Latest / Politics with Paul / "Voter Dollars": the Solution to Our Campaign Finance Woes? w/ Dan McMillan | Politics with Paul #71
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08As you can see, we got another guest.
- 0:10And for those, I always start off with a disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or
- 0:15against a guest's political views or groups they support.
- 0:19But campaign finance is one of the chief sources of consternation in politics across
- 0:24political parties and ideologies.
- 0:26One of the most common complaints about elected officials and candidates is that they are
- 0:30bought by the most well resourced special interests.
- 0:34And each successive election cycle finds some way to break records for most expensive races,
- 0:40and running for the highest offices is only getting pricier.
- 0:44The issues with campaign finance are entrenched and hard to fix.
- 0:48But is the idea called voter dollars the answer to these woes?
- 0:53What is this voter dollars concept, and how could it potentially be the solution?
- 0:57Well, here to talk about that and this voter dollars idea and campaign finance reform in
- 1:02general is my guest today, Dan McMillan.
- 1:05Dan founded and leads Make Voters the Donors.
- 1:08Their aim, as they put it, is to, quote, put the American people in charge of our government
- 1:13by making us the donors who fund candidates' election campaigns, end quote.
- 1:19Dan also taught German history at Eastern Illinois University and prosecuted criminal
- 1:23cases for the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office.
- 1:26And in 2014, he published the book How Could This Happen?
- 1:29Explaining the Holocaust, diving into the causes of the Holocaust.
- 1:34So let's talk about campaign finance reform and Dan's idea of voter dollars.
- 1:39Please welcome Dan McMillan to the show.
- 1:41Dan, thanks for coming on.
- 1:43How are you?
- 1:44I'm doing as well, Paul, and it's good to be with you.
- 1:47Thank you for having me.
- 1:48Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:49So normally I like to start with how people got into what they're doing and then we will, but
- 1:54this voter dollars concept is very intriguing.
- 1:57It's one that I've never really heard before.
- 1:59So it's a pretty unique one.
- 2:00Let's just get right into it first.
- 2:02What exactly is this concept of voter dollars and how'd you come up with this idea and how
- 2:07long has this campaign been going on?
- 2:09Right.
- 2:11So the concept is simply that, you know, that pretty much at this point, because election
- 2:17campaigns are so expensive, Politicians and candidates really listen only or primarily to
- 2:24the big, you know, the big, deep pocketed donors who can pay for these incredibly
- 2:29expensive campaigns.
- 2:30I mean, for the price for the White House is a cool billion or more.
- 2:34And they don't get that money from me.
- 2:35Maybe not from you either, Paul.
- 2:37They get it from people who can give the money in bulk, you know, checks of 50,000, half
- 2:411,000,000, 5,000,000, in some cases, even 50, as we know.
- 2:46And then consequently, we, the people, are no longer the constituents of these elected
- 2:51officials.
- 2:52They're donors of the constituents, and the voters have become a nuisance, you know, a
- 2:58necessary evil.
- 2:59We're necessary because they still need our votes to get into office.
- 3:02But we're an evil because we take away from time that they want to spend with their donors.
- 3:07And also, as Hillary Clinton notoriously said in 2016, they have to have two positions on
- 3:15every important issue, one for the donors, which is what they're really going to do, and
- 3:18whatever they say to us to buy us off and get our votes.
- 3:21Anyway, if only donors have power in our political system, well, then let's make
- 3:26ourselves the donors.
- 3:28And this this concept was invented more than twenty years ago in a book by a couple of very
- 3:34law professors, Bruce Ackerman and Ian Ayers.
- 3:38It actually it's been referred to also as democracy vouchers or democracy dollars.
- 3:43They have a system somewhat like this in Seattle for city elections since 2017.
- 3:49But the way this would work at the federal level is that when you get when you register to
- 3:54vote, you would get an online account of campaign cash with an allotment of campaign
- 3:59cash for each federal cycle.
- 4:01And you can't take the money out and spend it, but you log on and you direct your voter
- 4:05dollars to those candidates you wanna support.
- 4:08And we're talking about putting a lot of money in the system, a $100 per voter in a
- 4:12presidential year, $50 for the midterm years, which are cheaper.
- 4:16And if we funded at that level, candidates who wanna serve us can raise enough money from
- 4:21voters in conversations with voters, to run a strong campaign.
- 4:26And on the other hand, no one's gonna have much excuse for taking money from George Soros,
- 4:31Charles Cook, Elon Musk, big oil, big pharma, labor unions, you name your favorite villain.
- 4:37You know?
- 4:37And then suddenly, you know, right now, I mean, what do politicians do when they get to DC?
- 4:43They take care of their donors.
- 4:45Going forward, they'll keep doing that.
- 4:46But if we're the donors, then they take care of us.
- 4:49They listen to us.
- 4:50And suddenly, we are getting our on our way back to government by the people here in the
- 4:56land of its birth, which right now we don't completely have.
- 4:59So that's the concept.
- 5:03Interesting.
- 5:03So the basic idea is, is it just coming directly from people's pockets or is it just
- 5:10like, is it a, they get something directly from the government and says, Hey, you're going to
- 5:15give this money to whichever candidates you want.
- 5:17How exactly does that part work?
- 5:20Oh, yes.
- 5:20No, it's not What it is, the money is public money.
- 5:24It's from the federal treasury.
- 5:25So if you pay federal income tax, then you're contributing to this.
- 5:30And that which which raises kind of brings up the most common objection that we get.
- 5:36The first time that that we try to present this to people is, wait a minute, you know, my tax
- 5:42dollars funding food stamps for politicians.
- 5:45You know, it's understandable that people would cut a bristle at that idea.
- 5:49Just briefly, the, you know, probably one response that we have and there are other
- 5:54responses.
- 5:54But I would just point out that this reform would pay for itself dozens of times over
- 5:59because there's so much wasteful spending, government contracts of every kind, and also
- 6:04tax breaks for corporations that really don't serve any economic purpose or not good for the
- 6:11country, but which lobbyists can extract from Congress because the lobbyists and their
- 6:16clients are paying for for, you know, for candidates campaigns, which gives has given
- 6:22lobbyists the political muscle to effectively dictate to politicians.
- 6:26I mean, literally, laws and regulations all too often are not actually written by legislative
- 6:31staff.
- 6:32They're written by lobbyists, and then members of congress put them into laws or likewise
- 6:36regulatory agencies.
- 6:38The lobbyists just write the regulations, which, of course, I guess, makes everyone's job
- 6:42easier, but it's not necessarily good for
- 6:44us.
- 6:44So Gotcha.
- 6:46I do wanna get more into those objections later on, but I thought that was really interesting
- 6:50that you had said that this has actually been something that's been around for about twenty
- 6:56years.
- 6:56This is not something that I have, I don't think I've heard this specific kind of idea
- 7:02before.
- 7:02Now you see like, do you wanna donate to the presidential election fund or you have like the
- 7:08the Maine has like those matching funds kind of deal.
- 7:12So you hear about those kinds of ideas where it's it's public money for campaigns.
- 7:19And Florida actually has a similar thing down here too where they have some public money for
- 7:25certain campaigns depending on if they reach certain criteria.
- 7:28But this is a pretty unique way to do it that I haven't really heard before.
- 7:32But I wanna go back to Yes.
- 7:34Ultimate because I always like to go back to what ultimately spurred my guests to do the
- 7:39work that is the center of these podcast episodes and the work they do in general.
- 7:43So what got you interested in campaign finance reform and ultimately to work in making such
- 7:49reforms happen?
- 7:51Well, you know, I think in some ways it goes back to my junior year in college, which I
- 7:56spent at the German university in what was then West Berlin when the city was so divided during
- 8:02the Cold War.
- 8:02And being there on the front lines of the Cold War and also just being in this other country
- 8:08was kind of the beginning of my appreciation that of of the uniqueness of this country,
- 8:14namely that this is the only country where membership in the nation doesn't depend on
- 8:19race, religion, language, culture, which it does everywhere else.
- 8:23It depends on ideals, you know, about, you know, liberty, quality of opportunity.
- 8:27And I think for me, most important government by the people, which I think is most important
- 8:32because without it, the other two freedoms are never never safe, you know, the other two
- 8:36ideals.
- 8:37And that was kind of something that intensified my patriotism and gave it kind of a clearer
- 8:42definition.
- 8:43And as I came back, you know, I graduated college in 1982, began to follow politics a bit
- 8:50more.
- 8:51And as the decade wore especially the election in 1988, you know, I think before your time
- 8:57between Bush senior and Dukakis, it was clear to me and all my friends and also was in the
- 9:03air.
- 9:04People were talking about it.
- 9:05You know, pundits were talking about it that something had gone wrong with our politics.
- 9:09No one could really figure out exactly why.
- 9:11But the thing what was so apparent was just that the that the conversation had just become
- 9:17so trivialized that more and more, instead of talking about substance, about practical ideas
- 9:23to solve problems that we have in this country, to make the country stronger, politicians were
- 9:29relying more on kind of just cheap emotional appeals keyed to hot button social issues and
- 9:36ugly personal attacks.
- 9:37And more and more, you had this focus on the personal lives of politicians, which most
- 9:42Americans, frankly, could care less about.
- 9:45I certainly don't care.
- 9:47And, you know, and and I hear that today, especially when I talk to Americans left,
- 9:51right, you know, all across the spectrum.
- 9:54The thing that I'm often most often hear, I turn on the TV and I see these ads and all they
- 10:00do is tear down the other guy.
- 10:01They never tell me what they're gonna do for me.
- 10:04But how did this happen?
- 10:05How did our whole political conversation become empty?
- 10:09Why did they almost not talk about things anymore that matter to us?
- 10:14I mean, already in the nineteen nineties, you're seeing the hollowing out of the American
- 10:17middle class, You know, the loss of jobs and, you know, wages not keeping pace with inflation
- 10:23and so on.
- 10:24And and yet no one in Washington squarely addressing it, talking about it.
- 10:29And people for several years blamed the media because that's where you could see it.
- 10:34But the media ultimately, they're a trailing indicator.
- 10:37The media reflect what the political conversation is.
- 10:41And I really none I really had no idea, and frankly, no one else did.
- 10:45And I guess sometime around after the turn of the century, I began to become more and more
- 10:51aware of how much election campaigns cost and how much time candidates spend raising money.
- 11:00In fact, actually, kind of think about it, I think it was in 1996 or '7, Bill Clinton had a
- 11:05birthday party, maybe his fiftieth.
- 11:08And I think it was at, like, Madison Square Garden.
- 11:10It was also a massive fundraiser.
- 11:13And there was a there was was the cover of the New York Post, which is a Murdoch paper and has
- 11:17great headlines.
- 11:19And it showed Bill Clinton, President Clinton with a birthday cake, you know, a lot of a lot
- 11:23of candles.
- 11:24And and there was a subtitle saying, you know, Clinton raises $4,000,000 or $8,000,000, you
- 11:31know, and that the headline was dollar bill.
- 11:35Of course, but of course, it's not just unique to him.
- 11:37It's both parties equally anyway.
- 11:40And I started studying that issue more and more.
- 11:43And then already, you know, the 2010 Citizens United decision was a wake up call.
- 11:51It people spend too much time talking about it because so much of the damage was already done
- 11:55before Citizens United, but it kind of highlighted the problem for me.
- 11:59And already before I finished writing the Holocaust book, which I completed really at the
- 12:042013, I started researching and writing a book about how big money in politics disenfranchises
- 12:12the American people and makes the system dysfunctional and also started looking around
- 12:17for all the ideas that had been suggested for addressing it.
- 12:22And by the 2020, I had written a few 100 pages in unpublished pockets.
- 12:27I'd read a lot, read kind of all the books out there, and there's some good ones about
- 12:31different aspects of the problem.
- 12:34And in the spring and also by that time, I'd I had come across this voter dollars concept and
- 12:40realized that for all kinds of reasons, this just seems hands down the best.
- 12:45And we can talk about its political strengths and also the fact that the Supreme Court has
- 12:50basically gutted other campaign finance, you know, gutted limitations on donating and
- 12:56spending.
- 12:57And so the only path to game changing reform that can get past the court short of amending
- 13:03the constitution is a public financing mechanism.
- 13:05And you mentioned a couple of others like the matching funds for small dollars contributions.
- 13:10But by the 2020, I kind of had a couple of realizations.
- 13:15One was, you know, another book's not going to move the needle.
- 13:20Lots of people smarter than I am have written great books.
- 13:23And what has changed?
- 13:25And the other was that even candidates who were willing to make noise about money in politics,
- 13:30and I'm thinking Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren in the Democratic Party primary weren't
- 13:37willing to talk about a solution.
- 13:40They'd say sort of, we need a constitutional amendment to overturn Citizens United.
- 13:45And with the politics so polarized right now, I don't know that you could I don't know that you
- 13:51could get the two thirds super majority in house and senate for a constitutional amendment
- 13:56in favor of motherhood.
- 13:57Okay?
- 13:58Much less something like that.
- 14:00So, I mean, there are good people working on an amendment, but we need something faster.
- 14:05And and this I just saw the strengths of this, and I realized sand even Sanders and Warren, I
- 14:12don't question anyone's motives.
- 14:13I'd never met these people personally, but it was so strange to me that they didn't talk
- 14:19about voter dollars, which was out there.
- 14:21Everyone knew about it.
- 14:22It was discussed in the sort of reform world.
- 14:26And I realized that even they they have their big donors too in addition to their many small
- 14:30donors.
- 14:31And the rest of the Democratic and Republican conferences in Congress are also hopelessly
- 14:38dependent on their donors.
- 14:39I realize that everyone in Washington, no matter how well intentioned, is trapped in
- 14:44their dependence on donors, they can't lead in this issue.
- 14:48And this has to come from the ground up.
- 14:51And so then I had to say, gosh, I guess I've got to bite the bullet and figure out how to be
- 14:55a politician, you know, which is outside my comfort zone.
- 14:59And I that's I found in my outfit in 2020.
- 15:03And then it's been a long period, you know, process of trial and error.
- 15:07But I've learned a lot since then.
- 15:09And then at the end of the summer, really kind of took the whole campaign to an entirely new
- 15:14level in a much more concrete way that, you know, I think we'll get to.
- 15:18You highlighted one of the many reasons why I would never wanna run for office, and it is
- 15:23just the sheer amount of hours that you need to spend raising money.
- 15:29Even if somebody ostensibly doesn't like it, no matter how
- 15:31much
- 15:31they decry big donors, you have to go to them to some extent, even if you have a lot of small
- 15:40donors as well.
- 15:41And it is unfortunate that you have such a entrenched it's very hard to get around that
- 15:50whole having to deal with really big donors no matter how much you wanna get away it.
- 15:55Now, of course, if you're doing, like, a local level office, it's not gonna be such a big deal
- 15:59as long as it's like a a relatively small area.
- 16:02But if you're going to, like, New York City or Chicago, then you probably are gonna have to
- 16:05have some bigger donors.
- 16:07But it it is pretty amazing just how entrenched it is in American politics.
- 16:16And and something you kind of got on about is these various things that people have said of,
- 16:23we need to fix campaign finance laws with X.
- 16:25And I think some people just say campaign finance laws need fixing without clearly
- 16:31demonstrating why.
- 16:33I think some people assume that it's very self evident, but maybe some people don't realize
- 16:40why it's a big deal and thus why it needs to be fixed.
- 16:44So what do you think are two to three of the biggest problems brought about by current
- 16:51finance laws?
- 16:54Well, I think that in some sense, they all boil down to one above all that then has further
- 16:59consequences.
- 17:00And I want to highlight it, and that is that the bulk of the damage comes from the fact that
- 17:06candidates need to self censor to avoid alienating potential donors.
- 17:11I mean, if you have to raise tens of millions or even hundreds to run for a contested senate
- 17:17seat, and that is the reality now, you know, or even in the house, if you wanna challenge an
- 17:22incumbent, you know, it's not enough to to get money from the top industries in your district.
- 17:30You basically gotta take money from everyone that you who's willing to give it.
- 17:34And because you need money from everywhere, you can't afford to offend anyone.
- 17:39And I think that this leads to kind of the most that is when I talked earlier about how more
- 17:45and more the conversation was drained of substance, of real policy proposals that, you
- 17:50know, could be implemented is because for every good idea out there to, you know, seize our
- 17:56country's opportunities and to fix our problems, there's gonna be a group of donors
- 18:01who will be offended.
- 18:02And now the donor doesn't even have to get on the phone to their lobbyist and have their
- 18:06lobbyist give instructions to the congressperson.
- 18:10The candidates already know what's expected, and they know not to go there.
- 18:13And now which then leads to a second problem that has escalated, especially in the last ten
- 18:19years, that deprived of a positive way forward out of a need to self censor, increasingly
- 18:26parties hit the parties had defaulted to negative messaging because anger is all they've
- 18:30got left.
- 18:31And when you think about it in the last two presidential cycles, '24 and '20, the top line
- 18:37message of both major parties was identical.
- 18:40If the other side wins, the world's gonna come to an end.
- 18:44You know?
- 18:44And this is not a message of this is not leadership.
- 18:47This is not a message of hope for the American people.
- 18:50It's a it's it's a collective declaration of bankruptcy.
- 18:54And, you know, what's so weird is that we Americans who historically had been famous for
- 18:59our optimism and justly so, and our optimism has been rewarded again and again by successes
- 19:05and triumphs that other peoples could only dream of, we have become a nation of
- 19:10pessimists.
- 19:12I don't think that's permanent, but as long as our political system is a mess, we're probably
- 19:17not gonna feel too optimistic about our future.
- 19:19And I do think it's interesting, you know, the the the cost of campaigns really skyrocketed
- 19:25after Citizens United, but especially in the leaps from, like, 2016 compared to 2014.
- 19:32And I mean, I'm sorry, 2018 to '14 and 2016 to 2020 and '22 to 2018.
- 19:39I mean, each cycle shattered previous fundraising records from 2016 to 2020.
- 19:49The federal elections, that is White House and Congress together in constant dollars adjusted
- 19:53for inflation, more than doubled, you know, in only four years.
- 19:57And during that same period, partisan rancor just escalated, you know, off the charts.
- 20:04And there are people, for example, on the Democrat side who will say, oh, this is
- 20:08President Trump's fault.
- 20:09But, no, I I don't think so.
- 20:12I mean, I I I have criticisms of both sides, but frankly, this is not about individual
- 20:16politicians.
- 20:17It's about the system.
- 20:18I would argue that in this way, indirectly, the money chase has driven the polarization.
- 20:23But I would say, just to to recap the argument, I think the biggest issue is that it has it's
- 20:30just taken all good options off the table.
- 20:33We were blocked by and and I also want to say that in all of this, I don't fault politicians
- 20:40and I don't fault the donors.
- 20:42They're doing what they have to do on the rules of a broken system.
- 20:47The money chase, arms race between the candidates in fundraising and spending that
- 20:52took off really around the end of the 1970s, it has its own dynamic.
- 20:56This is not something that any of us chose.
- 20:59And we get away from blaming anyone.
- 21:01You know, for us, it's not the 99% against the 1%.
- 21:05We're not hostile to business interests.
- 21:08You know, my father was a very successful corporate manager.
- 21:12I mean, it's it's not about that at all.
- 21:15It's about it's really about 100% of the country, pretty much against the money.
- 21:21And that's also kind of one of my important part of my message.
- 21:24Our fellow Americans are not the enemy.
- 21:26The money is the enemy.
- 21:27And let's go together against this enemy as Americans on the base of the basis of American
- 21:32ideals.
- 21:33The whole blame game thing, a lot of times it's really just about self aggrandizement and
- 21:40patting yourself on the back as opposed to actually fixing issues.
- 21:45There was something you said at the beginning.
- 21:47Oh, you're talking about not alienating donors.
- 21:50It's funny, it's true.
- 21:51Yeah, you gotta be careful not to alienate donors.
- 21:54You can alienate an entire segment of the actual voting population.
- 21:59That's that's perfectly fair game.
- 22:01Sometimes that even removes you camp strategy wise, but which obviously don't wanna see
- 22:08either.
- 22:08But for for some candidates, it's unfortunately a good strategy for them to actually win.
- 22:15But the people who are actually funding your campaigns, you gotta be careful not to alienate
- 22:19them.
- 22:19So that's that's definitely a a good point as well.
- 22:23And another thing that might seem maybe self explanatory, but I I think it really helps to
- 22:32demonstrate it clearly.
- 22:33And reforms are often difficult to make happen in politics in general.
- 22:38If they weren't, a lot of our issues wouldn't be so pervasive, and we wouldn't be arguing
- 22:42about them for years and years on end.
- 22:45But it seems that
- 22:46Nicely put.
- 22:47Yeah.
- 22:48But but it seems that campaign finance reform is a particularly arduous thing to achieve even
- 22:55though ostensibly nobody is happy with how campaign finance works, say for maybe some of
- 23:01the biggest donors who can, you know, throw their waiter out.
- 23:04You think that campaign finance reform is maybe the most difficult reform to achieve?
- 23:11And whether you agree with that sentiment or not, why do you think campaign finance reform
- 23:16is particularly difficult to implement?
- 23:21Yeah.
- 23:21No, that's it.
- 23:22That's really kind of right on the money.
- 23:24I mean, that's the $64,000 question, Paul.
- 23:27And and altogether, I kind of need to explain, need to defend why I think, in fact, that in
- 23:32the next three years, my team and I, and we'll talk a little bit about how we propose to make
- 23:36this happen, can put the problem of money in politics and the voter dollar solution squarely
- 23:43on the national agenda like a top three issue in the presidential year.
- 23:47I think we can do that, and we have a plan for that.
- 23:49But as far as why it's been so difficult, well, this is this is a fundamental catch 22, which
- 23:55is that how can politicians fight the big money?
- 23:58They're too busy raising it, you know?
- 24:01And it's like and this is not again, I don't question anyone's moral character or good
- 24:05intentions.
- 24:06But, you know, you can't really it's very difficult to go out on the campaign trail and
- 24:11tell the voters that money in politics is evil.
- 24:15And the next day, get on the horn to your evil donors to ask them for more of your evil money.
- 24:20I mean, it's kind of an awkward conversation.
- 24:22I know that sounds pat and simplistic.
- 24:24Some things in life are that simple.
- 24:26Most aren't.
- 24:26But this one is, I think.
- 24:28And specifically, I want to highlight, you know, that over the last, particularly since o
- 24:34eight, we keep voting for candidates who promise fundamental change, but in the vaguest
- 24:40terms.
- 24:41I mean, for President Obama, you know, change we can believe in.
- 24:45Yes, we can.
- 24:45Well, what can we do?
- 24:47You know, Mr.
- 24:49Obama.
- 24:49And in 2016 was, in some ways, the most fascinating election in the last twenty years
- 24:54because on both sides of the aisle, you had change candidates.
- 24:58President Trump ran against the system, said we must drain the swamp.
- 25:02Bernie Sanders ran against the system, said we need a revolution.
- 25:07But where was the plan to drain the swamp?
- 25:10What exactly did this revolution consist of altogether?
- 25:13Where did the swamp come from?
- 25:15What broke the system?
- 25:16On that, crickets.
- 25:18You know, the silence was deafening.
- 25:20And the reason for that is is that those candidates could not fight the money.
- 25:24They were too busy raising it.
- 25:26And that, I think, is kind of the catch 22 that has kept our country stuck in kind of a doom
- 25:30loop for such a long time.
- 25:34The good news, I guess, is that but in a way, you know, one of the things that people really
- 25:40focus on Citizens United because it kind of further opened the floodgates in various ways.
- 25:45But I think it's actually done us a favor because I think that things had to get this
- 25:49bad.
- 25:50And I think the money problem had to become this glaring and visible before we could really
- 25:56turn this around.
- 25:57And I think we've arrived at a moment in our politics in the next three years where we do
- 26:02have an historic window of opportunity to really to turn this around and to reclaim our
- 26:08saying how we are governed and indeed not just to reclaim, but to make government by the
- 26:13people in this country stronger than it has ever been, whether here in any country.
- 26:18Because historically, no one has done democracy better than Americans.
- 26:22After all, we invented it, you know, and we have been the model for the rest of the world
- 26:26so many times.
- 26:27But, you know, speaking specifically well, anyway, I answered your question about, you
- 26:32know, why I think it's been so hard to solve.
- 26:34Right.
- 26:35Because the only people who can solve it are elected officials who pass laws.
- 26:38But those are the people who are most dependent on this system and the system of raising tons
- 26:43of money.
- 26:44But let me take a step back and let you get a word in edgewise.
- 26:48No, no, you're good.
- 26:50I think obviously that does make sense.
- 26:53But another thing that I think doesn't necessarily get talked about as much is I think
- 26:59that campaign finance laws in particular like, generally people understand something's wrong
- 27:07with it.
- 27:08But Yeah.
- 27:08When you get into, like, the nitty gritty parts of it, I think it's a lot harder to to teach it
- 27:15to the general public.
- 27:17Like, some people might have, like, a basic understanding of health care policy or Yeah.
- 27:23Gun policy and things like that.
- 27:25I think campaign finance policy is a lot less accessible and understandable to the regular
- 27:33citizen.
- 27:33Yeah.
- 27:34Okay.
- 27:34Yeah.
- 27:34You gotta raise money to and spend it on
- 27:37on a campaign.
- 27:38But, like,
- 27:38the actual you know, what are the limits for and is it different between federal, state, and
- 27:45local level?
- 27:46Is it different between the states?
- 27:47What are all these other little nooks and crannies here?
- 27:50How do independent expenditures work?
- 27:52I think that's a little bit harder for people to understand all those nooks and crannies.
- 27:57So even trying to generate enough support from voters to pressure candidates and elected
- 28:06officials so that they're less likely respond to big donors.
- 28:10I think that can also be a big challenge.
- 28:13But this actually is getting a little bit more into the strategy, so I want to give you a
- 28:17chance to talk about the strategy.
- 28:20And, obviously, I don't want don't want you to lay out all the strategy, tell, you know, tell
- 28:24all your secrets.
- 28:25No.
- 28:25No.
- 28:25No.
- 28:25We don't have time for that anyways.
- 28:26But can you give us at least a a rundown of how you are trying to garner support for your voter
- 28:32dollars concept and how exactly you are trying to get the voter dollars concept implemented.
- 28:39That said, you know, you raised such a great question.
- 28:42And I I think that I would like to just take a couple of minutes to break down campaign
- 28:46finance law because although the folks, you know, people work in politics wanna make it
- 28:51complicated for us, it's actually kind of brutally simple.
- 28:54And also, the reason it doesn't make sense to people is that it doesn't make sense.
- 28:59This is idiotic.
- 29:00And I'll tell you why.
- 29:01Basically, what happened is back in 1976, the Supreme Court and its infinite wisdom, seven
- 29:06justices out of the eight that were serving at the moment, decided that, free speech included
- 29:14money you could spend to purchase an audience for your speech.
- 29:18Up to that point in our country, in every country, free speech meant what you and I are
- 29:21doing.
- 29:22We express our views.
- 29:24It never included the money itself you might spend on campaign advertising or billboards or
- 29:30door knocking campaign was not itself speech.
- 29:33But, you know, in in this unsigned opinion, a precarious opinion, this majority of seven
- 29:39justices decided that money, in fact, political money, money that you're spending basically to
- 29:45purchase influence in government is free speech and enjoys the protection of the First
- 29:49Amendment, which doesn't automatically mean that there can be no regulation.
- 29:53But basically then over time and especially under the leadership of John Roberts as chief
- 29:59justice since 2005, the Supreme Court has taken this fundamentally, I have to say, idiotic idea
- 30:05and taken it to its most ridiculous conclusion to the point where it's like you really it's
- 30:11it's it's there are very few limits remaining on how much anyone can donate and spend.
- 30:17And I I, you know, I I think it would be difficult to go into any bar in this country
- 30:22and find seven customers no matter how inebriated to endorse this this idea, you know,
- 30:29that money is speech and that it's somehow irrelevant that special interests can drown out
- 30:35everyone else's speech by spending hundreds of millions on ads.
- 30:39But nonetheless, that's how the justices see it.
- 30:43To me, it's one of the greatest triumphs of book learning over common sense that I've ever
- 30:47heard of in my study of history.
- 30:49In any case, the court's not going anywhere.
- 30:51Right?
- 30:52So the only path to fixing, to play, to changing the game, short of amending the
- 30:57constitution, and there are some very good people promoting that group called American
- 31:02Promise, good people.
- 31:03You might want to talk to them.
- 31:04Short of amending the constitution, which is time consuming, is a public financing mechanism
- 31:12because what you're doing is you're making available a pool of money that candidates can
- 31:17draw on, funded by the taxpayers.
- 31:20And if they get their money from us, then they don't then they're not beholden to any special
- 31:24interest who gives it to them.
- 31:26And the thing is that of the public financing mechanisms, this is the best because it puts
- 31:33power directly in the hands of each individual voter.
- 31:37You know?
- 31:37It says, look.
- 31:38Here's the coin of political influence we put into your hands.
- 31:41Candidates are gonna come to you not just for your vote, but for something they need a lot
- 31:46more urgently than your vote.
- 31:47The campaign cash without which they can't ask anyone for their vote.
- 31:51And it has other political strengths that I can return to.
- 31:54And the thing is that it's I it's hard to see how the Supreme Court could strike this down.
- 31:59Now, although I have a law degree, constitutional law is not my specialty, but
- 32:03I've studied the campaign finance law.
- 32:05And I mean, the court, they've they basically locked themselves into this position that money
- 32:09is speech.
- 32:09Well, Okay, if you want robust, unfettered political speech, voter dollars gives the power
- 32:16of political, quote unquote, speech, that is campaign donation, to a 174,000,000 registered
- 32:21voters, almost all of whom never didn't have it before because very few of us have enough cash
- 32:26lying around we can afford to donate to politicians.
- 32:29Suddenly, look, you want free speech?
- 32:31This gives it to the country in spades.
- 32:34And so that is also a reason why I put all my chips on this reform of all the proposals out
- 32:39there.
- 32:40So but let me now pivot to how we propose to make this happen.
- 32:45You know, we think that ultimately the voter dollars reform, once enough people hear about
- 32:50it and once people really feel that this is something that could actually happen, you know,
- 32:58that it will sell itself.
- 32:59And, you know, because its political strengths, I guess the most important is the way that it
- 33:04directly empowers each voter.
- 33:05Look, now you have skin in the game.
- 33:07Now you have a say.
- 33:08Now you're in the driver's seat.
- 33:10It's also it's common sense.
- 33:13Whoever pays the piper calls the tune.
- 33:15As the saying goes, we want to call that tune in Washington.
- 33:17We got to pay that piper.
- 33:19You summarize it in four words, make voters the donors.
- 33:23It also and I there's reams of data demonstrate that as well as my experience in speeches, in
- 33:29conversations, in 150 media interviews, on outlets from left to right.
- 33:34This is something that absolutely can command support from Americans left, right and center.
- 33:38It's a unifying issue, indeed, that can really help us in that way.
- 33:44It also we're going to get better candidates, candidates who want to serve us.
- 33:48And you don't have to be a millionaire anymore to challenge an incumbent in the House.
- 33:52So if you're you could be 25 years, the minimum, you know, age for the house, smart
- 33:58young person, social media savvy, got some good ideas.
- 34:01You could get a campaign off the ground with voter dollars.
- 34:04Right now, the congress looks like a cross between a nursing home and a country club
- 34:09because really to run, you kind of have to be a millionaire with millionaire friends.
- 34:12So you've got all these things going for it.
- 34:15But we have two really probably the two very big obstacles we have to overcome.
- 34:20One is just breaking through the noise and the fact that everyone who's working in politics,
- 34:26running for office, the fact that they're beholden to donors is the last thing they want
- 34:31to talk about.
- 34:32Right?
- 34:32So that's hard.
- 34:33And I think even bigger that so many Americans are so discouraged, you know, because we've
- 34:38been promised fundamental change again and again, and it hasn't been delivered.
- 34:43And, you know, we've and because we didn't know what had gone wrong in our politics, because we
- 34:49had no way of seeing this process, because this process was, you know, of candidates self
- 34:54censoring and how that asphyxiated our democracy by sucking the substance out of the
- 35:00conversation.
- 35:01No one even could imagine that was going on.
- 35:04You know, we're actually the only group that's really kind of putting a name on that problem.
- 35:08And because Americans couldn't see what had done this, we, the people with our
- 35:12individualistic, you know, the ethos of individual responsibility that is so American,
- 35:17we have blamed ourselves and blamed each other and said, oh, the problem is that my fellow
- 35:21voters are stupid or apathetic or vicious or whatever.
- 35:25And it has made us feel helpless.
- 35:27And this feeling of helplessness and pessimism, is thoroughly understandable, no shame in it
- 35:32for anyone, is a big obstacle.
- 35:35That the issue is how do we generate, you know, get get enough attention, you know, from people
- 35:42and from the media, and how do we generate a feeling of momentum and let people see that
- 35:46this is a growing concern and could in fact happen?
- 35:49And our strategy for doing so is to lever the outsized attention that media and candidates
- 35:55pay to certain states, small number of states in the presidential contest in 2028.
- 36:01So we are building.
- 36:03We are organizing and building support in four states in Iowa, first primary state and in
- 36:09three swing states, Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania.
- 36:13All of these in Pennsylvania, in particular in 2024, everyone said.
- 36:18You can't win that that race without winning Pennsylvania.
- 36:22And the other states, of course, have been critical, both in they were in 2016, they were
- 36:27in 2024 to President Trump's victories.
- 36:31So and so we're we're you know, I've hired, you know, full time state director in in
- 36:38Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Iowa.
- 36:40We're interviewing someone from Michigan this week.
- 36:42I've also got a chief of staff who's director of coalitions and partnerships.
- 36:47We're also going to be hiring part time assistants to the state directors.
- 36:51Mostly we're going to have to rely on volunteers and building volunteer support for
- 36:55this, but basically we're starting just going to people in their communities, you know, in at
- 37:02the Grange, at rotary clubs, talking to, you know, congregations, pastors, people who run
- 37:08food banks, people who work at, you know, volunteer fire departments, people who are
- 37:11already serving their communities, people on college campuses and students and political
- 37:16groups.
- 37:17Particularly, you've got young people who right now feel completely ignored by the political
- 37:22system because they are, because no one of their age group really can donate funds and and
- 37:27really with this message.
- 37:30And, you know, it's it's a you know, so that's what we're doing.
- 37:33We're still in the early stages.
- 37:34We just but basically, we're going to have six full time paid staff for the next three years,
- 37:39plus myself as a seventh full time staff member on a purely voluntary basis.
- 37:45And that's kind of what we're working on.
- 37:49And the thing is, I think that we're, you know, we're optimistic.
- 37:53We're very optimistic about being able to get the kind of very large numbers of volunteers
- 37:59that we will need to really put this on the agenda, on the national agenda, to force the
- 38:04political system to confront this problem because we're, you know, 85% of the American
- 38:11people are already saying the system is broken.
- 38:13We've been clamoring for fundamental change for years.
- 38:16But nope, that what's been missing all along is the concrete plan for change.
- 38:20Our change candidates never gave us a concrete plan because what most needs changing is money
- 38:25in politics, and they were too busy raising the money to fight it.
- 38:28And here's a concrete plan, very simple, easy to explain, cross partisan support, you know,
- 38:37directly empowers voters, speaking directly to the feeling of hopelessness and powerlessness
- 38:43that is so infuriating to Americans regardless of of of their political orientation.
- 38:49And last but not least, that this is really about what it means to be an American.
- 38:54This is about government by the people, which is, you know, which after all, we Americans
- 38:59invented government by the people and down through the generations.
- 39:04This is my perspective as a historian of modern Germany, looking at our country, seeing how
- 39:08remarkable this country is, that we are truly unique.
- 39:11800,000 Americans giving their lives in wars fought for the freedom of others.
- 39:17I mean, our freedom has not been under credible military threat since the war of eighteen
- 39:20twelve.
- 39:22And nonetheless, I mean, we didn't have to fight Hitler.
- 39:25You know, we we sent you know, we did that.
- 39:27We fought for the freedom of others because we feel so strongly about our ideals.
- 39:31And I just think that I don't see any compelling reason why Americans will hesitate
- 39:37to, when no one has to get killed, you know, or really spend anywhere near the kind of money we
- 39:44spend in World War II, to make a bit of an effort to to tell politicians we want that
- 39:48freedom for ourselves here at home.
- 39:51I think that we have all these things going for us.
- 39:54And now and I guess I should also mention in connection with the sort of patriotic quality
- 39:58of the undertaking is this is a wonderful way to bring Americans together because if you
- 40:03follow you look at the media and the loudest voices in social media, you think half the
- 40:07country hates the other half and is happy with their hatred and enjoys it.
- 40:11Most Americans, every poll says, don't want this.
- 40:15We're not a nation of haters.
- 40:17We don't want to hate each other.
- 40:19Some of us the efforts to divide us by party have succeeded to some degree.
- 40:25Some of us are kind of agitated and angry because of that.
- 40:28But ultimately, that's not what we want.
- 40:30And we also know that it's not solving our problems.
- 40:32It's not putting food on the table.
- 40:34It's not getting our kids through college and so on and so forth.
- 40:37So for all these reasons, I think that we have something to offer that really meets the
- 40:41moment.
- 40:42And we're also at a point where I think, you know, the political system is just is breaking
- 40:47down and 2028 is going to be wide open because President Trump's not going be on the ballot.
- 40:51You're going to have an open primary on both sides of the aisle.
- 40:55And Americans are and none of the candidates at this point are going to be offering a path
- 41:00forward.
- 41:01None of them is going to offer a real solution to the system being broken and all the other
- 41:07specific policy problems we've got because their hands are tied by the need to not offend
- 41:13donors.
- 41:14And so, I think that there is tremendous opportunity for us to break through.
- 41:19I have no crystal ball any more than anyone else, but I think if anything is going to get
- 41:23the job done, I think it's this.
- 41:24I think we have something very exciting to talk about.
- 41:27Yeah, there is that big difference between having the theory of something and the idea of
- 41:34something and then actually having it to put it into practice, kind of like how you said a lot
- 41:39of times people say, We need something to change campaign finance reform, but then you
- 41:43actually have to implement it.
- 41:44And you you talked about not wanting to people most people not wanting to hate and be angry,
- 41:53which is true.
- 41:53It's just, unfortunately, those are very easy to activate, and that's why they just are
- 41:58always so potent and probably another big reason why campaign finance has been a hard
- 42:05thing to reform and resolve.
- 42:07So we talked a lot about this voter dollars being in the context of federal government
- 42:13because we're talking about the highest the priciest campaigns, are typically going to be
- 42:21for federal government, especially president.
- 42:24But can this also be applied to state and local elections as well, or is that something you're
- 42:33hoping to do down the road, or is it just focused on the federal government?
- 42:38How exactly do you want voter dollars to be applied in terms of federal versus state versus
- 42:44local government?
- 42:46Well, our focus for the next three years is entirely and only on the federal level.
- 42:53Yeah, And
- 42:54And we we think think that Americans are ready for transfer to really fix the system.
- 42:57And so we feel that we got this excitement.
- 42:59But once we've got that done, yeah, absolutely.
- 43:02I think we need voter dollar assistance for state level, state office in all 50 states.
- 43:07And and and I think in our largest cities as well, I think once we get the federal system
- 43:11done and it and it proves itself, which I think it which I have no doubt that it will, then
- 43:17that will also happen.
- 43:18And I think that's going to improve the quality of our public life and also help us just, you
- 43:24know, make life better for ourselves all across the board.
- 43:28Because ultimately, you know, that one of the great things about the American people also is
- 43:32that historically we're not a nation of ideologues.
- 43:35We tend to be in our views clustered at the center.
- 43:37We're pretty practical, pretty common sense.
- 43:40Most Americans confronted with a problem rather than sort of fight about it or get into some
- 43:45theory about what should be right, kind of want to roll up their sleeves, put their heads
- 43:48together and get it done.
- 43:49And I think that once we start putting the American people in charge, we're going to start
- 43:53fixing things.
- 43:54And Americans, we will regain our optimism and move forward.
- 43:57But yeah, absolutely.
- 43:59State level systems are the next step once we have the federal system.
- 44:04Gotcha.
- 44:05Yeah, the point about ideologues, it is very easy to just look at the most ideological
- 44:12voters, the most partisan voters who are the most active, and it makes it seem like people
- 44:17are a lot more ideological than they actually are.
- 44:20It's actually people who are in office tend to be a lot more ideological than regular So,
- 44:25voters of course, any idea for reform is going to have us detractors for various reasons.
- 44:35And I know we talked about this a little bit before, but I wanna hone in more specifically
- 44:40on these counter arguments.
- 44:42So what are two to three of the most common arguments against this voter dollars idea,
- 44:48whether you have specifically heard them or you simply predict they will be made?
- 44:53And then what are your counterarguments?
- 44:56There's really two that stand out.
- 44:58I'd say 90 kind of 98 of the time someone raises an objection.
- 45:02It's these two.
- 45:02The first is is is the cost.
- 45:05We're already running this $2,000,000,000,000 deficit.
- 45:07Can we afford to spend more?
- 45:09And the most important answer to that is, you know, actually, this is going to reduce the
- 45:14deficit.
- 45:14We're going to be able to cut all this wasteful spending and start giving away, you know,
- 45:19sweetheart tax deals to corporations whose lobbyists have used the nations to extract them
- 45:25from these goodies from Congress.
- 45:26Another point I would make way of putting it is just that as a practical matter, these
- 45:30campaigns will continue to be expensive because the Supreme Court will not let us limit the
- 45:35cost of campaigns because that would be limiting speech.
- 45:38So candidates are going to get this money from somewhere.
- 45:41If they do not get it from us, they are going to keep getting it from special interests and
- 45:44billionaires.
- 45:45And we, the people will still be out in the cold disenfranchised.
- 45:49The other objection as well, if the court's not going to let you limit how much, you know,
- 45:55special interests and wealthy people donate and spend, will they not just swamp your voter
- 46:01daughter system with additional billions?
- 46:04And our answer to that is, first of all, actually, I'm pretty sure it was 2018.
- 46:09I '18 think it was or 2019.
- 46:14But definitely, we actually already had that happen because there is this kind of voter
- 46:18dollar system in Seattle, not very well implemented in my opinion, but still, you know,
- 46:23has had some successes.
- 46:26In that year, I think 2019, Jeff Bezos, I think to head off a slight increase in the property
- 46:32tax, got together with some of his cronies and decided to buy a city council more to their
- 46:38liking, invested an unprecedented 1 and a half million in seven city council races.
- 46:42But because the people of Seattle had been more educated to the importance of money in politics
- 46:48through the ballot initiative campaign for the vote there, what they called it, democracy
- 46:53voucher system and which had already then been used, I think, in at least one election cycle,
- 46:58you completely backfired.
- 47:00Everyone was outraged.
- 47:01The media were outraged.
- 47:02The voters were outraged.
- 47:03He's trying to buy our government and his candidates went down to defeat.
- 47:07I guess I would put it, you know, we are not gonna get a voter dollar system, a national
- 47:11voter dollar system unless and until I think a clear majority of the American people have
- 47:16heard of it, understand what it is, and are saying we want this.
- 47:20Because, again, everyone in Washington is dependent on their donors.
- 47:23We think absolutely we can reach that level of support among Americans because of all the
- 47:28strengths that this has.
- 47:29Once we have that, if we can count on the voters to punish any candidate who deliberately
- 47:35makes a point of going to special interest for money when such an ample pool of public funds
- 47:41controlled by voters is available.
- 47:44So can I guarantee that's going to be the case?
- 47:46But I'll tell you, even if we were wrong about that and even if the billionaires kept sort of
- 47:52just stepped up their spending and and a lot of candidates kept taking their money, what at a
- 47:57minimum it does, it levels the playing foot.
- 47:59It does give enough money for candidates who truly wanna serve us to be competitive.
- 48:03And ultimately, what matters in election is not so much who has the most because you can have
- 48:09you can sometimes do have many candidates who will outspend their opponent by five to one and
- 48:13still lose.
- 48:14The key is not having the most.
- 48:16The key is having enough.
- 48:18And if you have enough, you know, if you can raise a million, say, for a house campaign and
- 48:23you've got you're actually listening to voters and and offering them solutions, then, you
- 48:29know, as long as you're able to, you know, to run some ads, to hire a staff, to to fund a
- 48:34ground game and so on so that the media see that you're viable and that you're not ignored
- 48:39and not treated as a crank, that's really what matters.
- 48:43I mean, the key is not who has because people will object to me.
- 48:46I guess that's a third objection.
- 48:47Well, you know, you know, Slayton out spent Trump three to one in 2016 and he won.
- 48:54And yet there are always exceptions.
- 48:56Having more money is not a guarantee of victory.
- 48:58The crucial question is, do you have enough?
- 49:01And right now you can't get enough.
- 49:03You can't get that robust amount that makes you viable if you say anything that's offensive to
- 49:10donors.
- 49:10But going forward, when you say when you listen to to voters and start telling things that that
- 49:16are useful to voters and answering their questions, you will have enough.
- 49:20And so even then, that would be just a massive gain step forward for the country.
- 49:26Interesting.
- 49:27Something that just occurred to me on on you were talking about people saying, well, won't
- 49:34big donors just swamp the the voter dollars?
- 49:38Do you think that with this voter dollars idea, do you think that'll empower?
- 49:43Because we do have a problem with low turnout rates in this country pretty much across the
- 49:49board.
- 49:49Do you think that the voter dollars would help to alleviate that somewhat to make people
- 49:55think, oh, wait.
- 49:55My voice does matter, and they will that there will be more people that vote?
- 50:02Great.
- 50:02Thank you so much.
- 50:03That's that's very astute of you to point that up.
- 50:06And indeed, I think not only will we get higher rates of of voting, voter.
- 50:12I think the voters will also be much better informed because they have a reason to inform
- 50:15themselves.
- 50:16People are always people who are sort of, you know, elites of various kinds are always scold
- 50:21us for not informing ourselves.
- 50:23But why should we inform why should we inform ourselves when no one in Washington is
- 50:27listening to us?
- 50:28I mean, frankly, when I look at, you know, or why aren't more people voting?
- 50:32Frankly, when I look at how powerless we, the people, have become and how disrespectfully we
- 50:36are treated by candidates, to me, it testifies to the American people's uniquely powerful
- 50:43commitment to democracy that anyone votes in this country at all anymore.
- 50:47You know?
- 50:47So, yeah, I think we're gonna get higher turnout and we're gonna get more informed
- 50:51voters, more engaged voters.
- 50:53We're gonna have a much stronger political conversation.
- 50:56Much more good ideas are gonna rise to the top.
- 50:58Yeah.
- 50:58I think it's also a win in that way too.
- 51:03Interesting.
- 51:04And, you know, it is that is another thing too is that people get scolded for not informing
- 51:11themselves.
- 51:12And yet, some extent, do have a responsibility to inform themselves, but also the powers that
- 51:18be also often try to make it as difficult as possible to actually research things and just
- 51:24so people just go to candidates and their campaigns for information that you don't need
- 51:29to actually research everything.
- 51:30They oftentimes make it hard for people to research everything, especially because even if
- 51:35people wanna research things, they have to spend the actual time to go look for that
- 51:40information.
- 51:40That's something I've talked about a lot in several other episodes too, just this whole
- 51:46accessibility of information that is also a major problem.
- 51:51It's not just people don't wanna inform themselves.
- 51:54Mhmm.
- 51:54A lot of people do.
- 51:55They just don't know where to go or they don't know how to parse the information.
- 51:59How do they know that the information they're getting is good?
- 52:02So that's as as I appreciate you highlighting that point as well.
- 52:08And so you you just talked to you talked a little bit earlier about several other campaign
- 52:16finance reforms that have been put out there and that you support voter dollars
- 52:20specifically.
- 52:21So I wanna get a little bit more into that as well because we do see all these other ideas
- 52:26even if they're not necessarily as concrete for reforming campaign finance laws.
- 52:33So why do you support voter dollars versus other reform ideas?
- 52:38And what do you think are some strengths that voter dollars has that these other ideas do
- 52:42not?
- 52:44Excellent.
- 52:44Yeah.
- 52:45So really, there are two other models.
- 52:47First of all, to to really actually change things, you need a public financing mechanism
- 52:52because that will survive judicial review.
- 52:54It'll get past the Supreme Court.
- 52:56And the other two models are matching funds for small dollar donations and lump sum grants to
- 53:02qualifying campaigns.
- 53:04Matching funds is, say, a private citizen voluntarily donates, say, $10 to a campaign,
- 53:10and the government will match that at a ratio of, say, six to one, nine to one, in some
- 53:15cases, 12 to one.
- 53:17So the campaign would receive if it's six to one match, the candidate reached the $10 from
- 53:23the donor, the volunteer, the citizen and $60 from the government.
- 53:27And that's the system we have here in New York City.
- 53:30And just I think it was last year it was expanded to New York State as a whole.
- 53:34There are some other, you know, but there are some municipal jurisdictions and some states
- 53:40that have matching fund systems.
- 53:43And, you know, the people who have promoted these matching fund systems and and advocated
- 53:48them, you know, they have done yeoman service in educating people about the problem of money
- 53:54in politics.
- 53:55And I think that's been a step in the right direction.
- 53:58That said, it has a couple of problems.
- 54:00One is at the national level, I don't see how we're going to get any reform, whether
- 54:04incremental or very ambitious, without massive public support because Congress is just too
- 54:10dependent on donors.
- 54:12So my opinion, my view, our view is you got to have you really got to get massive public
- 54:17support.
- 54:17You're not going to get massive public support for a farm that really only benefits those
- 54:22Americans who have enough spare cash around that they can afford to donate.
- 54:26Because really, it's in any given election, it's got to be less than 5% of the voters who
- 54:31donate.
- 54:32So, you know, it's kind of in in that, you know, it's kind of and also just at the federal
- 54:38level, the elections are so expensive.
- 54:39It's just too little, too late.
- 54:41I mean, there's not enough small dollar money out there, no matter how no matter what the
- 54:45ratio at which you match it, that's going to move the needle.
- 54:48So, you know, there are people still pushing for it at the state or local level.
- 54:52And in some places, that's a good idea.
- 54:54But at the national level, I think that's just a dead end.
- 54:57The other approach is lump sum grants.
- 55:00I believe that's the system in Arizona and Connecticut, possibly Maine also.
- 55:04That is the campaign gets a certain number of signatures and small donations and then gets a
- 55:10lump sum grant from the state treasury.
- 55:13The problem with that is several problems.
- 55:15One is that at least in theory, it's possible for incumbents to rig the inform the formula to
- 55:21preserve their incumbency.
- 55:24A second is that it doesn't empower voters.
- 55:26It empowers bureaucrats.
- 55:27It empowers the state.
- 55:29What's better about voter dollar, and one of the things that's so good about it, is that
- 55:33it's impossible to rig or correct because the key decision, which candidate gets how much, is
- 55:38decentralized to a 174,000,000 registered voters.
- 55:43How are going to rig that?
- 55:44And on the positive side, every one of these voters is empowered.
- 55:48You know, we it's hard to see how we're going to get Americans fired up because we need a lot
- 55:53of Americans fired up to support, you know, a transformational reform.
- 55:59If all that reform does is create a pool of money in Washington that's going to be
- 56:04administered by faceless bureaucrats and doled out by some formula.
- 56:08When you give the money directly to the people, then the people see we see that we are that we
- 56:13have power.
- 56:14And so for that that reason as well, to me, voter dollars is hands down the best reform
- 56:21proposal out there.
- 56:22And there are also reform proposals that concern voting like ranked choice voting and
- 56:26people talk about.
- 56:27There's the electoral electoral state compact, which you may have talked about.
- 56:31A lot of worthy ideas out there, but is but none of those ideas is a game changer.
- 56:37But for the reasons that I said earlier, because of the damage done by candidate self
- 56:41censoring to avoid alienating donors, the most powerful, impactful reform we can we can do is
- 56:50the reform of money and politics.
- 56:53And because, you know, any leverage we gain in the money problem brings this massive upside.
- 56:58Suddenly, we're free to talk about health care.
- 57:01We're free to talk about the budget when we're now not free to do.
- 57:06And voter dollars is very serious leverage indeed on the money problem.
- 57:11And that's why I put all my chips on it.
- 57:12That's why I made it my mission in life to to make this happen.
- 57:17Interesting.
- 57:19You know, it's kind of the it kind of goes back to how a lot of campaigns, and this is
- 57:27something I've talked about on a couple of other episodes, you know, that the SWAT
- 57:31analysis, you know, the strengths and weaknesses of your campaign opportunities and
- 57:35threats.
- 57:35And you you you've real you've really done your homework on this, the whole, you know, what the
- 57:41strengths of it and what are people going to, you know, counter with and and then what are
- 57:45the other, for lack of a better term, threats to your campaign finance reform idea and it's
- 57:50it's other ideas.
- 57:51So it's it's definitely interesting to see it from all those angles that that you're you're
- 57:57arguing for.
- 57:59And, obviously, reforms, and we've said this already, but reforms need some level of popular
- 58:05support to happen.
- 58:07And I like to include practical, actionable information for my listeners.
- 58:14What are some practical ways that people can get involved with the voter dollars campaign?
- 58:20So the first thing to do is just please visit our website, which is makevotersthedonors.org,
- 58:28makevotersthedonors.org.
- 58:29Our organization is make voters the donors.
- 58:32And, you know, the first thing that you can do is is just to if you if you find if you like
- 58:38the idea or just think it's interesting enough to think about, please share it with your
- 58:42friends, share it on social media.
- 58:44And then there'll be a whole host of opportunities to volunteer and engage at
- 58:48varying levels, particularly if you live in any one of the four target states.
- 58:53These states that get such outsized attention, you have any act, anything you do in those
- 58:58states, you really get a lot of bang for your buck, you know, as far as an impact on the
- 59:03future of the country.
- 59:05We there is a donate button on the website, but we're not going to we really don't get in
- 59:10people's faces about money.
- 59:11I mean, certainly are not going to refuse money.
- 59:14We'd be very grateful for it.
- 59:16But frankly, everyone in this audience, I'd say to you, you can do something.
- 59:21You could do something for this cause that is so much more valuable than any amount of money
- 59:24you could give.
- 59:25And that is validation.
- 59:27Your seal of approval on on this idea and on our organization because, you know, I mean, I
- 59:36go on radio and television.
- 59:37I speak in person.
- 59:38I go on podcasts.
- 59:39I make my best case.
- 59:40But the people in the audience don't know me from Adam.
- 59:43People who know you and trust you, our message about money and politics and and voter dollars
- 59:48will always be a 100 times more powerful coming from you than it can ever be coming from us.
- 59:54So I don't think you can't move the ball down the field.
- 59:57And then, you know, there are you know, we're gonna be encouraging people to, like, make
- 1:00:00their own TikTok videos and and share them with us.
- 1:00:04We're gonna be specifically organizing volunteers in the targeted states, and there
- 1:00:08are links on the website to how to contact the state directors in each of those states.
- 1:00:16So, I guess the short answer is, you know, please go to our website.
- 1:00:21Please share our follow us on social media, our social media accounts.
- 1:00:26We're on Instagram, TikTok.
- 1:00:28I'm on X and on LinkedIn.
- 1:00:33Also, probably the most important channel is going to be YouTube.
- 1:00:36And, and also Facebook's very important.
- 1:00:38We've got all of those.
- 1:00:39You know, please follow us on social media.
- 1:00:41Please share our posts.
- 1:00:44If you like them, share if you're active on social media, share this concept with your
- 1:00:48friends and talk to people one on one, your friends, you know, because we have a message of
- 1:00:53hope here for the American people.
- 1:00:55And I think that this is something exciting.
- 1:00:57So, yeah, that's an overly long answer to your very good question, and thank you very much for
- 1:01:01asking it.
- 1:01:02No, that's fine.
- 1:01:04And, hey, no, I appreciate it.
- 1:01:07So, I'll, of course, put those links in the show notes and go to that website and and and
- 1:01:14check out more of of what Dan has has got going on there.
- 1:01:19So we're just about at the end of the episode here.
- 1:01:24I'll try a little bit of a different order of the last couple questions here.
- 1:01:29So I always like to put at the very end.
- 1:01:31We'll do this for the second to last question.
- 1:01:33I always like to, for those who are new, I like to put at the end of interviews a random
- 1:01:40question of the day, random, fun, nonpolitical, just to get a little bit of a different side of
- 1:01:46our guests because variety is good.
- 1:01:49It's nice to have different interests.
- 1:01:53So for you, Dan, today's random question of the day is, who is a US historical figure that you
- 1:02:01think doesn't get enough attention for their contributions to the country?
- 1:02:06You are an historian, so I figured that would be a good question for you.
- 1:02:11I I I yeah.
- 1:02:12That that makes a lot of sense.
- 1:02:14And, you know, the one that jumps immediately to mind is is President Eisenhower.
- 1:02:20Not that he isn't talked about and isn't respected, but in a way, Eisenhower was just so
- 1:02:26solid and so respected and thoroughly liked by everyone because he was, in fact, in addition
- 1:02:32to being a very good president, capable politician and extraordinarily brave, you know,
- 1:02:37military leader, competent military leader, who after all planned and oversaw the the Normandy
- 1:02:43invasion, Operation Overlord, which is the really, you have to say the most challenging,
- 1:02:48difficult, risk laden enterprise in all of military history with just phenomenal pressure
- 1:02:55upon the man.
- 1:02:56He was so solid.
- 1:02:57People kind of always underestimated him.
- 1:02:59People thought he wasn't that bright.
- 1:03:01In fact, Eisenhower was extremely bright.
- 1:03:03He wrote extremely well.
- 1:03:05You look at his internal correspondence and his meetings to say, oh my gosh, this guy really
- 1:03:09was the smartest guy in the room.
- 1:03:11But he deliberately kind of not I don't know, not dumb himself down, but kind of really he
- 1:03:16just he was he was also humble in character and he portrayed humility, you know, and he was so
- 1:03:24well liked.
- 1:03:24And it was, of course, you know, a button that every so many people were in in the fifties.
- 1:03:28I like Ike.
- 1:03:30People did like him.
- 1:03:31And it's interesting, too.
- 1:03:33I remember this when I was in college.
- 1:03:35You know, some of my historians were really pretty left wing.
- 1:03:38One of them actually, Barton Bernstein, was an avowed Marxist, historian of American foreign
- 1:03:43policy.
- 1:03:44And they were all saying, you know, this Eisenhower, we don't like some of the things he
- 1:03:48did, like the coups in Guatemala and Iran.
- 1:03:50But actually, this guy was, you know, really smart.
- 1:03:53He made some very good calls.
- 1:03:56He diffused potential military conflicts.
- 1:04:00He kept military.
- 1:04:02Military spending was much higher as a part of the budget as in the GDP back then as it was
- 1:04:07now.
- 1:04:08But he and, you know, as you remember in his final speech, he warned us about the military
- 1:04:13industrial complex.
- 1:04:14He was a man of great vision, an extremely bright man, but a man who wore his air edition
- 1:04:19lightly.
- 1:04:20The fifties were a period kind of a golden age of bipartisanship in American politics.
- 1:04:26The only thing really that he in which he did not lead, but then again, neither did anyone
- 1:04:31else, was race.
- 1:04:32That was, you know, racial segregation, racial conflict.
- 1:04:36That was, you know, the I mean, that was just well, no one wanted to touch that.
- 1:04:41And people in Washington only were willing to touch that when these incredibly brave people
- 1:04:47in the South, black civil rights activists and leaders, stood up at the risk of their own
- 1:04:52lives and forced the country to confront it.
- 1:04:54But other than that, you have to say Eisenhower was a terrific president.
- 1:04:58And in a way, he's he we don't think of him too much because I think the guy was so solid.
- 1:05:03There was so little drama and so few problems.
- 1:05:05And he just handled everything so well with his even temper and his humility and and just also
- 1:05:11solid moral character.
- 1:05:12So, I find him enormously admirable.
- 1:05:14I guess he's one of my favorite overlooked American.
- 1:05:19Thank you very much for that question.
- 1:05:20Great question.
- 1:05:21Yeah.
- 1:05:22Well, thank You you highlighted it at the very end there is I don't think there's really any
- 1:05:29historical figure that you should 100% agree with everything to do.
- 1:05:33I think if you are if you are doing that, you're maybe not thinking hard enough about
- 1:05:37Yeah.
- 1:05:38What you what you do and don't support about them.
- 1:05:40But like you said, Eisenhower is a war hero.
- 1:05:43He I mean, even though he wasn't on the front lines in World War two, I you can see in in I
- 1:05:50remember reading a biography about him years ago and just stuff you read about him in
- 1:05:59general is the the D Day invasion, all that weighed very heavily on him.
- 1:06:06And he knew he was sending a lot of 18, 19, 20 year olds, sometimes even younger than 18
- 1:06:12because they lied about their age, boys to die for their country.
- 1:06:17And that's that's that's gotta be incredibly harrowing.
- 1:06:20And and something you kind of touched on too is it's pretty remarkable.
- 1:06:24The federal politics of that day were pretty solidly Democratic, but yet he was a Republican
- 1:06:31president who was able to garner a pretty wide array of support, which is, I think that's
- 1:06:38impressive regardless, but especially when you look at today's heavily divided politics.
- 1:06:45And so I think every US president, good or bad, that that has not gotten as much attention
- 1:06:55should be more well known.
- 1:06:57I mean, they were US presidents.
- 1:06:59Now some that are some of them are were not such great guys, but they were still US
- 1:07:05presidents.
- 1:07:06But I I'm I would give and then sometimes my my answer might might change depending on the day.
- 1:07:12But for for this, I'll give James Madison.
- 1:07:16And he he's my personal favorite president, not as much for his actual presidency.
- 1:07:21And, obviously, like I said earlier, shouldn't agree a 100% with everything they say.
- 1:07:27But for a guy that's called the father of the constitution, yeah, he he did not agree with
- 1:07:32that.
- 1:07:32He he was more humble than that.
- 1:07:35He had such a profound impact on the formation of this country, and I honestly don't think he
- 1:07:42gets enough credit.
- 1:07:43A lot of people know George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton.
- 1:07:48James Hamilton's or James, excuse me, James Madison, I think he surprisingly gets not swept
- 1:07:53under the rug, but doesn't quite get as much fanfare as he showed with with Federalist
- 1:07:59papers or just the the actual framing of the constitution.
- 1:08:04He was the first president to with America as its own nation to see a war and the war of
- 1:08:14eighteen twelve, you know, fought on the soil.
- 1:08:16And that I mean, that's that's pretty you don't he he doesn't really have a precedent, no pun
- 1:08:22intended, to follow in that regard.
- 1:08:25You have to kind of figure it out as you go along.
- 1:08:27So
- 1:08:28That's to the point.
- 1:08:28I hadn't thought of it that way.
- 1:08:29You're right.
- 1:08:30Yeah.
- 1:08:30Yeah.
- 1:08:31Yeah.
- 1:08:31So so James Madison would be would be my choice.
- 1:08:34And then I might also say Chester Arthur just because he's a he's not very well known, but he
- 1:08:40was a huge reason why you have the civil service policies in government that you have
- 1:08:48today.
- 1:08:48Obviously, a lot of this has changed since then, but he was really the guy who really
- 1:08:51helped bring about civil service in place of patronage.
- 1:08:55So I'll I'll also throw him out there as well.
- 1:08:58And him just getting kinda thrust into the spotlight with the assassination of James
- 1:09:02Garfield.
- 1:09:03So I'll I'll but James Madison would definitely be my my number one choice there.
- 1:09:09I'd like to add I'd like to add just a little bit, which have you read that recent biography,
- 1:09:13the light of battle that's about operation overlord and his role in it?
- 1:09:17No.
- 1:09:19Wonderful.
- 1:09:19Short book.
- 1:09:20It's really just about it's a little bit about his earlier life and career and then really
- 1:09:24about Overlord.
- 1:09:25The title comes from his final guess telegram to George Marshall, as the order the order had
- 1:09:32been sent and the boats were already on their way.
- 1:09:34And And he was talking about the troops, and they have a sense of purpose.
- 1:09:38The light of battle is in their eyes, which I thought was just a wonderful phrase.
- 1:09:43And, it was it's just which is funny you mentioned Chad Arthur because I still vividly
- 1:09:47remember my high school history teacher, Carol Barkis.
- 1:09:50I took APUS history from her, one of the best teachers I ever had.
- 1:09:53And one of those teachers that helped change the course of your life.
- 1:09:57And we never got into it.
- 1:09:58But I remember her saying in passing, you know, I thought Chester Arthur is really underrated
- 1:10:02and pretty good.
- 1:10:03I didn't know why.
- 1:10:04But and then you reminded me why, you know, the civil service system, which is crucially
- 1:10:08important.
- 1:10:09Yeah.
- 1:10:10That's going to just about wrap things up.
- 1:10:12One last question for you.
- 1:10:14Final thoughts that you wanna give people about campaign finance reform, voter dollars, or
- 1:10:19anything else that is relevant to those?
- 1:10:22Well, one is briefly, we never use the term campaign finance reform because it made
- 1:10:27people's eyes glaze over.
- 1:10:28And also, it's a phrase associated with the Democratic Party, who somehow think they have
- 1:10:33ownership of this issue when in fact neither party acts on it.
- 1:10:36I'm not criticizing you.
- 1:10:37I'm just sort of.
- 1:10:38So we talk about making focus.
- 1:10:40And ultimately, our goal is not to reform campaign finance.
- 1:10:43Our goal is to put the people in charge.
- 1:10:45But, you know, when I talk about people, you know, Americans are discouraged and I get it.
- 1:10:51But and there but and there's there's five or six reasons I could give you why I think the
- 1:10:56odds are actually very strongly in favor of our success.
- 1:10:59But I'll just finish with one, which is, you know, for every other nation and every other
- 1:11:04country, government by the people is an option.
- 1:11:07For Americans, it is existential.
- 1:11:09It is who we are.
- 1:11:10And down through our history, I talked about the 800,000 Americans who gave their lives and
- 1:11:14wars fought for the freedom of others.
- 1:11:17We Americans have shown ourselves capable of a kind of idealism that you will find in the
- 1:11:22history of no other people.
- 1:11:24And this is one of the reasons why I personally am so proud of my country and proud to be an
- 1:11:28American.
- 1:11:30And we may not be feeling too idealistic about our politics now.
- 1:11:34And who can blame us after six years of lies and broken promises and disappointments.
- 1:11:39But the American people have not forgotten what our country stands for.
- 1:11:43The people in Washington may have, but we haven't forgotten.
- 1:11:46And I think that once Americans sort of see start hearing about voter dollars and our
- 1:11:52campaign from other people and start seeing we start getting more and more media coverage as
- 1:11:58our organizing efforts bear fruit and people come to see, wow, this can happen and we begin
- 1:12:03to recover some of our optimism.
- 1:12:06I think this is going to snowball very quickly because this is ultimately about what it means
- 1:12:11to be an American and one of the most important reasons to be proud of being an American and
- 1:12:15one of the most important reasons to love not only your country, but your countrymen, the
- 1:12:19people in it.
- 1:12:21And I would say in conclusion that this fight may not be easy, but it is simple.
- 1:12:26All we really need to do is remember who we are and what our country stands for.
- 1:12:31And if you can do that, everything else is gonna work itself out.
- 1:12:35Well, I think that's a great way to end it right there.
- 1:12:39Regardless of whether you ultimately support voter dollars or not, I think that's a very
- 1:12:46important thing for us all to remember regardless of where our politics lie.
- 1:12:51So that is going to wrap things up for today's episode.
- 1:12:53Thank you, Dan, for being on here, and thank you all so much for listening at home.
- 1:12:58I'll, of course, include the links that he talked about in the show notes for my show
- 1:13:03notes, the my Facebook page, Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn profile, my medium.com
- 1:13:09profile that I write on from time to time, my website, Paul Raider dot org, my email,
- 1:13:14PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com, and also my educational email course, five day educational
- 1:13:20email course on how we can better, more effectively mitigate polarization in this
- 1:13:26country.
- 1:13:28And that's where we're gonna end it off.
- 1:13:30So thank you so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.