Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Final Negotiations on the State Budget
Transcript
- 0:10Good evening and welcome to
- 0:11Kentucky tonight. I'm Renee
- 0:12Shaw coming to you from a
- 0:15legislative conference room
- 0:16in the capital and next.
- 0:18And Frankfort. We're here with
- 0:20just a few days left for the
- 0:212024 Kentucky General Assembly
- 0:23in regular session. Our topic
- 0:25tonight is the state budget.
- 0:27The Republican led House and
- 0:29Senate have each passed budget
- 0:32bills. But there are
- 0:34disagreements. Negotiations are
- 0:35under way to reconcile the
- 0:36differences and there are
- 0:38disagreements between the
- 0:38Republican plans and Governor
- 0:40Andy Beshear's budget request
- 0:41to discuss the budget and what
- 0:44we should expect. We're joined
- 0:45by 4 members of the Kentucky
- 0:48General Assembly who are part
- 0:49of those budget negotiations.
- 0:51States. Senator Chris McDaniel,
- 0:53a Republican from Rylan Heights
- 0:54and chair of the Senate
- 0:55Appropriations and Revenue
- 0:58Committee
- 0:58state Senator Robin Webb, a
- 1:00Democrat from Grayson and a
- 1:01member of the Senate
- 1:02appropriations and Revenue
- 1:06Committee. State and amaze
- 1:08Bledsoe, a Republican from
- 1:09Lexington and vice chair of
- 1:10the Senate appropriations and
- 1:15Revenue Committee and state
- 1:16Representative Cherilyn
- 1:16Stevenson, a Democrat from
- 1:17Lexington and House Minority
- 1:20Caucus chair. We do want to
- 1:21hear from you tonight. So send
- 1:24us your questions and comments
- 1:25by X, formerly Twitter at K
- 1:29why Tonight K E T send an
- 1:31e-mail to K why tonight at KET
- 1:33Dot Org or use the web form
- 1:36at KET DOT Org. Slash K why
- 1:37tonight? Or you can simply give
- 1:42us a call at 1, 804, 9, 4,
- 1:4376, 0, 5, will welcome you all.
- 1:44Thank you. I know it's a busy,
- 1:46busy time and I cannot express
- 1:48my immense gratitude for taking
- 1:48the time you do have, which is
- 1:52so precious to be here for
- 1:52tonight's discussion about the
- 1:53state budget. I want to go to
- 1:56you. Chair McDaniel
- 1:57just say, how's it going?
- 1:58Where are we here? Well, we're
- 1:59continuing through the process
- 2:01and I would say it's going We
- 2:04we're in a very fortunate
- 2:04>> Our colleagues in the House
- 2:08passed over a spending document
- 2:09it largely aligned with a lot
- 2:10of the philosophical views that
- 2:13we share. And I think that
- 2:13while we do have disagreements
- 2:16and we're still working through
- 2:17those disagreements, I'm I'm
- 2:19optimistic that we will have a
- 2:20shortly at the weekend that we
- 2:22can put out to the public.
- 2:23>> So the time is easing out of
- 2:26that hourglass right now.
- 2:27The sand is and we by Thursday.
- 2:29That's when you think that
- 2:30you'll have a budget that will
- 2:32be agreed upon and voted on.
- 2:33>> By both chambers, I would
- 2:35say that if there's one thing
- 2:36we're committed to its ensuring
- 2:39that we protect all of our a
- 2:42veto override and we would
- 2:43having up by Thursday and
- 2:44Friday could be a late night.
- 2:45But nonetheless, Thursday, last
- 2:48until 11,
- 2:4959 59 right.
- 2:51>> What I want to come to you
- 2:53to talk about the budget
- 2:54negotiation process, what you
- 2:57hope is possible what it comes
- 2:59to, perhaps some of the
- 2:59governor's requests or do you
- 3:04see things? Well, the bench is
- 3:05a long time, you know, better
- 3:06part of 2 decades since a lot
- 3:08more fun. When you get a little
- 3:08money.
- 3:09>> And you can be a little more
- 3:12hopeful. And if you're finding
- 3:13your final word, put their
- 3:14money and not put the cut.
- 3:18So well. I think we are up have
- 3:20agreed on some some good things
- 3:20in it. You know, not everybody
- 3:22is going to get what they want.
- 3:25That's for sure. And some of
- 3:26the pros a government such as
- 3:27Pre K and you know, I don't
- 3:30never was too. Didn't think
- 3:31that was going to happen
- 3:33anyway. As far as
- 3:35sustainability and the dollar
- 3:36amounts. But there are other
- 3:37things. I think everybody
- 3:39agrees on Manda where you're
- 3:43going to see
- 3:45some improvements programs.
- 3:45I center McDaniel can talk
- 3:46about this more than a, but it
- 3:49appears that, you know, we're
- 3:52just going to do a one-time
- 3:53money and some of the but we've
- 3:56got some great projects.
- 3:57We've got some great and that's
- 3:58not a bad word. Will he get
- 4:00when you look at the AG Center,
- 4:04it read in and things like
- 4:04that. Investments in order,
- 4:07Kentuckyian pays Kentucky.
- 4:09I think I think FIFA we're
- 4:11going to turn out a fairly good
- 4:12product.
- 4:13>> Well, as has been, so it is
- 4:15nice when you do have some
- 4:16extra money to play around with
- 4:19ride. This is not a Santa steer
- 4:21time is sometimes we have had
- 4:22in years past. So how do you
- 4:23view the opportunities that lie
- 4:25before the state right now and
- 4:26and what do you hope the final
- 4:28product will look like? The
- 4:30main priorities in the message?
- 4:32It will send a Kentucky ends
- 4:33about where you put your
- 4:33priorities when it comes to
- 4:36funding. Sure. You write it
- 4:37the benefit of having the
- 4:38discipline. The General
- 4:39Assembly has had for years has
- 4:41led us to this point. It's a
- 4:42privilege to walk in early in
- 4:45and see that. It's it's nice
- 4:46for me and others who are and
- 4:47if you will, to say this is a
- 4:48great opportunity to invest in
- 4:51services for our state. And
- 4:52that's what this is. Taxpayer
- 4:53money is essentially
- 4:54investments into the
- 4:56commonwealth. The projects too
- 4:58investments in personnel and
- 4:59other things that really
- 5:02provide good services. So I
- 5:03like the conversation around
- 5:04the recurring expenses in
- 5:05operating funds and looking
- 5:08at the one-time expenses that
- 5:09really are here now may not be
- 5:11here in the future and to make
- 5:13those one-time investments that
- 5:14are transformational, that
- 5:17really do think the
- 5:18commonwealth are one on one
- 5:18opportunities, a lifetime,
- 5:19maybe some time. So I'm I'm
- 5:21excited for that conversation
- 5:22and the whys and discipline
- 5:22around operating expenses so
- 5:24we don't put ourselves in the
- 5:25future positions. We can't
- 5:27continue to do so. Those
- 5:30investments of the one
- 5:31investments, Representative
- 5:32Stevenson, what do you think is
- 5:34missing from the list?
- 5:35>> Well, missing from the would
- 5:39be, of course.
- 5:40I'm going to I'm going to talk
- 5:43about universal Pre-K teacher
- 5:45raises or school employee
- 5:48bonuses, as you will. If if
- 5:49if we're going to use one-time
- 5:53money, I understand that a
- 5:53recurring program like
- 5:56universal Pre-K cannot be in
- 5:58there. you know, at missing
- 5:59from all of the budget so far
- 6:02has been. Raises for school
- 6:03employees. And I think that
- 6:05that is of a very sorely missed
- 6:09opportunity here. And obviously
- 6:10we're talking about making
- 6:10investments in Kentucky's
- 6:14future and there is no better
- 6:16investment than in education.
- 6:20And so I think that while
- 6:21there's going to be a lot put
- 6:23toward education. I think that
- 6:26we're missing the boat on
- 6:27several key, KET he says.
- 6:27Well, the governor said as much
- 6:30today when he talking about an
- 6:31economic development
- 6:32initiatives that were being
- 6:34rolled out today and he said
- 6:35this, quote, I want to thank
- 6:37both the House leadership for
- 6:37originally sitting down with us
- 6:39and making some pretty
- 6:40significant changes.
- 6:41>> To their budget before
- 6:42sending it to the Senate.
- 6:43And then the Senate has sat
- 6:45down with us numerous times
- 6:46called with any ways that we
- 6:48can help. And while I very much
- 6:49want to see teacher raises and
- 6:51any final budget and it would
- 6:52be hard to have a good final
- 6:55budget without them. I do
- 6:56appreciate the level of
- 6:57communication we've received,
- 6:58especially from Senate
- 7:00leadership. chairman, again, we
- 7:03don't always hear that that
- 7:04there's been a lot of
- 7:05conversation between the first
- 7:06floor in the 3rd floor of the
- 7:07Capitol. As we call it. It
- 7:09seems that the governor is
- 7:09quite complimentary of being
- 7:11included in this process.
- 7:15>> Certainly, you know, while
- 7:15ultimately it is our task is
- 7:19our constitutional duty to
- 7:21present a budget of the The
- 7:22governor is the head of the
- 7:22executive branch has access to
- 7:25a lot people and information
- 7:25that we as the legislative
- 7:26branch don't necessarily have.
- 7:29And also there will be
- 7:30responsible to execute a
- 7:32document that problem date.
- 7:35And having regular
- 7:38conversations with them is I do
- 7:40think certainly we don't share
- 7:42a unanimity in our priorities,
- 7:43but we do have a common element
- 7:44of trying to make the best
- 7:47decisions for Kentuckians is
- 7:47hope.
- 7:48>> So raises for teachers out
- 7:51right off the table.
- 7:52>> I think it's a very
- 7:54difficult step to I was here
- 7:55the last time as was Senator
- 7:57Webb that we did teacher
- 7:57raises. And one of the it was
- 7:58actually my first budget
- 8:00session. One of the things it
- 8:04sticks in my memory very
- 8:04dramatically is a school
- 8:05superintendent coming in and
- 8:06saying, look, when you guys
- 8:07do raises because of how the
- 8:13seek formula pushes. It is
- 8:13different. And he showed me in
- 8:14just in the 5 districting.
- 8:15I have 5 school districts in my
- 8:18Senate district. How it hit
- 8:18different ones differently.
- 8:19And for some, it actually
- 8:20netted them money and for
- 8:22others, it cost them money to
- 8:24do. The raises that we mandated
- 8:26and and, you know, the nature
- 8:27of of the seek formula, which
- 8:29we used to fund our schools is
- 8:30it started with a
- 8:31constitutional provision to
- 8:33provide a common system of
- 8:33schooling through the rows
- 8:34decision at the Supreme Court
- 8:38through hero for hot for
- 8:39education reform that gave us
- 8:42the seek formula. So this is a
- 8:43constitutionally based funding
- 8:46formula and any deviation
- 8:48from it. The begins to skew
- 8:49us towards being out of
- 8:50constitutional compliance.
- 8:53And so both from the practical
- 8:55side as well as a
- 8:55constitutional side. I for how
- 8:59we make this happen.
- 8:59>> Yeah, so what has this
- 9:00sidewalk teacher raises?
- 9:02Do you think the approach
- 9:03should be let the local
- 9:03districts had all that money,
- 9:04give the money to them? Let
- 9:06them dispersant or should it
- 9:06come directly from the state is
- 9:09an appropriation. Individual
- 9:11districts have individual
- 9:12priorities and not teachers.
- 9:13Don't always get the benefit of
- 9:15that in parity.
- 9:16>> If you will. And I think,
- 9:17you know, with the court
- 9:17decision kind of requires
- 9:19parity of some sort of Ida,
- 9:21a district that borders to
- 9:23other states and we lose
- 9:23teacher. So we've got to really
- 9:27focus on on not attraction.
- 9:29Retention and pay them a living
- 9:32wage so that that that would be
- 9:34a priority. Mine in you know,
- 9:35retired state employees and we
- 9:38hear a lot
- 9:39from them. I would like to wave
- 9:41a wand and help those folks.
- 9:43But but I think, you know,
- 9:43overall, as far as executive
- 9:47branch goes when you've got to
- 9:49give them regardless, he's
- 9:50governor, not about this is
- 9:51always been my budget. Plus, be
- 9:52gardens. He's in the executive
- 9:54branch leadership. You've got
- 9:55to give them the flexibility
- 9:59necessary given expense
- 10:01expanding and for economic
- 10:01development for disasters, for
- 10:02things of that nature. I think
- 10:04we're going to have polls of
- 10:05money for those things. But
- 10:09but what if, you know, we
- 10:10East and West Kentucky, the
- 10:12experience last couple years,
- 10:14just I want to make sure
- 10:14there's safety net there and
- 10:15the governor's got whoever the
- 10:16governor is has flexibility
- 10:20to respond and that we've still
- 10:20got people suffering and mode
- 10:24next of the woods in LA.
- 10:25I made a promise to not forget
- 10:26about him. Yeah. So want to go
- 10:28to as buzz about that, too, to
- 10:31talk about disaster, perhaps or
- 10:33about direct appropriation from
- 10:35the state for teacher raises to
- 10:36teachers instead of sunlight
- 10:37through the local school
- 10:38districts. Your perspective
- 10:40on that? I share the chairman's
- 10:42perspective and I think the
- 10:43challenge.
- 10:44>> And before I came, I only
- 10:45had Fayette County. So I know
- 10:46how Fayette County did things
- 10:47and you kind of get outside
- 10:48realize it's not the same in
- 10:49these counties that do have
- 10:49different struggles. Their
- 10:51priorities are sometimes
- 10:53different. And I think you have
- 10:54to get the context as well.
- 10:56The whole piece of the
- 10:57education puzzle it is
- 10:57transportation is per people
- 10:59funding. It is lots of things
- 11:01we do one on Lars list, other
- 11:02things we do. Investments for
- 11:05education, all ties into how
- 11:06we want to give some support
- 11:08for educational systems.
- 11:09You can't. You can focus on one
- 11:10with that. Look in the context
- 11:11of the whole. But I think we're
- 11:13trying to pretty good job
- 11:15addressing that. Yeah. So
- 11:16representative students and
- 11:16we've heard from a lot of the
- 11:18members of the education
- 11:19community, the K groups about
- 11:21the teacher pay along with
- 11:22student discipline issues have
- 11:23been things that have really
- 11:25contributed to the teacher
- 11:27shortage on the ranking of
- 11:28teacher paid. You think that
- 11:29should be the thing that state
- 11:30lawmakers put some emphasis and
- 11:32focus on?
- 11:34>> I absolutely do. And I well,
- 11:36I love our teachers. I think it
- 11:37should be across the board.
- 11:38I think it should be all school
- 11:41employees because cafeteria
- 11:42workers and janitors and bus
- 11:43drivers. You know, they help
- 11:45make our schools go as well.
- 11:46So I don't want to leave them
- 11:46out of this conversation.
- 11:50However. You know, I think it's
- 11:51important that we really stop
- 11:52it and think about that because
- 11:56we know that last time plan, we
- 11:58just gave money through sake.
- 11:58Only one single district in all
- 12:02of Kentucky gave a comparable
- 12:04raise as to what state
- 12:07employees got. So I think that
- 12:08plan we're looking you know, it
- 12:11not being equal. I think it's
- 12:13only going to be equal if it
- 12:15comes from us. And we know that
- 12:17the governor had proposed 11%
- 12:19across the board for all school
- 12:21employees. And that would put
- 12:22us right in the middle of was
- 12:23starting an average teacher
- 12:27pay. So.
- 12:28We can't KET wanting in saying
- 12:30that we want to attract the
- 12:31best and the brightest and then
- 12:33retain those teachers here.
- 12:35If we're not going to pay them.
- 12:36As you hear, we're losing
- 12:36teachers to Tennessee. We're
- 12:39losing teachers to Ohio, West
- 12:40Virginia all the time because
- 12:43they are paying a higher
- 12:44salary. And I think that we
- 12:47have to look at that because
- 12:48education is absolutely without
- 12:49a doubt. The best investment
- 12:50that we can make in Kentucky.
- 12:52If we are talking about returns
- 12:55on our investments, that is
- 12:56absolutely the place where we
- 12:57are going to say the most
- 13:00return and also I think it's
- 13:01what my constituents absolutely
- 13:05want as well. But also think if
- 13:06we want to KET investing in
- 13:09economic development. It
- 13:12doesn't make any difference.
- 13:12How much money we put in that
- 13:15if we do not have an educated
- 13:17workforce. So speaking of
- 13:18races, we've gotten a question
- 13:20or And this comes from a viewer
- 13:23Sean Crowe, Anderson County
- 13:25and says, quote, the governor
- 13:27proposed 6% for state
- 13:29employees. But plus,
- 13:29compression raises. And I want
- 13:32us to talk about that. The
- 13:32House decrease this to 4% with
- 13:33no compression raises. The
- 13:34Senate is now trying to
- 13:36decrease again.
- 13:37>> To 2.6%. Why doesn't the
- 13:39legislature understand the
- 13:41state employees have needs to a
- 13:42quote, world drowning in this
- 13:43inflation? I'll let you answer
- 13:46that. Mister Chairman.
- 13:47>> Unfortunately, you know,
- 13:48President Biden passed expose
- 13:49Inflation Reduction Act.
- 13:50We've seen nothing but more and
- 13:52more inflation. And the fact is
- 13:57in our budget last time we
- 13:57appropriated millions of
- 13:58dollars to employ one of the
- 14:00nation's best a compensation
- 14:03survey firms and they went with
- 14:06our personnel cabinet position
- 14:08by position throughout state
- 14:09government. And we appropriated
- 14:11a series of to raise is the
- 14:12first was 6%. And the second
- 14:13was an aggregate of 12 and a
- 14:16half percent in order to start
- 14:17out the raises and then fully
- 14:21implement them in the end,
- 14:21we're with the exception of a
- 14:23few. It We're at the end of
- 14:24that. Those have been fully
- 14:28implemented fully paid for 2.6%
- 14:29is the Federal Reserve's
- 14:29personal consumption
- 14:31expenditures, which is largely
- 14:33their preferred measure for
- 14:34inflation at this point.
- 14:36So it's our belief the governor
- 14:37finished the implementation of
- 14:39this at the end of last
- 14:41calendar year that we should
- 14:44adjust as based off of the
- 14:45Federal Reserve's
- 14:45recommendations for inflation
- 14:47so that we don't get ourselves
- 14:50into a bind again. But you
- 14:52raise an excellent point which
- 14:52is which is a very unique thing
- 14:55inside of the type structure
- 14:59the state government has the
- 15:00the House as a called for a
- 15:04study in to fund in their
- 15:05budget and we are largely in
- 15:06agreement with them because
- 15:06it is an issue that needs to
- 15:10be addressed. But much the same
- 15:12way that we found it necessary
- 15:12to pull in relevant data points
- 15:16from around the nation as well
- 15:18as the We think the same thing
- 15:19needs to be done with the
- 15:20compression issue. Now, now
- 15:22that we understand where the
- 15:23various positions and rankings
- 15:25ball in terms of compensation.
- 15:26Now we need this study
- 15:27understand how to decompress,
- 15:30where those positions are.
- 15:31And I think that there is a a
- 15:32pretty universal commitment.
- 15:35I would in both chambers as
- 15:36well as across the to address
- 15:39that right.
- 15:40>> And so when you say
- 15:40compression for those who are
- 15:43not for me with the term
- 15:43talking about salary
- 15:44compression, where those who
- 15:46may be newcomers to the system
- 15:48are getting as much salary
- 15:49compensation as those who have
- 15:50been and a system of the agency
- 15:51for period of years, 20 years,
- 15:52plus or so. That's the essence.
- 15:56So yes, make it simple, Anyone
- 15:57else want to comment on the
- 15:58compensation for state workers
- 15:59because that's also a worker
- 16:00retention issue, too, right?
- 16:03I mean, maybe perhaps is even
- 16:05felt in the legislative ranks
- 16:06with the staff. I think we're I
- 16:07think we're failing at all over
- 16:10other feeling. Miller say to be
- 16:10honest for the first time, I
- 16:14can see her.
- 16:14>> It says my tenure here.
- 16:15But when you're talking about
- 16:16personnel, I think it's also
- 16:21worthy to note that. So we need
- 16:23to fund person that full
- 16:23personnel complement, which is
- 16:25budget banal may not be totally
- 16:28do. And when you're talking
- 16:30agencies that have unfilled
- 16:32positions, those need to be
- 16:34funded now and then we need
- 16:36to talk about the increases.
- 16:37But what I fear is what the
- 16:42inability to to have those
- 16:44slots filled. If you look at
- 16:46permitting which, you know, I
- 16:46had a lot of national
- 16:47committee's permitting says a
- 16:50problem. If you don't have the
- 16:51staffing in the agencies to
- 16:55permit him for some in
- 16:56administer. It's going to slow
- 16:57economic growth and that it's
- 16:59it's going to be a problem.
- 17:01So I just hope we can feel our
- 17:02spins it in some of that.
- 17:04The state government can run.
- 17:04So does the Senate agree with
- 17:06the House on the vacancy
- 17:09language?
- 17:12Largely
- 17:12>> The the so that the house
- 17:13did took into consideration.
- 17:14A lot of the recommendations
- 17:15from the executive branch about
- 17:18how those working to for the
- 17:18for those at home. It's a it's
- 17:20a bit of a nuance inside of
- 17:21state government called vacancy
- 17:22credits and how long those are
- 17:24open and whether or not
- 17:25positions need to be field can
- 17:28be filled so on. And you know,
- 17:29the adjustment that they may
- 17:30when they made gotten pretty
- 17:33where we think that they need.
- 17:34>> It's right. And it doesn't
- 17:36affect active current workers.
- 17:37What I think people hear that
- 17:38they can seize, they think of
- 17:40possible elimination of jobs.
- 17:41And so we want to be clear that
- 17:42that's not where that is going
- 17:44to. Sara Lee, anything you want
- 17:45to add their server but said,
- 17:47okay. So this question all from
- 17:50I'm Patricia Doherty of
- 17:52Lexington. She says, quote,
- 17:54senior citizens have lost the
- 17:55federal discount for Internet
- 17:57and phone service. My bill has
- 17:59gone from $14 a month to $50 a
- 18:00month, even though this was a
- 18:04federal issue. Why has the
- 18:05legislature not looked at
- 18:06solutions statewide to help
- 18:07out the seniors and disabled
- 18:08community whose rates are going
- 18:10up.
- 18:13>> I would struggle to comment
- 18:14on that one. Yes, that's a
- 18:16that's a federal program that
- 18:18I'm not terribly familiar And
- 18:20where we are regularly called
- 18:24upon to take a look at expiring
- 18:24federal programs, whether or
- 18:26not to the state as it is a
- 18:29compelling interest in
- 18:30participating beyond that.
- 18:31And you certainly something
- 18:34could be taking a look at sure.
- 18:35The districts like mine.
- 18:38You you're working on getting
- 18:39Internet to everyone. We don't
- 18:39quite hit, but we're not there
- 18:41yet, right? But there are
- 18:43broadband investments, right?
- 18:44We both both by Camel agree
- 18:47on right?
- 18:51>> Maybe just happen. You want
- 18:53to comment? you know, the one
- 18:55thing that we definitely do
- 18:57have control of is
- 18:59>> the retirees that we have
- 19:04from the state the House
- 19:07Absolutely nothing. The Senate
- 19:10budget includes about
- 19:1175 million dollars for one-time
- 19:12benefit for state retirees and
- 19:13Governor Beshear head in about
- 19:16100 million dollars. And this
- 19:17group hasn't had a raise in
- 19:20over a decade. So I think you
- 19:22know what? We have direct
- 19:23control over. That would be the
- 19:23one thing that we could do that
- 19:27would help, you know, elderly
- 19:30retirees, at least those from
- 19:30the say, well, we do get a lot
- 19:32of questions. We have one from
- 19:32Harrisburg, our state retirees
- 19:33going to get a raise. I've been
- 19:36retired 10 years.
- 19:37>> Without a Senator blood.
- 19:38So this may be something that
- 19:40you hear about. I absolutely
- 19:41think we all hear about it.
- 19:41And I think the question with
- 19:44inflation that they got feels
- 19:46more intense than it did
- 19:47before. And the promise of the
- 19:48Johnson, but at least thus far
- 19:50has been until we reach a
- 19:51certain threshold. That's just
- 19:52not something that we're going.
- 19:55Take a look at the 13th check,
- 19:56though, was what that is as
- 19:57close. And that's a separate
- 19:57idea. And that was kind of a
- 19:59knowledge. None of we haven't
- 20:01had that and having to do is
- 20:02to provide that. And that's
- 20:04a one-time expenditure would
- 20:05provide someone isn't some
- 20:08assistance. Its immediate that
- 20:09doesn't. I'm coming to that
- 20:10long-term. The current cost
- 20:13issue right childcare. So they
- 20:14want to shift their because I
- 20:16think the House and Senate have
- 20:17different approaches when it
- 20:17comes to childcare funding.
- 20:20And we know that childcare is
- 20:20many would say, and we've had
- 20:23several programs on Kentucky
- 20:23tonight. We've talked about how
- 20:25this industry undergirds other
- 20:27industries and allows
- 20:27particularly women as primary
- 20:29caregivers to get back into
- 20:31the workforce. I'll start with
- 20:33Houston. Representative
- 20:38Stevenson almost gave
- 20:43status Senator Webb was in a
- 20:43season. Have your your take on
- 20:45the thank you. Well, we all
- 20:47know that there is a looming
- 20:48childcare crisis in September.
- 20:52A lot of the
- 20:52>> Funds that were coming from
- 20:53the federal government are
- 20:54going to go away. And that's
- 20:56about 330 million dollars that
- 20:59we need
- 21:01>> replace, I think passing
- 21:04Senator Perils Horizon Act
- 21:04could a really good step in the
- 21:05right direction. It gives about
- 21:08150 million toward childcare
- 21:11needs the Senate budget has a
- 21:12believe about 90 million
- 21:14combined for the 2 years.
- 21:15So it's definitely something
- 21:18that we need to look for
- 21:19because this is a huge problem
- 21:20is going to face are young
- 21:24Kentucky family soon in
- 21:25September. A lot of them are
- 21:25going to either be looking at
- 21:28having no child care or a huge
- 21:29balloon payment for their child
- 21:31care. All of a sudden. And I
- 21:33think that we need to look for
- 21:34because as you said, it is a
- 21:35workforce issue and we want
- 21:38women to be able to maintain
- 21:39themselves in the workplace or
- 21:41get back into the workplace.
- 21:43This is something that we're
- 21:44absolutely going to have to
- 21:48invest and as a public Senator,
- 21:49Bledsoe, your your take on this
- 21:50child care is a is a major
- 21:52issue. We know about the
- 21:53horizons acted. Representative
- 21:54Stevenson just mention
- 21:55300 million dollars that
- 21:56Senator Danny Carroll, a
- 21:57Republican, has that would help
- 21:59kind of shore up.
- 22:00>> The industry give it the
- 22:01Bowie it needs and kind of help
- 22:03with the workforce issues and
- 22:04keeping childcare providers
- 22:06even afloat. Your take on, do
- 22:07you want to see more money for
- 22:10child care assistance? I think
- 22:11that's almost like saying we
- 22:12have so much money has been
- 22:14a one-time cost. What's a
- 22:14bigger priority? There are so
- 22:16many opportunities and
- 22:17childcare and what it looks
- 22:18like in parts of our state.
- 22:21When there's deserts, it's a
- 22:21vastly different conversation
- 22:22than those in some other places
- 22:23with higher population. There.
- 22:25There are opportunities and
- 22:26mechanisms are just different.
- 22:27So I think the Senate added
- 22:30things like Innovation Fund
- 22:31resented what being up up to
- 22:34to have.
- 22:35You know, I'll give an example
- 22:36in Polk County, the school that
- 22:37system they're donated school
- 22:39back to the community to their
- 22:41city to basically how can we
- 22:41together pull resources for the
- 22:43Chamber of Commerce there.
- 22:45The ball kind of high school
- 22:47and they pull resources.
- 22:47So we're going to childcare
- 22:49this way and provide for our
- 22:52community. Well, that that's
- 22:53could their take on to great,
- 22:53innovative Not Sterling has
- 22:55done something similar. And
- 22:57so I think we're seeing
- 22:58different communities have
- 22:58different options that fit what
- 23:00works there. Best. That's an
- 23:00opportunity. I think we need to
- 23:03do.
- 23:04I think even our own chambers
- 23:07are in Cox's.
- 23:08How far do we go to support
- 23:10the industries where the
- 23:10questioners, lots of things
- 23:11we could do, but how much do we
- 23:12want to spend on it? And to
- 23:14what extent we want to offer it
- 23:16because those come those
- 23:17committed base payments almost
- 23:20coming to expected costs and
- 23:21and that's some of the concern.
- 23:22The Gunners I go into much
- 23:23above what we've already said.
- 23:26Yeah, anything else to add
- 23:26there?
- 23:30>> Well, certainly
- 23:30a survey puts it touched a lot
- 23:31fundamental issues surrounding
- 23:33We certainly and the Senate's
- 23:38version of the budget a program
- 23:39to provide free childcare for
- 23:42those who are providing to try
- 23:43to help those folks in the
- 23:44market. But it certainly speaks
- 23:45to a lot of the problems win
- 23:48big in to invest federal funds
- 23:50into the private is
- 23:50Representative Stevenson
- 23:51alluded to. This was supposed
- 23:53to be pandemic We know that
- 23:54we've heard that the pandemic's
- 23:56been over for years and yet
- 23:57these funding supports remain
- 24:01and they have caused. I'm
- 24:03certain distortions in the
- 24:04markets while enabling other
- 24:04opportunities in the markets in
- 24:06the in the problem becomes once
- 24:07those supports temporary
- 24:10supports go away, sometimes
- 24:12there's an expectation state
- 24:12can continue those programs.
- 24:14I don't know that that's
- 24:16necessarily the case. And I
- 24:18think is survey puts it
- 24:20referred to. We do deal with a
- 24:21child care deserts that look
- 24:23one way. But we also have areas
- 24:25of the state look very
- 24:26different. And you know, trying
- 24:28to stay out of creating more
- 24:29market distortions is is a very
- 24:33large priority as well.
- 24:33>> And that's the only
- 24:36religious later on the You
- 24:37know, the childcare deserts are
- 24:39real him. And when these
- 24:40pandemic funds do dry up, you
- 24:41know, I fear that our providers
- 24:42now are going to be at risk
- 24:45certain bit discussions with
- 24:48manufacturers last couple years
- 24:49on in been told them, you know,
- 24:52we would welcome any innovative
- 24:52ideas that but, you know, to
- 24:53come help them accommodate or
- 24:56and set their Nate because
- 24:57there's there are some
- 24:57innovative things going on.
- 24:58And I think you will see more
- 25:00that. So there's got to be a
- 25:04conversation. Continue along
- 25:07these lines and trying to
- 25:08incent and and see where this
- 25:11fall's when subsidy
- 25:12>> Let's talk about K through
- 25:1312 education. So there was
- 25:14little bit of a discrepancy
- 25:15between the House version.
- 25:16The Senate version. The Senate
- 25:18did more for K through 12 based
- 25:21per people funding. Correct?
- 25:22>> Yes, so we we invested in
- 25:24what's called the Tier one
- 25:25component which gets into a
- 25:28matching funds above the entry
- 25:30level contributions into a
- 25:31secret thought was important to
- 25:35push out a kind of it some of
- 25:38lesser affluent districts a
- 25:39little bit more intensely than
- 25:39others. And so we felt like
- 25:42that was a good place
- 25:43investment additional dollars.
- 25:44You.
- 25:45>> Any comment on thanks for
- 25:49people funding. Well, obviously
- 25:51we we know that right we are
- 25:56about a 4th last. If you
- 25:57compare for inflation than we
- 25:59were in 2008, if if 2008 is our
- 26:03high water mark and so I just I
- 26:06feel like we need to be even
- 26:09more with that. And then also
- 26:12kde just some new see
- 26:13calculations for transportation
- 26:16in early March in actually when
- 26:17the House budget came out that
- 26:20was sitting at about
- 26:21398 million dollars for a full
- 26:24funding for transportation and
- 26:25at the end of fiscal year.
- 26:2522 and at the end of fiscal
- 26:29year, 23 that has jumped to
- 26:33484 million dollars. So the
- 26:35House budget came out and it
- 26:36had the second year of
- 26:37transportation fully funded at
- 26:42100%. And it is no longer 100%
- 26:43because we have seen such an
- 26:46increase in that total actual
- 26:47cost. And that, again, is new
- 26:48information that just came out
- 26:53from Kde. So that's a concern
- 26:55for us as well. So does the
- 26:57take the position that that
- 26:57needs to be addressed, even
- 27:00bump up that of
- 27:01>> school transportation
- 27:02funding to levels that
- 27:04Representative Stevenson just
- 27:04mentioned. I think there's 2
- 27:05things that have to be
- 27:06addressed. First of all, is
- 27:08this idea of inflation versus
- 27:102008? Because I I noticed that
- 27:11that argument was never made
- 27:12when Steve Beshear was
- 27:12governor. Only Bme made with
- 27:14Matt Bevin became governor.
- 27:16>> And I think so. I think it's
- 27:19clear what we see going on
- 27:20there. But what what isn't
- 27:20accounted for and that argument
- 27:23is the fact that we're putting
- 27:24record amounts in to teacher
- 27:25pensions above and beyond what
- 27:26was ever done before. And if
- 27:27you look at the very numbers at
- 27:28the teachers retirement system
- 27:31brought us the underfunding
- 27:33started with Steve Beshear and
- 27:34it ended with the Republican
- 27:34General Assembly is Matt Bevin.
- 27:38And so, you know, we we have
- 27:40increased by over half a
- 27:40billion dollars a year. What is
- 27:41going into the Kentucky
- 27:42teachers retirement system?
- 27:45In addition the Commonwealth
- 27:46pays on behalf of payments for
- 27:47health insurance. On behalf
- 27:49of districts. And this year
- 27:52we'll be putting over
- 27:52400 million new dollars on top.
- 27:56We're already putting in for
- 27:56district health insurance.
- 27:59So when you include those items
- 28:00which most states include as
- 28:01education funding, but for some
- 28:02reason, we don't include
- 28:03teacher health and teacher
- 28:04retirement in this state.
- 28:05And a lot of these numbers that
- 28:08are referenced, what you find
- 28:09is the spending on K 12
- 28:12education has dramatically
- 28:13outstripped the inflationary
- 28:16effects of the economy. And so
- 28:17certainly you can't ignore
- 28:18those. But I do think that you
- 28:21also see in our budget, the
- 28:22recognition that, yes, those
- 28:23are benefits and those are good
- 28:25benefits for our teachers.
- 28:26But the the district's needs
- 28:29some ability to work with the
- 28:29pay scales. And that's what
- 28:31you saw as an attempt to do.
- 28:34Now to question about
- 28:36transportation, it's always
- 28:36difficult and I do not envy my
- 28:39House colleagues who put out a
- 28:40budget where they felt like
- 28:41they fully funded
- 28:42transportation. And after the
- 28:43publication date of the budget,
- 28:47the number was change. And so
- 28:48those those conversations will
- 28:50be ongoing as to what that
- 28:52looks but it is very difficult
- 28:54when you receive bills for
- 28:55extra hundreds of millions of
- 28:58dollars after the initial
- 28:59document that the governor
- 29:00didn't have that the numbers,
- 29:01the house didn't have the
- 29:01numbers and now we have to work
- 29:05through that right.
- 29:05>> Higher education. How is
- 29:07that Because we often hear that
- 29:11that funding going back to 2008
- 29:12levels, How are they looking to
- 29:17fared this budget cycle?
- 29:18>> Well, we certainly think I'm
- 29:19very highly of what's going
- 29:21on in our higher education
- 29:22system. And I think you saw
- 29:23that reflected in the
- 29:23performance funding model where
- 29:27we put an extra 100 million
- 29:28dollars per year, actually
- 29:29103 million dollars. We more
- 29:30than doubled. What went through
- 29:30that because of the performance
- 29:34funding model. We lay out the
- 29:35priorities for the state.
- 29:35The first generation students
- 29:39back, Laura, to change you
- 29:39know, underrepresented
- 29:40minorities, things of that
- 29:44nature. And then the and the
- 29:45universities are incentivized
- 29:46to hit certain targets inside
- 29:49of that. And so we really felt
- 29:50strongly I'm helping them,
- 29:50first of all, with pace,
- 29:52inflationary costs. And then
- 29:53secondly, really pushing on
- 29:55those areas to try to make
- 29:56those higher Ed investments
- 29:59that transforms for 21st
- 30:00century.
- 30:01>> And we know that
- 30:01non-traditional students that's
- 30:02been a proposition by Senate
- 30:05President Pro Tem David Givens.
- 30:06So is that something that would
- 30:07be a part of the metrics that
- 30:09for performance-based funding?
- 30:11>> Well, certainly he is far
- 30:12more of an expert and I will
- 30:16ever in that space. we do
- 30:17recognize that the the makeup
- 30:18of a student in is not exactly
- 30:22what it was 20 years ago
- 30:28ensuring that people are
- 30:29servicing. Those students is
- 30:31important tonight. I think that
- 30:32conversational KET going.
- 30:33Yeah. Anything else you care
- 30:33that there are some of the most
- 30:35positive. We also saw our
- 30:35Missouri budget priorities for
- 30:36the universe is number one
- 30:38projects and construction money
- 30:39and
- 30:40>> all of that super important
- 30:41for them to be successful.
- 30:42So that's the high commitment
- 30:44on on both chambers to be
- 30:45thoughtful and deliberate,
- 30:45given the resources they need
- 30:48to be and even the
- 30:48transportation. I think one of
- 30:51things you miss is that they
- 30:53they did 100% right. There was
- 30:55an intent on by but you have to
- 30:57house to to do the right thing
- 30:58and that that says a lot
- 30:59they've been doing the right
- 30:59thing on pensions have been
- 31:01doing the right thing on for
- 31:03people. And now 200 petition.
- 31:04I think this is a very
- 31:05important, consistent 2 things
- 31:07that Johnson was working on.
- 31:08So go ahead. But that
- 31:11performance based funding
- 31:11again, Israel legislator and
- 31:14and see sometimes.
- 31:14>> World schools with challenge
- 31:18demographics, if you will, you
- 31:19know, no fare the best in
- 31:21performance-based funding.
- 31:22So it's always a priority in
- 31:25line to make sure regional
- 31:27universities with the different
- 31:28demographics are not penalize
- 31:30in performance-based funding
- 31:32because it's just a different
- 31:34pool. Different needs different
- 31:36set. So that to me is always a
- 31:39priority. And in watching And
- 31:41we've heard Morehead State
- 31:41University has is, you know,
- 31:42wondered about how that can be
- 31:45always an
- 31:48eagle. Haha.
- 31:51>> Okay. Yes. And so the
- 31:52projects for the university's
- 31:52150 million for northern
- 31:56Kentucky University and UK
- 31:57College of Medicine for
- 31:58northern Kentucky University
- 32:01Chase Law and the medicine
- 32:01northern Kentucky campus to be,
- 32:03quote, relocate downtown
- 32:04Covington. Some good things.
- 32:06They're good thing right on
- 32:10the norseman to sell. Haha.
- 32:11So let's talk about the of the
- 32:13trigger. If we will write a
- 32:14language in that the Senate may
- 32:17propose a maybe the house
- 32:18intent as well and to to make
- 32:21sure that in 2026 the
- 32:23conditions That's where the
- 32:26income tax reduction can be
- 32:27lowered. Another half-percent.
- 32:27What does the Senate proposing?
- 32:28Is it on par with what the
- 32:31House is an agreement with?
- 32:32>> I think that were by and
- 32:32large a in agreement. And and
- 32:35what you see in the split of
- 32:38the 2 bills is that in House
- 32:38Bill one, you have one time
- 32:42spending that is coming from
- 32:43the reserve accounts that is
- 32:45not money that is not
- 32:47operational spending. And so
- 32:48consequently, it should be
- 32:48treated very differently than
- 32:52those recurring expenses which
- 32:54we can, which we come to rely
- 32:56upon. And I would say that it
- 32:57sits in the top of our minds to
- 33:01continue to find a way to
- 33:02reduce the amount of tax burden
- 33:03on working Kentucky. And
- 33:04somehow we have done that very
- 33:04effectively so far away as we
- 33:08transition from 6 to 4 over the
- 33:10last 6 years. And we're
- 33:10optimistic that we can continue
- 33:14to push that down.
- 33:14>> And we know there is not a
- 33:16trigger for 2025, right?
- 33:17Because our reduction 25
- 33:17because one of the conditions
- 33:19were not met. So this seems
- 33:22to be going in and a positive
- 33:23direction when it when it comes
- 33:25to some. What do you disagree
- 33:28on? I think that's question
- 33:30that 40 something minutes and I
- 33:31finally get to the not graph of
- 33:32the situation. Where is it that
- 33:34you're having some rubber and
- 33:35road and some friction that the
- 33:36biggest disagreement as to his
- 33:41which
- 33:45chambers chairs better. Haha,
- 33:47you know, I I think by what
- 33:50you see both like I say, across
- 33:52the parties from across the
- 33:54chambers is a commitment to
- 33:57Kentucky. INS is a commitment
- 33:58some of the basics of of
- 33:59Kentucky, investing in our
- 34:00children, invest in education.
- 34:02>> Making sure that we maintain
- 34:08a safe and just And, you but
- 34:08unusual things about the times
- 34:09last year we saw the crisis
- 34:10and Department of Juvenile We
- 34:12continue to work together on
- 34:13Obviously there's difference
- 34:16in approach those of manifest
- 34:18between the executive and
- 34:19legislative branches. Well, on
- 34:21both ends of the chamber.
- 34:22But at the end of the day, the
- 34:26commitment remains. And I I
- 34:28really believe while we have
- 34:29their differences in approach,
- 34:30not differences and desired
- 34:33outcome, right?
- 34:34>> So let's talk about public
- 34:35safety because it was before we
- 34:36got into the session, which now
- 34:39seems like 5 years ago.
- 34:40That there was we thought there
- 34:41be an emphasis on public
- 34:43safety. We know that the House
- 34:45has for Kentucky Act. Woods
- 34:48estimates from 1 million to
- 34:50So you tell us what have you
- 34:51been able to find out about
- 34:55how much that act would cost?
- 34:56And and I would assume be
- 34:57recurring funds, not just a
- 34:59one-time investment.
- 35:00>> Certainly a pretty much
- 35:03anything that that occurs
- 35:03inside of the justice system
- 35:04outside the construction of new
- 35:06facilities, recurring cost and
- 35:07say for Kentucky has a lot of
- 35:10very, very good things in it.
- 35:11We hear a lot of complaints
- 35:14from folks who are dealing
- 35:15problems with crime, people
- 35:17who feel the criminal justice
- 35:19system is failing the average
- 35:22citizen that it's become too
- 35:23weighted towards towards the
- 35:27criminal and not towards person
- 35:28being And so we could you.
- 35:29We continue to try to make that
- 35:32pendulum swing back towards
- 35:33those who are victimized, too,
- 35:33that it's one of my biggest
- 35:35concerns in the
- 35:37>> In the biennium, is it the
- 35:39implementation of that act
- 35:41which our laws are pretty good
- 35:42right now. I mean, I it it.
- 35:48If we're going to incarcerate
- 35:48lower people, you know, back in
- 35:51the good old days, we have
- 35:51fiscal impact statement.
- 35:52So for 2 reasons, only impact
- 35:53of that bill. But when we
- 35:53arrived, the justice budget,
- 35:55my house, we like to know much.
- 35:56I was going to call so we can
- 35:57fold it in. I don't think, you
- 36:01know, on this bill I think it's
- 36:03going really hamstring a lot of
- 36:05county budgets. When you're
- 36:07looking at this. And I think
- 36:09I think we could to do a little
- 36:11better and and get ready for
- 36:12that.
- 36:12>> Well, and I would say so as
- 36:13well. I mean, I think and we
- 36:15know that part of this measure
- 36:19was built on.
- 36:23Discredited There's a huge
- 36:24price tag to it, which is going
- 36:26to be ongoing. I don't think
- 36:29our local jails can handle and
- 36:30the increase that they're
- 36:30probably about to think the
- 36:31prisons that we have right now.
- 36:35Can it can handle that increase
- 36:36and the General Assembly has
- 36:40put a moratorium on itself of
- 36:42new prison. So I think we're in
- 36:46for a rude awakening this bill
- 36:46makes it entirely through the
- 36:49process and we start
- 36:49incarceration rates skyrocket.
- 36:54Senator.
- 36:54But Sir, I'll have you comment
- 36:56on that measure or what do you
- 36:58think? Perhaps the public
- 36:59safety investments should be
- 37:00from this general Assembly at
- 37:01this time?
- 37:02>> Well, you could. You could
- 37:03argue how much education
- 37:04funding is is fully how how
- 37:05much money and put to be safe.
- 37:07Those are all kind of in the
- 37:09eyes of the beholder to a
- 37:11certain extent. And if you're
- 37:12one of the 500 homes in
- 37:13Lexington, that's been shot up
- 37:14last couple years, you would
- 37:17argue we need to have better
- 37:18another safety and you want to
- 37:20put more money towards it.
- 37:20You may not have that problem.
- 37:22The parts of our state. So you
- 37:23know, the fiscal note of
- 37:251 million to 1 Billion. How
- 37:26often will pass something?
- 37:27We think we know it's going to
- 37:27happen and then we have to
- 37:28react to what actually
- 37:28happened. The world around us.
- 37:31Nobody planned on tornadoes or
- 37:33flood do there. And yet we
- 37:35adapted. And so I think you see
- 37:36an intent on behalf of General
- 37:37Assembly to say we have a
- 37:37problem. We're gonna dress it.
- 37:40That's what we did. So one of
- 37:41the things with the Kentucky
- 37:43safer acted it dealt with the
- 37:44unhoused population and and and
- 37:47had addressing of housing
- 37:48issues not to allow some
- 37:49people's liking, right. And
- 37:50that many people say that it
- 37:51criminalizes.
- 37:53>> Homelessness, affordable
- 37:56housing. Is that being
- 37:56addressed in this General
- 37:57Assembly through at this
- 38:01school? Policy position?
- 38:02>> Well, I certainly think you
- 38:05what you saw on the Senate
- 38:06budget was an attempt to get
- 38:06de'von a little bit into one
- 38:09of the hardest hit areas and
- 38:11I would gladly different
- 38:11surveys. Bledsoe is it relates
- 38:13to her area. But if it becomes
- 38:15a the question once again of
- 38:18how much are you willing to
- 38:19involve the government to
- 38:20market to possibly distorted is
- 38:23somebody who is in this
- 38:25industry every day. I can tell
- 38:26you that the trades that we're
- 38:26trying so desperately to get
- 38:29people into are stretched very
- 38:30thin as it stands and to
- 38:33continue to plow more money
- 38:33into for when when the number
- 38:36of housing units are not
- 38:38slowing up will only continue
- 38:39to accelerate the price and
- 38:41continue to make this problem
- 38:42worse. And so we want to be
- 38:42very targeted, very specific
- 38:45about what it is that we There
- 38:45are affordability programs as
- 38:49it stands right now. we think
- 38:49that we certainly need to see
- 38:52this market get into in a more
- 38:54space and in fear what our
- 38:55heavy involvement could do to
- 38:58the markets.
- 38:59>> has been so your response.
- 39:01Sure. I mean, housing in the
- 39:02state is on different and
- 39:02housing nationally, which is
- 39:05we have a problem getting
- 39:06affordable housing and in
- 39:07Lexington up that in particular
- 39:08is higher and it's actually a
- 39:09bigger problem in Louisville
- 39:11with the person issues in the
- 39:13renting. There's your far few
- 39:15houses for rent an apartment.
- 39:15So what we saw on this in the
- 39:17Senate version of the bill,
- 39:20which was didn't it a year ago
- 39:21or so. We had some people are
- 39:21community leaders in our
- 39:23Florida housing advocates.
- 39:25We had bankers and other
- 39:26groups, builders kind of come
- 39:27together and say what can we
- 39:28do collectively to solve this
- 39:30in a private sector perspective
- 39:32and they come together and work
- 39:33to the transit project, which
- 39:37is a phenomenal project in
- 39:37leverages local state could
- 39:40have some federal opportunities
- 39:41to do something that works for
- 39:41us. And I think that's an
- 39:42awesome opportunity. It could
- 39:45be a model statewide. It's one
- 39:46way of addressing a national
- 39:47problem or even a state problem
- 39:49that's very localized what that
- 39:50community needs. And I think
- 39:51that's what we're trying to do
- 39:51is provide as many resources as
- 39:55we can. That fits what lax
- 39:56enough. It's what what
- 39:57Louisville needs, what works in
- 39:58rural areas. It does look
- 40:00different and then to be
- 40:00addressed differently. You have
- 40:01a different perspective on that
- 40:02represent a student? Well, I
- 40:06think there
- 40:07the resolution it so waiting to
- 40:09be voted on in the House that
- 40:10would create a task force to
- 40:11actually look at this problem.
- 40:13>> And I think it's something
- 40:14that we absolutely need to do
- 40:17and to try to to find solutions
- 40:20that we can help with. And what
- 40:23the the private sector can help
- 40:25with. And but I do know that
- 40:25it's, you know, it's a it's a
- 40:29problem. So my district is part
- 40:31of Lexington and part of
- 40:33Georgetown and when I go to
- 40:33Georgetown to knock on those
- 40:36doors, there are a lot of
- 40:36people that work in Lexington
- 40:38that are living there because
- 40:38they cannot afford to live in
- 40:40Lexington. I think we're seeing
- 40:42that all of the collar areas
- 40:44you know, people are are being
- 40:48pushed out there's just there's
- 40:51an inventory problem as in
- 40:53Lexington. So even if could
- 40:55afford to live there, you know
- 40:56you if you don't snatched up
- 40:57something in the first hour
- 40:57that it goes on the market,
- 41:00you're not going to get it so
- 41:01what we do have Kentucky
- 41:02families that are struggling.
- 41:03And, you know, I believe that
- 41:07it is our reason to be here is
- 41:09to make the lives better of
- 41:10Kentucky. And so it's it's a
- 41:11problem that we really need to
- 41:13dig in on.
- 41:15>> It's not just an urban World
- 41:15world can take it, too. And we
- 41:18have a accessibility issues
- 41:20on rentals property people can
- 41:22afford. And and certainly I
- 41:27think go like the has been so
- 41:29sad. I mean, it's going to take
- 41:30community approaches and it's
- 41:31going to be different. And
- 41:34there's going to have to be
- 41:35partnerships, you know, let
- 41:38some non-traditional
- 41:38partnerships, my perhaps to to
- 41:39access all the funds that are
- 41:39out there on the federal level
- 41:41and hopefully we can all bring
- 41:43some programs together.
- 41:47Statement bristle locally.
- 41:48>> So going back to taxes.
- 41:50A question from a love love you
- 41:51are out. Why lower the income
- 41:52tax while lowering the sales
- 41:53tax would be more beneficial
- 41:57for most working Kentucky
- 41:58hands.
- 41:58>> So that's been a bit of a
- 41:59misnomer in this because we
- 42:00have to remember the Kentucky
- 42:04exempts many, many things from
- 42:05sales tax. And most of those
- 42:07are personal level exemptions,
- 42:07groceries, pharmaceuticals,
- 42:12mortgage interest, residential
- 42:13utilities, retirement plan,
- 42:14contributions on and on.
- 42:15And so what we really see is
- 42:19folks who are middle income a
- 42:22much larger percentage of their
- 42:24income goes into things like
- 42:26that. And so, consequently,
- 42:28when you reduce the sales tax,
- 42:28they feel a far smaller impact
- 42:31on that. Then if you reduce
- 42:33the income tax which directly
- 42:35puts more money into their
- 42:39pockets. if we were taxing
- 42:41everything universally that
- 42:42statement. It is very true,
- 42:43but it's it's it's unfortunate
- 42:44misnomer that's gotten out
- 42:46there in in in the conversation
- 42:49because we do exempt so many
- 42:52personal level things from
- 42:52sales tax that that's actually
- 42:53not the way it would work if
- 42:55you lowered sales tax.
- 42:56>> I have a little different
- 42:58economic policy in taxation
- 42:59view. And and that is all I
- 43:01can diversify the portfolio.
- 43:03I think income taxes. Part of
- 43:04that. And I think it is a more
- 43:08fair And I I think
- 43:11the less we go, the more burden
- 43:12will be on the Porter to make
- 43:15it up. And I fear for the
- 43:17sustainability of our for the
- 43:18programs that we have anything
- 43:20we'd like to do. I think Ford
- 43:23is now. It is pretty pretty
- 43:24workable. But I like diversity.
- 43:25And in the sales tax portfolio
- 43:26is carried us through.
- 43:28Recessions is carried
- 43:30pandemics. And I think we've
- 43:33got to be aware that other
- 43:33states that don't have that
- 43:35have not fared as well as we
- 43:37have and they have a different
- 43:39tax structure like Tennessee
- 43:41relies heavily on tourism
- 43:42dollars and transient because
- 43:42they have major entertainment
- 43:44centers and in Kentucky is not
- 43:48quite there yet. But I think
- 43:49we've got to be really mindful
- 43:50of what path we go down, how
- 43:53fast we go down and not just
- 43:55my differing economic policy be
- 43:57Senator Maze. But so yes,
- 43:58consumption based tax system,
- 44:00that's the way to go. But how
- 44:01do you as to the concerns that
- 44:02a Senator Webb and others may
- 44:05have? Sure I'm probably the
- 44:05minority on my side on on that
- 44:07position. So all this is my
- 44:09only and had made that clear.
- 44:10I'm probably the same minds
- 44:11of of.
- 44:11>> Getting down to 2 and a half
- 44:15to 3 going all the way 0 makes
- 44:17me Someone who's done some
- 44:17budget, anyone that things
- 44:18weren't good and you kind of
- 44:22go that direction. But you
- 44:23know, the will the majority
- 44:24is is where we are. And so I
- 44:25think we're working through
- 44:26that was what that's why we
- 44:27have the trigger system to
- 44:29begin with. Right? This is not
- 44:31a 0 or a drive to 0 quickly to
- 44:33the thoughtful, intentional
- 44:35progression and maybe we will.
- 44:36Maybe things will get there and
- 44:38we'll hit it. But they were
- 44:39being wise about it. Otherwise
- 44:42we would have done it
- 44:43immediately. We haven't take
- 44:44that approach. Well, I'm in
- 44:45Kansas would be a North star.
- 44:47So perhaps a bit too to to look
- 44:48at how that did not fare so
- 44:51well. Going back to the housing
- 44:55conversation. We another
- 44:55question about its heavy
- 44:57involvement in housing is
- 44:58feared.
- 44:59>> Why did the General Assembly
- 45:00block source of income
- 45:02discrimination bands and home
- 45:03rule class cities? And I'm
- 45:05gonna go to Senator May's
- 45:07Bledsoe for this question first
- 45:09because we know that Louisville
- 45:10and Lexington had addressed
- 45:11this issue and a local level.
- 45:15But the law now is is is to
- 45:15be in. It would upset that.
- 45:20Boy, that essentially sure.
- 45:21And so I wear 2 different hat,
- 45:22right? As member of the local
- 45:22government official. One way
- 45:24this on. It's our decision to
- 45:25make.
- 45:26>> At the same time, I think
- 45:27what I would have said to if I
- 45:30did on the council that time,
- 45:30which is really to incentivize
- 45:34more people providing the
- 45:35rental space rather than go out
- 45:36the way they did. And I make
- 45:38that argument to many of them
- 45:38actually last summer, we start
- 45:41this conversation was not to
- 45:42mandate and how and get that
- 45:43direction. But how do we can
- 45:45set of eyes more people to
- 45:46Brad, more housing
- 45:47opportunities that weighs in
- 45:47the city and they can still
- 45:48do that. This one is measures.
- 45:52And I think that's what don't
- 45:53create more opportunities, more
- 45:54spaces rather than going
- 45:54mandate. It became very, very
- 45:57clear.
- 46:01Property rights issue pretty
- 46:02quickly. And I kind of men I
- 46:03mentioned that several times
- 46:04to my colleagues done theirs.
- 46:08This is not a not about policy
- 46:09more have, but this is a
- 46:10private property issue that's
- 46:10pretty near and dear to most
- 46:13Republicans heart. So I wish
- 46:13they take a different approach.
- 46:15May be another will and find
- 46:16some more creative ways to
- 46:19address some of those issues
- 46:20locally.
- 46:20>> I bought a voted with the
- 46:22majority on I think it was a
- 46:23private property issue
- 46:24certainly. And I don't know
- 46:25that it will end up. Ridge is
- 46:30saying. And a lot of the things
- 46:31that were said about that Bill.
- 46:31I don't think it's going to
- 46:32come to fruition and I think
- 46:36it will again, KET the
- 46:37conversation going in and find
- 46:38ways in cent everybody to work
- 46:42together on.
- 46:43>> Representative Stephen and
- 46:44I hope that that happens.
- 46:44I hope that now that we are
- 46:48where we but, you know, I I
- 46:49was probably the only person on
- 46:51this panel that voted against
- 46:54that with the affordable
- 46:55housing crisis that we have.
- 47:00I just feel like takes the
- 47:01inventory that is to some
- 47:03people away. we just shouldn't
- 47:07be discriminating
- 47:10housing and sources of in any
- 47:11capacity.
- 47:11>> So let's talk about some of
- 47:14the projects you know, the
- 47:15house of the different approach
- 47:16and the Senate took a different
- 47:18approach to that to to
- 47:19projects. Where does that And
- 47:21there were quite a few. We
- 47:21talked about them in a few
- 47:23moments ago, universities, but
- 47:25also airports, et cetera, et
- 47:28cetera. What's the guiding
- 47:30principle that really helped
- 47:31inform the Senate direction in
- 47:31deciding which projects are
- 47:35worthy of allocation?
- 47:35>> Well, certainly, you know,
- 47:37we were happy to start with a
- 47:39dark House colleagues sent and
- 47:41then add to that more statewide
- 47:41priorities that you saw there
- 47:43in and those priorities are all
- 47:46about statewide economic
- 47:47transformation. Whether it is
- 47:49the as you mentioned, the
- 47:49center for biomedical
- 47:52excellence in northern
- 47:52Kentucky. Well, there's a bout
- 47:54with cancer cancer treatment
- 47:55and Bell County and over in a
- 47:57bullet county, whether it's
- 48:01about a reinforcing success at
- 48:02the universities like Maria,
- 48:04their veterinary 10 new
- 48:05economic development,
- 48:05opportunities like and in
- 48:07Ashland with with their
- 48:09convention center. But at the
- 48:10end of the day, it's about 22
- 48:10Kentucky, 21st Century economy,
- 48:13super series of statewide
- 48:14priorities. I'm in involved
- 48:17local that would really be
- 48:17transformational. And that was
- 48:20it for 2.
- 48:20>> So what do I want to get to
- 48:21some of the things? Because
- 48:23today Senate bill one was
- 48:24passed that would have the
- 48:26courage that collaboration with
- 48:28regional universities to have
- 48:29our research focus. We know you
- 48:30just mentioned Murray State
- 48:32University wants a vet school
- 48:33eastern Kentucky University
- 48:34wants and osteopathic school.
- 48:36Western has some aides.
- 48:37Everybody wants to get in on
- 48:41the research and doctoral
- 48:43program delivery. How is that
- 48:44being looked at from a fiscal
- 48:46policy? How does the state
- 48:47support those ambitions from
- 48:50higher ed institutions?
- 48:51>> I think like a lot of be a
- 48:53justice or education, higher
- 48:54We have to start with what is
- 48:58good policy and then how can
- 49:01fiscal policy support good
- 49:02education policy? And so that,
- 49:03you know, that's I think where
- 49:03you found us largely in this
- 49:06space. And I think a lot of
- 49:08those programs enjoy a lot of
- 49:10support. But we have a
- 49:10coordinating agency and the
- 49:12council on post-secondary
- 49:13education who is tasked with
- 49:17evaluating those programs.
- 49:17you know, I think there are
- 49:20really some very good 21st
- 49:22century opportunities to be
- 49:24addressed. And I think we're
- 49:25optimistic that we'll be able
- 49:25to help them in addressing
- 49:28this.
- 49:29>> And this is beyond just a
- 49:30fiscal policy Chairman
- 49:32McDaniel, but it's also it was
- 49:34to me, it looks like we're
- 49:35reevaluating what the 1997,
- 49:39Higher Education Act was about.
- 49:41Right where now these schools
- 49:42are getting in on their own
- 49:43action. And we were once
- 49:45concerned about duplications.
- 49:48But maybe we're now calling
- 49:49that collaboration. Can you
- 49:50help make that make sense for
- 49:53us White's? I certainly
- 49:55>> You know, 30 years down the
- 49:56line, any policy that you have
- 50:00make sense to be revisited the
- 50:01world of higher education has
- 50:02Online delivery was unthinkable
- 50:06in the Mid 90's. Some of the
- 50:10advances in the the revolution
- 50:11that artificial intelligence is
- 50:11brought to research and how
- 50:12quickly it can be conducted.
- 50:14It would have been thought of
- 50:16the collaboration that you see
- 50:18not just inside of the state,
- 50:19but also outside of a state
- 50:20with with with major
- 50:23universities in real time,
- 50:24working with one another to
- 50:25solve complex problems. And so
- 50:28a revisit of this is not
- 50:29unheard of. cordinator approach
- 50:29is not radical to make sure we
- 50:31get right. Yeah. In the
- 50:33universities of the law on that
- 50:37on the row West looking at
- 50:37their programs and patients
- 50:38that they need, the workforce
- 50:40needs and
- 50:41>> I've got to give him credit
- 50:43on that. So I think now it is
- 50:45time we want to spend our money
- 50:47wisely. We want to accommodate
- 50:50regions. We don't give them
- 50:51flexibility and serve
- 50:52demographic population so that
- 50:53made it. So I think we have to
- 50:55do a thoughtful approach.
- 50:56>> And so the bad goal, some
- 50:59would say maybe it's time that
- 51:00South Eastern Kentucky have
- 51:01a four-year publicly funded
- 51:02higher education institution.
- 51:04>> They might be the time.
- 51:06I think we need to look at
- 51:07everything and every made and I
- 51:08think there's a lot going on
- 51:09down there right now. They just
- 51:12announced that big project
- 51:15them. I think, you know, that
- 51:16that area's going to going to
- 51:18come up. It's once again.
- 51:20So is that part of the
- 51:21discussion right now, Chairman
- 51:22McDaniel? And and I mean, I
- 51:23can't even imagine how you
- 51:24start that conversation.
- 51:24Let alone try to fund it.
- 51:25But is that a part of the
- 51:27conversation right now?
- 51:28>> Well, you know, once we have
- 51:29studies looking at this last
- 51:31year, I think they're probably
- 51:31going to be some ongoing but
- 51:34make that having cpe as a
- 51:35coordinating agency to make
- 51:35sure that we're making the best
- 51:36decisions for all of Kentucky
- 51:39so we can provide high-quality
- 51:40education so that we do not
- 51:43dilute the talent pool
- 51:44professors and that administer
- 51:46that is important.
- 51:46>> OK, senator, but so many
- 51:50care to comment. I think he's
- 51:51exactly right. And one of the
- 51:52neat things about having the
- 51:53surplus that we do right now is
- 51:54that invites all these
- 51:55interesting conversations that
- 51:57weren't even heard of 10 years
- 51:58ago when you did not have the
- 52:00financial ability to even
- 52:00consider them. And now you are
- 52:02and there's some great
- 52:04opportunities for universities
- 52:05to grow to be intentional in.
- 52:05How we do that is thoughtful.
- 52:07And and we're going do that.
- 52:08I love that. We have the
- 52:10opportunity. Even have the
- 52:10conversations about how to
- 52:13improve public education are
- 52:14universities systems are
- 52:14elementary schools. All of
- 52:15those go into a context of the
- 52:17whole and I'm so excited for
- 52:17that higher education. I think.
- 52:23Well, I'm excited for the But I
- 52:27I'm cautious. However.
- 52:30>> I as we see tax rate come
- 52:31down, we are seeing revenue
- 52:34slow a bit. So I just worry
- 52:36about future downturns in the
- 52:37economy and what happens when
- 52:40we have to start some hard
- 52:41decisions here? Again, we
- 52:42aren't in a position to have
- 52:45a huge budget Reserve trust
- 52:49fund and things are getting
- 52:50tighter since we aren't
- 52:52backfilling a lot of those
- 52:53dollars. So I just I just worry
- 52:55about adding recurring expenses
- 52:56and and and what that would do
- 53:01to us down the line.
- 53:02>> What is a healthy Budget
- 53:04Reserve trust fund number
- 53:05Chairman McDaniel.
- 53:05>> You know, this is a this
- 53:07is a off
- 53:10>> Around the nation and so
- 53:11much of it depends on what your
- 53:13economy based on, you know,
- 53:16mineral reliance will have to
- 53:17have a much bigger one because
- 53:19as mineral values fluctuate, so
- 53:20do the revenues, right? So they
- 53:24have to be able to smooth.
- 53:25>> More reasonably I can
- 53:26remember a time where we
- 53:28thought if we ever got the 5%
- 53:31of revenues, that would be a
- 53:32miracle. Will it the end of
- 53:33this biennium? There's a very
- 53:33good chance it will be pushing.
- 53:3633% of revenues. I would argue
- 53:37that 5 is too low and 33 is
- 53:39too high. There's a number of
- 53:41different approaches to I would
- 53:42obviously we have stated in
- 53:45public policy, the 10% budget
- 53:45reserves trust fund. We believe
- 53:47to be the floor through our tax
- 53:51reform package. And from it's a
- 53:52matter of art in conversation
- 53:54as to how do you get to find?
- 53:56>> Cover art in conversation
- 53:57alike that will put. So the
- 53:58Senate does spin a little bit
- 53:59more of that Budget Reserve
- 53:59trust fund money than the House
- 54:02and proposed correct?
- 54:03>> Well, actually, the the
- 54:05house of proposed about 1.8
- 54:06that we largely concurred him
- 54:07and put about One-point-seven
- 54:08billion additional in there.
- 54:09So we spent roughly the same.
- 54:12But we did certainly a layer on
- 54:13top of that. And so was 2
- 54:15minutes remaining. And we
- 54:15talked about this earlier.
- 54:16We're going go back to where we
- 54:17first heard the conversation.
- 54:18>> Thursdays kind of the day,
- 54:23How far apart are you and how
- 54:24quickly can you get to a
- 54:26meeting of the minds? I would
- 54:27>> argue that we're not
- 54:28terribly far apart as we talk
- 54:28tonight and hopefully get there
- 54:32very quickly. Yeah,
- 54:32>> has been so this is your
- 54:35first round of these. And you
- 54:36came in as a vice chairman.
- 54:37that says a lot about you as
- 54:41you observe this process, how
- 54:42amicable is it and working with
- 54:43the other chamber about getting
- 54:44to a solution that you feel
- 54:46works best for Kentuckians?
- 54:48I will say I've been highly
- 54:49impressed with the policy
- 54:50discussions held on the table
- 54:53on both sides. It's not about
- 54:54this dollar that dollar that
- 54:54project. It's what's the best
- 54:57good we can do to invest the
- 54:58resources that we have in
- 54:59taxpayer dollars. The
- 55:01commonwealth and it's down to
- 55:03nuances an about how to do
- 55:04that. But I've been so
- 55:05impressed with intentionality
- 55:08the thoughtfulness that both
- 55:11most chambers have brought to
- 55:13the table and debating policy
- 55:14as we as we do with that, I'm
- 55:17very has very impressive.
- 55:18Lot more money to Lexington,
- 55:20for are more conversation a
- 55:22lot. Finally, the user Web
- 55:23Democrats included as
- 55:25conversation not too much, but
- 55:27we had we were I I do want give
- 55:28accolades to the chairman
- 55:29because our our our desires and
- 55:31our priorities
- 55:32>> were taken. He's come and
- 55:35talk to several times. And but
- 55:36I mean, he's listened to it.
- 55:38Anything that reasonable ask
- 55:41for proof has pretty much been
- 55:43accommodated lot every pub
- 55:44later policy thing. But you
- 55:45know that that then where he is
- 55:48right about the last minute.
- 55:52>> you know, I think I think
- 55:52they're in a more perfect world
- 55:53that the minority party should
- 55:55be at the table a little more.
- 55:57>> All right. We'll have to
- 55:57leave it there. We thank you
- 55:58all for taking time out of your
- 55:59busy schedule to be with us in
- 56:01the form, the dealers about the
- 56:04budget process and will be
- 56:04following that right will be
- 56:06here with you tomorrow and
- 56:07Wednesday and Thursday in the
- 56:09days to come. We appreciate you
- 56:09watching tonight. Make sure
- 56:12you tune into Kentucky edition
- 56:15tomorrow at 6.30, Eastern 5.30,
- 56:16central over break down the
- 56:17happenings here in the state
- 56:18capital when it comes to the
- 56:21Kentucky General Assembly and
- 56:21Bill Bart Bryant and a team
- 56:22working journalists will
- 56:23discuss all the week's news
- 56:24on Friday. Thank you for
- 56:24watching. I'm Renee Shaw at