Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The Impact of California's New Civility Rules on Litigation and ADR with Hon. Yvette M. Palazuelos (Ret.)and Alan S. Petlak
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everybody and good afternoon and welcome to our program entitled the impact of California
- 0:12Civility Rules on Litigation in ADR, a very interesting topic indeed.
- 0:18I'm Robert Cohen, Chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association Mediation and ADR section
- 0:23and I have the privilege of introducing today to you two terrific panelists.
- 0:28The first is the Honorable Yvette Palazzullos and I hope I said that right, Paulette.
- 0:34If I didn't, you'll crack me.
- 0:35That's okay, Palazzullos.
- 0:37Palazzullos, okay, thank you.
- 0:39And the second is Attorney Alan Petlack and both Judge Palazzullos and Alan are very
- 0:47experienced in terms of trials and litigation and they've been through the wars over decades,
- 0:54whether it was in the federal courts or in the state courts.
- 0:58Judge Palazzullos first joined Judicat West this year after 24 years of service on the
- 1:05Superior Court bench.
- 1:06She was appointed in 2000.
- 1:08Initially, she presided over a wide variety of civil matters while sitting in an individual
- 1:13calendar, direct calendar courtroom.
- 1:16Then in 2018, she was assigned to preside over complex civil cases such as mass torts,
- 1:24mass actions, and complex business disputes.
- 1:28Prior to her appointment of the bench, she was an assistant U.S. attorney prosecuting
- 1:32federal criminal matters in the Central District.
- 1:37Alan has a different background.
- 1:40He's been a full-time mediator since 2018 and an arbitrator as well.
- 1:45And since 2022, he's been on Judicat West's esteemed roster of neutrals.
- 1:50Prior to becoming a neutral, Alan spent over 20 years as a big law litigator and trial
- 1:56lawyer handling a variety of civil disputes from intake through trial.
- 2:01Alan has expertise in real estate, personal injury, consumer finance, employment, and
- 2:06securities law and has litigated many complex business disputes over the years.
- 2:13He is always prepared for any assignment that he takes on and he is quite successful in
- 2:19bringing matters to settlement by utilizing his special problem solving techniques and
- 2:25his years of litigating and trying a multitude of cases.
- 2:29So Judge Palazulis and Alan, the floor is yours and I look forward to being in the audience
- 2:34and hearing what you have to say.
- 2:36Thank you.
- 2:37Thank you so much, Robert, for that very nice introduction.
- 2:42We have a lot of material we intend to cover today.
- 2:46If we have time at the end, we will take some questions, but it's a very broad topic when
- 2:52you speak about civility.
- 2:55It's something that has been in discussion through the judiciary and litigators and
- 3:01transactional attorneys from, I think, from the beginning of practicing law.
- 3:07And it's taken on a renewed focus over the last few years.
- 3:11In 2021, there was a report that came out from the California Civility Task Force, which
- 3:19was a joint project of the California Judges Association and California Lawyers Association.
- 3:25And they came out with a number of proposals to really stress the importance of practicing
- 3:33law with civility.
- 3:36There were a number of proposed rules, which we will discuss.
- 3:39Some of them are passed, some of them are still pending.
- 3:42Among one of the rules was to require an annual oath for lawyers on a going forward basis,
- 3:52making clear of their obligation to be civil.
- 3:56This actually stems from the relatively new requirements, new for need, because I became
- 4:03a member of the Bar back in 1995, but in 2014, the California Rules of Court 9.7 was adopted.
- 4:13And 9.7 requires all new admittees to take an oath that says, as an officer of the court,
- 4:21I will strive to conduct myself at all times with dignity, courtesy, and integrity.
- 4:28It's also true, and I know that we have many in attendance today, and I'm happy to see
- 4:32it, that it's now an MCLE requirement that you take one hour of civility training, beginning
- 4:41compliance period, January 31, 2025.
- 4:44And I will tell you, since that's been adopted, this is now my third presentation on civility
- 4:49that I have given.
- 4:51But it's sort of the emphasis of part of the skill, part of being a good advocate for your
- 4:59client is also demonstrated for your client the importance of civility in the practice
- 5:06of law.
- 5:07I'm going to turn it over to you, Yvette, now to talk about some of the proposed rules,
- 5:14including what's affectionately called as the snitch rule.
- 5:17And one of the things that is being proposed is that a lawyer may be disciplined for not
- 5:27being civil.
- 5:28Yvette, let me turn it over to you.
- 5:30Well, thank you, Helen.
- 5:32Helen, yet the state bar has proposed a new rule 8.4.2 based on recommendations of the
- 5:38California Civility Task Force, and Helen just described what that task force was.
- 5:43And this rule provides that a lawyer may be disciplined for incivility.
- 5:47That was kind of surprising to me that there wasn't such a rule to begin with, but in fact,
- 5:51there isn't.
- 5:52And this rule is under consideration, hasn't been passed.
- 5:55We're going to talk about the text of it, but realize that what we're presenting today
- 5:59is not the final rule.
- 6:00It could be amended.
- 6:01In fact, it could be entirely rejected, but it could be amended or changed in some fashion.
- 6:07But we're going to talk about what it looks like now.
- 6:11So this is the new proposed rule 8.4.2 labeled prohibited incivility.
- 6:17In representing a client, a lawyer shall not engage in civility in the practice of law.
- 6:23And for purposes of this rule, incivility means significantly unprofessional conduct
- 6:28that is abusive or harassing, and shall be determined on the basis of all the facts and
- 6:32circumstances surrounding the conduct.
- 6:34So the key question now is, what is unprofessional conduct that is abusive or harassing?
- 6:41So we have some guidance is provided for us in the comments to the new rule.
- 6:47For example, comment one says, for guidance on the conduct that may be significantly unprofessional
- 6:52that is abusive or harassing, lawyers should consult the current California attorney guidelines
- 6:56of civility and professionalism and other relevant authorities.
- 7:01Those other relevant authorities would be case law, for example.
- 7:03We're going to talk about the case law later so you can get a sense of what courts have
- 7:07determined to be significant incivility.
- 7:10But you should consult the guidelines as well as case law and any local rules of court and
- 7:16bar associations, codes of civility.
- 7:20Now we have provided in the materials for this seminar the LA Superior Court guidelines
- 7:27for civility.
- 7:28They can be found in local rules under Appendix C, but we provided them today as part of our
- 7:34materials.
- 7:35That can also inform us as to what is unprofessional or abusive or harassing conduct.
- 7:39Also comment to the new rule four defines incivility as a rule that may include conduct
- 7:48or speech that violates an attorney's duties under the business and profession code.
- 7:52But what I found really interesting about this comment is its reference to the California
- 7:56judicial code of conduct.
- 7:58As you can see, Canon VB says regarding a judge's responsibility to require lawyers
- 8:04under the judge's direction and control to be patient, dignified, courteous, to litigants,
- 8:09jurors, witnesses, lawyers, and others.
- 8:11So that's telling you what the rule expects of civility.
- 8:18Cursions, dignity, and courteousness.
- 8:21And it also makes sure that you understand that your civility is expected for all these
- 8:26parties in the process, not just opposing counsel but litigants, jurors, witnesses,
- 8:32and the court as well.
- 8:33So it's not just confined to opposing counsel.
- 8:36If I really want to ask you a question, because I'm not going to restrain you.
- 8:40When it says that one of the obligations is to be patient.
- 8:46And unfortunately, as a mediator, I'm very patient outside of being a mediator.
- 8:51I probably am less patient than I should be.
- 8:55But the setup to this point is the fact that it's a possibility that one day having a lack
- 9:04of civility may be subject to you to discipline.
- 9:06Can you really be subject to discipline for being impatient?
- 9:11You probably could, but interestingly enough, in the context of mediation, you will see
- 9:14that there's a privilege associated with mediation, as you know.
- 9:18And therefore, in civility that may occur in the context of mediation may be privileged.
- 9:23That will come up later in the presentation.
- 9:25But it's interesting that you do raise that as a possibility.
- 9:28But yes, patience is required of all of us, of the mediators, of the participants in the
- 9:32mediation.
- 9:33But the privilege attached to it would probably make that not reportable.
- 9:37But we'll get into that later.
- 9:40All right, this is what we call lovin'ingly the snitch rule, the California rule of professional
- 9:46conduct 8.3.
- 9:48And that is actually a rule that's in effect.
- 9:50It's not proposed, it's in effect now.
- 9:53And that provides a lawyer's shell without undue delay, inform the state bar or a tribunal
- 9:58with jurisdiction to investigate or act upon misconduct, when the lawyer knows of credible
- 10:03evidence that another lawyer has committed a criminal act or has engaged in conduct
- 10:08involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or reckless or intentional misrepresentation, or misappropriation
- 10:13of funds or property.
- 10:15That raises a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness
- 10:19as a lawyer in other respects.
- 10:21That's quite a mouthful.
- 10:22So what I did in this next little slide here is try to break that down a little bit.
- 10:28So what the rule requires, this niche rule requires, is that attorneys report the following
- 10:32type of misconduct by fellow attorneys.
- 10:35Criminal acts, of course, and that probably as a result of Thomas Gerardi, unfortunately,
- 10:40that situation.
- 10:42Criminal acts would have to be reported by attorneys against fellow attorneys to the
- 10:48state bar.
- 10:49Also conduct including dishonesty, fraud, deceit, misrepresentation, misappropriation.
- 10:54But the last part is what I find very interesting.
- 10:56This is kind of the catch-all for reporting.
- 11:00Conduct involving a substantial question as to the attorney's honesty, trustworthiness,
- 11:04or fitness as a lawyer, or as an attorney in other respects.
- 11:07And that's where we have the meeting of the 8.3, the snitch rule, and this insubility
- 11:14rule.
- 11:15You have a question for you.
- 11:16So what happens if you don't snitch?
- 11:18So if you see that conduct, choose not to report it.
- 11:23What's the consequence?
- 11:24That could be disciplined by the bar.
- 11:26I mean, that's why this first little sentence here, we say, it's the violation of the ethics
- 11:31rules for lawyers to fail to report or snitch on fellow lawyers.
- 11:35And so what that means for our insubility rule is since misconduct includes conduct
- 11:41that raises a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or
- 11:45fitness, the lawyer's likely must report significant insubility to the state bar.
- 11:50So that's the impact of kind of marrying those two rules together.
- 11:55So what does a substantial question of significant insubility mean?
- 12:00Well, I think, and then this is going to have to be developed over time, obviously, but
- 12:05we're not talking about garden variety, rudeness.
- 12:08OK?
- 12:09It requires something much more than that.
- 12:12The definition of substantial in rule 1.0.1L says substantial when used in reference to
- 12:18degree or extent means a material matter of clear and weighty importance.
- 12:22So the garden variety, rudeness, will not be part of the insubility that would be reportable.
- 12:28What they're talking about is severe or substantial incivility, and it would not be failing to
- 12:34return a phone call.
- 12:36That's rude, yes.
- 12:38It's not appropriate, but it happens, but it wouldn't be rise to the level, at least
- 12:42in my view, of substantial and significant incivility.
- 12:47But we'll go through the cases later.
- 12:49Alan, I will go through.
- 12:51Yeah.
- 12:52And question for you on that.
- 12:53I mean, isn't it sort of still a slippery slope?
- 12:55Because what I think is very offensive may not be what you think is very offensive, and
- 13:00then you have to decide what's reportable and what is it?
- 13:04Yes.
- 13:05They're very true, which is part of why I said this aspect of the rule is going to have
- 13:10to be developed.
- 13:11And hopefully, I would like to see from the civility tax force, maybe examples, maybe
- 13:18a sheet that would give lawyers examples of what would constitute substantial incivility
- 13:23as opposed to this garden variety type rudeness.
- 13:29We're not there yet, Alan, but you raise a very good point.
- 13:32This is something that's got to be developed over time.
- 13:37There's a comment to the Stitch Rule, comment, note six, permits reporting to either the
- 13:43state bar or a tribunal with jurisdiction to investigate or act upon such misconduct.
- 13:48So we actually have to make a determination.
- 13:50So are you reported to the state bar or should I report it to the tribunal?
- 13:54Now if you have a case you're litigating in the IC court, for example, and you have some
- 13:59kind of incivility in discovery, obviously you can bring that to the attention of your
- 14:04trial court, and that will be taken care of.
- 14:08If it can't be taken care of by the trial court for some reason, then you report to
- 14:12the state bar.
- 14:13But there's an interesting paragraph in note six that deals specifically with our
- 14:20arbitration.
- 14:21It states, however, whether litigation is pending before a private arbitrator reporting
- 14:26to the tribunal may not be sufficient.
- 14:29A determination whether to report to a tribunal instead of the state bar will depend on whether
- 14:34the misconduct arises during the pending litigation and whether the particular tribunal has the
- 14:40power to investigate or act upon the alleged misconduct.
- 14:45Let me fair it out a little bit more.
- 14:47So if you are before a superior court judge, like you were once a superior court judge,
- 14:54and there is severe misconduct by the other counsel, then in that respect, you'd be permitted
- 15:00to report that to the judge because the judge could potentially then investigate it and
- 15:05come to some sort of findings.
- 15:07Is that right?
- 15:08That's correct.
- 15:09Either through, for example, in a discovery issue, either through emotion to compel discovery
- 15:14with requested sanctions or just a request for sanctions, you could do that as well.
- 15:18Also Alan, another thing that I think could be done is status conference.
- 15:22Just set the mat on for status conference.
- 15:23You don't even have to bring in motion.
- 15:25Just ask the court to set a status conference and kind of alert the court to the problems.
- 15:29They could be kind of worked out in that way.
- 15:32That's another possible avenue that a trial court or a tribunal could address it.
- 15:38But in the context of arbitration, the tribunal, the arbitrator has limited power.
- 15:43So for example, here, if the incivilities outside the litigation, does the arbitrator
- 15:49have power to address it?
- 15:51I don't think so.
- 15:52It's not.
- 15:53No.
- 15:54And that would be a circumstance where you'd have to report to the state bar because a tribunal,
- 15:57the arbitrator cannot address the incivility.
- 16:01For example, if you're doing an arbitration, arbitration concludes, maybe it settles, for
- 16:06example, maybe two days into the arbitration, you settle your arbitration.
- 16:12But after it falls apart and the arbitration is dismissed, then for some reason the party
- 16:17is getting disbued over the settlement and there starts to be some incivility among the
- 16:20parties in that context.
- 16:22Would the arbitrator be able to jump in at that point?
- 16:25No, because the arbitration has been dismissed.
- 16:28You settled your case.
- 16:29That's outside the power of the arbitrator.
- 16:31So that would have to be addressed to the state bar.
- 16:37However, if your trial court somehow still maintains jurisdiction in some fashion, even
- 16:42though the arbitration was dismissed, perhaps that can be brought to the attention of the
- 16:46trial judge.
- 16:47Let me ask you this question.
- 16:49And I think it's probably a question without an answer.
- 16:52What if your arbitration agreement provides that the arbitrator has the same authority
- 16:56as a superior court judge?
- 16:58Would that make a difference?
- 17:00I don't know the answer to that.
- 17:02That's a good question.
- 17:03I really don't know the answer to that.
- 17:05That would have to be tested, I think, in the courts in some fashion.
- 17:11I would assume if you had the same power you could.
- 17:16I don't know if an arbitrator would really want to do that, but I'm assuming if you have
- 17:20the same power you could.
- 17:22But I think that would have to be tested, Ellen.
- 17:24I don't think I don't have the answer to that.
- 17:26Certainly a nopelid issue.
- 17:28And the second little PowerPoint there about arbitrators do have power to act, obviously,
- 17:34in the context of the litigation motions to compel and sanctions in connection with that
- 17:38for instability.
- 17:40Also reduction for attorney's fees that comes up in arbitration.
- 17:43That could also take care of any kind of instability.
- 17:46So there are times when the arbitrator can address instability.
- 17:51So that would not be required to be reported to the state bar.
- 17:53That could stay right with the arbitrator.
- 17:55But I also noted here there are some powers that I think, and Ellen raised that just recently.
- 18:01I think the arbitrator would be limited.
- 18:03For example, if there's a severe instability, warranting contempt, is that something an arbitrator
- 18:08can impose?
- 18:09I have doubts about that.
- 18:11The reason being arbitrators are given power to decide civil disputes.
- 18:16We know that contempt is kind of a quasi-criminal type of proceeding.
- 18:20Is that really something that was given to an arbitrator to do in connection with this
- 18:25civil matter?
- 18:26I have doubts about that.
- 18:27But again, this is something that can be explored later.
- 18:30And it raises an issue whether that really is with that if instability is so severe, it
- 18:34would result in contempt.
- 18:36Is that really something that an arbitrator can take care of?
- 18:38I doubt it.
- 18:39It's a great point.
- 18:41It's the fact that you get into in the land of criminal and that may impact the authority
- 18:46of the arbitrator to really act.
- 18:49And same thing goes for removal of counsel for instability.
- 18:52If it's so severe that counsel should be removed for instability, and we'll see later on there's
- 18:57case law about that, that's not something an arbitrator typically does.
- 19:01That probably would be reserved for the state bar.
- 19:04That would be a circumstance where you wouldn't necessarily report to your arbitrator, but
- 19:07would report to the state bar.
- 19:08I believe we had a little lapse in connection.
- 19:19Oops.
- 19:20Yeah.
- 19:21Go ahead, you're back on.
- 19:23Okay, good.
- 19:25That same comment to this vitro provides that, see I can't see that too well, also provides
- 19:31that a report to the proper tribunal may also trigger obligations for the tribunal to report
- 19:35the misconduct to the state bar or to take other appropriative corrective action.
- 19:40So what that means in the context of arbitration is that if the report is made, invincibility
- 19:46is made to the arbitrator or the arbitrator observes it in some way, that may trigger
- 19:51the arbitrator's obligation to report it to the state bar.
- 19:53It says may trigger.
- 19:54It doesn't say must, but it does say may.
- 19:57So our arbitrator is going to have to consider whether or not he or she can actually take
- 20:02care of the misconduct in some way or the instability.
- 20:06But if he or she cannot, my reading of this comment is that that would be reported to
- 20:11the state bar.
- 20:13The arbitrator would have to do that.
- 20:14If the arbitrator, him or herself, could not take care of it.
- 20:23There are exceptions to the stitch rule, by the way.
- 20:27I'll just go over.
- 20:28I won't read the rule to you, but basically attorneys and arbitrators and mediators are
- 20:32not required to report information or misconduct information that they obtain in connection
- 20:40with the attorney client privilege or the mediation privilege.
- 20:43Alan, we talked about this early.
- 20:45If there's instability during mediation, I think there's no way you can report that
- 20:49to the bar because that's something that would violate the mediation privilege or any other
- 20:55privilege for that matter.
- 20:57There's no obligation to report that under the stitch rule.
- 21:00And let me just stop there because I think that makes a lot of sense because part of
- 21:05mediation, it's being able to be open, being able to be yourself.
- 21:10Sometimes that comes across differently from other times.
- 21:14And to sanction someone or bring something to the attention of the state bar based upon
- 21:21how an attorney acts in mediation, that's a little bit unfair, I think, because really
- 21:25that's the form of really being able to express yourself.
- 21:29Absolutely.
- 21:30Absolutely.
- 21:31That's the interest behind the mediation privilege that still needs to be protected, even the
- 21:35context of this stitch rule.
- 21:37So the stitch rule does recognize that.
- 21:40The other circumstance that's an exception is when an attorney is undergoing treatment
- 21:45for substance abuse or mental health issues.
- 21:49And that makes sense too, right?
- 21:50Because we don't want to discourage people, attorneys, from seeking help either for the
- 21:55drug abuse or for a mental health condition.
- 21:58Want to encourage them to do that.
- 21:59If they're afraid that something would be reported to the state bar because of alleged
- 22:06insubility, that really discourages them from seeking treatment, so it makes sense.
- 22:11Also, if an attorney is consulting other attorneys about insubility or misconduct, that also
- 22:19should not be reported.
- 22:21Because the attorney is asking for help, right?
- 22:23Trying to wade through what is misconduct, what is insubility, what are my obligations.
- 22:29If you're doing that by reporting that attorney, you're defeating the whole purpose of this
- 22:33civility, right?
- 22:36You're turning them in and really they're seeking help.
- 22:37So those are exceptions to the reporting requirement.
- 22:40And at ethics hotlines, same issue.
- 22:45We're open, that's fine.
- 22:49I have it now.
- 22:50We're going to change focus a little bit and talk about how courts have dealt with insubility.
- 22:57And you will see there's been an evolution.
- 22:59And you bet we'll talk about a lot of the earlier cases where courts have dealt with
- 23:04a lawyer night acting with property quorum by either sanctioning that attorney contempt.
- 23:13And there's been a shift.
- 23:14And the shift now is, and I'll talk about it, it's my favorite case, the snook decision,
- 23:19which I'll speak about in the end, where the court says, you know what, if you're not
- 23:23going to behave properly, I'm not going to judge you the same way as a lawyer of your
- 23:28experience level.
- 23:29So when it comes to attorney's fee motions, that could be a basis to lower the attorney's
- 23:36fees that you are requesting based upon your conduct throughout the litigation.
- 23:40So you bet if you would please, please match with some of those cases where we talk about
- 23:46sanctions and contempt and as we get closer to the snook decision.
- 23:50Yes, absolutely.
- 23:51So what we're going to do here is give you examples of what's considered severe, a substantial
- 23:56insubility and go through all the various consequences of the insubility that courts
- 24:02have imposed all the way from monetary sanctions, contempt, other types of punishment.
- 24:09And then Alan will talk about the attorney's fees issue, but we'll go through those cases.
- 24:14There's not every case, by the way, we just kind of categorize them.
- 24:18So it's not every single case that has ever addressed insubility.
- 24:22Or between me to mention.
- 24:25Yeah, unfortunately.
- 24:26Okay, our first category deals with false statements to the court and false accusations
- 24:31against opposing counsel as a basis for insubility.
- 24:34The first case I want to talk about is the case of Kim versus Westmore.
- 24:38That's a case where plaintiffs' counsel asked and received an extension to file an appellate
- 24:42brief late.
- 24:44And the basis for the request was that I need more time to research the cases and finish
- 24:49my brief.
- 24:50I don't have too many time commitments.
- 24:52Well, in fact, when the brief was ultimately filed, the Court of Appeal found that the
- 24:56plaintiff's brief was essentially a copy of a brief he filed earlier.
- 25:01So it really wasn't, didn't reflect any new research or complex research of complex issues.
- 25:07And counsel could not have claimed any more significant time in preparation for that brief.
- 25:13So the court said his conclusory claims in support of his extension were not to put too
- 25:17fine a point on it, untrue.
- 25:20We cannot overlook such conduct.
- 25:22It is critical to both the bench and the bar that we be able to rely on the honesty of
- 25:25counsel.
- 25:28Then if you want to add insult to injury, the brief also accused defense counsel, the
- 25:34opposing attorney, of falsely arguing the case, calling the appeal frivolous, which
- 25:39it was not, and asking for $20,000 in sanctions without discussion of the facts or the law
- 25:45that would support the claim that the appeal was frivolous or the sanctions.
- 25:50So the court just was not happy with that.
- 25:53The request for sanctions should be reserved for serious violations of the standard of
- 25:57practice, not as a bullying tactic.
- 25:59And clearly, that was what was intended in this case.
- 26:03And I want to read to you what was stated by the Pellicourt in that case, because it
- 26:08really is a warning for all of us and kind of a little lecture, actually.
- 26:13So let me read that.
- 26:14I like it quite a bit.
- 26:16It says a lot about us.
- 26:19Our profession is rife with cynicism, awash in insubility.
- 26:23Lawyers and judges of our generation spend on great deal of time lamenting the loss of
- 26:27a golden age when lawyers treated each other with respect and courtesy.
- 26:30It is time to stop talking about the problem and act on it.
- 26:35For decades, our profession has given lip service to civility.
- 26:38All we have gotten from it is tired lips, which I love that line.
- 26:43We have reluctantly concluded lips cannot do the job.
- 26:46Teeth are required.
- 26:47In this case, those teeth will take the form of sanctions, and the attorney will sanction
- 26:51$10,000 and refer to the state bar.
- 26:56The next case I want to talk about is similar in terms of the allegations against opposing
- 27:00counsel and litigants.
- 27:02It's Fendleton versus Coyote.
- 27:04It's a Native American case in which the tribe, in its brief, accused the litigant of embezzlement,
- 27:10and then accused the opposing counsel of having a known history of harassment and personal
- 27:14animus toward Native Americans.
- 27:17Which was not appropriate, not true, and served no purpose other than to impugn the motives
- 27:22and integrity of an opposing litigant, counsel, and witnesses on whom he relies.
- 27:26What's interesting in that case is the Court of Appeal had a discussion about how when
- 27:30they see those types of attacks on litigants and opposing counsel, they see it as a mission
- 27:37that your merits are weak.
- 27:40There was a whole discussion about that.
- 27:42Because of that, they're going to disregard your arguments because you have made an admission
- 27:45before them that you have a weak argument because you're attacking your opposing counsel
- 27:49unfairly.
- 27:50It's a great point.
- 27:53Yes, so often it's the case where a lawyer believes that by his or her behavior, by being
- 27:59rude or talking down to another attorney or a party, that they're being intimidating.
- 28:06But in fact, what these cases are telling you is it's the opposite.
- 28:09They're just being all out west effective.
- 28:13So incivility in the form of false statements to the Court and false accusations against
- 28:20opposing counsel will result in monetary sanctions, referral to a state bar, and potentially
- 28:25disregard of all your substantive arguments before a court.
- 28:32Our next category of incivility, hardball scorched earth litigation tactics.
- 28:38And the case I want to highlight here is actually a very severe example of incivility.
- 28:43It's Crawford versus JP Morgan.
- 28:45That's the case where the two attorneys were having a dispute over scheduling plaintiff's
- 28:52deposition.
- 28:54And what happened, they eventually came to an agreement for a date.
- 28:57But the plaintiff's attorney brought a pepper spray and a stun gun to the deposition.
- 29:03And the attorney pointed the pepper spray at the opposing counsel and said, I will pepper
- 29:07spray you if you get out of hand.
- 29:09And then he took the stun gun and put it close to the opposing attorney's face and then fired
- 29:14it close to his face, not at his face, but close to it.
- 29:18Just horrible, really, really severe, hardball tactic, I will say.
- 29:23And the trial court got wind of it and it posed a terminating sanction against the plaintiff's
- 29:28counsel, basically dismissed the action.
- 29:30And the Court of Appeal affirmed that.
- 29:33And the Court of Appeal stated, if ever a case required a terminating sanction, this
- 29:37is it, counsel made it impossible to continue with the litigation far from the trial court
- 29:42abusing its discretion.
- 29:44It would have been an abusive discretion not to impose a terminating sanction.
- 29:48So that's in nature a very severe type of incivility, resulting in a severe sanction.
- 29:55But you also, by terminating sanction, you also open yourself up to a lawsuit from your
- 30:00client.
- 30:01Absolutely.
- 30:02There you go.
- 30:03There's another malpractice, right?
- 30:05There's another outcome from that malpractice.
- 30:08In this case of marriage of Davenport, that's a family law case.
- 30:14There the attorney used abusive, rude, and disrespectful language in letters, but also
- 30:20scorched earth litigation tactics over many years.
- 30:23And this had come to the attention of the appellate court.
- 30:26And the appellate court highlighted one particular letter where opposing counsel said of the
- 30:32other, I'm sorry, counsel said of opposing counsel this in a letter.
- 30:37We've noticed that in the past, you have some trouble keeping things straight.
- 30:41We also noticed that you tend to stretch things somewhat too far in the name of appearances.
- 30:45It's no surprise then that your letter appears to be an attempt to create a false and misleading
- 30:49exhibit for use at a later law and motion hearing so that your client can sit in court
- 30:53with a halo over his head.
- 30:55And so you can say how many times can offer to settle.
- 30:58That wouldn't surprise us at all, giving your practice of attaching a large pile of
- 31:02exhibits to your declarations without any testimony from you concerning their truth.
- 31:06So you can see there's a lot of scorched earth litigation tactics being discussed, a lot
- 31:11of acrimony between the lawyers and absolutely no trust and no respect going on there.
- 31:19The court of appeal says there's ethical violations there, violations of duty to your
- 31:23own client and the opposing counsel.
- 31:27The court found that the counsel's demeaning comments to the opposing attorney were contrary
- 31:32to the California attorney guidelines of civility and professionalism promulgated by the state
- 31:37bar and also closing the discussion with a reminder to counsel, all counsel, regardless
- 31:43of practice, regardless of age, that zealous advocacy does not equate with attack dog or
- 31:48scorched earth, which was what we saw here, nor does it mean lack of civility.
- 31:53Zeal and vigor in the representation of clients are commendable, so are civility, courtesy
- 31:58and cooperation.
- 31:59They are not mutually exclusive.
- 32:01So the court affirmed sanctions of $100,000 and an additional attorney's fees of $307,000.
- 32:09So I think that that statement, that civility and courtesy and zealous advocacy are not
- 32:15mutually exclusive.
- 32:16They go together.
- 32:17I'm looking through some of the questions and one question strikes me, which I think
- 32:24is a great question that's worth discussion.
- 32:26The question reads, we have cases where pro-purs represent themselves and behave outrageously,
- 32:33threateningly, and the courts and family laws do little to curb them.
- 32:38Will these rules apply to pro-purs acting as their own attorney?
- 32:42I would say they don't, unfortunately, because these rules are meant for lawyers.
- 32:47Pro-purs are up to a different standard.
- 32:48I think what you're left with when you deal with a pro-purs is bringing it to the intention
- 32:53of the court and having the court deal with it.
- 32:56I think that's right.
- 32:57These rules are meant for attorneys.
- 32:58They are not meant for pro-purs, and I don't think they will be applied to pro-purs.
- 33:01But your trial judge should try some way of controlling the pro-purs.
- 33:09Sometimes with pro-purs, as we all know, it sometimes is better just to let them rage
- 33:13on for a short bit and then cut them off, but give them a little opportunity to say
- 33:18their piece.
- 33:19And once they say their piece, hopefully they'll be done.
- 33:21But yes, it is a problem, but these rules will not apply to those pro-purs.
- 33:26And just for tiny purposes, we're a little bit more than halfway through the program
- 33:30right now.
- 33:31All right.
- 33:32I'll try to go quickly.
- 33:34So incivility in the form of hardball scorched earth litigation tactics, the result will
- 33:39be terminating sanctions, dismissal if you're the plaintiff, striking the answer and entering
- 33:43of default if you're the defendant, substantial monetary sanctions, and attorney's fees award.
- 33:49The last category I want to talk about is abusive, aggressive, disrespectful language
- 33:53to the court, counsel and litigants.
- 33:57First case I want to talk about is Mahoney.
- 33:59That's a case where the Court of Appeal was impugned in the brief, an attorney filed a
- 34:03brief impugning the integrity of the Court of Appeal, basically actually stating to the
- 34:10Court of Appeal, our society has been going down the tubes a long time, but when you see
- 34:13it in black and white, as in this opinion in this case, it makes you wonder whether we
- 34:17have a fair system accusing the Court of Appeal of just judicial sleight of hand, telling
- 34:22the Court of Appeal it did not follow the law, telling the Court of Appeal you indiscriminately
- 34:27screwed my client, the petitioner.
- 34:30Well telling the Court of Appeal you screwed their client was not the way to go.
- 34:35The Court of Appeal found that attorney guilty of two counts of contempt and said, we published
- 34:40this decision as a cautionary tale.
- 34:42The timber of our time has become unfortunately aggressive and disrespectful.
- 34:46Attorney's address to opposing counsel and courts has lurched off the path of discourse
- 34:51and into the ditch of abuse.
- 34:53This isn't who we are.
- 34:55So in addition to the two counts of contempt, the attorney was reported to the state bar.
- 35:02In the case of Martin versus Valtier, this is a relatively new case.
- 35:05It's unpublished, but I highlighted it because it had a remedy that's unique.
- 35:11This is a divorce matter in which during the divorce the Court made a ruling against one
- 35:16of the parties and the attorney for that party approached the opposing attorney's spouse
- 35:23and called her a lying bitch and others in the courtroom heard it.
- 35:27And when the trial court got wind of that, it ordered the attorney disqualified from the
- 35:31case and the appellate court affirmed that, saying, you know what, you're off this case.
- 35:36That's unacceptable.
- 35:38The court said, the appellate court said, rule 4.2 is not limited to communications
- 35:42made in the absence of the party's counsel.
- 35:44Rather, it applies by its terms to all communications made without counsel's consent.
- 35:49And there is nothing in this record to show counsel consented to the attorney approaching
- 35:53the opposing party and speaking to her in vulgar and insulting terms and in an angry
- 35:57manner.
- 35:58So there you have where, again, Ellen, a potential malpractice action, right?
- 36:03Somebody began to substitute it out because of their misconduct or their insubordination.
- 36:06Absolutely.
- 36:07What's it to be with all the attorney's fees they charged up until that point?
- 36:10Is it going to be collectible?
- 36:12Is the client going to want their money back?
- 36:14Very good point.
- 36:15Next case is also a recent case, 2024 case, Massimo versus Vanderpool.
- 36:21And this is a case where emails exchanged between counsel are nasty and the court was not having
- 36:26any of it.
- 36:27This is the email.
- 36:29Counsel the email to opposing counsel.
- 36:31You are joking, right?
- 36:32In 30 years of practice, this may be the stupidest things I've ever seen.
- 36:36Robert, is this really why you went to law school?
- 36:38Quit sending us paper.
- 36:39You know we are out of the case, so just knock it off and get a life.
- 36:42Otherwise, we're going to be requesting sanctions against your firm for even bothering us with
- 36:46this nonsense.
- 36:47Well, the court of appeal felt that that was the nonsense and said, civility is not about
- 36:52etiquette.
- 36:53It's not about a matter of bad manners.
- 36:56Insubility slows things down.
- 36:57It costs people money.
- 36:58Money they were hoping their lawyers to help them save.
- 37:02Insubility is the adult equivalent of school yard bullying and we will not keep looking
- 37:07the other way when attorneys practice like this.
- 37:09They will be called out and immortalized in the California Pellet reports.
- 37:14The $10,000 sanctions was affirmed in that case.
- 37:20The case of Claypool versus County Monterey, this is a trial court case, but I wanted to
- 37:25bring it to your attention because it actually talks about the intersection between civility
- 37:30and bias.
- 37:32In that case, there was a deposition going on with a male attorney and a female attorney
- 37:36and during the deposition, the male attorney said to the female attorney, move on with
- 37:40your next question and don't raise your voice at me.
- 37:43It's not becoming of a woman or an attorney who is acting professionally under the rules
- 37:46of professional responsibility.
- 37:48Oh boy, when the trial court got a hold of that, was not happy.
- 37:53Lawyers all due to professionalism to their clients opposing parties in their counsel,
- 37:57the courts and the public as a whole, those duties include among others civility, professional
- 38:02integrity, personal dignity, candor, diligence, respect, courtesy, cooperation and competence.
- 38:08The practice of law before this court must be free from prejudice and bias.
- 38:13Counsel has stooped to an indefensible attack on opposing counsel.
- 38:17In that case, attorneys fees were awarded for the motion and the deposition and interestingly,
- 38:22$250 to the Women Lawyers Association of Los Angeles.
- 38:26Yeah, let me jump in on that one because I think that surprises me a bit because it's
- 38:32one thing to award sanctions and have those sanctions paid to the other attorney.
- 38:38It's another thing to order money to be paid to an organization as a sanction.
- 38:44What's your thought about that?
- 38:47I wonder what would happen on appeal if that had been appealed.
- 38:50We don't know if that's the case because this is a trial court case.
- 38:52It doesn't appear to have been appealed as far as I can tell.
- 38:55I'm not sure that would be appealed.
- 38:57I'm not sure there's any authority to do that, but this is what trial courts have done.
- 39:01If that's ever done, we'll see there may be a challenge to it.
- 39:08Let me do this.
- 39:09I'm going to switch focus a little bit since we are getting close to running out of time
- 39:14a bit and talk about the snow case.
- 39:16You've spoke about sanctions, contempt, even a trial court being as bold as to order money
- 39:23is being paid to the Women's Lawyers Association as a sanction.
- 39:28Another reason why that bothers me is that's not a sanction.
- 39:30That's something you should do voluntarily.
- 39:33The snow case is a new paradigm.
- 39:34Actually someone on the civility committee actually emailed me about this case when it
- 39:40came out.
- 39:41It was originally an unpublished decision and there was a big movement to get it published
- 39:47because it was so good in addressing what it means not to behave properly and how that
- 39:52should impact the lawyer's pocketbook.
- 39:56In snow, plaintiff, it was a FIHA case, it was an employment case.
- 40:01Plaintiff was successful through trial and one cause of action, entitling the lawyer
- 40:05to attorney's fees.
- 40:07The attorney's fees in that case was over $1.1 million, which the court found was reasonable
- 40:13given all the work that was done through these years of litigation.
- 40:18The court exercised its discretion and reduced the amount by over $400,000 to $686,795.
- 40:29What the trial court did is it applied a negative 0.4 multiplier.
- 40:33It basically reduced the fees by 40% based upon the lawyer's conduct throughout the litigation.
- 40:42What the appellate court said is it agreed with the trial court and said a court may
- 40:49apply in its discretion a positive or negative multiplier to adjust the load star calculation,
- 40:57a reasonable rate times a reasonable number of hours to account for various factors, including
- 41:03attorney skills.
- 41:04It's equating civility to whether the lawyer is acting with the skill required to gain
- 41:11the result.
- 41:13The court went on.
- 41:14The record before us amply supports the trial court's finding that Plaintiff's counsel
- 41:18was repeatedly and apparently intentionally when civil to defense counsel and to the court
- 41:25throughout the litigation.
- 41:27The facts of this case are great.
- 41:30The court examines 12 emails that counsel sent to defense counsel, talks at length,
- 41:38two and a half pages work of the opinion, talking about 13 statements made that were
- 41:45bullion.
- 41:46What the court said is that the trial court, they agreed with it, noted that Plaintiff's
- 41:53counsel, in civility with not only directed to opposing counsel, it was also directed
- 41:58to the court.
- 41:59The court remarked that in a previous minute order that Plaintiff counsel's tone of voice.
- 42:08It wasn't what the counsel said, it was the tone in which it was being said, which was
- 42:12not reflected in the court reporter's record was both belittling and antagonistic.
- 42:19At times it verged on the contentious.
- 42:22The court continued, Plaintiff's counsel's ad hominem attacks were unnecessary for the
- 42:27zealous representation of his client.
- 42:30Citing case law, the court noted the absence of civility, heightened stress and debased
- 42:37the legal profession.
- 42:39That's a big point.
- 42:40It's not only the fact that if you're going to act that way, you're not acting with the
- 42:44requisite skill level of someone with your experience, but it also makes the practice
- 42:49a lot so much more difficult, which is really what these rules are trying to get at.
- 42:54We want lawyers to zealously advocate for their clients, but that you want to do it
- 43:00in such a way where you're fighting over the facts, not over each other.
- 43:06Going through the case, the court talks about how it lowered the load star.
- 43:12It says a downward departure from the load star figure is justified where the attorney
- 43:17demonstrates that he is less skilled than would be expected of an attorney with comparable
- 43:25expertise or experience billing at the same rate.
- 43:28The evidence supports the trial court's implied finding that Plaintiff's counsel presented
- 43:32issues with less skill because of the way that he behaved through his instability than
- 43:37would be expected of comparably experienced attorneys charging $750 per hour who conducted
- 43:44themselves with civility.
- 43:47The trial court thus had discretion to reduce the load star figure based on counsel's skill
- 43:52reflected by his disability.
- 43:54It's a watershed moment in this regard.
- 43:57Even in arbitration, when you're looking at attorney's fees award, you're giving the
- 44:01trier fact another tool to make sure everyone behaves the way they should.
- 44:07Because if you don't behave the way you should, not only is it looked upon badly, it can also
- 44:14impact the ultimate attorney's fee award if you are a prevailing party and are entitled
- 44:20to such award.
- 44:21I'm going to switch to, we have about 15 minutes left.
- 44:26And I'm going to make a suggestion.
- 44:29Let's go to our last part of our program.
- 44:32Because we already handed out these guidelines.
- 44:35Let's go to that last part.
- 44:36I think that's a great idea.
- 44:39So what's in the material is an example of various superior courts have local rules which
- 44:46talk about civility.
- 44:48And it's talked about in terms of how you conduct depositions, how you assert your objections,
- 44:54how you give extensions of time.
- 44:56I was always such a stressful part of litigation when I was a litigator asking for an extension
- 45:05and not knowing how that counsel would respond and whether they would try to gain a tactical
- 45:10advantage.
- 45:11So the LA Superior Court is a good example.
- 45:13I think if you look through the district court rules, you will find similar examples.
- 45:17And you look at other jurisdictions.
- 45:20It's the understanding that being an attorney does not mean game and shit.
- 45:26Being a successful advocate also requires that you act professionally.
- 45:30We're going to switch a bit and just talk about some examples of instability that we've
- 45:36experienced in practice.
- 45:38My best story, and I'll turn it over to you, that was when I was a young lawyer defending
- 45:43a deposition.
- 45:45And I was very lucky.
- 45:46In that case, I had a discovery referee.
- 45:48And as I was asserting my objections, the much more senior lawyer was belittling me,
- 45:53telling me my objections were inappropriate, calling me names.
- 45:56And I followed a motion with the arbitrator that we had looking at discovery motions for
- 46:04us.
- 46:05And not only did he look at what I submitted to the arbitrator, he also looked at the entire
- 46:11record and the discovery referee.
- 46:14Not only sanctioned plaintiffs counsel but notified our trial judge.
- 46:19And I still remember the next time I was before another motion before that discovery referee,
- 46:26he mentioned the trial judge called him to think of.
- 46:30Because even then, we're going back 15, 20 years, it was an issue that judges and many
- 46:37lawyers were cognizant of trying to bully someone because they're younger, they don't
- 46:44have your experience, or because of their gender, which we'll talk about.
- 46:49That's something that's not conducive to the practice of law.
- 46:52Yvette, do you have any war stories that you'd like to share?
- 46:56I have one in connection with being on the bench.
- 46:59It really was an instability toward me.
- 47:01I guess it was dealing with instability.
- 47:04I had a case when I was in the IC court where I think it was an employment case where one
- 47:09of the parties was having trouble in the deposition because the other party's lawyer kept objecting
- 47:14repeatedly with the same objections over and over and just could not get through a decent
- 47:19day of deposition.
- 47:20And they were showing me transcripts saying, look, judge, I just can't get through this
- 47:24deposition because of these objections.
- 47:25They keep coming in.
- 47:26They're unmeritorious.
- 47:27I just can't get through it.
- 47:29And so I said, OK, fine, they asked me if I would do the deposition in my chambers, not
- 47:36in my chambers, in the jury room.
- 47:38And I said, well, I really don't like doing that.
- 47:40But I said, this is pretty severe.
- 47:42They can't seem to get through it.
- 47:44I'll be available if you need me.
- 47:47So they came in.
- 47:48They had a court reporter.
- 47:49They're in my jury room.
- 47:51And sure enough, they called me and went in.
- 47:54OK, I have to make rulings on these deposition objections.
- 47:57And sure enough, the lawyer was objecting, objecting, harassing type of objections over
- 48:01and over.
- 48:02Finally, I got to the point where I was overruling the objections, but they didn't seem to stop
- 48:06the lawyer until I did this.
- 48:08I said, you know what, counsel, I'll make a deal with you.
- 48:11You can have a standing objection as to whatever it was, relevance or whatever his, you have
- 48:15a standing objection.
- 48:16And I might rule, ruling overruling you is standing as well.
- 48:20So let's move forward.
- 48:21For some reason, that worked.
- 48:22So we kind of made this deal.
- 48:24You have your standing objection.
- 48:25No problem.
- 48:26Let's just move forward.
- 48:28And that somehow worked.
- 48:29So we didn't have to keep coming back and forth.
- 48:31So that was one way of dealing with it.
- 48:33But I have to tell you, I don't recommend doing that because judges don't like taking
- 48:38up their jury rooms and being in the middle of depositions when they're on the bench.
- 48:41So.
- 48:42And you also don't have the resources to deal with it.
- 48:44I mean, that's an incredible example that you as a sitting judge went in and actually
- 48:51took part in their deposition to make sure that they were acting properly.
- 48:54Because even if a judge wants to do that, most of the time they don't have the time
- 48:59to allow them to do that.
- 49:00Yeah, that's true.
- 49:02Let me switch topics a little bit and talk about our current practice.
- 49:06So I do mediation arbitration, so there's your bet.
- 49:09And we think about how instability impacts our practice.
- 49:13You know, on the mediation side, and I wrote an article about it, what strikes me is when
- 49:17I first started practicing law, when I went to a mediation, there was always, we'd always
- 49:22start with a joint session, I would give my opening statement making sure that I would
- 49:27make my client's point, but not upset the other side to the extent to make settlement
- 49:33impossible.
- 49:34And now most of the time, me included and my colleagues, I think share this, we rarely
- 49:39start with the joint session.
- 49:41And when we do bring counsel, the parties together, we oftentimes, unless it's very
- 49:46clear counsel is just getting along, we have rules.
- 49:49You know, you'd have to listen to the other side, you can't talk over them, you have to
- 49:53behave professionally.
- 49:55And I always thought that, you know, I started my mediation, and it's still true because
- 50:00I want to build individual connections, so I separate the parties.
- 50:04But what I've discovered is part of the reason why I don't bring them together from the beginning
- 50:10is because of the fear that someone may say something to upset the other side, which wouldn't
- 50:16be conducive to settlement.
- 50:18And it's another avenue where we don't even think about it, but civility plays a role.
- 50:23You bet you, do you have anything to say with respect to mediation?
- 50:26I do, and not with arbitration, but I do with mediation.
- 50:30And it's kind of a quandary really for lawyers, I think, but this is a true story.
- 50:37The names have been changed to protect the innocent, right?
- 50:39Because it's mediation, so I can't really get into a lot of detail.
- 50:41I'll just give a short little synopsis of what happened.
- 50:45It's very quick, but it's a true story.
- 50:51I was in mediation and some bad news have been delivered to one side, okay?
- 50:56Because, you know, they're communicating with each other, and one side was willing to disclose
- 51:00some evidence that they had, so it's bad news for one side.
- 51:03So I was there delivering the bad news, right, for one side to the other side, and we're
- 51:09all talking about it.
- 51:10All of us, the lawyers, me, the clients were there on that side.
- 51:15And I was about to move into, and it was got a little bit heated, I mean, the discussion
- 51:20about the evidence was a little bit heated, but I was about to move into the other room.
- 51:26It was on Zoom, I was about to move to the other room, and I heard the clients say, there
- 51:32were two people, two clients in the room, I heard the clients say, who side are you on?
- 51:39So I stopped moving to the other room, and I said, excuse me?
- 51:45I said, did I miss something?
- 51:48I didn't know whether he was referring to me or his attorney.
- 51:52Either way, that was not civil, right?
- 51:53That was clearly a bad, uncivil way to deal with the bad situation.
- 52:00Now interestingly enough, that didn't come from the attorney, that came from the client.
- 52:04So if the client was addressing me, that's horrible, but I could deal with that, but
- 52:08the problem was, what if he was dealing with his lawyer?
- 52:11I thought, no one of these poor lawyers, they react because they get these horrible statements
- 52:16from their clients, the horrible pressures from their clients.
- 52:19So I guess what I'm trying to say, it's not an excuse for being uncivil, but it is an
- 52:27explanation for why it happens, that clients put horrible pressures on their attorneys.
- 52:31I'm sure many of you out there have experienced that, and that I think could be the basis
- 52:35of a lot of reason, a lot of the basis for why attorneys act the way they do.
- 52:41Sometimes their own clients do that to them.
- 52:44True story.
- 52:45Let me touch arbitration just for a second so we can move on and get through.
- 52:51In arbitration, my view is, I think lawyers tend to act a lot more civil than they may
- 52:58act in trial court because number one, it's a lot more expensive, but you're paying for
- 53:03the arbitrator's time, you're focusing in on the issues.
- 53:07And in the arbitrations I've done, personally, I'm sure arbitrators will have different stories
- 53:13to tell.
- 53:14I personally have not seen lawyers acting improperly.
- 53:18I have seen parties acting improperly.
- 53:20And the biggest issue is making faces during a witness testimony and what I always do is
- 53:25I always stop the proceeding right there to make clear what we're there for, and that
- 53:29is to present our cases and to be professional and to act with a proper level of respect
- 53:37towards the other side, even though you disagree with them.
- 53:41Let's move on to our next topic, which is we talked about it a little bit about younger
- 53:46attorneys.
- 53:47Definitely true.
- 53:48Younger attorneys tend to get ramshotted, and they're the ones who experience instability
- 53:56the most.
- 53:57It's also true, unfortunately, about certain female attorneys.
- 54:01I personally, I sacked the real disability presentation.
- 54:05I wasn't on the panel for this one, where one of the lawyers said in response to a senior
- 54:12partner at a big law firm said, when one of my female lawyers gets bullied or when there's
- 54:18conduct inappropriate, I stick a male attorney in the room with her.
- 54:24And the reaction to that, me and other people there, was really like, a female lawyer doesn't
- 54:31need the male lawyer's help in order to combat instability.
- 54:35I had dinner that night with a group of very senior experienced female trial lawyers, and
- 54:40they were all outraged by that comment.
- 54:43And it shows that part of the reason why these things happen to younger attorneys, female
- 54:50attorneys, is the fact that there is, unfortunately, still today, an idea that they don't know
- 54:56how to react, and maybe an unfair advantage can be gained.
- 55:03When you were on the bench, do you feel that lawyers treated you differently because you're
- 55:08a female instead of a male judge?
- 55:11I think that happened more when I was a junior judge.
- 55:13When I first got on the bench, I think I saw a lot more kind of disrespectful type behavior
- 55:19as I got older, more seasoned, so to speak, on the bench.
- 55:23I didn't see it as much.
- 55:25But as a young woman judge, yes, I definitely saw it, definitely.
- 55:29It's so unfortunate.
- 55:30And with our limited time, we have five minutes left.
- 55:33Let's talk about whether instability has gotten worse through COVID and Zoom.
- 55:38And I guess on the one side is that through Zoom, and you're at home, people are all responded
- 55:47are a lot more easier to misbehave.
- 55:50I will say on the mediation front, I don't know if that's true or not because we don't
- 55:55do joint sessions as often.
- 55:57If someone misbehaves, I look at it as part of the process and helpful to get the emotions
- 56:03out.
- 56:05Arbitrations what I see, and I'm going to ask you about court trials, the problem I see
- 56:10with arbitrations is lawyers trying to speak over other lawyers because they're not together
- 56:15in the same room.
- 56:17And even that, I find to be with a lack of respect and is somewhat unsymbolic.
- 56:24You bet.
- 56:25What are your thoughts?
- 56:27I think, well, with the court uses Zoom or Zoom type technology in the courtroom.
- 56:34And so when I was on the bench, I would see, I didn't really like Zoom that much, to be
- 56:38honest.
- 56:39I really don't like it.
- 56:40I prefer in-person hearings and in-person trials and all of that.
- 56:43I don't like remote.
- 56:45I understand it's the savings for attorneys.
- 56:48But I do think that attorneys tend to act worse.
- 56:52I think there's worse conduct because of Zoom.
- 56:56I tend to see they're not with each other or they're not in the courtroom, so they feel
- 57:00comfortable throwing little zingers at each other over the internet.
- 57:03I mean, that's how I view them.
- 57:05A lot of zingers, but they're not accountable.
- 57:08They're not in the courtroom.
- 57:09So they don't see the other side necessarily the same way.
- 57:12And they don't see the court the same way.
- 57:14They're just a little box on the screen.
- 57:16So I think it makes it worse, actually.
- 57:18I don't think Zoom has helped at all.
- 57:21I'm not sure COVID did anything, but Zoom doesn't help.
- 57:25That's my view.
- 57:26I think that's right.
- 57:27I'm going to read one of the questions that we've gotten into.
- 57:30To the extent we don't get to your questions, which we probably want since we're almost
- 57:34out of time, we will try to respond to you in writing at a later date.
- 57:40But one question, and it said ways nicely to our next topic, is how do you recommend
- 57:47dealing with instability from the bench to counsel during ongoing litigation, including
- 57:53while on appeal?
- 57:55You bet.
- 57:56Where are your thoughts?
- 57:59General instability.
- 58:00I mean, I'm not sure exactly what you're saying, but in general, I think the best thing to do,
- 58:05the best way to combat instability is with civility.
- 58:08In other words, don't take the bait, basically.
- 58:11I mean, somebody who's acting that way with you is trying to get you to make a mistake
- 58:15in some way, whether it's in your papers or what you say or what you do.
- 58:19So the best way to combat instability is to be civil yourself.
- 58:22I mean, I know that probably sounds easy to say and hard to do, but I think that's the
- 58:28best way to do.
- 58:29If it becomes a repeated problem or severe, then I think you should bring it to the attention
- 58:34of your trial judge in some way.
- 58:36And earlier rather than later, and make sure that when you do do that, you're calm and
- 58:41collected.
- 58:42You have your ducks all in a row with exhibits or letters or emails or whatever.
- 58:46Make sure that you're calm when you present it to the judge, too, because the judge, if
- 58:49you're very upset about it and very emotional in your presentation, the judge may think
- 58:55you're the problem.
- 58:56So make sure that you're nice and calm when you present your sanctions motion or whatever.
- 59:01Present the civility issues to your judge.
- 59:04I think that's 100% correct.
- 59:06That's funny.
- 59:07When you said don't take the bait, I had written down my own personal notes.
- 59:11Don't fall for it.
- 59:12The worst thing you can do in the face of someone misbehaving, calling your names, yelling
- 59:17at you is doing the same to them because that's what they want you to do.
- 59:21They want you to lose focus and your focus should always be on representing your client
- 59:26to the greatest extent possible.
- 59:27And when you're angry, when you feel slighted, when you feel like you have to get back on
- 59:33the opposing counsel, it also impacts your ability to represent your client.
- 59:37What I used to do when I was a trial lawyer, when someone yelling at me, which happened
- 59:41a lot, I would use silence.
- 59:45I would just stop talking.
- 59:47Eventually, the other lawyer would see I wasn't saying anything and I would say, I'm only
- 59:51going to speak when you give me the opportunity to do so.
- 59:55That sort of would lower the temperature and bring us back to the ultimate subject we were
- 1:00:02dealing with.
- 1:00:03I see we have one minute left, which is perfect because we're down to the final word and I'll
- 1:00:10send it over to you back to Sarah Gauver, what we've learned today.
- 1:00:14I think this really sums up our civility obligations and I'll read it.
- 1:00:19Thank you, Alan.
- 1:00:20There is no better guide to professional courtesy than the golden rule.
- 1:00:23You should treat opposing counsel the way you yourself would like to be treated and that's
- 1:00:27directly from the Ninth Circuit.
- 1:00:30That's really what should be your guiding light.
- 1:00:34Thank you, everyone, for spending time with us today.
- 1:00:36I hope that you took away something from it.
- 1:00:39As I mentioned with the questions, we will try to respond to them at a later date.
- 1:00:46Thank you.
- 1:00:47You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:00:50Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.