Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E021: Michael Saylor – Pursuit of Bitcoin Yield
Transcript
- 0:00Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 0:04We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 0:08Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 0:12unaffected by the demand. If you want to preserve your
- 0:16wealth, you have to convert that currency into an asset that's
- 0:21scarce, desirable, portable, durable, and maintainable.
- 0:26Hello, I'm Andy, Ed Strom and I'm happy to welcome you to the
- 0:2921st episode of Scarce Assets, a show that examined scarcity, the
- 0:33most fundamental driver of economics and markets and the
- 0:36scarcest asset of all, which is Bitcoin.
- 0:39It's great to be here with my Co host Jesse Myers and our guest,
- 0:42the inimitable Michael Saylor. Now within the Bitcoin space,
- 0:46Michael really needs no introduction, but we do have
- 0:48some listeners who are new to Bitcoin, so I'll say just a
- 0:51couple things. First, Michael has envisioned
- 0:54and implemented a corporate Bitcoin strategy that has
- 0:57allowed him to deliver unparalleled investment returns
- 1:00to shareholders of his company, MicroStrategy.
- 1:03And second, I think that Michael has educated more people about
- 1:06Bitcoin than anyone. And since education is the most
- 1:09important path to widespread Bitcoin adoption, he may be the
- 1:13most important man in Bitcoin today.
- 1:15So that's why I thought it would be fitting to honor him with
- 1:17Episode 21 of Scarce Assets. And I'm so delighted that he has
- 1:21honored us by speaking with us today.
- 1:23So, Michael, how are you? Thanks for having me gentlemen,
- 1:27happy to be here. Excellent, excellent.
- 1:29Well, it feels like already quite a bit of water under the
- 1:33bridge, I think since we first encountered each other.
- 1:35You laid out the Bitcoin treasury strategy for your
- 1:40company MicroStrategy about four years ago, and your stock has
- 1:44outperformed all the big tech companies.
- 1:46Why do you think we haven't seen more companies implement your
- 1:50strategy yet? You know, I, I think the three
- 1:54big three big planks of corporate adoption of Bitcoin
- 2:00are #1 fair accounting and we started with indefinite
- 2:08intangible accounting and we get fair value accounting in January
- 2:12of 2025. That's mandatory.
- 2:15So there's been about a, you know, a four year period of
- 2:19normalizing the accounting. I think the accounting was is
- 2:24hostile and prejudicial to a well run company just because if
- 2:29you, if you can only lose money and you can never make money on
- 2:32an investment, a reasonable CEO or CFO would say would say, I
- 2:38don't know if I want to make that investment.
- 2:39And so even though the reality is you would make money on an
- 2:44accounting basis, it would look like you're losing money.
- 2:46So I think that was the first challenge.
- 2:49The second challenge is fair treatment as as an institutional
- 2:57asset, you know, via the Securities and Exchange
- 3:01Commission or the major financial regulators.
- 3:04And we started to get that January of 2024 with the
- 3:08approval of the spot Bitcoin ETFs.
- 3:11And before that point, a lot of skeptics were of the opinion
- 3:15that maybe it would be banned or they're not sure it's an actual
- 3:19real asset. You have all the skeptics saying
- 3:21it's Tulip bulbs or it's a Ponzi scheme or something.
- 3:24But of course, the SEC would never approve an ETF for a Ponzi
- 3:30scheme. So probably for people that
- 3:33don't really think hard one way or the other about this, they're
- 3:37reflexive investors. They're looking for that
- 3:40endorsement from the most important financial regulator in
- 3:45the world or regulators in the world.
- 3:47So that was Plank 2. And I think Plank 3 is, is fair
- 3:53treatment from the banking system.
- 3:56So right now it's impossible for most major banks to custody
- 4:01Bitcoin, buy Bitcoin or sell Bitcoin for you.
- 4:06It there are a few banks in Switzerland.
- 4:08I mean, there's standard charter bank in Europe.
- 4:11There are some of the banks in Brazil that can handle the
- 4:14asset. But the major corporations,
- 4:18right, the Microsoft, the Google, the Amazon, the Apples
- 4:22of the world, they wire billions of dollars a month to a too big
- 4:27to fail bank, right? A bank with a trillion dollar
- 4:30balance sheet. And right now they wire the
- 4:33billions of dollars a month to buy sovereign debt.
- 4:37They're just saying, OK, take this billion dollars today and
- 4:40buy T-bills with it and it's like a 10 second transaction.
- 4:45It's routine. They've been doing with the the
- 4:48business with the same bank for 30 years, 40 years.
- 4:51City City is National City Bank. National City Bank was the Bank
- 4:57of John D Rockefeller run by his brother.
- 5:01OK, that tells you how long, how far back JP Morgan, right?
- 5:06Try to remember who founded JP Morgan, right and how far back
- 5:09it goes. JP Morgan wasn't the 1st, right?
- 5:13He took it over. So what you have are these 100
- 5:17year old banks and 100 year old relationships and at the point
- 5:23that ACFO can send a billion dollars of cash to their bank,
- 5:28buy a billion dollars of Bitcoin, do it and hold it there
- 5:32no risk, right or or what they perceive as no risk, right.
- 5:36These are too big to fail banks. So the shareholders of Apple and
- 5:41the shareholders of Microsoft, they're not obsessing over the
- 5:45risk that Apple and Microsoft take to do business with Bank of
- 5:49America or JP Morgan or Citi, right, or Wells Fargo.
- 5:54So that's a very important thing when, when you've got all three,
- 5:57when you've got fair accounting, when you've got fair, you know,
- 6:01securities treatment or, or trading treatment and, and when
- 6:05you've got fair banking treatment, then you'll see mega
- 6:09corporations that will think, OK, well, this is a reasonable
- 6:13thing to do and it's practical to do until you've overcome
- 6:17those 3, then you've got, you've got problems to solve.
- 6:24Yeah. And, and it seems to me there's
- 6:26also the track record that MicroStrategy has now shown of
- 6:29your, your thesis from the start has always been hold it for at
- 6:33least four years and, and watch what happens.
- 6:35And, and you've delivered on that.
- 6:37And now there's this end of one of, of real success doing that.
- 6:40Do you think that paves the the way you know, blazes the trail
- 6:45for other companies to follow more readily now?
- 6:48I, I think that after you've got the three structural, look, if
- 6:53the accounting is prejudicial and if the regulator is
- 6:58prejudiced and if the banks are unwilling to do business with
- 7:03you, those three things are just show stoppers, right?
- 7:06Like we haven't even got to the question of what's my
- 7:11allocation, right? So, so I think that the
- 7:16allocation is 0 for a, if you say to a corporation you're only
- 7:22going to lose money on an accounting basis, you'll never
- 7:24make money. The allocation is 0.
- 7:26If you say to an institutional investor that trades on the New
- 7:32York Stock Exchange or trades in the US and they're regulated and
- 7:36you say you can buy it via IBIT or via FBTC using with a call to
- 7:45Morgan Stanley or JP Morgan, then the allocation might be
- 7:49something. But if you say you have to set
- 7:52up an account on FTX or Binance or offshore or even on Coinbase,
- 7:58well, I mean the allocation is probably nothing, right?
- 8:02It's probably 0. So this is a zero to 1.
- 8:05So I think those first three things are what's possible for
- 8:09the asset to come to life. After you have those things,
- 8:13then there's a discussion of well, what's the volatility,
- 8:16what's the, what's the performance, what's the sharp
- 8:19ratio, what's the duration, what's the holding period,
- 8:25what's the risk? And then what's, you know,
- 8:27what's the communication strategy?
- 8:31And I, so I think that this education, it's pretty important
- 8:35for individuals, what, what we've been doing has been
- 8:38important for individuals. It's pretty important for family
- 8:45offices, especially forward thinking ones for private
- 8:50companies, maybe they could do something.
- 8:53But if you ask like who are the most conservative movers in the
- 8:58universe? Well, the second most
- 9:01conservative would be company operating companies that are
- 9:04publicly traded, right, that that are disclosing everything
- 9:08they do every quarter and regulated.
- 9:11And the most conservative are the banks, public companies that
- 9:16are actually regulated custodians of other people's
- 9:19assets. So the fact that we worked our
- 9:23way from individuals to high net worth individuals to private
- 9:29companies, up to, you know, the, the tech innovators and now
- 9:34we're working on the mega, mega public corps and the banks,
- 9:39right? That's a sign of the asset
- 9:41improving. And and you know, education
- 9:44matters, setting an example matters, right?
- 9:49But there's just a lot of moving parts here.
- 9:52And we're talking about the birth of an asset class and a
- 9:56paradigm shift. And, and in both cases, right,
- 10:00it's like a, it's like an organic viral process.
- 10:06You know, it's like, which is, you know, they say one of the
- 10:09first things they taught me at MIT about this was, you know,
- 10:13they said, you know, if you have a, if you have a pond and
- 10:17there's algae in the pond and the algae is doubling every day
- 10:21and in 30 days it covers the entire pond.
- 10:24On what day of the month will you notice you even have any
- 10:27allergy? You know, and it's like, well,
- 10:3090% of the days you don't even know you have any.
- 10:35And like on the 26th day you notice something and then in
- 10:39three more days the pawns completely covered, right?
- 10:42So with exponential processes, there's a whole lot of nothing
- 10:46apparently going on as the process builds and builds and
- 10:51all the sudden there's a little blip and then all the sudden you
- 10:55have, you know, you have more action, right?
- 10:59Like with Apple stock, right? It took forever, 40 years to
- 11:02make it to a trillion and it took like 18 months to make it
- 11:05to 2 trillion. You know, it's like, but you see
- 11:08that as a phenomenon. And that's the phenomenon here,
- 11:11organically, virally spreading everywhere in the world, I
- 11:14think. So Speaking of organic growth of
- 11:19participants in the industry, one of the I guess spicier
- 11:24topics making the rounds right now is how many coins there are
- 11:27on Coinbase and I think all the major corporates, MicroStrategy
- 11:32included, use Coinbase. How do you think about, you
- 11:37know, as a fiduciary risk with respect to single custodian and
- 11:43the trade-offs versus using multiple custodians and
- 11:47diversifying your custodians or maybe alternatives like multi
- 11:51institution custody. How do you think about those
- 11:54those risks and balances and trade-offs?
- 11:56I think generally any major public company or major
- 12:00institution that's either a Trust Company like a like a ETF
- 12:06or an operating company, they're going to go through a vetting
- 12:09process and they're going to choose an institutional grade
- 12:13custodian that's regulated. There's maybe a dozen in the
- 12:17world. I suppose there's about half a
- 12:20dozen in the United States. It'll take some number of months
- 12:25depending upon how motivated they are.
- 12:27You could spend as much as you could spend if you were in a
- 12:30super in a hurry, you could spend a month.
- 12:32And if you're taking your time, you can spend 12 months vetting
- 12:37the custodian. They're not going to custody
- 12:40Bitcoin anywhere other than in one of them.
- 12:45And then normally what happens is you didn't find a second May,
- 12:49so maybe a third. So you're going to want to have
- 12:53a couple of vetted custodians and then you're going to want to
- 13:00review that continually. And I think it's not right
- 13:03practical to have more than three.
- 13:07It's probably advisable to have more than one. 2 is not
- 13:13unreasonable and then it's a continual process right there.
- 13:17The thing about Bitcoin is that I think it's important to point
- 13:21out is, is a lot of the security comes from the optionality to
- 13:28move the Bitcoin from 1 custodian to another.
- 13:33You can like if you, if you had a $10 billion real estate
- 13:37portfolio in New York City, you don't have the optionality to
- 13:41move the real estate from New York City to Tokyo, right?
- 13:47And if and in certain extents, if you have a a large holding of
- 13:56an ETF, you don't necessarily have the optionality to move
- 14:00your holding to a different ETF provider without taking a tax
- 14:06hit, right? Without a taxable event, right?
- 14:09This is This is why cash creates and redemptions are much less
- 14:13efficient than in kind create and redemption.
- 14:17If you had an in kind create redemption, you could actually
- 14:19take a redemption without a taxable event and Bitcoin move
- 14:23it to another ETF provider and then swapped out for shares
- 14:27without a redemption. So, so being able to relocate
- 14:31your asset between various counterparties and various
- 14:36custodians and various places without a taxable event is, is
- 14:40very important. So if you own underlying Bitcoin
- 14:46and you have it with a custodian and you lose confidence in them
- 14:50or you don't like the business relationship, you can move it to
- 14:52a second custodian without a taxable event.
- 14:54You could do that in an hour, right?
- 14:57Practically speaking, a big company would take more than an
- 15:00hour to do it because just like there's a ton of people on the
- 15:03custody side, there's a ton of people on the institutional
- 15:06side, you know, And so there would be a set of processes you
- 15:11would go through, but that that keeps everybody honest and keeps
- 15:17the market competitive because, you know, the mayor of the city
- 15:21knows that you can't move the building.
- 15:24And so they can double the property tax rate and you're not
- 15:28moving the building and you your only recourse is to try to vote
- 15:32them out of office. But if you're a custodian, a
- 15:36Bitcoin in Singapore and you double or triple the maintenance
- 15:41fee or the, you know, the custody fee, then maybe the
- 15:44Bitcoin finds its way to fill in the blank another place, Paris,
- 15:49London, US, different country. Or even if you had two
- 15:54custodians in New York City, the Bitcoin can move between one and
- 15:57the other. You know, we talked about the
- 15:5919th century gold issue. Gold was like a settlement t + 1
- 16:02year and Bitcoin is in the worst case T + 1 hour.
- 16:09So if you, if you, you know people often times they fixate
- 16:12their like they think the lesson of Satoshi is don't trust any
- 16:16counterparty. I don't think that's the lesson
- 16:19of Satoshi. I think the lesson of Satoshi is
- 16:24if you can store your money for 1000 years without a
- 16:27counterparty, you've, you've created perfect money, right?
- 16:32I think, or perfect digital capital.
- 16:33I think that's the first lesson. And I think the second lesson is
- 16:39if you can move the Bitcoin without a trusted intermediary,
- 16:44now you've got an open global network.
- 16:46And what it really means is that 300 million companies can settle
- 16:51with each other. And that means that at 50,000
- 16:55banks can settle with each other.
- 16:58And so this becomes a settlement network, right?
- 17:02It when, when we teach people that corporations are not to be
- 17:05trusted, banks are not to be trusted, and governments are not
- 17:09to be trusted, we become crypto anarchist.
- 17:12But Apple's a corporation and the hospital's a corporation and
- 17:16insurance companies are corporations, you know, and
- 17:19Uber's a corporation. And the United States
- 17:22government, for better or worse, does useful things, right?
- 17:26Just like your city government, sewerage, sewer, power, water,
- 17:30etcetera. The power company is a
- 17:32corporation. So if you embrace the idea there
- 17:36are some companies that provide you with food, electricity,
- 17:39transportation, you know, airline service, freight,
- 17:43etcetera, then you're like, OK, companies are probably OK.
- 17:47And if you embrace the idea that yeah, yeah, you could be like,
- 17:50OK, well, I got to self custody. Well, like, how's the 12 year
- 17:53old kid supposed to self custody?
- 17:55How does an 85 year old with Alzheimer's self custody?
- 17:59Right. This idea that corporate that
- 18:01that you should never trust a corporate custodian is also a
- 18:04kind of orthodox, zealous ideological notion.
- 18:10The truth of the matter is there's a lot of circumstances
- 18:14under which you want a company to fixate on custody.
- 18:17Just like we use Apple to custody our photos and custody,
- 18:22you know, our documents and and the whatever.
- 18:26And you can rail against it, but I don't, I haven't seen any
- 18:30crypto anarchist that's proposed a solution to the dependence on
- 18:34Apple and Google and Microsoft that we currently have today.
- 18:39So I, I think that the deeper idea is not that Bitcoin allows
- 18:45you to avoid depending on a custodian.
- 18:48The deeper idea is Bitcoin gives you a competitive market, a
- 18:54global competitive market for custody and you have the option
- 18:59to move $10 billion in one hour anywhere in the world to any of
- 19:04hundreds of millions of potential custodians.
- 19:08And so that creates an, a competitive market, a a free
- 19:13global capital market and arbitrage between every type of
- 19:18custody and every country and every form of possible custodian
- 19:26and, and what is it the, the last resort, right?
- 19:32As a last resort, you can take self custody and and you don't
- 19:38have the ability to take self custody of $10 billion of Apple
- 19:43stock as a last resort. And you don't have the ability
- 19:46to take self custody of $10 billion worth of real estate as
- 19:50a last resort. And you don't have the ability
- 19:53to take self custody of $10 billion of gold as a last
- 19:56resort. And so the last resort is
- 19:59useful, but really, you know, a more practical thing you find in
- 20:04life. And, and every corporation finds
- 20:07this out. It's like when you need to buy
- 20:09electricity or when you need to buy oil, you know, yelling at
- 20:15General Electric or yelling at, at the at Exxon that if they
- 20:19don't give you a better deal, you'll just drill for the oil
- 20:23yourself, that that's not credible, right?
- 20:26The salesperson looks at you and they laugh.
- 20:27You like, yeah, sure, you're going to start your own
- 20:30petroleum company, drill for your own oil.
- 20:32I bet you will, right a much better negotiating strategy to
- 20:38say to to the gas station, if you don't sell me gasoline at a
- 20:43reasonable price, I will go across the street to your
- 20:45competitor that will or I will do business with Chevron instead
- 20:50of Exxon. And, and so generally, if you
- 20:53want to get treated fairly, you know, any Business School would
- 20:57say to you, OK, you create a competitive auction and you find
- 21:01the two or three specialists. You know, when you're at a
- 21:05restaurant and you want to lever Coca-Cola for a better deal on
- 21:08Coke and Diet Coke, you don't threaten to create your own, you
- 21:13know, beverage company or do it yourself and create Mikey Cola.
- 21:17What you do is you bring in the PET.
- 21:19You have the Pepsi sales guy and you have the Pepsi hat sitting
- 21:22on the table. You say, you know, I just met
- 21:24with the dude from Pepsi and he offered me a better deal.
- 21:28And the Coke sales guy goes back to the district manager and
- 21:30says, you know, Pepsi's in there talking to them.
- 21:32So I think we better give them a better deal.
- 21:35And, and of course, there's only Coke and Pepsi.
- 21:37That's only two. As a practical matter, you have
- 21:40to have two. When there's one, you're in deep
- 21:43trouble. But Satoshi gave us 10,000,
- 21:50right? 1010 thousand, there's 50,000
- 21:53banks, right? If you, if you get like 100
- 21:57custodians competing with each other, you're going to have a
- 21:59pretty good market and, and a pretty fair market.
- 22:02And, and, and I think that's what's going on here.
- 22:08So the big institutional holders like MicroStrategy or the big
- 22:13ETFs, yeah, they're going to use regulated custodians.
- 22:18They're going to put pressure on them by the way, that you know,
- 22:22they're there's the crypto anarchist and there's the
- 22:26libertarian view, not your keys, not your coin.
- 22:29And it's a good it's an important mantra.
- 22:32But barking at Coinbase and telling them or barking, you
- 22:37know, at Mount Gox or, you know, yelling at some exchange to be
- 22:42better on Twitter doesn't work, right.
- 22:46You're not what I'll tell you what works when BlackRock has
- 22:51$20 billion of assets and then the guy that runs the BlackRock
- 22:56ETF goes to talk with Coinbase, you know, or, or when Fidelity,
- 23:04you know, Fidelity looks and they're like, well, I think
- 23:05we'll just go and do it ourselves.
- 23:07When a mega Corp with trillions of dollars of assets decides
- 23:11that they want better service or they don't trust the exchange,
- 23:16now you have a market dynamic that and that works because
- 23:20there's huge amounts of assets at risk and there's armies of
- 23:26lawyers and armies of account. It's like, it's like, you know,
- 23:29you have to go through a, you know, a Sarbanes-Oxley, you
- 23:34know, risk control, audit in order for me to do business with
- 23:38you. And that means we've got a list
- 23:40of 10,000 things. So I think that the
- 23:42institutional players, the SEC 40 trust companies and the SEC
- 23:4833 operating companies, those are applying pressure to the
- 23:51crypto exchanges to become much better, but they're also the
- 23:57ones that are lobbying for the repeal of Saab 121, right?
- 24:01And the repeal of Saab 121 will result in all of the major banks
- 24:07in the United States and then the rest of the world starting
- 24:09to consider becoming crypto custodians and and Bitcoin
- 24:12custodians and the like. And so, so that's again, that's
- 24:16going to happen because BlackRock and Fidelity, you
- 24:20know, and other mega corps talk to their senator, talk to their
- 24:24Congress person, talk to the regulators and point out that
- 24:29they want more options and the banking lobby gets involved,
- 24:34etcetera. And so Bitcoin is going through
- 24:37this seasoning process where really it's encouraging new
- 24:42companies to buy it and it's encouraging new custodians to
- 24:47custody it. And we should welcome both,
- 24:51right? The more corporations that own
- 24:53it, the better we are, and the more corporations that custody
- 24:57it, the better we are. It it's, it strikes me as if
- 25:02there's any risk in crossing the chasm for Bitcoin.
- 25:06You know, getting to the mainstream necessitates
- 25:08infrastructure where the 12 year old and the 85 year old don't
- 25:10have to do self custody. And so, you know, I think that's
- 25:14that's what we've we've been working on trying to improve the
- 25:17options there and improve the format of what's possible.
- 25:20Because when you're, you know, when you have this digital
- 25:24value, you dematerialize value, you have the ability to reduce
- 25:28the friction so much in in the custody options, custody formats
- 25:32in the competition. I think that you articulated so
- 25:34well there. I guess two-part question here
- 25:37of of Michael. Do you think there are risks in
- 25:41crossing the chasm for Bitcoin? Or do you think that that
- 25:45Bitcoins endogenous properties make it so that it it will not
- 25:49have a problem continuing into the mainstream?
- 25:53I don't. I don't view them as risk as
- 25:56much as just. It's like asking me in 1650, are
- 26:04there risks in building Manhattan into a great city in
- 26:08North America? There's steps that have to be,
- 26:14you know, if I find you the greatest port in North America,
- 26:20you know, an island of granite sitting between the East River,
- 26:23the Hudson River with the great natural harbor right in the
- 26:28right location. And everybody's decided it's
- 26:31their favorite city and the year is 1650.
- 26:35Are there risks with growing the city?
- 26:38I mean, I suppose, but I, I don't think of it that way,
- 26:42right? Just I, I just think there's,
- 26:43there's challenges to be overcome and opportunities,
- 26:46right. And so I think, I think bitcoins
- 26:50going through all that, right? There's stuff to be built.
- 26:53Yeah, right. Working if if the accounting
- 26:56changes for every company in the world in February of our January
- 26:59of 2025, then I guess that means the accounting profession has to
- 27:03learn a bunch of new things. There's new stuff to be done,
- 27:05right, New procedures and accounting systems to be, you
- 27:09know, reviewed. And likewise, it's one thing to
- 27:14say banks should custody Bitcoin is another thing to create, you
- 27:17know, are 10,000 banks going to create their own Bitcoin custody
- 27:22service? Well, is that a risk or is that
- 27:25an opportunity? I, I guess I'm, I'm back to 1900
- 27:29and I'm in New York and we just admitted electricity.
- 27:33And I'm just pointing out that I think like one day all buildings
- 27:36we wired with electricity. And you're asking me, are there
- 27:38risks in the wiring of New York City with electricity?
- 27:41And I, you know, I guess there's going to be some electric fires,
- 27:44right? And there's also going to be a
- 27:46lot of fire insurance to get sold.
- 27:48And there's also going to be electricians and there's going
- 27:51to be electricians union and there's going to be a lot of
- 27:53projects and there's probably going to be a bond and
- 27:56somebody's going to complain about it.
- 27:57We're going to dig a lot of trenches right to where those
- 28:00power lines running. And someone's probably going to
- 28:03put a, you know, a drill, you know, jackhammer through one of
- 28:07the power lines and stuff's going to happen.
- 28:10But and then we're going to fight over whether we burn coal
- 28:13or we run the power line in Niagara Falls and there's going
- 28:16to be stuff. But I just think there's just a
- 28:19lot of work to be done. We're building out the future.
- 28:22One, one thing that's nice too about Bitcoin as compared to
- 28:26Manhattan is with the city, you might have a single regulator
- 28:30jurisdiction that you got to deal with.
- 28:32And of course you got to negotiate the rights of way to
- 28:37build out the infrastructure. Nice thing about Bitcoin being
- 28:40that it's global and open. Anybody can build on anything.
- 28:43As you say, you know, a bunch of banks can give it their best
- 28:46shot and they'll be competition among them to to provide the
- 28:51best service and the market, the market will decide.
- 28:55Are there any areas within Bitcoin infrastructure?
- 28:59You mentioned custody, you mentioned banks, obviously
- 29:02you've got corporate adoption. Are there other areas that are
- 29:06particularly fruitful or or interesting with respect to the
- 29:10story right now that you're that you're watching carefully or are
- 29:14those the main ones? Well, you know, I'm focused upon
- 29:17Bitcoin is the digital, is digital capital.
- 29:21So it's the transformation of financial and physical capital
- 29:25to digital capital. And that's not complicated.
- 29:29That's a very simple idea if you just say it like that.
- 29:32But the implication is it's also driving the digital
- 29:37transformation of the capital markets.
- 29:41So the capital markets are fragmented, right, that the bond
- 29:44market trades in Japan at different times than the bonds
- 29:47trading in Germany and then the bonds trading in Brazil, then
- 29:50the bonds trading in the US. And the equity market, right?
- 29:54Our, our existing capital markets are built around equity
- 29:58and debt. And you know, and so, and
- 30:00there's some derivatives, right, equity, debt derivatives and
- 30:02they trade 9:30 to 4:00 Monday through Friday and they don't
- 30:06trade on the weekends and they don't trade on holidays.
- 30:09And they're all fragmented and they're, and you know, they're
- 30:13limited in access. So the implication of somebody
- 30:19being able to trade in a capital market in Australia on Saturday
- 30:24and having an impact, someone in the United States, you know, 12
- 30:29hours off on the time zone or something.
- 30:32That's interesting. So a real time 24/7 global
- 30:37capital market is interesting and up until up until now it has
- 30:44been again, it was point O 1% of the money in the world.
- 30:50You know when it was 6000 or 7000 a coin and now it's point
- 30:571% of the money in the world. And so it's, it is a global
- 31:04digital capital market, but it's still de minimis in, in amount
- 31:09of capital. And so I think that as you see
- 31:12bigger players come in into the marketplace and it gets to be 1%
- 31:17of the capital of the world. Now you're going to have the,
- 31:21the tension of the 20th century, the 20th century capital
- 31:25markets, They're fragile. They're, they're limited to a
- 31:28certain set of people. There are very limited
- 31:31settlement options. They're they're slow, they're
- 31:34not smart. You can't trade Apple stock
- 31:39100,000 times on a Saturday afternoon, right?
- 31:44You so you can't, you know, you can't vibrate it at a high
- 31:47frequency. You don't have global, you can't
- 31:50self custody, you can't program it right.
- 31:53So the capital that's in the traditional markets, it's not
- 31:56programmable, it's slow, it's fragile.
- 32:01And the capital in the, in the 21st century, it's going to be
- 32:05smarter, faster, stronger. And so that the interesting
- 32:08opportunity is what happens when the investment bankers and the
- 32:13commercial bankers and the money managers realize that digital
- 32:20capital is smarter, faster, stronger, universal, right?
- 32:29Because it has a lot of implications, right?
- 32:33Like there's 50,000 publicly traded companies and how many of
- 32:39them are capitalized on Bitcoin? How many of them are capitalized
- 32:42on bonds? So 99.99% of the corporate
- 32:48capital is financial capital, which is fragile, fragile,
- 32:56fragmented, right and and defective, right, Right.
- 33:02What digital capital is appreciating at 45% a year and
- 33:07over the last four years and financial capital is
- 33:10depreciating at 4% a year and Fiat, this is in USD terms,
- 33:17right? But you know, I think that has
- 33:21profound impact on investment banking, right?
- 33:23Like why wouldn't you go and recapitalize every company?
- 33:29So that's interesting. I think what's also interesting
- 33:32is is, you know, it's like the same set the financial world
- 33:37brags about taking settlement from T + 5 days.
- 33:42You know, like in 1970 to 75, it was like T + 5 days, T + 5 to 10
- 33:46days, then T + 3 days and it was T + 2 days as of a year ago.
- 33:51And now we're going to T + 1 day.
- 33:54But we're, but we're not T + 1 day on Friday.
- 33:57You know it, it might be from Friday at 4:00 till Monday at
- 34:0210:00 AM or something to settle something.
- 34:06So money still moves very slowly and it has to pass this fragile
- 34:10network of correspondent banks that anybody can block the move
- 34:15and, and you can't program it right.
- 34:19So I, so I, you know, I, I use this phrase, you know, I mean,
- 34:26when you think about digital capital, digital capital is
- 34:28invisible, right? It's intangible.
- 34:32It's immortal, right? It's, it's indestructible.
- 34:38But while you're working through your bowls, like comparing it to
- 34:41a building, it's all those things.
- 34:43It's musical. And the musical is something to
- 34:46think about, right? Think about a Symphony.
- 34:49Think about vibrating the strings of a guitar.
- 34:54You know. Think about, you know, energy,
- 34:57frequency and vibration. And think about Mozart's or
- 35:02Beethoven's Seventh Symphony or Beethoven's Ninth Symphony.
- 35:05Think about what happens when you start to vibrate on various
- 35:08frequencies. And literally you hear it and
- 35:12it's beautiful. And then think about how fast
- 35:15you can vibrate a building and think about how fast you can
- 35:19vibrate a billion dollar block of Apple stock and see they
- 35:25don't play right. They they vibrate like a rock,
- 35:28right? You, you can't, right?
- 35:30The answer is you can't play that capital, right?
- 35:34You can't. But with digital capital, you
- 35:38can't, you know, on on the base network, you can move it once an
- 35:41hour. That's actually comparatively
- 35:43high frequency compared to moving gold once a year, right?
- 35:48What, Eighty 87160 hours a year? So 8760 times faster than the
- 35:56fastest gold seems like high frequency.
- 35:58But really when you put it on a layer 2 network, the real point
- 36:02is if I can settle on the underlying network, then when
- 36:06you put Coinbase against finance as a counterparty or you put
- 36:10block against you, you know, set up layer 2 and layer 3
- 36:14counterparties, they can move the stuff, you know, at 10
- 36:19kilohertz on the weekend. And, and now you combine that
- 36:25with a, you know, high, high speed trading has been a fixture
- 36:30in certain equity markets, but we've never had high speed
- 36:35global trading. And now we've got AI.
- 36:40And so if, if you actually created an AI and you said to
- 36:43the AII want you to like, go ahead and scan 100,000 possible
- 36:47counterparties that want to borrow the Bitcoin, assess the
- 36:50risk. And I want you to make the micro
- 36:52loans, chop it up, send it to them, then fetch it back and
- 36:57optimize the yield or, or the risk return on that.
- 37:01I mean, it's quite, it's quite likely that the AI is not going
- 37:05to make one decision per three years.
- 37:08But if you look at most corporations, they pick one
- 37:12custodian, they place their capital with the custodian and
- 37:17they generate, you know, if you have $10 billion of Apple stock,
- 37:22what do you think your yield is on it when you actually have it
- 37:25at a wire house? I mean, most people don't get
- 37:28any yield for the most part. You know, when's the last time
- 37:31someone paid you a yield on a, on a $1,000,000 block of stock?
- 37:37Occasionally you can find someone to offer you something,
- 37:41but generally that's not a very competitive market.
- 37:46It's a very slow market. I I would suggest to you that
- 37:5099.999% of all equity investors have never been delivered any
- 37:56yield on any equity asset that they hold.
- 38:00And yet except that if you hold government securities, if you
- 38:05hold the dollar or you hold, you know, you hold this favored
- 38:09capital asset which we love, you know, you would expect to get
- 38:13paid interest on that. But but stop and think about it
- 38:16for a second. Why is it you get paid interest
- 38:19on $1,000,000 of U.S. Treasuries, but you don't get
- 38:23paid interest on $1,000,000 of Microsoft stock and ask what, by
- 38:29the way, couldn't I just take the Microsoft stock and give it
- 38:32to a big bank and they could loan it out to someone that
- 38:34wants to short it and charge them sulfur and they could split
- 38:37it with me. By the way, they do right?
- 38:40They just don't give you any right?
- 38:43Like these big, these big custodians of equity, they do
- 38:49loan out your equity to short sellers and they do get
- 38:53compensated. They're just not cutting you,
- 38:56the owner of the asset. And why not?
- 38:59It's not a competitive market. It's not a transparent market.
- 39:03You don't have the option to take self custody, right?
- 39:06You can't shop or you're not so easy to shop, right?
- 39:10And and there's some people would like to topple that.
- 39:13But in a regulated marketplace, innovation goes 1000 times
- 39:19slower. So back to your question, what's
- 39:22interesting, you know, the formation of the global capital
- 39:25markets, right? Money moving at the speed of
- 39:28light, money vibrating at, you know, 440 vibrations a second,
- 39:36right? Stuff happening smarter, faster
- 39:40and stronger, right? That that's interesting to me.
- 39:45And I think that's where the opportunities are, right?
- 39:48If you're right, if you're trying to make money, how do you
- 39:51make money? Well, you securitize Bitcoin or
- 39:55you become a banker, an investment banker or commercial
- 39:59banker of Bitcoin, or you create these radical new products that
- 40:06have Bitcoin embedded in them, right?
- 40:09Or for it. And and those are all very
- 40:11interesting. Does your Bitcoin custody set up
- 40:14keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 40:16sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 40:19Or maybe you've set up your own self custody but don't feel safe
- 40:21with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 40:23device in your desk drawer. Gain Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 40:27and our multi institution custody solution.
- 40:29Here's how it works. On Ramp creates a dedicated
- 40:32multi sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 40:35a key on ramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 40:40unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 40:43over your coins with on ramps multi institution custody.
- 40:46You'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is stored
- 40:48with best in class security on chain with fault tolerant multi
- 40:51sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 40:53going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 40:56exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench of tax
- 41:00in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 41:03you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 41:06custody set up. Onramp's multi institution
- 41:08custody eliminates single points of failure, reduces your
- 41:12personal attack surface and technical burden, and provides
- 41:15access to financial services that allow you to confidently
- 41:17secure your Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance
- 41:21backed warranties for all balances and transactions, low
- 41:23cost trading and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 41:26asset. Secure it right.
- 41:28Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com. So you mentioned yield, Michael,
- 41:33I noticed in your filings a new notion called BTC yield as
- 41:39you're reporting it. I think that you call it a key
- 41:43performance indicator representing the percent change
- 41:47period to period of the ratio between the company's Bitcoin
- 41:50holdings and its diluted shares. Basically, it sounds like
- 41:55Bitcoin per share. I guess my question for you is,
- 41:59is this in the same vein as the yield you were just describing
- 42:02and is this metric really central to the company's
- 42:05strategy or is it just one of many going forward?
- 42:09Well, first of all, there's a, there's 1000 interesting
- 42:12business strategies for people that want to launch a business
- 42:17or, or generate something of value on Bitcoin.
- 42:21And so this is, this is one, this is the first derivative of
- 42:27Bitcoin per share, right? It's the rate of increase in
- 42:31Bitcoin per fully diluted share, right?
- 42:34That's, that's the idea behind the KPI.
- 42:37So if I have $100 and I buy a spot Bitcoin ETF and I pay 25
- 42:45basis points fee, that means over the course of four years
- 42:48I'll pay a dollar roughly in custody fees.
- 42:53I've, I've pretty much got $99.00 of Bitcoin, right.
- 42:57So, so I, there's a slight dilution of my Bitcoin per share
- 43:03after fees in that situation. It's a very simple value
- 43:06proposition and I'm paying the 20 or 25 basis points for
- 43:10someone else to handle the custody and the compliance, you
- 43:15know, and, and the like and that it's not a bad deal.
- 43:18It's pretty good deal. You know, it's, you know, some
- 43:22people paid 100 basis points for a custodian before.
- 43:26So 20 basis points of 25 is not bad.
- 43:29What MicroStrategy is doing though is we're securitizing
- 43:33Bitcoin. So if we can sell $200 worth of
- 43:39stock back by $100 worth of Bitcoin and then we buy back
- 43:44$200 a Bitcoin, we've actually captured 100 $100 Bitcoin
- 43:50premium, if you will. And So what we're doing is we're
- 43:54generating a yield as we're if we're selling a security backed
- 43:59by by less than 100% Bitcoin and then we buy back the Bitcoin,
- 44:05we're arbitraging the difference and capturing that as a benefit
- 44:09to our shareholders. So you can do that variety of
- 44:13ways. You might do it by selling
- 44:15equity at a premium and net asset value.
- 44:18Another way you could do it is you can sell a convertible bond.
- 44:23If you sell a convertible bond at 40% premium to the equity
- 44:27price and if the equity was already at a premium to the
- 44:31underlying asset, you get a double boost.
- 44:34So you might very well sell APA convertible piece of debt at a
- 44:39200% premium to the underlying asset.
- 44:43If you do that, you know, if you do a $300 million bond offering
- 44:47at a 200% premium, you're like capturing $200 million of
- 44:53benefit in the arbitrage, right? And then, and then you're
- 44:58holding the debt. And the issue is, do you think
- 45:01that the thing you bought with the debt, the, the Bitcoin is
- 45:03going up or going down over six years or so?
- 45:06So let's assume you, you basically issue convertible debt
- 45:13and then you and then you hold the Bitcoin for six years and
- 45:18you do it. What you're doing is you're
- 45:20offering shares six years out and you're swapping a set of
- 45:25shares at a premium to the underlying asset for the asset.
- 45:30If the asset trades up, you're going to capture another,
- 45:33another Bitcoin premium or a benefit on the back end right to
- 45:37$300 million of Bitcoin. You buy double s and double s
- 45:40again, so you make $900 million in, in sort of an investment
- 45:45gain on the back end and you make $200 million in arbitrage
- 45:49gain on the front end. BTC yield is, is, is a AKPI
- 45:57we're using to help our investors figure out how we
- 46:00think about each of these transactions.
- 46:02And you know, if you thought about it, you can realize that
- 46:04if our stock was trading at exactly net asset value and we
- 46:08sold $100 million of stock and bought $100 million of Bitcoin,
- 46:12we'd have no BTC yield, right? It's a net neutral.
- 46:16And you can see that instantly, right?
- 46:19And if we sell the stock, you know, back 200 million of stock
- 46:23backed by 100 million of Bitcoin, then we capture that.
- 46:26And now how much yield is it? Well, it's the 100, $1,000,000
- 46:30divided into the entire, the, the total asset position.
- 46:33Or another way to do it is you, you know, you look at the
- 46:36Bitcoin and then you look at the fully diluted Share Account.
- 46:40Of course, there's, it's lots of complications because you have
- 46:43to look at all of the various elements of the capital
- 46:45structure over time. And then there are other also
- 46:48risk factors like what happens between now and then if the
- 46:55stock trades down and what youth and a convertible bond that you
- 46:58thought would convert in a certain number of shares
- 47:00converts a different set of shares.
- 47:01So, so that's why it's not really a a normal gap metric.
- 47:06It really is just a KPI. But the general idea is if you
- 47:12simply want to take a plain vanilla investment position,
- 47:16then you buy a spot Bitcoin ETF and you just hold it.
- 47:21And that's a very safe, simple, straightforward thing to do.
- 47:25You're taking counterparty risk to the ETF provider.
- 47:28And then there are vendors, right?
- 47:30You've got risk to Black Rock and you've got risk to black
- 47:33rocks custodians, and you read the filings and that, and you've
- 47:36got risk to Bitcoin, right? Those are your 3 risks with an
- 47:41operating company, a Bitcoin miner.
- 47:43A Bitcoin miner can generate BTC yield.
- 47:46An operating company can generate BTC yield.
- 47:49If you generate 100 million in cash flow and buy Bitcoin,
- 47:52you'll generate a yield, right? If you issue equity at a premium
- 47:57and buy Bitcoin, you'll generate a yield.
- 47:59If you if you issue a convertible bond at a premium,
- 48:03you'll generate a yield. I mean, there's some things you
- 48:06could do if you buy an ice cream truck company for equity and you
- 48:12get no more Bitcoin, but you issue a bunch of shares of
- 48:15equity that will be dilutive, you'll have a negative yield,
- 48:18right? If we were to go and buy a
- 48:19billion dollar ice cream truck ice cream truck company, we
- 48:24would have a negative BTC yield, right?
- 48:26And if you're ABTC investor, you would say, you know, what are
- 48:29you guys thinking, right? So, so it's the, by the way, a
- 48:33lot of times people do dilutive acquisitions all the time and no
- 48:36one can figure out if they're dilutive or not.
- 48:39The beauty of BTC yield is if you're on a Bitcoin standard and
- 48:43you and you calculate that metric, the way that we've
- 48:46defined it, any investor, any Bitcoin maximalist investor can
- 48:52see immediately whether the companies they're invested in
- 48:56are doing rational things that increase the amount of Bitcoin
- 48:59per share or they're doing foolish things that decrease
- 49:03Bitcoin per share, right? And so I, I think it's a very
- 49:08useful thing for companies on the Bitcoin standard or if
- 49:12you're an investor that wants to, that wants to accumulate
- 49:16more Bitcoin because you as an operating company, you can do
- 49:22things to create BTC yield and SEC 40 company or a trust
- 49:27probably can't, right? That if you want to understand
- 49:30the difference between micro strategy and marathon and say
- 49:34black rocks I bid and FBTC, micro strategy and marathon can
- 49:40create BTC yield, right? We can also, you know, create
- 49:45negative BTC yield, right? Like why we can, we can buy a
- 49:50portfolio of apartments in San Francisco with billions of
- 49:53dollars of equity and we can brag about what a great deal it
- 49:57is, but it didn't generate any yield.
- 49:58It generated, you know, minus something, right?
- 50:02So we have the option to do intelligent things or non
- 50:05intelligent things. And and that's the counterparty
- 50:09risk. You know, you're you're taking
- 50:10risks to the management team and the management strategy.
- 50:13So operating companies can do that.
- 50:16And this is an interesting metric to evaluate them.
- 50:21Trust companies, they can't. And that's kind of like why you
- 50:25want to put, if you want to put an, if you want to buy gold and
- 50:29you want to leave in your portfolio for 40 years.
- 50:32You don't want to wake up and find out that the CEO of the GLD
- 50:36decided to do a mortgage back, you know, a junk bond to buy ice
- 50:41cream truck companies and speculate on whatever you
- 50:45because it's just too many, you know, complications for you.
- 50:50So there's a place for both strategies.
- 50:53But I, I think people have struggled with the idea of how,
- 50:57how do I know what's a creative and dilutive.
- 51:00And BTC yield is a, is a simple metric that, that we're doing
- 51:06because our shareholders want more Bitcoin per share.
- 51:09And they've said it loudly and frequently.
- 51:12But I also think it's a contribution to the entire
- 51:15community. And I think that any company
- 51:18that wants to pursue a Bitcoin standard would be wise to to
- 51:22stare at that KPI and think about adopting it because it's
- 51:28it's just a useful, a useful, a communications tech tool.
- 51:32Yeah, it, it's incredible the tools that you're able to stack
- 51:35together to create quite a bit of tailwind for, for the value
- 51:39of MicroStrategy. And but it creates a conundrum
- 51:42for people like me, Michael, because I, I adhere to your
- 51:46advice of never sell your Bitcoin.
- 51:48But now there's this asset out there that's creating yield on
- 51:51Bitcoin that that I don't own because I'm already all in on
- 51:54Bitcoin. You know, it's a, it's a funny
- 51:57problem for I, I guess turn turn that into a question.
- 52:00Is there is there any condition by which you you think that
- 52:06bitcoiners who are holding Bitcoin should consider
- 52:09switching into a an asset that generates Bitcoin yield like
- 52:13this? What I think is Bitcoin is the
- 52:18risk free return for a Bitcoin maximalist.
- 52:22So just start there, right? Bitcoin is the risk free return
- 52:27and the question is, do you want to take risk or not right.
- 52:33So, and I asked this question like in my personal life, like
- 52:37like we've created the Bitcoin 24 model.
- 52:40The Bitcoin 24 model is based on a lot of your work, Jesse.
- 52:43You'll find, you'll find we started with your work and then
- 52:47we we created it, we put it in the public domain.
- 52:50And the Bitcoin 24 model, you know, you can go Google it and
- 52:54find it on GitHub. I think 20,000 people have
- 52:56grabbed it. You know, since I tweeted it and
- 53:00it in it, you've got all of the assumptions about the macro
- 53:03environment. You can put crank in your own
- 53:05inflation assumptions, your own innovation assumptions, your own
- 53:08monetization and demonetization assumptions about gold and art
- 53:12and real estate and bonds and currency.
- 53:16And then you can put in all your own Bitcoin growth assumptions
- 53:20and create a bowl case and a base case and a bear case.
- 53:23And then after that there are micro models.
- 53:25And so you can model your family and decide, do you want to move
- 53:29to UAE and or not? And how much money can you
- 53:31generate and when and how much assets do you start with?
- 53:35And you're going to, you know, inherit money from your rich
- 53:37aunt and you know what? And then you could decide, you
- 53:41know, if you can mortgage your house or not mortgage your
- 53:43house. And so you've got a micro model
- 53:45and it's also got a corporate model.
- 53:48And you know, if you're a corporation, you can crank in
- 53:51your corporate model. You can also build your own.
- 53:54I mean, it's an open spreadsheet.
- 53:55Just grab the thing, duplicate it and be off to the races.
- 53:59And you can create a institutional model.
- 54:02Like if you're the answer is different, if you're running
- 54:05Harvard's endowment, then if it's, you're running, you know,
- 54:08the Meyers family trust, then if you're an individual, then if
- 54:13you're a Bitcoin miner or if you're an operating company or
- 54:16if you're a bakery or if you're tahini brothers, right?
- 54:19I mean, everybody's got their own thing.
- 54:22So, so that model is very open. But what I you know, what I've
- 54:27done is I cranked in my assumptions and I have presented
- 54:30my base case and and in Nashville and my base case is
- 54:36Bitcoin goes to 13 million a coin and it's the ARR of 29% ARR
- 54:42over 21 years. Yeah, it's again, it's like you
- 54:45don't have to accept my assumptions.
- 54:47Make your own just go down. If you can use a spreadsheet and
- 54:50type in numbers and hit save, you can do your own model for
- 54:54the next, you know, and you can do it in 10 minutes and you'll
- 54:58generate lots of beautiful graphs and you'll decide
- 55:00whatever you'll decide. But if we start with my base
- 55:05case, my base case is the risk free return is 29% ARR for 21
- 55:11years. Which means that when you pitch
- 55:13me an idea, if you come to me and say, hey, I got a new
- 55:16Bitcoin custody thing or I got a new hardware wallet or I got,
- 55:20you know, a new Bitcoin whatever banking thing, or I got a new
- 55:23whatever. I'm like, well, so can you
- 55:26guarantee me 29% plus the risk premium, which is probably 8%,
- 55:33six, 810%. You know, it's like the risk
- 55:37premium on a mega corporation like Disney or whatever is 4 or
- 55:415%. And the risk premium on a small
- 55:44start up has got to be 20%. OK.
- 55:48And so if you pitched me an idea and said OK, I guarantee you 40%
- 55:53ARR for the next 21 years. And I'm like, oh, and is it
- 55:57going to be capital free? Like I, you know, I don't have
- 56:00to bother with it and I don't have to put any more money in
- 56:03later. Like, well, if you promised me
- 56:06all that stuff I would like. OK, well, let me think about it.
- 56:12But probably if you gave me 10 of those ideas, I probably still
- 56:16don't want them because it's just a distraction because my
- 56:20alternate, my view is 29% ARR risk free.
- 56:26And then I guess I would say when you look at it like that
- 56:31and you compare it to the next 50,000 publicly traded company
- 56:34ideas and the next 500 million private ideas, it's like they're
- 56:39all kind of distractions with the exception of this, which is
- 56:43the only thing that's better than Bitcoin is more Bitcoin.
- 56:48OK, so so what's, what is my personal idea?
- 56:54My, my personal view is like my personal holding strategy is I
- 57:00own Bitcoin. You know, I either hold the
- 57:03asset 17,732 Bitcoin, you know, which I tweeted, you know, four
- 57:09years ago, which I'm still holding, or I would hold like
- 57:15the ETF if I needed to try, you know, to buy if I had extra cash
- 57:21flow yesterday and I just wanted to have it.
- 57:25And I thought, well, I don't know if I can hold it for a
- 57:27decade. I might need to spend it in two
- 57:29years to pay some expenses, but I'm going to hold it for now.
- 57:32So I, if I'm trading in high frequency in and out or
- 57:35whatever, you know, it's like, you know, I, I would buy an ETF
- 57:41of Bitcoin and I, and I'm, I would take the counterparty risk
- 57:45to Black Rock or or Fidelity or something.
- 57:49But you know what, I put my Bitcoin with Celsius, you know,
- 57:56or Block FI or FDX or Genesis long list.
- 58:04They all pitched me. By the way, I already said no to
- 58:08every one of them. No, no, no, no, no.
- 58:12But why? Because the counterparty risked
- 58:15to an unregulated entrepreneurial custodian is
- 58:21like 25% a year. Like, like there's a, they're
- 58:24going to fail every three years, right?
- 58:27So I'm just rationally thinking and I just don't need the
- 58:31headache. So if you offered me 40%, I
- 58:35mean, I mean, think about this, right?
- 58:37If if you thought you've got 25% counterparty risk and your risk
- 58:41free rate is 29% / 21 years, you're already up to the point
- 58:46where they have to offer you 55% interest to put your money in
- 58:52their custodian, right? So did any of them offer me 55%
- 58:56interest? No.
- 58:59And by the way, if they did, then my next question is, well,
- 59:02how are you going to generate 55% interest?
- 59:04Well, we're going to like put it in the D5 levered protocol on
- 59:07what I'm like. OK, well, no, now I've got like
- 59:11towers of counterparty risk, you know, that's like 7 layers of
- 59:16risk. And eventually there's a
- 59:17degenerate trader, you know, offshore in a dark pool that's
- 59:21levered up 20 to one that's paying that.
- 59:23So, so none of those things are very compelling.
- 59:28So I, I, I would say those don't make any sense.
- 59:31But you know, on the other hand, like if JP Morgan offered me 5%
- 59:38interest on my Bitcoin and they pledged their balance sheet too
- 59:44big to fail if they said JP Morgan won't back it.
- 59:47Not not I'm going to if they said we'll take your Bitcoin,
- 59:50we'll loan it to someone who wants to short it.
- 59:52And if they short it, then you're out, out.
- 59:55I wouldn't take them as a broker, but if I was facing them
- 59:59as the counter party, I'm like, I think that I think that the US
- 1:00:04government will have to fail before JP Morgan fails.
- 1:00:08And so, you know, if it's one of those top four too big to fail
- 1:00:12banks and they offered me sulfur and sulfur was 550 basis points,
- 1:00:17then would I take that yield? Probably, yeah, maybe.
- 1:00:21Or I mean, I, I mean, don't, don't hold me to any amount
- 1:00:26forever, right? But some portion of my assets I
- 1:00:31I already trust those banks, right.
- 1:00:33And, you know, but you don't trust those banks.
- 1:00:36Keep in mind that the US government trusts those banks
- 1:00:38right there. The entire civilization runs on
- 1:00:41those banks. Apple, Google, Facebook, all run
- 1:00:43on everything else you own is is clearing through those banks,
- 1:00:47right? So you're probably going to
- 1:00:49starve to death and the supermarket shelves are going to
- 1:00:52empty out of those banks. Stop working.
- 1:00:54So yeah, there's a certain degree of trust there that I
- 1:00:57might take. And I think there are certain
- 1:00:59things you consider taking, but I don't recommend any of them.
- 1:01:03I don't even recommend my own stock.
- 1:01:05My point, you want to buy a stock, Why don't you read every
- 1:01:10single SEC filing, every 10K, every 10 Q?
- 1:01:16The irony of course is on Twitter people all opine on all
- 1:01:20this stuff and they have a lot of strong opinions.
- 1:01:23Most of the time if I post a paragraph of text, I can count
- 1:01:28on them to not read the fourth sentence in the paragraph,
- 1:01:32right? Like I I generally assume that
- 1:01:34people will read the first sentence.
- 1:01:37I discount the 4th sentence. You know, if there's 2 pages in
- 1:01:42the 8K, very few people read to the 6th paragraph of the second
- 1:01:47page of the 8K. And if you're a professional
- 1:01:50investor, you're expected to read all 100 pages of the 10Q or
- 1:01:57the 10K filing. You know, we hired very
- 1:02:01expensive lawyers and very expensive accountants to write
- 1:02:04all this stuff down. So you could think about it.
- 1:02:08And if, if you're prepared to think about it, right, and, and
- 1:02:11if you understand you're taking risk, there's risk.
- 1:02:14It's interesting, you know, there's like a, there's an ETF
- 1:02:19called MSTY. Have you heard of it?
- 1:02:22Yes. OK.
- 1:02:24Well, MSTY basically sells something like it feels like
- 1:02:29unhedged MicroStrategy volatility, right?
- 1:02:32So, so if you buy it, you know, you're taking downside risk and
- 1:02:36they purport to be selling the upside via, you know, call, you
- 1:02:39know, synthetic long position selling calls or something.
- 1:02:46And you know, right now on my screen, I look at it, it says
- 1:02:50they've got $476 million of capital and it yields 226%
- 1:02:55interest. Wow.
- 1:02:59OK, so that's yield now the the question really is, is it you
- 1:03:04know what what is the risk associated with it?
- 1:03:07Download the prospectus, study the strategy, look at, you know,
- 1:03:11back tested. Does it does it actually
- 1:03:15constitute taking downside risk and getting paid 226% for the
- 1:03:20for giving up the upside? Is that exactly what it is?
- 1:03:24Or is there an embedded leakage where you know you're actually
- 1:03:27losing 20% of your principal per year?
- 1:03:32I don't know, right? You want to do an interesting
- 1:03:35podcast, right? I mean, do that analysis back,
- 1:03:39test it, study it, take apart all the take, take apart all of
- 1:03:43the risk factors. Have the people running the ETF
- 1:03:48on your podcast, quiz them on this and try to figure out, have
- 1:03:53they figured out a way to generate 226% yield on MSTR?
- 1:03:59Yes. No, right.
- 1:04:01Very interesting if you're bored and you want something and you
- 1:04:06want and by the way, if you if you're running an investment
- 1:04:09fund and maybe there's someone that wants to generate yield on
- 1:04:13Bitcoin, like, you know, some people just want to hold the
- 1:04:17asset and pursue the capital gain unrealized forever.
- 1:04:21I get it. If you had a fund, if you're an
- 1:04:24institution, if you're Harvard Endowment or a church and you
- 1:04:27don't pay tax on operating income, I look at 226% and I
- 1:04:33think, well, oh, that's a pretty big tax bill.
- 1:04:36But then I think, well, my, what if I didn't have a tax bill?
- 1:04:38What if I lived in UAE or Singapore's, right?
- 1:04:41Or what if I had a trust, which was tax advantage?
- 1:04:44Maybe you would feel differently about that.
- 1:04:46If I, what if I've raised a billion dollars to invest, you
- 1:04:51know, I get paid 2 and 20 and I'm supposed to find all these
- 1:04:54ideas? Well, I think I, I think there's
- 1:04:59lot of interesting ideas. I think that if Bitcoin is a 55
- 1:05:05Vol arr or 50 Vol arr with A50 Vol, you know, or 50 volatility
- 1:05:12and 50% arr, there's a lot of people that they would rather
- 1:05:17have 20 arr, 20 Vol like they don't really.
- 1:05:22It's like high voltage power coming into your house.
- 1:05:26It's nice to have it, but then you don't want it in your hair
- 1:05:30dryer, lest you drop it into the bathtub and electrocute
- 1:05:33yourself, right? Or on your electric razor.
- 1:05:36So you've got this big transformer box that steps down
- 1:05:41high voltage to low voltage digestible power.
- 1:05:46So some people, some people, what they want to do is they
- 1:05:50want to lever up like micro strategy levers up Bitcoin to
- 1:05:55get to higher Vol, higher performance.
- 1:05:58And, and that's the that's high volatility equity.
- 1:06:02And that's why some people like our stock, But and some people
- 1:06:06are degenerate crypto traders and they want 10X leverage.
- 1:06:11So if you want to, to have real leverage, you buy the calls, you
- 1:06:17don't even buy the equity, right?
- 1:06:18You know, we're, we're levering, we're levering 1.25 to one or
- 1:06:231.3 to one. There are people that want 2 to
- 1:06:261/4 to 1/8 to 1. You know, there's MSTX.
- 1:06:31Have you heard of that? Yep, that's Andy's on top of
- 1:06:35this, Jesse, I, I got you guys pegged.
- 1:06:38Andy is the traitor and Jesse is the fundamental, you know, macro
- 1:06:44analyst thinking about the long term and the philosophy.
- 1:06:48And I think the two of you paired together is probably a
- 1:06:51good thing, but because you need the one and the other.
- 1:06:55MSTX has got $185 million in capital they've raised in two
- 1:07:00weeks and they're offering 1.75 X levered long MSTR exposure.
- 1:07:08Risky, OK, put it, put this in perspective.
- 1:07:11There are a lot of ETFs that have been that have been out
- 1:07:14there for years and years. They can't raise 100 million in
- 1:07:16capital, right, of 500 million in.
- 1:07:19And these are ETFs that, you know, they charge fees, 99 basis
- 1:07:24points, 129 basis points. Somebody created a business, you
- 1:07:28know, overnight that will generate $5,000,000 or or $10
- 1:07:34million in fees. That'll scale.
- 1:07:36And it's just like one person with a Bloomberg trading an hour
- 1:07:41a day, right? But so there's a lot of appetite
- 1:07:45for that obviously in the options market.
- 1:07:49Micro strategy has about $22 billion of open interest in the
- 1:07:54options market right now. And 11.5 billion is short.
- 1:07:59It's it's puts, OK. And 10 and .8 is long.
- 1:08:05So the put to call ratio is like one O 6, the duration's 172
- 1:08:10days. This is my best guess right now.
- 1:08:13Don't hold me to it. You can do your own calculations
- 1:08:15if you like, but I look at that and it's like, OK, well, a lot
- 1:08:21of people just want to short Bitcoin with with leverage.
- 1:08:25So they, they basically, or they want to short, they short micro
- 1:08:28strategy or they, or they, and they can borrow the stock to
- 1:08:32short it, but then they can also just buy the put.
- 1:08:36And then maybe they go along the underlying Bitcoin with call or
- 1:08:41they own the spot ETF or something.
- 1:08:44And you know, it's like their favorite trade or somebody's
- 1:08:47favorite trade. And, and I don't mind, like I, I
- 1:08:51see my, my, my belief is we're here to provide an institutional
- 1:08:58bridge. If you want to go long short
- 1:09:01with leverage, without leverage, there's one set of people that
- 1:09:04want more leverage and more volatility and we're giving it
- 1:09:08to them. And there's another set of
- 1:09:10people that want less volatility and less leverage, you know, So
- 1:09:17you, you know, you buy our convertible bonds right now.
- 1:09:21My last snapshot was you get 82% of the upside, 9% of the
- 1:09:25downside of the equity. OK.
- 1:09:29Well, so maybe somebody wants that.
- 1:09:31Yeah, right. Like maybe?
- 1:09:32$300 trillion. A bond market wants that.
- 1:09:36So coming back to your question, I think if you're a normal
- 1:09:40person, you know, and, and you just want the risk free thing,
- 1:09:45the risk free thing is buy Bitcoin whole Bitcoin forever
- 1:09:50and turn off the television, right?
- 1:09:53And, and I, I think there's a lot of investors for which
- 1:09:57that's wise if you're a professional or if you have a
- 1:10:02very particular, you know, entity, right?
- 1:10:07I mean it's or a particular portfolio if you're a
- 1:10:10professional investor or money manager, you've got you've got
- 1:10:13to protect your coin of your client saying I want fixed
- 1:10:16income, I want to generate this much, I need to generate, you
- 1:10:20know yield etcetera. Well, I mean, one thing I do
- 1:10:24think is I don't think you should go, you should chase
- 1:10:26after yield with FTX or offshore unregulated opaque exchanges,
- 1:10:32not wise. If you're going to chase after
- 1:10:36yield, you should do it with regulated entities with full
- 1:10:38disclosures, knowing what, what kind of risks you're taking and
- 1:10:44with and with clarity as to who's accountable for the risk.
- 1:10:50But I don't, I don't recommend anything because I, I really do
- 1:10:54believe there's 50,000 publicly traded companies.
- 1:10:59It's, it's, the question is, are, are any of them underpriced
- 1:11:05versus the risk expected return? And that, that comes and goes.
- 1:11:10That's very complicated. And then you've got, you know,
- 1:11:13there's 50,000 nice pieces of art and there's 50,000 cool
- 1:11:17buildings. And those are all things you can
- 1:11:19invest in. I just think you ought to be an
- 1:11:21expert and fixated on it. And I take the position that
- 1:11:26probably they're all going to underperform Bitcoin.
- 1:11:29And you know, 29% ARR is pretty good.
- 1:11:34I mean a very simple idea is if you can figure out a way to
- 1:11:37borrow money long term at 1/3 of that, if you can borrow money at
- 1:11:44at 8% and you could then loan it to the Bitcoin network at 29%
- 1:11:53and you've got a duration on that, on that debt instrument of
- 1:11:58eight years to 12 years. Now you're 3 epics, right?
- 1:12:02You're probably going to be fine.
- 1:12:04That's brilliant. I mean, how do you do that way?
- 1:12:06You could have done that with a 15 year mortgage at 2.8%
- 1:12:10interest 24 months ago, right on your real estate, right.
- 1:12:13So if you can do a 15 to 30 year mortgage at low interest rates
- 1:12:18and just and then buy Bitcoin, you're arbitraging 368 percent
- 1:12:26money versus 29%. And that's that's intelligent.
- 1:12:30If you can create a company that raises equity or debt to buy
- 1:12:35Bitcoin, that's intelligent. If you can borrow money at 4%,
- 1:12:41that's even more intelligent. If you can borrow money at 1%
- 1:12:44and buy Bitcoin with it, no recourse more than four year
- 1:12:47duration. I think you ought to do that,
- 1:12:50right? That would be intelligent.
- 1:12:52So, so levered Bitcoin levered long as long as it's not mark to
- 1:12:58market degenerate. I mean like when you're when
- 1:13:00you're trading 10X leverage. What that means is Bitcoin
- 1:13:03trades down a few $1000. You get forced liquidated while
- 1:13:06you're sleeping and you lose everything.
- 1:13:08That's stupid. Don't do that right?
- 1:13:11But, but a simple idea is if you have capital and you can hold it
- 1:13:16more than four years, I think you buy the Bitcoin and just
- 1:13:19forget about it. If someone will give you a loan
- 1:13:23and they're not going to ask for the money back in less than four
- 1:13:26years, you can consider it. You see, if they're giving you a
- 1:13:30loan for one year, right, you might get wiped out on that,
- 1:13:34right? Or if they're giving you a loan
- 1:13:36where you have to actually post additional collateral every day,
- 1:13:40if Bitcoin trades down, right, that's actually anxiety
- 1:13:44inducing. But when the loan duration goes
- 1:13:47to more than four years and there's no mark to market, well,
- 1:13:50that's probably interesting. And of course, if you can get
- 1:13:53out to 8 years, it's, I would kind of say four years duration
- 1:13:57on equities, a no brainer 8 year duration on debt starts to feel
- 1:14:03safe. And I guess my issue with all
- 1:14:05these other ideas is you can either give me a very
- 1:14:08complicated entrepreneurial idea and I stare at it, but it's just
- 1:14:12so complicated and it's, it's, you probably don't even know the
- 1:14:17way you're going to fail. I might rather you just give me
- 1:14:21a financing idea like, hey, we can take over this cash cow
- 1:14:25company for one times revenue and then we can convert its
- 1:14:29balance sheet into Bitcoin and then we can lever it up by
- 1:14:32borrowing $2 billion at 8% interest.
- 1:14:36I mean, I, I like that idea better, right?
- 1:14:40Just a very simple idea. I'm going to borrow a billion
- 1:14:43dollars at less than the cost of capital.
- 1:14:46The risk free cost of capital is fill in your number.
- 1:14:49Mine's 29% but if you're pessimistic maybe yours is 12%.
- 1:14:55OK. If your if your base case
- 1:14:57forecast is 12% and borrow the money at 4% and it works right?
- 1:15:02And and this is all still in the context of $899 trillion of
- 1:15:07value is not earning 29% annualized.
- 1:15:11And you know the like the best asset class historically is
- 1:15:16venture capital earning 25%, but you have to lock it up for 10
- 1:15:19years and and all the returns come from the top decile.
- 1:15:23So you know, like that's what everybody else is looking at as
- 1:15:26as their riskiest longest term bet or you could just get the
- 1:15:29most liquid asset returning 29% plus.
- 1:15:34Yeah, I think people work too hard at this.
- 1:15:36I mean, it's very simple idea. You've got a trillion dollar
- 1:15:38asset going to $100 trillion asset.
- 1:15:41It's 100 X. And so what's the best way to
- 1:15:44make money? It's it's basically capitalize a
- 1:15:49private company with Bitcoin, capitalize a public company with
- 1:15:53Bitcoin. You know, convert debt to
- 1:15:55Bitcoin, borrow money and buy Bitcoin.
- 1:15:58If you're, if you're AVC, you can try to find the next 10
- 1:16:02Alibaba's that's hard. Or you can just go and invest in
- 1:16:0810 private companies that do anything that are cash cows.
- 1:16:14How hard is it to find a company growing zero to 5% that makes
- 1:16:18money? It's easy.
- 1:16:20How hard is it to find a private company that's going to grow
- 1:16:23more than 20% a year for the next decade without consuming
- 1:16:28capital hard? Go find one of the cash cows
- 1:16:32that's private. Invest in them.
- 1:16:35Convert their treasury to Bitcoin over capitalize them,
- 1:16:41take them public. The equity becomes a Bitcoin
- 1:16:45derivative. The volatility is off the
- 1:16:48charts, right? If half the enterprise Oregon
- 1:16:51more is Bitcoin, you get to a 55 Vol, then you've you've set fire
- 1:16:55to the company. You make fortune, right?
- 1:16:57What risk did you take? You have Bitcoin risk.
- 1:17:00You see everybody, but here's the thing, right?
- 1:17:03I mean this is a big ego thing. Everybody's got a big ego, and
- 1:17:08the biggest idea and the biggest, most important thing in
- 1:17:13the 21st century was already invented and discovered by
- 1:17:16Satoshi. Satoshi created digital capital.
- 1:17:22Digital capital is worth hundreds of trillions of
- 1:17:25dollars, $400 trillion by my last estimate.
- 1:17:30Somebody's already invented a better idea than you're.
- 1:17:33If you're going to, you think you're smart enough to come up
- 1:17:35with a better idea than $450 trillion idea.
- 1:17:41Like what's the second best idea?
- 1:17:43Right, right. The price there is no second
- 1:17:46best idea, right? There's a you know, there's an
- 1:17:49idea, it's called Bitcoin. It's digital capital.
- 1:17:53OK, so you've got the best idea and you're a business person.
- 1:17:58And if you humble yourself before Satoshi and you recognize
- 1:18:04the brilliance of digital capital and you recognize the
- 1:18:09fact that this is inevitably going to go from a trillion to
- 1:18:1210 trillion to 20 trillion to 40 trillion to 80 trillion to 160
- 1:18:17trillion, it's the nothing stops this train, right?
- 1:18:22Nothing stops this train. Once you recognize that you're
- 1:18:27AVC investor, what do you do? You invest in private companies,
- 1:18:30put them on the Bitcoin standard, take them public, and
- 1:18:33they strengthen the Bitcoin system and then they draft off
- 1:18:37the Bitcoin network, right? You're a private equity
- 1:18:41investor. You find big private companies,
- 1:18:45you invest in them, you recapitalize them with Bitcoin.
- 1:18:48You take them public. You're an invest.
- 1:18:52You're an investment banker. What do you do?
- 1:18:54You don't. You don't negotiate 1000
- 1:18:58complicated mergers between 1000 different counterparties or or
- 1:19:03how many different pairs? 1000 companies and A and 1000
- 1:19:07options each. So it's 1000 * 1000 combinations
- 1:19:12and you can solve all of the com combinations because you're
- 1:19:15brilliant. Or you just merge 1000 companies
- 1:19:18with Bitcoin. Bitcoin is a universal merger
- 1:19:22partner. OK, I got 1000 zombie companies
- 1:19:24at the bottom of the Russell 2000.
- 1:19:26How do you fix them recapitalize them on Bitcoin?
- 1:19:30Bitcoin is the universal merger partner.
- 1:19:32OK, but but but I need to come up with a new idea.
- 1:19:35No, you don't. Satoshi already came up with the
- 1:19:38idea right? Everybody wants to come with a
- 1:19:41new idea. Well, I got a company.
- 1:19:42I got to grow my company. Oh, is your company going to
- 1:19:44grow faster than 29% a year with no cost risk free for the next
- 1:19:5021 years? You have a better idea than
- 1:19:52that, right? Again, you have pride cometh
- 1:19:58before a fall. A bunch of alpha males running
- 1:20:02around and they all they all look at like, yeah, Satoshi was
- 1:20:06smart, but I got a better thing. Yeah, Bitcoin was good, but I
- 1:20:09got a better thing. You know, it's like, but, but
- 1:20:11you know, how am I going to get rich and famous if I just
- 1:20:17embrace Bitcoin? It's like, by the way, there are
- 1:20:22ways to get rich and famous by embracing Bitcoin, right?
- 1:20:26The problem is when you stray from the path of righteousness,
- 1:20:31you embrace Bitcoin, you become a great Bitcoin custodian.
- 1:20:36Then you trade shit coins, right?
- 1:20:38You embrace Bitcoin, you create a Bitcoin fund, then you start
- 1:20:42to trade altcoins, right? You embrace Bitcoin, you
- 1:20:47securitize it, and then you drift off to do the next thing,
- 1:20:50right. The world's full of people that
- 1:20:53they found it and then they thought, well, I've, I've
- 1:20:56conquered this. Now I got to do something else,
- 1:21:00you know, by, by the way, I was that guy, right?
- 1:21:02When I, yeah, when I came public, I had a good thing.
- 1:21:05MicroStrategy, the greatest business intelligence software,
- 1:21:08We grew for a decade. We conquered the world.
- 1:21:10And I was like, OK, well, I've declared victory.
- 1:21:12Now I got to invent 210 more things, so I launched 10 more
- 1:21:16things. I launchalarm.com, I launch
- 1:21:18angel.com, I launch wisdom.com, I launch alert.com.
- 1:21:21I launch blah, blah, blah. It's like none of those work as
- 1:21:25well. It's like, guess what?
- 1:21:28Just because you can do one thing doesn't mean you could do
- 1:21:30the next 10. He's like, you know, Napoleon.
- 1:21:34He Yeah, he ended up taking over France.
- 1:21:37Good for him. He was in Italian.
- 1:21:38He took over France. But then he's like, I think I'll
- 1:21:40take Italy, too. Oops.
- 1:21:42He took it. He lost it.
- 1:21:44I think I'll go conquer Egypt. Oops, he took it.
- 1:21:47He lost it. I think I'll go into Syria.
- 1:21:49That didn't work so well. I think I'll go take over Spain.
- 1:21:51Oops, that didn't work. Now I'll go conquer Germany.
- 1:21:55Oops, got it. Lost.
- 1:21:57I think I'll take Russia, get to Moscow.
- 1:22:01Oops. You know, he drops 3 armies
- 1:22:06along the way, one in Russia, one in Egypt, one in Spain.
- 1:22:10Manages to get whatever millions of people to follow him.
- 1:22:16They die, right? It's like, congratulations on
- 1:22:19that. Seriously, right?
- 1:22:21It's like the, it's, it's like the, the, you know, the
- 1:22:24Alexander the Great Napoleon complex.
- 1:22:27Everybody thinks that because they came up with one idea that
- 1:22:31they were put on earth that, you know, as God's gift to deliver
- 1:22:35their brilliance and the point. And there's a point of humility
- 1:22:39when you realize that maybe your brilliance was to discover
- 1:22:45somebody else had a good idea and to embrace the idea.
- 1:22:53So, yeah, I think there are a lot of good business I
- 1:22:55businesses to be created on Bitcoin, but the but the
- 1:23:00operative words are on Bitcoin, on Bitcoin and and focus and,
- 1:23:08and that's why laser eyes matter so much.
- 1:23:11It's just laser like focus, right?
- 1:23:14And just because you can do a thing doesn't mean you should do
- 1:23:17a thing. And, and some people have to do
- 1:23:20a thing or maybe there's a responsible way to do the thing
- 1:23:24because you're solving a problem.
- 1:23:26Like like in Shanghai, they want Bitcoin, but they need a state
- 1:23:30regulated, you know, custodian that the Chinese government will
- 1:23:33support. So the guy that sets up a
- 1:23:36Bitcoin ETF in Shanghai will open up a gateway for 1 billion
- 1:23:41Chinese people to buy Bitcoin. And that'll be good for China
- 1:23:46and good for the world and good for Bitcoin.
- 1:23:48And you know, that's an idea, right?
- 1:23:51There's there's probably another idea is probably a regulated
- 1:23:56Chinese company that could be the micro strategy of China.
- 1:24:00Because what is micro strategy doing?
- 1:24:02We're giving people bonds, we're giving them highball equity,
- 1:24:05we're giving them options. Do people want, but I mean, some
- 1:24:09people, how do you buy Bitcoin at the all time high and take
- 1:24:12very little downside risk or no mark to market risk?
- 1:24:15You buy a bond, you don't want the equity.
- 1:24:18So once you embrace the idea that the world's full of a lot
- 1:24:23of people, they're in different regulatory regimes, they're in
- 1:24:26different cultures, they're different, You know, that the 80
- 1:24:29year old has a different risk profile than the 20 year old.
- 1:24:34You know, institutions and churches and endowments have
- 1:24:38different tax treatments and different regulatory
- 1:24:40requirements than a hedge fund, than a ball trader, than
- 1:24:44institutional investor, right? So Satoshi gave us a big idea,
- 1:24:50like perfect money, profound big, huge paradigm shift idea.
- 1:24:55But it's not not different than electricity.
- 1:24:59It's like our fire, right? Or we can extract energy from
- 1:25:02material, right? Right.
- 1:25:05We can actually move energy cleanly, you know, powerfully
- 1:25:10over hundreds of miles into your bathroom.
- 1:25:13OK, that's the big idea. But how many different
- 1:25:15businesses got launched based on fire?
- 1:25:19How many businesses got launched based on electricity?
- 1:25:23A lot, right? Like a lot.
- 1:25:27How many businesses got launched or will be launched based on
- 1:25:29digital capital, digital energy? Oh, a lot, I have no doubt.
- 1:25:35But it's just like, just remember, you know, pick the
- 1:25:40right protocol, you know, and don't get distracted and, and
- 1:25:44try to avoid blowing yourself up, you know, in in the process.
- 1:25:49Sage, sage advice. I can't help myself by the way,
- 1:25:54going back to MSTXY and Ms. yeah, or MSTY&MSTX, just this is
- 1:26:00like public service announcement.
- 1:26:01And again, none of this is a investment advice.
- 1:26:04But for the D Jens out there, be advised that these are quote UN
- 1:26:07quote daily trading investments. So if the share price starts at
- 1:26:11$10 and it goes up to 11 the next day and then the next day
- 1:26:16it goes back to $10 to where it started.
- 1:26:18Actually, the way the math is you'll lose money.
- 1:26:21And that by the way, is if the instrument works.
- 1:26:24And in my, you know, I've been watching these daily levered
- 1:26:28instruments for years now, not specific to, to Bitcoin, but
- 1:26:32sometimes they blow up and sometimes they deviate
- 1:26:35significantly from their, from their benchmark.
- 1:26:37So it's all in the same vein as do your own research, be
- 1:26:40careful, watch out for leverage. Yeah, those are all securities
- 1:26:44trading ideas, and you should become a securities expert on
- 1:26:47the idea and think hard, right? The empowerment of Bitcoin is,
- 1:26:52wouldn't it be great if we took our money, we invested in an
- 1:26:56asset, and we could turn off the TV and forget about it for a
- 1:27:00decade? That's why at the end of the
- 1:27:02day, you have to keep coming back to Bitcoin, right and come
- 1:27:08back, come back to this idea of an asset without that
- 1:27:12counterparty risk, right? Without, without them, they're
- 1:27:15they're you could, you could talk for 20 hours about the
- 1:27:18risks, right? And, and for the most part, most
- 1:27:22people would benefit just understanding Bitcoin and and,
- 1:27:26and Bitcoin, I think is the solution to the great majority
- 1:27:29of the people's problems. These other things are it's like
- 1:27:35there's a professional guy who has an equity investment fund
- 1:27:40who might have $10 billion of capital and their charter says
- 1:27:44they have to invest in publicly traded operating companies that
- 1:27:48trade on the NASDAQ or the New York Stock Exchange.
- 1:27:52And so that guy can't buy Bitcoin, even though I would say
- 1:27:56that's the, you know, the risk adjusted best thing at the end
- 1:27:59of the day, it's like that, that guy can't buy that.
- 1:28:02And, and that guy took money from a pension fund that
- 1:28:06represents 8 million retired firefighters or something and
- 1:28:11they can't buy Bitcoin. So what you have is you have a,
- 1:28:14you have one pension fund that represents, that represents the
- 1:28:20interest of unborn children. You know, people that don't even
- 1:28:23live right now, right? It's a, it's truly a public
- 1:28:27institution with a long duration.
- 1:28:30They're looking out 100 years. They have allocated their
- 1:28:34capital to a variety of money managers.
- 1:28:38They they might have 2% with a commodity trader, that guy can
- 1:28:42buy Bitcoin. Maybe they've got another X
- 1:28:44percent with an equity trader, that guy can't.
- 1:28:48The pension fund can't do anything.
- 1:28:51So when you look at the way the capital is structured in the
- 1:28:5521st century, if you are a public company, you can create
- 1:29:00public securities that meet the requirements of all these pools
- 1:29:04of capital. That's just useful.
- 1:29:07That's a solution for them, right?
- 1:29:10Just just like a Chinese pension fund, it cannot and probably
- 1:29:14cannot buy a United States based software company, right?
- 1:29:18Just we have lots of pools of capital and they represent real
- 1:29:23people living dead or about to be born.
- 1:29:28And, and Bitcoin represents the digital transformation, the
- 1:29:32capital markets. And if you're going to rebuild
- 1:29:34hundreds of trillions of dollars of capital and you're going to
- 1:29:39give them a path from physical capital and financial Fiat
- 1:29:44capital to digital capital. Well, I mean, there's a lot of
- 1:29:48commercial banking to be done. There's a lot of investment
- 1:29:51banking to be done. There's a lot of money
- 1:29:53management to be done. There's a lot of journalism and
- 1:29:56analysis to be done. Someone has to create the
- 1:29:59securities and we need the auditors and the accountants to
- 1:30:03account for it. We need the lawyers to figure
- 1:30:05out how to disclose and assess all the risks.
- 1:30:09There's a bunch of regulations that have to be formed to
- 1:30:12clarify right there. There's a lot of work for a lot
- 1:30:16of people in the ecosystem. And, you know, you can make your
- 1:30:21career being a leader in any one of those areas.
- 1:30:26You know, there's a dude that figured out how to create
- 1:30:28electric shavers, you know, and the contribution is it works and
- 1:30:33it doesn't electrocute you. And it was probably a, you know,
- 1:30:38probably there's an entire company that dedicated their,
- 1:30:40you know, 30 years to perfecting that thing.
- 1:30:44And, and we're going to have the equivalent of those sort of
- 1:30:47things right in the digital assets ecosystem.
- 1:30:52And, and that's the inspirational part.
- 1:30:54There's something to do in your day job.
- 1:30:57That's, that's how you earn money.
- 1:30:59But you know, never forget, right, that I, you got to see
- 1:31:03the world as P&L and balance sheet on your P&L.
- 1:31:07You should do something, whatever you're best in the
- 1:31:09world at whatever your best. If you're a dentist and you're
- 1:31:13the best dentist in your city or you'll have a good job, my
- 1:31:17advice is make sure you stay on top of the dentistry thing,
- 1:31:21right? And be a good dentist on your
- 1:31:24balance sheet. That's where you want to take
- 1:31:27the lowest risk. You know, I, I would generally
- 1:31:30recommend someone figure out how to buy Bitcoin and just figure
- 1:31:33out are you going to custody it or who do you trust to custody
- 1:31:36it for you? And that's about the extent of
- 1:31:38the risk you want to take and leave all of the other risk
- 1:31:43taking to securities professionals who do it for a
- 1:31:47living. And you know, and they, and they
- 1:31:49can, they either obsess over it or they obsess over it.
- 1:31:53And then the they diversify. Like like my, my view is, I
- 1:31:57think diversification is a dirty word with regard with regard to
- 1:32:02Bitcoin. Like once I've decided it, I
- 1:32:05don't want to diversify. But if I'm trading securities,
- 1:32:09you know, if you said, well, here's 100, you know, 100
- 1:32:12companies backed by Bitcoin or 100 AI, One of my two best
- 1:32:18ideas, digital capital, digital intelligence.
- 1:32:21If you came to me and you said, well, here's here's a dozen
- 1:32:24digital intelligence ideas, well, I don't know if I'm going
- 1:32:27to put all of my money into one of them, right?
- 1:32:31And here's 10 companies on the Bitcoin standard.
- 1:32:34Which one do you trust? Well, you got to think really
- 1:32:37hard. You got to study all those,
- 1:32:40right? You know, and, and my job is to
- 1:32:43obsess over micro strategy. That's my day job.
- 1:32:46That's what I do. I'm not obsessing over the next
- 1:32:4927 companies, right? I don't have an information into
- 1:32:53their transparency one way or the other.
- 1:32:56So I think I think people should be very thoughtful about that.
- 1:33:03It's very interesting that I don't think I've heard anybody
- 1:33:06articulate this before. And I think you're kind of
- 1:33:08laying out the outline for what could be the next big wave of
- 1:33:11like private equity, like the leveraged buyout phenomenon of
- 1:33:15the 90s that where a ton of people made a ton of money by
- 1:33:18deploying this playbook with private equity of, you know, go
- 1:33:23buy cash flowing companies and and lever them up.
- 1:33:28It's. Like the LBO craze, right when
- 1:33:30you had cheap debt, you go and you basically LBO.
- 1:33:33How many companies did we LBO like 1000?
- 1:33:37Yep. Well, what kind of company?
- 1:33:38It doesn't matter. All I need is a company that I
- 1:33:40can lever up, right. So the point is, it's like the
- 1:33:44LBO craze was the last 30 years or or so.
- 1:33:47And this could be the next. Bitcoin craze, right?
- 1:33:49Yeah, that that's kind of wild to to think about.
- 1:33:52And there's always some frontier and finance where there's some
- 1:33:55fortunes to be made by deploying a a playbook.
- 1:33:58And I think you just articulated the outline of that for the next
- 1:34:0130 years of private equity. That's it.
- 1:34:03Note notice to investment bankers out there, Even if the
- 1:34:07Fiat system recedes, there's still plenty of work to do
- 1:34:12turning existing Fiat based companies into Bitcoin based
- 1:34:15companies. Lucrative work.
- 1:34:18That's it. Lucrative fees that can be
- 1:34:21stacked, stacked further in Bitcoin.
- 1:34:23Wow. Well, you've given us a lot to
- 1:34:25think about, Michael. This has been a tremendous
- 1:34:28conversation. Of course, I want to call
- 1:34:30people's attention to all your other fantastic content,
- 1:34:34hope.com, your recent presentations, HC Wainwright
- 1:34:38Conference, of course, the the Bitcoin conference keynotes.
- 1:34:43Are there any other final words you'd like to leave us with
- 1:34:47today? I think this is an exciting
- 1:34:49time. 2024 is like year 1 of institutional adoption.
- 1:34:53I mean I feel like the gun went off with January approval of
- 1:34:57ETFs. Next January the second gun goes
- 1:35:01off with fasby account a fair value accounting and then the
- 1:35:05the the third trigger is going to be full bank custody.
- 1:35:09And I don't know when that happens, but I think it happens
- 1:35:11definitely in the next 4 years. Maybe it'll happen faster
- 1:35:15depending upon the outcomes in November 5th.
- 1:35:18And so I think all of us, you know, we should grant ourselves,
- 1:35:25view ourselves as being fortunate to be in the Bitcoin
- 1:35:29ecosystem right now as the entire asset class is coming to
- 1:35:34life as a mainstream institutional asset.
- 1:35:37And as people start to recognize the power of the digital capital
- 1:35:42transformation. I'd encourage everybody just,
- 1:35:45you know, do your own work, you know, go to hope.com.
- 1:35:47There's a lot of information there.
- 1:35:49I, I post a ton on X, you know, slash Twitter and there's a lot
- 1:35:54of other good content, you know, everybody's putting on.
- 1:35:57So, so I think you'll find it to be interesting.
- 1:36:04And then depending upon your situation, there's
- 1:36:08opportunities. Everybody's got different
- 1:36:10opportunities. You have to just internalize it.
- 1:36:13I would laser like focus in on Bitcoin and then think hard
- 1:36:17about, you know, what are your professional assets that you can
- 1:36:22bring to bear? What kind of financial assets
- 1:36:24can you bring to bear? You know, what kind of political
- 1:36:28assets can you bring to bear? What kind of communications
- 1:36:32marketing assets can you bring to bear?
- 1:36:34And everybody can do something to both benefit themselves and
- 1:36:37benefit Bitcoin and benefit all the other Bitcoiners if they
- 1:36:42think long and hard about about what's about to happen.
- 1:36:47I would encourage people by the way, to go to the Bitcoin 24
- 1:36:50model, download it, play with it, create your own versions of
- 1:36:55it. Jesse, you know, you're the
- 1:36:57dude. So you should take it and and
- 1:37:00start to play with it because you know your initial chart with
- 1:37:04the 900 trillion of course has become quite famous by now.
- 1:37:08Thanks to you. Thank you for so much for using
- 1:37:10it. It's been it's been probably the
- 1:37:12biggest honor I've had in in Bitcoin is you taking those
- 1:37:15ideas and and broadcasting them to millions of people.
- 1:37:18So thank you. Well, I would add, I'm happy to
- 1:37:21do it. It was, it was a great
- 1:37:23contribution. But I'm also happy to point out
- 1:37:26that there's any number of 2045 charts that can be generated
- 1:37:30depending upon your assumption. I've been tinkering a little
- 1:37:32bit. Yes, Sir.
- 1:37:34And, and we just need the best and the brightest of the
- 1:37:38analysts in the community to think really hard about what's
- 1:37:41going on, because I think the Bitcoin community is special,
- 1:37:46because the people in the community think longer and
- 1:37:49harder and deeper about fundamental issues like
- 1:37:54inflation, demonetization, innovation, monetization, you
- 1:38:01know, asset macro economics. You don't see any gold people
- 1:38:05thinking super hard about the future of gold with the, with
- 1:38:10the open source community gold model.
- 1:38:12And you don't see the art people doing that.
- 1:38:15You don't see the real estate people, You don't see the people
- 1:38:18pitching the S&P index. At the end of the day, their
- 1:38:22position is just, well, just do it just because or, and in fact,
- 1:38:25the most common position is, well, we know it's probably all
- 1:38:28risky, You know, don't, don't invest any money you can't
- 1:38:32afford to lose, diversify and, you know, or just, or give me
- 1:38:36your money. And trust me, there's a lot of
- 1:38:38that. And I think that I think that
- 1:38:41Bitcoin 24, that model is, is US moving toward a position where,
- 1:38:48you know, the Bitcoin community, we're actually looking out 21
- 1:38:51years and we're thinking about this.
- 1:38:54And, and you can take that and you can crank in different
- 1:38:56assumptions about the US debt and the growth rate of, you
- 1:39:00know, any government. You can create models for any
- 1:39:03country, any company, any family, any endowment, the
- 1:39:08United States, all the other assets.
- 1:39:11And, and so there's a, there's a lot of very good discussions to
- 1:39:14be had there. And, and there's a lot of
- 1:39:17reasonable debate, but I think that I think that welcoming the
- 1:39:22debate is the beginning of a conversation that elevates
- 1:39:25everyone's thinking to new levels of sophistication.
- 1:39:30And, and ultimately there's just a lot of businesses, a lot, I
- 1:39:36mean, most corporations. What's your treasury strategy?
- 1:39:39Oh, well, we just buy treasuries and look for something better.
- 1:39:44What? We just have money parked there
- 1:39:47until we find a good merger, right?
- 1:39:49What what I mean, of course they'll have a strategy.
- 1:39:53They're their their strategy is just not to lose too fast.
- 1:39:58And, and you know, Bitcoin is a is about a strategy of winning.
- 1:40:02And most public companies, most private big companies and most
- 1:40:07startups, they all could immediately benefit if people
- 1:40:11started talking a lot more about, you know, Bitcoin
- 1:40:15treasury strategies. And you can go ahead and take
- 1:40:18Bitcoin 24 and you can spend out.
- 1:40:21Spin up these models, you know, to help everybody figure out
- 1:40:25where they want to take their company, their endowment, their
- 1:40:27whatever and elevate their thinking.
- 1:40:30I think 10X because most, most of these models and you know,
- 1:40:35are just intellectually vacuous. You know, they're garbagey
- 1:40:39things, short sighted, not very thoughtful.
- 1:40:43And I think it's, I think it's incumbent upon us to elevate
- 1:40:47everybody's thinking and sophistication and it'll be a
- 1:40:50benefit to the marketplace in general.
- 1:40:55Well, to our listeners, there's your admonition.
- 1:40:57Had those conversations help people figure out what they can
- 1:41:00contribute to Bitcoin, how they can capitalize on Bitcoin, how
- 1:41:03can they be a part of this exciting and rapidly growing
- 1:41:07sphere? And thank you, Michael, for all
- 1:41:09you've added to the conversation.
- 1:41:12And thank you for coming on Serious Assets.
- 1:41:14Thanks, Jesse. Thanks, Andy.
- 1:41:16Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:41:18If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:41:20episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:41:23app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:41:24today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:41:27Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Ramp Media is
- 1:41:29for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:41:32nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:41:35Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:41:37to hear from you. Visit on
- 1:41:39rampbitcoin.com/contact. Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:41:42of our private client advisors.