Latest / Beyond The Horizon / The United States Governments Brief In Response To Ghislaine Maxwell's Appeal Request (Part 9)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome back to the Epstein Chronicles.
- 0:04In this episode, we're going to get right back to
- 0:06the United States government's brief in a response to Glenn
- 0:10Maxwell's attempt to appeal her sentence point number four. The
- 0:16District Court's response to a jury note did not constructively
- 0:19amend the indictment. At all times, the government consistently argued
- 0:24that Maxwell enticed and transported Jane to New York with
- 0:27the intent that Jane engage in illegal sexual activity, and
- 0:31that Maxwell conspired to do so. Regarding Jane and the
- 0:34other victims, that is the issue Judge Nathan instructed the
- 0:38jury to resolve, and that is the criminal conduct charge
- 0:41and counts three and four of the indictment. Accordingly, no
- 0:45constructive amendment or variance occurred a relevant facts. Count three
- 0:51and four charge Maxwell with arranging for Jane's transportation to
- 0:55New York with the intent that Jane would engage in
- 0:58sex acts with Epstein and violatetiontion of New York state law,
- 1:01and with a conspiracy to transport miners to New York
- 1:04for the same purpose. At trial, the government martialed evidence
- 1:08that Maxwell transported Jane to New York and aided and
- 1:11abetted Epstein in doing so, with the intent that Jane
- 1:15engaged in sexual activity there. That evidence included detailed testimony
- 1:19from Jane about Epstein's New York residence and specific sexual
- 1:24acts that took place in New York while Jane was
- 1:26a miner. The government's summation similarly discussed these charges as
- 1:31encompassing conduct directed at New York. As to Count four,
- 1:35the government argued the evidence showed Jane was transported to
- 1:39New York and Maxwell was involved in making travel arrangements.
- 1:43The government also clarified that the crime happened the moment Maxwell,
- 1:47Epstein and Jane crossed state lines, and to be very clear,
- 1:50when Epstein flew Jane to New York and Maxwell aided
- 1:54and abetted him, that's enough too for the conspiracy accounts.
- 1:58The government referenced its earlier discussion of the elements of
- 2:01the substantative offenses, and the government argued that even though
- 2:05Carolyn and Annie were not sexually abused in New York,
- 2:09that it was Maxwell and Epstein they both intended it
- 2:12CEE t R two eight nine five Tosh ninety six,
- 2:15arguing that Maxwell groomed Danny for abuse after she had
- 2:18already visited Epstein in New York. The District Court's jury
- 2:22instructions also permitted the jury to determine only whether Maxwell
- 2:26had intended that Jane, for the substantative counts or the
- 2:30conspiracy victims, engage in sexual activity in New York. During trial,
- 2:35Judge Nathan granted defense requests for limiting instructions that the
- 2:40time evidence came in to make clear that the charges
- 2:42focused on the intent that sexual activity take place in
- 2:46New York. At the conclusion of trial, Judge Nathan instructed
- 2:50the jury that count for alleged that Maxwell knowingly transported
- 2:55Jane with the intent that Jane with the intent that
- 2:58Jane engage in sexual activity for which any person can
- 3:01be charged with a criminal offense in violation of New
- 3:04York law. Judge Nathan also instructed the jury on one
- 3:09and only one predicate state offense, a violation of New
- 3:13York Penal Law section one thirty dot fifty five. The
- 3:17instructions on count three incorporated this discussion of the elements
- 3:21of Count four, and the only statute identified was New
- 3:24York Penal Law section one thirty dot fifty five. During deliberations,
- 3:29the jury sent the following note under count four, if
- 3:33the defendant aided in the transportation of Jane's return flight,
- 3:37but not the flight to New Mexico, where if the
- 3:39intent was for Jane to engage in sexual activity, can
- 3:43she be found guilty under the second element. The note
- 3:46led to a lengthy discussion, at the conclusion of which
- 3:49Judge Nathan determined she should refer the jury back to
- 3:52the jury charge on the second element of count four
- 3:55because the jury note was otherwise too difficult to parse
- 3:58factually and legally. That night, Maxwell filed a letter seeking
- 4:03reconsideration of Judge Nathan's response and raising the possibility of
- 4:08the constructive amendment or prejudicial variance, because, in her view,
- 4:12the note showed that the jury might convict based on
- 4:15Jane's testimony that she was abused in New Mexico. Maxwell
- 4:19asked Judge Nathan to instruct the jury as to the
- 4:22intent elements of counts to and four, and to add
- 4:25that an intent that Jane engage in sexual activity in
- 4:29any other state, then New York cannot form the basis
- 4:32for these two element counts too and four. Judge Nathan
- 4:36rejected Maxwell's request, both because the jury did not inquire
- 4:40about count two and because of the final sentence as
- 4:43just wrong in suggesting that the intent that Jane engaged
- 4:46in sexual activity outside of New York may have no relevance.
- 4:50As Judge Nathan explained, this is the same discussion we've
- 4:54had a couple of times sexual activity with respect to
- 4:57Jane in New Mexico under the age of seventeen can
- 5:00be relevant to intent to transport to New York to
- 5:03engage in sexual activity under the age of seventeen. Judge
- 5:07Nathan repeated that she did not know how to parse
- 5:10the jury's question exactly, but that her instruction directing the
- 5:14jury to the original charge included a reminder that it's
- 5:17a violation of New York penal law. That's charge and
- 5:20is the illegal sexual activity that they're considering. Judge Nathan
- 5:24also pointed out that Maxwell did not seek to exclude
- 5:27Jane's testimony about New Mexico or seek a limiting instruction
- 5:31with respect to that testimony. Judge Nathan added, I have
- 5:35no idea if that's what the jury is asking or
- 5:38many other plausible readings. Noted that the defense had proposed
- 5:42an incorrect instruction and concluded no more was required than
- 5:46sending the jury back to the charge be applicable law.
- 5:51A constructive amendment occurs when the charge upon which the
- 5:54defendant has tried differs significantly from the charge upon which
- 5:58the grand jury voted. States vs. Kulobski, five F. Dot
- 6:02f four two seventy nine to ninety three, Second Circuit,
- 6:06twenty twenty one. Not every alteration of an indictment, however,
- 6:10rises to the level of a constructive amendment United States
- 6:13versus Dove, eight eighty four F Dot three d one
- 6:16thirty eight one forty six, Second Circuit twenty eighteen. Instead,
- 6:21to prevail on a constructive amendment claim, a defendant must
- 6:25demonstrate that the terms of an indictment are an effect
- 6:28altered by the presentation of evidence and jury instructions which
- 6:31so modify essential elements of the offense that there is
- 6:35a substantial likelihood that the defendant may have been convicted
- 6:39on an offense other than that charged in the indictment.
- 6:44United States versus d Amelio, six ninety three F dot
- 6:47three d four twelve four to sixteen, Second Circuit, twenty twelve.
- 6:52This Court has consistently permitted significant flexibility and proof, provided
- 6:57that the defendant was given notice of the core of
- 6:59krememality to be proven at trial. United States versus lebettev.
- 7:05Nine thirty two f dot three d forty fifty three,
- 7:08Second Circuit, twenty nineteen. The core of criminality is the
- 7:13essence of a crime in general terms, but not the
- 7:16particulars of how a defendant affected the crime d' emilio
- 7:20six ninety three f. Dot three, d at four eighteen.
- 7:23There is no constructive amendment where the allegations in the
- 7:26indictment and the proof at trial both relate to a
- 7:29single set of discrete facts or form part of a
- 7:32single course of conduct with the same ultimate purpose id
- 7:36At four nineteen through four to twenty one. A variance
- 7:40occurs when the charging terms of the indictment are left unaltered,
- 7:44but the evidence offered at trial proves facts materially different
- 7:48from those alleged in the indictment United States versus Bankey,
- 7:51six eighty five f dot three d ninety nine one nineteen,
- 7:56Second Circuit, twenty twelve. Reversal due to a variance is
- 7:59appropriate only when the defendant can establish that substantial prejudice
- 8:05occurred at trial as a result of the variance. A
- 8:08showing that cannot be made where the pleading and the
- 8:11proof substantially correspond, where the variance is not of a
- 8:14character that could have misled the defendant at trial, and
- 8:17where the variance is not such as to deprive the
- 8:20accused of the right to be protected against another prosecution
- 8:25for the same offense Koloopski, five f. Dot fourth, at
- 8:29two ninety four. So long as the defendant receives notice
- 8:33of the government's theory, the defendant cannot show prejudice. Ceg. Bankee,
- 8:38six eighty five f. Dot three d at one nineteen.
- 8:42This Court reviews claims of constructed amendment and prejudicial variants
- 8:47Denovo Dove, eight eighty four F. Dot three d at
- 8:50one forty six and one forty nine, Part C. The discussion.
- 8:55There is no likelihood, much less a substantial likelihood, that
- 8:59the Jerry convict Maxwell's solely because Jane was transported to
- 9:03New Mexico. At no point during the trial, including its summation,
- 9:07did the government argue that the jury could convict on
- 9:10a theory that Maxwell intended Jane to be abused in
- 9:13New Mexico. Similarly, the District Court's charge required the jury
- 9:17to decide whether Maxwell intended to violate New York law.
- 9:21The trial contained no instructions describing for the jury any
- 9:25particular criminal statute in New Mexico or any other basis
- 9:29by which a jury could convict based on conduct in
- 9:32New Mexico. Maxwell's argument to the country rests entirely on
- 9:36her reading of the jury's note. According to Maxwell, the
- 9:39note shows that the jury decided that there was no
- 9:42corroborating evidence that Maxwell was present for or helped arrange
- 9:46any of Jane's trips to New York, but that the
- 9:49flight logs did corroborate that Maxwell was present for Jane's
- 9:52trip to New Mexico. This reading, she claims, as buttressed
- 9:56by the fact that the jury acquitted on count two, which,
- 9:59in her telling, shows that the jury determined that the
- 10:02only corroborating evidence linking Maxwell to the New Mexico trip
- 10:05was a flight log showing that she was present on
- 10:08the trip, but said nothing about whether she persuaded, induced, enticed,
- 10:12or corps Jane to take the trip. Judge Nathan correctly
- 10:16rejected this argument. Judge Nathan found that the original jury
- 10:20instructions and the government's summation captured the core of criminality
- 10:24charged in the indictment focusing specifically on conduct directed at
- 10:28a sexual activity in New York. Even if the note
- 10:32revealed that the jury were confused and wondered whether it
- 10:35could convict based on conduct in New Mexico, Judge Nathan's
- 10:39response used that confusion. As Judge Nathan explained, she sent
- 10:42the jury back to the instruction, which accurately instructed that
- 10:46count four had to be predicated on finding a violation
- 10:49of New York law that was sufficient. Ce United States
- 10:53versus Ramy Bibo six ft three d one O eight
- 10:56one twenty six, Second Circuit, two thousand and seven enjoys
- 11:00considerable discretion in framing a response to a jury note,
- 11:04and is only required to answer the particular inquiries posed.
- 11:08As Judge Nathan explained, Maxwell failed to propose a better response,
- 11:12requesting instead a series of instructions that were unresponsive, redundant,
- 11:17and legally inaccurate. See Ramy five oh six ft three
- 11:21d at one twenty six. Judge Nathan's response to the
- 11:25jury note was sound and did not constructively amend the indictment.
- 11:29All right, folks, we're gonna wrap up right there, and
- 11:32in the next episode we're going to pick up with
- 11:34Maxwell's contrary views rest on extensive speculation. All of the
- 11:39information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 11:42the description box.