Latest / Humanise The Numbers - for ambitious accountants in practice / John F Thompson - CEO Wisdom in Practice
Transcript
- 0:05Paul Shrimpling: Welcome to the Humanize the Numbers podcast series Leaders, managers and owners of ambitious accounting firms sharing insights, successes and issues that will challenge you and connect you and your firm to the ways and means of transforming your firm's results.
- 0:22John Thompson: If you narrow that right down to one question, the best question you can ask anybody at the start of a telephone call, at the start of a meeting, is a primarily non-business question.
- 0:38John Thompson: How are you feeling, Paul?
- 0:39John Thompson: And depending on your response, we might spend 10 minutes talking to you about that without getting onto a business-focused agenda, because actually that will massively impact upon the business agenda anyway and you might be having a really bad time and you might say I actually had a really bad day.
- 0:59John Thompson: Well, you then do not skip into the business agenda.
- 1:03John Thompson: You say, oh, what happened?
- 1:05John Thompson: What's going on?
- 1:06John Thompson: Because all these things going on in your personal life, we as professionals fool ourselves if we believe that's not going to impact upon the business world.
- 1:19Paul Shrimpling: How ambitious is ambitious?
- 1:22Paul Shrimpling: What about trebling your top-line fees in two years?
- 1:28Paul Shrimpling: That would feel ambitious.
- 1:30Paul Shrimpling: Well, the conversation we're about to have with John Thompson zeros in on a process, a mechanism, a series of standard operating procedures, changing conversations so that you, your team, your firm can transform your results because of a deeper relationship with each and every one of your SME clients.
- 1:55Paul Shrimpling: Let's dive into that conversation with John now.
- 1:59John Thompson: Hi there, paul.
- 1:59John Thompson: Great to see you.
- 2:00John Thompson: I hope there's lots of listeners to the podcast.
- 2:03John Thompson: As you know, my name is John Thompson.
- 2:05John Thompson: How can I describe myself?
- 2:08John Thompson: I've been qualified since 1992 as a chartered accountant, so that obviously makes me an FCA, because I'm old enough to be an FCA.
- 2:16John Thompson: Have been a partner in a top 10 firm.
- 2:20John Thompson: Have been a business development director in a regional practice.
- 2:23John Thompson: We tripled in size in two years.
- 2:26John Thompson: I can tell you how we did that later.
- 2:28John Thompson: Also worked outside the profession in big corporate leisure world for five years and have been FD of an M&E contractor in construction for five years.
- 2:38John Thompson: Currently chief exec of Wisdom in Practice Group, best known for working with accountancy practices who want to generate loads of extra fees out of the advisory space Brilliant.
- 2:55Paul Shrimpling: And what's going on in John's personal space?
- 3:00Paul Shrimpling: A bit about you as a human being.
- 3:02John Thompson: Oh, in my personal space as I say I'm going on a bit about you as a universal space.
- 3:06John Thompson: I was the same going on a bit now.
- 3:06John Thompson: So, uh, three grown-up kids, uh, six grandchildren, uh, no spare money and no spare time right.
- 3:13Paul Shrimpling: Okay, so let's assume you're using it is in exactly the way that you would want to.
- 3:20Paul Shrimpling: It's a real pleasure having you on the uh on the podcast, john John, thanks for joining us.
- 3:24Paul Shrimpling: So broad experience, industry practice, practice, development, advisory space.
- 3:35John Thompson: What does the phrase humanise the numbers mean to you.
- 3:37John Thompson: It's a derivative of something I've always believed, paul, and that is that actually the numbers only tell part of the story and it's actually what numbers mean to the individual clients, the individual business owners, in terms of them being individuals, them being human.
- 3:58John Thompson: Simple example, paul client number one's got a million quid in his bank account.
- 4:04John Thompson: He's delighted, he's over the moon, he's so happy.
- 4:07John Thompson: Client number two's got a million quid in their bank account.
- 4:10John Thompson: They're miserable.
- 4:11John Thompson: The numbers mean different things to different people and therefore we need to understand the mindset of the individuals, the human circumstances of the individuals and what their numbers mean to them, because you cannot judge things by purely numbers alone.
- 4:29Paul Shrimpling: Right, ok.
- 4:30Paul Shrimpling: Ok, so it's the perception, interpretation, meaning behind the numbers.
- 4:35Paul Shrimpling: That's the key here, ok, so why is that important to managers, leaders, owners of accounting firms?
- 4:43John Thompson: If we don't understand what's going on in the client's mind, we don't understand their personal circumstances, we don't understand what their current numbers mean to them and what they'd like their future numbers to be and what those future numbers would enable them to do in their personal world, it is really difficult to give good advice world, it is really difficult to give good advice.
- 5:11Paul Shrimpling: Okay, so, without an appreciation of what a an individual I'm using that word uh, uh, full-blooded, because there's the individuals, their team, and individuals their clients.
- 5:21Paul Shrimpling: Now, I guess they were going to focus very much in the client space, but I think the same principle applies't it to a team member as it does a client.
- 5:30Paul Shrimpling: Do we understand them well enough?
- 5:33Paul Shrimpling: Do we understand what they want for their future well enough?
- 5:35Paul Shrimpling: Determines how well we're going to get connected, how well we can challenge their decisions, their actions, their behaviours, support what they're doing in order to achieve what they want.
- 5:45Paul Shrimpling: So how do accountants put that to good use then, john, if they're going okay, I get that I need to zero in on the future of the people in my business life.
- 5:54Paul Shrimpling: How do we put that to work?
- 5:57John Thompson: Well, in terms of clients, we need to do what maybe we used to do, and that is, we need to do what maybe we used to do, and that is we need to actually sit down and talk to them and have conversations and, I would argue, structured conversations so that we've got some sort of leverage in the practice, we've got some sort of consistency, we've got quality control in order to actually make sure we do understand them.
- 6:24John Thompson: We've got to build that into our day-to-day way we run our practice.
- 6:31Paul Shrimpling: So it's got to become part of the Part of what we do.
- 6:35Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, just normal, automatic, habitual, automatic, systematic, right?
- 6:41Paul Shrimpling: So how do?
- 6:41Paul Shrimpling: I was going to ask a how question, but let's go to.
- 6:46Paul Shrimpling: Why should firms bother with this when there's plenty of work on audit, there's plenty of work on management accounts, on annual accounts, on ITSA, on lots of work to do, why should we bother in this space?
- 7:01John Thompson: As most business decisions end up being Paul, it's good risk management and it makes you more money.
- 7:07John Thompson: So, starting with making more money, the better you understand your client, the better you're able to identify potential services that would benefit them and obviously, the fees generated would benefit you.
- 7:20John Thompson: It's also a fantastic differentiator to win new business because unfortunately, a proportion of our profession don't do this hardly at all.
- 7:30John Thompson: The other side on the good risk management is, without wanting to scare somebody too much, that you don't want to get a PI insurance claim and the client turn around and say, well, they didn't ask me these questions and therefore that's why we've ended up where we are are.
- 7:46Paul Shrimpling: So you need to know as much as possible about your clients okay, so it's taken the kyc know, your client piece, onto a completely different level, which yeah, which where kyc should be I agree, I agree, I agree.
- 8:00Paul Shrimpling: Um there's than it being a box ticking exercise could be should be.
- 8:07John Thompson: Currently it's Mickey Mouse, isn't it?
- 8:10Paul Shrimpling: It's underrated, I think, as a focus area and it's clear to me, john, and your experience is almost certainly going to be similar is look at the firms who have got a very high average fee.
- 8:24Paul Shrimpling: Let's just exclude audit, just just to take all day at the back.
- 8:28Paul Shrimpling: The action go right.
- 8:29Paul Shrimpling: What does a high average fee look like?
- 8:31Paul Shrimpling: Well, just been listening to a previous podcast with Andrew, andrew Botham, who ran a practice.
- 8:38Paul Shrimpling: He sold it six, seven years ago.
- 8:41Paul Shrimpling: When I was working with Andrew, maybe ten years ago, he had an average fee of about 14 000 pounds.
- 8:48Paul Shrimpling: That's not index link, that's back then.
- 8:50Paul Shrimpling: Uh, non-audit, because he was really good at the kyc.
- 8:55Paul Shrimpling: He was really good at getting to know the goals and the challenges of the firms that the businesses that he worked with and was able to monetize that.
- 9:05Paul Shrimpling: So it reflected on the fees and the profitability of the firm.
- 9:08Paul Shrimpling: I'll look at Luke, I look at Alistair, I look at you know, poor, I don't know doesn't two dozen, three dozen other firms and look at average fees of 12k, 30k, 35k, because they're zeroing in on a much deeper 35k, because they're zeroing in on a much deeper understanding, much deeper relationship with their clients, which is a completely different skill to the deliver accountancy, deliver management accounts, deliver, payroll deliver, and so on.
- 9:35Paul Shrimpling: Um, how does your experience, uh, resonate with that?
- 9:41John Thompson: I think, um, there's a, a number of firms at the moment who, um, and I can think of two in particular obviously won't name them, but are actively shedding audits to give them more capacity to do what some people call advisory, but I would just call common sense look after your clients yeah, yeah, yeah uh, and they have done the number crunching, and one in particular, which is quite a chunky firm, is in two years they expect to get rid of a million pounds worth of audit and they think by replacing that with only 750,000 worth of what they call consultancy and advisory, they'll actually make more money from 750,000 worth of that than they would for a million awarded.
- 10:30Paul Shrimpling: Right?
- 10:30Paul Shrimpling: Well, because they've got fewer people attached to the delivery.
- 10:33John Thompson: Fewer people, fewer training requirements and the ability to have conversations that will create more fees rather than just do the audit Right okay, so that's a big strategic decision for that firm to make, isn't it?
- 10:46Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, so that's connected with well, what are they wanting to do as a firm?
- 10:51Paul Shrimpling: Subject to the scale of the firm, it's either focusing in on business goals or focusing in on the personal goals of the owners.
- 10:59Paul Shrimpling: I'm now curious as to which is, or if both are, driving that decision.
- 11:05John Thompson: It's a mixture.
- 11:06John Thompson: It's a mixture of both.
- 11:07John Thompson: Part of the sort of extra benefit of that is they are able to and they do work with audit clients of slightly bigger firms who have taken a very hard line and said we cannot do non-audit work on clients we're doing audit on.
- 11:30John Thompson: Now I know that is a little bit of a gray area for some practices, but the higher you got the food chain, so to speak, the more seriously they take that.
- 11:40John Thompson: So they're doing a lot of quote unquote advisory work for clients of bigger audit practices.
- 11:48Paul Shrimpling: All right, that's interesting because there's other people out there.
- 11:51Paul Shrimpling: Aren't they who are taking audit work because they either don't want to work on audit fees that are too low for them as a firm, or and don't want to take on the audit work because they're connected with advisory work and therefore, like you say, higher up the food chain, they're less able to do that because they're more under the spotlight.
- 12:13Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 12:15Paul Shrimpling: Right.
- 12:15Paul Shrimpling: So what's the?
- 12:17Paul Shrimpling: So I can see the material impact, you know.
- 12:19Paul Shrimpling: Sacrifice a million quid's worth of audit, gain 750k's worth of let's just call it advisory for the sake of the label, and be more profitable.
- 12:27Paul Shrimpling: Um, how do they set about doing that then, john?
- 12:31John Thompson: it's back to what we said just previously.
- 12:33John Thompson: It's about building the systems and processes into the way they operate, um, what you might call sops or standard operating processes.
- 12:43John Thompson: Most practices may have them recorded or may not have them recorded, but they're pretty much aware that if there is a set of accounts needs preparing, there is a process to follow, and they teach people right from day one when they join the practice.
- 12:59John Thompson: This is what you need to do.
- 13:00John Thompson: I mean, in audit, there's an audit program.
- 13:03John Thompson: For instance, in how to complete a tax return, there is a written or unwritten process to do.
- 13:05John Thompson: I mean, in audit, there's an audit program.
- 13:05John Thompson: For instance, in how to complete a tax return, there is a written or unwritten process to follow.
- 13:09John Thompson: So it is not that difficult to build an advisory process.
- 13:14John Thompson: So it becomes every day.
- 13:17John Thompson: So everybody understands.
- 13:18John Thompson: For instance, we go along to a prospecting meeting.
- 13:22John Thompson: What are we going to talk about?
- 13:24John Thompson: Well, if we follow a particular line of inquiry, rather than say, hey, I looked at your accounts and I've spotted some numbers that could be improved, yawn, yawn, yawn, blah, blah, blah, they take a different approach.
- 13:38John Thompson: And so, right from day one, with the new client or the potential new client, they're establishing a different kind of relationship.
- 13:46Paul Shrimpling: I like that line of inquiry out of the police nomenclature.
- 13:51Paul Shrimpling: So what line of inquiry are we actually talking about here?
- 13:55John Thompson: Well, most clients in this country, even if they're business clients, are SMEs.
- 14:00John Thompson: So most of the time, those businesses only exist to create wealth for the individuals that own them, to do lots of wonderful things for themselves and for their families and whatever else they choose to do.
- 14:12John Thompson: So an easy starting point is actually to be brave enough to say let's put your accounts in the drawer and let's just talk about you.
- 14:22John Thompson: Let's talk about you and your family.
- 14:24John Thompson: Let's talk about your personal wealth.
- 14:25John Thompson: Let's talk about what you are doing at the minute in your life and what you'd like to do in the future.
- 14:31John Thompson: Great, now let's talk about how the business can actually create the wealth to enable you to do that.
- 14:38John Thompson: And often the clients have never been asked questions like this before.
- 14:42John Thompson: They I wouldn't say struggle, but because they've never been asked questions like this before they.
- 14:45John Thompson: I wouldn't say struggle, but because they've never been asked questions like this before, they haven't maybe thought about it deeply.
- 14:50John Thompson: So you're helping them clarify their own thinking, which is massive value from day one, and you're also giving a really in-depth understanding of what's going on in these people's lives.
- 15:01John Thompson: And then, when you segue back into the business, sometimes the way the numbers are becomes much clearer because you understand that they've got these commitments, if you like, outside of the business, that obviously impact upon the performance of the business.
- 15:19John Thompson: Sometimes that's extremely positive, sometimes it might not be positive.
- 15:23John Thompson: But this sort of marriage of business and personal, I think as a profession we're fooling ourselves, for instance, particularly in SME world, if we believe that the company is the client.
- 15:37John Thompson: It might need to be the client, but in reality the business clients are relevant.
- 15:44John Thompson: It's actually the people who own the business, it's the individual business owners.
- 15:48John Thompson: They are the real client, not the company or the partnership or whatever else they're operating under.
- 15:57Paul Shrimpling: Yeah.
- 15:57Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, it might be a limited company and therefore a legal entity, but actually the real conversation with the real people who own that business.
- 16:04Paul Shrimpling: You know, that's my personal experience.
- 16:06Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I talk from stage often about the six accountants I've worked while I've been running the various businesses I've run over the last 30 years and, okay, it's a bit dismissive and I apologize for it, but still mean from the from the bottom of my heart is four of those accountants were, in inverted commas, chocolate teapot accountants, because when it got difficult, when it got challenging for us, they melted away, whereas the, the two who were serious about me and kate and the four kids, were able to influence my thinking, influence my decision making, influencing the actions we therefore took in order to create the stable financial world that we now live in.
- 16:45Paul Shrimpling: Um in in at our stage in life and I, without any hesitation, go a lot.
- 16:52Paul Shrimpling: Without neil and without rob, um, I wouldn't be where I am.
- 16:56Paul Shrimpling: You know that and therefore, you know recommend them all the time, um, and they, well, one of them took my son out for dinner just before his wedding only a week or so ago.
- 17:09Paul Shrimpling: So it's, and he's what and his wife to be.
- 17:11Paul Shrimpling: They're that close to us and isn't that something that and again, this is about caricatures.
- 17:19Paul Shrimpling: You know, your traditional, what people expect of an accountant are going to find it difficult to get into that personal understanding kyc space.
- 17:31Paul Shrimpling: You use the word bravery.
- 17:33Paul Shrimpling: Are they brave enough to ask the questions that have got nothing to do with their accounts or their audit and everything to do with who they are as human beings?
- 17:40Paul Shrimpling: isn't that alien to your typical accountant it's only being brave the first time.
- 17:48John Thompson: After that it's just something you do.
- 17:50John Thompson: And also, I think, where we kind of even the accounts that are not doing this at the minute.
- 17:57John Thompson: They're flirting with it because they usually are doing the personal tax affairs, so they're usually having to ask some of these questions anyway as part of their personal tax services.
- 18:09John Thompson: So we're not talking a giant leap here, we're talking a small step and we're actually just pulling together what in reality already exists, but we haven't codified it, we haven't created a system, we haven't almost recognized that this is what we do.
- 18:29John Thompson: And if we talk to 100 accountants, paul, they've all got stories that they've forgotten about where they really, you know, helped someone on a not just on a business level, but on a personal level, and they've forgotten about it.
- 18:50John Thompson: Because we are taught to act a certain way and often you could extend that into our measurement systems and our CRM systems that we don't record this stuff.
- 19:01John Thompson: We sort of just kind of gloss over it, but actually often that is the most powerful experience we have given a client.
- 19:12Paul Shrimpling: This is close to where I'm at from a thinking and challenge perspective.
- 19:19Paul Shrimpling: So if I describe the challenge, you can perhaps shine some light on how we resolve this, john, so, in the world of psychometric profiling whether it's DISC or any other form and there's many, many forms out there they'll ask a whole series of questions and work out the natural mix of your behaviours and the unnatural mix and the stress that might be caused because you're in the wrong role or not because you're in the right role.
- 19:50Paul Shrimpling: Great, I keep repeating this and I've mentioned it on a couple of podcasts before now.
- 19:57Paul Shrimpling: Is Peter Thompson, an old mentor of mine, still one of the greatest sales trainers I've ever worked with, says that people won't consistently do who they aren't, but they will consistently do who they are, and lots of accountants and you use the phrase um, I think recognize themselves.
- 20:17Paul Shrimpling: This is that this is what you do, is ask these personal questions, whereas if your measurement system in your crm system doesn't clearly show you that this is who you are, you therefore won't consistently be who you are, which is someone who can should get closer to their clients.
- 20:40Paul Shrimpling: Am I, um plowing the right furrow here, do you think?
- 20:44John Thompson: no, I, I, I think.
- 20:46John Thompson: I think I can completely understand what you're saying, paul.
- 20:48John Thompson: Um, I think in some of the conversations, for instance, I have with accountants, I, I would, and, and often this is this is part of their defense mechanism they go oh, I'm not sure about this, I'm not sure I can do that.
- 21:02John Thompson: And then you would suggest to them, for instance, that they are naturally changing their behaviours depending upon the environment.
- 21:16John Thompson: They're in every single second of every single day.
- 21:19John Thompson: So they're already doing it.
- 21:20John Thompson: So we're not asking them to do anything they're not already doing.
- 21:23John Thompson: And the example I would give the way they would speak to their grandmother is not the way they would speak to their mother, is not the way they would speak to their wife, is not the way they'd speak to their daughter, and so on.
- 21:37John Thompson: So they're naturally changing their behaviours.
- 21:40John Thompson: And you know, I just said earlier on, I've got six grandchildren.
- 21:43John Thompson: I speak differently to my grandchildren than I do to my kids.
- 21:49John Thompson: Yeah, and you know I'm.
- 21:51John Thompson: It would be extremely embarrassing some of the conversations I have on my grandchildren, but it's natural.
- 21:56John Thompson: You say all sorts of gobbledygook, yeah, and it's natural.
- 22:00John Thompson: And I don't think, oh, I'm not being myself.
- 22:02John Thompson: Myself is this highly professional person?
- 22:04John Thompson: That's just a nonsense.
- 22:06John Thompson: There's a really good friend of mine who is now working.
- 22:11John Thompson: He's got his dream job at Newcastle United in the media department.
- 22:15John Thompson: When he was a young lad, so to speak, he was the son of a church minister Nicest guy in the world.
- 22:25John Thompson: But once he got into the football ground.
- 22:28John Thompson: He was on the barrier leading the singing.
- 22:30John Thompson: Now, different environment, different natural behaviors, inverted commas natural behaviors.
- 22:38John Thompson: People are changing the way they behave all the time, quite naturally.
- 22:44John Thompson: I accept there are extreme circumstances where people will feel stressed out or uncomfortable.
- 22:51John Thompson: You know, you walked in a bar and there was a bar fight going on.
- 22:54John Thompson: You wouldn't feel very comfortable.
- 22:56John Thompson: But 99.9% of the time, every second of every day, you're moving around in the way you behave depending on your environment.
- 23:06John Thompson: So I'm not asking them to be anything they're not already doing.
- 23:09John Thompson: It's just kind of being aware of that.
- 23:11John Thompson: It's just being self-aware of well, I'm already doing this actually.
- 23:15John Thompson: So all I've got to do is just accept that's the way I am.
- 23:19John Thompson: I'm changing all the time.
- 23:22Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, and so if they become, when they become self-aware that I behave differently in different settings, in different environments, maybe they're therefore less resistant to then stepping into the space which is actually.
- 23:39Paul Shrimpling: I can go deeper in this KYC space.
- 23:41Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 23:43Paul Shrimpling: Please forgive this brief interruption.
- 23:45Paul Shrimpling: John and I have just been talking about mindset, about how you see yourself, how your team see themselves, and whether it feels natural or not for you to ask deeper, more meaningful, more personal questions and open those conversations.
- 24:00Paul Shrimpling: And that mindset issue is something to take deadly seriously, and if you want to investigate what it feels like, what it looks like, to have a growth mindset, check out the growth mindset business breakthrough in the show notes.
- 24:13Paul Shrimpling: Um, how did they become self-aware, though, in this, john?
- 24:21John Thompson: they to be.
- 24:22John Thompson: They usually need help.
- 24:25John Thompson: They usually need help.
- 24:26John Thompson: Um, you know, even the great sports people have got coaches and those coaches aren't really coaches.
- 24:32John Thompson: They don't teach them out once they get to a certain level.
- 24:36John Thompson: You're not going to teach roger federer to improve his forehand, for instance, but he values the fact that somebody's there just talking to him, listening to his problems, nudging him in the right direction, reminding him of what was really good.
- 24:50John Thompson: Because, again, we as accountants, we forget over time some of the great stuff we do.
- 24:57John Thompson: Now, even ourselves.
- 25:00John Thompson: I might do a support call with a firm and they'll say oh, we haven't really done very much in the advisory space in the last month.
- 25:06John Thompson: And my stock answer is just run me through your diary and there's always stuff they've forgotten about and that's in the last four weeks.
- 25:14Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah.
- 25:15Paul Shrimpling: And so that self-awareness is a skill, is it?
- 25:19Paul Shrimpling: Or is it one of your SOPs that can help bring it to the fore?
- 25:27John Thompson: It's a combination.
- 25:28John Thompson: It's a combination because, if the so what the sops ideally do is they establish good habits and good behaviors, and it's a little bit like driving a car at some point you just start doing it.
- 25:40John Thompson: You know, you, I'm sure you've experienced it, paul, where you've driven home and thought, blimey, I'm home when you were when you first passed your test.
- 25:51John Thompson: I bet every hundred yards.
- 25:52John Thompson: You are massively concentrating and you are making yourself do the right things yeah, absolutely, and celebrating that you haven't just stuffed it through a fence.
- 26:03Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, so SOPs in the beginning help that.
- 26:10Paul Shrimpling: Standing up operating procedures help nurture, help establish the habitual behaviour.
- 26:17Paul Shrimpling: Is that in the right setting and natural anyway?
- 26:20Paul Shrimpling: It's just we've not yet habitual eyes them, not yet recognizing them and therefore not yet making the most of the opportunity in that space, whereas if we can get the standing operating procedures working well, we stand a better chance of succeeding.
- 26:36Paul Shrimpling: Okay, correct, all right.
- 26:38Paul Shrimpling: So best SOP on the planet for helping accountants become better at getting deeper around the SME owners goals and challenges?
- 26:51Paul Shrimpling: What's the best SOP ever?
- 26:57John Thompson: if you, if you narrow that right down to one question, the best question you can ask anybody at the start of a telephone call, at the start of a meeting, is a primarily non-business question.
- 27:13John Thompson: How are you feeling, paul minutes talking to you about that without getting onto a business focused agenda?
- 27:27John Thompson: Because actually that will massively impact upon the business agenda anyway and you might be having a really bad time and you might say I actually had a really bad day.
- 27:35John Thompson: Well, you then do not skip into the business agenda.
- 27:39John Thompson: You say, oh, what happened?
- 27:41John Thompson: What's going on?
- 27:42Paul Shrimpling: yeah, yeah, because all these things going on in your personal life, we, we, we as professionals fool ourselves if we believe that's not going to impact upon the business world yeah, I can't tell you how many times I'm a huge fan of you know that what you call the business focused agenda, but agenda item one, you know pressing issues or pressing challenges.
- 28:06Paul Shrimpling: So you know we've got.
- 28:07Paul Shrimpling: Before we get dive into what I think we need to be talking about, tell me what's going on, what's what, what's what's really pressing in on you at the minute the word.
- 28:15John Thompson: The word feeling is so much more powerful than thinking.
- 28:18John Thompson: If you ask someone how they think they dive into analysis and they sort of.
- 28:23John Thompson: If you ask someone how they think they dive into analysis and they sort of go like Joey from Friends and look up and around the ceiling of the room and they have to sort of think and analyse and what you want is gut feel.
- 28:34John Thompson: How are you feeling, paul?
- 28:37Paul Shrimpling: But, john, now we've got these accountants, who aren't necessarily self-aware about being naturally prone to asking simple but deeper, more personal questions, and now we're encouraging them to have a conversation about emotions.
- 28:54Paul Shrimpling: That's almost a step beyond the pale, do you not think?
- 29:00John Thompson: Again, I would turn that around and say so.
- 29:04John Thompson: You work late at the office, Paul, pretending you're an accountant from years ago.
- 29:10John Thompson: Yeah, You've got home at 7 o'clock, You're a bit tired, You're a bit worn out.
- 29:15John Thompson: It is likely that your significant other would go what's your day been like?
- 29:20John Thompson: And it's likely you would turn around to your significant that how are you?
- 29:27Paul Shrimpling: you're doing it all the time and yet we have a profession that have been educated, told, cajoled, encouraged to step into this personal human advisory space for decades.
- 29:44Paul Shrimpling: You know, starting with ran, if indeed, if ever started, then I would argue I think you would as well that the the the further back you go in the profession, you more you get closer to accountants who were really deep in the lives of their business owner clients.
- 29:58Paul Shrimpling: And as the technology's advanced, we've become more almost immune to the fact that actually there are human beings working in a professional service firm dealing with a business owner, an accountant dealing with an individual.
- 30:10Paul Shrimpling: It's almost as if that's got diluted because of the obsession with the technology, obsession with getting services out the door.
- 30:16Paul Shrimpling: Um, I'm not sure what question I'm driving towards here, but there's.
- 30:20Paul Shrimpling: It's almost as if we've lost what we once had.
- 30:22Paul Shrimpling: The profession has lost what it once had, which I think you were hinting at earlier on in the discussion.
- 30:29John Thompson: I think technology is a really interesting one, because there are obviously massive benefits to technology, sure.
- 30:34John Thompson: However, most of the benefits are for the accountancy practice.
- 30:38John Thompson: There are less benefits in technology for clients.
- 30:42John Thompson: Yes, because we're back to what we're saying about humanizing the numbers.
- 30:48John Thompson: Now we might be able to get the numbers a bit faster, a bit more accurate, etc.
- 30:53John Thompson: Etc.
- 30:54John Thompson: But we still need to interrogate those numbers, um, to the point of reference of what does the client actually think about them?
- 31:02John Thompson: How do they feel about them?
- 31:04John Thompson: Are they good numbers?
- 31:04John Thompson: Are they bad numbers?
- 31:05John Thompson: Are they giving them what they want?
- 31:07John Thompson: But we're we're a bit obsessed with production and, rather than and and I.
- 31:17John Thompson: It's a really interesting one because there's a um, there's a really good friend of mine's got a successful manufacturing business and, and they are.
- 31:26John Thompson: They are obviously obsessed with production, but what they really offer, which they struggle to sell, is what I would call a design and build service, because customers come to them and say give me 100 of these, and a lot of the time they go back and say's a better way to do that?
- 31:48John Thompson: We could swap out this, we could do this, we could do that, and there's a real design element and then the production slash building takes place and and they, with some of their customers, they have succeeded and actually um educating them and um being able to essentially say look, this is this.
- 32:12John Thompson: They don't call it design and build, but that's essentially what it is, not just production.
- 32:17John Thompson: We as a profession are in danger of just being seen as production people and the.
- 32:24John Thompson: The real danger of that and I know not everybody agrees with this, but the real danger of that and I know not everybody agrees with this, but the real danger of that is production is low skilled and it is more easily replaceable.
- 32:37John Thompson: And you know, if half of what people are predicting with AI comes in place and the numbers of people employed in practices will significantly reduce or it will release people to do other things, my fear is that a proportion too large a proportion of the profession will say we'll cut the headcount.
- 33:02John Thompson: Yeah, because they want to drive their EBITDA up, don't they?
- 33:08John Thompson: Well, I would argue that's short-term profit, it's not long-term profit.
- 33:12John Thompson: But we could talk about this for hours.
- 33:18Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, of course.
- 33:18Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I guess some of this comes back to you know, just to reflect your suggestion that a manager leader of an accounting firm should ask the business owners they're working with questions about what matters most to them, whether it be about the problems and issues that they're experiencing or the future goals that they want to achieve.
- 33:40Paul Shrimpling: They need to turn those questions on themselves as well, don't they?
- 33:44Paul Shrimpling: You know, what do you want for your firm?
- 33:45Paul Shrimpling: What do you want for your people, your family?
- 33:48Paul Shrimpling: your life, which is what you're talking about which then gives a I would suggest a strategic perspective around which you make decisions that's in your best interests as a manager and leader of your firm.
- 34:02Paul Shrimpling: Um, I'm just wondering what those best questions would be.
- 34:08John Thompson: It's very similar to what you would ask clients.
- 34:14John Thompson: You've got to ask yourselves those questions.
- 34:18John Thompson: In my past life, mark, I facilitated well over 100 business strategy sessions and the thing I learned very quickly was a business strategy is absolutely useless without bottoming him out the personal situation first, because it's the personal situation which drives the business strategy.
- 34:40John Thompson: So, for instance, there's a friend of mine who I know several years ago spent a lot of time working in the states and ago spent a lot of time working in the States and he made a lot of money working in the States, but it got to the point where he was away from home too much.
- 34:57John Thompson: So the decision is do I spend time at home and give up income?
- 35:05John Thompson: And he decided that was the right thing to do and at a certain point or a certain level we, we can all do that.
- 35:16John Thompson: I mean, we've all had clients sme clients, for instance who maybe have got one super, super customer who is too big because they're too reliant on them and they're going.
- 35:32John Thompson: But this is great, we're making lots and lots of money, but actually if they walk, your business goes.
- 35:39Paul Shrimpling: So what's the trade-off?
- 35:40Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, yeah, where's the core business?
- 35:43Paul Shrimpling: Where's that risk-reward payoff piece?
- 35:46Paul Shrimpling: That is how you want to live your business life and therefore impact on your personal life.
- 35:52Paul Shrimpling: But business goals, business strategy drives personal goals.
- 35:59Paul Shrimpling: Personal strategy drives business strategy is what you're saying.
- 36:02Paul Shrimpling: I agree, wholeheartedly, I do.
- 36:06Paul Shrimpling: And so key skills then, john, is it as simple as just asking the obvious dumbass questions that aren't as dumbass as they appear?
- 36:28John Thompson: good car driver is always going to be a good car driver and better than a bad car driver.
- 36:31John Thompson: But if you can build systems and processes, um around that, you're going to give people a better car to drive.
- 36:38John Thompson: So I mean, we all know, don't we, that the cars of today are much safer than the cars of yesteryear and um.
- 36:45John Thompson: So the starting point is let's give you a really nice car, so we're going to make the journey as easy as possible, and but we have to accept, I think, that some people will become, you know, fantastic car drivers, and other people will be not as good.
- 37:04John Thompson: However, as long as they don't crash and they're better than they were, that is progress.
- 37:13John Thompson: Again, our profession.
- 37:14John Thompson: One of the things I think we kind of learn over time is we don't have to have all the answers.
- 37:18John Thompson: We can bring other people to help us.
- 37:21John Thompson: There's loads of small firms use VAT consultancies, use R&D consultancies, et cetera, et cetera.
- 37:28John Thompson: But we can still have these, what I would call these primary conversations and work at a high level about what's really important to the client and how can we help them record that so they can share that with other people, they can educate other people, they can communicate that.
- 37:49John Thompson: And then what you might call the traditional services are the secondary services and that's the stuff we always do the management accounts, the basic tax advice and any sort of advice around that.
- 38:02John Thompson: But there's a sort of third level, a sort of tertiary level, which is stuff we won't do or can't do, but our primary conversations have identified there's a need.
- 38:13John Thompson: So you know there's obvious things.
- 38:15John Thompson: Like you know, you bring a lawyer in to sort the will out, you bring a financial services guy in to sort out certain things.
- 38:22John Thompson: It could be a marketing person, an it person, whatever is.
- 38:25John Thompson: But because we are working at the primary level, we're in control of the relationship.
- 38:30John Thompson: We are doing the most important stuff.
- 38:35John Thompson: Again, our profession.
- 38:36John Thompson: I think sometimes we get excited when we're being clever.
- 38:40John Thompson: So we do a clever piece of tax advice.
- 38:42John Thompson: Client doesn't understand it.
- 38:43John Thompson: You're wasting your time.
- 38:44John Thompson: He doesn't understand it.
- 38:46John Thompson: All he's interested in you saved him money, great, fantastic, love you to death.
- 38:51John Thompson: But the technicalities of it, the read, the stuff that we know is really difficult and we're really amazed that we can do this straight over the head of most clients.
- 39:01John Thompson: The most important thing is the primary level conversations that identify the most important things, the most urgent things, and then we work at a secondary level and we bring in people we know to work at a tertiary level because we won't do it or can't do it it's interesting is that the the client doesn't care about the moving parts, the clever stuff in the tax planning or whichever other service we want to talk about.
- 39:32Paul Shrimpling: They care about the outcome of that which might save them some money but actually and I'm just picking up on your point about how they then feel about that what they're going to do with this extra money and the impact that has on their personal lives.
- 39:47Paul Shrimpling: That's, that's the where the real value, you know, it's an emotional payoff.
- 39:53Paul Shrimpling: Isn't it not the financial payoff that they care more?
- 39:56Paul Shrimpling: About do you agree with that?
- 39:58John Thompson: yeah, it's it.
- 40:01John Thompson: I think the emotional side, which where, again, we are taught from an early age to sort of, if you like, put it away and put it away and not really, you know, focus too much on it it is the most powerful driver.
- 40:14John Thompson: I mean, you know, we've all been shopping and we've got three things on the shopping list and we buy 10 things.
- 40:22John Thompson: We've all done it.
- 40:26Paul Shrimpling: So and we buying for emotional.
- 40:29Paul Shrimpling: This, as you can probably tell a frustration of mine, which is let's have more, and you agree with it.
- 40:39Paul Shrimpling: So I'm very happy with the way this podcast is going.
- 40:41Paul Shrimpling: Uh, more emotional conversations?
- 40:43Paul Shrimpling: Yes, have the functional and financial conversations, because the actual value equation, which is made up of emotion, function, financial.
- 40:50Paul Shrimpling: The trump card in that hand, if you will, is the emotional payoff.
- 40:55Paul Shrimpling: Not so much, don't get me wrong.
- 40:57Paul Shrimpling: Functional payoff is pretty strong, financial payoff is also strong, but the trump card is what's the emotional payoff for the business owner?
- 41:05John Thompson: leader payoff of the business owner, leader and and the functional and the financial payoff.
- 41:13John Thompson: They enable the client to do stuff and that's where the emotional payoff comes from, and the emotional payoff is probably several multiples of the functional and financial I agree, john, this is personal and this isn't me showing off.
- 41:28Paul Shrimpling: It's just demonstrating the power of a conversation with Rob.
- 41:32Paul Shrimpling: Chartered accountant is, and he asked the question is this your lifetime home?
- 41:40Paul Shrimpling: Is this where you want to?
- 41:41Paul Shrimpling: You know, is this it?
- 41:43Paul Shrimpling: He didn't say it in a dismissive way.
- 41:46Paul Shrimpling: Yes, he didn't say it in a dismissive way, yes, Is it.
- 41:49Paul Shrimpling: And Kate and I were like, well, I don't know.
- 41:52Paul Shrimpling: That conversation resulted in us not moving from here but actually buying a very nice, modest property out in Portugal, which, literally two days ago, I was sat on the veranda of that property going.
- 42:03Paul Shrimpling: How did I end up here?
- 42:04Paul Shrimpling: Well, I ended up here because Rob asked me and Kate a couple of simple questions that resulted in some thinking, some decision-making and actions.
- 42:13Paul Shrimpling: And every time I visit that property, I can't help but thank Rob by the way, he's also a clever bugger that he is insisted on buying a tree for the garden.
- 42:23Paul Shrimpling: So every time I look at this tree that's growing, every time I'm always thinking of him.
- 42:27Paul Shrimpling: I don't think he did it for that reason, but it just shows that the emotional joy peace that we have in this little house is thanks to Rob.
- 42:44John Thompson: That's powerful, isn't it?
- 42:46John Thompson: It is, I mean.
- 42:47John Thompson: I think one of the biggest revelations to some business owners is they don't want to sell out.
- 42:52John Thompson: They want to sell out until they reach a certain age because they actually like what they're doing.
- 42:57John Thompson: And this modern approach where everybody wants to build a business and sell it, that's great for some people, but not everybody.
- 43:06Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 43:07Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, so I agree.
- 43:10Paul Shrimpling: I was with a three-owner leadership team in an accountancy firm yesterday and they were essentially saying the same thing no, no, we love what we're doing.
- 43:19Paul Shrimpling: We love the way this is going.
- 43:21Paul Shrimpling: We don't want to be part of a bigger firm as an employee.
- 43:26John Thompson: This is going too well part of a bigger firm as an employee.
- 43:32John Thompson: This is going too well, isn't it interesting, with p everywhere and and and everyone's going oh, p e, p, e, p, and you've got grant.
- 43:36John Thompson: Thornton have basically sold a slice of their business to p?
- 43:39John Thompson: E, and bdo in the states have gone completely the other way.
- 43:44John Thompson: They're saying we're remaining independent.
- 43:46John Thompson: I'm not sure what they call it in the states, but essentially it's a bit of an employee ownership trust.
- 43:51John Thompson: So the employees now own bdo, whereas grand thornton they've got uh, part ownership at least from private equity.
- 44:01Paul Shrimpling: Now, neither's wrong, it's just what people feel is best for them yeah, and then we're back into what is it you want your life to be like yeah, and, and some people are comfortable having a p um investors demanding certain results and behavior.
- 44:24John Thompson: people say I don't want that.
- 44:26John Thompson: I want to feel that you know, if me and my fellow partners, for whatever reason, are not having a great year, fine, we're not going to have a great year every year.
- 44:39John Thompson: As long as we have more good years than bad years, we're fine with that.
- 44:42John Thompson: Yeah, yeah.
- 44:43Paul Shrimpling: It's that you know what is it business owners really want, is the question that's triggered in my head from this conversation and one of the answers and it comes from having worked with and studied Michael Gerber and EME3 Visited and all of that space that it's business freedom.
- 45:04Paul Shrimpling: What's your definition of business freedom?
- 45:06John Thompson: Feels like a good question to pose oneself as a practice leader and also, by the way, your business owner clients paul, one of my, one of my little talks, where I get asked to go and speak at things, includes what I tongue-in-cheek called the three songs of life, and one of the songs of life is from those great musical philosophers, the, the Spice Girls.
- 45:30John Thompson: Tell me what you want, what you really, really want.
- 45:33Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 45:35John Thompson: And you know, for those in the audience who are still awake when I'm on stage, I say write that down and ask yourself don't do it now.
- 45:43John Thompson: Tomorrow morning, look in the mirror and ask yourself that what do you want?
- 45:48John Thompson: What do you really, really want?
- 45:52Paul Shrimpling: We can't leave the other two songs hanging, John, if you're opening that one.
- 45:59John Thompson: The other one is you can imagine you pick the songs to fit the message, but Ronan.
- 46:03John Thompson: Keating's Life is a Rollercoaster, right, you've just got to ride it, and sometimes you'll have good years and sometimes you'll have bad years.
- 46:11John Thompson: And as long as you have more ups and downs, fine.
- 46:14Speaker 3: Yeah.
- 46:15John Thompson: And the one that I actually think is possibly the most meaningful for our profession is, again, huge musical philosophers Fun Boy 3 and Banana Roma.
- 46:27John Thompson: It ain't what you do, it's the and Banana Roma.
- 46:28John Thompson: It ain't what you do, it's the way you do it and that's what gets results.
- 46:33John Thompson: And if you think carefully about that and British people are very good at this, because we've all probably experienced you standing at a bar and one of your friends walks in, slaps you on the back and goes how are you doing?
- 46:47John Thompson: You bastard Americans don't understand that, yeah, but if you do it in a nice voice with a big smile on your face, it's fine yeah, if you walk up with several knuckle dusters and a machete and do it, yeah, it's different.
- 47:04John Thompson: So it's not just what you do, it's the way that you do it, and and and.
- 47:07John Thompson: Life is not black and white, it's full of gray areas.
- 47:12John Thompson: And you and back to what we were saying before about natural behaviors.
- 47:15John Thompson: I bet a lot of our people who say, oh, I'm not sure I could ask that question, I'm not sure I could do this, they've probably got friends where they behaved in a flippant manner, and it's natural yeah, I was researching and writing a piece recently on.
- 47:33Paul Shrimpling: You know how language develops.
- 47:35Paul Shrimpling: You know from childhood, all the way through, and there was a line in the research which goes everyone learns how to communicate until they stop learning how to communicate yeah, yeah and uh, you know, it's like in my world, the way, the way I'm wired, you know, every day is a learning day.
- 47:54Paul Shrimpling: There's always, which is why I love running the podcast, because it's like, oh, there's got to be several insights from today.
- 47:59Paul Shrimpling: Um, there's always something that can just shift, not what we do, but how we do it.
- 48:05Paul Shrimpling: Just to pick up on the fun boy three banana, which and, by the way, it's probably one of my most quoted references, because it is it ain't what you do, it is how you do it.
- 48:14Paul Shrimpling: The way that you do it, you've got to finish the line up and you get the results.
- 48:18Paul Shrimpling: You can't not use the words.
- 48:21John Thompson: Paul, we've all probably written or received awful emails from people and the message is correct and we understand the message, but the way it's written is awful, yeah I agree and and, by the way, they should have picked up the phone and had a conversation rather than written it in a chuffed email shouldn't they.
- 48:43Paul Shrimpling: yeah, you know, I don't know if this frustrates you, but, but you know, the default communication tool of the profession has turned into email and actually and I get this complaint all the time from business leaders we can't get our people to pick up the phone.
- 48:57Paul Shrimpling: We're finding it difficult, post-covid, to get people to get back into a room with clients in their premises.
- 49:03Paul Shrimpling: You know, I don't know if you're experiencing, you know, similar frustrations or struggles and if you are, what, what, what, what, what a firm's doing to overcome that?
- 49:13John Thompson: because the deeper, the stronger the relationship, the more likely they're going to stay as a loyal client and the more likely they're going to recommend and refer you it's um, it's an interesting one where maybe it's another standard operating process needs to be put in place and discussed with the team and explain to them why this is important.
- 49:37John Thompson: You know Zoom and Teams and Google Meets, et cetera.
- 49:43John Thompson: They're great.
- 49:43John Thompson: They're great, but you can't beat sitting around a table having a cup of coffee, sharing a biscuit and just looking at the body language and just picking up what's going on.
- 50:04Paul Shrimpling: Do you think there's a generational level of resistance to that younger than there is older, or is that just where we're at?
- 50:08Paul Shrimpling: There is a general resistance and therefore we have to take it into our leadership hands and build standing operating processes, backed up by our crm and measurement processes, that make it crystal clear what's expected of people.
- 50:23Paul Shrimpling: Given that we are a relationship business in the world of accountancy, what are your thoughts?
- 50:29Paul Shrimpling: Relational?
- 50:30Paul Shrimpling: Um does it matter, and let's just zero in on what we have to do about it there's an it.
- 50:36John Thompson: Well, kpis are a really interesting topic because what most people think are kpis are not really kpis.
- 50:44John Thompson: They're key performance measurements rather than KPIs.
- 50:48John Thompson: And behind the measurement one, two, three levels back is one or two single actions, which are the core indicators, and I'm aware of a very small number of practices that do this.
- 51:09John Thompson: But one of the KPIs is how many clients have you spoken to on the phone this week?
- 51:16John Thompson: And it's actually as simple as that, because extrapolate that forward.
- 51:26John Thompson: You're probably going to lose less clients.
- 51:31John Thompson: You're probably going to be given more introductions to potential new clients from that single action.
- 51:41John Thompson: And it's amazing how many people can't do it.
- 51:47John Thompson: Even if you said you must make one phone call a day to a client and just say hey, paul, how are you doing?
- 51:53John Thompson: And I don't know what the percentage would be, but I'm guessing there would be a percentage where you'd go.
- 52:01John Thompson: I'm glad you rang.
- 52:03John Thompson: I was just thinking about giving you a ring about A, b and C.
- 52:08Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, I was in conversation with people listening to this might know Chris Downing, who's at Sage, was with a good accounting firm before he was at Sage and, like you've just said, there I've suggested more phone calls, more meetings with clients typically results in more loyal clients, more work, more referrals.
- 52:33Paul Shrimpling: Haven't necessarily got a bank of evidence to prove that, but I have yet to come across a partner leader of an accounting firm, who doesn't say it's funny how the more meetings I have, the more work I get.
- 52:45Paul Shrimpling: There's a direct correlation.
- 52:47Paul Shrimpling: I share this with Chris and he said in 2008, in a conversation I had with him only a couple of weeks ago, I said I went back into the firm and I looked at our CRM and ropey as the data might have been looked at, the KPIs and as challenged as that might be or unclear checked people's diaries.
- 53:05Paul Shrimpling: But I did a granular, you know, exercise in.
- 53:09Paul Shrimpling: Is this right?
- 53:09Paul Shrimpling: And he says without any shadow of a doubt, the people who had more phone calls and more meetings with clients had a faster growing portfolio than the ones that didn't category but undeniable back in the day back in the day, I'm sure, when we were training.
- 53:28John Thompson: It's not such a big thing now and I can understand that with the way business is conducted now and also with COVID et cetera.
- 53:36John Thompson: But business lunches a lot of the team thought that was a perk.
- 53:44John Thompson: And they didn't.
- 53:46John Thompson: Maybe it wasn't communicated to them properly, but it wasn't.
- 53:51John Thompson: Until they got a bit more senior they realized it wasn't a perk because my old, my old boss slash mentor.
- 54:00John Thompson: He said to me john, you're pretty good at bringing in work.
- 54:05John Thompson: Yeah, and I go yeah, he's right.
- 54:06John Thompson: If you're not having two lunches a week, I want to know why.
- 54:10John Thompson: And that was the standard, and actually it was a bit like yourself.
- 54:17John Thompson: Could I 100% prove it on a spreadsheet?
- 54:20John Thompson: No, but if I did two lunches a week, we got more work.
- 54:26John Thompson: If I was on holiday and those lunches didn't happen, guess what?
- 54:30Paul Shrimpling: There was a bit of a drop it's a powerful KPI number of calls, number of meetings, number of lunches.
- 54:39Paul Shrimpling: It's a relationship KPI people forget what CRM means, paul.
- 54:45John Thompson: These days it's more like to be a coffee.
- 54:48Paul Shrimpling: No one wants a two hour lunch anymore they've got to go to the gym to work it off, haven't they?
- 54:54John Thompson: but now it's coffee a 30 minute coffee.
- 54:57Paul Shrimpling: Now I get that.
- 54:58Paul Shrimpling: So, John, you hindered right at the start of this conversation about the fact you'd worked in a regional firm and you three times the fees in two years, did you say?
- 55:09John Thompson: Yeah, in two years we tripled the top line.
- 55:11Paul Shrimpling: Right, so what was going on there?
- 55:17John Thompson: We and you may have sort of heard of this we, the firm was called harris walters, a managing partner's guy called richard walters who was the guy who said to me you've got to go out for lunch twice a week, john.
- 55:27John Thompson: Otherwise I want to know why.
- 55:28John Thompson: Yeah, and we um targeted clients of bigger firms, not not giant firms, but firms bigger than us.
- 55:37John Thompson: We thought so.
- 55:38John Thompson: They're a bit bigger than us, so their average spend for that client's going to be better than we've got.
- 55:41John Thompson: Let's target them, yeah.
- 55:43John Thompson: And we essentially went along to them and we organized meetings and and we it sounds crazy all we just said was what's your plans?
- 55:53John Thompson: Tell us what your plans are.
- 55:55John Thompson: Yeah, that, don't want to see your accounts, just Tell us what your plans are.
- 55:58John Thompson: Yeah, don't want to see your accounts, just tell us what your plans are.
- 56:00John Thompson: And then we offered them.
- 56:01John Thompson: We said right, come away and spend a day with us.
- 56:05John Thompson: Don't have to pay us anything, just spend a day with us.
- 56:10John Thompson: And the feedback from that was we helped them put together a high level strategy for themselves and for their business.
- 56:21John Thompson: And the feedback we always got was my accountant never does anything like this with me.
- 56:27John Thompson: My accountant never asks me these questions.
- 56:30John Thompson: My accountant actually doesn't really understand me or my business.
- 56:33John Thompson: My accountant couldn't even tell me my wife, my wife's name.
- 56:36John Thompson: My accountant doesn't even know that I'm part investor in an office block of a development in tenerife, um, because nothing's ever been remitted.
- 56:50John Thompson: So why does he need to know?
- 56:51John Thompson: And and so on.
- 56:53John Thompson: And therefore we just naturally acquired these people and we got, and there was won't name names, but there was one big local firm got really, really annoyed with this and I just thought well, that's just tough cookie, mate.
- 57:12John Thompson: You know, if you knew the things that your clients who are now our clients had us about you, you'd be shocked yeah, yeah.
- 57:19Paul Shrimpling: You earn the right to the results you get, don't you whether they're good?
- 57:23John Thompson: or bad, yeah, and and we probably.
- 57:27John Thompson: Um, like I say, we, we tripled the top line and the split on fees was probably probably compliance, about 60, what would now be called advisory, about 40%.
- 57:42Paul Shrimpling: Brilliant.
- 57:42Paul Shrimpling: I remember working with firms who were using the Harris-Walters toolkit.
- 57:47Paul Shrimpling: John going back 20 years Fascinating.
- 57:51Paul Shrimpling: So one of the and I know we're sort of relatively short of time now, but this is my penultimate question Scaling advisory is I get pushback all the time from the leaders.
- 58:05Paul Shrimpling: So I might have a leader in a firm who's and I was talking to two literally in the last two days who are actually you know, they've cracked this have more conversations with more business owners about more personal stuff more often and all of a sudden they see the transformation in the relationship, transformation in their willingness to buy extra services and want to talk about the stuff that really matters to them.
- 58:30Paul Shrimpling: But they can't get the team to do it.
- 58:35Paul Shrimpling: We can't scale and leverage this, but they can't get the team to do it.
- 58:41Paul Shrimpling: We can't scale and leverage this.
- 58:42Paul Shrimpling: We can't.
- 58:42Paul Shrimpling: You know, um, no matter what the sops are, no matter what uh, we've tried, we're just not.
- 58:45Paul Shrimpling: We've failed miserably in getting others to do this.
- 58:49Paul Shrimpling: What's the solution there, john, do you think?
- 58:51John Thompson: well, I think, um, it'd be interesting to know what their sops are.
- 58:55John Thompson: I think, a little bit like anything, you've got to be realistic on your timescales.
- 59:02John Thompson: This is not going to be switching a light on and off.
- 59:05John Thompson: You're going to have to develop this over, I'd say.
- 59:12John Thompson: I'd think it's a three-year plan, and three years in the modern business world is deemed to be a be huge, long period of time, whereas it's not really.
- 59:21John Thompson: No, um, and the other thing you've got to do, you've got to put your measurement.
- 59:26John Thompson: You've got to align your management system measurement system, sorry with what you're trying to do.
- 59:31John Thompson: And you've also and I'll use the word brave again you've got to align your reward systems with what you're trying to do.
- 59:34John Thompson: Because, if you really believe, you've got to align your reward systems with what you're trying to do, because if you really believe this, you've got to actually make it happen.
- 59:42John Thompson: And there's other things which need to be done as well is, and that is, you can't.
- 59:52John Thompson: You've got to be brave enough.
- 59:54John Thompson: Again, I'm using the word brave.
- 59:56John Thompson: You cannot see this as being something that sits alongside what you've got to be brave enough.
- 59:58John Thompson: Again, I'm using the word brave.
- 59:59John Thompson: You cannot see this as being something that sits alongside what you've got.
- 1:00:02John Thompson: It's got to be integrated, it's got to be part of what we do and the phrase that, I think, is the challenge to our profession, which is interesting because I think most clients would absolutely agree with this Put yourself in your client's shoes and everything's advisory.
- 1:00:25John Thompson: Because if you go back to that little model I explained of the primary, the secondary and the tertiary, where do you put audit?
- 1:00:31John Thompson: Audit's a secondary service.
- 1:00:33John Thompson: Accounts prep is a secondary service.
- 1:00:36John Thompson: Tax return preps our secondary services, and it's all driven by the primary conversations.
- 1:00:43John Thompson: Because the example I would give is I could come along to an accountant who doesn't know me from anywhere and and they're going to have a conversation with me and they're going to ask me stuff like so what are you trying to do?
- 1:00:54John Thompson: Where did you come from, etc.
- 1:00:56John Thompson: Etc.
- 1:00:56John Thompson: Etc.
- 1:00:57John Thompson: And at some point, particularly if I'm a startup that you know existing structures don't exist, they're going to say well, it seems to me, john, that the best thing for you to be to have a limited company.
- 1:01:09John Thompson: Don't worry, to begin with you won't need an audit, it'll be as simple, what we call a cast job, but you'll also need this doing and that doing and this doing, and I'm going yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:01:21John Thompson: And if I'm not an accountant, you're advising me.
- 1:01:24John Thompson: This is an advisory service.
- 1:01:26John Thompson: We're talking about my future, we're talking about what's important to me and you're helping me clarify my thinking.
- 1:01:32John Thompson: You're helping me put together what you might call a bit of a plan.
- 1:01:36John Thompson: Look, you know, I want to achieve these things and this is how we're going to do it and this is the support you're going to give me.
- 1:01:41John Thompson: So one day, if I had a magic wand, paul, I'd say look, this compliance versus advisory thing is a complete red herring.
- 1:01:51John Thompson: We're just looking after our clients.
- 1:01:54John Thompson: We're just helping our clients build the wealth and the lives they want.
- 1:02:00John Thompson: And I accept, in PLC world it's different, but there's still elements of PLC world which this is applicable to, because the chief exec has got his personal agenda, whether we like it or not.
- 1:02:13John Thompson: The FD's got his personal agenda, whether we like it or not, and yeah, he's got certain he's got his personal agenda, whether we like it or not.
- 1:02:19John Thompson: And yeah, he's got certain he's got more regulations to deal with, but he's still going to make sure he hits his bonus, he's still going to make sure he gets his share options, etc.
- 1:02:29John Thompson: Etc.
- 1:02:29John Thompson: And that's still going to enable him to buy a nice place in portugal, to go on a nice holiday, to wherever, to put the ridiculous, huge, monstrous kitchen in that his wife wants.
- 1:02:43John Thompson: So it's always the personal side.
- 1:02:47John Thompson: But the big stumbling block is we are obsessed with compliance.
- 1:02:51John Thompson: I hate the word compliance, I hate it, terrible word.
- 1:02:56John Thompson: And they use it in other other professions as well, and they, etc.
- 1:03:00John Thompson: And when you're working in a manufacturing business on the shop floor and there's certain regulations you've got to follow, etc.
- 1:03:08John Thompson: You do not say I'm compliant, it's just not there.
- 1:03:15John Thompson: So we've got to put ourselves in our client's shoes and we've got to say look, you know what's going on in these guys' minds.
- 1:03:20John Thompson: They're not differentiating between the preparation of a tax return and a piece of tax advice that saves them 20 grand.
- 1:03:29John Thompson: They're just saying you're my tax advisor, aren't you?
- 1:03:33John Thompson: Isn't that what you do, isn't it?
- 1:03:35John Thompson: Yeah, love that.
- 1:03:45John Thompson: So our, our profession is.
- 1:03:46John Thompson: In many other industries they are much more custom I mean, our profession would hate this but they are much more customer focused than we are.
- 1:03:49John Thompson: We we are some of us are too obsessed with.
- 1:03:55John Thompson: It's all about the compliance, it's all about the regulation and we've got to cross this T and dot this.
- 1:04:00John Thompson: I Well, hang on, yes, but the client doesn't care about that.
- 1:04:04John Thompson: The client wants to know that they are doing better by working with you.
- 1:04:15Paul Shrimpling: And if they're not and I would argue John and some people might be listening to this going well, yeah, we get that about compliance.
- 1:04:21Paul Shrimpling: I would then say, well, if you're not compliance obsessed, you probably uh, get the job finished obsessed.
- 1:04:27Paul Shrimpling: Get the tax return done, get the serve, get the accounts job done, get the vat out, get the you, you service line.
- 1:04:34Paul Shrimpling: You're still in your secondary tier that you referenced.
- 1:04:38Paul Shrimpling: And if your obsession is there, you're in volume land.
- 1:04:44Paul Shrimpling: You're not in.
- 1:04:45Paul Shrimpling: Get close to your client land, which is almost certainly the route you want to reduce in the volume of work and the stress levels and up the level of interest, enjoyment, pride and value and secure the future of interest, enjoyment, pride and value and secure the future of your firm because you're closer to the personal lives, the personal wealth.
- 1:05:03John Thompson: There's a really interesting task force I'm sure you've come across before where you could speak to a managing partner and you could say pick a client, any client and they choose a client.
- 1:05:13John Thompson: They say tell me about them.
- 1:05:14John Thompson: And too many accountants will say, oh well, they're a december year end and you think I don't care what the year end is, we can move the year end, tell me about them.
- 1:05:27John Thompson: And if they turn around and some of them do to be fair, and say, well, actually they're a um, they're a business that works in this sector and it's owned by two brothers and a cousin and and I'm thinking hallelujah, they're talking about the client, not about whether a december year end, because that's about the practice.
- 1:05:47John Thompson: Well, it's a december year end, so we've got to do the stock taking early december or end of november and we've got to do this and that and that's all about the accountant, it's not about the client yeah, that's back to your point that not not as client-centric as they could should be.
- 1:06:02John Thompson: And and by client, based on this conversation, john, you're suggesting it's the human being leading and managing owning that SME it's the people, because the, because the businesses could come and go, but those, hopefully, those people would be around for 70, 80, 90 years.
- 1:06:19Paul Shrimpling: Yeah, in one generation or another.
- 1:06:21Paul Shrimpling: So, of everything we've covered, john, last question of everything we've covered, we've got managers and leaders of accounting firms listening into this.
- 1:06:28Paul Shrimpling: If there was one thing they could should do more of better of one thing based on our conversation today, what would you anchor them to?
- 1:06:36Paul Shrimpling: What would you go?
- 1:06:38Paul Shrimpling: Look, if you're going to make something of this podcast, do something with it, take decisions and action off the back of it.
- 1:06:43Paul Shrimpling: What one thing would you have them do?
- 1:06:46John Thompson: Well, I'd suggest two things.
- 1:06:48John Thompson: One thing is, put yourself in your client's shoes and everything's advisory and start to switch the culture of your practice to be that way and I appreciate that might be a bit daunting for a lot of people, but the number one simple thing they could do is think about your team, and obviously you might not want to ask trainees to do this, but there's a certain level where you can ask them to do this and pick a number.
- 1:07:25John Thompson: I want you to ring three clients a week, one client a day.
- 1:07:29John Thompson: Just ask them how they are and record the responses, because it is likely we will find out things we never knew which will either protect the client relationship or enable us to actually provide them with services they've never had before.
- 1:07:54Paul Shrimpling: And, just to mirror something you said right at the beginning probably reduce the risk profile of your firm because you're closer to your clients and therefore, yeah, absolutely All sorts of upsides benefits come from that.
- 1:08:04Paul Shrimpling: John, I can't thank you enough for taking time out just before you disappear on holiday.
- 1:08:12Paul Shrimpling: Hopefully you enjoy this as much as I have Really appreciate you being so open, candid and up for sharing key insights in that how do we build a more human practice?
- 1:08:25Paul Shrimpling: Thank you very much.
- 1:08:28John Thompson: Thanks, Paul.
- 1:08:35Paul Shrimpling: In this conversation with John Thompson, we've talked about standard operating procedures.
- 1:08:40Paul Shrimpling: We've talked about how you change the culture of your firm so that you're building new service lines stronger, better, more valuable service lines that deliver greater fees and greater profits to fees and greater profits.
- 1:09:00Paul Shrimpling: We're talking about changing your view of yourself and your firm so that you naturally see yourselves as an advisory firm, a firm that delivers significant value to your existing clients, so that they want to stay with you and want to recommend you and want to buy more services.
- 1:09:12Paul Shrimpling: Essentially, what I'm describing here is the Accountants Growth Academy a series of workshop sessions and follow up, support and accountability that helps you influence change, take different decisions, follow through on actions that delivers the results you want for your firm.
- 1:09:31Paul Shrimpling: If you want to find out more about the Growth Academy, go to the show notes and check out the link that you'll find there.
- 1:09:37Paul Shrimpling: More about the Growth Academy go to the show notes and check out the link that you'll find there.
- 1:09:41Paul Shrimpling: You'll find more valuable discussions with the leaders of ambitious accounting firms.
- 1:09:45Paul Shrimpling: At humanizethenumbersonline, you can also sign up to be notified each time a new podcast is made available.
- 1:09:50Paul Shrimpling: You're about to hear a short excerpt from a podcast discussion with russell watkins about lean process kaizen how to improve the results of your firm.
- 1:10:06Paul Shrimpling: If you like what you hear and you want to get to the full podcast, go to your favorite podcast platform or go to humanize the numbers dot online.
- 1:10:15Paul Shrimpling: There's a fellow called fujioio Cho.
- 1:10:17Speaker 3: He was summarizing how he wanted people to behave in their business and he said go see, ask.
- 1:10:26Speaker 3: Why show respect?
- 1:10:27Speaker 3: So go see means don't assume what you're told.
- 1:10:30Speaker 3: Don't just look at your numbers.
- 1:10:31Speaker 3: Go and look at what's actually happening and go and talk to the people who are doing the work, and that can be an office or a shop floor, it could be anywhere.
- 1:10:38Speaker 3: Let's go see, ask.
- 1:10:39Speaker 3: Why is not ask who made this error?
- 1:10:42Speaker 3: It is, why do we think this happened in the first place?
- 1:10:45Speaker 3: Or why is this such a difficult thing to do?
- 1:10:48Speaker 3: And that takes you towards the problem solving five.
- 1:10:51Speaker 3: Why's get into the root cause and then show respect is be clear that in a manufacturing plant, the people who truly add value are those who are putting stuff together.
- 1:11:03Speaker 3: The rest of us are just here to support that, and so, for example, it becomes really interesting when you talk about an accountancy or a firm of lawyers, because nothing is made except the definition of value is very clear for me.
- 1:11:20Speaker 3: So in a manufacturing plant, the definition of value is something that transforms the product towards what the customer wants physical transformation.
- 1:11:29Speaker 3: In an accountancy firm or this engineering services firm, I define it as you are anytime you pass on usable information.
- 1:11:38Speaker 3: Usable information for the next step in our process that delivers something for the customer, because accountants and all other financial services, for example, they are full of unclear processes with necessary, unnecessary steps and multiple rework loops the kind of things I was talking about earlier.