Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Stock Buybacks During Market Dips
Transcript
- Lucas: If you're running a recently public company and your stock drops ten percent in a week, the question isn't whether you should think about a buyback. It's whether you have the conviction to actually pull the trigger. Luna: And that's the tension, right? Because the same dip that makes the stock cheap also makes the board nervous. Lucas: Exactly. Today we're talking about how post ipo companies use stock buybacks specifically during market dips. Not the routine quarterly buyback, but the opportunistic, we see a disconnect kind. Luna: And we've got some real-time data to ground this. Looking at this week, Apple is up about five percent in five days, while Tesla is down over three percent. Two very different market reactions. Lucas: Right. Apple's buyback machine is well-known — they spent over $110 billion on buybacks last fiscal year. But the conversation around when to buy is much more nuanced for a smaller post ipo company with limited cash. Luna: So what's the playbook? When does a dip become a buyback opportunity rather than a reason to hunker down? Lucas: The starting point is having a disclosed buyback program already authorized. Companies that wait until the dip to ask the board for permission lose the element of surprise and the price advantage. The best practice is to have a standing authorization — say, $50 million over 12 months — and then execute at the company's discretion. Luna: So it's about preparation, not reaction. Lucas: Exactly. And the research backs this up. A study by the University of Chicago looked at buyback announcements from 2004 to 2020 and found that companies that buy back stock when their market price is below their intrinsic value — measured by book value or earnings multiples — outperform those that buy on a fixed schedule by about two percentage points annually. Luna: Two points is meaningful. But the challenge for a young public company is that the 'intrinsic value' argument is harder to make when the street doesn't have a long track record to evaluate. Lucas: That's the real rub. A company like Rivian, which went public in 2021, has seen its stock go from a peak of over $170 to around $17 today. If management believed in the long-term story, a buyback at $17 would be a massive vote of confidence. But they also need cash for operations and capex. Luna: And Rivian actually has done buybacks — small ones — but they've been cautious. They bought about $300 million worth of stock in late 2024 when the stock was in the $30s. Since then it's dropped further, so those buys are underwater. Lucas: Which is the nightmare scenario: you buy at what you think is the bottom, and the bottom drops out. That's why the most sophisticated post ipo buyback programs use algorithms to execute over time, not a single market order. Luna: We talked about algorithmic execution in episode 98. But the key point is they're using volume-weighted average price, or VWAP, algorithms to avoid moving the market against themselves. Lucas: Right. And they also use disclosure rules strategically. Under Rule 10b5-1, companies can set up a pre-arranged trading plan that allows them to buy back shares even during blackout periods, as long as the plan was established when they were not in possession of material non-public information. Luna: So you can have a buyback plan that automatically accelerates during a dip. That's clever. Lucas: It is. And some companies are starting to tie buyback triggers to specific valuation metrics. For example, a company might say: if our price to sales ratio drops below three times trailing revenue, we'll deploy $10 million in accelerated buybacks over the next ten days. Luna: That kind of transparency actually helps the market, because it signals that management sees downside as opportunity rather than crisis. Lucas: Exactly. And on the flip side, companies that announce large buybacks during a dip but then don't execute — that's a red flag. The market interprets inaction as a lack of conviction, and the stock can actually fall further. Luna: So it's not just about having the authorization, it's about following through. Let's talk about the cash constraint. For a post ipo company, especially one that's still burning cash, how do you decide how much to allocate to buybacks versus growth? Lucas: That's the fundamental capital allocation question. And the honest answer is that most CFOs of unprofitable tech companies should probably not be doing buybacks at all. The money is better spent on R&D or sales. But if you are generating free cash flow, the calculus changes. Luna: Case in point: Shopify. They went public in 2015, and for years they didn't do buybacks because they were reinvesting everything. But by 2023, they had turned profitable and had $5 billion in cash. They started a buyback program and have been opportunistic with it. Lucas: And Shopify's stock is up about twenty percent year-to-date. They've used buybacks to offset dilution from employee stock compensation, which is a common rationale for post ipo companies. Because when you issue shares to employees, you're diluting existing shareholders. A buyback can neutralize that dilution. Luna: Right. And there's a signaling aspect too. When you announce a buyback during a dip, you're telling the market: we think our stock is undervalued. But if you're wrong — if the decline is justified by fundamentals — you've just wasted cash. Lucas: Which brings us to the most important rule: don't fall in love with your own stock. Management teams are often overconfident about their company's prospects. That's why independent directors should be involved in setting buyback parameters. Luna: And that's especially relevant now, with the market seeing some sharp rotations. Look at the ARK Innovation ETF, ARKK, down almost four percent in five days. Some of the high-growth names in that fund are getting hit hard. Lucas: Yeah, and for a company like Coinbase, which is down about flat this week but has been volatile all year, a buyback during a dip could be a double-edged sword. If the dip is tied to regulatory news, you might be catching a falling knife. Luna: So how do you tell the difference between a value dip and a falling knife? Lucas: You look at the cause of the decline. Is it a market-wide selloff that's taking everyone down? That's a value dip — your fundamentals haven't changed. Is it a company-specific issue like a missed earnings estimate or a product delay? That could be a falling knife, because the market may be repricing risk. Luna: And in those cases, the best buyback is often the one you don't do. Lucas: Exactly. There's a great example from 2022. When the Federal Reserve started hiking rates aggressively, many tech stocks lost fifty to eighty percent of their value. A handful of companies — like Zoom and Peloton — did large buybacks near the bottom. But those buybacks didn't stop the declines because the fundamental stories were broken. Luna: Right. Zoom's revenue growth had already decelerated from triple digits to single digits. Buying back stock didn't change that. Lucas: So the takeaway for post ipo companies is: have a plan, use algorithms, be transparent about your triggers, and most importantly, be honest about whether you have the conviction to buy when no one else will. Luna: And if you're a listener who's building or running a public company, these are the kinds of strategic decisions that separate well-managed firms from the rest. Lucas: Speaking of that — if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, that's exactly why we do this. And it's why listener support matters so much. Luna: Yeah, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: Small amounts, real difference. No pressure, just if it's valuable to you. Back to the topic — one more thing I want to highlight is the role of buybacks in the IPO market itself. Luna: How so? Lucas: With OpenAI reportedly planning an IPO, and with Apple's lawsuit potentially disrupting those plans, the question is whether a company like OpenAI — which has massive capital needs — would ever consider buybacks. Probably not in the near term, but it shows how buyback strategy evolves over a company's lifecycle. Luna: From no buybacks to opportunistic buybacks to sustained buybacks. It's a maturity curve. Lucas: Exactly. And the companies that navigate that curve well are the ones that earn long-term investor trust.