Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Dec 22nd-Ark Nova
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin. We look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to Board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. Just when I
- 0:32mentioned yesterday, yesterday, that's right, just Civilization and New Dawn and how
- 0:38it's similar in its mechanisms to this game. We finally get to talk about
- 0:42the smash hit of twenty twenty. So twenty twenty one. I don't know.
- 0:49I'm gonna look on my phone. I played at at Laria Con this
- 0:51year. I've got a lovely mechanical keyboard on my phone. It was so
- 0:55new twenty twenty one. Dave twenty twenty one. Yeah, time flys if
- 0:59it was the expansion, can pust fuck it? Steven it? Well,
- 1:02I know that at Larria Khan it was so popular you couldn't even like get
- 1:04a copy of it on the tabor. You had to like stand it.
- 1:07So or maybe maybe did I play it in twenty twenty two and I can't
- 1:10even remember he did? Yeah, so it's twenty twenty two that I played
- 1:14it. Yeah, God, I'm getting old, like because it released to
- 1:17twenty twenty one and you played in Larria Con twenty twenty six. God years
- 1:19or off the tree of my life. You know, do you remember who
- 1:23he played it? Yeah? Famed board game designer Isaac Shale. Indeed.
- 1:26So I'm going to ask you a question, Steve. You're always asking me
- 1:30questions. So I consider myself, you know, a commentator on the art
- 1:36form. Yes, yeah, I don't think that's an illegitimate claim, is
- 1:40it. I think you are one of the few people in the hobby who
- 1:44can legitimately claim to be a critic in the best possible sense. So I
- 1:49have not played this game. Is this a dereliction of duty? I would
- 1:57say yes, it is, because if you're going to have your finger on
- 2:01the pulse of the hobby, whether you like it or not, you have
- 2:05to give it a throw for the games that the hobby is talking about.
- 2:08So, and it's not a bad game, by the way. So this
- 2:12one is considered the fourth best game ever made. Overrated I think we were
- 2:15talking about three days ago. What does it mean to be overrated? I
- 2:20don't know if we ever came down on like whether or not Terraforming Mars is
- 2:23overrated. I think you say yes, I think it is, and I
- 2:25say, well, and maybe I could say something similar about Ark Noova,
- 2:30it's so popular. I mean, maybe I'm wrong, maybe I'm missing something.
- 2:32Terraforming Mars I think is better than ark Nova. Ark Nova is like
- 2:38just another as you would call it silver, a zero game with a bunch
- 2:42of mechanisms, and it has a cute animal theme. So let's talk about
- 2:46this animal theme then, yes, So since Wingspan was the one that's sort
- 2:52of introduced, that's my theory. And there were loads of animal games.
- 2:55But my theory is is that it's a coffee table game, and I think
- 3:00there was a bandwagon effect after and the theme is kind of inconsequential. It's
- 3:02the general stylistic milieure into which it fits. But does no raving a cute
- 3:12animal theme theme fit into my bourgeoisification of games? The theme of cute animals,
- 3:23I mean, seems very bourgeois, I guess, unless you're trying to
- 3:27make an argument about like like sort of green politics and conservation, very like
- 3:32bourgeois sorts of is he is he? Well? Okay, and they certainly
- 3:37are these days. So I've criticized Friday for future like Arkanova is sort of
- 3:40like owning a tesla, right, So I've criticized Friday's for Future, not
- 3:46because I disagree with it, because I think it's a it's a middle class
- 3:50affectation. You mean gluing your hand to the pavement. No, No,
- 3:53Friday's for Future that you you do a march on a Friday afternoon. It
- 3:57was what got Turnberg staff. Okay, so you you think that the people
- 4:00who poo their hands to the pavement are more legit? No, no,
- 4:02no, that's what I'm saying. My criticism with Fridays for Future was that
- 4:08there are sways of people, mostly working class people, who would not be
- 4:16able to convince their boss to give them a few hours off on Friday afternoon
- 4:21to let them go on the march. You've got to fucking operate that lead.
- 4:25So it's ostensibly a middle class movement that expressly excludes the working class.
- 4:31Therefore, I think working class people, as much as anybody, should be
- 4:35interested in the degradation of our environment. But Friday's Future explicitly excludes them simply
- 4:43by holding it on a Friday. Right, should you give up the alliteration
- 4:48to allow the working class to join in on it? Ah? So then
- 4:53we could do like Saturdays for shagging. Okay, Sundays for shagging I can't
- 5:01do Monday. You can't do Mondays because you know the same reason. Exactly.
- 5:04Yeah, we need four day work week, Ben. Well, indeed,
- 5:09that's only gonna be for like middle class tech you you you working class
- 5:14people. I'm pointing to you, Ben, You're still gonna have to work
- 5:15five maybe six days a week, exactly. Someone's got to fucking clean the
- 5:19AI. Boy, someone's got to deliver your fucking lunches. I'm not gonna
- 5:24go out and get lunch by myself, close busy, like you know,
- 5:27making slide shows for my meetings exactly. Yeah. So, yeah, explained
- 5:32to me, is arc Nova because I really don't know anything about it?
- 5:36Is aren't Noova? It's got like hexagons? Is it like an environmentally themed
- 5:42game? Oh yeah, yeah. It's all about conservation and building habitats for
- 5:47protected species from what I recall, so no fits squarely into that category.
- 5:53And you you research technologies to this effect, you get bonuses to this effect.
- 5:58You're like building you actually like build out your own zoo for this purpose.
- 6:03I just think it's like very it's very like shaggy game that can mix.
- 6:10It's long. It's a long one, right, yeah, I mean
- 6:14not not like longer than average for a fucking silver azuro game these days.
- 6:19I didn't have a bad time playing it, right, and you can get
- 6:21into it, you learn it. It's not like, you know, a
- 6:24big headache or anything like that. I just don't understand why it's what is
- 6:28it number four? Yeah, number four game of all time. I mean
- 6:30this, like I was saying the other day, this sort of cult of
- 6:33the new that puts just the most popular game as the best game on the
- 6:38list, that that's really that's really annoying you. It doesn't disservice in a
- 6:44sense to to the to the hobby in some way. I mean, if
- 6:46you're going to talk about, like the best novel ever written, is it
- 6:49going to be? Is it likely going to be a novel that's been written
- 6:53in like the last two years, Well you might argue that. You might
- 6:56argue, and I think this argument could legitimately have some weight. The board
- 7:00games hasn't really legitimized itself as an art form until the last twenty years.
- 7:06Katan is the first instantiation of a sort of artful board game as opposed to
- 7:14something that is a distraction and the advancement in game design. Yeah, it
- 7:21has been has been huge in the last twenty ti years. Yeah. I
- 7:26mean, on the other hand, you get the Sam bankman Fried argument,
- 7:28who he apparently said Shakespeare could not possibly be as great as everybody thinks that
- 7:31he is, because like there are more people writing like more plays now and
- 7:36producing more writing now than any other time in human history. What are the
- 7:42odds that, like, the greatest writer in the English language would have been
- 7:45one of the first writing in some modern version of the English language, and
- 7:50we're not just all sort of part of some consensual collective delusion, is yeah,
- 7:56exactly. So it's an interesting, like, it's an interesting statistical argument,
- 7:59right, I mean, the same art argument would say that we are
- 8:01probably living at the moment when there are like there will never be like many
- 8:05more human beings alive than there are now, Like there's no future for humanity
- 8:09in which there are trillions of us right living around like the Solar system.
- 8:13That's rather a mouth hughsy in arguments night, Well, the idea Thomas mouth
- 8:16has thought he was right. Well, it's a it's a statistical argument,
- 8:20like if if there's a future in which there are trillions of humans living throughout
- 8:22the Solar system. Statistically speaking, you would most likely to be you would
- 8:28throughout all of human history, You're most likely to be alive at that time,
- 8:31but you in fact alive now. Therefore, this is probably the peak
- 8:35something like that. I don't know if I completely buy it, because I
- 8:39think that people can be definitive of a form as well, like Montagne and
- 8:45the Essay, Shakespeare and likes play Ben Maddox and you know, like purvy
- 8:52poems about like masturbation and killing homeless people. Yep, sometimes people just like
- 8:58you know, come right out of the gates. I got arrested for that.
- 9:05But you see what I mean. I mean, like it's it's not
- 9:09as if it's unfair to compare the latest output of any artistic form with what
- 9:13came before, would established the genre in the first place. I mean,
- 9:16sometimes they are. They are like the benchmark according to which we judge everything
- 9:20else, and they we shouldn't forget them. So I'd like you to steal
- 9:22man Arkanova's position as as number four, as number four, steal money,
- 9:33steal man it. I mean, it's got like hexagons in that this is
- 9:41incredible bull getting criticism. No, I can't do it. I can't like
- 9:43I can't justify ark Nova being number four, Like, I don't think there's
- 9:48anything like, Okay, what does that say about the game, that there's
- 9:52something distinctive about it, or that it simply does what a lot of other
- 9:56games do better than they do. Yeah, I mean clear clear If you
- 10:00were to clearly if you like to tap one hundred doesn't even make sense.
- 10:03Well clearly. If you were to make a sort of rational argument, you
- 10:07might argue that more people are animated to rate stuff on board game Geek because
- 10:15the explosion, yeah for sure, And the games you play when you get
- 10:20into the hobby tend to stick with you longer, and so people have been
- 10:24motivated to rate. That would be the and that would be the rational argument
- 10:28where it's stick Well, they're fucking games. They're fun, like you play
- 10:31them and you have good feelings about them. And like I played this once.
- 10:35I don't think I can even really comment on it. I played it
- 10:37once two years ago, so who am I to say anything about it?
- 10:39But I think most people they they they get the game, they play it,
- 10:43they have a good time, and like fucking rate at ten because they
- 10:46just played a game. And more people are rating now than previously. That's
- 10:48the reason. But and and and it's not like a bad game like a
- 10:52great game. There are so many great games. Tom Bassel once said it
- 10:56was his favorite game of all time. Right, I don't get it.
- 10:58I mean I would be in to know it's popular and people play it,
- 11:01they have fun, they rated highly, and because more people are playing more
- 11:05games, and so many games are great because like I guess, it's well
- 11:09understood now how to design a decent game. But does the game? Does
- 11:13the game have anything inherently within it that will justify its position. It's got
- 11:16animals in that. I mean you think that's it. I honestly so to
- 11:22me, Like I said, I played it once. But it has like
- 11:26a lot of different mechanisms going on. It's got the the action selection mechanism
- 11:31from Civilization and MoU Dan. And you're building a zoo with some hexagons,
- 11:35and you're putting animals in the zoo, and you're doing some like card drafting,
- 11:39and you've got a tech tree. I mean, there are like lots
- 11:41of elements of gameplay in it, but not like some sort of like through
- 11:48line that makes me think this is brilliant, this is genius, This is
- 11:50like the one thing that makes this game memorable and worthy of being played timed
- 11:56again and of a number four spot on this list. So at people will
- 12:00say, well, it's massively original. That's why it's pretty not not noble.
- 12:03Specifically, my father's work is far more original. I think so.
- 12:05And I'm just pointing because you brought it to the market. Why did you
- 12:09bring my father's work to the Christmas market? I'll just carrying it around and
- 12:11people go, oh, because the voice. But it's interesting, right,
- 12:16I don't think so. We were talking about Shakespeare as always. Do you
- 12:22think he's startlingly original? I mean, this could be a long conversation.
- 12:28I mean it's just very conformist in terms of form, right, yeah,
- 12:33I mean in some ways yes, in some ways no. And there's a
- 12:35lot about Shakespeare that is derivative, but but not just derivative. Conformist is
- 12:41what I'm for sure for Specifically, I am a panamaton Yeah, writing within
- 12:46certain modes and genres and sticking to the structure of those, even the contents
- 12:52right right, even even the storylines, but the the assemblage of parts and
- 12:56the way he put together put them together so still counts for something. So
- 13:01maybe we're not looking for startling original Do we overrate originality when we talk about
- 13:07very likely? Yes? But is it is it originality or is it taking
- 13:11the existing materials and remixing them in a way that it can produce something new?
- 13:16Novel? Unexpected? Was Titan original? Titan? Yeah? That Italian
- 13:22painter Titan. There is actually a board game called Titan. I thought you
- 13:26meant that. No, I'm talking about the painter Titan. Titan was the
- 13:30original? His name's Titan, Yeah, Titan, Yeah, Titan. What
- 13:33did you paint? Titan? I don't know. I'm going to look on
- 13:35my phone. What did Titan write? Talk about? Titian? What did
- 13:39Titan paint mean? Titian A lovely, lovely mechanical keyboard on my phone?
- 13:43Titian Dido, So have a look Venus of Urbino, sacred and profane?
- 13:52Yep, Diana and acting on. That's all Titan? So was the original?
- 13:58There were probably one hundreds of painters painting stuff that looks like that.
- 14:01Why did these survive? Why did these stick in our memory? Why were
- 14:05they definitive of their genres? I mean, I don't I chose him as
- 14:09an example because corner him Titan is a good guy. Yeah, it's hilarious.
- 14:13It's hilarious. It's not as good as a Saturday Night Live routine in
- 14:16which they refer to him as Titian. What about Dant was the original Dan?
- 14:24I think Dent was more original than Bokatch right anyway, So anyway,
- 14:31Christmas, Steve, I'm gonna go and get another drink. So you think
- 14:33aren't No was shit? And it should all the Coppees should be burned,
- 14:35exactly' saying what what? Thank you for listening. You can support the show
- 14:43at Patreon dot com, forward slash five GFID, and join the discord by
- 14:46going to five g fd dot com. Have a very merry Christmas,