Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / 55 Mysterious Murders And Suicide Iin Texas The Podcast Paper Ghosts From M William Phelps
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: I'm not just a podcaster. I'm a podcast connoisseur. That
- 0:03means I listen, I study, I pay close attention. But
- 0:07when it comes to variety, how many times have you
- 0:09gone to somebody's streaming website and when nope, nope, nope, nope, nope,
- 0:13nope nope. Okay, now you know why we created ero
- 0:17dot net a R r oe dot net, seventeen different
- 0:22styles of podcasts to choose from. Enjoy your exploration. I
- 0:26got to ask you a question here when it comes
- 0:29to really digging in the way that chat. First of all,
- 0:31I'm very proud of you for doing this because I
- 0:32believe that we are really witnessing a new day of journalism.
- 0:36But I know how much that I pour into it
- 0:38when it comes to research and the emotions that are involved.
- 0:41How when you do a project like paper Ghost, how
- 0:44are you recovering? I really would like to know what
- 0:47you do with that energy that you're pulling from out
- 0:49of nowhere.
- 0:51Speaker 2: Wow, that's a great, great question. Yeah, how am I
- 0:56recovering from that? Well, there's a decompression process, you know.
- 1:01After I do something like this and I spend years
- 1:04with the material, and part of that for me is
- 1:09obviously I'm a big time reader, so I read a lot.
- 1:13Another part is I have a lake house that I
- 1:15built a couple of years ago that I kind of
- 1:18I kind of shut off the world from and turn
- 1:21off my phone and go there and kind of zen out,
- 1:26and you know, I just kind of let I let
- 1:28everything just kind of filter out of me, you know.
- 1:31And and it's hard sometimes, it's really hard because we're
- 1:37talking about real people, We're talking about real lives. Yeah,
- 1:40you know, And you know, I find that the cases
- 1:45that stick with me longer are the ones that are
- 1:47the most frustrating, right and the paper got season five
- 1:51here Texas team mergers is certainly one of those. The
- 1:55frustration involved and not getting answers for forty two years,
- 2:00you know, it's just you know, and we're talking about
- 2:02a sixteen and fourteen year old victims here, So that
- 2:05kind of stuff can stick with me longer. But there
- 2:09comes a point where I have to let go right
- 2:11right erro I mean, you got to let go, you
- 2:14got to let go.
- 2:15Speaker 1: Well, that's that's one of the reasons why I dfrag
- 2:17every day. It's part of that letting go process. I mean,
- 2:19you've got to sit there and ask yourself the questions
- 2:21and then question your answers and try to figure out
- 2:23where the balance is. And so in in experiencing your podcast, dude,
- 2:27I feel like I'm sitting right there with you and
- 2:28that you invited me into the circle of creativity.
- 2:32Speaker 2: Oh, thank you. That's that's I'm very grateful for that.
- 2:36That's that's that's what I'm trying to do. That's what
- 2:38I'm striving to do as a creator, you know, as
- 2:40a as an artist, if you will, making the shows
- 2:44beyond the investigative part is I want you to come
- 2:47along the journey with me, you know, and I want
- 2:50to reveal to you what what I'm discovering, you know,
- 2:54and podcasting is just the ultimate format for me to
- 2:59do that. You know. For many years, you know, twenty
- 3:02five years, I've written books, you know, and I've done
- 3:06a lot of TV and you can't you can't do
- 3:07that with those mediums, you know. So the podcasting kind
- 3:11of brought the two together, you know, the book and
- 3:13the TV work brought it together for me. And I'm
- 3:16able to, you know, because podcasting is a very intimate thing,
- 3:20right It's just me and one listener, right, yep. That's it,
- 3:24that's it, Me Me, Me in two ears. You know,
- 3:29do you always got to keep that in mind when
- 3:31you're making a podcast like I do, like these investigative
- 3:34kind of limited series, you know, you got to keep
- 3:37in mind it's just you and that one listener. You know,
- 3:40you're telling them a story, and you know I do
- 3:44that through different voices and yeah, so.
- 3:48Speaker 1: How many times? How many times though, when you're recording that,
- 3:50you know, that script, do you sit there and say, no,
- 3:52I need to shrug my shoulders a little bit more
- 3:54because I don't think they felt what I'm really trying
- 3:55to project right now, because I mean, you do, You've
- 3:58got this pacing about you. It's like, dang it, why
- 4:00am I dickted to this guy's presence? Ah?
- 4:03Speaker 2: Wow? Thanks? Yeah, I don't really. I don't really record
- 4:08stuff more than once. Sometimes I'll sometimes I'll flub a
- 4:13line and I'll you know, I'll record that line again.
- 4:16But for the most part, I have a studio in
- 4:18my house, and I go into the studio and I
- 4:21sit down and I just kind of I just kind of,
- 4:24you know, act like there's one person in front of
- 4:26me I'm telling the story to, you know, like, I
- 4:30guess it's the what's his name, the painter, Bob Bob Ross.
- 4:34Speaker 1: Oh yeah, yeah, you know, it's simple, make it simple.
- 4:39Speaker 2: Yeah yeah. So I'm just kind of I'm myself real,
- 4:43I'm not trying to be anybody else but myself when
- 4:46I'm telling this.
- 4:47Speaker 1: Story, Well, did you come from the world of radio,
- 4:49because what exactly what you're saying is what people would
- 4:52share with me back in the nineteen seventies with Arrow,
- 4:54it's one on one, there's only one person there, put
- 4:58a picture in front of you, and that's who you're
- 5:00here in a conversation with. I mean, it sounds like
- 5:02you came from the world of radio.
- 5:04Speaker 2: Ah, that this is the last place I thought I would. Really, Yeah,
- 5:09I've never I never considered myself ever going into radio
- 5:15or doing broadcasting like this, or even podcasting when podcasting
- 5:20became popular, you know, I kind of just shrugged it off,
- 5:23you know. And then and then iHeart came to me
- 5:25and said, hey, we hear that. You know, you know,
- 5:28you know, you do good work on TV, you write
- 5:31these books, you're an investigator. Maybe we can get something
- 5:34going here. And I said, all right, let's try it,
- 5:36you know, and and I just found it perfect for
- 5:40what I do, the perfect, perfect place for what I do.
- 5:45Speaker 1: Well. To me, it's the next level of storytelling. I mean,
- 5:48if Dolly Parton, can you sit there and tell me
- 5:50that country music was the it was the local newspaper
- 5:52of its time. The thing is is that podcasting we're
- 5:55speaking to a generation that's not born yet because they're
- 5:58going to find it. Dude.
- 6:00Speaker 2: Yes, yes, that's it. That's so true. I mean, this
- 6:03stuff's forever now, Yeah, it's it's it's it's not like
- 6:07a book you know that ends up at a tag
- 6:09sale or in a used book store or whatever it
- 6:12goes out of print or whatever like that. You know,
- 6:14TV is very disposable, right, very disposable. Podcasting it's always there,
- 6:21you know. That's why advertisers, advertisers love it so much.
- 6:24It's it's always there and new people are finding it
- 6:27every day, right, And yeah, I just find it. I
- 6:31find it really really comfortable. I'm very comfortable in this space.
- 6:37Speaker 1: So when when the story was forty two years ago,
- 6:40the thing is is that now I have to ask you,
- 6:42as somebody who takes walks in force and I really
- 6:44do listen to the universe, is that who tapped you
- 6:47on the shoulder to go into this story because you
- 6:49you were pulled into something forty two years ago, dude,
- 6:52and now you've made it twenty twenty five.
- 6:56Speaker 2: Yeah. A lot of a lot of the stories that
- 7:00I do in my podcasting on four Paper Ghosts and
- 7:06my other podcasts Crossing the Line with m William Phelps,
- 7:09which is more of a weekly show, a lot of
- 7:13the stories people write into me, so get I get
- 7:17ten twenty stories a week. People write into me, and
- 7:21I take a look at them. If it's something I
- 7:23think I can make a difference in, I go for it.
- 7:26With this one with the Texas Team Murder season five.
- 7:32You know, I had a woman from the town where
- 7:35this takes place, Weatherford, Texas, where Yellowstone was mostly filmed
- 7:40the TV show, and she had written into me and
- 7:43she said, you know, you ought to look into this case.
- 7:45This is the case that everyone in town has been
- 7:49talking about for forty years and it needs M. William Phelps.
- 7:53It needs somebody like you to come in and take
- 7:55a look at it. So you know, I took a
- 7:58look at it and I said wow. Said now my
- 8:02first answer is wow, this is something I am interested in.
- 8:07My second question in my head is can I make
- 8:09a difference? And so I do, like a pre investigation
- 8:14with any of the cases I decide to get into
- 8:16and I start to talk to people, and with this case,
- 8:18it just kind of starts opening up. You know, the
- 8:21cases that don't open up, I kind of move away
- 8:23from this case just kept opening and opening and opening,
- 8:27and more people and more people started talking.
- 8:30Speaker 1: And here we are, Please do not move. We are
- 8:33just getting started with m William Phelps. Hey, thanks for
- 8:38coming back to my conversation with M William Phelps. His
- 8:41podcast is titled Paper Ghosts. First of all, it's season
- 8:46five and there are fifty five murders. There's a connection
- 8:49of fives here, and fives are very big when it
- 8:51comes to numerology. And it's like going, okay, where are
- 8:54you going with this? Because this is going to serve
- 8:56as an open door to go to even a bigger
- 8:58investigation coming up next, because you're prepared for it. Now
- 9:01you're messing with numerology here.
- 9:04Speaker 2: Yeah, I I you know, I never I never go
- 9:07into stuff thinking how big will this get?
- 9:11Speaker 1: Yeah?
- 9:11Speaker 2: I always go I always go into it thinking how
- 9:16can I service the victims? Families. Number one. Number two
- 9:20is you know, can I offer anything new? You know,
- 9:24if I can't offer anything new, then I'm just rehashing
- 9:26old stuff. I'm not doing it. And number three, are
- 9:31there people willing to go to a lot you know,
- 9:34to go go to distance with me and talk about this,
- 9:37to to to open up and trust me? And you
- 9:41know all three of those, you know, in this case,
- 9:44you know began right away from me with this.
- 9:47Speaker 1: It was Ronald Reagan that said that we are part
- 9:49of the sound bite generation. And right away, as a broadcaster,
- 9:52I thought, I need to straighten up my game and
- 9:54make sure that I don't become what he's talking about.
- 9:57But what And I'm so impressed by your sound bites
- 9:59because you allow us as listeners to envision, to embrace,
- 10:04and to become emotionally involved. It's not one of those
- 10:07where boom boom, it's just a SoundBite and then you
- 10:09move on with the story.
- 10:11Speaker 2: Yeah, I you know that kind of storytelling. I'm not
- 10:16interested in that. You know. If you know, if I'm
- 10:21going to honor the victims of murder and in this case, kids,
- 10:25you know, I need to tell their stories. I need
- 10:27to get you into how devastating. This truly is because
- 10:33we can't become desensitized to how tragic this stuff is.
- 10:39And I think within the first minute of the podcast,
- 10:42you get an idea that the mother of one of
- 10:45the victims, it's forty two years later and this thing
- 10:48is still affecting her TODAYEP the same as it did
- 10:52when it happened. So I wanted to I wanted to
- 10:56show that. I wanted to want listeners to hear that
- 10:59from the more immediately that this is real. You know,
- 11:03this happened. This woman lost her fourteen year old child
- 11:08to an execution style murder, and you know, forty two
- 11:12years have gone by, but the pain, it's it's still that.
- 11:17There's a line I think in the first episode where
- 11:21I say, whoever said time is a healer never lost
- 11:27a damn child to murder?
- 11:29Speaker 1: No, no, no, no, I'm with you on that because
- 11:31my wife is still trying to get over her mother's
- 11:33murder and and I wish there was somebody that could
- 11:36come along and to dig in because I frig I
- 11:38don't know where to hell to turn around when it
- 11:40comes to this kind of stuff. And that's why I
- 11:42think I study the hell out of you is because
- 11:44I'm going to go. One thing I'm learning in is patience.
- 11:46I swear to God that's what you're that you're putting
- 11:48into this project. Paper goes is there's so much patience here.
- 11:52Speaker 2: Oh thank you. I I greatly appreciate that. Yeah. There,
- 11:56you have to you have to be patient and allow
- 11:58things to happen. You know. I when I start looking
- 12:02into stuff, I allow people to come at me the
- 12:06way they need to come at me. That's why it
- 12:08takes me a little longer to do stuff then. You know.
- 12:13You know a lot of podcasts, you know that they
- 12:15come out so quickly. I you know, when the story's done,
- 12:18it's done for me. You know, I can't. I can't.
- 12:20It's this is real stuff. You know. I can't. I
- 12:23can't say when you know it's gonna be done at
- 12:25this point, you know. So yeah, it's a you know,
- 12:31we have become desensitized how tragic murder is. We really
- 12:35have And you know I need to. I need to.
- 12:39I need my listeners to hear that you know this
- 12:42pain is real.
- 12:43Speaker 1: Well, and you're being authentic in the way though, dude,
- 12:45because I mean I was all over Chad Gpt saying
- 12:48are we living in more dangerous times today than any
- 12:51other time. It said, no, no, we need to look
- 12:54into our own past and see that man, it was
- 12:57just as bad, if not worse, back then, and you're
- 12:59proving that true here.
- 13:02Speaker 2: Erro. I can tell you from you know, my work
- 13:05as an at crime expert, the murder rates, violent crime, rape,
- 13:12all of that has dropped about fifty percent, wow, from
- 13:16twenty five years ago. But at the same time, the
- 13:21reporting of those murders and rapes and violent crimes has
- 13:25shot up over one thousand percent. So we're just seeing
- 13:30a lot more reporting about a lot less crime, and
- 13:36it makes us believe that, you know, we're living in
- 13:39Roman times, crazy society, right yep, yeah, yeah, and we're not.
- 13:44It's just the reporting of it.
- 13:46Speaker 1: Do you sit there and never think about who is
- 13:48the armchair quarterback investigator that you're that you're kind of
- 13:51subliminally charging up And the reason why is because it's
- 13:54a podcast like this that people are going to say,
- 13:57I want to be like this, this is who I
- 13:59want to be, I want to do this story. I
- 14:00want to do one like this because I mean, you
- 14:02you are a pioneer in the way of making sure
- 14:05that we get the whole story and not a five
- 14:07minute version.
- 14:09Speaker 2: Yeah, thanks, thanks, Well, I like to say Scooby Doo
- 14:13yes first, and to honestly, Colombo I went as a
- 14:21kid my dad, Yes, my dad, My dad would would
- 14:25loved Colombo, and so I would watch Colombo with him.
- 14:30And what's great about Colombo is the great thing about
- 14:33Colombo is within a minute or two of that show,
- 14:37you know who the killer is, but you you sign
- 14:40off for ninety more minutes to see how Colombo will
- 14:44figure it out. Right, So you're riveted by how this
- 14:49guy is going to get the killer to crack. So
- 14:52so that's the kind of storytelling, investigative storytelling that I
- 14:56grew up with. And you know, I just kind of huh,
- 15:00I don't know, I just got you know, I did
- 15:02have a mentor, a guy from Manhattan who was you know,
- 15:07he worked for the CID Criminal Investigation Division of the Army.
- 15:11He worked for customs. Uh. You know, he he was
- 15:15big time.
- 15:16Speaker 1: Uh.
- 15:17Speaker 2: He busts a lot of big cartels. Columbian guy. And
- 15:21we became friends early in my career and I was
- 15:23kind of thinking about writing about him, and so he
- 15:27taught me. You know, I was a journalist. When I
- 15:29met him, and when I left him a couple of
- 15:31years later, I was an investigative. He taught me how
- 15:33to investigate people. Wow yeah, wow.
- 15:35Speaker 1: So now what do you do in a situation because
- 15:37I just did this story on iHeartRadio, and that is
- 15:40is that we interpret what our lives used to be.
- 15:43And because if you didn't write it down and document
- 15:45it perfectly, it's the interpretation of what you went through.
- 15:48So then when I look at you, I'm going, how
- 15:50does he how does he know the difference between truth
- 15:53versus rumor if we're all giving our interpretation of what
- 15:57we did in that time period or what we learned.
- 16:00Did I ask that question? Right?
- 16:02Speaker 2: Yeah? Yeah, no, I get it. Well in this case,
- 16:05particularly the Texas teen murders. You know, when when I
- 16:09speak to five ten people and those people don't know
- 16:15each other, right, and they're telling me the same thing, Well,
- 16:19then I know that I'm close, very very close to
- 16:22the truth, because you know, they didn't get together before
- 16:26they spoke to me and say, you know, we got
- 16:28to get our story straight. You know, one didn't know
- 16:31I was speaking to the other. So when you start
- 16:34hearing the same thing, rise to the surface from various
- 16:38forms of different sources. You know, you're getting at the
- 16:42truth here in this case. You make a really great
- 16:45point that you know, are people remembering stuff correctly? Right?
- 16:50And so I just backed that stuff up with other
- 16:53sourcing and and and get at it, come at it
- 16:57from a different way and say, yep, you know this
- 16:59person they got it right. You know, they they remember
- 17:02this correctly. You know, I mean, how do we remember
- 17:06something from forty two years ago? I mean, it's but
- 17:09you know, but then again, when trauma is involved, you
- 17:12tend to remember you know, uh uh but details.
- 17:17Speaker 1: Yeah, well, you're shaking you're shaking me up with this
- 17:19with this podcast only because the last time that I
- 17:22was involved with a story like this was when Wayne
- 17:24Williams was doing what he was doing down in Atlanta.
- 17:26And then when you when you give me paper Ghosts,
- 17:29all of a sudden, it shakes me up on that story.
- 17:31But it makes me dig deeper into your story because
- 17:33I'm going, what the hell and and and and there's
- 17:36just so much going on at one time, but you
- 17:38you really do put it out there in a way
- 17:40to where we can go one person, one story at
- 17:43a time.
- 17:45Speaker 2: Yeah, and each voice lends itself to the next yes, right, yes,
- 17:50and and then I try to be with my voice
- 17:52over with my narration. I try to be the person
- 17:55in the middle saying, well, you know that didn't happen.
- 17:58You know this happened, or no, that person's not telling
- 18:01the truth. This is the truth, you know, so and
- 18:04this is what I found. You know, you know, you know,
- 18:08I never accuse anybody of anything in my podcast. I
- 18:13you know, I say, look, allegedly, this is what this
- 18:16person did, because you know what ten people are saying it,
- 18:21you know, And and in this season in particular, you know,
- 18:25you got some higher ups here. There some high people
- 18:28involved that have a lot of power or had a
- 18:31lot of power at the time. And you know when
- 18:34you get people in power situations, you know that goes
- 18:37right to their head. And you add add millions of
- 18:41dollars involved in it, and all bets off, you know. See.
- 18:44Speaker 1: My biggest fear of all the time is what do
- 18:46you do when you pop a microphone in the in
- 18:48front of a person who is unprofessional and doesn't know
- 18:51what that microphone is about, ready to do because they
- 18:53to me, they become actors. Then I say, no, don't
- 18:56give me an actor answer. I need to have a
- 18:57real one here.
- 18:59Speaker 2: That that's a really that's a really great point that
- 19:02brings up something from me. So you know, I had
- 19:05I had an investigative series on uh Investigation Discovery, uh
- 19:11uh uh Dark Minds three seasons. I you know, I
- 19:16investigated cold case serial murders. And what I found was,
- 19:22you know, you go inside someone's house, you set up
- 19:25all the lights, set up the camera, you sit down,
- 19:28and they you know, that is intimidating. But I found
- 19:33with podcasting they forget about that mic pretty quickly, and
- 19:38so you're just talking. Now, now you're just talking. There's
- 19:42no camera, there's no lights, there's there's this mic that
- 19:45becomes invisible, and now you're just having a conversation. And
- 19:49and I found that people open up a hell of
- 19:51a lot more with podcasting than than definitely with you know,
- 19:55making a documentary for television.
- 19:58Speaker 1: God William R. Murrow to make sure that somewhere in
- 20:01that path that they created for all the broadcasters and newspeople,
- 20:04that they start honoring journalists like yourself because you're doing
- 20:07exactly what he set out to do. But we had
- 20:10no podcast back then. It was called television.
- 20:14Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah, well, hey, I appreciate that. That's very kind
- 20:17of you. I just you know, I get up every
- 20:19morning and try to do give a thousand percent. I
- 20:23try to I try to do the best work I
- 20:26can possibly do that day and then move on to
- 20:29the next day. And I'm just grateful for all the
- 20:33people who came forward, you know, dozens and dozens of
- 20:37sources for this season. I mean, it made it what
- 20:40it is.
- 20:41Speaker 1: You know, you got to come back to this show
- 20:43anytime in the future. Twenty minutes with you is not enough.
- 20:45I gotta have more. I'm sorry, I'm gonna be I'm
- 20:47gonna be selfish here. I need more.
- 20:48Speaker 2: I need more. Thanks, Sarah, I appreciate that. It's been
- 20:53really really great talk to you.
- 20:54Speaker 1: Will you'd be brilliant today.
- 20:56Speaker 2: Okay, all right, thank you. Take care.