Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP262: Should You Invest In Your Technology Stack or Expect To Reduce Your TCO When Replatforming?
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 0:05by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 0:10featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 0:13industry thought leads and the C-Suite of key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest in digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:18and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:24help fine tune your ECOM strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35Thanks for tuning into the Inside Commerce podcast
- 0:37sponsored by Centra and Greben. More about them later.
- 0:41So our topic today, now this is one that's come up in many
- 0:44conversations recently with clients and with our people in
- 0:47the industry. And we think it's an important
- 0:48one to discuss, which is should you invest in your tech stack or
- 0:52reduce your TCO when looking at technology change.
- 0:54So the reason for this and why it's important is there's often
- 0:58an expectation amongst leadership teams when you're
- 1:02pitching for technology change, whether that's big re platforms
- 1:05or specific systems that actually you can get cost
- 1:08reduction and cost efficiency through that change.
- 1:11However, that's not the primary focus and shouldn't be.
- 1:16That's not what we're saying that cost isn't important.
- 1:18We will, we will come to that later.
- 1:20But fundamentally, there's a big shift in outcome when you focus
- 1:24on value versus cost and focus on cost excludes a a focus on
- 1:30wider business goals can be and how technology can deliver
- 1:33better capabilities or, you know, better speed to market,
- 1:36greater agility, whatever, whatever the current
- 1:38constraints, sometimes you need to investment to achieve that
- 1:42cost reduction and F you need a business case for investment to
- 1:45present them get inside of. And we all know that RE
- 1:49platforming requires detailed cost model analysis.
- 1:53And if we don't understand the goals and drivers for change, we
- 1:56don't model correctly and look at all of the cost lines
- 1:59impacted, including operational cost lines, including things
- 2:03like resourcing. And we can undercut numbers and
- 2:06we can also not look at areas that probably need a bit more
- 2:09investment than there should, put extra costs into that.
- 2:12So the reality of of changing technology and reducing on or
- 2:17increasing costs is quite nuanced.
- 2:19And bringing leadership teams on that journey is critical to get
- 2:22by in. So we're going to focus on on
- 2:25that today. We're going to talk about why
- 2:26reducing costs isn't always possible.
- 2:29Areas of where you can sometimes offset costs so you can maybe
- 2:33reach cost neutrality rather than increasing or decreasing.
- 2:37Paul, do you want to any, anything to add alert in terms
- 2:40of position in terms of why, why we're talking about this today?
- 2:43Dave Biggs, I think we'll come on to this, but I think it's
- 2:46it's probably easier than ever to reduce cost, you know, with
- 2:51consolidation, with using native functionality within platforms
- 2:55maybe isn't best in class, all of that kind of stuff.
- 2:58And like, you know, stripping out a line for like, you know,
- 3:03GAGTM, all of that kind of stuff.
- 3:05But yeah, I think it's just this episode obviously we wanted to
- 3:08cover like it's the like kind of balancing out, reducing like the
- 3:15cost of the CapEx project and or not even the CapEx project, more
- 3:19of the OpEx costs or both. Yeah, we've trying to maximize
- 3:25the value of the product and set yourself up to kind of, yeah,
- 3:30trade the site and build the best experience possible.
- 3:34Yeah, I agree. And, and, but it's also getting
- 3:37into the detail because I, I hear 2 often me we say, Oh yes,
- 3:41we can, we've got that natively. A good example would be a modern
- 3:45SAS platform with a native page builder.
- 3:47And it's like, yes, we can do the content management natively,
- 3:49don't worry, you don't need a third party.
- 3:51But when you get into the details, you realise there are
- 3:53compromises because there are limitations in those page
- 3:56builders, visual editors, you know they don't do proper
- 3:59publishing. And in order to do that you
- 4:01either have to create a custom app on top to do basic
- 4:05scheduling, or you have to make a compromise in your publishing
- 4:09process. And often businesses can combine
- 4:12into cost reduction without having understood the functional
- 4:16implications. And actually, if they'd properly
- 4:19understood those functional implications upfront, they
- 4:21probably would have made a different investment decision,
- 4:23potentially invested in the specialist third party or build
- 4:27an extra contingency for development to, to build extra
- 4:30capability on top. And that's why it's really, This
- 4:32is why value versus cost is such an important discussion.
- 4:36So let's sorry, what are you going to?
- 4:38Say no. I was just going to say, I think
- 4:40content probably, I think that's a really interesting one because
- 4:44I'd probably say it's like a scale for like level of
- 4:48compromise. I guess it depends where you're
- 4:50coming from. Like if you've got like a really
- 4:52solid CMS in place, I'd say it's probably slight more on the
- 4:55luxury side. But the one I see the most at
- 4:57the moment with the SAS platforms, which I think
- 5:01dependent on your business is not the right way to go, is
- 5:05search. So a lot more people aren't
- 5:08investing in a third party search solution.
- 5:10And to be honest, none of the platform have a good native
- 5:13search solution. And I do think it's like an
- 5:15important area of, of the site and you know, of an experience,
- 5:20but also in addition to that third party, it's like during
- 5:23COVID, people go in and spend them, you know, like small
- 5:26retailers and spending five KM up on a search solution like
- 5:29that. There's good solutions now for
- 5:31relatively low amounts of money. And I think that's a good area
- 5:33where you probably it's unlikely you should compromise.
- 5:37Greben create digital flagship stores for iconic brands of
- 5:40today and tomorrow. We are the number one centre
- 5:43agency in the world with more than 50 centre implementations
- 5:47to date. We are also e-commerce design
- 5:49specialists, platform and tech partner agnostic.
- 5:52Try our new e-commerce design subscription.
- 5:55Visit greben.com. Yeah, and This is why this value
- 5:59versus Koslins it and that's a great the search and match well,
- 6:02I I was coming up against him recently with a native search
- 6:04and the native search works it's got some basic semantic
- 6:07capabilities. It's got type ahead.
- 6:09OK, great. But actually when you get down
- 6:12to the nuance of trade in search journey, then you fall down
- 6:15because, OK, you want to have default results where you can
- 6:19show default product or you can't do that unless you build
- 6:23some customization. You can just have basic text
- 6:26linked. And then you realise that
- 6:28actually, oh, I want to add some specific business rules.
- 6:31Well you can only do very basic like product boost and that has
- 6:36no unique. The biggest one on that, and
- 6:39this applies to product racks as well, because realistically you
- 6:42can get by and you can you, you know, you can build your own
- 6:44solution for product racks and you can add like basic
- 6:47personalisation, everything else.
- 6:48But the biggest thing, if you're looking to trade the site in the
- 6:52most effective way possible, you need reporting as well.
- 6:54And you need to understand which products performing well and
- 6:57like how you should be reacting to, you know, uplifts or
- 7:01reduction like whatever else. And I think that's the thing
- 7:04that a lot of people lose when they're reducing cost as well.
- 7:08Yeah, that's a very good point. And and then the, the, the other
- 7:12example, I guess in SAS world, you know, great APIs, great
- 7:18availability of data. And, and that is really good
- 7:22because you take it back from like shop fund Bigcommerce, they
- 7:24do have good APIs and you can pull data out, you know,
- 7:26purchase data, really good depth, but you need a resource
- 7:31to do that. And you need somewhere for that
- 7:34data to go and somehow for that data to be visualised.
- 7:36And that by the means pulling that data into a, a third party
- 7:41reporting, a visualisation tool, or, you know, pick one.
- 7:46There are loads out there, polar, for example, or you need
- 7:50to to build them out in, in a, in a, in your own like reporting
- 7:56studio. So again, there's all these not
- 7:58con implications and course where where people at face and
- 8:01go. That sounds great, brilliant.
- 8:03We've got that data sorted actually haven't because it's
- 8:05not in the format you need to use.
- 8:07So yeah, great. So let's talk about the license
- 8:10fee. One for me is this often comes
- 8:12up, it's great. We'll lower your license fee,
- 8:15which will lower your TCO. And and that's kind of smoke and
- 8:20mirrors because it doesn't that doesn't always stack up.
- 8:24And I've seen people moving from a legacy platform where they
- 8:27might be on at 1% of their sales, moving to a lower.
- 8:33So you can, you know, pick your platforms, Shopify, Centre, big
- 8:36Commerce that all lower license fees and the like, sales force,
- 8:39for example. But then you've got these
- 8:42additional costs that come in depending on which platform you
- 8:45use. So you might be able to reduce a
- 8:49cost from a specific line, but you've got to model out the
- 8:52impact on other lines. A good example Shopify is that
- 8:56if you've got a payment a provider across the business, it
- 8:59might be used for like trade in retail online for phone orders
- 9:04and actually the finance team have got redline that you cannot
- 9:07change that. That is the payment provider.
- 9:09Then you need to use that as a third party payment processor if
- 9:13supported in in like Shopify and pay a .2% transaction fee, which
- 9:16is fine but you've got to model that in and all of a sudden
- 9:19point that .35 transaction fee becomes .55.
- 9:22In reality, Centre is the only commerce platform built
- 9:25exclusively for fashion brands. Over 300 fashion brands run on
- 9:28Centre including icons like Paul Smith, Jeff Ave. and Nudie
- 9:31Jeans. Centre solves business logic
- 9:33challenges for fashion brands. I know other platform and they
- 9:35are on a mission to help you scale up rapidly globally across
- 9:38all online and offline channels. Take your fashion brand global,
- 9:41faster, further, stronger today. So there's all these nuances.
- 9:45Where do you normally see people like undercut costs and get
- 9:49caught out I. Mean, to be honest, the payment
- 9:51wire's quite interesting as well, because I think I've had
- 9:54clients that have used Agen and they've paid extra to use a
- 9:58fraud solution, which is really good.
- 10:00And then they've moved over to another payment provider as part
- 10:03of the build and then they've had to pay more of a premium for
- 10:07a decent fraud solution as an example.
- 10:10So like that's an additional cost.
- 10:12I think when you're talking about platform costs, that over
- 10:15licensing, I think I back in the day, Magenta was always an
- 10:21interesting one where, you know, people looked enterprise at the
- 10:24time or commerce or now Adobe commerce as being expensive.
- 10:30But you know, realistically a decent host nowadays or like
- 10:33back even back then, like you know, working for Kuva, if
- 10:36you've got a lot of volume, you know it's gonna cost you.
- 10:38And I'm not saying Cuba, it's not better than commerce in
- 10:41terms of like the infrastructure and the approach, but you know,
- 10:45it's going to cost you the same. So it's like I think that's
- 10:48just, it's just those nuances and like you know, if you are
- 10:51hosting it yourself, all the other technologies you might
- 10:53need in other areas as well. So yeah, I think it's all of
- 10:58that. And then I think more modern
- 11:00today like in terms of, I mean the big one that you and I have
- 11:05done quite a lot recently sent through and Shopify.
- 11:09And I think you're right that the external payment provider
- 11:12where that's needed is a big one.
- 11:14And if you do need to permit your payment provider
- 11:17potentially what impact that could have on like retail
- 11:21payments and things like that, I think that's a big one.
- 11:26And then I don't know too many of us.
- 11:29I think like when it comes to like base platform fees, I don't
- 11:33know too many of us. I think one thing that's going
- 11:34to be interesting soon, so in Shopify world is going to be
- 11:38Shopify Enterprise, which I've started to see here a little bit
- 11:42more about recently. And when that was first
- 11:44launched, it was launched. I think it's $12,000 a month,
- 11:47something like that. It's like base price, but I
- 11:50think it's coming down and I think that's an additional fee
- 11:53that, you know, gives you more higher API limits and, you know,
- 11:59better professional services and support and stuff like that.
- 12:02And that could be one in the future potentially dependent on
- 12:06how that ends up being kind of how they position that.
- 12:11So I say, for example, I need something, oh, you need shop for
- 12:14enterprise, but that could be one.
- 12:17And professional services in general is quite interesting.
- 12:20I've seen other platforms and people have moved to where it's
- 12:23like they have an intentional like percentage of, you know,
- 12:28change costs that they have targets on to sell professional
- 12:32services. And you do see that in more
- 12:34enterprise vendors. But yeah, that's probably about
- 12:37it. Yeah.
- 12:39The, the other one, which is if your business model is changing,
- 12:44a good example, I've worked on a project a while back where they
- 12:47were introducing subscriptions because they knew it was going
- 12:50to be the big growth area for them.
- 12:53They were moving to SAS. They moved from open source to
- 12:55SAS, but they were introduced. So they're adding a license to
- 12:59there, but they're also introducing subscriptions.
- 13:01And if you're not used to the way that the subscription
- 13:04license and pricing model works and it works differently across
- 13:07different providers, you know, for example, with, you know,
- 13:10with like a recharge, you can, you can do a blended fee or you
- 13:15can split it with a lower percentage transaction
- 13:18processing fee plus a fixed monthly fee.
- 13:20You can, you can get that to come out lower than the overall
- 13:22blended fee, but you've got all the different costs that come
- 13:25in. And that can surprise finance
- 13:27teams who are not thinking, they're thinking they're getting
- 13:30a, a new platform for the business and there's a licence
- 13:32and that's going to give them everything.
- 13:33Well, actually, no, because that's not doing this
- 13:35subscription piece. But you say, I don't know,
- 13:37platforms like Shopify building out like basic subscription
- 13:40functionality, but often that's not enough if somebody's wanted
- 13:44to be a more advanced subscription business.
- 13:45So it's really important to to understand that, that, that
- 13:50sometimes these cost lines are going to be, oh, the costs are
- 13:53going to be higher than you expect.
- 13:57Yeah. What should we talk about next
- 13:59in terms of this investment versus cost reduction?
- 14:02I've been the one, the thing that like when we were talking
- 14:06before this episode that we both thought was important to cover a
- 14:12guess is like it's the positioning that if you're going
- 14:15to your CEO or the board with a business case for a re
- 14:21platforming project, realistically, the easiest
- 14:24message is always going to be, you know, we spend X per year
- 14:27now or in the next three years, we're going to spend X, we're
- 14:30going to reduce it to X and our monthly outgoings are going to
- 14:33be X And after five months it's pure profit, blah, blah, blah.
- 14:37I think that's always going to be the easiest message.
- 14:39But instead of that, it's trying to basically take a budget, keep
- 14:45it the same or potentially even increase it, but say, you know,
- 14:48we're actually going to build a much better experience for new
- 14:51customers. We're going to get way more
- 14:53engagement with these community features.
- 14:56We're going to drive way more revenue per user as a result of
- 15:00this revenue per customer as a result of this membership
- 15:03program. Like it's that it's like, I
- 15:06think it's trying to build incrementality into justifying
- 15:10expense beyond just reducing customers.
- 15:13Yeah. The that I I fundamentally agree
- 15:16on if you're introducing new capabilities that are that you
- 15:20can model and you there there is evidence and date in the
- 15:24marketplace where you can say, well, look, Oh yeah, business A
- 15:27was able to increase lifetime value or increase retention
- 15:31rates by Y. And I guess things like the
- 15:35simplicity of introducing loyalty because you've got the
- 15:37two bits under you guys, what what loyalty do in terms of
- 15:40customer retention and lifetime value repeat purchase rates.
- 15:43Also the, the, the lower cost of integrating a loyalty platform
- 15:48in an ecosystem that will exist, you know, like SAS world where
- 15:53they've got routing regions with three or four top top loyalty
- 15:57partners versus an older platform that that doesn't have
- 16:02the connectors you need, where you're going to have to do a
- 16:03custom integration. So you've got different cost
- 16:05lines. The bit I'll tell you the thing
- 16:07that I always advise against though, is and there's a lot of
- 16:10sales pictures out there about move to this platform and you'll
- 16:14increase your conversion rate. And I advise that on that pure
- 16:19just by moving platform I don't agree with.
- 16:22I've seen too many nuances in that especially you know when
- 16:27who say yeah, best convert and check out.
- 16:29Well, I've got clients who've got like 80% plus converging the
- 16:32check out because they are predominantly at subscription
- 16:35return customer business and and actually moving to a new
- 16:38provider's not going to have the same up so.
- 16:41To be honest, I mean, I think conversion rate when it comes to
- 16:44read flat forming, there's you're never going to have more
- 16:47variables. Like that's almost like the
- 16:49worst KTR I'd look at because the biggest one is tracking.
- 16:52Like typically if you're moving from a tech stack you've had for
- 16:55a long time, it's unlikely that you've had ongoing investment in
- 16:59your kind of GA implementation or whatever else you're using.
- 17:03Like most of the time people like I have zero confidence in
- 17:06it. However, I want to be confident.
- 17:08So I'm going to rebuild the whole thing.
- 17:09I'm going to introduce server side tracking across the
- 17:13etcetera, etcetera. So like that's variable one.
- 17:16The other thing is you're going to have probably changes to your
- 17:18channel mix. Like you might turn paid off for
- 17:20a period of time. You might see change in SEO,
- 17:23Google shopping, whatever else. Like that's variable 2.
- 17:26You then got that the front ends completely changed.
- 17:29So I think that I think I'm the same as you and I've had it
- 17:34three times recently. And I would usually go to
- 17:36specific areas of the site and pull out like, you know, we're
- 17:39improving this, improving this, improving there's how what
- 17:42impact do you think we couldn't could see based on previous
- 17:45projects in these specific areas to AOV maybe, you know,
- 17:51conversion rate or interaction rate, whatever with those
- 17:53specific areas. But I'm exactly the same like I
- 17:57see so many people or brands that have said, you know, our
- 18:01expectation was conversion rate would go up 20% and it's like
- 18:04that mentor that's not should one, it's like that's complete
- 18:08finger and wire and you've got all the variables and then two,
- 18:11it's just not how you should be looking at the project.
- 18:14Yeah, exactly. And and to be honest, it's it is
- 18:17dis is disingenuous to say that simply by change technology are
- 18:22like you said, the conversion rate was tied to that because it
- 18:24can be tied to so many other things.
- 18:27Yeah, the marketing mix is a classic 1, the promotional mix,
- 18:30the product mix, so fixing other things behind the scenes that
- 18:35have Hanford your ability to convert the line as well.
- 18:38So, yeah, and I think coming back to that investment point
- 18:42about this and the expectations is every business is hamstrung
- 18:46by certain things. And that can either be
- 18:48technology hamstringing or resourcing.
- 18:51You know, the ability to get projects over the line because
- 18:55of speed to market and and re platform is a classic time when
- 19:00you look to solve some of those problems and you solve some of
- 19:02it through tech and some of it through automation and better
- 19:05processes. And then freeing up time for the
- 19:07business to focus on stuff because they're not having to,
- 19:10you know, spend a day building a new page because the the tool is
- 19:14not fair. So I, I think this is really
- 19:16important that businesses stop and think about the areas they
- 19:18want to get addressed and what they need to invest in that
- 19:23project in order to, to get it achieved.
- 19:25And that can be through configuration, theme
- 19:27customization, third party tools.
- 19:30And often I see the scenarios like in the integrations where
- 19:34potentially in the past, they've got either an old middleware and
- 19:37it's not fit for purpose and it can't handle the data bodies, or
- 19:41they've got APIs that are just not working and they want to put
- 19:45in a new middleware and they want to improve the data flows.
- 19:49And they want to ensure that they've got the the right speed
- 19:52of flows to process orders at the right volume during peak.
- 19:56And you, you find that all of a sudden there's another license
- 19:59fee in there. And the areas you've talked
- 20:02about before, like search and merch and then loyalty reviews
- 20:06and often and then BI, as you said, change.
- 20:08And there's a lot of times when these things change over.
- 20:11Yeah, I think another thing that I was talking about, so I was
- 20:13on, I was chatting to Lewis who we've had on the podcast before,
- 20:16who run ID 8 Charles E com practice, whatever they call it
- 20:22this morning. And was, and this is specific to
- 20:27SAS. I think when you're
- 20:28historically, pre COVID, if you and I went into a RE platformer
- 20:33project, half the time there would be a half £1,000,000
- 20:35project, the budget for the bill you'd be moving to Magento and
- 20:39you'd say here's a blank sheet of paper.
- 20:41How can we achieve the most from a functional perspective with
- 20:46our budget? Whereas nowadays and if you're
- 20:48moving to the SAS platform, there's a lot of appeal to just
- 20:54to approach all the features in a very standardized way.
- 20:57So use a standardized set of apps, use a set of native
- 21:01functionality. And from a front end
- 21:03perspective, you know, approach things just as everyone does.
- 21:08And I said the other thing with this project and it's very easy
- 21:10to do that and you know, do a build for 50 to 100K and you've
- 21:15got what is largely really strong functionality that's very
- 21:20usable and easy to manage. But like when it comes to like,
- 21:25you know, we we've talked about Nudie jeans, we've talked about
- 21:27Jeff Abbott on the brands that have got real like depth behind
- 21:33some of the core functionality, like just community
- 21:35functionality, Nudie's like positioning of all the like
- 21:42sustainability messaging and like some of like the depth
- 21:45behind that. And it's like, I think the other
- 21:48thing going into a re platform a project, particularly if you've
- 21:50got a decent percentage of the budget going to design, I think
- 21:54there needs to be like, if I was a brand now, I'd be really
- 21:59thinking about, OK, these areas of the site are important to
- 22:02revenue. These areas of the site, you
- 22:04know, getting a lot of eyeballs and interaction.
- 22:08How can I build something a bit more unique?
- 22:12So I think that's a really interesting thing in the SAS
- 22:14space at the moment. Yeah, 100%.
- 22:17That echoes a few project experiences I had recently
- 22:20where, I mean, I'm always, I always believe that actually,
- 22:25you know, Anessa is a a fundamental reason to go
- 22:28headless. You stick with the feet and you
- 22:29look to get the most out of it. But actually there are certain
- 22:33brands, and I'm talking to another one at the moment where
- 22:36I can see where they really want to create an elevated customer
- 22:39experience and they want to create some very bespoke
- 22:42customer journeys that actually a default theme is not going to
- 22:46cut out. You need a custom bill because
- 22:48otherwise you re. I'm in a project at the moment
- 22:51where we're reaching some, there's some compromises being
- 22:53made to launch a store and actually you get the point where
- 22:57you go, do you know what? We're making too many
- 22:58compromises. And that's when you get this
- 23:01whole investment pieces is, is, you know, if you, if you're
- 23:04happy to have cookie cut out and that's good enough because you
- 23:07did MVP launch, that's absolutely fine.
- 23:09A lot of criticizing it, but I think some, some, some brands
- 23:12need to, to invest your writing properly in that whole design
- 23:16and build process. Don't have to go like, you know,
- 23:19headless CMS, but you can do a custom theme.
- 23:22So you unpick some of those limitations.
- 23:24Completely great. And I think if you've got a very
- 23:27strict budget for commercial reasons, fine.
- 23:30If you've got very strict short deadline for commercial reasons,
- 23:34fine. But if you were going into the
- 23:35project and you know that's just your first way of justifying,
- 23:39you know that we can do this quickly, we can do this easily,
- 23:42we can do this at low cost and you don't need to do that.
- 23:45I just think it's a bit of a waste, particularly like the
- 23:47average brand, you know for all of their new customer
- 23:51acquisitions coming from better, they're spending a fortune on
- 23:53it. And it's like if you're like a
- 23:56lot of the time, if you're trying to build and experience
- 23:59that for a new customer that doesn't know the brand, doesn't
- 24:01know the product has zero and 10.
- 24:03Like I think that's why I like these are the areas you should
- 24:06be trying to invest in that are going to be even moving the
- 24:09needle slightly is actually having a major impact if it's on
- 24:13a net new customer. Yeah, exactly.
- 24:17And I guess the, the, the my final point on this is that is
- 24:23that instead of instead of looking at cost cutting, I
- 24:27advise people to think about cost offsetting and cost
- 24:30neutrality. That that's for me is the
- 24:32Rubicon. That is, it is if you can build
- 24:35a five year business TCO model for a big technology change that
- 24:40is cost neutral without showing that you're saving the business
- 24:46money. That to me is a real plus
- 24:48because you've then swallowed the upfront and we know that the
- 24:52upfront year one cost all the CapEx stuff is heavy.
- 24:56And actually when you look at the percentage, so I'd like to
- 24:59flow percentage of GMV the spends per year with all the
- 25:03CapEx and Karakumi speed now CapEx and OpEx lines as a
- 25:07percentage of total GMV based on your target run rate.
- 25:11Now what you should see at by the end of the five years is, is
- 25:14that should be cost neutral versus your as is.
- 25:18But you're seeing that the percentage is coming down year
- 25:21on year. So actually if you carry that
- 25:23through lifetime, you're actually more efficient.
- 25:25It's just you had a big heavy upfront cost.
- 25:27So I always start that as my principal.
- 25:30I don't know, how do you how do you go into?
- 25:32I think similar and I think it's, I mean ultimately this is
- 25:35like it's, no, it's, it's the, it's positioning something when
- 25:39you're asking for money. I mean, I guess it's, it's,
- 25:43yeah, it's purely positioning because I think if you're like
- 25:45you say keeping the costs the same, but you got these benefits
- 25:48over here, which could be like you say like efficient, more
- 25:52efficient use of resource investment in brand investment
- 25:55in functionality that's going to lead to more revenue, more
- 25:58revenue per customer, etcetera, etcetera.
- 26:01Then I think it's more likely to be signed off.
- 26:03But I think that's what it comes down to.
- 26:05It's it's positioning and yeah, creating a case around return
- 26:10because I mean, the other thing I would say is, you know, and we
- 26:13talk about saving money or keeping costs the same.
- 26:16But even then, like so many brands should be going into and
- 26:18saying, right, I want to invest 50% more because I think we can
- 26:22deliver X Yeah. And it just comes down to
- 26:25positioning. Yeah, it is an interesting
- 26:28because if you look at marketing spend, I think this is always
- 26:31the, the, the challenge in businesses is marketing spend,
- 26:35digital marketing spend because it's directly correlated with
- 26:38revenue is let's invest. Whereas technology and related
- 26:43costs and that is, you know, support maintenance costs, you
- 26:47know, retailers to push through new features, functionality,
- 26:52digital third party licenses, everything that goes around
- 26:55this, any freelancers, contractors, it's always seen as
- 26:58how can we, how can we reduce it?
- 27:00Whereas you're right, This is why we started this episode
- 27:03about investment versus cost reductions.
- 27:05You've got, if you're targeted with 25% growth next year and we
- 27:09know that trading is tough at the moment.
- 27:11And then you have to, you have to look to find cost savings
- 27:15where possible. You've got to make the
- 27:17investment in the areas you know that's going to push that and
- 27:20you've got to fight for those costs because if they're not
- 27:21baked into the cost model upfront, very hard to go back to
- 27:26a director or ACFO ago. Actually we need another 30K
- 27:30because we've undercooked it and we now need to buy a new license
- 27:33that we haven't budgeted for. Yeah.
- 27:35I think the market in comparison is really interesting actually.
- 27:39I guess a lot of this also comes back to because of the market,
- 27:44because a lot of people have raised money because a lot of
- 27:47people have expected to continue growing when they haven't.
- 27:50I guess it's like most college. So many conversations now are
- 27:53about finance. But I think the marketing piece
- 27:56is really interesting because like you see so many people like
- 28:00realistically the thing that's going to achieve long term
- 28:02growth is investment in brand and new customers, but it
- 28:05doesn't perform as well. So instead, they'll invest in
- 28:07like Google and you know, bottom of funnel demand and they'll see
- 28:13an immediate impact on some level, but you're gonna see a
- 28:16much bigger impact long term. And I guess it's like it also
- 28:18comes back to that organic search thing as well.
- 28:20And I think this is exactly the same where it's like it's not as
- 28:23tangible, it's harder to measure, but you've kind of got
- 28:26to just go a bit deep a bit further to try and get data to
- 28:29justify it. And I think that's kind of where
- 28:31a lot of people, a lot of paid media managers are at internally
- 28:34now where they've got to like go and collect more data from the
- 28:37industry around the impact of brand and like the Halo effect
- 28:40of certain campaigns and other things.
- 28:42Because. And I think it's the same for
- 28:44this like investing in creative, investing in, yeah, really deep
- 28:49functionality on site. Yeah, exactly.
- 28:53So I think we kind of covered all our points so not to so that
- 28:57we don't go back and repeat ourselves.
- 28:58Let's just do some our key takeaways.
- 29:00So I got two key takeaways from this today.
- 29:03And the question the the our focus if anyone can remember
- 29:07from the start is why you should go into technology change
- 29:11thinking about investing rather than saving cars.
- 29:15And the two bits are make sure the business case and cost
- 29:17models for change stacks are that manufacturing KPI up there.
- 29:20So, so try and think about that conversion's high at AOV,
- 29:24they're harder to guarantee as we've discussed.
- 29:26And there are so many other variables that impact them,
- 29:29product range, competitor price and sort of you name it.
- 29:32So don't listen to the case studies out there say by
- 29:37switching to platform edge, you can increase your conversion
- 29:40rate and you and then the other thing is demonstrate financial
- 29:44acumen by looking at where you can offset the cost.
- 29:47How can you reduce cost? So a good example might be that
- 29:50you've got a a large engineering team.
- 29:53You know, a couple of people are are due to leave.
- 29:55Well, actually by by pivoting tech, you don't need to replace
- 29:58those people because you don't need that engineer and you don't
- 30:01need the front end engineer anymore.
- 30:03Or maybe it's a reduction of back end engineering due to move
- 30:06to a particular platform type and look at where you can time
- 30:10stamp cost efficiencies. So a good example of one
- 30:13business where we looked at the three key tiles, they would no
- 30:17longer have to get developers involved in because they could
- 30:20just direct to the platform and that took time and cost out.
- 30:22So look at where, look at that and look at any other licenses.
- 30:27I had a project recently where where there were three third
- 30:29party tools would no longer need, they would be redundant
- 30:31and use that they'd come out. I think that really helps
- 30:34because if you're going into the CFO with we need to invest more
- 30:37here, being able to demonstrate you've really thought hard about
- 30:40where you can take existing costs out will will benefit that
- 30:44discussion. Those of mine, what's your take
- 30:46away I. Think so.
- 30:48I think I'm going to piggyback on yours.
- 30:50So I'm just going to talk about consolidation, which I think in
- 30:53the SAS world has been a big trend, which I think you've
- 30:56already touched on. But I'm going to piggyback on
- 30:58what you've said. And basically just so you know,
- 31:00if you're trying to re engineer where your costs are sitting, I
- 31:05think it's important to avoid the temptation to just approach
- 31:11everything how everyone else approaches.
- 31:14And this is in, this is almost entirely aimed at the SAS
- 31:18platforms, but I think it's just very easy to approach.
- 31:22Yeah, like your core functionality in a very
- 31:25standardized way. And I think it's just as part of
- 31:29that budget and exercise instead of doing something a way that's
- 31:32going to be really efficient and take one elephant day or two
- 31:36developers, whatever, go and invest 20 grand in it and still
- 31:41or whatever, I'm still kind of allow for differentiation.
- 31:44So I think that for me, that's like getting the most out of the
- 31:47budget, that investing in core functionality rather than, yeah,
- 31:54just kind of seeing that as a given and that investor
- 31:57sometimes. Cool.
- 32:00Well I hope you've enjoyed the episode.
- 32:02I hope it's giving you food for thought.
- 32:03Hopefully, if you're in the middle of processes like this,
- 32:05it can help you like tidy up your approach, your cost model
- 32:08and your investment pitch. Let us know what you think,
- 32:11anything you think we've missed and we should have talked about.
- 32:14And also make sure you find an Inside Commerce and LinkedIn and
- 32:16subscribe to our Inside Commerce newsletter.
- 32:19Until next week everybody, you're listening to the Inside
- 32:23Commerce podcast. Hosted by experienced
- 32:24consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers, Inside Commerce is your
- 32:28fast tracked additional knowledge featuring interviews
- 32:31with leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought
- 32:33leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to explore the latest
- 32:36digital strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 32:39Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 32:42advice based on experience to help fine tune your E Comm
- 32:44strategy and text. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 32:48out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an E comms
- 32:50project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 32:52episode.