Latest / C-Suite Perspectives / How to Build Retirement Income That Lasts: Prudential's Phil Waldeck
Transcript
- 0:00I have in-laws and a parent who are in their 90s, so I see one side of
- 0:04it, and then I have kids in their 20s.
- 0:06My kids have heard that debate many times at the table, which is you
- 0:10need to be in at the beginning.
- 0:12And I was very happy to see both their employers auto-enrolled them.
- 0:15And that's where I see where the psychology of this is so powerful, which
- 0:18is if you are hearing this message for decades and seeing your balance grow, in
- 0:24one sense, you take pride in the success that you're watching this balance grow.
- 0:29But another sense, you feel a sense of loss if you start to
- 0:33take it out and you see it go down as you are now in retirement.
- 0:37And I think the art of this is to get the idea that this isn't
- 0:42about a balance of success.
- 0:43It's about having a way in which you can draw down your retirement savings
- 0:49into income that you won't outlive.
- 0:52In today's conversation, we're gonna talk about the new retirement reality and
- 0:55financial security in an age of longevity.
- 0:59It's a lot of words but what it means is that we're living longer-- making
- 1:03great progress there-- but that's exposing issues in our retirement system.
- 1:09So joining me today to talk about all this is Phil Waldeck, head of
- 1:12businesses in the US at Prudential.
- 1:15Phil, welcome.
- 1:17Steve, thank you, and thanks to The Conference Board.
- 1:19Yeah.
- 1:19It's apropos that we're having this conversation because we are in
- 1:23National Retirement Security Month.
- 1:26I presume that you didn't describe it that way.
- 1:28It's some congressional designation, but it's a great initiative because
- 1:32it's meant to highlight where we are in our retirement system and what
- 1:36people should be thinking about, right?
- 1:38Retirement security is one of the defining themes of our time, so this
- 1:42month it's helpful to have focus on it.
- 1:44As longevity is increasing, as you described, and as a significant population
- 1:49moves into retirement, this matters more not only for the individual lives, but for
- 1:55our economy and for society more broadly.
- 1:58This is becoming a bigger and bigger need in terms of getting it right.
- 2:01Yeah, and here we are, the baby boomers are coming to the end of their careers.
- 2:04This generation has been the pig through the python on every aspect,
- 2:08because they're just so big.
- 2:10Boomers are the ones that were born between 1946 and 1964.
- 2:14But you also see the beginning of the next generation, which is Gen
- 2:17X, are starting to retire too.
- 2:19So you've got a couple of generations here, and people are living longer.
- 2:23So you got a lot of people who are retired right now.
- 2:26There will be 75 million people over the age of 65 by the
- 2:29end of this decade in the US.
- 2:31And at the same time, you described how you've got multi-generations.
- 2:34You've got people in the middle that are the sandwich generation that
- 2:38are navigating the lives of their children, often adult children,
- 2:41and their parents, and taking care of their own retirement needs.
- 2:45That's a lot of wants.
- 2:46That's a lot, yeah.
- 2:47You got elder care, you've got children, you got grandchildren, you're retired.
- 2:51A lot of pressure on this generation, and hence, the subject, which
- 2:56is retirement security, right?
- 2:58Yes, and I would say there's pressure on our federal government and our
- 3:02fiscal resilience, given the state of the economy in terms of the size of
- 3:08debt compared to our GDP, 100% of GDP.
- 3:11The ability of the government to do more to help in that situation has some limits
- 3:16given the scale of the obligations we already have and a need to secure those.
- 3:22But increasingly, individuals and employers will have to do more
- 3:26to make that system work better.
- 3:27Yeah, it's really true.
- 3:29The Conference Board has written a lot about this, where for over 40 trillion
- 3:33dollars in debt is way over 100% debt to GDP, but we're running 2 trillion dollars
- 3:38in deficit every single year, mostly because of Medicare and Social Security.
- 3:43So that's putting even more pressure on the system as you have more
- 3:46retirees going into all of that.
- 3:47And servicing that debt, I'm sure, is increasingly
- 3:50challenging as rates have risen.
- 3:51And to the extent that rates are greater than your rate of growth, that's a
- 3:56really tough squeeze play in terms of crowding out the rest of the budget.
- 3:59So yes, getting Social Security and Medicare, that's job one, but being able
- 4:03to do more than that in terms of the federal government, pretty challenging
- 4:07when it comes to retirement security.
- 4:08So in terms of what is the new reality, which is what you've
- 4:11been talking about, it is this growing population in this group.
- 4:15It's the cost of servicing it from a federal and a state standpoint.
- 4:20But retirement funds are not returning as much and it's not as powerful
- 4:25with inflation as high as it is.
- 4:27So you've got declining buying power, all of this leading
- 4:30to some level of insecurity.
- 4:32And you don't have the structure that prior generations benefited from
- 4:36in terms of number of people under defined benefit plans that solve that
- 4:40collectively, and there's a reason why that became challenging for employers.
- 4:44But the reality is that's less and less likely to be providing the answers for
- 4:50employees who have workplace retirement in terms of defined contribution plans,
- 4:55but it's not the same in terms of their resilience to the risks that they face.
- 4:59So you've just completed a new survey just recently, the Retirement Pulse Survey,
- 5:03looking at retirement savings and all.
- 5:06Talk about some of the headlines from your survey.
- 5:08I think the headline here, and this is the 28th year we've done this survey.
- 5:11This survey's intended to identify financial, behavioral, and emotional
- 5:16challenges that Americans face.
- 5:18And right now we have what you just described, increasing longevity, a
- 5:22cohort that is facing those challenges, and a need to get prepared to navigate
- 5:28the uncertainty of retirement.
- 5:30One of those uncertainties is how long will you live?
- 5:32And because of that, people often lack confidence in terms of entering
- 5:36retirement and the complexity of, gee, I built this account balance,
- 5:40but now how do I draw it down?
- 5:43Am I gonna take it out too fast and run out, or am I gonna take it down
- 5:47too slow and live more modestly?
- 5:50So there is a significant cohort that has been successful through the workplace
- 5:54but that now is facing a new challenge in which they lack confidence and have
- 5:59a level of fear that's not good for them individually and not good for our society.
- 6:03You read, Phil, in the newspaper that this generation of retirees is
- 6:08the wealthiest ever, and it makes it sound like they're eating caviar
- 6:11every night or whatever it is.
- 6:12But that's not everybody.
- 6:13And there's a whole lot of people who are kinda living
- 6:16paycheck to paycheck, as it were.
- 6:18Yeah, so there's a few things going on.
- 6:20On one hand, there has been great progress on building retirement savings.
- 6:24That's been one of the successes over the last few decades in
- 6:28terms of employer-based plans and where there are defaults,
- 6:31auto-enrollment, auto-contribution, auto-allocation into investments.
- 6:35So there is a segment of America that has done pretty good, meaning that's made real
- 6:42progress and built up a lot of retirement assets at the workplace and in IRAs.
- 6:47Then there is a group that doesn't have sufficient access, and they
- 6:51are vulnerable, that we need to get into some version of auto savings.
- 6:56And for those that were relatively successful, that have built these
- 6:59balances, they're now paralyzed often in terms of what do I do?
- 7:04How much do I draw down?
- 7:05And they have what we call FORO rather than FOMO-- meaning fear of running
- 7:11out rather than fear of missing out.
- 7:14And even those that have been successful see that balance
- 7:18and they're afraid to use it.
- 7:19And that's not good for them individually and it's not good for the economy
- 7:23overall in terms of spending and the dynamics that could otherwise occur.
- 7:27Yeah, I had a grandmother that lived to be 99, and I asked her, I
- 7:30said, " What wisdom do you wanna pass on?" And this was a few years ago.
- 7:34She said, "Well, don't outlive your retirement savings."
- 7:38Which she was joking.
- 7:39She still had her sense of humor.
- 7:41But it's not a joke for a lot of folks who really have run through it very quickly,
- 7:46and particularly in high inflationary times, it's not covering the costs.
- 7:50And I think they are right to be concerned, meaning if there is a longevity
- 7:54pool of one where I've got to save for, is it 10 years or is it 30 years?
- 7:59Is it 40 years?
- 8:00That's a great variation in terms of how much do I need.
- 8:04And if it's a large population, that's what pension plans do, that's what Social
- 8:08Security does, that's what annuities do in terms of pooling longevity risk.
- 8:13But if I'm an individual, I want to prepare for the worst.
- 8:15And so your 99-year-old grandmother had some logic in what she was saying that
- 8:20she appropriately didn't want to run out.
- 8:23But the baby boomers have been told from the beginning of their adulthood, "Don't
- 8:27count on Social Security 'cause there's, it's not gonna be around. You're gonna
- 8:30pay in your entire life and you're gonna get nothing out of it." It hasn't come to
- 8:35fruition, but you can see in a very short period of time where that might happen.
- 8:41And so it does mean that there's gonna be greater pressure from
- 8:45a private standpoint and from a self-assurance standpoint on making
- 8:50sure that people can cover their own.
- 8:51Yeah, I would be astonished if our society let that happen.
- 8:54I think we obviously-
- 8:56But it could be means tested.
- 8:57It could be means tested.
- 8:58There could be a variety of solutions that could change Social Security.
- 9:02But it is a great success in terms of protecting elderly against poverty.
- 9:07But to the broader point, we are gonna be debating that over the next few years
- 9:11knowing that the point with which there will be insufficient Social Security
- 9:16funds to meet obligations that is coming, and it's not that far, 2032.
- 9:21That will put this in the spotlight, and that will increase anxiety
- 9:26for baby boomers and others which is, all right, what can I count
- 9:30on and how do I protect myself?
- 9:32And that's where I think having some portion of one's retirement capabilities
- 9:39being protected lifetime income is an important dynamic, and that's part of what
- 9:44the private sector, employers, financial institutions, insurers can be a part of.
- 9:49And you think of this as a challenge, and we've been talking about it in
- 9:51terms of the baby boomers, early Gen Xers, but if you're a Gen Z or even
- 9:56a Gen Alpha, it might be even worse.
- 9:58You really have to be thinking about retirement from the very
- 10:01beginning of your adulthood.
- 10:02Yes, and I have in-laws and a parent who are in their 90s, so I see one side of
- 10:07it, and then I have kids in their 20s.
- 10:09My kids have heard that debate many times at the table, which is you
- 10:14need to be in at the beginning.
- 10:15And I was very happy to see both their employers auto-enrolled them.
- 10:19Both their employers have contribution escalation and auto
- 10:24allocation into target date funds.
- 10:26Those are the types of solutions that work, and that's part of how you get
- 10:30that generation on the right track.
- 10:32It also needs some version of auto income as a way in which they can safely
- 10:39draw down and have pooled longevity, and I think that's the missing part
- 10:44of that auto equation, either at the workplace or through individuals.
- 10:48Yeah, so talk about that because one piece of it is collect the assets.
- 10:51The other piece of it is make sure that the assets produce enough income so
- 10:55that you can live year to year without depleting all those assets, right?
- 11:00And that's where I see where the psychology of this is so powerful, which
- 11:03is if you are hearing this message for decades and seeing your balance grow, in
- 11:08one sense, you take pride in the success that you're watching this balance grow.
- 11:14But another sense, you feel a sense of loss if you start to
- 11:17take it out and you see it go down as you are now in retirement.
- 11:22And I think the art of this is to get the idea that this isn't
- 11:26about a balance of success.
- 11:27It's about having a way in which you can draw down your retirement savings
- 11:33into income that you won't outlive.
- 11:36And that's a mindset shift that can be helped at the workplace and in
- 11:40other varieties of environments in which you start to see your balance
- 11:45as an income stream, what it produces as opposed to just a balance.
- 11:48And then there's the mix.
- 11:49When you're more junior in your career or your lifetime actuarially, you
- 11:54try to produce growth and then later on you try to reposition for income.
- 11:57And this is something that Prudential are experts at.
- 12:00Yes.
- 12:00So I think yes, you do need both, and you're gonna need some element
- 12:03of that growth into the decades that you may live after retirement.
- 12:07So I'm not implying that 100% of somebody's balance should
- 12:10suddenly be an income, but a portion of it is appropriate.
- 12:14And communicating what that might produce in income along the way, every single
- 12:19statement, every single communication, that's how you change the orientation
- 12:24so it's not just about the balance and what does the balance accomplish for you.
- 12:27, Phil, there used to be this magic thing.
- 12:29You do X amount in equities, X amount in fixed and, yeah.
- 12:33And that didn't work for about the last 10 or 20 years.
- 12:36What do you do now?
- 12:37I think there is uncertainty that people face, whether it's inflation, whether
- 12:41it's health care costs, whether it's concerns about the economy, and that's
- 12:44where diversification is valuable, where some version of protection is appropriate,
- 12:49meaning having your basics covered.
- 12:52And our survey demonstrates that people really value having their basics
- 12:56covered so they then have the license to spend on things beyond their basics.
- 13:01So I think some level of pooling of risks, both market risks and longevity
- 13:06risk, is a helpful solution for people.
- 13:08Yeah, now risk is something else that your study looked at and there's
- 13:12the risk you just talked about but there's also just risk in life.
- 13:16Which is what you try to insure for.
- 13:18There's risk of catastrophic loss.
- 13:20There's risk of a market crash, which seems to happen, you know
- 13:24more regularly than you'd like.
- 13:26Financial crises.
- 13:28But also personal issues like health issues that can deplete
- 13:32your capital base, right?
- 13:33So you've gotta balance all of that risk and backstop for it.
- 13:36It's a very complex undertaking when you think about when I
- 13:38referenced the pension plan before.
- 13:40It took care of a lot of that for someone.
- 13:42But I think that's why ultimately people need to be in early on
- 13:46retirement savings, the autos.
- 13:48People need a structure that gets them on the right path
- 13:52that they could default out of.
- 13:54And then they're gonna need advice and guidance on how to then move into
- 13:59retirement and have a portion that's protected and a portion that's flexible,
- 14:03both to either grow or to be used for larger exposures like long-term
- 14:09care or a big health care expense.
- 14:11And that's why you need to have a balance of both income that's protected that
- 14:16you can't outlive but also an investment account that could be drawn on for the
- 14:21types of risks that you referenced.
- 14:23Yeah, now what we were told coming up is save as much as humanly possible.
- 14:27Put it away.
- 14:28You don't know about the future and it's uncertain.
- 14:30All that.
- 14:31But now you hear the politicians saying people have too much.
- 14:34There's no reason why you need more than whatever your favorite
- 14:37number is in an IRA, and we're gonna start seizing assets in the IRA.
- 14:40You probably heard some of this as well.
- 14:42And so the cynical people say why should I bother doing this when all
- 14:46the politicians are gonna take it away?
- 14:48How do you respond to that?
- 14:50I think that we've done a lot very well in terms of building the savings
- 14:54base and I think the security of those assets, I would have confidence that
- 14:59the existing retirement system, both individual and workplace, will be
- 15:03preserved and protected, in part because what we started our conversation on in
- 15:07terms of debt to GDP, the scale of the problem, and the efficiency that the
- 15:13economy gets when things are pooled.
- 15:15It costs a lot more if every individual has to save to 100 as
- 15:19opposed to having the pooling of risk.
- 15:21I don't think the politicians will be tapping the piggy bank
- 15:24the way that you just described.
- 15:25You never know, but that's the prevailing wisdom.
- 15:27Now, then you have the whole pre-tax versus post-tax debate about savings.
- 15:31You have a point of view on that?
- 15:33There are benefits to young people going the route of Roth
- 15:36and paying their taxes up front.
- 15:38So it depends on your age and your time horizon.
- 15:40And your tax rate.
- 15:41Exactly.
- 15:42Yeah.
- 15:42Yeah.
- 15:43And it's a balance and this is why if you don't have the expertise on your own, you
- 15:47really should seek the expertise, right?
- 15:49And that's another one of the themes that is emerging from our survey, which
- 15:53is roughly a quarter of people have advice-- which means three quarters
- 15:58don't-- and roughly a quarter of the people have a plan in terms of
- 16:03some sort of withdrawal strategy.
- 16:05And people need more advice, need more access to financial advisors,
- 16:09need that in a objective way that aligns with their interests.
- 16:13And it needs to happen at the workplace and outside of the workplace
- 16:16because these are complicated topics for people to navigate.
- 16:19How do you know who to trust?
- 16:20I have my own point of view on that but how do you advise people?
- 16:23'Cause you hear these stories about well, they're making their money on the churn.
- 16:27They're putting you in the kind of investment vehicles where it's good for
- 16:30them but it may not be good for you.
- 16:32Just give us some themes on what our listeners should look for.
- 16:35I think for most Americans, they have a lot of trust in their employer and the
- 16:39employer has fiduciary responsibilities for their workplace plans, and they're
- 16:44gonna want to do the right thing for their workers, and they'd wanna do so
- 16:47in a way that doesn't expose their firm.
- 16:49So I think whatever can be delivered via the workplace is
- 16:52a really effective platform.
- 16:54And having unbiased advice or guidance is valuable in that setting.
- 17:00You had talked a little bit about the responsibility of the employer.
- 17:03And some of that is legal.
- 17:04ERISA and another rule.
- 17:06We have a lot of listeners who are human capital professionals and C-Suite folks.
- 17:10It really is a different world, and the role of the employer and the trust in
- 17:15the employer is absolutely critical.
- 17:17So it's a benefit, but it's part of the whole relationship
- 17:20with your employees, right?
- 17:22Yes.
- 17:22Employers consistently care about their workforce.
- 17:25Now, they have business to run, so this is part of their economic model, but I
- 17:30think it is sincere that employers are doing and want to do the right thing.
- 17:35Ensure there's governance around what they do in terms
- 17:38of their fiduciary obligations.
- 17:40But employers are a real force for good in this system, and I think
- 17:44how we get policymakers, employers, financial providers, academics on
- 17:49the same page to help employers have the either legislative and/or
- 17:55regulatory support to do this properly.
- 17:58That's how we can get to a better place both for workplace plans, for
- 18:02communicating income, for making income solutions defaults that can be a part
- 18:08of a plan for a portion of the assets.
- 18:10But that role of the employer has been part of the success that has
- 18:15gotten us to where we are today.
- 18:17It is a frustration that we hear over and over again from CHROs that
- 18:21employees don't value the benefits component of their total rewards.
- 18:25They look at base salary 'cause they know they can count on that.
- 18:29They can see it in their paycheck, however frequently that is.
- 18:32Even an annual bonus, it's a black box.
- 18:35They don't count on it.
- 18:36It doesn't motivate employment.
- 18:38And so more and more you hear, "Gosh, I should just start getting rid of the
- 18:42benefits because there's the people aren't valuing them. They're job hopping
- 18:45based on getting a bump in the base when you've got all this huge amount of
- 18:51compensation that's really in the benefits side." How do you advise CHROs and other
- 18:56executives to to deal with this in a way that is salient to their employees?
- 19:03They will know their own workforce better than you or I will.
- 19:05Health care is probably the issue that is most challenging there.
- 19:09It costs more than employees think, and that is squeezing the
- 19:13employers more and more given the rate of health care inflation.
- 19:17But I think ultimately, this is part of the glue that sticks
- 19:21with employees, particularly when we have economic downturns and
- 19:25periods of stress in the economy.
- 19:27I think this is part of the value proposition that gets long-term
- 19:31stickiness, which is valuable for employers given the cost of turnover.
- 19:35Yeah.
- 19:35Now, we're in the US, we're not in Europe, but you read about
- 19:38the UK system where they've lengthened the retirement age to 68.
- 19:42At the same time, you've got France at 62 and rioting when they try
- 19:46to move it up by a day or two.
- 19:48It's really remarkable.
- 19:50And you have some of that debate still here in the US, and you have
- 19:53people who say, "Oh, I can't wait, I'm gonna retire at 55." Shouldn't
- 19:56people be thinking about keeping the income stream going longer as well?
- 20:00There's a variety of reasons as an individual, as an employer, and
- 20:04as society, where it is beneficial to have people working longer.
- 20:08We're gonna have that demographic upside-down pyramid, lots of baby
- 20:12boomers, not that many workers, harder for the economy to grow and harder for
- 20:16those workers to support this system.
- 20:19But we recently sponsored a survey earlier this year with the Global Aging
- 20:22Institute that looked at five different countries-- UK, US, Japan, Netherlands,
- 20:28and Australia-- and the US has a voluntary system where employers choose
- 20:33to offer plans, so we have to make it attractive to employers to wanna do so.
- 20:37And I think that's part of the balancing act.
- 20:40Sure, if you could just mandate outcomes that would create results
- 20:45on paper, but politically that wouldn't work in our society.
- 20:49So this voluntary system that we have has done a lot really well.
- 20:52The increase in coverage, the effectiveness at building those
- 20:57balances that we discussed earlier.
- 20:59But I think if you're potentially gonna have a 30 or even 40-year
- 21:03retirement, that age 55 retiree doesn't make a lot of sense.
- 21:07Yeah.
- 21:08Now you mentioned AI a little earlier.
- 21:10Is AI really gonna be a helpful tool to individuals through this
- 21:14process and/or is it gonna be helpful to employers in this process as
- 21:19well, or is it still a lot of hype?
- 21:22I think it ultimately will be helpful to individuals and to employers.
- 21:25You know, what activity did you take in the last week in which you purchased
- 21:29something where you started with AI?
- 21:31Probably the way you used to Google it, now you use an AI engine.
- 21:34When you approach that interaction, you've got some foundation of knowledge.
- 21:39When you go to the doctor, etc., people are tapping it
- 21:42as a way to get up to speed.
- 21:45Employers will do that, individuals will do that, and in this space that has great
- 21:49opportunity to make things more effective and cost efficiently effective that has an
- 21:55opportunity, and I think that can be good.
- 21:56And you would think that individuals would be able to put in enough information
- 22:00about where they are in their life, what their income level is, what their asset
- 22:04base is, what their plans are, and do scenario planning essentially and you
- 22:09still are relying on actuarial data.
- 22:12Nobody knows how long they're gonna live and what their needs are but it ought
- 22:15to be pretty instructive in terms of, "Hey, this is how much you gotta save.
- 22:19Here's how you should be thinking about it," all the things you talked about in
- 22:22order to get to the end successfully.
- 22:24Yes, and I think individuals will do this, companies will do this for their
- 22:27workplace plans, and advisors that are advising those individuals inside and
- 22:32outside of the workplace, those advisors have their own AI engines that are helping
- 22:37them be more efficient and effective.
- 22:39In our survey we identify that individuals want the AI engine
- 22:43and they want the human advice.
- 22:45So I think it's gonna be an and, not an or.
- 22:48Yeah.
- 22:48It's really important 'cause you can't just turn this thing over
- 22:51to a tool that doesn't have an overlay of human judgment on it.
- 22:55Yeah.
- 22:56There obviously has to be a regulatory overlay here to make sure it's
- 22:58done right, and there needs to be human judgment to help people.
- 23:02And sometimes it is helping people know what they need to do and actually do it.
- 23:08The challenge often is one of access, where people need access to that extra
- 23:13coaching and discipline to get it done because left to their own devices they
- 23:19often avoid complicated decisions.
- 23:21And when you avoid things associated with retirement, time is not your friend.
- 23:25Starting early, getting it in place right, is way better if you do it
- 23:30early, including these income solutions.
- 23:32Any final thoughts here that we haven't covered or any other insights from your
- 23:36survey that you wanna share with people?
- 23:37I think I would ask employers to take the next stage in terms of making sure
- 23:43income is understood and visible in terms of translating those balances.
- 23:48Work to have income solutions in your plan, and then if I'm an
- 23:51individual, you need to build a plan.
- 23:54And that means use the tools from your workplace and individually to
- 23:59understand how to build this plan, including a withdrawal strategy.
- 24:03And then I think probably for everybody, we need to support policy that makes
- 24:07this more likely to happen, which is why I keep hammering on the default
- 24:11aspect of it 'cause I think that's how we get better outcomes as a society.
- 24:14And the reason for a National Retirement Security Month, which we're in,
- 24:18is to raise awareness of this and really give permission and remind
- 24:22employers that you need to do a little education here for your employees
- 24:26about the importance of all of this.
- 24:28Exactly, Steve.
- 24:29There is a whole generation of people that are approaching retirement
- 24:32or just starting retirement that have been savers, and how do you
- 24:36turn them into effective spenders?
- 24:39That's a very different dynamic for this next stage of their life.
- 24:43Phil Waldeck from Prudential, thanks for being with us today.
- 24:46Great pleasure.
- 24:47Thank you, Steve.