Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #12 - Election 2024 Preview Part 2 - General Overview of Competitive Non-Presidential Races
Transcript
- 0:00Ding, ding, ding, ding.
- 0:01It's time for more politics.
- 0:04Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08Today is part 2 of our election 2024 preview.
- 0:12It's gonna be a general overview of the competitive non presidential races.
- 0:17So last week, we talked a bit more we we talked about the more predictable races in the 2024
- 0:23elections.
- 0:23So now we're gonna move on to where the highest levels of competition are.
- 0:27Name a little bit about context that are expected to go democrat or republican, but have
- 0:32an outside chance of being an upset.
- 0:35What exactly makes these races competitive?
- 0:37Why these races and not other ones?
- 0:40Now it became clear when I was putting these notes together for these episodes that this was
- 0:45gonna be way too long and way too much info to pack into one episode, so I'm gonna break it up
- 0:49into several.
- 0:50Today is a more general overview of the competitive non presidential races.
- 0:55I'm going to go over some of the factors that makes each election more competitive versus
- 1:01less competitive or at least can make them more competitive.
- 1:04Though these contests don't need to be competitive in every single one of these
- 1:07aspects, and in fact, a lot of times, they won't.
- 1:11And then I'll highlight what is expected to be competitive, which races across US senate, US
- 1:17house, governor, and state legislative chamber control, which which of those are expected to
- 1:22be competitive.
- 1:23But in another episode or 2 later this week, I'll dive more into what makes those races so
- 1:29competitive.
- 1:30And of course, in the week before the election, we'll cover the competitive states for the
- 1:35presidential races.
- 1:37Save the marquee of all marquee races for last, but there are plenty of races that we should
- 1:41pay attention to because they're all important.
- 1:44So what makes a race competitive?
- 1:48So there's these factors that can level a playing field.
- 1:51If a candidate or a party knows how to harness and utilize them.
- 1:56They give.
- 1:58So voter registration numbers, not every state tracks the party affiliation of its voters, but
- 2:04somewhere 30 or so states do track that.
- 2:08So it makes it a little bit easier to look at the populations and see, okay, who's
- 2:14predisposed to voting democrat, who's predisposed to voting republican, how many
- 2:19nonpartisan third party voters are there.
- 2:23If there's comparable numbers of registered democrats and republicans that can make things
- 2:27more even, but you still have to account for turnout rates even if there's, say, a 1000000
- 2:33democrats and a 1000000 republicans, but republicans turn out more often.
- 2:37Republicans are gonna have an advantage.
- 2:38And in fact, if my state is an example of this, even when Florida democrats were more numerous
- 2:45than republicans for the past, really, for the past 25 years, they've at least Democrats have
- 2:53really struggled to turn out their voters while Republicans have been a lot better.
- 2:57And now in 2021, Republican voters for the first time in Florida's history outnumbered
- 3:03democrats, and now there's about a 1000000 more republicans registered to vote in Florida than
- 3:10there are democrats.
- 3:11So democrats have their work cut out for them.
- 3:14They really need to improve their turnout capabilities for, for voting.
- 3:21Campaign spending, relatively equal amounts of contributions and expenditures usually expected
- 3:26to be competitive.
- 3:27But if you don't spend it wisely, even a major monetary advantage doesn't matter.
- 3:33We can look back at the 2016 presidential election.
- 3:37Hillary Clinton, the Democrat, had way more money raised and spent than, excuse me, than
- 3:44Donald Trump did, and she still lost the election.
- 3:47Open secrets numbers, the campaign committees for Clinton spent or the committee for Hillary
- 3:55Clinton spent about $564,000,000.
- 3:58Donald Trump spent only about 333,000,000.
- 4:01And then with outside money, those independent expenditures, which we'll get into in just a
- 4:05moment.
- 4:06Clinton's once supporting Clinton spent about 206,000,000, and the ones for Trump spent a
- 4:11$100,000,000.
- 4:12So even though there was a several $100,000,000 difference in support and campaign spending for
- 4:21Hillary Clinton's campaign or at least super packs that were in support of Hillary Clinton
- 4:28versus the ones that supported Donald Trump or were his committee even though there was a
- 4:33several $100,000,000 difference.
- 4:35Donald Trump won.
- 4:36They won the popular vote, but he won the electoral college.
- 4:38So you have to know where to spend that money, when to spend that money, how to spend that
- 4:43money.
- 4:44Campaign committee expenditures versus independent expenditures.
- 4:48Independent expenditures are those super packs that can raise and spend unlimited amounts of
- 4:53money as long this is a really big key here.
- 4:57As long as they do not coordinate with the campaigns for that candidate.
- 5:03So for Kamala Harris and Donald Trump, any super packs that are supporting them, they the
- 5:09one supporting Kamala Harris cannot coordinate with Kamala Harris's campaign.
- 5:14The one supporting Donald Trump cannot coordinate with Donald Trump's campaign.
- 5:18As long as they do that, they can spend raise and spend as much money as they please.
- 5:24Thanks to the Citizens United ruling from 2010, which basically ruled that that limits on those
- 5:33organizations would be considered basically a first amendment an infringement on the first
- 5:38amendment free speech rights that they have.
- 5:41But, again, if you are the actual candidate's campaigns, you are subject to a lot of limits
- 5:48on what you can raise and spend.
- 5:51High levels of independent expenditures getting involved tends to indicate that there's an ex
- 5:56expectation of competitiveness.
- 5:58This big money often what they call dark money interest, especially want to leave things to
- 6:04chance as little as they possibly can.
- 6:07So they will spend as much money as they possibly can, raise as much money as they
- 6:11possibly can to try to make sure that their candidate wins.
- 6:16And so there's high spending by both the Republican and the Democrat, or if there
- 6:20happens to be an independent that's making a lot of noise and it's keeping things
- 6:24competitive As there's a good chance that the race is gonna be likely competitive.
- 6:28But there's actually one US senate race, Arizona, where the there's a very stark
- 6:33difference where the democrat has a huge advantage in money raised and spent, but that
- 6:39race is still expected to be competitive.
- 6:41So it's still about whether you spend that money wisely.
- 6:46Open seats versus incumbents.
- 6:48So when a seat is open, that tends to automatically add a level of competitiveness to
- 6:52the election as opposed to if there was an an incumbent.
- 6:55Doesn't mean that it will be a competitive race.
- 6:58The Republican or the Democrat might still be the heavy favorite to take the seat.
- 7:04And that but incumbents have that major incumbency advantage from name recognition,
- 7:09connections, money.
- 7:11We've talked before, in a previous episode about high rates of reelection for these
- 7:17incumbents around 75 to 90% of candidates that are running for reelection depending on what
- 7:23kind of race we're talking about.
- 7:25And, again, incumbents running for reelection means they're running for that seat that
- 7:29they're already in, so they might be we're not talking about incumbents who are running for a
- 7:34higher office like a US house rep that decides to run for US senate.
- 7:37That's not what we're talking about.
- 7:38We're talking about they're running for their seat or their office again.
- 7:43So if an incumbent is involved, it's I mean, depending on who the incumbent is.
- 7:48But if it's an incumbent involved, that tends to make things a little less competitive, just
- 7:54regarding other factors that might be involved.
- 7:57Support from the political party apparatus.
- 7:59So if a party thinks one of its candidates can win, it generally tries to provide support in
- 8:04some way, whether they're already in office or whether they are challenging an incumbent or if
- 8:11they're running for an open seat like we were just talking about.
- 8:13If the party provides little to no support to a candidate, there is a very likely chance that
- 8:19that candidate has no chance of winning, or at least they just don't expect that candidate to
- 8:23win.
- 8:24Out if the party if, I mean, if the party thought the candidate had a chance, they'd
- 8:27probably provide some volunteers, paid campaigners, monetary support, etcetera.
- 8:33Again, those things are finite, so they have to parties have to pick and choose which of these
- 8:39candidates to give these kinds of resources to.
- 8:42Now exceptions could be if the party just doesn't have enough resources to spare, but
- 8:46they still believe the candidate can win, but you have to have the resources available, or
- 8:51the candidate is very wealthy and can largely self fund their campaign.
- 8:54If they can do that, parties aren't gonna gonna try not to give too much of their resources to
- 9:02help them win because they're trying to help all these other candidates all across the
- 9:07ballot, federal, state, and local level trying to get them to win.
- 9:12So you gotta be able to spend or spread those resources wisely across these races all across
- 9:21the ballot.
- 9:22Now the party providing money and volunteers and paid campaigners, that doesn't necessarily
- 9:28mean it is a competitive election.
- 9:30They could assume that their candidate has a better chance of winning than they do in
- 9:34reality.
- 9:35And, again, these resources could be spent in a very inefficient manner.
- 9:41They're not sending their camp, campaigners and volunteers to places where they really need to
- 9:46drum up support, for example, or they spend money on on poor advertising, whether the ads
- 9:52themselves are poor or whether they should go for example, if they're spending too much on TV
- 9:58and they need to spend more on mailers, for example, or they spend a whole bunch of money
- 10:02on billboards.
- 10:04You have to be able to spend that money wisely.
- 10:07And so even if the parties fork over, money for those endeavors doesn't necessarily mean that
- 10:13it's gonna be a competitive election.
- 10:15They might think an election is more competitive than it actually is.
- 10:18But generally speaking, if a party is providing support to a candidate, they expect that that
- 10:24candidate has some sort of chance at winning that election.
- 10:28Alignment with the overall political party and highest ranking members of the party.
- 10:32You have to really strike a a careful balance between strongly aligning yourself with your
- 10:37overall party and its standard bearers and listing yourself just enough to say that you
- 10:43stand on your own.
- 10:45Now how much a candidate should go one way or the other depends on the race.
- 10:50It's it's all a part of campaign strategy.
- 10:52So for some for candidate in I don't I don't know.
- 10:59Tennessee, a running for the US house in Tennessee.
- 11:01A Republican may want to highlight just how much they support Donald Trump there, but if
- 11:07you're a Republican in California, in the US house race, that might not be the way to go.
- 11:15Donald Trump and Kamala Harris for their respective parties can be seen as a boom or an
- 11:21anchor for those candidates chances.
- 11:24So you really have to be able to strike that careful balance between allying yourself too
- 11:29much with those those people and not just the presidential candidates.
- 11:33For democrats, if if you how much you ally yourself with Nancy Pelosi, former speaker of
- 11:40the house, or Chuck Schumer, the senate majority leader, as a Republican, how much you
- 11:45ally yourself with somebody like Mitch McConnell who is the minority and previous
- 11:52majority leader for the US senate, for Republicans or Mike Johnson as speaker of the
- 12:00house.
- 12:00So how much you say, oh, I'm with them versus you you might might also you gotta also be
- 12:08careful not to distance yourself too much because then you might piss off on a bunch of,
- 12:13your your core base where they're like, why are you not tying yourself to these standard
- 12:19barriers for our party?
- 12:21So so fine line that you gotta walk there.
- 12:24Name recognition.
- 12:26So incumbents, like we said before, they generally get a boost, inherently get a boost
- 12:31in name recognition, but a well known challenger can even this aspect out.
- 12:37Now challengers don't necessarily need to have a comparable name recognition because name
- 12:42recognition knowing the name of somebody isn't the only part of the name recognition aspect.
- 12:48Do people have favorable views when they do know who this candidate is, or how many of them
- 12:53are unsure of their opinion versus flat out?
- 12:57I don't like this person.
- 12:59There's a lot that goes into that.
- 13:01Just just people knowing who you are isn't the end all be all, but it certainly helps as long
- 13:08as there's a chance for a lot of them to if they don't have a favorable view of you
- 13:14already, for them to develop a favorable view of you at some point during the campaign.
- 13:20Concurrent races.
- 13:21So concurrent meaning races that are happening at the same time because it's not just the
- 13:25presidency that's going on.
- 13:27There's US senate, US house, governor, state legislative races, local races, other races and
- 13:34and and ballot measures too.
- 13:36Any one of those that are also on the ballot that are considered pivotal can lead to impacts
- 13:41on other races happening at the same time.
- 13:44So this year, we've got a presidential race on the ballot.
- 13:47Donald Trump and Kamala Harris will be seen as either a boon or an anchor to the chances of
- 13:52their fellow Republicans and Democrats respectively, like we were just saying a moment
- 13:57ago.
- 13:57So it depends on the context of the race.
- 13:59But with these concurrent races going on, if there's some if if there's one that's expected
- 14:04to be very noteworthy in some way, it's it's gonna have an effect even if it's not all that
- 14:13big or it doesn't seem to be that big of an impact, it will still have an impact on other
- 14:18races.
- 14:18And if it's if there's a particularly close race, like for US senate, for example, there's
- 14:25a really close race for US senate.
- 14:27What happens at the pres, for the presidential election?
- 14:31Like, for example, Nevada, US senate is supposed to be even though it slightly favors
- 14:36democrat Jackie Rosen, the fact that it's competitive and that it's expected to be very
- 14:42competitive for the electoral college votes of Nevada or Nevada, depending on who you ask.
- 14:49For if we're president, it's it's supposed to be very competitive.
- 14:51And how people vote for Donald Trump versus Kamala Harrison there Knights decide how people
- 14:58vote for Jackie Rosen.
- 15:01Again, just depends on the context of the race.
- 15:05Rolling numbers.
- 15:06Those polling numbers often suggest that a race is competitive, and not every poll is
- 15:11worthwhile.
- 15:13Media tends to treat, polls, a poll, a poll.
- 15:17Not every one of them is is well done or even if it's a reputable source that's doing the
- 15:25poll, there might be some faults that they don't necessarily account for.
- 15:31Polls are a very meticulous art and science, and there are certain things that can throw
- 15:36them off if they aren't accounted for, like a social desirability bias.
- 15:40How people respond in these polls, even though their name is not being put to these poll
- 15:46results and what they said.
- 15:48You're not saying, John Smith said this about Kamala Harris and this about Donald Trump.
- 15:54That's not you you can't look into that.
- 15:59But John Smith might if he thinks that there's a it's undesirable for him to say that he
- 16:06supports Kamala Harris or that he supports Donald Trump.
- 16:09He might go the opposite direction.
- 16:12There's also nonresponse bias.
- 16:14Polls are having a lot of issues with these work.
- 16:17The way they do the sample is they randomly select from a population because you want it to
- 16:23be random.
- 16:23You don't wanna pick and choose people because that's gonna bias the sample.
- 16:27But there's there's a lot of people that just aren't answering polls when they're being
- 16:33contacted, so it's limiting the pool of potential responses.
- 16:38And so you're not getting what they're saying or what they think about an election and the
- 16:45issues that are going on.
- 16:46So that can also bias the sample, how polls determine what a likely voter is.
- 16:55There's no real objective way to say this person is a likely voter.
- 17:00Each pollster has their own method for determining, the likelihood that they think
- 17:06whoever's responding to their polls, who is going to actually turn out to vote.
- 17:11Because lots of people will let you know their opinion about what's going on in election, but
- 17:15they don't actually turn out to vote.
- 17:19And, again, there's a little bit of that social desirability bias where there's over reporting
- 17:23of how much people turn out to vote.
- 17:26You have you can have, like, 55% turnout.
- 17:29And if you pull people, there might be 75% of those on that say, oh, yeah.
- 17:33I totally voted because they don't want people to look down on them for the fact that they
- 17:37didn't vote, say they didn't do their civic duty, that they were being lazy, or that they
- 17:42that they if they didn't vote, then they shouldn't complain kind of thing.
- 17:46So just because people tell you what they think, doesn't necessarily mean they're
- 17:51actually going to act on that, that they're actually gonna turn out to vote.
- 17:54So determining who a likely voter is, there's not a real objective way to do it, but these
- 18:00pollsters all have their own ways of doing it.
- 18:02So just because there's a response, any poll does not necessarily mean that it actually has
- 18:09any importance for what happens in the election because if they don't actually vote, then for
- 18:15the purposes of winning an election that that, that voters opinion doesn't really matter.
- 18:20Not obviously, it does matter in the grand scheme of things, but in terms of determining
- 18:25who wins that election, if they don't turn out to vote, then we're it doesn't really make a
- 18:30whole lot of sense to account for their opinion, but you don't know if they're gonna go
- 18:33vote.
- 18:34So it's it's a it's a very there's a little it's a little bit of finickiness when
- 18:40determining who is likely to vote.
- 18:44And sometimes pollsters develop questions in a way where they try to figure out, okay.
- 18:49If they answer a certain way on this question, we can expect them to be a likely voter.
- 18:53Again, depends on the pollster and how exactly what exactly their method is.
- 18:59So, however, polls are very valuable in predicting election results as long as you know
- 19:05what you're doing with them.
- 19:06Don't consider them to be the end all be all, but there's a lot of people who don't
- 19:10understand how they work that just say, oh, polls suck that they're why do we even do them
- 19:15still?
- 19:15They are valuable.
- 19:16You just have to know how to use them and what potential flaws might arise with these polls.
- 19:24And then last aspect we'll go over is, obviously, the candidates themselves matter.
- 19:29I mean, that's kind of an obvious thing to say, but we're talking about measurable and non
- 19:36measurable aspects and subjective and objective and what I would consider semi objective
- 19:42aspects where it's not necessarily a thing that you can you can quantify, that you can put a
- 19:50number on or or a descriptor where everybody is going to say, oh, yeah.
- 19:53That's that's undeniable.
- 19:55But things like a like charisma, authenticity.
- 20:00Authentic does not mean that you think someone is a truth teller.
- 20:04There's a lot of people that think Kamala Harris is a liar that think that Donald Trump
- 20:07is a liar.
- 20:09Authenticity is not referring to that.
- 20:11It's whether you think their personality, what the kind of personality that they show, that
- 20:17that is who they are in real life.
- 20:20Do you think that they're authentic?
- 20:21No.
- 20:22I won't go into that because people might assume that that means I'm saying, oh, that
- 20:30Kamala Harris or Donald Trump are I mean, you're just saying that they're authentic
- 20:33people might give people impression that I support one of them or the other.
- 20:38That's that's not or another candidate.
- 20:40That's not what I'm trying to get at.
- 20:42But you have to admit that both of them have charisma.
- 20:45Charisma, they're they're able to inspire devotion in people and really energize people.
- 20:52And admitting that does not make you a supporter of either one.
- 20:55You can admit that both of them are charismatic, different kinds of charisma, but
- 20:59Harris and Trump definitely have a level of charisma that is really important to have as a
- 21:04candidate.
- 21:05Now not being charismatic does not necessarily mean that you're not a good candidate or that
- 21:10you're you're not gonna be competitive or anything like that, but charisma certainly
- 21:16helps to have.
- 21:17And it's also about the ability to connect not just with voters, but local movers and shakers.
- 21:24Are you able to energize not just the people who are gonna come out to vote, but the people
- 21:27who are ultimately gonna work for you or work for an organization that is working for you?
- 21:34You gotta be able to fundraise.
- 21:35You gotta be able to limit certain gaps, make connections, know how and where to go to rally
- 21:41people.
- 21:42So all those a lot of times intangible qualities of these candidates you have to
- 21:47account for as well.
- 21:48Now when these forecasters are using all these aspects to say that this candidate is going or
- 21:57that this election is gonna be competitive, all these forecasters have their own way of of
- 22:02combining all these things.
- 22:03This is just a an overall view of a lot of the aspects of elections that a forecaster an
- 22:10election forecaster, election predictor might use to say, this is going to be a competitive
- 22:16election.
- 22:16There's no real objective formula to to doing that, but there are a lot of things that you
- 22:21can look out for, that you know to look out for to say, okay.
- 22:25This one is going to be, an intense battle Yeah.
- 22:30Whatever office it may be.
- 22:32So now quick overview of the actual races that are supposed to be competitive.
- 22:37So some states or districts can be competitive for one race, but not necessarily for another.
- 22:43For example, North Carolina's governor is expected to say stay democratic, but it's
- 22:48considered a toss-up for president.
- 22:50New Hampshire's governor's race is expected to be much more competitive than for president.
- 22:55So a little bit of the opposite of what North Carolina's got going on there, to some extent.
- 23:03So just because you see one race as competitive in a state or district does not mean that
- 23:10another race in that state or covering that same district is also gonna be competitive.
- 23:15Again, you have to consider all these other factors that are going on.
- 23:18But some of the competitive concepts that we will cover both in this episode and or briefly
- 23:25in this episode and in the next few episodes, US senate, US house, governorships, state
- 23:32legislative chamber control, not specific seats for state legislatures.
- 23:36There's just way too many of those.
- 23:37There's thousands of those.
- 23:39But just chambers that have a chance to flip majority party control.
- 23:43So if a Republican chamber has a chance to flip Democrat or a Democratic chamber has a chance
- 23:47to flip Republican, those are the kinds of chambers that we'll be talking about too.
- 23:53First up, US senate.
- 23:55So the overall US senate picture, we have 51 democrats, which includes those 4 independents
- 24:00that either caucus with or and or used to be democrats, but have now become independents.
- 24:07Kyrsten Soudema of Arizona, Joe Manchin of West Virginia, both who are not running for
- 24:13reelection, used to be democrats.
- 24:15They are now they are now independents.
- 24:19Angus King of Maine and Bernie Sanders of Vermont are they're they're in they're a long
- 24:25time independence, that caucus with Democrats.
- 24:27But in the US Senate, only a third of the chamber is up every 2 years.
- 24:32These are 6 year terms.
- 24:33So so you have class what they call class 1 senate seats up, and 2 years later, they do
- 24:39class 2.
- 24:40And then 2 years later, they go class 3, and then 2 years after that goes back to class 1.
- 24:45I can't remember which class it is off the top of my head this year.
- 24:48I wanna say it's class 1.
- 24:49But in any case, up for election this year are 23 democrats and 11 republicans.
- 24:56And most of the seats that are expected to be competitive are held by democrats.
- 25:01So there's a really good chance for republicans to take control of the US senate this year.
- 25:07And for Republicans who'd pay control, they need one seat if Donald Trump wins because the
- 25:14vice president becomes the tie breaking vote in this in the senate.
- 25:18So whenever the US senate splits 5050 on something, the vice president serves as the
- 25:23tiebreaker.
- 25:23If Donald Trump wins, JD Vance from Ohio would become that tiebreaker.
- 25:29Now if if Kamala Harris wins the presidency and then Tim Waltz becomes the, the the vice
- 25:39president, then republics of republicans would need to take 2 seats to take majority control
- 25:47of the US senate because then they'd have 51 seats.
- 25:51And the states that are expected to be at least be a little bit competitive, if not very
- 25:55competitive, and a couple of them I'm I'm a little skeptical of, and I'll talk about those
- 25:59in just a minute.
- 26:00But Arizona, Florida, Maryland, Michigan, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada or Nevada, Ohio,
- 26:08Pennsylvania, Texas, and Wisconsin.
- 26:11I don't personally expect a competitive election in Florida, and it is it's one of
- 26:15those ones that most forecasters see as, like, yeah, there's a little bit of a chance, but
- 26:21it's probably gonna stay Republican.
- 26:23Reason being, I talked a little bit about it earlier, and it it is my state, so I have a
- 26:28little bit more of a ground level view of what goes on in Florida politics.
- 26:34Democrats in Florida have had a very they had a lot of trouble with turning out their voters
- 26:40over the past at least 25 years, and now there's a 1000000 more registered Republicans.
- 26:46There's still a lot of nonparty affiliated voters that could potentially vote, democrat,
- 26:54but republicans have been a lot better at getting their base to turn out than democrats
- 27:00have.
- 27:00So I'm I'm pretty skeptical of of that one.
- 27:02That one is incumbent Rick Scott who was a 2 turn governor of Florida going against Debbie
- 27:07McCarsel Powell who used to be in the US house.
- 27:10So expect that to be retained by Republican Rick Scott, but there is a little bit of a
- 27:19chance that maybe that's an upset, but I would not count on it.
- 27:22And I'm also slightly skeptical of Texas' competitiveness, not as much as for Florida.
- 27:28It's definitely gonna be more competitive than than Florida's is, but, with republican Ted
- 27:33Cruz, not necessarily the most popular with his own party, but and until further notice, I'd
- 27:41I'd I'm a little skeptical of just how how much Texas Democrats have gained ground on
- 27:49Republicans statewide, but we'll see how it goes.
- 27:53Competitive races for the US House.
- 27:55So overall US House picture right now, 220 Republicans, 200 12 Democrats, 3 vacancies.
- 28:03Unlike with the US senate, everybody in the US house is up for election every 2 years.
- 28:09Republicans can only have a net loss of 2 seats to retain control of the chamber because then
- 28:13they have 218, 218 being just over half of 235.
- 28:19Excuse me.
- 28:20435.
- 28:21So and only about 50 to 80 seats depending on which forecasters you use are considering only
- 28:28only about 50 to 80 seats are considered to be competitive to some extent.
- 28:33And races all over the place that are competitive, we can't cover all of them, but
- 28:39some of the states or some states with competitive districts that I won't be
- 28:42highlighting in this particular series included some in California, Colorado, Iowa, New Jersey,
- 28:48New York, Ohio, Oregon, Washington, and Virginia.
- 28:53Now you see a couple of those states and you say, oh, well, aren't those very democratic or
- 28:57or aren't those very republican?
- 28:59Yes.
- 29:00Statewide statewide candidates for democrats might not be competitive in one of those states
- 29:07or probably good candidates might not be competitive in in statewide in those in those
- 29:14states, but there's specific districts where there's more of the disadvantaged party for
- 29:20lack of a better term.
- 29:21So for example, California and New York, very democratic states, but there are pockets around
- 29:27those states where knee where where Republicans are a lot more competitive, a lot more
- 29:33powerful.
- 29:34So just keep that in mind with districts versus the overall states.
- 29:39But contests we will dive into later include Alaska's at large district, Arizona's 1st and
- 29:446th, Maine's second, Michigan's 7th, Minnesota's second, Montana's first, Nebraska's
- 29:522nd, North Carolina's 1st, and then Pennsylvania's 7th 8th.
- 29:55And I'll talk obviously a little bit more about what makes those competitive and why that I
- 29:59highlight those ones specifically besides the fact that we just don't have time to cover all
- 30:04of those.
- 30:05So competitive races for governor.
- 30:07Overall, gubernatorial picture, the fancy way to say governor, gubernatorial.
- 30:1127 Republicans and 23 Democrats right now.
- 30:15Like like with state legislatures in 2010, Republicans made a lot of gains in
- 30:19governorships, and they've still held on to majority for that time.
- 30:24But how many they've had is ebbed and flowed.
- 30:28But this year, it's only 8 Republicans and 3 Democrats that are up for election.
- 30:32Most governorships are up in midterm elections.
- 30:35So 2022, 2026, 2030, so on and so forth.
- 30:41Now there's too few competitive races in 2024 for democrats to take a majority of
- 30:47governorships, but they can't make enough of a game to where they potentially claim a majority
- 30:52in 2026.
- 30:53Or there's even a slight chance they did do so even in 2025 because Virginia's governor
- 31:00happens in odd numbered years, 2025, 2029, 2033, so on.
- 31:07Glenn Youngkin is the Republican, but in Virginia, governors can only serve one term,
- 31:12then they have a sit out term, then they can run again if they want, but they can only serve
- 31:16one term.
- 31:17They can't even serve 2 consecutive terms.
- 31:19They have to, serve 1 and then sit out.
- 31:22So there's never an incumbency advantage really for that election unless you consider
- 31:29incumbency advantage for a party, instead of a specific person.
- 31:35So but for democrats to take a majority of governorships, they're probably gonna have to
- 31:39wait till 2026.
- 31:41New Hampshire's this year, talking this year, New Hampshire's is easily the most competitive.
- 31:48Republican Chris Sununu won 4 straight elections, and in New Hampshire, New Hampshire
- 31:53and Vermont actually have 2 year terms for their governor, whereas everywhere else is 4
- 31:57year terms.
- 31:59But he's not running for reelection again.
- 32:01So despite and and and he he won 4 straight elections, see, 2016, 2018, 2020, and 2022.
- 32:093 of those years, democrats actually won US senate race, and those are governor and US
- 32:15senate.
- 32:15Those are both statewide races because everybody in the state is voting on that
- 32:20office.
- 32:22So that makes his wins a bit more stark, I guess.
- 32:28But before Sununu won in 2016, democrats had won New Hampshire's governor governorship 6
- 32:36times, 6 straight times, 2004 to 2014, and then they and they'd won it 9 of the last 10 times,
- 32:422002 being the exception there.
- 32:45Historically, republicans have won the governorship there a lot, but in recent memory
- 32:50before Sununu, Democrats were winning the governorship of New Hampshire the vast majority
- 32:57of the time.
- 32:58But election forecasters see an outside chance for Republicans in North Carolina and
- 33:04Washington and Democrats in Indiana in part because the incumbents in those races are not
- 33:11running for reelection, whether that's by choice or because they are term limited.
- 33:16And Democrats have won Washington's governorship since the 1984 election, so
- 33:20they've done it for almost 40 years straight now.
- 33:23They win it again this year.
- 33:25It will be 40 years straight.
- 33:27So North Carolina, Washington, Indiana, little bit of competitiveness competitiveness there,
- 33:34but probably not gonna whip parties in in in North Carolina Washington's case.
- 33:40Republicans probably not gonna win.
- 33:42Indiana's case, Democrats probably not gonna win, but you might wanna pay attention though
- 33:46just in case there's a big upset in those elections.
- 33:51The last group we're gonna talk about, state legislative chambers.
- 33:54So, again, the overall chambers, not specific seats because there's just way too many of
- 34:00those.
- 34:01The overall state legislative chambers picture, 9 there's 99 total state legislative chambers,
- 34:06not a 100 because new Nebraska decided in the 19 thirties to become unicameral, so they only
- 34:12have a state senate.
- 34:14Eighty 5 chambers across 44 states are having elections this year, and there's a few cases
- 34:20where only one chamber of a state's legislature is having elections, but not the other chamber.
- 34:24For example, Michigan senate is not having elections, but the Michigan house is.
- 34:30And there are some cases where only half a chamber seat is up for election, typically,
- 34:36senates.
- 34:37Now since 2010, Republicans have controlled the majority of state legislative chambers.
- 34:43The number they've had has ebbed and flowed over time, but since 2010, they've had a
- 34:47majority of those chambers.
- 34:49Right now, Republicans control 56 Chambers and Democrats control 40.
- 34:54In Alaska's case, they're technically republican majorities, but they have cross
- 34:58party coalitions.
- 34:59And in the house, there's a few independents that are part of that coalition.
- 35:03There's no independents in the Alaska senate, but republicans and democrats a lot of the
- 35:08republicans and then all the democrats are part of a governing coalition there.
- 35:12Alaska's got some very quirky politics compared to the rest of the nation.
- 35:18And then Nebraska's, you that state senate, not only is it, you know, not only is Nebraska's
- 35:26state legislature camera where it only has 1 chamber, in this case, senate, but they are
- 35:31also considered nonpartisan.
- 35:33Although in reality, most of them are Republican.
- 35:36But nominally, they are nonpartisan.
- 35:41So looking at the potential for partisan control flips for overall chambers, not
- 35:45specific seats that are battlegrounds, there's plenty of chambers where majority party control
- 35:50is isn't up for grabs.
- 35:52They have specific seats that are competitive.
- 35:54So we're not talking about those here.
- 35:55We're talking about chambers that could potentially flip, majority.
- 36:01So chambers with reasonable potential to flip majority partisan control.
- 36:07Alaska, we just talked about with the house and senate.
- 36:09Now maybe they'll keep those power sharing agreements that they have between republicans
- 36:14and democrats and in the case of the the state house there, independence.
- 36:19We'll have to see see if Republicans increase their numerical majority and if they decide to
- 36:26keep those governing coalitions.
- 36:28So Alaska is kind of, up in the air in terms of majority control because of those, coalition
- 36:36agreements.
- 36:38Arizona's house and senate is razor thin Republican majorities in both of those.
- 36:44Democrats have made gains in in Arizona politics in recent years.
- 36:49Will they be able to finally flip both of those the the belt of states, house, and state senate
- 36:55chambers there?
- 36:57We'll talk more about that obviously, later on this week.
- 37:00Michigan's house, which we just mentioned before, senate's not having elections this
- 37:05year, but Michigan's house potentially could flip back.
- 37:08It it just became democrat, majority democrat back end who want the 2022 elections, so it
- 37:14could potentially flip right back.
- 37:17New Hampshire's house and senate, Pennsylvania's house and senate, and Wisconsin
- 37:22senate.
- 37:23All those are ones that could potentially flip, mid majority party control.
- 37:29So we're gonna talk obviously a little bit more about those later this week.
- 37:35And because this is sort of a multiparter of the, this part 2 is gonna technically be more
- 37:44than a single part.
- 37:46I'm actually gonna do a random question at the end of this string of episodes focusing on the
- 37:50non presidential races.
- 37:52So no random questions today.
- 37:55I know you're all very disappointed.
- 37:59So I love I love doing random questions, but we'll we'll we'll do in the one of those after
- 38:05the next in the, either at the end of the next episode or episode after that.
- 38:09Depends on how long, the analysis of these non presidential races is.
- 38:16Can we only have so much time, But I'll try to pack as much useful information on all of those
- 38:22as I can.
- 38:24So we'll close it out here.
- 38:26Thank you again as always for listening to my ramblings.
- 38:31Time me on Facebook call, but but more of the the links in the show notes, but Facebook,
- 38:40LinkedIn, Medium, if you want me on your own podcast, matchmaker FM.
- 38:45My book on Amazon, why independence really win elections and how they could become more
- 38:49competitive.
- 38:51My website, paulraeder.org.
- 38:53That's r a d e r.
- 38:55And with that, we're gonna close out.
- 38:57So until next time.
- 39:00Take care.