Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Leverage a Rejection Into a Better Opportunity
Transcript
- Lucas: So you go through three rounds of interviews, you genuinely click with the team, you walk out thinking, okay, I think I've got this one. And then a day or two later, the email lands in your inbox. Subject line: 'Update on your application.' And it's a no. Luna: That feeling is brutal. And I think a lot of us have been there — that moment where you reread the rejection, wondering if there's something you missed. Lucas: Exactly. And the natural instinct is either to spiral — what did I do wrong, maybe I'm just not good enough — or to fire off a quick 'thank you for your time' and move on. But I actually think there's a smarter third path, and it's one that can turn that rejection into a better opportunity down the line. Luna: I'm intrigued. What's the third path? Lucas: It's a two-step move. First, you ask for specific, actionable feedback. Not just 'can you tell me what I could improve?' — that's too vague. You want to know what, exactly, was the gap. Was it a skill gap, an experience gap, a culture-fit thing? And second — and this is the part most people miss — you ask for a referral, either to another role in the same company or to a colleague at a different company. Luna: Okay, I love the idea of asking for a referral. But let's be real — after a rejection, isn't the hiring manager usually ready to move on? How do you ask for that without seeming pushy? Lucas: Great question. And it comes down to timing and framing. I had a former colleague — let's call her Sarah — who interviewed at Google for a product marketing role. She got rejected, but instead of just accepting it, she sent a very short, very gracious email saying, 'I really appreciated the process. If you have a moment, I'd love to know what skill or experience gap you saw. And if you know anyone who might be hiring for a similar role, I'd be grateful for an introduction.' Luna: And what happened? Lucas: The hiring manager wrote back with a specific piece of feedback: they wanted someone with more B2B SaaS experience — she had mostly consumer tech. But he also said, 'I have a former colleague at Spotify who's building a similar team. I'll make an intro.' She ended up landing at Spotify, in a role that was a better fit, and the salary was fifteen percent higher than what she'd been targeting. Luna: That's a fantastic example. And it shows that sometimes the rejection isn't about you not being good enough — it's about a specific mismatch. And if you can get that information, you can adjust. Lucas: Exactly. The feedback is gold. But here's the thing — you have to ask for it in a way that makes it easy for the hiring manager to say yes. Keep it to one or two sentences. Acknowledge their time. And make it clear you're not arguing the decision, you're just trying to learn. Luna: I think that's a big one — the 'not arguing' part. A lot of people, in their hurt, want to push back or prove the decision wrong. But that's a fast way to burn a bridge. Lucas: Right. And the bridge is valuable. Even if you don't get the job, that hiring manager might be a future colleague, client, or referral source. So treat the rejection like the start of a professional relationship, not the end. Luna: I want to talk about the feedback itself. Sometimes the feedback you get is not very helpful. Like, 'we went with a candidate who had more experience' — that doesn't tell you much. Lucas: It doesn't. And that's where you can ask a follow-up question. Something like, 'I appreciate that. Could you share what specific experience or skill was the deciding factor?' Sometimes you'll get a genuine answer, sometimes you won't. But it's worth trying. Luna: And if they don't give you anything specific, you still have the option to ask for the referral. Because even a generic 'not a fit' can still lead to a warm intro. Lucas: Exactly. And I'd add — don't limit yourself to asking for a referral only at the same company. Ask if they know anyone at other companies who might be hiring. People in similar industries often have networks that overlap. Luna: One thing I've noticed is that some people are hesitant to ask for feedback because they're afraid of hearing something negative about themselves. How do you get past that? Lucas: That's a real fear. But I think you reframe it: the feedback is not a judgment of your worth as a human being. It's data. And data helps you make better decisions. If you know you're weak in B2B SaaS, you can either build that skill or target roles where it's less critical. Luna: I also think there's a timing element. When should you send that follow-up email? How soon after the rejection? Lucas: Within 24 to 48 hours. You want to strike while the interaction is still fresh in their mind, but not so fast that it seems like you dashed it off without thinking. And make sure you thank them for the opportunity first, before asking for anything. Luna: And what about the subject line? If the original email said 'Update on your application,' should you reply to that thread or start fresh? Lucas: I'd reply to the same thread. It keeps the context together. And the subject line stays — you don't need to change it. Just hit reply and write a short message. Luna: Let's talk about the 'ask for a referral' part more. Do you think it's better to ask for a referral to a specific role, or leave it open? Lucas: I'd say leave it open-ended, but with a little direction. Something like, 'If you know of any teams working on product marketing in the consumer space, I'd love an introduction.' That gives them a general area without making them do the work of figuring out what you'd be good at. Luna: That makes sense. And then, if they do make an intro, you should treat that as a serious lead — don't waste it. Lucas: Absolutely. And follow up with the new contact promptly. Thank the introducer. Keep them in the loop. That person has put their reputation on the line for you. Luna: One more scenario — what if you get rejected after a final round, and the feedback is that you were too nervous or didn't seem confident enough? How do you handle that? Lucas: That's tough because it's subjective. But you can still ask for specifics—was it the way you answered a certain question, or your overall demeanor? And then you can practice. Do mock interviews. Record yourself. Work on storytelling. It's fixable. Luna: I think there's also a psychological trick here. When you frame the rejection as an opportunity to learn and connect, you take the sting out of it. You're no longer a passive victim of the process — you're actively shaping the next step. Lucas: That's a really powerful reframe, Luna. And I think it's the core of what we're talking about today. Rejection is not a stop sign — it's a detour. And if you know how to navigate that detour, you often end up somewhere better. Luna: So before we wrap up, let's distill the key moves. One: thank them and ask for specific feedback. Two: ask for a referral — to another role or to someone else in their network. Three: use that feedback to improve your approach. Lucas: And I'll add a fourth: follow up with a handwritten note or a quick email a few weeks later just to stay on their radar. Not asking for anything — just a 'hope you're doing well' check-in. That keeps the relationship warm. Luna: I love that. And you know, something that just occurred to me — if you're listening and you've found this advice useful, it's a reminder that good career guidance is out there, and it's often fueled by people who care about making work better. Lucas: That's a nice thought. And speaking of which, if we've helped you think through a career move or a tough professional moment, know that this show stays ad-free thanks to listeners who support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's not expected, but it's appreciated — and it lets us keep doing deep-dives like this. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to keep the conversation going. And we're grateful for every bit of support. Lucas: So to close: next time a rejection email lands, don't hit delete or reply with a quick 'thanks anyway.' Take a breath, write that thoughtful follow-up, and turn a no into a new door. Luna: And if you have a story of turning a rejection into something better, we'd love to hear it. You can find us on LinkedIn or through the Fexingo website. Lucas: Thanks for being here. We'll see you next time on Office Hours with Fexingo.