Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Camp Thunderbird Gate Fight And A 15-Year Lawsuit Over A Supposed Public Road
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment joined by character and collector with Mulligan Defense Lawyer.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: In fact, Michael Muller.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Good afternoon, Michael.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: I'm doing great.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: What's on our agenda for today?
- 0:15Michael Mulligan: Uh the first case on the agenda is a local one, uh, and it's a case that uh involves a dispute between the YMCA, YWCA, uh in Greater Victoria, uh, and uh two companies that uh own some property they want to install a what sounds like a cell phone antenna on.
- 0:32Michael Mulligan: Uh and this dispute uh involves uh property, a number of different parcels of property uh that uh are where Camp Thunderbird is located, right?
- 0:43Michael Mulligan: That that's where the uh Y's uh property is.
- 0:46Michael Mulligan: It's the Y's out the Y Outdoor Center in Camp Thunderbird.
- 0:49Michael Mulligan: Uh and the company that owns this other parcel of land um is sort of adjacent, and it sounds like further in from where the road is out there.
- 0:59Michael Mulligan: Um and the uh Camp Thunderbird, the Y, uh has installed a gate uh some time ago uh that uh controls access to the property.
- 1:10Michael Mulligan: Um and they uh require you know somebody to identify themselves and so on before they can just drive into Camp Thunderbird uh and I guess in some way or other drive into this other piece of property owned by this company.
- 1:22Michael Mulligan: Now, the reason this is a dispute is all of these things go back a very long time.
- 1:27Michael Mulligan: Uh the YMCA has been operating that camp since about 1935.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: Uh and so this is long and historic, and the uh company that owns this other piece of property that's adjacent uh to it, and they want to pass through uh the wise land to get to it, what they're alleging in their claim is that they're claiming that there was a public road at one point that went through there and that they should be able to go through there, I guess, to put up their cell phone tower.
- 1:55Michael Mulligan: Um and they claim that this road was referred to uh either by two possible names, either Settlers Road, gives you an idea of maybe the age of it, or the Glints Lake Road.
- 2:06Michael Mulligan: Uh and they have an old map that seems to show a road there.
- 2:09Michael Mulligan: But uh there's gonna be much more to it in terms of is that a public road, what was the nature of it, where did that go to?
- 2:14Michael Mulligan: There are all kinds of questions.
- 2:16Michael Mulligan: Now, the immediate thing being dealt with in this case, dealt with two things.
- 2:21Michael Mulligan: First of all, this has been going on, not only the road issue, but the case for a very long time.
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: Uh and in fact, these companies started this claim against the Y back in December of 2010, if you can believe it.
- 2:34Michael Mulligan: Wow.
- 2:35Michael Mulligan: Uh more than 15 years ago.
- 2:37Michael Mulligan: And so they started this action suing the Y, and the Y responded to the civil claim in 2011.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: Didn't take that long.
- 2:44Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then there's this long history of things happening like originally it was scheduled for trial, I think originally sometime at like 2014 or 2013.
- 2:55Michael Mulligan: First trial date, 2012, and then the companies added the chosen in SUK as defendant, so the trial got adjourned.
- 3:01Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then they dropped those two people as defendants, so the trial got adjourned again.
- 3:06Michael Mulligan: Uh, and uh then uh the CRD got involved, it got adjourned again, and sort of on and on.
- 3:11Michael Mulligan: The thing's just been repeated, just gone on for a really long time.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: Uh the the Y alleged that part of the delay was caused by intentionally these companies kind of holding off on proceeding, hoping they could get access by clean getting mineral mining rights and then getting some road access that way, and then that they uh that didn't work out, so they were kind of back on to scheduling trial dates.
- 3:33Michael Mulligan: We're now on to, I think, the fifth trial date is scheduled for 2027, if you can believe it, more than 15 years later.
- 3:40Michael Mulligan: And so this the Y brought an application to have this claim dismissed for what's called want of prosecution.
- 3:49Michael Mulligan: Um and there's a bunch of law about that.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the first thing to know is that um the the rules of court, this is in the BC Supreme Court involving land, um, and the the rules of the Supreme Court include principles uh that, for example, the rules are in place to secure a just, speedy, and inexpensive determination of every proceed every proceeding on its merits.
- 4:10Michael Mulligan: And as they point out, there's tension between speedy and on its merits, right?
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: And that's always what sort of comes up in a case where you the thing isn't really moving along.
- 4:20Michael Mulligan: And then the other point to remember is that the obligation to, you know, get on with it in a civil case is borne by the plaintiff, the person who's asking for something, rather than the person who's defending the claim.
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: Kind of makes sense, right?
- 4:33Michael Mulligan: You're trying to get the court to do something, it's kind of your job to keep that thing moving.
- 4:37Michael Mulligan: Um and where there is a long delay, the courts have established sort of a uh intellectual framework to determine whether the delay is so long that it should not be allowed to continue.
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: Uh and it involves, first of all, whether the uh defendant, this case the why, could establish that the plaintiff's delay was inordinate, as language used, or is much too long.
- 5:00Michael Mulligan: And then if so, the plaintiff would have to show that the delay was uh whether the delay was excusable, and then finally, um whether it's in the interest of justice to allow the thing to continue.
- 5:11Michael Mulligan: Pretty broad test.
- 5:12Michael Mulligan: Now, the first of all, that first part of it, whether this delay was inordinate, uh, the judge didn't have too much trouble with that given that the total delay was fifteen years.
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: Uh and said, well, this, you know, there's some complexity to all of this, uh, but uh, you know, that just is clearly in that category of inordinate in terms of how long the delay is, just too long.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: Uh and then the uh companies that were suing then had to go on and say, okay, well, is that is the delay inexcusable?
- 5:42Michael Mulligan: Uh and say made various arguments to kind of excuse the delay, including, well, they changed lawyers at some point a couple of times, although that really wasn't blamed on it.
- 5:51Michael Mulligan: They threw in COVID as one of the reasons for delay, that's always a good one, right?
- 5:55Michael Mulligan: Uh, but the judge said, look, there was no specific evidence relating to how COVID had anything to do with anything, although yes, I guess it did occur in the last 15 years.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so they found that uh they hadn't uh man the plaintiffs hadn't managed to sort of overcome it on the basis of some explanation for the delay, like the courthouse burning down or you know, something like that.
- 6:15Michael Mulligan: Uh, and that when they get that far in the intellectual framework, it then creates a rebuttable presumption of prejudice.
- 6:21Michael Mulligan: Uh, and but then that brings on to that final test of whether it's like in the interest of justice to say that's it.
- 6:26Michael Mulligan: It's just too long, you can't continue here.
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: Um, and in that regard, there were some compelling potential uh reasons to suggest that, including, for example, uh the the Y had planned to call some witnesses uh that had like some firsthand experience with was there actually a road there?
- 6:44Michael Mulligan: Uh and they had managed to find somebody who I guess was like uh uh attended Camp Thunderbird back in the 1940s, um, who apparently was going to provide evidence that uh while there were hiking trails in and around there, there was no road capable of supporting vehicular traffic.
- 6:59Michael Mulligan: That fellow, unfortunately, went there in the 1940s, passed away in 2022.
- 7:04Michael Mulligan: And so that was an example of, hey, you know, we're prejudiced our ability to defend this thing.
- 7:08Michael Mulligan: The other side, the cell phone companies or wannabe cell phone uh installers, argued that, well, this is really going to amount to uh reviewing historical documents and maps to try to figure out whether this was a public road or or not.
- 7:22Michael Mulligan: Uh but ultimately it sounds like one of the things that the that has to be considered, there's law for this, is that another consideration is like, you know, how far along is the claim?
- 7:32Michael Mulligan: Is it just getting started or is it like almost ready to go to trial?
- 7:35Michael Mulligan: Now, appreciating that there have been a number of efforts to get this thing to trial, but there is a trial date set in 2027.
- 7:41Michael Mulligan: And the other thing that was significant for the judge, even though he found this just completely too long, um, is that um there's no limit there's no limitation period that prevents this claim from just being like filed again now.
- 7:55Michael Mulligan: And so if the judge struck this out on the basis that uh for want of prosecution, there'd be nothing stopping the cell phone company from just starting over again.
- 8:04Michael Mulligan: And so the judge goes to well, look, the thing's now set for trial in 2027.
- 8:08Michael Mulligan: You've taken way too long, but if I strike this thing out, y you could just start it again, and probably it would delay it further, right?
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: And it's not gonna, you know, so on that basis the judge denied the uh application by the Y to have this thing struck out for want of prosecution.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: But that wasn't the end of it because the cell phone uh comp cell phone tower installation companies um were also asking for a an injunction to get have the Y remove the gate in the interim, like until they have a hearing, they wanted it out, like an in-term injunction.
- 8:42Michael Mulligan: Uh and there's a test for that.
- 8:43Michael Mulligan: Uh I think we've talked about that before, in terms of whether there's irreparable harm, like harm you couldn't remedy with money, um, and a balance of convenience.
- 8:52Michael Mulligan: And on that regard, the Y produced like financial documents saying, hey, if you order a order us to pay something, we can pay it, right?
- 8:59Michael Mulligan: If there's some financial loss not having the cell phone tower up earlier.
- 9:03Michael Mulligan: But the final thing that the and this is another twist on that uh irreparable harm balance of convenience test, and it it has to do with cases where you're seeking a mandatory injunction which isn't to just stop doing something, but instead order you to positively go and do something.
- 9:21Michael Mulligan: Like in this case, go remove your gate, as opposed to just, you know, get off the road or you know, whatever, stop your behavior.
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: Uh and where you're order where you're at seeking in order that a party go and do something, uh there is a obligation now as well to show that you have a strong prima facie case.
- 9:42Michael Mulligan: And the judge wasn't satisfied that that was so, because even though there was some indication there was a road there, and uh even though for some portion of it the Y agreed that there was a road in some place, what they had agreed to would not even get the cell phone company where they want to go.
- 9:58Michael Mulligan: Like one of the other interesting issues here is if there was a public road, where did that road go to?
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: Uh and it might well not go to, even if there was a road, it might not get the cell phone company where they want to go.
- 10:10Michael Mulligan: Like maybe it leads to, you know, the the back of the Camp Thunderbird or something that doesn't get them where they're wanting to go.
- 10:17Michael Mulligan: And so, you know, yeah, you you got something to go on there, but it's not a case where, hey, look, this is you know, we're just gonna succeed, stop ragging the puck.
- 10:25Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then the other thing, which was I think a consideration for the judge, is that the fact there's a gate there is relatively meaningful, I guess, in terms of how Camp Thunderbird operates, so you don't have like everyone just driving into Camp Thunderbird.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: You know, they want to be able to control that, I guess, for the safety of the kids and people coming in there, coming and going, right?
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: You don't want it to be uh um uh on uh uncontrolled access to the camp.
- 10:48Michael Mulligan: So the judge dismissed both the application by the uh the Y to just get rid of this thing because it was too long, too, uh they'd taken too long, and dismissed the application for the mandatory uh injunction ordering them to remove the gate.
- 11:02Michael Mulligan: Uh and so all of that means that now, I guess after 16 or 17 years, assuming nobody else gets added or subtracted from the pleadings and nobody puts anything off again, in 2027, uh we'll have a I think now a 15-day trial is scheduled, uh at the end of which uh I guess we'll have a determination as to whether the uh whatever was there uh amounted to a public road, uh settlers road, and if so, where does that road go?
- 11:27Michael Mulligan: Uh and I guess it would be uh really ironic if after 17 years the cell phone companies succeed in determining that there is a road, but it doesn't get them anywhere near where they want to go.
- 11:36Michael Mulligan: So that's what's going on between the cell phone company and the uh the YMCA.
- 11:40Adam Stirling: Michael Mulkin's Michael Mulkin's Michael is evidence.
- 12:00Michael Mulligan: So uh so uh uh uh first of all, I think most listeners would be familiar with the general concept that in a criminal case the police and crown would have an o have an obligation to provide what's called disclosure to the accused person of the evidence they've collected.
- 12:16Michael Mulligan: Um and that's a constitutional requirement, the principle of fundamental justice, the court has found under section seven.
- 12:23Michael Mulligan: And that idea makes, yeah, I think, intuitive sense.
- 12:26Michael Mulligan: The idea a person should know what evidence is against them when they're being charged with a crime.
- 12:30Michael Mulligan: Now, one of the corollaries of the that obligation to provide disclosure of the evidence against somebody in a criminal case is to preserve the evidence so that you can give it to them, right?
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: It's a pretty hollow uh requirement if there's no obligation to keep the stuff.
- 12:45Michael Mulligan: It's kind of like Seinfeld and the uh, you know, uh rental car reservation.
- 12:50Michael Mulligan: Anyone can just take the reservation, it's the keeping the reservation that counts.
- 12:54Michael Mulligan: Uh and so here the fact pattern was that back in 2015, uh the RCMP had a report made by a friend of one of these uh eventual complainants uh indicating uh that uh they had received a text message from the complainant alleging that they'd been uh that person and her sister had been touched inappropriately.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: Uh and it caused the police to investigate that, as you would expect.
- 13:17Michael Mulligan: And in fact, the police had the uh person who wrote the text in for uh an interview in 2015.
- 13:24Michael Mulligan: Uh and they video recorded the interview, an audio recorded the interview, and likely recorded a a third way with uh like a portable recorder.
- 13:33Michael Mulligan: Uh and at that point, the uh person who uh wrote the email acknowledged that she had written it, but uh during the interview the notes indicated that she uh had uh told the police that uh it was false, that she'd lied in the uh message to her friend, uh, that she was depressed and wanted attention, the person had never touched her in any inappropriate way, didn't make her feel unsafe in any way, and it just didn't happen.
- 13:56Michael Mulligan: Uh and so as a result of that, not surprisingly, I think the police concluded, okay, well, there's nothing here to arrest the person for, and so they concluded their investigation.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: But and when you record the reclude the investigation, the RCMP have detailed policies.
- 14:11Michael Mulligan: It's not just a free-for-all over there.
- 14:13Michael Mulligan: Uh, right, they've got procedures whereby the police would take recordings of uh interviews of witnesses or complainants, and they uh with their digital, they record it in a computer system and it's reviewed by a supervisor to make sure that's all done.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: There's a whole process for it.
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh for whatever reason in this case that simply didn't occur.
- 14:33Michael Mulligan: Um and what then happened is in 2021, uh that original complainant, the person who wrote the or the original person who wrote the text message came forward and said, No, I was abused uh back then.
- 14:45Michael Mulligan: Um and provided another interview saying that it had happened.
- 14:49Michael Mulligan: And so the person was charged on the basis of what was being said now, uh, but that then naturally led to, okay, well, let's have a look at what the person said previously, because they're compare the two things.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: Uh and it turned out that they were lost.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: And then the law, there's a bunch of law around how that works.
- 15:05Michael Mulligan: Uh, and really it's a the analysis has three components to it.
- 15:09Michael Mulligan: The first part of that analysis uh is the judge looking at uh whether uh the crown, when once you show that something like that's lost, like relevant evidence, the interview with a person saying it didn't happen and they lied about it previously, um then the crown would have an obligation to prove that the evidence had not been lost due to what's referred to as unacceptable negligence.
- 15:32Michael Mulligan: You have to pause for a moment to ask yourself what is acceptable negligence look like.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: Um or two, uh, did the police uh engage in an abusive process?
- 15:42Michael Mulligan: Now, that second part, that abusive process, would be a more serious thing.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: That would be like, let's say, for example, the police know, like, hey, I found this evidence that is really unhelpful for our murder investigation.
- 15:52Michael Mulligan: You know, the witness identified somebody else in the police lineup, and somebody were to say, well, let's just put that in the shredder, and we won't have to worry about that at trial.
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: That'll just smooth things out a whole lot.
- 16:02Michael Mulligan: So that that abusive process could be things like that, like intentionally destroying something, or even if it's not that blatant, you might have a case where let's say they had a policy to destroy relevant evidence after some in some way, knowing that uh it would be maybe exculpatory.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: Uh but that issue of whether something is lost due to unacceptable negligence uh really amounts to can the crown show that there was some, you know, something let's say beyond the you know, police made reasonable efforts and something beyond their control caused it to be lost.
- 16:33Michael Mulligan: Like I don't know, the uh they made three copies of it, but the police station burned down and the server got destroyed.
- 16:39Michael Mulligan: Okay, well, you know, you might say, well, they took reasonable steps, but it uh it uh just didn't make it.
- 16:45Michael Mulligan: Here, um, as you might expect, once you go back that long, like for example, they managed to find some of the police that were involved with that original interview back in 2015, I think one of whom was retired, and it amounted their evidence amounted to I just have no memory and no idea what happened, right?
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: I said, Yeah, there's a policy we should have preserved this, maybe it got saved in the wrong place, just no one could really answer what happened to it.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: It's just gone.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: Um, and the judge on that basis found look, you know, that's not really that's not acceptable, right?
- 17:16Michael Mulligan: That is not that is unacceptable negligence, right?
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: That's important evidence.
- 17:20Michael Mulligan: They knew it was important, they had a policy to preserve it and keep it, and by apparently multiple human failures, it just hadn't been kept, and it could potentially be important evidence.
- 17:30Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found on that basis it was a breach of the accused person's uh right to uh receive the evidence and if the evidence preserved so it could be provided.
- 17:41Michael Mulligan: That was breached, but that's not the end of the matter, because the law is in cases like this where evidence is lost, the judge can find that to be a breach, which the judge has done, but then the the way it works is that you would run the rest of the trial to then determine, well, how important was that?
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 17:57Michael Mulligan: The thing that was lost, was that really critical, or did it not really matter at the end of the day because, you know, we found detailed notes of the what was said, or the complainant uh acknowledged that she had lied and it was dealt with adequately in that respect, for example.
- 18:11Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so here that is found to be a breach, not uh the abuse of process, sort of you did it intentionally, but uh it was uh that category of unacceptable negligence, uh, and we'll have to wait until the end of the trial for the judge to determine uh what the remedy for that uh will be.
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: Uh so that's uh oops.
- 18:30Michael Mulligan: Are you still able to hear me okay?
- 18:31Michael Mulligan: Yeah, yeah.
- 18:32Michael Mulligan: Okay, sorry.
- 18:33Michael Mulligan: We have two minutes left.
- 18:34Michael Mulligan: That's how two minutes left.
- 18:35Michael Mulligan: Okay, final one is a two-minute summary.
- 18:38Michael Mulligan: Uh the final case is over the court of appeal, and it involves a uh person who was uh a lawyer, who was a pro bono lawyer who does work for free or virtually for free, who had been uh ordered by the law society to pay a five thousand dollar fine uh for failing to take all of the necessary steps to get identification from a client.
- 18:58Michael Mulligan: And the background of that is that if you're a lawyer's engaged in financial transactions, there's an obligation to identify who the person is so that lawyers aren't used for laundering drug money, is basically it.
- 19:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and the law society alleged that this promoter lawyer hadn't done this with respect to money they were transferring to a woman who had fled to the United States to get away from an abusive husband, and they were helping her get money from a family home that went into foreclosure.
- 19:24Michael Mulligan: That was a fact pattern.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: Uh and they had uh found her to be in breach of this rule, claiming that they hadn't she got ID from her and verified it in person, because the lawyer had only verified it over video uh with her and then done various other things to identify her, but hadn't done it in person as was uh required.
- 19:43Michael Mulligan: The challenge was that the law society hadn't read its own rules, which actually said that that was unnecessary, where the money being passed along was from another lawyer's trust account.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: And the idea there is that you would have some certainty that this isn't drug money when the lawyer who originally received it would have done the the verification requirements on it.
- 20:01Michael Mulligan: And so the uh uh fine was overturned on a judicial review, uh, but at that judicial review stage, the judge hearing it found that the law society's conduct, including not reading its own rules and pursuing this nonetheless when its case fairly had little merit, uh, was worthy of rebuke and ordered the law society to pay what are referred to as special costs to this pro bono lawyer to compensate them for the cost of defending this whole thing.
- 20:30Michael Mulligan: They got that order.
- 20:32Michael Mulligan: Uh order was made by the judge to that effect, but the law society appealed it to the Court of Appeal, who just concluded that the judge didn't have authority to do that uh because the law society amounts to a a uh like a tribunal which you don't ordinarily order costs against, uh, even when uh a decision might not have uh merit and is overturned on appeal.
- 20:52Michael Mulligan: And so I thought the case was worth mentioning just uh for one point to if lest anyone have any concern that the law society is not diligently ensuring that uh everyone is following uh uh the rules that are imposed, you could have uh great assurance that they are extremely diligent in doing that.
- 21:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and also I thought notable uh because as the Court of Appeal pointed out, this was hardly the Law Society's finest moment, having failed to read its own rules uh in finding this person.
- 21:20Michael Mulligan: So the net result is no fine uh but no cost for the uh pro bono uh lawyer uh because of the uh the nature of the decision.
- 21:28Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers legally speaking during the second half or second hour of the Thursday.
- 21:33Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 21:33Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:35Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:36Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.