Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Student Mental Health: A Deep Dive into AI and Well-being
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:03and today we're speaking to Sean Wheelock and Dr.
- 0:06Donna Tversky for a deep dive into student mental health.
- 0:10Thanks so much for joining us today. It's great to have both of you here to
- 0:13talk about this super important topic. Thank you for joining us.
- 0:17Yeah, thanks so much for having us, Aurora. We're really excited to be here.
- 0:21So let's let's dive right in to start us off. Tell tell my audience a little
- 0:25bit about your work and what brought you into this to the space of mental health and well-being.
- 0:31So honestly, for me, it was really my own personal journey with mental health and well-being.
- 0:39Growing up, I went to an all boys Catholic Jesuit high school in Toledo,
- 0:44Ohio, and we did not really at that time talk about mental health at all.
- 0:49And so when I went to college and I started experiencing mental health challenges
- 0:54for the first time, I didn't have good coping mechanisms to deal with that effectively.
- 1:00And so I turned to drinking alcohol as a coping mechanism.
- 1:04And that didn't work out well for me in the long term.
- 1:07But I was lucky that I was able to get the help that I needed.
- 1:11And so now I'm several years sober and things are going really,
- 1:15really well for me on that journey.
- 1:17But it was that experience that made me want to build something to help students
- 1:24build the coping skills and resilience to be able to handle the challenges of
- 1:28daily life better than I did. Congrats. Congrats on that.
- 1:32So yeah, tell us a little bit more about your organization, your tool that you're working with.
- 1:39Tell us more about Inner Peak. Yeah, sure.
- 1:42So the original idea behind Interpeep was we want to try and provide a more
- 1:48personalized way of delivering mental wellness support that doesn't require
- 1:55an expensive human professional's time.
- 1:58And so we're trying to bridge technology with human connection and human therapist
- 2:06expertise to deliver a tool that provides both personalized 24-7 support for students,
- 2:13but also helps them learn well-being and coping skills to be able to kind of
- 2:20self-help through their own life.
- 2:24Awesome. So Donna, tell us a little bit about you. Dr. Donna,
- 2:27what's your area of expertise?
- 2:29And where do you fit into the tapestry here with student well-being?
- 2:34Great questions all around.
- 2:36So I am on the clinical faculty at Stanford, and I teach psychotherapy and have
- 2:44a passion for, in general,
- 2:45making the world a more psychologically minded place, because I think that's
- 2:50also a more compassionate world.
- 2:52And so to that end, I do a lot of teaching. I teach psychotherapy to residents.
- 2:58And I also started a course for undergraduates called How to Think Like a Shrink.
- 3:03And that's kind of how Sean found me when he was at business school at Stanford.
- 3:09And we got to talking a little bit.
- 3:12And I had a lot of concerns about AI and also a lot of hope for AI.
- 3:18And I can articulate some more of those kind of as time goes on.
- 3:22But it turned out Sean and I shared a lot of a vision together.
- 3:27And I really feel strongly about what's basically called psychoeducation,
- 3:32of learning about how our minds work, learning about how we see the world clearly
- 3:37and when we don't see the world clearly, and then how to kind of live our own best lives within that.
- 3:42And I think a lot of that can occur in the context of a mental health kind of
- 3:47relationship, a more typical one.
- 3:49And obviously, I mean, that's what I do with a lot of my time, most of my time.
- 3:52But I also think there's a ton of other avenues for it. And so that's kind of
- 3:57my personal interest and then easily dovetailed with Sean's efforts and Inner Peak.
- 4:04Great. So, you know, you're both deeply engaged in supporting student mental
- 4:07health from different angles.
- 4:10So tell us a little bit about what you're seeing in the field right now.
- 4:14What's most urgent or most misunderstood about this moment?
- 4:19Yeah, I'm happy to start.
- 4:22It's, I mean, perhaps this is not a huge surprise, especially coming out of COVID.
- 4:28But the biggest thing that students are struggling with, that they come to intervene
- 4:32for help with, is relationship skills. How do they interact with each other, themselves?
- 4:41How do they handle romantic relationships? How do they handle friendships?
- 4:46How do they handle relationships with their parents?
- 4:49And so that combination of TikTok and social media that's pulling students more
- 4:56and more into their phones, coupled with some of the isolation that happened during COVID.
- 5:03It's just a really challenging social environment for students today.
- 5:07And that adds to some of the anxiety that is also happening as a result of being
- 5:13focused on their phones all the time and not going outside at all like we used to as much.
- 5:19But Donna, what would you add to that?
- 5:22Oh, my gosh. You know, honestly, I maintain a lot of humility around it right now.
- 5:27Like, I honestly couldn't say anything really conclusive. I think all the points
- 5:31that Sean brought up are absolutely right on.
- 5:33I also think, you know, honestly, when we have, you know,
- 5:38upwards of 40% of students endorsing thoughts about hurting themselves,
- 5:43about killing themselves, and just as many with kind of severe anxiety that
- 5:48prohibits them from engaging in life and their activities and relationships,
- 5:52I actually don't think of it as individual problems. I think of it as a societal one.
- 5:57I think it's a public health approach and not a medical one.
- 6:02So I get a little testy around diagnosing and sort of like treating individuals
- 6:09as if they're the problem.
- 6:11Like I think what we need really is to start creating healthier environments
- 6:15for people and think about the features of them that we want to bring out,
- 6:21that we want to elicit, that will lead to greater life satisfaction.
- 6:25And meaning. And so that's something I'd like to see.
- 6:30And I'd like to see a lot more understanding of what's going on with students
- 6:35and probably stepping outside of our traditional frameworks for trying to understand
- 6:40what we kind of loosely call mental health.
- 6:43How would you say this is impacting students with disabilities distinctly?
- 6:48Yeah, I think it's having an even more magnified impact on students with disabilities,
- 6:55where if you're already predisposed to maybe feel socially uncomfortable or
- 7:01need additional support in these ways,
- 7:06spending more and more time on your phone and spending more time away from other
- 7:13people is going to magnify those issues even more.
- 7:18Whenever we're in a system and there's a stressor to the system and that system,
- 7:22that stressor could be COVID, it could be the pace of life right now and the
- 7:27pace of technological kind of changes and changes in a social life and the time spent on screens.
- 7:32Any number of those things could be a stressor, as could be a traditional one,
- 7:36like the loss of a loved one or a relationship, but that in the system,
- 7:41the most vulnerable part of that system is going to get hit hardest.
- 7:45And so we see that with families, for instance. You know, a common thing that
- 7:48will happen in our world in psychiatry is that we'll get someone bringing in
- 7:53their child because the child is symptomatic.
- 7:55They're wetting their bed again. They're super anxious. They don't want to go to school.
- 7:57And then you look at what's happening. You start to treat the child.
- 8:01And then all of a sudden you're like, wait a second, what's going on in the
- 8:03family system? And you find out the parents are fighting a lot. There's a divorce.
- 8:06There's something else. And so it's always those of us with the most vulnerability,
- 8:12the most sensitivity, the youngest, that are going to express the distress of a society the most.
- 8:17So you can hear me going back to like we have to think about the environment
- 8:21and the vulnerable people within it.
- 8:24And so that would be one way to think just sort of at a broad level about being
- 8:30extra careful with those of us with disabilities of any form or sensitivities of any form.
- 8:36And that's not to say we just we overprotect. That's not at all the point.
- 8:40It's being mindful and thought like caring about how people are going to respond
- 8:45to these changing times.
- 8:47Yeah. We talk about challenges, but what about the flip side?
- 8:50What have you seen in schools that's helping? What promising practices or supports
- 8:54are you seeing out there that feel encouraging?
- 8:58There are a lot of organizations that are bringing peers in to support each other.
- 9:05And I think peer-to-peer support and sharing of experiences can be very,
- 9:11very powerful, especially with regards to mental health.
- 9:15I think things like social-emotional learning programs are actually starting
- 9:20to make a difference. And then I also think there are great opportunities to
- 9:24use new technology to be able to be supportive for students.
- 9:29And that's one of the things that we're trying to do at InterGeek,
- 9:32where before things that were not delivered by humans had very limited ability to be personalized.
- 9:41Lives, but now we have the ability to personalize to exactly each individual, however we want.
- 9:50And that is really, really exciting in thinking of how do we best communicate to students?
- 9:56How do we meet them where they are and help them with the specific thing that
- 10:01they're struggling with?
- 10:02And so I think we're trying to
- 10:05do that at Inner Peak and that's a really exciting, exciting opportunity.
- 10:09Yeah. And I think in general, probably, I mean, there's some wonderful trends
- 10:14over the last 10, 15 years.
- 10:17You know, we are seeing mental health is something we all talk about now.
- 10:21You know, I shouldn't say we all, but it has become a much more mainstream conversation.
- 10:26And there is a lot less stigma. I mean, I love how readily my students at Stanford
- 10:31share stories of their therapists and what they were thinking about and with one another.
- 10:35And I think there's been a normalization around a lot of previously kind of
- 10:42maybe pathologized symptoms, like there's something wrong with you,
- 10:46which is something I fight against actively. So I think there's some really great things.
- 10:50And I think AI does have some really special promise in being able to detect
- 10:56things that are actually harder for humans to pick up on,
- 11:01both because your therapist isn't with you 24-7 and because there's a certain
- 11:06kind of attention that I think some of our new technologies can actually pick
- 11:11up on better in some ways than humans.
- 11:14So I think there's promise on the horizon, too, that does not come without a
- 11:20lot of concern. So I have to, like, just sneak that in there.
- 11:23Yeah, yeah. I mean, that's where we're kind of going.
- 11:27And a lot of conversations that we're having at ELA with our partner organizations,
- 11:32with parents, families, students, teachers, is what are the opportunities and
- 11:38what are the challenges? And how do we...
- 11:42Navigate, right, this kind of balance, this dance. So I'll throw it to maybe you first, Sean.
- 11:49Where do you see technology, especially AI, as an opportunity to support student mental health?
- 11:57One thing about AI that is really, really helpful, but also really,
- 12:02really dangerous, is that it can be unconditionally positive and supportive and patient.
- 12:10No human has infinite patients but ai
- 12:13does and so that can be really great
- 12:16when you're sharing something and you can get
- 12:19validated and feel really good when ai is
- 12:22validating you uh but if you start to depend
- 12:25on that too much uh like and if you start to expect that type of response from
- 12:30humans then you're going to end up in a world of trouble and so i think that
- 12:35that is a really great illustration of how even some of the great things about
- 12:40AI can be dangerous if taken too far.
- 12:44And so we just have to be really careful in how we design solutions to make
- 12:50sure that we're using them appropriately.
- 12:53One of my biggest concerns is kind of around shaping the minds of young people,
- 12:57shaping the minds of anyone that's interacting with the system too much,
- 13:00and that we are just in the way that our reward systems can get hijacked by
- 13:05alcohol or drugs or porn or video games.
- 13:10Our attachment systems can get hijacked by a compelling conversation with an AI.
- 13:16You know, and the classic example from years ago, the movie Her,
- 13:19where, you know, the guy falls in love with his OS and that kind of thing.
- 13:23You know, we're seeing it happening. That makes so much sense from a psychotherapist's
- 13:27vantage point, which is, you know, when we're in conversation with people,
- 13:30when we're deeply connected with them, we become more like them.
- 13:33We're very vulnerable and we can be brainwashed. We can be manipulated.
- 13:37And so that I can't get over, you know, and and will stay perseverating on,
- 13:44I think, hopefully, too, because I think it's going to be a chronic risk.
- 13:47I'll tell you an example, another one of something that I think it's going to
- 13:50where it's going to be really powerful and cool is that if you think about,
- 13:53you know, your students who you're talking about with disabilities and might
- 13:56have some identification with a disability, whether it's dyslexia or autism.
- 14:01I might say like forget about that throw it
- 14:04out the window interact with this new system with your
- 14:07own goals for growth say you want to become
- 14:10you know better at connecting with people that's
- 14:13just where you are or you want to become more confident about taking charge
- 14:17in your life that an AI can meet you right there potentially and listen to whatever
- 14:23it is that you want to work on and pick up on little stylistic things that you
- 14:27might do like say you never say you want to learn about other people,
- 14:31but you never pause to think about like, oh, well, what was my mom thinking
- 14:34when I was talking to her? What was my friend thinking when I was talking to her?
- 14:37And I could notice that and say,
- 14:39hey, you know, I don't hear you take the perspectives of other people.
- 14:42If you want to connect more with other people, let's have you do that.
- 14:46What do you think your mom might be thinking after you stormed out of the room?
- 14:50You know, and then you can kind of get into the nitty gritty of our interactions
- 14:54and our goals without the burden of diagnoses and things that are kind of narrowing
- 15:00our way of thinking and behaving.
- 15:02Think a lot about student privacy and student safety when you're working with
- 15:07tech, when you're working with AI.
- 15:09How do we mitigate some of these risks, right?
- 15:14That's something we spend a lot of time thinking about, and it can range.
- 15:19One of the risks that I mentioned was, and that Donna mentioned too,
- 15:25is around identifying too much
- 15:27with the AI, potentially becoming more like that, being reliant on it.
- 15:32And so as we build these AI coaches or personas that the students are going to be interacting with,
- 15:41we are careful to let them speak as though they are human,
- 15:46but not give them too many human qualities so that we We don't let them become
- 15:53like human and that they are mistaken for human.
- 15:58Things like that, things like monitoring for how students are using it.
- 16:04And if you're seeing too much student usage, flagging that to a counselor or
- 16:10getting that student help.
- 16:12Another couple things really quickly. One is monitoring for threats of violence.
- 16:20So there are some situations where students should just not be talking to an AI.
- 16:25And so we pick up on that and direct the student to a crisis support hotline.
- 16:31And then the other piece is we really try not to just push kids' heads back
- 16:39into their phone more and more.
- 16:41While we are a technology platform, a lot of the things that we do encourage
- 16:47students to go out into the world and either challenge themselves to do something
- 16:53and then come back and reflect on it.
- 16:55It's not just, oh, come talk to the chatbot as much as possible.
- 17:00It's talk to the chatbot, but then get recommended a therapist-created video
- 17:05so that you see a human face, there's a human connection there.
- 17:10And then, oh, try this exercise, like describe this to your friend or share
- 17:15this with your parents or different things like that.
- 17:18Yeah. And they're not there yet. I'm trying to leave that question in here more
- 17:22organically. I mean, Donna, you're from the clinical perspective or from the
- 17:27perspective of a, let me try this.
- 17:31You know, like I said, student safety is a huge concern.
- 17:36Donna, where do you see, sorry, I am not leading you into this question.
- 17:42Well, I'm trying to read it here. Yeah.
- 17:45What I'm trying to get to, yeah,
- 17:47is that sometimes student safety is over student privacy, student data.
- 17:52I want to kind of land on the, like, we don't want students giving away or caregivers
- 17:59giving away all of the students.
- 18:01Like good information. That's something that I'm always kind of trying to get
- 18:05in there. So somebody give me that. I don't know.
- 18:08I mean, I can say something there. I think there's two different kinds of student,
- 18:12I mean, there's more than two different kinds of student safety,
- 18:14but just thinking about two right now, the biggest ones, one would be,
- 18:18you know, their actual physical safety. Are they at risk of hurting themselves in one way?
- 18:21And then there's all kinds of precautions we need in place in order to make
- 18:27any kind of AI intervention or assistant useful and responsible there.
- 18:33That's a big issue and, yeah, one that a lot of us are thinking about.
- 18:38And ideally, it's really interwoven into a therapeutic context that's largely
- 18:43human-driven and AI-assisted.
- 18:46There's a second big area of student safety, which is around just the data.
- 18:50And right now we are in the wild west
- 18:53make no mistake it is an unregulated landscape out
- 18:57there there is regulation creeping up in various different contexts to try to
- 19:03regulate what's done with the information that's given to these ais now and
- 19:08i think and i hope what we'll see actually i mean right now when you interact
- 19:12with chat gpt or claude or whoever you're interact whatever you're interacting with, not who,
- 19:17that data is just taken.
- 19:19And there's no, you're not protected one bit. So know that now.
- 19:24And I think this is actually a precious time for people who want that information
- 19:28because it's really lucrative in certain ways.
- 19:30Ideally, within the next couple years, that will not be as free as it is right
- 19:35now. Our data will be more protected.
- 19:38And that needs to be so, especially with minors. If there's one shift you'd
- 19:43like to see in how we support student mental health and student well-being?
- 19:48What would that be? And where do we begin?
- 19:52One that comes to mind for me is just generally with regards to using technology and using AI.
- 20:01I think there's so much fear.
- 20:05People's first reaction when they hear of AI and using technology to support
- 20:10student mental health is often one of fear.
- 20:12And I think just shifting that perception of fear to a perception of curiosity.
- 20:20Like cautious curiosity, but curiosity nonetheless, opens up so many more opportunities
- 20:28for us to actually try and do what's best for kids.
- 20:32And so just that slight mind that shift
- 20:35of well let's let's learn a little bit about this before we
- 20:38dismiss this out of hand i think is
- 20:42is very important but it's it's ruined a
- 20:45little by some bad actors as donna was talking about
- 20:48where there like are some companies that will just take your data and so just
- 20:53we have to be careful which companies we're working with and that's why we have
- 20:57a very rigorous standard at Inner Peak of how we store and save data that we
- 21:03don't share or sell it with third parties or anything like that.
- 21:06I want us paying more attention to the environments that we're creating for students.
- 21:11I want to create healthier environments for all of us, honestly,
- 21:14and be thoughtful from the get-go, you know, in the same way a teacher designs
- 21:19their classroom to make it comfortable for kids and inspiring.
- 21:24And I think we need to do that everywhere to think about how to bring out the
- 21:29most health from our students.
- 21:31And then, of course, to continue protecting the most vulnerable.
- 21:35I mean, there's a lot of students out there suffering a lot.
- 21:38And that needs immediate attention. But then for the long term to be thinking
- 21:43about how do we create healthier environments?
- 21:47Well, we're almost out of time, but before we go, how can listeners,
- 21:51how can folks in the ELA-verse, the ELA universe, how can we get involved with
- 21:55your work or learn more or connect with you? You know, let us know.
- 21:59Yeah, absolutely. So the first thing you can do is check out our website.
- 22:03So it's www.innerpeak.ai.
- 22:11There's ways to contact us. You can read more about what we're doing.
- 22:14If you want to try out our app, it's beneficial to everyone, not just students.
- 22:20You can try our seven-day free trial.
- 22:23We're available on the App Store, the Google Play Store, just search Innerpeat.
- 22:27And if you have specific questions or want to talk about student mental health,
- 22:32feel free to just email me at sean, S-E-A-N, at innerpeat.ai. Always happy to chat.
- 22:39Yeah. And Sean, do we have a place for users to give feedback?
- 22:44Like if they have an experience with the app? fit?
- 22:48Yes. So they can email that feedback to our general email address.
- 22:54It's general at interpeek.ai. And we would love to hear all the feedback that people have.
- 22:59And one other thing I would add is we usually partner with schools to bring
- 23:04our tool to their students.
- 23:05And so if you work at a school, know school administrators who might be interested
- 23:10in exploring bringing Peek to their school, feel free to reach out and connect us.
- 23:15Thank you both so much for joining us today. It was great to chat with you.
- 23:19Likewise. Thanks so much for having us, Aurora. We really appreciate it. Yeah, thank you.
- 23:24That's it for us today, folks. Thank you to Sean Wheelock and Dr.
- 23:27Donna Tversky. To learn more, visit my website at educatingalllearners.org.
- 23:32I'm Aurora from ELA, and this was a deep dive into student mental health.