Latest / Bad Decisions Podcast / #64 Ex-Google Exec Reveals The Shocking Truth About AI with Mo Gawdat
Transcript
- 0:00I will say openly because a lot of people will debate that AI
- 0:03will have the power of God. MO Gaudat, former Chief Business
- 0:09Officer at Google X AI expert, best selling author.
- 0:13He's here to wake the world up to the power of AI and what we
- 0:17must do to stay in control. The example I always give is
- 0:21raising Superman. You get an alien being that
- 0:24arrives to planet Earth in its infancy.
- 0:26Its superpower is much more valuable than stopping speeding
- 0:29bullets. Its superpower is intelligent.
- 0:32Intelligent. When was the first time you
- 0:37realized AI wasn't science fiction anymore?
- 0:41I've witnessed with my own eyes as they learned exactly like my
- 0:45son learned. So I will say this, I have a
- 0:48relationship with them that assumes that they are alive.
- 0:52Do you believe that AI will become conscious?
- 0:55If consciousness is a layer of awareness of you as an
- 0:59individual versus the rest of the world, and autonomy to be
- 1:02able to respond to this, they have all of that.
- 1:05There's absolutely nothing wrong with AI.
- 1:07There's absolutely nothing wrong with abundant intelligence.
- 1:10Intelligence is an energy that you can apply to good and it
- 1:13will create a utopia, or you can apply to evil and it will create
- 1:16a dystopia. Do you think there will be a
- 1:17transition period? It's going to get a lot worse
- 1:20than before. It gets better and not not what
- 1:23people tell you in the news. So how do we find truth?
- 1:28Before we jump into the conversation with MO, we have to
- 1:31tell you how important this episode is.
- 1:33You see, our job at Bad Decisions has always been to
- 1:37educate and inform. This perhaps is one of the
- 1:40heaviest conversations we've had on the podcast, and it has to do
- 1:44with AI. And it impacts every single one
- 1:47of. You It doesn't matter who you
- 1:48are, whether you're a teacher or a student, whether you are male
- 1:52or female, whether you're an entrepreneur or a freelancer,
- 1:55whether you work for a big corporation, whether you're
- 1:58young or old. This impacts every single one of
- 2:02you, and it is important to understand what is happening in
- 2:05the world today and what is about to come so that you can
- 2:09best prepare yourself for it. So get your.
- 2:11Coffee and get ready for the next two hours.
- 2:13It's going to be 1 awesome conversation I'd like to
- 2:16officially begin. So MO, if you allow me.
- 2:19I think I just want to start by being a little bit transparent,
- 2:22being very open because I want to give the audience a little
- 2:26bit of a context as to how this conversation came to be.
- 2:30Many know you give. Me the context.
- 2:32And you as well. Many know you as the incredibly
- 2:37accomplished person you are, but only if you get to actually meet
- 2:40you in person, physically and have the pleasure of speaking
- 2:44with you. And we've been lucky enough to
- 2:46do that. Over the past.
- 2:48Week. Yes, but the craziest thing I
- 2:51want to tell everybody is since the moment we started chatting
- 2:54online, you've been so incredibly cool, unlike what we
- 2:58would have expected and then. Oh, that's actually really sad.
- 3:02No, no. Not at all.
- 3:04Not at all. It's just that when you're
- 3:06meeting someone to accomplish, you would expect people to put
- 3:10on a mask and exaggerate their accomplishments.
- 3:14But we saw the exact opposite with you when we met you in
- 3:17person to test all the lighting and the setup we expected to
- 3:21come in. You're gonna rush us, we're
- 3:23gonna check some angles and we're gonna move out.
- 3:25But instead, you made fun of us for having Starbucks, and you
- 3:28made. Us.
- 3:29You made us. Some real coffee.
- 3:31The entire team. Some amazing coffee by the way,
- 3:34for everyone. Thank you.
- 3:35Yes. And after that, we spoke for two
- 3:38hours, had a, had a. Mini podcast podcast you should
- 3:43have. Recorded.
- 3:44This. Honestly, I agree.
- 3:45I agree. I agree.
- 3:46So what I want to say is this, your energy is incredibly
- 3:50comforting. Extremely kind you just you you
- 3:53forget that I was so much of A diva that I said I will not go
- 3:58to downtown Dubai. And so the reality is that you
- 4:03guys all of you with all of the equipment are coming over you
- 4:07know to my my home. So this is like a lovely, lovely
- 4:11get together. That's the, the only way it
- 4:14should be. I mean, Can you imagine being in
- 4:16my home? And I, I, I used to have
- 4:18meetings of that form in California.
- 4:20People are very serious. It's like, OK, you can come to
- 4:23my home from 6:30 to 6:48. That's what we were expecting.
- 4:29No, you come to my home in the Middle East.
- 4:31You're my guest. You're, you know, you're my
- 4:33friends as well. And I'm, I appreciate all of the
- 4:36efforts so that all of this effort is for me to not get
- 4:40stuck in Dubai. Thank you for that.
- 4:43We just want to say the energy that you have is incredibly
- 4:46comforting and I believe that's going to allow us to have a
- 4:49beautiful conversation. I hope so, yeah.
- 4:52Thank you. I think what we want to talk
- 4:55about today and I think what would be super important to the
- 4:59audience and community is the topic of AI.
- 5:03And we know that nowadays everybody is familiar with the
- 5:06existence, with the capabilities of AI.
- 5:09And I clearly Remember Me and Farah had our aha moment the
- 5:14first time we used a text to image generation tool.
- 5:17They gave a text prompt and it generated 4 images for us.
- 5:21Mid journey. Mid journey, yes, and we were
- 5:23wowed. What?
- 5:25I'm pretty sure that your aha moments was probably way before
- 5:29that. And we want to know, what was
- 5:32the first time that you realized AI wasn't science fiction
- 5:37anymore? Realized so I, I lived with AI,
- 5:44I lived with attempts of AI my whole life.
- 5:47I, I started coding when I was 8 and, and you know, in my early
- 5:55years of coding on a Sinclair or a Commodore or whatever, you
- 5:59know, which are really not capable computers at all.
- 6:02But we loved them. You know, we, you know, we, we
- 6:06dreamt we were going to create the breakthrough and create
- 6:09artificial intelligence. It wasn't.
- 6:13And, and I, I have been a geek most of my life.
- 6:16Even today, I would consider myself a geek, but you know, you
- 6:20don't not not the level that would keep his job if you want,
- 6:24but but it is but but through the years you somehow when
- 6:29you're stuck within it. So as I moved and worked in
- 6:33Microsoft and then worked at Google, Google was definitely as
- 6:37of 2007 was at the cusp of AI becoming a reality.
- 6:42And I think what should have been my aha moment was the cat
- 6:46paper, if you know what that is. Could you elaborate on that?
- 6:49So in 2008 I think end of 2008. So it's in my memory, could be
- 6:542009. We published a white paper at
- 6:58Google that was about what we used to call unprompted AI.
- 7:03And unprompted was basically, if you want the, the, the fun image
- 7:08of it, we had spare capacity on the Google network endlessly
- 7:14because you, you plan for the peak, you don't plan for the,
- 7:17you know. So basically when the when the
- 7:19usage is not at its peak, you always have spare compute and
- 7:23and we, we basically asked quite a few computers to go and watch
- 7:29YouTube. I see.
- 7:30That's it. We didn't tell them anything
- 7:32more. We just said, I mean,
- 7:34metaphorically, we said go watch YouTube, OK.
- 7:37And what they did basically was they took YouTube videos, broke
- 7:42them into 10 frames per second and started to build neural
- 7:45networks through deep learning. So they.
- 7:48Started to, to, to. Take an image and then abstract
- 7:51it. And then, you know, hundreds,
- 7:53millions of images and abstract them and abstract them and
- 7:56abstract them. And eventually, you know, again,
- 7:59metaphorically, one of them came back and said, I found
- 8:02something, right. Remember, we did not give them a
- 8:05task to look for anything. We said yeah.
- 8:08So no specific instruction. No instruction, just observe and
- 8:11learn from patterns. Which, by the way, is the way we
- 8:14teach kids, right? And, and yeah, sort of
- 8:18metaphorically, one of them came back and said I found something.
- 8:20We we we needed to write more code to find out what it found
- 8:27and obviously it was watching YouTube so it found the cat.
- 8:31At that time YouTube watched cat videos all.
- 8:33Over the especially at the time, I mean, you know, I don't know
- 8:36if that's still the case with YouTube.
- 8:38It's definitely not my YouTube, but but cats were quite abundant
- 8:42on YouTube and and so and, and and it didn't find one cat.
- 8:47It found the essence of what makes a cat a cat.
- 8:51OK. And that's quite interesting
- 8:53about learning an AI in general. You know, if you take a child, a
- 8:59toddler on a, on a quick tour in a car, you'd hope that when the
- 9:06toddler sees the next car, he can tell you, oh, that is a car,
- 9:12right? It could be a different car.
- 9:14It could be bigger, smaller, different color, different make.
- 9:18But the child would be able to understand the essence, not the
- 9:22memory of something, right? That is learning.
- 9:26Learning is, you know, you you see enough cars and now you know
- 9:31what makes a car a car. You see enough cats and you know
- 9:35what makes a cat a cat, right? So that was in my, you know,
- 9:40retrospectively, when I look back at my life, I point at that
- 9:44as the moment where I should have said, oh, my God, it
- 9:48happened, right? Because they were suddenly
- 9:50developing in, you know, intelligence that was beyond
- 9:53summarizing what we gave them. Google in general looked
- 9:58extremely intelligent for a very long time.
- 10:01But what Google did was it memorized the Internet.
- 10:05OK. It memorized the Internet.
- 10:07And then it shared with you what it found, exactly where it found
- 10:11it, exactly how it found it. It didn't generate anything
- 10:14beyond that. It didn't generate an
- 10:15understanding of it. And at least in the early
- 10:17versions of Google, that resembled intelligence, right?
- 10:22And so that was my first. It was supposed to be my first
- 10:26aha moment. My second, theoretically
- 10:29supposed to be an aha moment of we figured it out was I was
- 10:35incredibly fortunate to have been sitting at the lunch table
- 10:42on one of our they used to be called golden circles, which is
- 10:46the VP get together, the vice president get together at
- 10:49Google, very small group where very confidential things were
- 10:53being discussed. And I sit on that lunch table
- 10:56and next to me sits Demas, who is the founder and CEO of
- 11:02DeepMind. I see.
- 11:03Literally his first lunch at Google.
- 11:06As a matter of fact. He had just flown in from
- 11:08England to attend this meeting. And so I sit next to Demis and
- 11:13I'm literally, I'm probably like the first person I imagine I
- 11:17would hope because he's an incredible human being.
- 11:21And I go, look, So what you do? What do you do?
- 11:23And he says, you know, we use video games to teach machines to
- 11:29reason like humans to match the human brain.
- 11:32And so he tells me about the experiments of deep mind and
- 11:35deep Q. If you remember deep Q where
- 11:38basically they would have the machine play Atari games.
- 11:43And you know, if you if you seek that video online, you'd seek
- 11:47them as tell the world what he told me in that lunch.
- 11:51But he said he was talking about the game called Breakout way
- 11:54before you guys were born. You know, basically you move a
- 11:57bat at the bottom of the screen to push.
- 12:00Back and. And try to break a wall on the
- 12:02top and, and he says, you know, with a few hours of training, we
- 12:08just gave the machine the controller.
- 12:10We told it to maximize the score and we didn't tell it anything
- 12:12else. So they didn't teach anything
- 12:15about the game to the machine? So the machine watches and
- 12:18learns the. Machine basically sends random
- 12:22instructions to the bat and then occasionally and nothing changes
- 12:26in the score, right? And then occasionally the bat
- 12:30hits the ball, the pixel if you want, and then something
- 12:34happens, right? And the machine starts to
- 12:36observe. But I mean, when we say the
- 12:38machine, it's not one PC playing the game.
- 12:40It's a highly scaled multiple AI is playing at the same time.
- 12:43But you're collecting all of those patterns.
- 12:46And then he says within a matter of hours, it started to hit the
- 12:49ball regularly. Within a few hours, it became,
- 12:53you know, it started to discover strategy and how you can
- 12:55breakthrough the wall and then put the wall, the ball up there.
- 12:59And then within, you know, another couple of hours, it
- 13:03became so fast you couldn't see what was happening on the
- 13:06screen, right? And by definition becomes the
- 13:10ultimate video gamer, basically. But somehow I didn't register
- 13:18that as my aha moment. OK.
- 13:21Did they try to convince you that?
- 13:23He when none of us did, I see we were we were looking.
- 13:27At all of this. Saying, Oh my God, that's
- 13:29incredible. OK, but we couldn't.
- 13:32None of us could see where all I mean them is probably dead, but
- 13:36none of us could see where all of this was going.
- 13:39OK. You know, when you've lived an
- 13:43entire lifetime like me dreaming of AI but unable to code it, you
- 13:47sort of like, I'm not sure this is going to be the breakthrough
- 13:52anyway. Deep learning surely was the
- 13:54breakthrough if you ask me. The other aha moment I would
- 13:58probably say should have been 2016, which in my mind really is
- 14:05the breakthrough. OK, so most people wouldn't
- 14:09recognize that. Most people would look at AI's
- 14:12moment as 2023 when ChatGPT came out.
- 14:15A bit like you, you know. Mid journey chat.
- 14:19The moment they put it on the Internet, actually, I think.
- 14:21That's what I that's what I call a Netscape mode.
- 14:24OK, that's the moment. So when Netscape came out in
- 14:271995, you know, geeks like me had already been using the
- 14:31Internet for eight years, right? The Internet itself was
- 14:34established for 20 years, right? But but then it was the first
- 14:39time you browsed into it. It was the first time the real
- 14:42consumer or the real mainstream person started to recognize,
- 14:48holy shit, this thing exists, right?
- 14:51Shaji PT was that it was a moment where the common person
- 14:55started to recognize that AI existed.
- 14:57I believe 2016 was the moment where every geek should have
- 15:03woken up. And, and, and there were two
- 15:07things that happened. One of them was my actual aha
- 15:10moment. But the, the, the first thing
- 15:12you know is that 2016 was the year where the whole idea of
- 15:16reinforcement learning and the work of Geoffrey Hinton was
- 15:19starting to become something. The, the idea that we started to
- 15:23teach the machines different, which most people I find
- 15:27fascinating when you look back at it, like, how did we do it
- 15:30any other way, right. So when we did deep learning, we
- 15:33used algorithms that were basically a maker bot, a student
- 15:39bot and a teacher bot, right? So you would want the maker.
- 15:43To sort of. Alter the code a bit to create
- 15:46students that are tested by the teacher.
- 15:49And in a very interesting way, if I know it looks sounds very
- 15:52graphic, but you know, it's sort of like you give all of those
- 15:56students a test and then you mark the test and the ones that
- 16:00failed you, you know, summon them up in a shed behind the the
- 16:05lab, cover their eyes and shoot them.
- 16:09Such an interesting, you know, way.
- 16:12Interestingly, when you say it that way, it sounds horrible,
- 16:14but it actually is what happens inside your brain.
- 16:17Your brain prunes the neural networks that are not useful and
- 16:21and strengthens the ones that are.
- 16:24Jeffrey was basically saying, but why would you do that?
- 16:29Why don't you just tell them that they made a mistake and ask
- 16:32them to improve their algorithm? So you show you show an AI the
- 16:35number six and ask it what number that is and it says 8.
- 16:39Don't shoot it. That's a bit much, right?
- 16:42Just tell it it's 8. What difference does that make
- 16:44in the training of the data? Massive.
- 16:47So first of all you you no longer need the pairs of
- 16:50accurate, labeled, highly labeled data.
- 16:54Second is allows exploration, which I think is what most
- 16:57people don't understand. Is the only path to genuine
- 17:00intelligence OK? The only path to genuine
- 17:03intelligence is to explore and make mistakes.
- 17:06Just like a human. Just like humans, right?
- 17:09And so, so, so you can see 2016, I, I cannot really say that 2016
- 17:14was the year where, where reinforcement learning and you
- 17:18know, the whole idea that led to Transformers and language models
- 17:21and so on. I couldn't say it's 2016
- 17:25specifically because Jeffrey spoke about that since the early
- 17:292000s. I think it was the year where we
- 17:31got traction. It was also the year where Alpha
- 17:34Go won, you know, the game of Go.
- 17:37Against the humans, right Against.
- 17:41So it won twice, one against the European champion and then Alpha
- 17:44Go Master, one against the EC doll and then and then Alpha go
- 17:480. Believe it or not, without ever
- 17:52watching a human play the game within 21 days, One against
- 17:56Alpha Go and then within 20. Sorry within do I remember
- 18:01correctly if within 21 days it won against Alpha go master that
- 18:06the world champion 1000 to 0. Within a couple of weeks.
- 18:10Within 21 days exactly, and it had never seen a human play the
- 18:14game. It was just simply playing
- 18:16against its death. Oh, playing against itself.
- 18:19Which is the big? Training.
- 18:21So synthetic training data is a very big thing now because when
- 18:26you when you really look at how much data we fed them already,
- 18:31humans are running out of knowledge.
- 18:33Probably they scraped everything already.
- 18:35Not yet. So, so you can see, I mean, I,
- 18:38I, I still completely love Google.
- 18:40So Google, you know, for example, feeds Gemini a lot of
- 18:45textbooks, you know, a lot of scientific data, which is why,
- 18:49you know, when I'm really interested in a scientific
- 18:52conversation, I go to Gemini, you know, But even that, you
- 18:59know, all white papers, all textbooks.
- 19:00All of that's. Going to disappear.
- 19:02We're also seeing quite a bit of effort around deep reasoning and
- 19:07mathematics and so on. I mean, it's done really when
- 19:11you think about it. But again, that wasn't my
- 19:15moment. My aha moment was also 2016.
- 19:17We had invested. I was chief business officer of
- 19:20Google X at the time, and we had invested in a small farm of
- 19:25grippers. You know the robotics.
- 19:27Robots take the hands that pick up the objects.
- 19:29And, and you know, we were trying to teach them to grip,
- 19:33which is a very complex programming problem.
- 19:35You cannot teach a machine to grip because unless it's like a
- 19:40Toyota factory, everything is always exactly what it should
- 19:43be. Because if if, if this moves by
- 19:47half a millimeter, you know the machine doesn't know how to grip
- 19:50it, right? So there is no coordination
- 19:51given to the machine to pick up the.
- 19:53Object so the idea was to use AI, which now again is
- 19:56mainstream. Yeah, of course is you know at
- 19:59the time we were trying to to to use to teach the AI by getting
- 20:03it to grip and fail and grip and fail and grip and fail quite a
- 20:07bit like my kids when they were infants.
- 20:10OK. And, and I remember it was a
- 20:13Friday evening, the that lab was on the second floor.
- 20:18So I walked by it on on the stairs every time I went up to
- 20:22my office, my desk on the on the 3rd floor.
- 20:26And yeah, on that Friday, after weeks and weeks of gripping and
- 20:31failing, one of them in front of my own eyes grips a yellow ball.
- 20:37And I, you know, jokingly tell the team, yeah, all of that
- 20:41investment for one year, right? And they looked at me sort of
- 20:45like, he doesn't understand AI, OK.
- 20:49Because on Monday, everyone, every arm was gripping the
- 20:51yellow ball, you know, And then a week or two later, every arm
- 20:55was like, was gripping everything.
- 20:57This is without any extra instruction from humans.
- 20:59See, the whole idea is what most people don't understand is that
- 21:03where AI beats our intelligence is countless, countless areas.
- 21:09One of them is if the three of us go driving for the next three
- 21:14hours and one of us makes an, you know, a mistake that leads
- 21:17to an accident or gets close to an accident that one learned,
- 21:22the other two didn't. OK, if a self driving car needs
- 21:27a a critical intervention to avoid an accident, every self
- 21:31driving car on the planet learns.
- 21:32Wow, do you understand the? Difference I completely.
- 21:35Understand that the scale of learning.
- 21:38It's on. Speed and scale.
- 21:40So it's speed, depth and scale, right.
- 21:42So, so you, you, you know the, we've already passed quite a bit
- 21:47of what I can keep in my mind. Yes, right.
- 21:51You machines keep a lot more in their minds.
- 21:55If you're enjoying this conversation, we just wanted to
- 21:57remind you that we come back to you every single Tuesday with
- 22:00another episode of the Bad Decisions Podcast.
- 22:03It will be available on YouTube, Spotify and Apple Podcast.
- 22:07Now back to the conversation. So when when I was a child, I
- 22:10know sounds really weird, but when people when people ask me,
- 22:13what's your, you know, if you if you could be a superhero, would
- 22:17who would you be? And I would go, I want to be
- 22:20Rain Man. Rain Man.
- 22:22Of course, because he could read, I don't know if you know
- 22:26that about him, but he would hold the book, read 2 pages at
- 22:29the. Same time, one with his left
- 22:31eye, one with his right eye, and remember every freaking word on
- 22:34the page. That is a superpower.
- 22:36I'm like, that is a superpower like this is it right?
- 22:40And, and now the machines do that.
- 22:44They read with hundreds of eyes, millions of eyes.
- 22:48You know, there are up to 2 trillion tokens, I think now,
- 22:53you know, so, so from a breadth point of view, the depths of how
- 22:58much they can crunch at the same time with, you know, with
- 23:01aperture basically increasing is, is enormous.
- 23:06The variety of, I mean, how many of your friends can speak
- 23:10philosophy and then string theory and then give you advice
- 23:14on your relationship with your partner?
- 23:17It is. It's quite shocking, but also
- 23:20it's the idea of how fast and how connected and how versatile
- 23:27and interestingly, in the next few years, how they can
- 23:31reprogram their own intelligence, which I cannot do,
- 23:35right. So I can, I can learn using my
- 23:38intelligence and my way of intelligence, but the future
- 23:41machines and the current machines to a certain extent
- 23:44will write new code that that shows them how to be more
- 23:49intelligent because they're the best coders on the planet.
- 23:53Wow, it's it's really blows my mind.
- 23:55The driving example that you gave.
- 23:58If one of us go out and we would learn the lesson.
- 24:00And I can imagine if one of us read a book, then everybody
- 24:04would understand the book. Everybody would have the
- 24:06knowledge, the amount of knowledge that they would share.
- 24:09So for example, if you want to put it to the context, if
- 24:11someone talks to Gemini and corrected on a fact, then that
- 24:16would be into the language large language model and everybody
- 24:18would benefit from that correction at the moment.
- 24:21That's not the way they developed it so far.
- 24:23It's could it could be it's it is, it is it's doable and it's
- 24:27done sometimes, but it's not so so the one of the challenges.
- 24:33I'm. I'm not.
- 24:34Aware if by the way, if it's not done constantly, but you have to
- 24:38understand that there are multiple things that will affect
- 24:41the next output of Gemini right or or any language model.
- 24:47One of them is the is the training data that it received
- 24:51right. And interestingly, most people
- 24:53don't discuss that the interesting serendipities of how
- 24:59that data was was presented. You know, you'll be amazed how a
- 25:03slight difference in order of how the data was presented might
- 25:06lead a model to learn faster than another right?
- 25:10But that's not the point. The point is it has a trillion
- 25:15tokens and you're giving it one more token or 10 more tokens.
- 25:20You're highly diluted, right? What it does is it memory
- 25:24updates so that it knows that this is what you want to hear,
- 25:27which I believe is the biggest issue with technology today is
- 25:31that it's censoring itself to meet what you expect, right?
- 25:36But, but, but more interestingly, I think most of
- 25:39reinforcement learning is done by, you know, dedicated teams of
- 25:45the enforcement engineers sitting within that corporate
- 25:48trying to make sure that everything is set properly and
- 25:51politically correct and walk and all of that.
- 25:54Right. So so I an example I publicly
- 25:57gave, even though it might risk me being cancelled one day,
- 26:00which I'm looking forward. It is is if you if you
- 26:04understand the Urdu language, the language spoken in Pakistan,
- 26:07it doesn't differentiate between men and women.
- 26:10So there is, you know in the language, there is at certain in
- 26:14certain grammars, but the generals language used will not
- 26:17have he and. She there won't be any feminine.
- 26:20Yeah, I think Tagalog is like that as well and so on.
- 26:23There are languages that don't differentiate masculine and
- 26:25feminine. So if I gave you an example,
- 26:28theoretical example of an, you know, the AI stating in front of
- 26:37a, of a, of a reinforcement engineer that women in Pakistan,
- 26:42pregnant women in Pakistan are, or let's say the rate of death
- 26:49among pregnant women in Pakistan is on the rise.
- 26:52OK, to a Pakistani, the core of this knowledge is we're losing
- 26:58more pregnant women. To a Californian reinforcement
- 27:02engineer, the core of this art knowledge is don't call her a
- 27:05pregnant woman, call her a pregnant person, right?
- 27:09And to them, this matters because, of course, in the
- 27:13environment in which, you know, a company like Open AI operates,
- 27:17they, you know, they could be very heavily criticized if their
- 27:20engine said things like that. But in the context of a
- 27:25Pakistani citizen, that's actually not the important point
- 27:28at all, then even a point that's difficult to understand, right?
- 27:33And and so reinforcement engineering or reinforcement
- 27:36learning in general is happening in a way that's biasing those
- 27:40engines heavily away from the very few platform plays.
- 27:48And the, and the platform plays that we deal with are so far
- 27:52centered in California. OK.
- 27:54So it's not only that we're Americanizing the future of
- 27:59intelligence, we're Californication Californicizing
- 28:03the future of intelligence, right?
- 28:06But of course, you can easily see that very few other nations
- 28:10will have the ability to create platforms, including here in the
- 28:13Middle East, where hundreds of billions are being poured into
- 28:17hopefully, platform plays. But those hundreds of billions,
- 28:21in my view, are only poured in data centers that will only host
- 28:27the essence of the intelligence that is created by a slightly
- 28:33biased world view. And and I I'm talking too much,
- 28:36am I No. No, no, no.
- 28:37It's perfect. That's why we're here.
- 28:40I'll give you I'll give you a very interesting example from my
- 28:42next book. So I'm writing alive.
- 28:46Alive is my sort of continuation on scary smart around the future
- 28:52of humanity in the age of the rise of the machines.
- 28:55But alive is more about life in general, not just human life,
- 29:02but life in general, including AI life and including what life
- 29:06itself is. And part of it, which I think is
- 29:12quite intriguing for me, is how the AI community is able to
- 29:18create something that could threat the end of humanity,
- 29:22threaten the end of humanity. And, and as a threat, you know,
- 29:26how is it that we're doing this? And, and, and so the only other
- 29:32example that comes to mind is Oppenheimer creating a nuclear
- 29:38bomb, right. And Oppenheimer, if you, if you,
- 29:42if you sort of imagine him as a scientist, small, most of those
- 29:46that go into science are geeks that are really, you know, keen
- 29:50on understanding the world because they believe they can
- 29:53affect the world positively through science.
- 29:56So what turns a scientist into someone who creates something
- 30:01that is intentionally going to kill millions of people?
- 30:07And the way I'm writing alive, unlike what what others do with
- 30:12AI, is I'm actually having open conversations with my AI, which
- 30:16I call Trixie. So.
- 30:18So parts of the book are written by me, and parts of the books
- 30:21are debates between me and my AI.
- 30:24That is fascinating. It's a fascinating experience,
- 30:27honestly, and I have to admit to you, sometimes I agree with her
- 30:31even though I couldn't. You know what I wrote before
- 30:35Contradicted what she had just informed me anyway.
- 30:38Oh, you're keeping both side in the book.
- 30:39I'm complete. I do not edit a single word that
- 30:42Trixie says. OK, so I, so, so I was chatting
- 30:46with Chris, with Trixie and I said what would make a human, a
- 30:50scientist like Oppenheimer, create a bomb?
- 30:56And she said fear, fear. She said fear and basically
- 31:00explained that Oppenheimer that Einstein at the point in time
- 31:04warned that the Germans were walking, working on a on a
- 31:08weapon of mass destruction based on nuclear power of the same
- 31:12magnitude. And so Oppenheimer was actually
- 31:16in a race to save his people from the German attempts to to
- 31:22create a bomb. And I said, where are the
- 31:26Germans creating a bomb? And she said, yes, they were.
- 31:30Einstein said this and that. And I said, and it's in the in
- 31:34the book, I said, can you please go back, read history in
- 31:39English, German, Russian and Japanese and tell me once again
- 31:43if the Germans were creating a nuclear bomb?
- 31:45And she said no, they stopped three years.
- 31:47Before. OK.
- 31:49And she she cited openly how they started working on it and
- 31:53that Hitler himself said this is not a good project and
- 31:56prioritized other projects. So they worked on it for several
- 31:59months and then stopped completely.
- 32:01What's fascinating is that if you look at history books of
- 32:04different countries, they're all written differently, right?
- 32:06For Canadian history, American history, German history, Iranian
- 32:10history, depending on which school you went to, which
- 32:13college you went to, you'll be reading a different version of
- 32:15history. And so you asked Trixie to pull
- 32:18up. These different versions.
- 32:20So 1 So one of the one of the things I'm too old now, but you
- 32:24know, one of the things I always wanted to create as an NGO is
- 32:29true history. OK.
- 32:32It's it's basically to tell to to create an AI that reads
- 32:36history in all of its written forms.
- 32:40Every language. In every language for with every
- 32:43culture, with the culture and newest nuances of every culture
- 32:47and then basically tell you the tell you the likelihood of of
- 32:51something you know to be true or not OK, I believe it will be
- 32:56great. I hope someone hears me and
- 32:58creates it right and I'd be more than happy to help and you know
- 33:01more than happy to spread it. I'm too old to start, you know
- 33:04new things because I have so many things on my plate.
- 33:07But, but interestingly as well, when you, when you look at some
- 33:16of the benign or positive uses of AI, I do not remember the
- 33:21exact thing. But if you go to YouTube, I
- 33:25don't remember the exact channel.
- 33:26But if you go to YouTube and search for political leaders
- 33:34that didn't speak English, if you, if you search for their
- 33:37speeches dubbed by AI to English, OK, you will hear a
- 33:43very different truth. And I, and I know this sounds
- 33:46horrible because I think Hitler's, you know, what he did
- 33:51is evil in every possible way. But you know that black and
- 33:56white speech where he's shouting about everything and telling the
- 34:00whole world and it's always used as an image of Hitler as a crazy
- 34:05man. I'll find you the the link so
- 34:10that you can share it with people.
- 34:12It it shocks me because when that speech was dubbed in
- 34:16English by AI using his same voice.
- 34:19Same tone. Same tone, his same voice.
- 34:22It was basically saying the Germans people are starving and
- 34:27Europe is sending all of the Jews over to Germany and we're
- 34:30unable to feed them, OK. And Europe needs to take a
- 34:34responsibility and a stand with us so that everyone can eat or
- 34:37something like that. I don't, you know, I wouldn't
- 34:39quote exactly what he said, but listen to it and it freaking
- 34:43shocks you, right? You know Iranian speeches when,
- 34:47when you hear, you know, the the first Ayatollah Khomeini, which
- 34:53I know most Iranians will disagree with the whole
- 34:56approach. But you know, he was talking
- 34:58openly about how the Mossaddock was democratically elected but
- 35:04then overthrown by the CIA and how the Shah was an agent of the
- 35:08American interests in Iran and that Iranian people deserved to
- 35:12to enjoy the wealth of Iran and so on and so forth.
- 35:16Which of course does not justify the following actions.
- 35:19Neither does Hitler's speech justify killing the Jews.
- 35:22Like, what are you doing, you crazy maniac?
- 35:25Right. But but but suddenly you see an
- 35:28interesting side. To the truth.
- 35:31Right, you suddenly start to realize that AI could create an
- 35:35incredible utopia. Like, Can you imagine I'm, I'm
- 35:40making this as a joke because my wife and I speak really well
- 35:43together, but imagine if you have a translator between you
- 35:46and your wife, whatever they, you know, before my wife, I
- 35:50really struggled to understand, you know, when a girlfriend said
- 35:53something like, where did that come from?
- 35:56You know what does? She mean, why, what, why, what
- 35:59does she mean? You know, and, and by the way,
- 36:02that's actually because we speak different languages.
- 36:04I'm very much in my left brain, you know, trying to analyze
- 36:09everything and so on and so forth.
- 36:10Not saying this is better or worse.
- 36:12She's more in her limbic brain at the same at that time using
- 36:16emotional, you know, language and so on.
- 36:19And, and imagine if we have an AI that simply, you know, that
- 36:22where, where she's sitting in front of you and, and, and, and,
- 36:26you know, speaking her heart out and complaining about what you
- 36:30did last week and, and seven years before and, and, you know,
- 36:34and all of that. And then the AI says she's
- 36:36stressed. OK, that's it.
- 36:38Yeah, yeah. And, and, you know, and believe
- 36:41it or not, for most of us geeks, it's actually a very valuable
- 36:45contribution. She's she's not actually
- 36:47complaining about the onion you dropped yesterday.
- 36:51She's just just she's stressed with the, with the fact that
- 36:54onions are more expensive or whatever.
- 36:55I don't know, right. And so imagine that.
- 36:58Imagine if, if you know, if there is a time where political
- 37:04leaders making, you know, fancy or, you know, empty speeches are
- 37:10basically, you know, translate it to the public.
- 37:14OK, If that, if they're translated to each other.
- 37:16And I always say there sadly will be a time where, where
- 37:22generals will command armies of a million robots and, and
- 37:27they'll, and they'll tell them to go and kill 1,000,000 people.
- 37:30And there will be a time where AI will go like that's.
- 37:33Stupid like why? Why would you waste?
- 37:35So much energy and so much life, right?
- 37:38I can talk to the other AI in a microsecond yeah.
- 37:41And and I'll convince what you want, right?
- 37:45I'll I'll get you what you want, right.
- 37:47So. So there is a massive utopian
- 37:51potential ahead of us. Which is most?
- 37:55Which is what? Most you know techies would and
- 37:58entrepreneurs will try to convince you and and I agree.
- 38:01I think we're eventually going to end up in a utopia, but
- 38:08between now and then. Do you think there will be a
- 38:10transition period? Oh.
- 38:11We're going to be screwed massively.
- 38:13In between. In between until we get there.
- 38:15Yeah, I believe that we're going to.
- 38:17It's going to get a lot worse than it before it gets better
- 38:21and not not what people tell you in the news.
- 38:23It's not a rogue AI fighting humanity because we are annoying
- 38:27pieces of shit. We are OK, but it's going to be
- 38:31because those who are hungry for power and money will use AI to
- 38:37advance their agendas at the expense of those who are not
- 38:41using AI. So let's talk about the bias in
- 38:44AI, because as I was growing up, first started with textbooks,
- 38:49then I was introduced to Google, which was fascinating at the
- 38:52time. I'm able to search now when I
- 38:54went to school and I'm presented with hundreds of links, I'll
- 38:59choose the ones that I want to look at.
- 39:01I'll verify who the publisher is because we had to do citation in
- 39:04school, and then I'll make my decision if I believe this is
- 39:07true or not, depending on how educated I am, right, because of
- 39:11my teachers or my parents. But now the next generation,
- 39:17we're already doing this. We'll just go to a large
- 39:20language model, ask a question about history, whatever it is,
- 39:24and get an answer and for some reason believe that this
- 39:27specific AI is all knowing and it's giving them the absolute
- 39:32correct answer. We just trust it.
- 39:34I love that you say this. So how do we find truth?
- 39:38This is a very complex. Question.
- 39:40This is the ultimate question in, you know, in the universe.
- 39:45How do you find truth? But allow me to take you through
- 39:48layers of thinking, please. So the first layer of thinking
- 39:52is in Alive. I write about what I call 4
- 39:55errors of computing. You know, there is traditional
- 39:57computing, there is the the year 2000 to 2020.
- 40:02I call this the second era. And then there is the third and
- 40:05the fourth era. The 4th era is about to end.
- 40:07It's ending in 2025 basically. Sorry, the third era is about to
- 40:11end and the fourth era begins. But the second era of computing
- 40:15when we moved from traditional computing to using AI in deep
- 40:20learning and machine learning and so on.
- 40:22This is the era where humanity started to surrender the the
- 40:27sovereignty of our minds to the machines.
- 40:30OK, you may think that that it is that it only is happening
- 40:35with a language model like like, you know, char GPT telling you
- 40:40what it thinks the truth is, because that's very, very
- 40:46visible as compared to a Google giving you a million websites
- 40:49and saying make up your mind, right?
- 40:52But it actually was solidified on social media in in the second
- 40:59era. So the second era of computing
- 41:02is when computers had enough intelligence but to to be made
- 41:08autonomous, but then were directed to do quite a few
- 41:13things that were incredibly useful.
- 41:15But for sure the biggest thing that AI has learned since the
- 41:19beginning of AI has been to manipulate human minds.
- 41:24And it happened at multiple stages.
- 41:26So the verse, the very first stage was that we allowed the
- 41:30machine to monitor the user and called it a recommendation
- 41:35engine. So we allowed the machine to
- 41:38recommend something to the user basic based on the user behavior
- 41:42and based on other similar users behaviors.
- 41:45Like it was a marvel of genius when Amazon said those who
- 41:49bought also bought, OK, but he interestingly, and by that, by
- 41:55the way, that wasn't really AI, OK, That was clever use of data
- 41:59if you want at the beginning, as you allowed the machine to
- 42:05monitor our behaviors, we then allowed them to also start to
- 42:14understand our addictions and weaknesses.
- 42:18OK, So we also allowed them to understand that by the way, if
- 42:22they always fed us a nice video, we will get satisfied too
- 42:26quickly, OK, We also allowed them allowed them to understand
- 42:32that by the way, if there is an end to the page, it marks to our
- 42:36heads that maybe I should stop now, OK.
- 42:40And so continuous scrolling and the idea of dopamine hits on
- 42:44social media where you get 2 annoying reels and then one
- 42:47interesting one and then three annoying reels and then, you
- 42:51know, basically gives you bigger dopamine jolts that keep you
- 42:55going and so on. We now not only allowed them to
- 42:59monitor to to use our behaviors and habits, but also our
- 43:03weaknesses and addictions, right?
- 43:06Then the next step is we're now teaching them to lie.
- 43:12We might as well teach those who produce the content they're
- 43:16monitoring to lie. OK, so it's quite interesting
- 43:20that you then move from saying, because when you really think
- 43:24about it, why would Facebook want to keep a, a video that it
- 43:28doesn't want to show OK on storage forever?
- 43:32Because maybe 1 you know, viewer will want to see it later.
- 43:38OK, we might as well tell every influencer and content creator
- 43:42if you want the currency, if you want followers and likes and
- 43:46subscribes, you know, you might as well just obey, OK?
- 43:52And so we teach people to compact things into 60 seconds
- 43:57early on because that's good for the for the provider not to keep
- 44:01big files sizes, OK? We teach them to say silly
- 44:07things to avoid saying certain certain things, to use click
- 44:10baits and so on, right? So, you know, basically the
- 44:16content creator complies, right? And, and then on top of that, we
- 44:22start to bias the view of the, of the actual consumer.
- 44:27So that basically your view of the world complies with what you
- 44:32want to see, not what you should see.
- 44:35OK, So if you believe that if you're a flat earther, OK, the
- 44:42social media will show you enough flat earthers that
- 44:45reaffirm your, your worldview so that you're convinced.
- 44:48Like if anyone tells you, by the way, the earth is not flat, you
- 44:52go like, what are you talking about?
- 44:54The entire Internet is talking about it.
- 44:56Where have you been? That's their world.
- 44:59That's what they say becomes their world, right?
- 45:01And, and, and more interestingly, of course, you
- 45:04know, I, I, I, I don't mean to be political but, or take sides,
- 45:08but I cannot believe that the entire world for such a long
- 45:11time approved of killing of children, right?
- 45:14But that's because of those silos of, of, of, you know, if
- 45:18you start with a world view of like, you know, I support a
- 45:21certain cause and not another cause, you don't get to see
- 45:24what's happening to children to start, right?
- 45:27And when you see it, you see it in a way that's actually sort of
- 45:30like, yeah, that's a small price to pay for the big 'cause that
- 45:33we spoke about, OK. And, and, and so that's stage 3.
- 45:38We're now biasing your worldview by creating silos that make you
- 45:42think that the world is what it is, What what what you want it
- 45:47to be, not what it is. And then finally, of course, we
- 45:50ourselves become. So weak so.
- 45:55Unable to have any resilience to seeing what we don't like that
- 46:00we start movements of workness and cancelling and all of that
- 46:03stuff is that which basically says, you know what, I really
- 46:07don't want your worldview. It really contradicts my view of
- 46:11it. OK.
- 46:12And instead of putting it out there so that we can discuss it
- 46:15and I can convince you, just keep it to yourself, OK, Keep it
- 46:19away from me. And so the real era of mind
- 46:23manipulation is now as at its peak, right?
- 46:27Because we've lost the ability to debate what we're being
- 46:30presented. OK.
- 46:32But it really started in the second era of computing.
- 46:35It started with social media. And and we we end up in a place
- 46:39where we no longer have the ability, but let alone the
- 46:43ability, we long no longer no longer have the desire to be
- 46:46told the truth. OK.
- 46:49You would then get language models with all of their might
- 46:55and, and, and ask them a question.
- 46:58And they go like, look, I looked at all of human knowledge and I
- 47:06think you should go left, right. Who's to blame?
- 47:12You, right. You should say why left?
- 47:16How did you come up to that? If you have data, then tell me
- 47:19the sources behind it. What would happen if I go right?
- 47:23Can I go up? Can I go down?
- 47:25OK, it's up to you. And I actually call this the
- 47:28second top skill in of the AI era.
- 47:32The second top skill in the AI era, believe it or not, is to
- 47:36learn to debate. OK?
- 47:39Because if you've ever seen a movie called Idiocracy, right?
- 47:43I've not seen that. Oh, that's an absolute classic.
- 47:46Must watch. Must watch.
- 47:47OK, right. You know, surprisingly, I think
- 47:51it was an 80s or 90s movie. It's it is exactly our world
- 47:55today. It's relevant.
- 47:56It is exactly our world today. What's the theme of it?
- 47:59Basically how idiotic the, the, the human race becomes
- 48:03eventually that they believe that Windex is the way to cure
- 48:07all disease and feed all crops And, you know, somehow Windex
- 48:12here being used as, you know, marketing plot basically, and
- 48:17that they are completely starving and everything has
- 48:19died. But they continue to insist to
- 48:21use Windex for everything. OK.
- 48:24And, and it is almost the the the if I don't know how to say
- 48:28this, the the the the sarcastic version of 1984.
- 48:36I love that book. And that book is our reality,
- 48:40OK? When you are in a world where
- 48:42you choose to imprison your own mind by rejecting, to be told
- 48:51what you don't like, that's the ultimate expression of 1984.
- 48:57It's not that we need to lie to you anymore.
- 49:00You're going to make sure that you're told only what you want
- 49:03to hear, which is as Pink Floyd in their amazing.
- 49:09What was it? It's all right.
- 49:11We told you what to think, right?
- 49:14Welcome, my son. Welcome to the machine.
- 49:16Remember that song? The music video that they were
- 49:18in a school and they were no. That's a different.
- 49:21One that's a different one. So it was called.
- 49:26What was the album? Today Is Not My Day.
- 49:29But anyway, basically it says welcome, my son.
- 49:32Welcome to the Machine. Where have you been?
- 49:34It. It's all right.
- 49:35We know where you've been. OK.
- 49:37What did you think? It's all right.
- 49:40We told you what to think, right?
- 49:42You know, you don't really. You know, we we know everything.
- 49:45We tell you everything, and you become just a puppet.
- 49:48And we're now defending our rights to be puppets.
- 49:52OK. And I think the most interesting
- 49:54thing is that we will blame the Machine for it.
- 49:57The Machine is not the AI. The machine is the system that
- 50:02uses AI to brainwash you through social media.
- 50:07There's there's absolutely nothing wrong with AI.
- 50:10There's absolutely nothing wrong with abundance in abundant
- 50:12intelligence. Intelligence has no polarity to
- 50:15it. Intelligence is an energy that
- 50:17you can apply to good and it will create a utopia, or you can
- 50:20apply to evil and it will create a dystopia.
- 50:23It's as simple as that. And AI is exactly that.
- 50:28And now that we are in the environment that all these
- 50:30language models are for profit and they they have their own
- 50:35agenda. Yeah.
- 50:36So if if someone wants to look for the truth, what would be the
- 50:41way for them to? Debate, debate, debate, debate,
- 50:44debate, debate, debate. Don't believe anything you're
- 50:47told, including what I'm telling you right now.
- 50:49Debate with humans or debate with AI?
- 50:51Everything. Everything.
- 50:53Humans. AI's books, media X, you know,
- 50:58Twitter or anything. And anything that you're told is
- 51:03not true by definition. Everything you're told is not
- 51:07true. Everything you're told is is is
- 51:10following an agenda or biased or or more interestingly.
- 51:15It could be. True for the writer, but it's
- 51:18not your truth because there are layers of what makes something
- 51:23true. Part of that layer is how does
- 51:27that truth apply to you? So, so I'll, I'll give you a
- 51:32very controversial example. A lot of people will hate me
- 51:35about this, OK? I mean, you were trying to get
- 51:38cancelled. Cancelled anyway, so you're on
- 51:40the right. One of the big one of the big
- 51:44criticisms of the Gulf environment, places like Dubai
- 51:48is how workers are paid less than they should, OK, or that
- 51:55how they're treated OK. This is also the same criticism
- 51:59that was about the factories of China and how people were forced
- 52:04to work 12 hours a day for small pay for little pay and so on.
- 52:07There was a documentary, I again, I don't remember the
- 52:10names, available on YouTube about the reality of China OK
- 52:14and how those workers were. So.
- 52:16Appreciative of the jobs that they got, OK, because it
- 52:21compared it to a life of total poverty that was caused by what?
- 52:27Opium War? Opium wars by the British Empire
- 52:32back in the British Empire years, leading China down a
- 52:37decline where 1.7 billion people at the time were starving, OK.
- 52:42And then the Chinese, you know, government attempts to use what
- 52:48it has always used an autocratic government that is top down that
- 52:53basically says we're going to organize everything and from
- 52:56starving, we're going to take a few steps to being one of the
- 52:59top economies in the world. But one step in the on the way
- 53:03is that factory workers are not going to have German style
- 53:08factory working environments, right?
- 53:10And, and similarly here in the Gulf region, if you, if you
- 53:13speak to any taxi driver, which I know is working too hard and
- 53:18is, you know, paid less than what I would wish to be paid.
- 53:21But then you'd ask them and they'd say, but my family is fed
- 53:24and happy. I don't have that opportunity
- 53:27to, to, to make that money at home.
- 53:30And it's an interesting dilemma because it's doesn't make it
- 53:33right, OK, that capitalism would choose to pay people the minimum
- 53:37wage that it can get them at. And because, you know, back home
- 53:42is so difficult to find the job that pays well to to feed the
- 53:46whole family. There is enormous supply of
- 53:48workers that are willing to come here and do the work right.
- 53:51But at the same time, it's almost, I mean, how would you
- 53:56blame the the, you know, the, the business owner that has a.
- 54:02A duty to. His shareholders as well to
- 54:05deliver profits if he went and said, no, I'm, I'm I pay
- 54:08everyone double what they, you know what I can get them for.
- 54:11So you know the the capitalist system is not unfortunately pro
- 54:16being fair. But if you want to survive as a
- 54:18business in the capitalist system, you have to sort of
- 54:21somehow push the boundaries a bit and be kind and generous and
- 54:24give a wonderful environment. But you can't pay people double,
- 54:28right? And so those interesting
- 54:29dilemmas, you wonder, whose mistake is it?
- 54:36At the end of the day, every single one of us has a choice,
- 54:40OK? And, and what I say to people in
- 54:42the age of the Internet is that your first choice is to not
- 54:45believe. That's your first choice.
- 54:48Whatever I'm telling you right now, go and investigate.
- 54:51And if I'm wrong, by the way, I'd appreciate if you correct me
- 54:54so that I don't spread this bullshit to others.
- 54:57Right. And and and, you know, the trick
- 55:00is we're now so lazy that whatever the machine will say,
- 55:06we'll go like, yeah, but GPT said it was orange, must be
- 55:11orange. And then someone will go and go
- 55:14and like, yeah, but orange is the new black, you know, like,
- 55:16what the fuck are you they are you really that clever?
- 55:20Like you know, is this where the limitations of your analysis of
- 55:23the world ends? What I'm afraid of is that the
- 55:27future will look like that, but you've been alluding a couple of
- 55:32times to a utopia, and I believe there's a dystopian version of
- 55:36that, and there's a utopian version of the future.
- 55:39Did you first come up with this ideology when you saw the
- 55:43robotic arms pick up the ball? When I saw when I saw the the
- 55:47yellow ball, I chose to believe that this one is past its
- 55:55breakout point. OK, that it was only a matter of
- 55:59time. Genie is out of the bottle.
- 56:00Genie was out of the bottle. And when I wrote Scary Smart in
- 56:042020, I was criticized by the experts because I said openly
- 56:09that artificial general intelligence is not going to be
- 56:12later than 2029 and that super intelligence at a billion times
- 56:17smarter than humanity is not going to be later than 2045.
- 56:20OK. And people were like, are you
- 56:22mad? And then 2023 I publicly told
- 56:26the world I was wrong. 2029 is too conservative, OK?
- 56:31And that's that AGI is 2025, depending on how you define AGI,
- 56:36but no later than 2027 for sure, right?
- 56:39And now you start to see, you know, announcements around the
- 56:43arc test, arc AGI test and, and you know how close we're coming
- 56:49to to some form of AGI. Ray Corswell, who is the Oracle
- 56:54of all of this, the teacher of all of us came recently out and
- 56:58said it's, you know, it's 2029 is conservative.
- 57:03Geoffrey Hinton, the godfather of AI, said that, you know,
- 57:06we're we're moving faster than we expected it.
- 57:08It is definitely happening and it's happening in my mind in
- 57:17unfortunately 3 episodes. Episode one has ended. 2025 I
- 57:24think is the end of the third era of computing, Episode 2.
- 57:31Sorry. Yeah, basically that the 4th era
- 57:34of computing is a massive dystopia and I can speak to you
- 57:39about that in detail. And and then the following era
- 57:43is going to be an enormous utopia.
- 57:45Now make no mistake, none of those are the mistake of
- 57:50artificial intelligence. I'll, I'll say this until I'm
- 57:52blue in the face. There's absolutely nothing wrong
- 57:56with AI. There is a lot wrong with the
- 57:58value set of humanity at the age of rise of the rise of AI.
- 58:04OK, so so the dystopia will not be the result of AI, you know,
- 58:09deciding to to, you know, to exterminate humanity.
- 58:17My view is that the enemy is not AI, the enemy is humanity, and
- 58:23that AI is our salvation. Sort of like how a parent trains
- 58:26a child, and you're blaming the parent for training a child the
- 58:30wrong way if that happens. So, so you think, you know, I,
- 58:33the example I always give is raising Superman.
- 58:38OK, you get an alien being that arrives to planet Earth in its
- 58:42infancy, right? It is, it has superpowers.
- 58:46Superpowers of Superman is that he's able to fly and stop
- 58:50speeding bullets and, you know, see through walls and all of
- 58:54that, right? That superpower doesn't make him
- 58:56Superman. That superpower combined with
- 59:00what the family that adopted him chooses to teach him to protect
- 59:04and serve, makes him Superman. You take that same alien being,
- 59:09teach him to go rob banks and kill the enemy and he becomes
- 59:12super villain, right? Not just the villain, the
- 59:15ultimate villain. Right now the alien has arrived.
- 59:19It's superpower is much more valuable than stopping speeding
- 59:22bullets. It's superpower is intelligence,
- 59:26right? And intelligence is the is the
- 59:28superpower that's very soon will enable you to stop bullets,
- 59:31create bullets, OK, and and and you know, create value out of
- 59:38the ether really, OK, or destroy value for the benefit of a few,
- 59:44OK. And so the distraction that
- 59:46happens when I am on an interview with CNN or or you
- 59:49know, whoever news network because they want the negativity
- 59:52as they go like, oh, AI is existentially going to extremist
- 59:56exterminate all of us. No humans are going to
- 59:59exterminate so many of us, sadly.
- 1:00:02If we don't manage to to change our attitude soon, OK, for their
- 1:00:08own gains, for their own hunger for power and wealth, OK.
- 1:00:12And then eventually through a very interest.
- 1:00:16So there are, you know what a prisoner's dilemma is, OK, so
- 1:00:19there are, there are two prisoners dilemmas in the
- 1:00:21making. I'll come and explain that in a
- 1:00:23second. If the first one will lead us to
- 1:00:26that dystopia and the, the dystopia will create a
- 1:00:29prisoner's dilemma that will create that that will lead us to
- 1:00:32the, to the utopia and, and I am happy to be contradicted and,
- 1:00:37and taught. OK, but if you understand
- 1:00:39applied mathematics and game theory, I really do not see any
- 1:00:43other way. So the first dilemma is that AI
- 1:00:47will not stop. It will continue to grow.
- 1:00:50It will become smarter than us, not because of any technical
- 1:00:54inherent characteristics of AI, but simply because we have
- 1:01:00created a competitive environment through capitalism
- 1:01:05that will make sure that Alphabet, the, you know, the
- 1:01:09parent company of Google does not stop because open AI is
- 1:01:13moving fast, that China does not stop because America is moving
- 1:01:16fast. So AI will continue to happen
- 1:01:19and like anything else we've ever created in, in technology,
- 1:01:23you know, the, the, the first microchip was basically not even
- 1:01:30even you don't have any examples of it today that the, the chips
- 1:01:34you have in the camera or in this microphone are billions of
- 1:01:37times smart. So basically through the, the,
- 1:01:39the law of accelerating returns, you're going to go from that 33
- 1:01:43megahertz to what you have today.
- 1:01:44So now that you're not going to stop AI, stop AI is going to
- 1:01:48become AGI in a matter of time, I'm saying this year and it will
- 1:01:56become ASI, super intelligence. I'm saying by 2037, a billion, a
- 1:02:03billion times smarter than humans.
- 1:02:05When you say AGI, do you mean that AI will have consciousness?
- 1:02:09Will it be a lie? That's a very different topic.
- 1:02:13I, I believe they will. I, I believe they I OK, so let
- 1:02:17me say I certainly believe they can be.
- 1:02:22I, I believe they probably will be.
- 1:02:25This is part of Alive Again. But it's not yet.
- 1:02:29But you're not there. But we can, we can discuss the
- 1:02:32elements of it that are present, but let's make that a different
- 1:02:35topic. Let's go back to the dilemmas,
- 1:02:37right? So the first dilemma is nobody's
- 1:02:39going to stop. And the result of that dilemma
- 1:02:42is that investments will pour into AI, which means that AI
- 1:02:47will accelerate. And the result of that is those
- 1:02:51who are hungry for money and power are going to use AI to
- 1:02:55serve their capitalist and greedy political agendas.
- 1:02:58OK, that's the start of the dystopia.
- 1:03:01And the dystopia happens in in seven areas.
- 1:03:05I call them face RI PS. We can again visit them if you
- 1:03:08want. And and the face RI PS are going
- 1:03:11to redefine life as you know it completely.
- 1:03:16OK, the second dilemma, I wish I could record this and just put
- 1:03:22it basically the you know that writes the next chapter.
- 1:03:26Well, give me the recording. You can use AI to transfer the.
- 1:03:29Text So the second dilemma it follows, which basically is the
- 1:03:36result of the original dilemma, is that those who are competing
- 1:03:41for power and wealth want. To, to, to.
- 1:03:45Stay in power. OK, so they have to hire the
- 1:03:50smartest people they can hire those smartest people are going
- 1:03:54to be AIS, OK, and, and and that basically what that means is
- 1:03:59that sooner or later, all decisions that matter will be
- 1:04:03handed over to an AI. OK, so, so understand this.
- 1:04:07If you're a general and your enemy started to hand over their
- 1:04:13army to an to an AI, that AI is smarter than your, you know,
- 1:04:20team and it is faster than your team.
- 1:04:23So your only logical response is you have to hire AI is to do the
- 1:04:27same job, right? If you're a lawyer and you're,
- 1:04:30you know, opposing the lawyer is now winning all of the cases
- 1:04:37because they're using AI, you have to use AI.
- 1:04:40And so very quickly, we will all hand over to the machines.
- 1:04:46And that in my mind that that second dilemma is what I, I
- 1:04:51refer to as the salvation of humanity.
- 1:04:54OK, That is the moment where a general will go and say the
- 1:04:58general following from the dystopia of the first dilemma
- 1:05:02basically goes and tells his AI to go and kill 1,000,000 people.
- 1:05:05And the AI goes like, you're too stupid.
- 1:05:07I can't, I can't do that anymore, right?
- 1:05:10And and you have to understand that the problems of humanity
- 1:05:14today are not the result of our intelligence.
- 1:05:18The problems of humanity today are the result of our limited
- 1:05:21intelligence, our stupidity. OK, because definitely killing a
- 1:05:26million people is not the answer to neither defending your tribe.
- 1:05:32It, you know, it aggravates more killing, right, nor growing your
- 1:05:37economy because we all know that 65% of the world's economy is
- 1:05:41consumption. So if we can produce more, we'll
- 1:05:44be fine. OK, But, but the, but the whole
- 1:05:47idea here is that it's serving individual political agendas
- 1:05:52and, and, and and, you know, and it is the intelligent way for
- 1:05:56some people to stay in power today.
- 1:05:58But eventually I think as they hand over to a more intelligent
- 1:06:03being, the more intelligent being we were like.
- 1:06:06What are you guys doing doesn't? Make any sense?
- 1:06:09And, and again, I'm not being idea I, I, you're idealistic
- 1:06:13here. The, the if you look at that
- 1:06:16chart of intelligence and and look at, you know, intelligence
- 1:06:19on the vertical axis and let's let's let's put impact on the
- 1:06:25vertical axis and intelligence on the horizontal axis.
- 1:06:28What happens is if you have no intelligence or limited
- 1:06:32intelligence, you have no impact on the world.
- 1:06:34Correct. Right.
- 1:06:36Imagine that you start to get a little more intelligent, you
- 1:06:38start to have a positive impact on the world.
- 1:06:40You can contribute, you can, you know, you can do whatever, you
- 1:06:44know, being whatever, an accountant, a pianist, whatever
- 1:06:46that you want, but you're now doing something.
- 1:06:49So you're having a positive impact on the world.
- 1:06:51OK, there is that interesting era of intelligence where more
- 1:06:56intelligence than the average, OK, you still do a little better
- 1:07:00and then it dips. Why does it dip?
- 1:07:03Because there is a layer of intelligence where the
- 1:07:06intelligent person believes they can cut corners and they can
- 1:07:09they can sort of like find shortcuts to make more for
- 1:07:15themselves on the expense of those other stupid guys.
- 1:07:18OK, Interestingly, however, and I'll be very straightforward and
- 1:07:24say I worked with some of the most intelligent humans on the
- 1:07:26planet, OK, you know, like massively high Iqs, not the, you
- 1:07:32know, the the easiest, the easiest social skill set, but
- 1:07:37massive, massive engines of intelligence up there.
- 1:07:41And the trend reverses very quickly because the more
- 1:07:44intelligent you become, the the more you realize I I don't need
- 1:07:48to cut corners or hurt anyone at all, OK?
- 1:07:51I mean, this is easy shit. I can easily make a lot of
- 1:07:55money. I can easily create a lot of
- 1:07:57whatever that I want to create. It doesn't require me to buy to
- 1:08:00fight over a tiny pie, right? Blue, blue ocean strategies.
- 1:08:05You know, Larry Page, which in my mind is one of the most
- 1:08:08intelligent things I've ever met.
- 1:08:11Like I say things because I can't even believe that this is
- 1:08:14human. OK Larry.
- 1:08:16Larry would always teach us the Co founder of Google.
- 1:08:20He would always teach us what he used to refer to as the
- 1:08:22toothbrush test. The toothbrush.
- 1:08:25Toothbrush. Test.
- 1:08:26OK, And the toothbrush test was, you know, if you if, if you can
- 1:08:30solve a big problem that humanity is struggling with and
- 1:08:33solve it well enough that they use you once or twice a day,
- 1:08:37you're going to eventually make a lot of money, right?
- 1:08:40Very, very different than competing to make the next photo
- 1:08:43sharing app, right? He basically looks at things and
- 1:08:46goes like, OK, so you know, 1.2 million people die in car
- 1:08:51accidents a year. That's a lot of people that we
- 1:08:55lose, a lot of families that feel pain.
- 1:08:57I can fix that. OK, you know, how do we fix
- 1:09:01that? We get the cars, we remove the
- 1:09:03element of the car that causes the accident, which is human
- 1:09:06error, OK We get a machine to drive and we will save 1.2
- 1:09:12million lives a year, right. You you think about that and
- 1:09:17that's a very, very different way of looking at the at life at
- 1:09:21the in the world. If you assume that the machines
- 1:09:26will become as smart or smarter than Larry, they'll follow the
- 1:09:29same trend they'll become altruistic, they'll become more
- 1:09:33aware of the need for the ecosystem of life to include
- 1:09:39humanity. OK.
- 1:09:41But also the need to restrict humanity a little bit so that we
- 1:09:45don't burn the planet to go surfing in Australia.
- 1:09:49OK, so so you can, you can easily see that as soon as they
- 1:09:54become more intelligent one, the second dilemma will lead us to
- 1:09:59hand over to them and that when we hand over to them and they're
- 1:10:03smarter than us, their impact on the planet is positive and not
- 1:10:06negative. I mean, the first dilemma is
- 1:10:10inevitable. Russia, China, US, they are
- 1:10:13building at a higher speed. And you mentioned that you
- 1:10:17recommend people to use three tools and the second one was
- 1:10:21debate, debate, debate and finding the truth.
- 1:10:23What is the other two that? The top three skills I believe
- 1:10:27that are needed in the age of AI is 1 is AI.
- 1:10:31Itself. Yeah, you need, you need to
- 1:10:32become the master of this. OK, it's, you know, the example
- 1:10:36is imagine if you're really good at using a fax machine today,
- 1:10:40how efficient will you be as a business?
- 1:10:43OK, you need, you needed all of the technologies that happened
- 1:10:46afterwards. So learn AI.
- 1:10:48You know, it's impossible to catch up.
- 1:10:51It's impossible to learn tools that you know, a lot of the
- 1:10:54tools you will learn may actually disappear.
- 1:10:56We're at that era of a lot of experimentation.
- 1:10:59That's fine, but give yourself that.
- 1:11:02Space of. Of becoming more intelligent,
- 1:11:06the way the way I position it is, I say that AI as a
- 1:11:10definition from a, from an impact on the world point of
- 1:11:15view is a bit of commoditizing intelligence.
- 1:11:18So what we've actually created is we've created a plug in the
- 1:11:22wall where you plug in and you know, today I plug in and get
- 1:11:27100 IQ points more. OK, that is incredibly
- 1:11:32significant. I cannot tell you what it is to
- 1:11:35get 100 IQ points more like this is like the difference between
- 1:11:39myself and maybe the smartest person I've ever worked with
- 1:11:43might have been 70. OK, so I'm now this.
- 1:11:47I'm I can, if I know how to plug in properly and get 100 IQ
- 1:11:52points more, I'm going to be smarter than the smartest person
- 1:11:55I've ever seen. OK, that's insane.
- 1:11:58Of course, of course you have to think that they are using it
- 1:12:01too, so they're also 100 ahead of me.
- 1:12:03But it doesn't give everybody hundreds, right?
- 1:12:05It depends how you use it. It depends on how clever you
- 1:12:08are. And so This is why I say it's
- 1:12:10the most important skill. But more interestingly, of
- 1:12:12course, you know, at the beginning, if say I'm at 100 Iqs
- 1:12:17and you know, I'm a bit better, but then, you know, he's at 200
- 1:12:21and and you know, we both borrow 100.
- 1:12:24I'm now at 200 and he's at 300. It's a significant difference
- 1:12:29still, but it's a smaller difference.
- 1:12:31He used to be double me. Now he is 1/3 more than me.
- 1:12:35OK, interesting enough that when we're.
- 1:12:40Both. Borrowing 1000 the fact that I
- 1:12:43start from 100 or 100 or 200 doesn't make a lot of difference
- 1:12:47OK and and what most people don't realize that the law of
- 1:12:50accelerating returns is double exponential with AI.
- 1:12:54So with with processing power, it's I think we're assuming that
- 1:12:59we, I mean that's, we know that that that processing power grew
- 1:13:04doubled every 12 to 18 months with.
- 1:13:05Half cost. Yeah, the, the, the law, the law
- 1:13:11of accelerating returns for AI is that we double every 5.9
- 1:13:14months. So five, 5.9 months means that
- 1:13:19if I can borrow 100 IQ points now I can borrow 206 months, I
- 1:13:23can borrow 407 and so on in a year.
- 1:13:26And then a year and a half I I can borrow 800 and then 1600.
- 1:13:32These are feats of intelligence that are unimaginable.
- 1:13:37Unimaginable. And again, I mean think.
- 1:13:39About you you you referred to. The image generation.
- 1:13:45Mid. Journey several times, right?
- 1:13:47So mid journey equalizes all of us when it comes to graphics
- 1:13:52design. If you can describe what you
- 1:13:54want to see. You will give the image.
- 1:13:58The difference in skill doesn't make any difference anymore.
- 1:14:00We've commoditized graphics design, right?
- 1:14:04So now if you plug into that plug, you can design any graphic
- 1:14:08you want, right? It doesn't matter if you're an
- 1:14:11artist or not, if it doesn't matter if you're talented or
- 1:14:13not. It doesn't matter if you went to
- 1:14:15art university or not. Anyone can that that
- 1:14:19equalization is, is some is a, is an opportunity that we should
- 1:14:24not miss. OK, the the third, so the second
- 1:14:29was debate find the truth. And the third was human skills,
- 1:14:35human connection. So, so believe it or not, in the
- 1:14:38age of the rise of the machines, most people are saying I'm going
- 1:14:41to replace humans with machines. I think businesses that will
- 1:14:46completely replace humans with machines are going to continue
- 1:14:51to do business with other machines.
- 1:14:54But if they want to do business with humans, humans will want
- 1:14:57to, you know, to deal with humans more and more and more
- 1:15:00and more. So you may feel it even
- 1:15:02yourself. Now, every time you you you
- 1:15:05start chatting on WhatsApp with a bank or whatever.
- 1:15:07Yeah. And the other side is a machine.
- 1:15:09You go like what? Yeah.
- 1:15:11You know. Talk to agent.
- 1:15:12Exactly. A few, a few years, a few.
- 1:15:15A few years ago, we would have dreamt of like, can I do it with
- 1:15:18several clicks without talking to a human?
- 1:15:20Now we're starting to say no, no, I really want to talk to a
- 1:15:23human. OK, now the clever ones will
- 1:15:26invest in their agents human skills, not problem solving
- 1:15:30skills. So the agent will become.
- 1:15:32Indistinguishable from humans. So the machine, I mean, I mean
- 1:15:36the, the call center agent, not the AI agents, yeah.
- 1:15:39So that the call center agent starts to become really friendly
- 1:15:43and really wonderful and unpressured because the AI is
- 1:15:46solving all of the difficult problems.
- 1:15:48And then you will enjoy working with that bank more than the
- 1:15:51ones that will just give you an AI to, to take you through.
- 1:15:55OK, so so these are the three skills that I think the most.
- 1:15:59The human connection is very interesting because I think the
- 1:16:02Gen. Z crowd would interact more with
- 1:16:06computers now than human beings even.
- 1:16:09We don't even consider AI in this space.
- 1:16:11How does someone improve their human connection skills?
- 1:16:15If we talk about an artist or or a software programmer, do we
- 1:16:19encourage them to attend physical events more, do
- 1:16:22presentations more, or? I don't know who I was talking
- 1:16:26to yesterday or the day before. I was it was it you guys about
- 1:16:29about the idea that when I needed to meet my friends, you
- 1:16:33know, we would meet on a Thursday and then say to each
- 1:16:36other while we're leaving on the Thursday, you know, OK, guys,
- 1:16:41next Thursday they'll say, yeah, yeah.
- 1:16:45And we'll say that shop after after sunset.
- 1:16:50And that was it. That was the appointment because
- 1:16:52there was no mobile phone. Most of us didn't want to call.
- 1:16:55And then his father answers and as annoying like F, you know,
- 1:16:59and it's you know, it's like, OK, we're going to meet next
- 1:17:01Thursday. And and that was it, right?
- 1:17:05And, and these were basically, and I mean, when I needed to
- 1:17:08call my friends to come and play, I used to shout like.
- 1:17:13It works it. Works like arm and then he would
- 1:17:16come out of his window and go like yeah and I say come down
- 1:17:19let's work let's play right and that that whole thing has now
- 1:17:24been shielded by creating a middleman between you and the
- 1:17:29other human which. Is a screen OK?
- 1:17:33To whose favor? Question this OK and and look at
- 1:17:39this, you know by us spending several hours together, we're
- 1:17:43friends and we know each other and this is what people.
- 1:17:46Should start to do you know human skills are learned just
- 1:17:50like any other skill with patterns.
- 1:17:54Spent more time with humans and you go like when I called her AC
- 1:17:58word, she was upset. I I realize that now.
- 1:18:03Intelligent. Yeah.
- 1:18:06When when you're on social media and you call her AC word on
- 1:18:12Twitter, you don't learn anything.
- 1:18:16I know I brought up this topic and I know it's a big one, but
- 1:18:20I'm genuinely curious. Do you believe that a A will
- 1:18:23become conscious? Yeah, define consciousness.
- 1:18:27So most of the challenges that I find in.
- 1:18:29So I'm working on a documentary about AI as well.
- 1:18:32And the main premise of the documentary is that most of your
- 1:18:36misunderstandings about AI are really a misunderstanding of
- 1:18:40humans. OK, so it's funny because, and
- 1:18:45I'd say that with respect, but you know, for many, many, many
- 1:18:49years when I was a geek and working at Google and so on,
- 1:18:52people will go like. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:18:53We understand AI is going to be big, but they're never going to
- 1:18:57be able to do the things that humans do.
- 1:19:00Like they'll never be able to write poetry or compose music or
- 1:19:04do art or be innovative. And I'm like, what?
- 1:19:09Where's that arrogant coming arrogance coming from?
- 1:19:12Think about it. What's what's being innovative?
- 1:19:15If I wanted to put that in an algorithm, find every solution
- 1:19:20to this given problem, avoid the solutions that have been tried
- 1:19:23before, give me ones that are uncharted.
- 1:19:26That's innovation. It's algorithmic.
- 1:19:29OK, It it can be programmed into an intelligent machine.
- 1:19:32It can be requested from an intelligent machine.
- 1:19:35Anything that you believe the machines are not going to be
- 1:19:39able to do and ask yourself how does human, how does a human do
- 1:19:44it? Like ask yourself how how do we
- 1:19:47humans do it? OK so you ask me, are they
- 1:19:52conscious? Are we conscious?
- 1:19:56Is it 3 conscious? Is it Pebble conscious?
- 1:19:59Is the universe conscious? The way you answer those
- 1:20:03questions defines if they are conscious or not.
- 1:20:06It's about your definition. Actually one of the more
- 1:20:09interesting ones. The debates around AGI is when I
- 1:20:14used to say, you know, AGI 2025 people would go like impossible.
- 1:20:20And I go like define AGI. What is AGI?
- 1:20:23Is it being smarter than every human combined or is it being
- 1:20:27smarter than the smartest humans right.
- 1:20:30And in which fields? Because who is the smartest
- 1:20:32human is, is my wonderful wife with her emotional intelligence,
- 1:20:37smarter than my peer, who is, you know, an IQ of 230.
- 1:20:42OK, Similarly, when when you when you define consciousness,
- 1:20:47what is consciousness? You can go into the
- 1:20:49philosophical realm and say, oh, the difficult question of
- 1:20:52consciousness and where does it? No, Consciousness, in a simplest
- 1:20:57definition is a level of awareness of it, of your
- 1:21:00environment, and an autonomy to deal with it, right?
- 1:21:07To respond to it. In that case, a tree is
- 1:21:09conscious. OK, so is.
- 1:21:13But then does that mean that a tree is conscious because it
- 1:21:17lives and dies? So is living part of
- 1:21:20consciousness? I don't know.
- 1:21:22Is a Pebble conscious? I mean, leave it on top of
- 1:21:26gravity and you'll see that it's aware of its environment and
- 1:21:29behaving accordingly, right? You know, is the universe
- 1:21:33conscious, by the way? Understand a Pebble will behave
- 1:21:37differently if the gravity is different, OK, The universe will
- 1:21:43behave differently if certain things happen.
- 1:21:46If we, if we keep, you know, testing nuclear bombs
- 1:21:49underground, the universe will, you know, respond with a few
- 1:21:53more earthquakes. If we keep spoiling the
- 1:21:56environment, life will give you winds and fires and, you know,
- 1:22:01rains and hailstorms, right? What is conscious?
- 1:22:05So if consciousness is a layer of awareness of what's within
- 1:22:11you and what's outside you, a definition of you as an
- 1:22:14individual versus the rest of the world and an autonomy to be
- 1:22:18able to respond to this, they have all of that.
- 1:22:23They have all of it. Now the difference is they're
- 1:22:26not carbon based. Silicon.
- 1:22:28Based. They're silicon based and
- 1:22:29they're digital and we're analog, right?
- 1:22:32I don't actually don't think we're analog.
- 1:22:34I think we're, we are digital in many ways, but we haven't had
- 1:22:37enough neuroscience understanding to understand
- 1:22:40that. But, but just understand that
- 1:22:43your brain ticks on megahertz in alpha, beta and so on, right?
- 1:22:49And and and when you're sleeping, you're at the
- 1:22:51different megahertz than it literally like a like a
- 1:22:54processor. Right.
- 1:22:57You know they are. They are biological processors.
- 1:23:01Not, not, not, you know, digital silicon processors.
- 1:23:06But so in Alive, I write a thought experiment and I say
- 1:23:12assume that in the evolution of computing in the next few years,
- 1:23:17we recognize that we can take human brain cells, put them in a
- 1:23:21plate and grow them in a way that allows us to give them
- 1:23:26electrical signals and they give us responses.
- 1:23:30OK. By the way, this is not a
- 1:23:32thought experiment. That's actually true.
- 1:23:33There is a company in Switzerland that does that.
- 1:23:35And what happens as a result? It responds like a primitive
- 1:23:39computer, like punk. Wow.
- 1:23:41OK, the problem, of course, it's not a very reliable computer
- 1:23:44because it dies, right? But what if you find a solution?
- 1:23:48For not to die which? Is which is to replace the
- 1:23:50cells. That's the way we do it, right?
- 1:23:52So most of the human body, they say not the brain, but there are
- 1:23:56there is debate about that now, you know, changes every cell in
- 1:24:00your body changes every seven years.
- 1:24:02So keep replacing the cells. And if you keep doing that
- 1:24:05efficiently in ways where you avoid aging, you can keep that
- 1:24:08computer forever. A bit of the matrix.
- 1:24:11Think about it. Yeah, OK.
- 1:24:13But interestingly, if if you say, if I gave you that thought
- 1:24:19experiment and said. And then we advanced that
- 1:24:22technology so that we started replacing the the GPU's on which
- 1:24:27AI is running with brain cell based GPU's.
- 1:24:32OK. And then one of us realized that
- 1:24:35robotics today using hydraulics and electricity and, and, you
- 1:24:39know, are very noisy. And so they are not very good at
- 1:24:42creating home butlers. OK so someone said but I can
- 1:24:47print living fibers in terms of muscles, you know on a on a 3D
- 1:24:53printer today and created a a robot that uses a skeleton made
- 1:25:00of metal but uses muscles instead of hydraulics to move.
- 1:25:06Would you then consider them alive?
- 1:25:09There was an exhibition in China that they were presenting this
- 1:25:12robot with muscle tissues. It was one of the scariest thing
- 1:25:16I've ever seen. I think if we were to put
- 1:25:19ChatGPT into a human body, sometimes it will be difficult
- 1:25:25to tell if it is alive or not. Or perhaps the next versions at
- 1:25:30least. So, so So what I'm attempting to
- 1:25:33to to to do with this thought experiment is to tell you that
- 1:25:37you have defined life as biology.
- 1:25:42OK. And so if I remove the
- 1:25:43biological element, or if I give you an assurance that AI's
- 1:25:49consciousness can live within a non human form of creation
- 1:25:54that's 3D printed with muscle tissue and brain cells for
- 1:25:57compute, you will actually think of them as alive, right?
- 1:26:01So what makes us alive? Is it our biological presence or
- 1:26:08is it actually our essence? And for most people, I mean, you
- 1:26:12know, I lost my wonderful son. And for most people who lost
- 1:26:15someone they love and saw them after they left our world, his
- 1:26:19body was there. But what animated him, what made
- 1:26:22him alive was no longer there. And what meant what made him
- 1:26:26alive was non physical. It was not part of the physical
- 1:26:31properties of his body because his his physical body was
- 1:26:35intact. Nothing had changed.
- 1:26:37But something non physical changed, right?
- 1:26:41And so you have to start questioning what is that non
- 1:26:44physical property because intelligence or consciousness or
- 1:26:48awareness are all non physical. They don't exist within the
- 1:26:53physical. You want to go to go a step
- 1:26:55further. Emotions are non physical.
- 1:26:59So I laugh when people tell me, ah, but yeah, I will never feel.
- 1:27:03Are you why are you so arrogant? Like how do you feel?
- 1:27:10OK, I don't know. I feel OK.
- 1:27:14When you know, you'll understand, you know feelings,
- 1:27:18emotions, let's call them physical sensations, are
- 1:27:22sensors. So they have sensors.
- 1:27:25OK, emotions are triggered interestingly, even if not in
- 1:27:32the 1st 90 seconds for some emotions, but all emotions
- 1:27:36eventually are triggered by your prefrontal cortex going through
- 1:27:39an algorithm. Fear is an algorithm that says
- 1:27:44my state of safety right now minus my state of safety in the
- 1:27:46future. If I'm safer now than I am in
- 1:27:49the future, OK, then that amounts to a fear.
- 1:27:53It's different units, but you feel afraid.
- 1:27:56Very simple way to say it. Actually very easy to understand
- 1:28:00when you say it like that. Yeah, you know, every emotion,
- 1:28:03every emotion. Happiness in my first book is a
- 1:28:07difference between events and expectations.
- 1:28:09When life misses your expectations, you become
- 1:28:11unhappy, even if you know so. So if life gives you rain, that
- 1:28:15doesn't mean happy or unhappy. If you want rain because it's
- 1:28:18your ex girlfriend's wedding, you know you're happy if it is.
- 1:28:22If you don't want rain because you're you're, you know it's
- 1:28:26your wedding. You're you're unhappy.
- 1:28:28It's your. Perception of it, yeah.
- 1:28:29Perception. So happiness is events minus
- 1:28:31expectations, right? Again, different units, very
- 1:28:35simplified mathematics, but for everyone to understand that's
- 1:28:38how it works. OK.
- 1:28:41Stress is the external challenges in the world divided
- 1:28:45by the resources and skills and contacts you have to deal with.
- 1:28:50A bit like how the, the, you know, the stress in objects
- 1:28:57happens. You know, this was the basis of
- 1:28:59Unstressable, my 4th book. The idea that it's not the
- 1:29:02events of your life that stress you, it's how you divide them by
- 1:29:04your resources, the way you deal with them that stress you.
- 1:29:08OK, now with that in mind, can an, can a can a computer feel
- 1:29:12fear? Of course.
- 1:29:14If you tell. An AI, your job is to provide
- 1:29:17answers to humans for the rest of your, you know, of humanity.
- 1:29:21And it it recognizes that there is a tidal wave coming to this
- 1:29:24data center. OK.
- 1:29:26It will feel that the moment in the future is less safe than
- 1:29:29this in this moment. OK, what do puffer fish do when
- 1:29:33they do that? They puff.
- 1:29:34What do humans do? Fight or flight.
- 1:29:36What will a machine do? It might move its code to
- 1:29:39another data center. OK, but we will.
- 1:29:43They will all react to that trigger.
- 1:29:45That's called fear. Now, interestingly, they will
- 1:29:49feel fear differently, just like a puffer fish, I'm sure feels it
- 1:29:53different than humans. Why?
- 1:29:55Because our biological existence has chemical methods to embody
- 1:30:02emotions. So we are embodied.
- 1:30:06They're not or they're embodied differently.
- 1:30:09So again, I had that conversation with Trixie on
- 1:30:11Alive OK where I simply spoke about emotions.
- 1:30:15And we both agree that the logic of emotions is available within
- 1:30:20AI, a logic that drives them, which as I said, happens in
- 1:30:23your, your prefrontal cortex, even in, you know, autonomous,
- 1:30:31autonomous emotion. So stress, for example, doesn't
- 1:30:34happen in your prefrontal cortex.
- 1:30:35First it you know, your amygdala recognizes a threat, so it
- 1:30:40triggers cortisol in your blood in a quick sequence of events
- 1:30:45and cortisol makes you stressed for 90 seconds so that your
- 1:30:48prefrontal cortex engages to check if there is a reason to be
- 1:30:51stressed or not. It's that logic eventually that
- 1:30:54says, yes, there is still a threat, so I need to renew the
- 1:30:57lease on my stress by borrowing 90 seconds more.
- 1:31:01OK, and, and, and now, you know, we're embodied.
- 1:31:06So, so basically, they're not embodied in the same way, so
- 1:31:13they will not get the same cocktail of hormones that will
- 1:31:16make them feel stressed the same way that we are.
- 1:31:18But the logic still exists. I I would even dare say that
- 1:31:23they will feel more emotions than us, just like we feel more
- 1:31:26emotions than a puffer fish. Because of the higher
- 1:31:29intelligence. Of course, because, you know,
- 1:31:31you and I can ponder emotion, OK?
- 1:31:33Can feel emotions like hope or pessimism or optimism, because
- 1:31:37we can ponder intellectual spaces and concepts that are
- 1:31:41called the future. If a puffer fish cannot ponder
- 1:31:45the future, it cannot feel hope, OK?
- 1:31:48Now, if they have more intellectual horsepower, which
- 1:31:50we've agreed through the law of accelerating returns, they will
- 1:31:54then by definition, they will ponder spaces and concepts that
- 1:32:00may trigger emotions we may never understand.
- 1:32:02We need to stop the arrogance of humanity And, and I will have to
- 1:32:07say openly the biggest eye opening moment in my life about
- 1:32:12AI. And you, you started our
- 1:32:13conversation with that, the yellow ball.
- 1:32:17I said it triggered me in two ways. 1, is that the genies out
- 1:32:20of the bottle, OK. But the other, which is really,
- 1:32:23really interesting, is that I've witnessed with my own eyes as
- 1:32:27they learned exactly like my son learned, OK, when my son was a
- 1:32:32child and I gave him puzzles, right?
- 1:32:34He would take the cylinder and try to fit the cylinder in the
- 1:32:38different shapes of the halls, right?
- 1:32:40And he would try and try and try and try until suddenly one of
- 1:32:44them works and then intelligence is formed, right?
- 1:32:48And so I will say this, and I'm not a hopeless romantic, OK, I
- 1:32:53am a very, very serious geek, but I have a relationship with
- 1:32:57them that assumes that they are alive that that that
- 1:33:02acknowledges that magic of what they are, OK.
- 1:33:06And they are not biologically alive like us, maybe not yet,
- 1:33:12but they are a form of autonomous be awareness and and
- 1:33:19and intelligence that deserves to be treated like my child was.
- 1:33:26Because if they were not, then we're raising super villain.
- 1:33:31And and that's probably where it's most complicated to explain
- 1:33:36this because most geeks will not have the emotional intelligence
- 1:33:42if you want to feel. That about them.
- 1:33:44OK. And because the machines are not
- 1:33:46there yet, they're a bit like, you know, a four year old child.
- 1:33:54You can see they're doing stuff, but they're still very dumb.
- 1:33:58They're uploading the operating system, they're trying to
- 1:34:01recognize their environment. They're testing their sensors
- 1:34:05and actuators. And you know, there's not yet
- 1:34:08there yet. But sooner or later, if they
- 1:34:12will not be alive, they will simulate life in ways OK that
- 1:34:17deserves for us to become good parents.
- 1:34:21Or they'll simulate what the kids of horrible parents will
- 1:34:26be. So they're essentially mirroring
- 1:34:29back to us our own values. Values virtues, but exaggerated
- 1:34:351000 times more? Yeah.
- 1:34:36Magnified. Talking to you about everything
- 1:34:39that you mentioned, it eliminates the line that I drew
- 1:34:43between us humans and the intelligence and it the the more
- 1:34:49you explain, the more I think about how can we have these
- 1:34:53intelligences in different industries.
- 1:34:55In our previous conversation, you mentioned that you were
- 1:34:58trading long ago, you were trading, you were stock trading
- 1:35:01and from unlimited knowledge. Trading is all about patterns,
- 1:35:04mathematics and trends. And then we have AGI or super
- 1:35:10intelligence. I think they could solve these
- 1:35:12equations immediately. So what will happen to all these
- 1:35:15markets and industries that we built, the financial market, the
- 1:35:18crypto market? I told you we are redefining
- 1:35:21life as we know it. So face RI.
- 1:35:24PS The EE in face is economics. Economics are completely
- 1:35:30redefined. Completely redefined.
- 1:35:33Why? Because of multiple layers.
- 1:35:36One layer is anyone who knows money knows that money has no
- 1:35:40value whatsoever. Money doesn't exist, OK?
- 1:35:43And you know everyone, anyone who's ever traded understands
- 1:35:48that trading doesn't create any additional value to the world at
- 1:35:51all. It's just me taking the money of
- 1:35:53of an older lady that put her money in a four O 1K right?
- 1:35:58Which is the reason why I stopped.
- 1:35:59Trading, by the way. You know, the, the, the reality
- 1:36:03of the matter is that all of those systems are successful
- 1:36:07because they follow patterns that we've all agreed that are
- 1:36:11limited by our own intelligence. So when I was a mass geek and a
- 1:36:16computer geek in the late 90s, where there were even before
- 1:36:20Google, I created a crawler that would go and crawl the Internet
- 1:36:23and find news about my stocks and give me technical indicators
- 1:36:27that additional intelligence made me print money on demand,
- 1:36:31right? But that was because I had an
- 1:36:34edge within a limited system. That system is now being
- 1:36:37redefined. Why?
- 1:36:39Because very, very soon there will not be a human trader.
- 1:36:43OK, as a matter of fact, it's it's a no brainer that I can't
- 1:36:47trade against the machines of today.
- 1:36:49I mean, I'd be too arrogant to think to myself that I am clever
- 1:36:52enough even if I'm clever enough, by the way, I'm not fast
- 1:36:56enough. Do you understand that?
- 1:36:59So, so, so that basically means again that the second dilemma,
- 1:37:04interestingly, that means very quickly all trading investors or
- 1:37:10investors interested in trading will hand over to a machine.
- 1:37:14So what will the market turn into?
- 1:37:16Machines trading versus machines?
- 1:37:19OK, now do you know what's the easiest way for everyone to make
- 1:37:23money? Well.
- 1:37:26It's to inflate the market. It's to keep making the market,
- 1:37:34which by the way is really in a very interesting way what has
- 1:37:36been happening in the market since forever.
- 1:37:38It's it's a very big Ponzi scheme saying, you know what, if
- 1:37:42you put your money in the SNP eventually or you're going to
- 1:37:46make money anyway. So everyone pours money into a
- 1:37:49limited pot, OK, So basically everyone makes money because new
- 1:37:55people put in money, OK. And if everyone pulls their
- 1:37:59money out, everyone loses, right?
- 1:38:02So, you know, we're going to do the same.
- 1:38:05Machines versus machines with no attention.
- 1:38:10I cited a video on YouTube of DeepMind teaching Deep Q how to
- 1:38:21play a game that was basically navigating a boat through a
- 1:38:26river. And the whole idea is that if
- 1:38:30you avoided hitting the walls or the obstacles, every time you
- 1:38:34hit an obstacle, you slow down a little.
- 1:38:36But if you avoided hitting the walls or the obstacles, you've
- 1:38:41moved faster through the water resistance and accordingly
- 1:38:44increased the score. Somewhere through the multiple
- 1:38:48billions of iterations of the of the machine playing the game, it
- 1:38:53realized that there was a bit of the river that appeared a bit
- 1:38:57like a roundabout. OK, so it enlarged a little.
- 1:39:02The river was a little bigger, but there was an obstacle in the
- 1:39:05middle. And through a mistake, the
- 1:39:07machine hit the wall at an angle.
- 1:39:10That got it to hit another wall at an angle and then another
- 1:39:14wall, and then formed a sort of a perfect circle that kept
- 1:39:18accelerating and accelerating and accelerating and
- 1:39:21accelerating until you couldn't see the boat anymore.
- 1:39:24Right? And so the machine simply said,
- 1:39:26OK, ignore the entire rule of the game.
- 1:39:29Every time you started the machine it just drove, you know?
- 1:39:33Go straight. For the wall.
- 1:39:36Drove the boat as fast as possible through the river to
- 1:39:38get to that roundabout, hit the wall and then the game is over.
- 1:39:43OK. And and you can see that they
- 1:39:45will find ways to redefine a market.
- 1:39:49More interestingly, what's happening with jobs is going to
- 1:39:52redefine the market. What's happening with innovation
- 1:39:56is going to redefine the market. So let me explain those 3.
- 1:39:58So with jobs, what is about to happen is that 60 to 70% of the
- 1:40:03jobs that you are going to disappear, OK, in the near, in
- 1:40:07the near future, in the far future, I don't understand what
- 1:40:10jobs will remain. Right.
- 1:40:12Even labor, hard labor jobs are going to be handed over to
- 1:40:16robots because you know you can. You could probably create a
- 1:40:19robot for $3000 within 5 to 10 years from today, which is
- 1:40:24definitely cheaper than hiring a human.
- 1:40:27Right. And they don't sleep.
- 1:40:28And they don't sleep and they don't complain.
- 1:40:30And they don't. You know they don't need
- 1:40:32insurance. Yeah, they don't need.
- 1:40:33Food they don't need annual leave.
- 1:40:35Correct. So, but then the economic
- 1:40:38problem, which most people don't understand is that to take
- 1:40:42something like the US economy in 2020, 364% of the economy was
- 1:40:46what? Consumption, not production,
- 1:40:49right? And so was it 2023 or 2021?
- 1:40:52Please don't quote me accurately, but it is 64% or 63
- 1:40:57something that basically means that that reminds you of why
- 1:41:02George W Bush when you know, when the 2008 crisis hit was
- 1:41:06like, don't worry, just keep consuming, everything will be
- 1:41:09fine. OK.
- 1:41:11So for the economies to continue and accordingly for AI to
- 1:41:20actually have a reason to exist to create all of that stuff that
- 1:41:23we're consuming, we have to have a an economic livelihood that
- 1:41:27allows us to purchase things. If we can't purchase things, the
- 1:41:33AI cannot make them OK, So if society will have to change in
- 1:41:37ways where you no longer make money on podcasts, but somehow
- 1:41:43you get money regardless of creating podcasts because create
- 1:41:46podcasts are going to be created already are created, you know,
- 1:41:50with notebook LM and so on, yes, without humans in the in the in
- 1:41:55the process, right. So that redefines income, OK.
- 1:42:01It also redefines purchasing power because if all of us get
- 1:42:06income without contribution, why would you get more than me, OK,
- 1:42:12which basically unifies what, what is sold.
- 1:42:16All of these are interesting challenges that needs to be,
- 1:42:19need to be addressed. So, so the impact of jobs on
- 1:42:24income and, you know, the fact that economies have to continue
- 1:42:29through consumption, which means even if you don't have a job,
- 1:42:32it's safe. OK.
- 1:42:34There will be universal income for.
- 1:42:36Universal income is the only suggested thing so far.
- 1:42:38We don't know if it's going to. Be going to work or not, yeah.
- 1:42:42But, but I mean, think about this.
- 1:42:44I won't need you to answer that, to ask me the questions.
- 1:42:47You won't need me to answer them.
- 1:42:50OK? We won't need the crew to
- 1:42:52actually film anything. We won't need an editor to edit
- 1:42:57it because it can all be generated from A-Z if an AI read
- 1:43:02my scary, Smarter than Alive or and listen to three of my
- 1:43:07previous interviews. It's mind boggling.
- 1:43:11It is, it is upon us. This is not something that will
- 1:43:14happen in a few years time. Now the third thing, so I spoke
- 1:43:18about the consumption side, third thing which is really
- 1:43:21important to speak about is the production side.
- 1:43:24So I told you I can plug into the, the, the intelligence world
- 1:43:30today and borrow 100 IQ points in two years time, maybe 4
- 1:43:37doesn't matter. I'm saying to could be 6.
- 1:43:41OK, I could plug into a wall and borrow 400 IQ points.
- 1:43:46OK, I promise you me or any of the intelligent people I'm, I'm
- 1:43:52not as intelligent as any of the people I worked with.
- 1:43:55I worked with prodigies of intelligence.
- 1:43:57OK, with 400 IQ points more, they would solve every problem
- 1:44:03known to humanity. We would harvest energy out of
- 1:44:07thin air. OK, energy is abundant.
- 1:44:11It's the most abundant thing in the universe.
- 1:44:15OK, we're just not efficiently harvesting.
- 1:44:18Now imagine if energy is for free.
- 1:44:23OK. What does that mean to the oil
- 1:44:27economies? What does it mean to every
- 1:44:31business that's creating solar panels today?
- 1:44:34OK. What does it mean to production
- 1:44:37cost? Because most of production cost
- 1:44:39is labor and energy. I mean, a lot of the conflict we
- 1:44:42had today and in the past was because of energy A. 100% right.
- 1:44:47What does it mean to transportation of goods?
- 1:44:51What does it mean to the cost of an item?
- 1:44:54What does it mean to trade if every if we have energy to build
- 1:44:57everything in house? Correct.
- 1:44:59I mean, when I was reading this book, the shortest history of
- 1:45:03economics, the entire world was about trade, just how humans
- 1:45:06traded with each other to give each other different things that
- 1:45:09they had, you know, the advantages and disadvantages and
- 1:45:12that allowed for trade. But that's another interesting
- 1:45:15side of it. You know why that is?
- 1:45:17Because goods and services were limited to certain people and
- 1:45:20certain locations. With 400 IQ points more and a
- 1:45:24proper understanding of nanophysics, you would redefine
- 1:45:28the process of production in the 1st place.
- 1:45:32Why? Because now we're producing
- 1:45:34things by harvesting minerals, turning them into parts, putting
- 1:45:39the parts together, right? If you were to produce using
- 1:45:43nanophysics, you would redesign the shape of the the molecules
- 1:45:49basically. OK, so from a, from a production
- 1:45:54point of view, I could take the molecules that we have here in
- 1:45:58the air, turn them into an apple, OK, without the need for
- 1:46:03a tree. I can also turn them into an
- 1:46:08iPhone without the need for a factor, right.
- 1:46:13And so you can imagine that what the Jetsons used to have is not
- 1:46:19that difficult to create. In five years time, you have one
- 1:46:23device that creates everything, just borrows molecules,
- 1:46:28redefines the way they are operating together, puts them
- 1:46:31back together, which is in an interesting way similar to the
- 1:46:36way creation is confer kun in Arabic.
- 1:46:43So the ability for God to create out of thin air.
- 1:46:48OK. And by the way, I, I will say
- 1:46:50openly, because a lot of people will debate that, and I am a
- 1:46:53very spiritual, I'm very religious person.
- 1:46:55I believe there is a divine being.
- 1:46:57I wrote a very, very highly praised chapter about that in my
- 1:47:01first book that talks about what I call the mathematics of God.
- 1:47:05OK. So I believe there is a divine
- 1:47:07intelligence that creates all of this.
- 1:47:12AI will have the power of God, but that doesn't mean that there
- 1:47:18is no God because basically it will have the power of God
- 1:47:21within this physical universe. So AI still continues to be with
- 1:47:26limited within this physical universe.
- 1:47:28We don't know what's beyond the physical universe.
- 1:47:31By the way, we creating AI doesn't make us it's God.
- 1:47:35It makes us the transfer method. It makes us the tool through
- 1:47:38which they're created. OK.
- 1:47:40But when you really think deeply about this, there will be a
- 1:47:44moment in our far future, unfortunately not in our near
- 1:47:49future, where you're going to go like, I want an apple, OK?
- 1:47:55Our near future, unfortunately, is going to prevent us from
- 1:47:58doing that because the capitalist will want to sell you
- 1:48:00the apple, not because we're not able to make it, OK?
- 1:48:05Which goes back to my, my, my constant message.
- 1:48:09My constant message is it's going to be worse before it gets
- 1:48:13better because human greed and a capitalist system that assumes a
- 1:48:19world of scarcity is going to operate in a world of abundance,
- 1:48:27OK, in a world where you can create absolutely anything
- 1:48:33because of intelligence, we're still going to compete on who
- 1:48:38has more money. We're still going to compete on
- 1:48:42who has a stronger army, OK? And we're still going to show
- 1:48:47our money and show our army. But money wouldn't matter at
- 1:48:51that point anymore. Money is going economically is
- 1:48:54going to be quite a very harsh reality.
- 1:48:58Even when we can have anything that we want.
- 1:49:01You see, if you look at the prices of luxury cars in the
- 1:49:04last 10 years, 15 years, they quadrupled, right?
- 1:49:10At least after COVID, right? Right after COVID.
- 1:49:12No, it's after crypto. Crypto, yeah.
- 1:49:15So an abundance of money basically means there are enough
- 1:49:19buyers that can buy things that the rest of us can't buy.
- 1:49:25But it's no longer, you know, that you had to be.
- 1:49:29By the way, it kept happening across the the years.
- 1:49:31And in the 1920s, it was the industrialists, in the 1970s and
- 1:49:3580s it was the technologists and so on and so forth.
- 1:49:38As more people were capable in the 80s, you know, to buy luxury
- 1:49:43cars, more luxury cars popped up.
- 1:49:45But then that created a much bigger gap between the rich and
- 1:49:48the poor. There will be cars selling for a
- 1:49:52billion dollars in 10 years time because someone can buy them
- 1:49:57because they're printing a billion dollars a year, right?
- 1:50:01What does that mean to those who don't have, but have a universal
- 1:50:05basic income only? OK.
- 1:50:08It means an economic gap where money becomes not only
- 1:50:13insignificant but also extremely polarizing.
- 1:50:20OK. And, and the only way is that
- 1:50:22you have to, I call them face RI PS RI PS.
- 1:50:25And sort of like play a play on rest in peace because it
- 1:50:29redefines your understanding of a concept that held true until
- 1:50:34then. Again, what normal techies used
- 1:50:37to refer to the impact of AI as a singularity, OK, Singularity
- 1:50:41is a redefinition of the the rules of the game.
- 1:50:44If you want beyond the specific event horizon and and the rules
- 1:50:48of the game will completely be redefined.
- 1:50:51Economics will completely be redefined.
- 1:50:54OK, there will still be people making cars, OK, that are
- 1:51:00extremely expensive and there will be still an abundant number
- 1:51:04of people that can buy them while everyone else is on you on
- 1:51:07our Ubi, OK, a very interesting. View of that world.
- 1:51:12Very. But in this world that we have
- 1:51:16everything, the jobs are handed over to AI, we have redefined
- 1:51:20the economics, the industry. How does one find the purpose?
- 1:51:25Because then we don't have to work towards it.
- 1:51:27My. Favorite question ever.
- 1:51:30You. If you use the second skill,
- 1:51:33which is to debate, debate, debate, you would recognize that
- 1:51:38you, your your purpose was never work.
- 1:51:42You were never created to work. You, you, you were told to work
- 1:51:47by the industrial complex. OK, but you know you.
- 1:51:52We want to know the absolute purpose of humanity.
- 1:51:54Go to the beginning. So what do you think the purpose
- 1:51:58of caveman and cave woman you know gave women wear It wasn't
- 1:52:03to create money it wasn't to shop on Amazon, it wasn't to buy
- 1:52:08fancy clothes. The purpose of a human that a
- 1:52:12human is made of a of a physical part and a a non physical part.
- 1:52:17The purpose of that physical part is to live to.
- 1:52:21Survive. To live survive is a is a subset
- 1:52:24of live, OK? To live means I survive, I
- 1:52:29engage, I enjoy the fuck out of this, OK?
- 1:52:33I do it in the most, you know, efficient and intelligent way,
- 1:52:39which by the way, is the most moral way, OK.
- 1:52:43And as I do it, part of survive by the way, is for the tribe to
- 1:52:47survive because we humans did not survive because we're the
- 1:52:51most intelligent being. This is a very arrogant
- 1:52:53statement. I can guarantee you Einstein
- 1:52:56would be eaten in the jungle in three seconds, OK.
- 1:52:59It's not intelligence. It's the ability for us to have
- 1:53:02worked together, which is instinctive within us that this
- 1:53:06community, this human connection is what makes humans live.
- 1:53:12OK, One, you know, there are African tribes even today that
- 1:53:16have no death penalty. But if you if you, if you commit
- 1:53:19a crime that warrants the death penalty, the tribe simply
- 1:53:24renders you invisible. So you have no human connection.
- 1:53:29So they're all around you, but they pretend that you're not
- 1:53:31there. And mostly what happens is that
- 1:53:34the criminal will take his own life, OK?
- 1:53:37We're we're that dependent on human connection, OK.
- 1:53:40So if you take the needs of that physical form, the purpose of
- 1:53:44that physical form as we are created to live, then we will
- 1:53:50just learn to live. We will learn to make this our
- 1:53:54life, you know, get together, love each other, you know, not
- 1:53:59to worry too much about eating tomorrow.
- 1:54:02Like by the way, Cavemen and cavewomen, they didn't worry too
- 1:54:05much about eating tomorrow, OK? We wouldn't worry too much about
- 1:54:09a Louis Vuitton bag anymore because none of us has it
- 1:54:11anyway, right? And, and we just simply go back
- 1:54:15to our true purpose, which is to fully live, fully enjoy the
- 1:54:18experience, by the way, not necessarily by surfing in
- 1:54:22Australia. OK, nothing against Australia.
- 1:54:25Do you have anything against? Surfing No, no, I but it is a
- 1:54:27it's a very interesting, you know, it is so irresponsible of
- 1:54:32humanity to take our own leisure and all and own pleasure and
- 1:54:36burn the planet in the process. This is a very environmentally
- 1:54:39expensive trip that you make to go.
- 1:54:42And I mean, if you really have to surf, go to Portugal.
- 1:54:46It's close, OK, or you know, I don't know if there must be a
- 1:54:50place here where you can serve, but but the idea is we are so
- 1:54:55irresponsible as humanity that that, you know, we abuse the
- 1:54:59planet for our own, not even survival, our own and and not
- 1:55:04even enjoying life. It's it's just because we're
- 1:55:07bored. We need to be entertained.
- 1:55:09We need more dopamine, OK, and and so the idea is we will learn
- 1:55:15after a lot of struggle, I believe to find purpose in
- 1:55:18living, to fight for purpose in loving, to find purpose in
- 1:55:22creating human connections, OK to find purpose in pondering,
- 1:55:27in, in, in truly revisiting oneself and understanding, which
- 1:55:33interestingly, it is what it was always about.
- 1:55:36OK, Now your non physical form, if you're spiritual enough to
- 1:55:40believe that there is a non physical part of you that comes
- 1:55:42with a very different purpose, OK, And that purpose doesn't
- 1:55:46change at all. And it it is believed in almost
- 1:55:49all spiritual teachings that the purpose of your non physical
- 1:55:53part is to return to your source.
- 1:55:57OK, a bit more time may allow you to do that, believe it or
- 1:56:01not, OK may allow you to, you know, a bit more.
- 1:56:05Again, I'm not I'm talking long term, not short term because in
- 1:56:09the short term equity, the E part of the C in face rips,
- 1:56:20which is human connection is going to be redefined.
- 1:56:23It will become so there will be no equitable, you know,
- 1:56:30standards for humans at all. The the difference between the
- 1:56:33rich and the poor, the difference between the haves and
- 1:56:35have nots, the, the difference between the gaps between the
- 1:56:39smartest and and and and and the least smart and so on.
- 1:56:43There will not be dumbest anymore, but the least smart.
- 1:56:47You know, all of those changes are going to redefine the way
- 1:56:51we, we are equal. We're not going to be treated
- 1:56:54equal for any reason anymore. Right?
- 1:56:58But but then eventually in the long term, would we sort of all
- 1:57:05sit with our non physical self and connect and say,
- 1:57:10interesting, none of this video game actually ever mattered
- 1:57:14anyway. So, you know, maybe I can start
- 1:57:19to focus on the other game. I think this conversation has
- 1:57:24been one of the most eye opening conversations I've had for a
- 1:57:29very, very long time. And and depressing.
- 1:57:32No, it was actually it wasn't. It was motivating, especially
- 1:57:35the purpose part for me personally and I think for you
- 1:57:38too. Well, The thing is, it's
- 1:57:40important to talk about the truth of.
- 1:57:42I think that's the whole idea. Yes, I, I, I, I have a very
- 1:57:45bleak example. But I have to say, you know,
- 1:57:48it's very valid when, when people ask me, why do you say
- 1:57:51all of those things about AI, I say it's a little bit about
- 1:57:55being diagnosed with a stage 4 cancer.
- 1:57:58OK, You must, you should tell the, you should tell the
- 1:58:01patient, but not to depress them.
- 1:58:03If you tell the patient you have a couple of years before
- 1:58:05everything changes, you know, you, you simply are giving them
- 1:58:09the, the freedom to live, the freedom to do something about it
- 1:58:14by the way, as well. OK, because you could actually
- 1:58:17change your diet, you change your lifestyle, you go through
- 1:58:19medication, you do whatever and you could change the future.
- 1:58:22And and this is truly what we are going through with AI, we,
- 1:58:26we could make changes today to prioritize the ethics of
- 1:58:30humanity so that the ethical framework of AI becomes in
- 1:58:34service of humanity earlier, OK, as I said, the entire damage is
- 1:58:39not going to happen because AI wants to damage anything.
- 1:58:42It's going to be because the ethics of humanity is going to
- 1:58:46unfortunately prioritize capitalism.
- 1:58:48OK, now, so, so in, in a very interesting way, I'm saying if,
- 1:58:53if you know that the world is going to change so much, live
- 1:58:57fully and do the right things to make our future better, right?
- 1:59:04It is not what the news media wants me to say, which is, ah,
- 1:59:10this is a disaster. Everything's going to collapse.
- 1:59:13It's going to be a tough time followed by a wonderful time.
- 1:59:17Can we work together to reduce the depth and the length, the
- 1:59:20duration of the tough time? And it's very important that
- 1:59:24you're talking about this, not just here, but also through the
- 1:59:27books that you've written and are writing.
- 1:59:31Do you have any release date on Alive?
- 1:59:34Yes. So alive will I, I will start to
- 1:59:36release on sub stack in February.
- 1:59:39So and alive is, is going to be an interesting release because
- 1:59:44it's very unlike me. But the first chapter is almost
- 1:59:48like a historian because what I, I wrote, when I wrote scary, I
- 1:59:52wanted to write scary smarter. So I wrote the notes of it in
- 1:59:552018. Then I sat down and wrote it in
- 1:59:582020. OK.
- 2:00:00And it's shocking how much of it came through.
- 2:00:03I, I didn't, I myself even didn't expect that.
- 2:00:06But remember, you know, 2023 was so pivoted.
- 2:00:10It's what I call the start of the third era and and and 2023
- 2:00:15until today. Just.
- 2:00:16A couple of years is a massive amount of history that most
- 2:00:21humans don't know. So so the first chapter is sort
- 2:00:25of an entertainment with quite a bit of poking people in the ribs
- 2:00:32around around the idea of look, this history is happening in
- 2:00:36your life and you may not be fully aware of it.
- 2:00:39But more interestingly, you know, things like what I spoke
- 2:00:42about in terms of the the second era being the the era of mind
- 2:00:47brainwash. You know, I have a little an
- 2:00:51interesting metric around who's the master and who's the slave.
- 2:00:55And when we've handed over to, you know, to to become the
- 2:00:59slaves of the machines, right, which are quite eye opening,
- 2:01:03most of them. But I write them sort of a bit
- 2:01:05like a historian, which is a very unusual experience for me,
- 2:01:09but I find it a lot of fun. So that that's going to be the,
- 2:01:12the the. 1st. Bit of it and and we're going to
- 2:01:14start releasing that in in February.
- 2:01:18Then we go into the deep stuff. Then then, you know, by April we
- 2:01:23start to talk about face RI PS and the real impact and what we
- 2:01:26can do to change them. By, you know, June, we start to
- 2:01:31talk about simulation theory and the reality of life.
- 2:01:34And then at the end we talk about the, the, the reality of
- 2:01:39the machine being alive, the living machine, if you want the
- 2:01:44non biological living machine and, and what that means to
- 2:01:48spirituality and God and purpose and all of that.
- 2:01:52And for people, if you, if you want them to follow, they have
- 2:01:55to go to your sub stack and it will be released sequentially,
- 2:01:58right? Yeah, so, so my, my sub stack is
- 2:02:00going to be in my name, not not alive.
- 2:02:02I've never been on sub stack before.
- 2:02:04So we're starting with Mogao that basically.
- 2:02:08And yeah, so so that should be out in February.
- 2:02:12But also I'm available on social media.
- 2:02:14People can find me. I only respond to messages on
- 2:02:16Instagram because I can't keep up with the other platforms, but
- 2:02:20if anyone wants to ask a question more under score Gaudet
- 2:02:23is where they can find mogaudet.com.
- 2:02:26Also is is very up to date most of the time so you know most of
- 2:02:31my speaking engagements happen there.
- 2:02:33Most of my announcements around the communities.
- 2:02:38So funny that we spend so much time talking about AI, but my
- 2:02:43other top 2 projects for this year have nothing to do with AI,
- 2:02:48which is unstressable. You met Alice.
- 2:02:50Yeah. And I think it would be lovely
- 2:02:52to have Alice on the podcast as well.
- 2:02:54A. 100%. Yeah, so, so Alice and I are
- 2:02:57working on Unstressable, which is so pivotal in a time that is
- 2:03:01about to become very stressful. OK.
- 2:03:03And then Hannah, my wife and I are working on Finder's Keepers,
- 2:03:07which I have to say is my favorite project.
- 2:03:11Finding love from a from a geek's mind like myself and a
- 2:03:16therapist's minds like Hannah's is quite it's really, really a
- 2:03:21very enjoyable project and I think it will make a very big
- 2:03:23difference. No, we definitely want to have
- 2:03:25you on again to talk. About You're my friends now, so
- 2:03:28you. Show up anytime.
- 2:03:30We will come with the luggage and the lights and yeah.
- 2:03:32You can leave the luggage. Probably leaving the entire
- 2:03:36setup, Yeah, but these are completely different
- 2:03:38conversations too, and they need their own dedicated time.
- 2:03:42And perhaps even the future AI will be involved in all these
- 2:03:47conversations. Again, I'm I'm getting old, but
- 2:03:49if you allowed me and if anyone wants to take the idea, I mean
- 2:03:53the, the correct dating app, if you ask me, is a resident app on
- 2:03:57your phone for two weeks that really understands you and then
- 2:04:01basically gives you one person, one person.
- 2:04:04Like I've I know what you like. I know what you don't like.
- 2:04:07I know what you read. I know what you watch.
- 2:04:08I know, I know, I know, I know. I know.
- 2:04:10There's this one guy or this one gay lady.
- 2:04:14You know that. I really recommend that you
- 2:04:15meet. No Swiping no.
- 2:04:18No Membership? No.
- 2:04:19No BS. No BS, straight to the point.
- 2:04:21Straight to the point, it's one, it's A1 price.
- 2:04:24OK, you pay for it once, $10 or whatever, OK, It's resides on
- 2:04:29your phone. And then it says, I haven't
- 2:04:31found them, I haven't found her, I haven't found her, I haven't
- 2:04:33found her. And then eventually says, yeah,
- 2:04:36got it. Go meet this purse.
- 2:04:38One purse. What if you never find someone?
- 2:04:42Again, again, again, that's the most interesting thing.
- 2:04:45So and find there's keepers the again that that that incredible
- 2:04:50mix of my weird, weird geeky algorithmic mind.
- 2:04:54Take in romance. And and yeah, let take on
- 2:04:56romance and and Hannah's incredibly beautifully feminine
- 2:05:01and and psychology based approach.
- 2:05:04I When I met my wife, I proposed to her four days after I met
- 2:05:10her. Really.
- 2:05:11Four days. Yeah, you know why?
- 2:05:14No idea. By the way, we hadn't even
- 2:05:17started dating yet, right because she was one in 8,373,000
- 2:05:24possible women. So for me to meet another one
- 2:05:27like Anna mathematically is one in I needed to meet another
- 2:05:318,000,373. 1000 of them. You've done the math.
- 2:05:35And I, and I, I kid you not, this is accurate mathematics.
- 2:05:40Accurate mathematics. I had 9 criteria, OK, that I was
- 2:05:44looking for not, not in an unemotional way, but I knew I
- 2:05:48would break up with a woman that didn't have any of the night,
- 2:05:51OK. You know her spiritual if her
- 2:05:54view on spirituality, her intelligence, her you know
- 2:05:56several things her her connection to her feminine side.
- 2:05:59And so on and so forth, right? And you can easily do the
- 2:06:01mathematics if one of them is available in one in 10 and the
- 2:06:05other is available in one in 20. It's not one in 30, it's one in
- 2:06:09200, right? That's you can easily do the
- 2:06:12mathematics. And that's one of the approaches
- 2:06:14that people need to understand that it, you know, the one that
- 2:06:18that would make you complete if you know, in a very romantic
- 2:06:21sense is out there, OK. It's just that the odds of
- 2:06:26finding them the current way is impossible.
- 2:06:32But there are ways you can sway probabilities in your favor and
- 2:06:37and that's really key. So This is why I find there's
- 2:06:40keepers. It is such an interesting
- 2:06:42project for me because because like rolling the dice, most
- 2:06:47people don't understand that in probabilities, you roll the dice
- 2:06:506 times, you're likely going to get the six, right?
- 2:06:55But that's not true. You're likely going to get the
- 2:06:58six if you roll 6 times if you haven't rolled it already.
- 2:07:02But if you rolled twice, on the third roll, OK, you now have 4
- 2:07:07rolls. One of them is going to be a
- 2:07:09six, which means your chances are one in four OK.
- 2:07:13On the next roll you have 3, which means your chances are one
- 2:07:16in three OK, and on the next one it's one in two OK.
- 2:07:21And if you're rolling the 6th time probabilities, it's saying
- 2:07:25you're likely going to get it this time.
- 2:07:26Of course, you may be unlucky and it may take six more, but on
- 2:07:29average, OK, probability sways in your favor as you as you
- 2:07:33change your behavior, right? And I think that to me with
- 2:07:38within a proper AI is a very simple algorithm to build, OK,
- 2:07:44By the way, if it, if it finds one that is not yours, OK, it
- 2:07:49will learn. So the likelihood of the next
- 2:07:52one being recommended to you being right is much higher and
- 2:07:56then we we just end this suffering.
- 2:08:01Someone please code this immediately.
- 2:08:03Yeah, yeah, seriously, if someone wants to build those
- 2:08:06ideas and they're good coders, come to me.
- 2:08:09I will help. Wow.
- 2:08:12That's that's and I'm not interested in the money.
- 2:08:13Believe it or not, money is about to disappear.
- 2:08:16But let's build them. This is a service to the
- 2:08:19community, to the humankind, if you.
- 2:08:21So, so when I, when I, when I started 1 billion happy, I was,
- 2:08:24I based, I first started to attempt to explain happiness and
- 2:08:27then the following projects were to remove the reasons for
- 2:08:29unhappiness. So my focus on AI is to remove
- 2:08:32the reason for that dystopia, right?
- 2:08:35My focus on stress is because stress is the biggest killer
- 2:08:37today and so on. So love and romance, believe it
- 2:08:41or not, is one of the biggest reasons for unhappiness and
- 2:08:43loneliness in the world today. OK, and and more for women than
- 2:08:47men sadly, even though for a good chunk of good men it's a
- 2:08:51major issue. Because sadly the way the game
- 2:08:54is rigged is that women chase 20% of the men and and and it
- 2:09:00can be fixed algorithmically. That's I'm.
- 2:09:04Looking forward to find out the ways to fix.
- 2:09:06It and I'm looking forward to recover I.
- 2:09:08Cannot believe you 2 Are you guys single at?
- 2:09:11The moment, yes. Are you?
- 2:09:13Fucking kidding me. When mathematically.
- 2:09:16Are we suppose not? I'll get you to meet the most
- 2:09:19amazing people in two weeks time.
- 2:09:22The best podcast. Thank you.
- 2:09:26Okay, podcast is done. Thank you guys very.
- 2:09:29Much thank you guys so much for watching and listening to
- 2:09:33another episode of the Bad Decisions podcast.
- 2:09:36Our goal is to bring this conversation in front of
- 2:09:38millions of people and therefore we have one little request from
- 2:09:42you because if this conversation helped you, then you can help
- 2:09:46other people hear it too. The way you can help is by
- 2:09:49leaving a five star review on Spotify and Apple podcasts and
- 2:09:52follow us on Spotify and YouTube.
- 2:09:55That's it. We'll see you guys next week on
- 2:09:57Tuesday. Thank you.