Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 150: On making a new life in Paris with Susanna Schrobsdorff
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trimmuta. Almost a year ago, I launched a
- 0:14series on my newsletter called Leaving America, based on the
- 0:17multitude of reasons Americans opt to leave the country and why
- 0:20many of them, as it happens, end up in Paris.
- 0:24Through this series, and through my network of creative women in
- 0:26Paris, I've connected with so many brilliant Americans who
- 0:29have moved, want to move, or at least understand the desire to.
- 0:33And that includes Susannah Schrobstorf, a former executive
- 0:37editor and columnist for Time magazine who moved to Paris
- 0:40within the last couple of years. Since we've met, we've talked
- 0:44endlessly about the feelings tied up and leaving one's
- 0:46homeland and what Paris has done for us as it has for so many
- 0:50before us. She joins me today to talk about
- 0:53her path to Paris, why it was the right place to settle at
- 0:56this point in her life, and on building community to withstand
- 1:00the toughest of times. Susanna, welcome to the show.
- 1:05Thank you, Lindsay. I'm so happy to be here.
- 1:07I have so many questions for you and I'm not really sure where to
- 1:12begin, but I think, you know, I'm just fresh.
- 1:16Well, couple weeks off from my, you know, returning from my trip
- 1:20to the US, which summoned a lot of feelings.
- 1:23And you and I have talked a lot about the feeling of, you know,
- 1:27what was or what we thought we knew from our homeland.
- 1:31And then, you know, living here. I've lived here a lot longer.
- 1:34But you've been coming to France for a very long time.
- 1:37So I guess maybe that was the impetus in wanting to have you
- 1:40on the show for the first episode of The fall.
- 1:44Why are you here? Why are you in Paris?
- 1:47How did you get here? You're a newswoman.
- 1:50Yep. A long career in the news media
- 1:53as the executive editor of Time and a former columnist.
- 1:58How did you get here? Well, I came originally.
- 2:01I was here at the age of 26. I was the youngest person, I
- 2:05think Time magazine sent abroad with all the cushy benefits of
- 2:08an expat, you know, allowance, as they called it back then.
- 2:13And but they sent me to do to to upgrade the computers all over
- 2:19Europe and to handle the logistics for all the Olympics
- 2:21that were happening here. And so it was a very different
- 2:25life then. And it was great and then except
- 2:29that I didn't speak French and I'd never been to France.
- 2:31And so the culture shock was enormous.
- 2:33I cried for three months. As you might imagine, the French
- 2:36did not want to be have their stuff digitized.
- 2:40They did not want the new computers.
- 2:42They did not want any of the the people who are the core of the
- 2:45Time Bureau. And then it turned out all
- 2:47right. And they're all still my
- 2:48friends. And I stayed friends with them
- 2:50all these years. And I came back every few years
- 2:53to see my friends that lived here.
- 2:54So I maintained ties with France and I was transferred to
- 2:59Brussels, then back to New York. Then I had all these children.
- 3:02I mean there were only two. But that's a lot it.
- 3:05Felt like a lot. I married.
- 3:06I married a Swede that I met in Paris in the basement of the
- 3:09Catholic Church in the 6th with a bunch of Swedish au pairs and
- 3:14me. Why were you there?
- 3:16Taking French because I didn't speak any French when I got
- 3:18here. In fact, I learned my French
- 3:19watching Bewitched dump dubbed in French because I knew the
- 3:22plot also, which is, you know, limited conjugations and a
- 3:30simple plot. Yeah, the Hulk doesn't really.
- 3:32Yeah, it doesn't really emote. Like it was like, yeah, it
- 3:34worked well. It worked well.
- 3:35So, yeah. So I was taking French at night
- 3:37and he was a Swede, Swedish programmer, Vulcan, basically
- 3:41Smit, you know, like Swedish programmer in Paris.
- 3:43And we fell in love and we got married in the north of Sweden
- 3:46by the Arctic Circle, which is another issue.
- 3:49And all those people that were upset with me with for all the
- 3:52digitization came to the wedding and it was fun.
- 3:55And then they moved me to Brussels for a year and a half.
- 3:57Then they moved me back to New York and I missed Europe.
- 4:02My family has a long history in Europe.
- 4:04I lived in Berlin when I was a kid.
- 4:06You're German, my dad. Is German and Russian, so you
- 4:09know, but I moved to Brooklyn, which is fabulous.
- 4:12And then I had the the thousands of children too, too.
- 4:17And I ended up just consulting for Time for a period while I
- 4:20was raising the kids. And then one day I woke up and I
- 4:23said I have to go back to work. But Time was being one of its
- 4:27media convulsions in which it was being bought or sold from
- 4:29Time Warner or what you know, as we know, this is all that it had
- 4:33begun, the first wave of media insanity.
- 4:36And so I knocked on the door of people at Newsweek who had I'd
- 4:39met while doing the American presidential political
- 4:44convention logistics, you know, the Democratic and Republican
- 4:47conventions. And I begged the woman who ran
- 4:50the the website to hire me and I begged her every week for six
- 4:54months, I said. And she was my age.
- 4:57It was when they let people who were like 40 something onto the
- 5:00web at the time. It was before when the web
- 5:02nobody cared. So they said just would shuffle
- 5:03people over there. So she hired me, and I didn't
- 5:07tell her that my news desk editor title wasn't really
- 5:10editing. I was doing computers.
- 5:13So I came and I had done reporting, a lot of reporting in
- 5:15France, but it was sort of subterranean.
- 5:17Sure. She hired me, and then that
- 5:18started. By the end, I was running the
- 5:20website. And then it, as you may have
- 5:23heard, the Internet became a huge thing, even for Newsweek,
- 5:26which had denied it up until that point.
- 5:28Really, it was one of those places that had resisted
- 5:32tremendously. I won't name the editor that was
- 5:35in charge then, but he's a famous historian and he was not
- 5:38even willing to. He didn't really want to even
- 5:40say the word Internet. He really prized the print
- 5:42edition. So then.
- 5:45So then I was there for a bit and then I went to Time magazine
- 5:49when Newsweek was purchased by a billionaire.
- 5:53Oh, the first of those scenarios, right?
- 5:55Well, not the first, but you know, just a cycle of.
- 5:57Yeah, we, I didn't know that. I've I've been bought and sold
- 5:59by billionaires 3 times. So I just want to point that.
- 6:02Out. Oh yeah, yeah.
- 6:02So, you know, you know what the the uproar is about?
- 6:05Yeah. And then went back to time, but
- 6:07now as a new person, as a person who was fully a journalist.
- 6:11And so I'm just saying to all of you, you can be 43 and start a
- 6:15whole different kind of career. And and I stayed at time for
- 6:18quite a while and then I left to do writing full time right after
- 6:25the pandemic. And at that point, I wanted my
- 6:28kids were heading towards the end of college and I said, I
- 6:30really want to figure out where to live once they're graduated.
- 6:34And I just wanted to come back. And I thought of this as home
- 6:37always. I thought every time I would
- 6:39come in from the airport and charge the call when I come
- 6:41back, I knew like you'd come in in the first time, you see the
- 6:46little glimpses of the inner, the inner periphery can go, OK,
- 6:50I'm home so. It's really, it's so interesting
- 6:53you say that because that's kind of the feeling I had when I even
- 6:56before I got to the pay reef, when I got when the plane
- 6:59literally landed and were were were creeping up to the gate and
- 7:04and going to get off the plane, that's when I felt lighter.
- 7:07And the respiration. Yeah.
- 7:09Settles, huh? Yeah.
- 7:10And I don't, you know, that's not to say that there aren't
- 7:12stresses. I mean, there was someone who,
- 7:14you know, cut me off. And there are people who are
- 7:16very like Moody when you get off the plane and you're like, oh,
- 7:19I'm also home to that. But there I was, I guess it's
- 7:22now the, my familiar. And it feels a little bit more
- 7:28like an emotion I can manage. Whereas the, the unknown, the
- 7:33constant, just like latent anxiety in the US feels
- 7:38unmanageable. And I say this knowing I have a
- 7:40lot of American listeners, so I don't want anyone to feel like,
- 7:43you know, I'm, I'm, I think we're superior because we live
- 7:47over here. In fact, there's a certain level
- 7:49of self torment that we put ourselves under in trying to
- 7:55understand the place we come from.
- 7:58But from afar. Do you feel that?
- 8:00I mean, it took a lot for me to get here.
- 8:02And so in when you, there's a big difference between people
- 8:05who are like trailing spouses who come here or people who are
- 8:08sent by their job and they are unclear.
- 8:10Well, I sort of had to fight to get here, sell everything I
- 8:13owned, come here at a risk that they might not renew my visa.
- 8:16Anything could happen. But do you feel a little bit
- 8:21like people think it's either they think it's a fantasy dream
- 8:24that nothing like that your life must be perfect and that the
- 8:27other things that might happen and difficulties of life don't
- 8:30don't apply or you don't get a right to complain because.
- 8:33I think it's more, I think it's mostly that except that I like
- 8:36to say that, you know, obviously I have family living there.
- 8:41Some of the people I love the most are there.
- 8:43And it affects us here as American citizens because we pay
- 8:48taxes also to support consular services and all the things that
- 8:52are supposed to function for Americans no matter where
- 8:54they're living. I mean, that's begun that began
- 8:56with the military living abroad, that these sort of services and
- 9:00rights were extended. So I understand it's not the
- 9:02same day-to-day, you know, chaos, but if you're like us,
- 9:08and I know that we're not alone, we follow things so closely that
- 9:12it's as though we're there. I think it's just it does help
- 9:15to have a physical distance, but it is it feels like careening
- 9:20into an abyss. America looms large, not just
- 9:24for us. My French friends, my European
- 9:26friends feel every shudder. You know that old saying that if
- 9:29America gets a cold, the rest of the world gets the flu because
- 9:34the shudder of the American economy will ripple out their
- 9:38decisions on defense? We.
- 9:40See that now? Yep.
- 9:42This week I also think my kids are there my kids are gay,
- 9:46they're they're queer kids and they are anxious.
- 9:50I also think things have changed since you moved out of the US.
- 9:54The income disparity between top and bottom is gone.
- 9:57The, the level of insecurity where one bad medical bill, 1
- 10:02bad, one loss of job, the insecurity after the pandemic
- 10:05has left people feeling precarious.
- 10:08And that tension, there's that tension I think that you
- 10:11probably feel and the prices for food and housing dramatic.
- 10:16And it, and it did affect my decision to come here because I
- 10:21could be living in New York as an editor at a salary job or as
- 10:25a in a corporate job. I could not have lived there as
- 10:28a person who wants to write books and essays.
- 10:31Absolutely not because the cost of living in New York City,
- 10:34particularly, but also elsewhere is so tremendously high.
- 10:37I would have had to get some other kind of job with certainly
- 10:41with health insurance and I, I don't think it would have been
- 10:45possible. I think I would have had the
- 10:46same. You know, my hair was falling
- 10:48out by the 3rd billionaire. Really, it really the level of
- 10:52stress was so high. And I, and I do think that
- 10:55there's a, there's, it's palpable, right?
- 10:58It's palpable because if you, I take two kids out for bagels and
- 11:03cappuccinos and maybe one smoothie and it's $62.00.
- 11:07I look at my kids, I'm like, how are you guys doing this?
- 11:08And I'm like, mom, we don't go out, right?
- 11:10So you know what I mean? You're not wrong that things
- 11:13have changed. No.
- 11:14And that's even before the cultural upheaval.
- 11:17Yeah. And, and I, I feel that
- 11:19although, you know, it's interesting that we're talking
- 11:21about that disparity and in France right now there's the,
- 11:24you know, the, the new Prime Minister and they're talking
- 11:27about the 2% tax. That's going to be in my
- 11:28newsletter, the 2% tax plan proposed by Gabriel Zucchman on
- 11:34the ultra wealthy. So you know, it pertains to like
- 11:371800 who earn over or who have a wealth of over €100 million.
- 11:42And, and when you look at the, it's, I mean, it's staggering.
- 11:45If you look at the, the wealth disparity and how the wealthier
- 11:49have grown wealthier over the last 15 years, it is 6 fold.
- 11:55Yeah. And, and so, you know, I think
- 11:57for the most part, a lot of Europe is undergoing the same
- 11:59sort of tension. And if these countries don't
- 12:02want to tax people properly and they're giving these sort of,
- 12:05you know, free passes to, to billionaires, where is that
- 12:08going to leave us? The only thing that I feel a
- 12:10little bit more reassured about, and maybe I, I mean, I'd love to
- 12:13hear your thoughts on this because you came long before I
- 12:16was ever here, is the propensity toward protest here and, and
- 12:22like deep revolutionary spirit that could be reignited.
- 12:26I mean, maybe we're almost there.
- 12:28Think the unions are strong here you see the, the, the
- 12:30difficulties in America to gather up a a strong response.
- 12:33I think the, that the, the, the wealth gap is so dramatic in the
- 12:37United States that the money like it's, it's impossible to
- 12:40imagine. And if you are so precarious
- 12:42that you don't have healthcare, if you don't have a job and you,
- 12:47it is actually harder to protest.
- 12:49You don't have days off. You know, we take, you can't be
- 12:52out on a Tuesday. You, you don't have sick days.
- 12:56So it is interesting to see that if you keep it very, the people
- 13:00who are in the most precarious states have, have the least
- 13:04bandwidth to show their discontent in the United States.
- 13:07And so that's one thing that strikes me.
- 13:11And you would think that if, if what was happening in the United
- 13:14States were happening here, I don't know.
- 13:15I think they would just, you would see what will happen with
- 13:18the Gilligan like tenfold. So I, I'm worried about the
- 13:23America because there is, it's very hard for people to just
- 13:27stop study because they don't have any.
- 13:29They don't. Most Americans don't even have
- 13:31$500 in a bank for an emergency. I mean, that is an absolute
- 13:35fact. So you lose a day of work, you
- 13:37lose a day pay, you know, if you're sick.
- 13:39And in many cases, not everybody, but a lot.
- 13:41So I'm wondering because, you know, Paris has been a refuge
- 13:45for so many people for centuries.
- 13:48Like, you know, Americans have been coming to not not just to
- 13:52Paris, but if we're speaking just about Paris for so long,
- 13:55this is not a new trend we're seeing in people at various
- 14:00points of their lives choosing to, to uproot and, and settle
- 14:04here. We know obviously James Baldwin
- 14:08and all of the musicians who felt ostracized from the, from
- 14:11the states thinkers. We might now see scientists
- 14:14being welcomed here because they can't do their work and research
- 14:19freely in the United States. So what do you make of Paris in
- 14:24this moment that has its own very real tensions and this
- 14:29desire from foreigners, but specifically Americans, to keep
- 14:35to keep it in their front of mind as a possibility, as a
- 14:40home? I well, I think they'll based on
- 14:43the number of people that I know who now want, who are asking me
- 14:46to send them apartment listings. It's enormous.
- 14:51You know, they think that this this is like their getaway,
- 14:57their escape hatch, right. They don't really fully, I
- 15:00think, understand the cultural adaptation that they might have
- 15:03to make. They also that I wonder also
- 15:05what adaptation adapting Paris would have to do because the one
- 15:09thing I noticed that Americans come and they have a lot of
- 15:11money compared to the French here.
- 15:14So the, the friends that the people who have the money to
- 15:16come here will find their money goes further here.
- 15:19But it's, I'm not saying offensive, but it can be a
- 15:22little rude to come. And you'll see what happens here
- 15:27when, if Americans start doing what they did in Portugal and
- 15:29start paying high prices for the apartments and buying everything
- 15:32up. And I say this as a person who
- 15:34came here. But, but I, I think that could
- 15:39all that could also be a backlash.
- 15:41There could be a backlash to too many Americans moving in.
- 15:44So far nobody has looked at me and I'm the only one of I'm one
- 15:48of two Americans in my building and the other one has been there
- 15:50for 40 years. So she's she's grandfathered in
- 15:52and she was born in Paris, but she's an American citizen still.
- 15:56So I think they do dream of it. One of my friends who visited me
- 16:01immediately bought an apartment near the next year and she comes
- 16:04like in a pieta tere. She doesn't move to, but she
- 16:06thinks of it as in case it gets bad.
- 16:09And her partner is an African American, so she feels
- 16:13particularly nervous about staying there.
- 16:16So. Yeah.
- 16:17And not just Paris, you know, London, Portugal, Italy.
- 16:21We there's the conversation about who can get an European
- 16:24passport is through the roof. If you go on Instagram, you'll
- 16:28see that 1/2 the Americans I know are getting ads for those,
- 16:32those immigration lawyers that will get you a passport.
- 16:35And it's a cottage industry now. Yeah.
- 16:38I think that there's a point where the Europeans are going to
- 16:40go. Hey, but I don't know.
- 16:44Yeah, I, I, I think a lot about that particular issue of, of the
- 16:49Americans that have, you know, accelerated gentrification in
- 16:54places like Lisbon, for example. And, and, and in, in a lot of
- 16:58these countries, the, the average income is far lower than
- 17:02the average income in Paris. And so I feel like we don't yet
- 17:05yet, or maybe we won't feel it to the same degree in Paris.
- 17:10But there are people struggling, of course.
- 17:11And I didn't move here on AUS salary.
- 17:15I mean, I've always, you know, I had to sort of grapple with the
- 17:18fact that I don't earn the same amount as, you know, people my
- 17:22age who have gone a corporate route in America.
- 17:26But I am seeing the people whose money goes quite far here.
- 17:28But for how long? The dollar is declining rapidly.
- 17:32Since I've been here. I'm sure that you feel that.
- 17:34Yeah, you know, but I, I don't know.
- 17:36I'm I'm wondering what do you think it is about Paris that
- 17:40still holds so for people I. Think that I wrote a piece a
- 17:45while back for time about this, about after Bataclan, after the
- 17:48attacks. And I said the the place that it
- 17:50holds in the American imagination, which is I think
- 17:53that the generations and generations and generations of
- 17:56people who've come for their semester abroad, for their
- 17:59honeymoons, for their to go to schools, go to Bozo to do
- 18:03something. It is it is the place where you
- 18:06go that is non commercial in their heads.
- 18:09It is the place where you go for art, for food, for the things
- 18:14that are the not just the pleasures in life, but the more
- 18:17basic things that are less a capitalistic in a way.
- 18:20I mean, they sure, some come for shopping.
- 18:23I'm not diminishing, but those aren't necessarily the people I
- 18:25hear wanting to move here, right?
- 18:26The people I hear wanting to move here want to come to live.
- 18:30And you know, the, the old, the thing they say most often to me,
- 18:33I want to work to live, not live to work is exactly, which is not
- 18:37a new thing. No, no, no.
- 18:38But as hyper capitalism, extreme capitalism is not just embraced
- 18:45by the people in the administration right now as
- 18:48Darwinian capitalism is embraced.
- 18:51I think that is particularly appealing about Paris, on top of
- 18:57the fact that this is the dream to come here to, to be amongst
- 19:00people who read books, who love art, and in a city that spends a
- 19:08lot of time thinking about what's beautiful.
- 19:11You know, I just had a conversation with a group of
- 19:14French people at lunch last week.
- 19:16And again, it was like a, a table of people from very
- 19:19different backgrounds, but who managed to have plenty of things
- 19:23to talk about. And one of the things that
- 19:25occurred to me that we ended up discussing was that there's
- 19:29still this potential for intellectual debate.
- 19:32And not saying that everyone feels comfortable in that space,
- 19:35but everyone's thoughts are sort of valid and it can be can be
- 19:39debated and no one gets sort of, you know, violent or, or or or
- 19:48judgmental over the fact that we're having an intellectual
- 19:51debate. I mean, there's still this very
- 19:53philosophical foundation to to dialogue in among French people,
- 19:58I think. And so I was just astounded that
- 20:00when you take a situation like that or a gathering, you compare
- 20:04it to the overt anti intellectualism in America right
- 20:07now and banning books and seeking people uninformed.
- 20:10It is all the more staggering. But you know, like I, I wonder,
- 20:14given the, you know this. Our administration's inability
- 20:18to, and granted, it's not the first, but the inability to tax
- 20:23the billionaires and to actually hold them accountable for what
- 20:26they they owe. You know, are we becoming too
- 20:31American? Here, well, I mean, Macron has
- 20:34gotten Flack, I believe, about being too probusiness when who
- 20:39knows what's going to happen next Here.
- 20:41I think that there is a but I get this strong sense of
- 20:44respect, almost reverence for the working person here.
- 20:50Like there there's kind of a very strong like pride, I guess,
- 20:53in the people who because you can the restaurant managers are
- 20:57they had they feel like it's a metier.
- 20:58You know, it's a career and it can be a thing you do your whole
- 21:02life because you get a decent vacation.
- 21:04You know, a restaurant manager who goes to Polynesia, who's
- 21:08bought a small apartment that he rents out, and he has a life.
- 21:11And is this a restaurant owner you know?
- 21:12No, a restaurant manager, not a manager.
- 21:15That you know. Yeah, that I know.
- 21:16And I thought there's nobody who'd manage a cafe like you
- 21:20just wouldn't. You wouldn't ever just have.
- 21:22He doesn't want more than that, doesn't live on the edge of
- 21:26Paris, not down in the chic bits.
- 21:30But there's a certain respect for the for the work, right, for
- 21:34the, for the working class. And I think that's why the
- 21:36unions maybe are still holding on.
- 21:38So maybe there'll be more support here for the taxes for
- 21:41the billionaire and then anybody coming in will have to face up
- 21:44to that. But I don't know.
- 21:45It'd be really interesting to see whether France can do it.
- 21:49I don't think America, I think that's over now.
- 21:51I don't think that's going to happen.
- 21:53And get Gabriel Zukman has been interviewed as talking about how
- 21:56the US used to have one of the most progressive tax systems and
- 22:00so. Even under Reagan it was.
- 22:02Dramatically different, yeah. You know, I mean, I think the
- 22:05the administration doesn't really Revere the working class.
- 22:10And they say they do, but actually everything, all the
- 22:12policies that are in place, that what what is revered is the idea
- 22:16that you can become rich, the idea that you can become one of
- 22:21the people. Here or in the US?
- 22:23Oh, right, no, in the US there's still this like lack of class,
- 22:26class consciousness. And I'm not saying that France's
- 22:30way of functioning where the working class don't feel like
- 22:34they can ever. That's the opposite, that's.
- 22:38The. Opposite, but there needs to be
- 22:40this middle ground. And I think the the this
- 22:42obsession with becoming wealthy in America is part of what has
- 22:46led to this overwhelming, blinding support for, you know,
- 22:51an administration that doesn't have their interests in mind.
- 22:53But what's interesting is there is deep suspicion for extreme
- 22:56wealth in France. And so that's why there's
- 22:58overwhelming support among the population for these types of
- 23:01taxes. So we're talking about, you
- 23:04know, 1800 people who are complaining when they're still
- 23:08going to remain wealthier than most of us can ever imagine
- 23:13being. Sort of back to when why we're
- 23:16why I'm here. It's not just because it's
- 23:18beautiful, but it's because of a value system and the micro
- 23:23connections every single day with the, the, the level that
- 23:27that it's sort of it's built. Everything's built on
- 23:30relationships, the relationship with the person that sells you
- 23:32the fruit and the bread and you, you and less transactional
- 23:37certainly than New York, right. And I'm maybe because I'm good
- 23:41at that. Maybe I like it here because I
- 23:43like that, you know, maybe because I was a journalist that.
- 23:45You like talking to people? Like being with people and, and
- 23:48that value system of like, we don't love you.
- 23:51We don't think you're brilliant just because you have money.
- 23:54And in America, money is, can be, I'm not saying for
- 23:58everybody, certainly not for my friends, is associated with
- 24:01goodness and smartness. And you know, like the, the, the
- 24:04qualities placed on people who have money and the trust placed
- 24:08in them is extraordinary. And here it's a little less and
- 24:12it's one of the values. I sort of like you said,
- 24:14suspicion, a bit of suspicious. Why do you have all that money
- 24:17in America? It's like, it's like, you must
- 24:19be amazing. Because you have done well for
- 24:22yourself. We don't really care how you got
- 24:23it, but. And I, I don't think I can me
- 24:26can change that. So I'm here now, right?
- 24:28So that's so that's one of the one of the you when you go
- 24:32figure out where you want to be in the world, Sometimes you
- 24:35don't. This place isn't perfect.
- 24:37There are lots of things, but you have to find the, the place
- 24:40where the faults, the things that are not right are things
- 24:43you can live with and the things that that really matter to you
- 24:47align with something in like in your little Rubik's Cube of a
- 24:50heart, like they click in, you know, but doesn't it break your
- 24:54heart? I, I wrote about this a while
- 24:58back. I, I thought I really ran out of
- 25:02America. I sold my stuff in six months.
- 25:04I sold my apartment, gave away everything, wanted a fresh
- 25:08start, walked in here and thought, done with that.
- 25:11Don't have to read American news got I'm OK.
- 25:14And I went to see this Bob Dylan movie and they were playing
- 25:18music from the 60s. And when we were they were
- 25:22talking about, you know, segregation and all these
- 25:24terrible things. But then the Pete Seeger
- 25:26character was singing this land is your land.
- 25:28And I started to cry and I thought, what the heck, I don't
- 25:33love him. I mean, I left.
- 25:35It's sort of like looking at an old boyfriend and going oh, you
- 25:39know, but but I and I realized that my heart was breaking for
- 25:42something that feels lost now, like feels out of reach, and I
- 25:47do. Care if there, of course we
- 25:49care. You know, and I can't, I can't
- 25:52quit hoping. That something will.
- 25:57Yeah, it will. The the, the idea we used to
- 26:01have of the country will redeem it so they don't get overturned
- 26:04somehow. Maybe even better because we'll
- 26:07have to fix all the things that were wrong or or.
- 26:10But you and I, never you and I discussed this.
- 26:12I was never a believer in American exceptionalism.
- 26:15My father spent a lot of time taking apart American foreign
- 26:18policy and American pastry in particular, which made him very
- 26:21upset because it was unattractive.
- 26:23Could not understand. But he was German.
- 26:24He was German in Russian, he grew up in Germany and then
- 26:27lived in Canada for a while. So I never thought we were the
- 26:32greatest country in the world. And for the people who did, it
- 26:36was always a little bewildering to me.
- 26:38And you grew up that way. You grew up believing a little.
- 26:42Bit. Or not.
- 26:43I don't think I ever grew up in a family that overtly raised the
- 26:48flag for for everything America did, but also wasn't overtly
- 26:54critical at every turn. And I think that could be
- 26:57because when I was growing up, there was still a sense of
- 27:01decorum between the parties, and the parties were less extreme.
- 27:04And so I think, you know, even if you didn't align with, you
- 27:07know, stuff on the right, and I'm not saying I did.
- 27:10I'm talking about maybe my parents.
- 27:12Right. Yeah.
- 27:12And the conversations I would overhear, there wasn't the same
- 27:15vitriol. I'm sure there were things
- 27:17happening that I wasn't aware of.
- 27:19But I also think the access to information has really, you
- 27:22know, changed things And. And the fact that we're all sort
- 27:26of pundits is a big problem. And so even with that, it wasn't
- 27:32until I came as a student and I started to hear, you know, like
- 27:36what French people would say about America in passing or
- 27:40based on a current event, whatever it might have been.
- 27:42But then you also, I was also here when Obama got elected for
- 27:45the first time and, and how how enthusiastic the French were to
- 27:49see that that was possible because they know that their own
- 27:52country would have never elected a non white individual.
- 27:56So I think seeing or hearing observations from foreigners on
- 28:03your homeland is like the quick way to having a reality check
- 28:08and one that we all really should have all along if we're
- 28:11not being taught. Like, we've done some good
- 28:14things, we've done plenty of bad things.
- 28:15Let's make sure, you know, we're talking about this in equal
- 28:17measure. And because I don't feel like
- 28:20the way we're taught in school is, I mean, it's impossible now,
- 28:26but definitely when I was a kid, you know, there were things that
- 28:30were awful. I remember distinctly some
- 28:33teachers being very critical of the move into Iraq when I was in
- 28:37in the classroom. And but I was, I didn't fully
- 28:40understand and I wasn't playing on social media.
- 28:43That didn't exist. I had instant messenger.
- 28:45I was chatting with friends, you know, And so I think my
- 28:48worldview was purely shaped by what I allowed myself to see on
- 28:51television and what my parents were telling me.
- 28:55And so I think I'm someone who was more open to unpacking what
- 29:02I thought I knew because I was never so gung ho America.
- 29:07We're the best, but I was also not like we're the worst.
- 29:10So I was in that, that middle space that maybe makes it
- 29:14easier. But it wasn't until I think I
- 29:16read notes on a foreign country that I really started to put
- 29:21things together. And that coincided with, you
- 29:24know, Trump's first term. And then we move into the
- 29:27pandemic. And it was just, I had so much
- 29:30time to read into all the things that, you know, I, I maybe never
- 29:35allowed myself to read into. And does that 'cause not stress,
- 29:40but difference when you're speaking with your family at
- 29:45home? Because that happens a little
- 29:49bit with not everybody that I have friends at home, they all
- 29:52kind of just want to come, but not all of you know.
- 29:55And I think, but are there people back home who, who think
- 29:58you've changed and are now more fragile, more not quite aligned
- 30:03with America the way you were before?
- 30:06Oh, yeah, I had AI was at a family gathering, but in Europe
- 30:11and someone invited a guy who had been a CEO of a big
- 30:15corporation, an American guy. And we're talking.
- 30:19And over the course of several days, you know, hearing my
- 30:22thoughts on, you know, why I would never move back and, and
- 30:26what I value so much here. You know, at some point he said,
- 30:30you know, there's nothing worse than a lapsed American.
- 30:34And I was actually pretty shocked because I don't, you
- 30:38know, I think it's more just that I have had to rethink of my
- 30:42identity entirely. And it's not that I'm lapsed.
- 30:47I'm not giving up my passport. However, you know, there were
- 30:51some blatant problems. You know, why are you?
- 30:55So I'll equipped to see it. You're educated, but you're also
- 30:58extremely wealthy. And so it's very easy for you to
- 31:00sort of for this guy at least to brush things under the rug.
- 31:04And then within my own family, I think I'm very aligned with my
- 31:09parents, but they definitely sense a greater urgency in my
- 31:14way of talking about these things.
- 31:15And they sense that I get very anxious and I'm likely to
- 31:20spiral. And, and with my sibling, I
- 31:25think she takes the very privilege.
- 31:28And I've tried to tell her this, a very privileged stance of,
- 31:31well, I just don't get into politics.
- 31:33It's like, well, your whole life is political.
- 31:35So sorry, but I think she's so uncomfortable to even address in
- 31:41her own mind what she knows is really happening, and she's not
- 31:46ready to do that, to face that reality.
- 31:49There's a little there's a little bit of frog and water for
- 31:54for people over there and also the media depending on whether
- 31:57if you're in one of the Instagram rabbit holes of or
- 32:01blue sky rabbit holes of hysteria, there's that.
- 32:04But there's a whole other world where the both sides, the
- 32:09headlines can soothe you and to slowly they're slowly sliding
- 32:14down this road as if it were normal.
- 32:17Even I have friends who are quite well known Washington
- 32:20journalists, right? Some of them semi retired, some
- 32:23of them still working. And I remember one of them not
- 32:26that long ago said, I mean, the Dems will get the house in the
- 32:31midterms and, and you know, it'll be fine.
- 32:34You know, the, you know, Trump, they'll win in a landslide.
- 32:37And I, and I, I just looked and I because we really have faith
- 32:41in the system. And I said what?
- 32:44And I realized they're institutionalists and they're
- 32:47still, they, they can't see outside this.
- 32:51And if you look at it from afar, to me, it looks like a little
- 32:53fire on the West horizon. Exactly.
- 32:56And I thought, which one of us is right?
- 32:57I don't know. I guess we'll find out.
- 32:58But but I do think it's very clear from over here when you
- 33:03see the steps that are happening, right.
- 33:04And if you ask the, you know, scholars, Anne Applebaumann, the
- 33:08Atlantic or any of the people that sort of have watched, I've
- 33:11seen this story before. But sometimes when you're in it,
- 33:14you don't see it. And what do you do?
- 33:16We can't throw up our hands and go get out now.
- 33:20But because we don't know, even if that would help, because you
- 33:24know there, you'd move here and your money would be there or you
- 33:27know, your house would be there, there's no, there's no advice to
- 33:30give. Now, the reality is some people,
- 33:34I mean, many people won't be able to afford an immigration
- 33:36lawyer. So we're talking about and, and
- 33:38so that's where the tension comes between, you know, what
- 33:41we're suggesting here and talking about the experience of
- 33:44having left. It's not that we want sympathy
- 33:48at all. It's more just that I feel for
- 33:51people in this very moment who want to leave.
- 33:54And then there's the real criticism of no, this is the
- 33:56time you come home and you fight.
- 33:58And So what do you think of that?
- 33:59Because that is just simply not. The guilt of some little guilt.
- 34:04You know, my kids who fight already are worried about the
- 34:09gay and trans community. They live in New York, so they
- 34:11feel a little bit like they're in another country.
- 34:13But if the democratic socialist candidate Donnie wins, he'll be
- 34:20a very attractive candidate for Trump to do things too.
- 34:24And so they may not be in New York, may not be immune.
- 34:29And they're they're like, well, if we leave, they have European
- 34:31passports. So if if they leave, they said,
- 34:34but what about my friends who can't leave?
- 34:37Yeah, what about my partner who can't leave?
- 34:39So there are these choices that people have to make.
- 34:41And you realize that the privilege I have massive, you
- 34:44know, to be here. There's a little guilt.
- 34:46And we sort of talked about this.
- 34:48But that that movie Paris Blues, where you have Sidney Poitier in
- 34:51the 60s going. He has Diahann Carroll, who
- 34:55saying you should come back and fight for civil rights.
- 34:58You're avoiding it. Come home to where your people
- 35:00are in fight. And I think Paul Newman in the
- 35:03same film is like I, I'm best doing my art here.
- 35:06I'm staying here because my art, my music is what I want to do
- 35:10here. And so everybody's choice is so
- 35:13individual, based on your abilities, based on what you
- 35:17love. And so do you feel like in
- 35:19choosing to be here you are, you are able to contribute to this a
- 35:24sense of community and fighting against what is currently
- 35:30happening? So in my newsletter, I don't
- 35:34write about politics. I did when I worked a time, I
- 35:37did write, I did edit politics. And the originally the
- 35:42newsletter I wrote wasn't going to be about from mental health
- 35:44during the pandemic. Like like fuck up.
- 35:47That's OK. So this would be the opposite,
- 35:50but I think there is something to say.
- 35:52And what I do say personally to my friends is that, hey, I'm
- 35:55here if you need help getting here, I'm here to help.
- 35:58And then the other thing is that you're not crazy.
- 36:03If I can say that, that this that they need to organize their
- 36:10communities, that that having a network.
- 36:12Glenys Mcnichol, the author, and I just finished a writing
- 36:14workshop. And what was interesting, these
- 36:16women were from all around the world.
- 36:18And the one thing we have a WhatsApp group set up and the
- 36:21one thing we said is that if something goes crazy in the
- 36:24world because people are talking like that, we feel grateful to
- 36:28know all of you and all these other countries so that we can
- 36:30connect. So what's I feel will be
- 36:33happening is a localizing of community connections.
- 36:39And then maybe we connect with communities in America to offer
- 36:44support in whatever way we can, whether it's like I've got to
- 36:48move some money in euros and we put it back and help the people
- 36:52back home if something happens. Because I don't think we can
- 36:54rely on the institutional, the original institutional systems.
- 36:58I don't, I don't even know if I can rely on my Social Security
- 37:01when that time comes. Like I don't know.
- 37:03So there is this feeling that we need to strengthen the bonds
- 37:07that we have, even if it's across the ocean.
- 37:09So it's a bridge like creating this bridge, and not just
- 37:12between the US and France, but between other other countries.
- 37:16You can run, but you cannot hide from America.
- 37:18The America will like that. It is.
- 37:20We feel it, right? You know, we feel it and I feel
- 37:23it. Cab drivers, waiters will, will
- 37:27know as much about American politics as any American.
- 37:30I know they'll go, oh, Trump has decided to withdraw people from
- 37:35the NATO border up by Poland. And, and I'm not even sure if
- 37:39half of America would know that. And I mean, obviously it's quite
- 37:43an interest here. But the the threat is far closer
- 37:47and and more palpable perhaps. So we're here, but we're it's a
- 37:53global world, it's an interconnected world.
- 37:56And I think you and I, for us, our challenge is can we
- 38:00disengage? Because if we live here and
- 38:03we're immersed in the day-to-day news of there.
- 38:06And here. And here and we're not doing the
- 38:10very French thing of reading and looking at art and being
- 38:14immersed in the stuff of life. Right.
- 38:17I feel like we might be missing the the point or like a bit of
- 38:23the thing. That's my challenge.
- 38:24I mean, I don't want to place that.
- 38:25Oh. It's my challenge, right?
- 38:26Now, as to like, if you're here, don't get so sucked into the
- 38:31tunnel yet. I mean, you know, of, of
- 38:34American news as dire and as compelling as it is.
- 38:39And literally, you don't have to go very far to figure out what
- 38:41the news of the day was over there.
- 38:43Like it's all being reported here.
- 38:47So it's not like you're, you know, by disengaging or at least
- 38:52creating more boundaries. Let's say that that you're
- 38:55you're turning your head, you're turning your nose at the at your
- 38:59homeland. But it is true.
- 39:01It's, I like to think of the activists who at various during
- 39:06various social movements in the US specifically have talked
- 39:11about the need Forrest and the need for, you know, picking the
- 39:16moments when you're, you know, diving in with all of your, your
- 39:22energy into something that's going on because you can't, you
- 39:26literally cannot keep up with every single thing.
- 39:28And So what kind of fighter, creator, writer, thinker,
- 39:31whatever are you going to be if you are depleted?
- 39:34And and so I try to think of that and that feels also kind of
- 39:39French edit at heart. I will read a philosopher about
- 39:42something similar that was happening 200 years ago, right.
- 39:44See where that takes you right And I also, and I was going to
- 39:48ask you for advice about this since you've been here longer.
- 39:51I, I think I need to volunteer to help some things in my
- 39:56neighborhood or be in touch with real life and the things that
- 40:02are really going on here. I know that there's.
- 40:04A food kitchen up by the godless.
- 40:07And I think we have to stay connected to the communities we
- 40:11have right here because as the global thing gets more fraught,
- 40:17we have to turn to what's right next to you, what's right in
- 40:20front of you. Absolutely.
- 40:21And we know the homeless problem.
- 40:22Is huge. Huge.
- 40:25It's huge in New York. When you go to New York and when
- 40:27you come back, the one we had, we share that in every major
- 40:31city that I have been to in the last year.
- 40:33So what do we do? Well, I think you answered your
- 40:36own question. I think the the food kitchens,
- 40:40the there are public baths also where there are volunteers who
- 40:44help guide people to use the facilities and to use lockers.
- 40:49And I know some people who do that.
- 40:50And it's because he felt one person in particular who has a,
- 40:54you know, a corporate job and he's French American and felt
- 40:58like all the time he was wasting on social media could be used
- 41:02differently. Exactly.
- 41:04And and so he started volunteering.
- 41:07And whether it's that or something related to books,
- 41:12there are ways. And Paris is particularly good
- 41:16for this, I think, because people are are so quick to
- 41:20resist in the ways that they can.
- 41:21And often that means coming together around a shared
- 41:27mission. A couple weeks ago I saw a group
- 41:29dressed all in red and black and posing and singing, and they
- 41:32were raising money for the, the, the the blocking protests that
- 41:38happened. But they were, they were
- 41:40carrying a big red flag and only the French could make their
- 41:44protest raising money, attractively dressed, stunningly
- 41:48orchestrated with choreography and a song.
- 41:50And I went, I will give you money that is excellent that you
- 41:53have done here is excellent. Can I, should I be a part of
- 41:56this? I Can't Sing, but it feels, it
- 41:58feels incredibly. It's very moving somehow.
- 42:03Well, yeah, the their way of coming together, it's like
- 42:06they're like my, my individual life is not all that matters.
- 42:11Right. Do you find that?
- 42:12I think that that's true, the collective, and maybe it's that
- 42:16that piece of paper I signed for my visa that I had to pay
- 42:19attention to the fraternity part of the collective, you know?
- 42:24Well, I think that and then I'm also, you know, in the same
- 42:27breath going to say that their inability to or or disregard for
- 42:31certain COVID rules and other people's health, you know, not
- 42:36so collective, but I do think at least more so.
- 42:39And and there's the desire to want to think for the group
- 42:44because ultimately, what do we have if we don't have that?
- 42:47The kind of in your business too, if you walk around and your
- 42:50the belt on your coat is trailing, somebody will tell you
- 42:54if you drop €10 they will come and pick it up.
- 42:56They will talk to you there. There.
- 42:57There's a sense of weirdly involved in like, you know what
- 43:02I mean? Like you shouldn't be sitting
- 43:04down in the flip down Metro seat at this point.
- 43:06Somebody will tell. You you'll get shamed and then
- 43:08maybe start a fight with someone.
- 43:09I feel like it's like a small, like I was like, you know,
- 43:11instead of just ignoring it, they're like, this is not what
- 43:13you're supposed to do. And I, and I, I laugh because
- 43:16it's sort of almost like a village where there be people
- 43:20like, no, no, no, we don't do that.
- 43:22Yeah. What do we call that?
- 43:22Like neighborhood watch Neighborhood Watch on the.
- 43:25Public transit getting that way, too.
- 43:27There was somebody who left their trash by the canal, San
- 43:29Mar town. They went, I wanted you to
- 43:31choose. Excuse me, Hello.
- 43:33And I was like, oh God. Yeah.
- 43:34But this is what we need to do. You know, I guess in closing, as
- 43:39someone who has somewhat recently moved and, but has deep
- 43:44connections that last, you know, from decades ago and you have
- 43:48now this writing workshop called The Blue Hour with Clinus.
- 43:52What do you want Paris to be and to continue to be for, for not
- 43:59only for you, but for people who are in the process maybe of
- 44:02thinking about how they can make a move.
- 44:04And maybe it won't be Paris, but it will be France.
- 44:06But what do you want people or what?
- 44:09What do you want the country to to do and be?
- 44:14I want it. I would like it to stay.
- 44:17I would like the neighborhoods that are still true
- 44:19neighborhoods to remain neighborhoody and not become
- 44:26like parts of the Mara, become entirely outward transient,
- 44:30focused, like people that are coming through.
- 44:32There's a vast difference between going to a restaurant
- 44:36where they know they'll never see you again, most of their
- 44:38customers, and going in where there's some core people and
- 44:42there's some visitors. Because the feeling of being in
- 44:46these neighborhoods where the bakery people know your name and
- 44:51the, it is extraordinary, this feeling of community.
- 44:54And I hope that they keep that because if you need anything, a
- 44:58plumber or anything, I just walk out the door and ask somebody
- 45:00and they will tell me. And I think that's I cherish it
- 45:03and. It gets you through the
- 45:05everyday. Yeah, it gets me through the
- 45:07everyday and I don't feel alone with any of my my problems.
- 45:11So I hope they keep that and it doesn't become anonymous or
- 45:17Darwinian the way it might in some parts of New York.
- 45:23And I lied. I have another question.
- 45:26My closing question would be then what do you want people to
- 45:30keep in mind? People listening sort of now
- 45:32their homework if if France's homework is to, you know,
- 45:36preserve this neighborhood spirit.
- 45:39I think, and it's a little bit what you said when we spoke,
- 45:44which is do your research on real Paris, do your research,
- 45:49read the new Paris, read that book, read Lindsay's book.
- 45:53There's another book by the former Bureau chief of The New
- 45:57York Times called La Seducion, The Seduction.
- 46:00Oh, yeah. And it's about the the secret
- 46:03currency of Paris, which is not seducing everybody for sex, but
- 46:07how to get, how to get around and move within the city.
- 46:11What is the rationale behind the way relationships develop?
- 46:15And I mean relationships, even the most casual like your
- 46:18pharmacy, turns out you have to have a relationship with your
- 46:21pharmacist. So do the research because if
- 46:26you come here expecting it to operate the way you normally
- 46:29operate and just plunk down here and enjoy the croissant you're
- 46:32going to, you might find be frustrated.
- 46:33But if you do your research and you still want to come or come
- 46:37and rent for six months and see. Yeah, the trial is a good idea.
- 46:40Six months renting, it's it's you'll have to pay the money up
- 46:44front. There's some things you have to
- 46:45do or do Airbnb for three months, but with a three month
- 46:49visa you can stay up to three months because it's not a fairy
- 46:53tale. It's amazing.
- 46:54It's amazing, but it's not a fairy tale.
- 46:57I don't think there's anything more to add to that.
- 46:59It is not a fairy tale, but it is amazing.
- 47:02Susanna, thank you. We're so lucky you're here.
- 47:04Thank you. And for people who are
- 47:06interested in your workshop, you will be running it again in the
- 47:09new year, in April, in April. So it's called the Blue Hour and
- 47:13I will link to that in the show notes and I hope you'll come
- 47:15back for other discussions. Thanks, Lindsay.
- 47:19That's the show for today. If you're listening on Spotify,
- 47:22be sure to check out the poll related to this episode by
- 47:25scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 47:28conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 47:30subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 47:33what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 47:37from me at lindsaytremuta.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 47:40Sub Stack at Treyviento.