiations with Iran.
- 15:21This is the first official American acknowledgement that
- 15:24Beijing played a role in producing the ceasefire, a
- 15:27significant admission given that China had publicly condemned the
- 15:30war throughout its 40 days. China's position throughout this
- 15:34conflict has been to condemn the military operations while
- 15:37maintaining its economic relationships with Iran and
- 15:39continuing to import Iranian oil through the Strait of Hormuz at
- 15:43concessional rates. China receives roughly 1/3 of
- 15:46its oil through the Strait and peacetime.
- 15:49The Strait's closure has cost Beijing billions of dollars and
- 15:52disrupted supply chains that its economy depends on.
- 15:56Its emergence as a backstage facilitator of the ceasefire,
- 15:59alongside Pakistan's frontline mediation, reflects the reality
- 16:02that the countries with the most economic exposure to the war's
- 16:05continuation, China and Pakistan, ultimately had more
- 16:09leverage over Iran's decision to accept the ceasefire than the
- 16:12countries doing the bombing. That is a diplomatic observation
- 16:15that will shape how the world's major powers interpret their
- 16:18role in Islamabad process and the broader regional settlement
- 16:22that must follow the IDF Strikes on Lebanon and the Hormuz
- 16:25dispute were not the only complications on Day 41.
- 16:29Kuwait and the UAE both reported fresh Iranian drone attacks
- 16:33involving dozens of drones on Wednesday.
- 16:36The IRGC appear to be operating on a different instruction set
- 16:39than Iran's Supreme National Security Council, which have
- 16:42confirmed the ceasefire. This is the command and control
- 16:45problem that analysts had warned about since the ceasefire was
- 16:48first announced. The IRGC, which has run the
- 16:51military campaign autonomously throughout the war, does not
- 16:54automatically stand down because a political body in Tehran
- 16:57issues a ceasefire statement. The IRGC has its own operational
- 17:02timelines, its own targeting logic and, as the Posseski and
- 17:05Vahidi Exchange made clear weeks ago, its own relationship with
- 17:09the civilian government that has been characterized more by
- 17:12exclusion and coordination. Whether the Irgc's continued
- 17:15attacks on Gulf states represent a deliberate message to the
- 17:18Supreme National Security Council about the limits of its
- 17:21authority, a test of whether the ceasefire will hold under
- 17:24provocation or simply residual operations already in flight, is
- 17:28not confirmed. The practical effect is that
- 17:31Gulf states that have been hoping Wednesday morning would
- 17:33bring the first quiet night in six weeks instead spin and
- 17:36activating air defense systems again.
- 17:39For Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Kuwait, Qatar and Bahrain, none
- 17:43of them combatants, all of them damaged, the ceasefire has not
- 17:46yet produced a single quiet hour.
- 17:49The ceasefire's fundamental architecture is this a two week
- 17:52pause and bombing contingent on Hormuz reopening with
- 17:55negotiations in Islamabad. Everything else, the Lebanon
- 17:59question, the nuclear question, the sanctions question, the
- 18:02reparations question, the US military presence in the Gulf is
- 18:06unresolved. The two sides are heading to
- 18:08Islamabad to resolve all of it in two weeks.
- 18:11The gap between those objectives and the reality of what is
- 18:14actually happening on the ground on Day 41 is the widest it has
- 18:17been since the ceasefire was announced less than 24 hours
- 18:21ago. For the Islamabad talks to
- 18:23produce anything durable, they need to achieve, at minimum, the
- 18:26following a shared understanding between the US and Iran about
- 18:29what Lebanon status is during the ceasefire period.
- 18:32A concrete, verifiable mechanism for Hormuz to reopen and for oil
- 18:36to flow without Iranian imposed transit fees and without Iranian
- 18:40military coordination requirements that shipping
- 18:43companies cannot accept. And a framework for nuclear
- 18:45talks that gives Iran something it can describe to its domestic
- 18:50audience as acknowledgement of its status as a sovereign state,
- 18:53while giving the United States something it can describe as a
- 18:56verifiable constraint on Iran's nuclear program.
- 18:59None of those three things is easy.
- 19:01All three are necessary conditions for a ceasefire that
- 19:05lasts beyond two weeks. For Iran, the Islamabad talks
- 19:09represent the first time in 41 days that its civilian
- 19:12leadership, Karachi and the Foreign Ministry will help
- 19:15platform. Whether the IRGC will allow the
- 19:18civilian government to negotiate substantively or whether it will
- 19:22undercut the talks from the military side the same way it
- 19:25undercut possession throughout the war is the governance
- 19:27question that Pakistan's mediators cannot answer.
- 19:30For Tehran, there is an additional dimension that the
- 19:33ceasefire has not yet addressed. Iran's Supreme National Security
- 19:37Council claimed in its ceasefire statement that nearly all of the
- 19:40war's objectives have been achieved.
- 19:43That framing served a domestic political purpose.
- 19:45It allowed Common A to present the ceasefire as victory rather
- 19:49than surrender. But it also creates a problem
- 19:52for the Islamabad process. If the Iranian public has been
- 19:56told the war's objectives have been achieved, then any
- 19:59concession made in Islamabad on the nuclear question, the
- 20:02sanctions question or Hormuz governance will be presented
- 20:04domestically as a betrayal of that victory.
- 20:07Iran's negotiating position in Islamabad is constrained not
- 20:11only by the IRGC, but by the political narrative its own
- 20:14leadership created when it announced the ceasefire.
- 20:17The internal Iranian decision making structure that produced
- 20:20the ceasefire, apparently driven by Common A himself through the
- 20:24Supreme National Security Council, will need to remain
- 20:27coherent throughout the Islamabad process.
- 20:29History and the events of the past 41 days suggest that
- 20:33coherence is not guaranteed. The gap between Trump's social
- 20:36media framing of Day 41. Big money will be made.
- 20:40This could be the golden age of the Middle East and the ground
- 20:42reality of Lebanon under its heaviest strikes of the war.
- 20:46The IRGC continuing drone operations against Gulf states,
- 20:49the straight contested and Vance describing the ceasefire as
- 20:52fragile is not a minor rhetorical discrepancy.
- 20:56It is a substantive divergent about the state of the world
- 20:59that will create problems in Islamabad when Iran's delegation
- 21:02arrives on Saturday and is presented with an American
- 21:05counterpart whose president is publicly describing the golden
- 21:08age of the Middle East while 182 Lebanese are dead from Israeli
- 21:12strikes that began hours after the ceasefire was announced.
- 21:16The emotional and political distance between the two
- 21:18delegations will be considerable.
- 21:20Diplomacy can bridge distance. It cannot pretend the distance
- 21:24does not exist. If this podcast is helping you
- 21:27make sense of what is happening, please take 30 seconds to leave
- 21:31a review on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 21:34It makes an enormous difference to how many people find the
- 21:37show. This has been episode 41 of Epic
- 21:40Fury, the US Iran war podcast Day 41.
- 21:44The ceasefire is fragile. Lebanon is burning.
- 21:48The Strait is contested. The IRGC is still flying drones
- 21:53over Gulf states. Vance is flying to Islamabad.
- 21:57The nuclear question is starkly framed.
- 22:00And the two week clock that will determine whether this pause
- 22:02becomes peace or resumes as war began ticking less than 24 hours
- 22:07ago. We will be back very soon.