Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Forensic Psychology Explained: What Forensic Psychologists Really Do at Crime Scenes & in Court
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Psychology undergrad. Hey everyone.
- 0:03So glad you're starting with us today. Yeah,
- 0:05seriously. Imagine sitting across from a person
- 0:07who has just confessed to a terrible crime. Like
- 0:12they are crying, they're super vulnerable, and
- 0:15they are looking directly to you for help. Oh,
- 0:17man. Right. But instead of offering therapy,
- 0:20your legal job is to literally take the transcript
- 0:23of that confession and hand it directly to the
- 0:26judge so it can be used against them. Which is
- 0:28just wild. It's an absolute ethical nightmare.
- 0:31But that is just, you know, a typical Tuesday
- 0:34in the life of a forensic psychologist. It's
- 0:36definitely not what you see on TV. Exactly. And
- 0:39since the three of us are taking this forensic
- 0:40psychology course together, we figured the best
- 0:43way to prep for the upcoming exam is to just
- 0:45hash out chapter one of our textbook together.
- 0:47The Canadian perspective one, right? Yeah, that's
- 0:49the one. And we're bringing you along as our
- 0:51third study buddy for this deep dive. Because
- 0:54honestly, staring at a textbook for hours is
- 0:57a guaranteed way to just completely zone out.
- 1:01Oh, 100%. I fall asleep every time. Right. talking
- 1:04through the concepts, like actually pulling them
- 1:05apart and figuring out how they operate in the
- 1:07real world. That is how the material actually
- 1:10sticks in your brain. Yeah. Active recall. Exactly.
- 1:13And this first chapter is crucial because it
- 1:15builds the entire foundation for everything else
- 1:18we're going to encounter this semester. Like,
- 1:20if we don't understand the fundamental friction
- 1:22between the science lab and the courtroom, the
- 1:25rest of the course just won't make any sense.
- 1:27No. It really won't. So for our mission today,
- 1:30we're doing a deep dive into the source material
- 1:32to figure out what forensic psychology actually
- 1:35is. We are going uncover its unexpectedly dramatic
- 1:39history, break down the specific and often conflicting
- 1:43roles psychologists play, and examine what is
- 1:46ultimately a massive culture clash. The ultimate
- 1:49culture clash. Yeah, between the scientific method
- 1:51and the justice system. Okay, let's unpack this,
- 1:54starting with the biggest headache of all, which
- 1:56is literally just defining the field. Defining
- 1:58forensic psychology sounds like it should take,
- 2:00I don't know, one sentence. But it is notoriously
- 2:03messy. So messy. The field basically straddles
- 2:07civil and criminal justice while simultaneously
- 2:10trying to bridge two completely different worlds
- 2:12within psychology itself. The clinical side and
- 2:15the experimental side. Exactly. And there was
- 2:17this address by a professor, Jack Brigham, and
- 2:20he highlighted this beautifully. He pointed out
- 2:23that the public perception of the field has a
- 2:25very clinical flavor to it. Oh, yeah. thanks
- 2:28to movies and, like, true crime shows. Right.
- 2:31People immediately picture criminal profiling
- 2:33or a psychiatrist evaluating a serial killer's
- 2:36sanity in some dimly lit room. But the reality
- 2:38is much broader and frankly a lot more academic
- 2:42than that. The broad definition technically encompasses
- 2:45social, cognitive, and developmental psychology.
- 2:48It's huge. It really is. Basically, any psychologist
- 2:52who applies their research to the legal system
- 2:54is technically a forensic psychologist. Right.
- 2:58So like a cognitive psychologist studying how
- 2:59the human brain encodes memories of a car crash,
- 3:03they are doing forensic psychology, which is
- 3:05a relatively modern consensus, by the way, because
- 3:08the history of how those cognitive and experimental
- 3:11psychologists first fought their way into the
- 3:14courtroom is, well, it's anything but smooth.
- 3:17Honestly, that is my favorite part of this chapter.
- 3:20Yeah. The origins of the field feel less like
- 3:23a dignified scientific progression and more like
- 3:26an early 20th century academic rap battle. It
- 3:29really does. It all kicks off with this guy,
- 3:31Hugo Munsterberg. He was the director of Harvard
- 3:34Psychological Laboratory. And he published a
- 3:37book called On the Witness Stand. Oh, yeah, the
- 3:40infamous book. Right. And he didn't just propose
- 3:42that psychology could help the law. He basically
- 3:44came out swinging. He was incredibly aggressive
- 3:47about it. Munsterberg essentially called the
- 3:49courts blind and ignorant for relying on, you
- 3:51know, common sense instead of experimental psychology
- 3:54to evaluate things like witness reliability or
- 3:57false confessions. He was not holding back. Not
- 4:00at all. He genuinely believed his laboratory
- 4:02instruments were far superior to a judge's intuition.
- 4:06And you can imagine how well that landed with
- 4:08a bunch of elite legal scholars back then. Oh,
- 4:11they must have been furious. They were. It triggered
- 4:14this immediate, highly theatrical backlash. And
- 4:17the most famous response came from John Wigmore.
- 4:19Right, the legal titan. Yeah, a massive figure
- 4:21in legal scholarship. Wigmore published this
- 4:24satirical article in a law review journal. He
- 4:27literally staged a mock lawsuit on paper, putting
- 4:31Munsterberg on trial for libeling the legal profession.
- 4:34That is so petty and I love it. It's amazing.
- 4:37Wigmore cross -examined Munsterberg's book line
- 4:40by line, mocking his arrogance and ultimately
- 4:43finding him guilty of like... exaggerating what
- 4:46his psychological data could actually deliver
- 4:48to a courtroom. What's fascinating here is Wigmore's
- 4:51underlying contradiction. Oh, what do you mean?
- 4:53Well, he absolutely demolished Munsterberg's
- 4:56ego in that satirical piece, right? But buried
- 4:59beneath all the mockery, Wigmore admitted a profound
- 5:02truth. He admitted that the courts would eventually
- 5:04need to use psychology. Wow, really? Yeah, he
- 5:06just recognized that the science at that time
- 5:08wasn't mature enough yet. The crucial distinction
- 5:12for our exam notes here is the difference between
- 5:14witness reliability and verdict reliability.
- 5:17Okay, wait, break that down for me. So, Munsterburg
- 5:19had laboratory data suggesting a witness might
- 5:22misremember a detail, right? That's witness reliability.
- 5:25Right. But the legal system doesn't just need
- 5:28to know if a human memory is fallible. It needs
- 5:31to know if the final judgment, the verdict, is
- 5:34fundamentally sound. Ah, I see. Yeah. Munsterburg's
- 5:37data couldn't answer the law's ultimate need
- 5:39for finality. So Wigmore effectively slammed
- 5:43the front door of the courtroom in psychology's
- 5:46face, telling the scientists to come back when
- 5:48they grew up. Pretty much. But psychology didn't
- 5:50just wait around. If the front door was locked
- 5:52to expert testimony, they found a way to sneak
- 5:55in through the back door. Using paper. Exactly.
- 5:58Using paper. We are talking about the Brandeis
- 6:00brief. Yes. This is a brilliant legal maneuver
- 6:03that completely changed how social science influences
- 6:06the law. It originated in the same era. Musterberg
- 6:09was yelling at everyone in a U .S. case called
- 6:12Muller v. Oregon. Louis Brandeis, who was a lawyer
- 6:15and later became a Supreme Court justice, he
- 6:18needed a way. to show the court the real -world
- 6:21impact of a law. So instead of calling a scientist
- 6:23to the witness stand to be aggressively cross
- 6:26-examined, he submitted a massive document compiling
- 6:29social science research, medical reports, and
- 6:31empirical data. Because a Brandeis brief is documentary.
- 6:35unsworn evidence. Its entire purpose is to demonstrate
- 6:39the social context of a law. It allows the court
- 6:42to look past abstract legal theory and see the
- 6:46tangible psychological reality of a policy. The
- 6:49Canadian example in our textbook is the perfect
- 6:52illustration of this. especially regarding how
- 6:54the law handles religion and morality. Oh, the
- 6:57polygamy case. Yeah. Think about the constitutional
- 6:59evaluation of Canada's polygamy laws. Yeah. There
- 7:02was a community in bountiful British Columbia
- 7:04that was practicing polygamy for religious reasons.
- 7:07Right. And the law criminalizing it was super
- 7:09old. Exactly. Written way back in the 19th century.
- 7:12Its original foundation was entirely moral. It
- 7:15was designed to prevent harms to women, children,
- 7:18and the Victorian institution of monogamous marriage.
- 7:20But Canada evaluates its constitution under the
- 7:23living tree doctrine. Right, right. Meaning laws
- 7:26have to be interpreted within their current social
- 7:29context, not just frozen in the moral panic of
- 7:32the past. Yeah. So when the court looked at it
- 7:35recently, they couldn't just rely on an old moral
- 7:37assumption. They had to ask does this practice
- 7:41still cause empirical harm today? And to answer
- 7:43that, Chief Justice Bauman relied on a colossal
- 7:47Brandeis brief. He brought in contemporary developmental
- 7:50psychologists, sociologists, and economists.
- 7:54So he needed the social science to prove or disprove
- 7:56the moral assumption. Exactly. And based on the
- 8:00overwhelming empirical data in that brief, he
- 8:02found that the harms to children and women were
- 8:04still very real, so the law remained valid. So
- 8:08for your notes, think of a Brandeis brief as
- 8:10the court's reality check. I like that. Whenever
- 8:12the law makes a grand moral assumption about
- 8:14human behavior, the Brandeis brief is the social
- 8:17scientist showing up with the scientific receipts.
- 8:19The ultimate historical demonstration of that
- 8:22reality check is Brown v. Board of Education.
- 8:24Oh, absolutely. The Supreme Court had to decide
- 8:27if segregating schools by race was inherently
- 8:29unequal. The legal arguments were stalling. So
- 8:32psychologists like Kenneth Clark drafted a social
- 8:35science brief proving the devastating psychological
- 8:38harm that segregation inflicted on African -American
- 8:41children. The Dahl study. Right. Exactly. The
- 8:44court cited that research in a famous footnote,
- 8:46which outlawed segregation. It proved that you
- 8:50can fundamentally alter civil rights by forcing
- 8:53the court to confront the psychological consequences
- 8:55of its policies. That's incredibly powerful.
- 8:58OK, so we see how the science permeates this
- 9:00system through paper. But who is physically navigating
- 9:04this system today? Like, the field has exploded
- 9:07since Munsterberg's time. Oh, definitely. To
- 9:10prep for the exam, I built a little mnemonic
- 9:12framework to remember the seven different roles
- 9:15or hats that a forensic psychologist can wear.
- 9:18Let's hear it. OK, so we can group them into
- 9:20three buckets. The courtroom crew, the helpers,
- 9:23and the ivory tower. That structure actually
- 9:25works perfectly. Let's look at the courtroom
- 9:27crew first. These are the practitioners directly
- 9:29embedded in the litigation process. Right. So
- 9:32you have the trial consultant, the expert witness,
- 9:34and the evaluator. The trial consultant acts
- 9:36almost like a strategist, using psychological
- 9:39principles to help lawyers with jury selection
- 9:42or like witness preparation. Then the expert
- 9:45witness takes the stand to explain complex specialized
- 9:48knowledge. to a judge or jury. Right. And the
- 9:51evaluator is the one conducting direct assessments
- 9:54of a defendant like determining if they are competent
- 9:57to stand trial or evaluating their risk of future
- 10:00dangerousness. Okay. So moving to the second
- 10:02bucket, the helpers. This includes the treatment
- 10:06provider and the correctional psychologist. Okay.
- 10:08Got it. The treatment provider focuses on therapeutic
- 10:10intervention. They might be hired to... restore
- 10:15a defendant's competency so a trial can actually
- 10:17proceed, or to provide therapy to a victim in
- 10:20a civil trauma case. The correctional psychologist
- 10:23operates within the walls of a jail or prison,
- 10:25often juggling both evaluation and treatment
- 10:27of inmates. Well, that sounds exhausting. Finally,
- 10:30we have the ivory tower bucket. Right, the academics.
- 10:33Exactly. That comprises the researcher and the
- 10:36academic. These are the people designing the
- 10:39empirical studies, crunching the data, teaching
- 10:42the next generation. They literally generate
- 10:44the science that the Brandeis briefs and the
- 10:47expert witnesses rely on. But memorizing the
- 10:50land is the easy part. The exam will definitely
- 10:52focus on the immense cognitive dissonance required
- 10:55to wear these hats. Oh, for sure. Because a psychologist
- 10:58rarely wears just one hat. And shifting from
- 11:01a helper mindset to a courtroom crew mindset
- 11:04creates an absolute ethical minefield, particularly
- 11:08regarding confidentiality. The clash between
- 11:10confidentiality and court reporting is staggering.
- 11:13When we think of a psychologist, we are culturally
- 11:15conditioned to picture total confidentiality,
- 11:18right? Oh, yeah. The therapist's couch is a safe
- 11:20space. Exactly. But stepping into the role of
- 11:24an evaluator strips all that away. Like we said
- 11:26at the start, it's like a priest's confessional,
- 11:29except the priest is legally obligated to hand
- 11:31the transcript of your confession directly to
- 11:34the judge prosecuting you. Which is terrifying.
- 11:36And this raises an important question. Who is
- 11:38the actual client? In a clinical setting, the
- 11:40client is obviously the patient. But in a forensic
- 11:44evaluation, say, determining fitness to stand
- 11:47trial, the client is the court. The moral friction
- 11:51that creates is so intense. Just imagine you
- 11:53were the evaluator. The defense attorney hires
- 11:56you, hoping you're going to find mitigating psychological
- 11:59factors to keep their client out of prison. Yeah,
- 12:02they want you to help their case. Right. But
- 12:04During your interviews, you uncover a history
- 12:07of severe unrecorded violence. Oh, no. Your data
- 12:11shows this person is a massive risk to reoffend.
- 12:15As a clinical therapist, your instinct is to
- 12:17help the patient. But as a forensic evaluator,
- 12:20your duty of neutrality dictates you cannot hide
- 12:22that data just because the defense has signed
- 12:25your paycheck. Wow. You must include it in your
- 12:28report to the court, even if it completely destroys
- 12:30the defendant's life. That means the informed
- 12:32consent process flips upside down. Literally.
- 12:35The psychologist has to look the subject in the
- 12:37eye before they start and explicitly state, I
- 12:39am not your doctor, I am not here to help you,
- 12:42and absolutely nothing you tell me is a secret.
- 12:44That is so jarring. The fundamental therapeutic
- 12:47dynamic is erased. The psychologist's ethical
- 12:50obligation is entirely to the truth and the legal
- 12:53process. Given that ethical whiplash, it's really
- 12:57no surprise that psychologists and lawyers frequently
- 12:59drive each other crazy. Oh, kidding. They aren't
- 13:01just doing different jobs. They're operating
- 13:03on completely divergent logical wavelengths.
- 13:06And that brings us to Craig Haney's taxonomy
- 13:09of differences. He mapped out exactly why the
- 13:12science lab and the courtroom are destined to
- 13:14clash. Yeah, Haney identified several core philosophical
- 13:17divides. Let's tackle the distinction between
- 13:20the nomothetic nature of psychology and the ideographic
- 13:23nature of the law. Okay, we definitely need concrete
- 13:26definitions for those terms. Right. So no methodic
- 13:29refers to studying large groups to uncover general
- 13:32overarching principles. Okay. Psychology is obsessed
- 13:35with the aggregate. We study a thousand people
- 13:37to find an average behavioral trend. The law,
- 13:40however, is idigraphic. Meaning individual. Yes.
- 13:43It does not care about the aggregate at all.
- 13:45It only cares about the single specific individual
- 13:48sitting in the defendant's chair. The courtroom
- 13:50application of that is wild. Like imagine a cognitive
- 13:53psychologist takes a stand and testifies. My
- 13:57research shows that 60 % of eyewitnesses will
- 14:00falsely identify a suspect under these specific
- 14:03lighting conditions. And the lawyer steps up
- 14:06for cross -examination and says Fascinating.
- 14:09But was this specific witness wrong on the night
- 14:11of the crime? And the psychologist is forced
- 14:13to admit they have no idea. Exactly. The nomothetic
- 14:17group data cannot diagnose the enneographic individual.
- 14:20Haney also pointed out that psychology is descriptive,
- 14:23whereas the law is prescriptive. Right. Psychology
- 14:26attempts to describe how human beings actually
- 14:28behave in the real world, including all our cognitive
- 14:31flaws and biases. We're a messy. Very. But the
- 14:34law dictates how humans should behave. The legal
- 14:37system creates an idealized standard of conduct
- 14:39and punishes individuals who fall short, regardless
- 14:42of whether that standard is psychologically realistic
- 14:45for the average human brain. Okay, but here's
- 14:47where it gets really interesting, because the
- 14:49authors of our textbook actually push back against
- 14:52Haney on one of his most famous points. Wait,
- 14:54they do. Yeah. So Haney argues that the law demands
- 14:58absolute certainty, while psychology is merely
- 15:01probabilistic. Right. That makes sense. He claims
- 15:04the legal system needs a binary black and white
- 15:06outcome like guilty or not guilty, while psychologists
- 15:10only speak in probabilities, statistical significance,
- 15:14and p -values. Hold on. Haney's entire thesis
- 15:17is built on the law demanding that binary outcome.
- 15:21The gavel falls and the case is closed. How do
- 15:24you square that with probability? Because the
- 15:26mechanism driving the gavel is probabilistic.
- 15:29Oh, I see where you're going. Right. Think about
- 15:30the legal burdens of proof. In a criminal trial,
- 15:34the standard to convict is beyond a reasonable
- 15:36doubt. In a civil trial, it's on a balance of
- 15:39probabilities. OK, yeah. What are those phrases,
- 15:42if not statistical thresholds? Beyond a reasonable
- 15:45doubt doesn't mean absolute 100 % mathematical
- 15:47certainty. It means the probability of guilt
- 15:50is so overwhelmingly high. say 99%, that a reasonable
- 15:54person wouldn't doubt it. Right. And balance
- 15:57of probabilities literally just means 51 % likely.
- 16:00The law, I says probabilistic, just uses words
- 16:04instead of numbers. Once that statistical threshold
- 16:07is met, the system slaps a binary guilty label
- 16:10on it so it can function, but the engine underneath
- 16:12is entirely built on probability. OK, I see the
- 16:15textbook's point. The law relies on a sliding
- 16:18scale of likelihood before it makes its absolute
- 16:20declarations. Exactly. The authors also dismantle
- 16:23Haney's claim that psychology is a creative endeavor
- 16:26while the law is purely conservative and bound
- 16:28by rigid precedent. Oh right, because lawyers
- 16:31are actually super creative. Yeah, legal history
- 16:33is full of lawyers taking ancient precedents
- 16:35and creatively twisting them to solve entirely
- 16:37unprecedented modern social problems. So knowing
- 16:41they have all these fundamental differences,
- 16:42we need to know how to categorize their daily
- 16:44interactions. and I have another study hack for
- 16:47you for the exam. Nice. Lay it on us. To master
- 16:50Hayes' taxonomy of relationships between the
- 16:52two fields, you just need to memorize three prepositions.
- 16:55I, A, N, D, O, S. OK. Psychology and the law,
- 17:00psychology and the law, and psychology of law.
- 17:03Let's define the boundaries of each. So psychology
- 17:06and the law is the most common but also the most
- 17:08passive relationship. The law sets the rules.
- 17:11builds the playground and psychology just plays
- 17:14along within those boundaries. Give me an example.
- 17:17If a judge orders a psychological evaluation
- 17:19for competency, the psychologist is doing psychology
- 17:23in the law. The legal system defines what the
- 17:26word competency actually means. the legal system
- 17:29asks a specific question, and the psychologist
- 17:32merely provides the answer the system demands.
- 17:34Got it. Now, psychology -Andy law shifts the
- 17:38power dynamic. In this relationship, the two
- 17:40disciplines operate as co -equals. Okay. Psychology
- 17:44actively challenges the legal system's assumptions
- 17:46and forces it to change its procedures. Like
- 17:49the eyewitness memory stuff. Exactly. The ultimate
- 17:51example of the Andy relationship is the reform
- 17:54of eyewitness memory procedures. Yeah. Psychologists
- 17:56didn't just sit in the court evaluating individual
- 17:59witnesses. Right, they zoomed out. Yeah, they
- 18:01researched how police light -ups were fundamentally
- 18:03flawed and were actively causing false identifications.
- 18:07They took that data, challenged the justice system,
- 18:10and forced police departments to rewrite their
- 18:12protocols for showing photo spreads to suspects.
- 18:15That is psychology actively reshaping the law.
- 18:18It's incredible. Finally, there is psychology
- 18:20of law. This is the most philosophical category.
- 18:24This involves studying the law itself as a manifestation
- 18:27of human behavior. Oh, like asking the macro
- 18:29question. Exactly. Why do humans feel a psychological
- 18:33need to create laws in the first place? Why do
- 18:36we obey them? Like do we follow the speed limit
- 18:39because we genuinely believe in the moral authority
- 18:41of the government or simply because we fear the
- 18:44punishment of getting a speeding ticket? If we
- 18:46connect this to the bigger picture, Haney emphasizes
- 18:49a harsh reality for anyone entering this profession,
- 18:52which is the vast majority of the jobs and the
- 18:54funding are locked in that first category, psychology
- 18:57in the law. That is the daily grind of doing
- 19:00evaluations and testifying within the system's
- 19:03existing rules. But the greatest potential to
- 19:06actually improve society. That exists in the
- 19:10A and D and the O or F categories. Because that
- 19:13is where you fix broken systems rather than just
- 19:15participating in them. Exactly. Which is exactly
- 19:18why the field is pushing for people who intimately
- 19:20understand both languages. The textbook ends
- 19:24the chapter by highlighting the rise of JD slash
- 19:27PhD joint programs where students graduate with
- 19:30both a law degree and a doctorate in psychology.
- 19:33Which is a ton of school. So much school. But
- 19:35Professor Don Versoff, who founded one of the
- 19:37first joint programs, had a brilliant way of
- 19:40describing these graduates. He called them translators.
- 19:42Because science and law operate as two divergent
- 19:46cultures, right? They are completely walled off
- 19:48by their own impenetrable jargon. The jargon
- 19:50is the worst. Lawyers generally do not understand
- 19:53multivariate analysis or type 2 errors like the
- 19:56statistical risk of letting a false hypothesis
- 19:59slide and failing to recognize a real psychological
- 20:01effect. Right. Psychologists, on the other hand,
- 20:04rarely grasp the rigid legal nuances of due process
- 20:07or equal protection under the Constitution. but
- 20:10the joint graduate acts as the bilingual translator,
- 20:15standing right in the middle of the courtroom.
- 20:17They ensure the judge doesn't mangle the scientific
- 20:19data, and they ensure the scientist respects
- 20:22the procedural rights of the defendant. They
- 20:25stop the two sides from just talking past each
- 20:28other. Exactly. So what does this all mean for
- 20:30you, our study buddy? Whether you are prepping
- 20:33for our psych exam next week, or you are simply
- 20:36trying to be a more informed citizen the next
- 20:37time you watch the news, understanding this culture
- 20:40clash is vital. It really is. Every time you
- 20:43see a headline about a controversial Supreme
- 20:45Court decision or a debate over criminal justice
- 20:48reform, you are watching this exact collision.
- 20:51You are watching a rigid system trying to prescribe
- 20:54how humans should act, struggling to adapt to
- 20:57the scientific reality of how humans actually
- 20:59act. And as we close the textbook on Chapter
- 21:011, I want to leave you with a final thought to
- 21:03mull over before the test. Ooh, let's hear it.
- 21:06If the law is simply a society's codified morality
- 21:09and psychology is the objective empirical study
- 21:13of human behavior, is the entire field of forensic
- 21:16psychology ultimately just the scientific measurement
- 21:19of our moral failings? Think about that before
- 21:21your next exam. That is heavy. Well, happy studying,
- 21:24everyone. We will see you at the next session.
- 21:26Keep thinking critically. Good luck.