Latest / The Fast Breakdown / The WNBA's Caitlin Clark Dilemma
Transcript
- Medha Sunkara: Hi, my name is Medha Sunkara. Ria Abraham: So our first topic is going to be all-star snubs. So one of the big ones I think that I was noticing was Alyssa Thomas, you know, like she was in consideration for MVP last year. And this year she can't even make the all-star team. Like we discussed why she wasn't on our list, was because Mercury were doing so bad, but we had her as a reserve. And it's just crazy to me that she didn't even make the list. I was looking at the voting and she was so low. So it's just this overall culture around Caitlin Clark that has caused a lot of these problems and even brought random people, like literally random people, into situations that didn't concern themselves. And that's why we have so many people talking out about these things, because it's just it's just not the right place for the league to go. And it's I think it's problematic to call her the face of the league when so many of the people who consider her to be that. Another player that I was voting for was Shakira Austin. I think she's been doing great. I know she at the beginning of the season had side with the tempo and then the Mystics matched her offer, but I think that was a great decision from them to keep keep Shakira Austin as one of their I guess she's not really a vet, but on that team she kind of is. Shakira Austin and Michaela Onyenwere has been have been playing really good. And I think Shakira Austin deserved the all star nod, but I guess And my name is Ria Abraham. Medha Sunkara: And you're watching the fast breakdown. Ria Abraham: So this message was sent directly to the commissioner, Cathy Engelbert, by several Republican lawmakers, and we're not necessarily sure that we agree with what's been said in this letter. Medha? So talking about that same topic, Geno Auriemma, who is the UConn women's basketball coach who recently coached Paige Bueckers and Azzi Fudd, spoke on the same Caitlin Clark issue and had a very different opinion on the fouls that have been called against her. Your weekly women's hoops coverage. Today we'll be discussing all-star snubs as well as recent events regarding Caitlin Clark. Medha Sunkara: Yeah, this is definitely the weirdest thing I've seen in a while. So these lawmakers write this letter, they say Clark's been manhandled and poked in the eye, this, that, that's the violence. Like ⁓ Cathy, do something about this. Like, I don't it's just so absurd. Yeah, so he kind of just goes, These are fouls and she gets fouled hard, you know, it's like I think she is a target more than other players. But this isn't a race thing that has nothing to do with civil rights. This isn't a referendum on America. Like, guys, calm down, like these are just flagrant fouls, these are normal fouls, like this is what basketball is. And he he basically goes on to say there are other white players in the league that aren't really facing this same fouling problem. So like everyone's trying to turn this into a race issue, but it has nothing to do with that. Ria Abraham: it I think it would be between her and Kiki for the spot and Kiki definitely has a lot more fans and would definitely have gotten the fan vote. So that's kind of why I'm thinking that played out the way it did. Medha Sunkara: It's honestly insane to see that Alyssa Thomas wasn't voted because she's leading the league in assists. She has been a pillar for the Mercury, even though they're not doing so well. Like maybe All-Star or Starter wasn't warranted but definitely reserve. Like there are people that got All-Star that I would argue were not as good as her. And she definitely should have gone. And same Kahleah Copper. Like Kahleah Copper was or has been doing really good, you know, after her slow start. Ria Abraham: are so antagonistic towards the rest of the league. I I thought it was a little crazy that they called it like racially motivated. Caitlin Clark is not the only white person in the I I don't know that I should have to say that, but I definitely I mean, there have been flagrants against her there have been flagrants against a lot of people. It's definitely not something we condone or that should be happening, but it is something that happened and I don't think I mean I don't think people were intentionally like punching her Medha Sunkara: And then on the starter side, so I propose a trade here. And I don't know if everyone's gonna agree with me on this trade. So combine Allisha Gray and Rhyne Howard, send them in for Kelsey Mitchell. Because while I do think Kelsey Mitchell deserved all star, no doubt, I don't think she deserved that start that spark what am I saying? That starter spot over Rhyne Howard and Allisha Gray. Because Rhyne Howard has been leading the League and Steels. Ria Abraham: So is that it? Okay, very cool. Okay. Thank you for watching this week's episode of the Fast Breakdown. If you want to see us break down more topics, check us out on Spotify, TikTok, YouTube, and wherever you listen to your podcasts. Thank you for tuning in. Like and subscribe. Medha Sunkara: Yeah, that's... Ria Abraham: He does acknowledge that people might have animosity towards her and there could be something behind that. Obviously we don't have any proof that anyone is intentionally going after anyone like that, but it's just it's not a race thing, it's not a lawmaker thing, it's just fouling in a physical league, which has been happening forever. Medha Sunkara: shooting league low percentages with by which by the way, Jackie Young was also doing really bad at the beginning of the season and because she Ria Abraham: Like this is something that has happened in a lot of games where unfortunately when you're playing a physical sport, people will make contact. That's why we have fouls, that's why we have referees. And that's why that play was reviewed. And obviously they made a decision. So I wouldn't I feel like this was a little extra. I didn't think it was necessary in any way, shape, or form. And I thought it was a little insane the way they worded some things here. I was surprised by that. Jackie Young is definitely a super talented player, but I wasn't sure that I would call her season so far an all-star level season. She's definitely been struggling a lot. She's had like some like zero-point games. I know she was going through a lot at the time, but I just didn't feel like her. feel like her and Kahleah Copper have been very similar this season, and I was confused as to why one of was so high in the voting and one of them didn't make it at all. Medha Sunkara: She's been doing great offensively. I think their like five, six game slide has kind of hurt them a little bit. And I think if you combined Allisha Gray and Rhyne Howard into one player, they would have definitely been Yeah, this Caitlin Clark problem honestly might be going on till the end of Caitlin Clark's tenure in the league because everything she does, every action against her gets turned into a big piece. And that's actually how Sophie Cunningham got famous. You know, she ⁓ kind of exploited the fact that she was fighting this Caitlin Clark problem honestly might be going on till the end of Caitlin Clark's tenure in the league because ⁓ she does, every action against her gets turned into a big piece. And that's actually how Sophie Cunningham got famous. You know, she ⁓ kind of exploited the fact that she was fighting Ria Abraham: think any one of them have been playing better than and I d I don't know how I feel about Kelsey Mitchell and Caitlin Clark being on the all star team. I feel like one of them enough. I feel like like if we're talking about injuries and Caitlin Clark hasn't played like a bunch of games and she's gonna miss in the future as well. And sh I feel like you know I everyone's been talking about her volume shooting, right? It's like yes she gets a lot of points, but on how many attempts and Kelsey Mitchell I think has she's been playing well but not Medha Sunkara: Yeah, especially with the recency bias and the fact that Kahleah Copper has been averaging like twenty seven points per game last ten games. Like I definitely feel that her or Alyssa Thomas or both should have gone all star. And I know that it's kind of hard to give it to a team that are lower in the rankings and lower in the standings, but like they deserved it. Like you have some people on this list that I don't know if I fully agree with, like Courtney Williams, I don't know if I agree with that one. Ria Abraham: It's just insane when Sophie Cunningham faced so much positive had such a positive reaction when she attacked Jacy Sheldon and Alyssa Thomas in a basketball play is receiving death threats and so much hate over something that was not intentional. It's just insane when Sophie Cunningham faced so much positive had such a positive reaction when she attacked Jacy Sheldon and Alyssa Thomas in a basketball play is receiving death threats and so much hate over something that was not intentional. Medha Sunkara: Right. And something interesting that me and Ria were actually talking about earlier was that they mentioned in this ⁓ there's a social media post that was threatening Caitlin Clark. That was that was Tip Hayes like ⁓ saying some like, I don't know, she was saying some bullshit, but she wasn't being for real. Like they're they're saying these this like it's for real. Like like I think ⁓ Ria Abraham: as well as she was last season. Obviously when you were sharing the ball with another card, it's not gonna be the same kind of ⁓ points. But she's it's not the same level we saw. So I again I don't know how I feel about her getting starter. Medha Sunkara: Yeah, it's just insane. She's like, she's gotten over a million Instagram followers. Her podcast is doing amazing. Like I can't believe it. It's like it's the complete like split side and the fans and the media and everything. And this is the Caitlin Clark dilemma. Like, this is the problem. Like Caitlin Clark herself is not a bad person. Like, she's great. She doesn't do anything wrong, but her fans are a problem. Like they turn everything to a race thing. Everything that happens to her, the person on the other side gets attacked. Like Ria Abraham: Okay, okay. I do okay, so ⁓ when All Star voting was happening, I did vote for Courtney Williams several times and I did think she deserved it then. I don't know that she's been playing at the same caliber still, ⁓ but I definitely think she had a lot of really great games, but a lot of those really great games were Medha Sunkara: At the end of the day, this is the culture that's been going on in the WNBA for like a long time. Like it's a physical, physical league. Like everyone gets flagrantly fouled at some point. Like it's like Did we see what happened in the WNBA finals last year or semifinals? Like it's it's been going on. It's not just a Caitlin Clark problem. And the fact that all these Republican like lawmakers come together and they they're like, this has been happening to Caitlin Clark, protect her, like this and that. Yeah, I think Kelsey Mitchell is definitely a little questionable. And then Rhyne Howard and Allisha Gray getting reserve. I mean, I think at least one of them should have made starter. And you know how Angel Reese kinda said the whole thing to the media where where like, ⁓ one of them should have definitely got starter. Like I completely a hundred percent agree with her. Like, ⁓ Rhyne Howard, day you'll get your revenge. So ⁓ just saying, I I love Rhyne Howard and I think that she'll definitely get a lot of starters again in the future and Ria Abraham: because of Olivia Miles. But I wouldn't argue that Natasha Howard's really good games are also because of Olivia Miles. So I don't know that Courtney by herself is that all star level, like you said, but I she definitely was playing pretty well like with the pieces on her team, which is what everyone's doing, right? Medha Sunkara: There is no way to win here. Ria Abraham: It's just difficult to discuss Caitlin Clark or support her without considering the implications of what sh it's it's hard to say she has caused because she hasn't she did speak about against this specific incident where Alyssa Thomas was receiving hate messages, but this is not a one-off occurrence and this has happened a lot. Medha Sunkara: Yeah, I think with the links, ⁓ it's kinda hard to not give them three all star people because they've been doing so good without like their main player in Phee But Like it it just comes off so weird 'cause she's like she's white and they're doing this 'cause she's white. Like I I don't understand. This year was kind of a steal, but she'll get it eventually. Ria Abraham: They're making it hidden. They're saying we think she's being racially like and it's I it's just a crazy way to say all of this. Yes, there have been issues with physicality in the league. That's why they're going a little strict with the ⁓ the referees are going a little stricter this year. They've had some new ⁓ new gu guidelines on what is a foul. So that was our All-Star Snub section. And next we're gonna be talking about the letter that was recently sent to Cathy Engelbert by Republican lawmakers concerning Caitlin Clark. Medha Sunkara: Alters this year just seemed a little strange to me. Like I I looked at the list, I was like, someone's missing here. And you have Brittany Sykes, who averaged like twenty-two points per game before she was injured. Ria Abraham: And she rarely speaks out about it. And it it when you don't speak out against things like this, it feels like permission. And it feels like I'm okay with people who say those things supporting me. I'm okay with those people being in the seats It's not even It's like we were discussing like her injuries kept her out recently, but so is Kelsey Plums and I would argue both of these people deserve to be on the all-star list. But it's like when injuries are playing into are factoring in, one of them makes it, one of them doesn't. It just kind of sucks, you know? And then talking about how so we're talking about how the Lynx had three players, the Aces had two players, the Valkyries, number three in the standings, they only had one player in Gabby Williams. And I would argue that Veronica Burton And that's all being done to protect all the players because it's an issue that was hurting a lot of players. But it's just crazy to say this is all just happening to one person. It's happening to one white person, the one white person who is the best player in the lake, the face of your it's just all around icky wording. It's just an all-around uncomfortable situation. And I don't know why they felt the need to do this. has should also have been an all-star. What do think? Medha Sunkara: Yeah, Veronica Burton had been playing really good in May. I think she slowed down a little bit in June because she had like a quad injury and she wasn't playing that great. But when she's off the floor for the Valkyries, you can see the difference. Like when on and off, I'm sure those numbers are insane. But like she's kind of that poise the Valkyries needs. When she's on there, she orchestrates the offense. And I she hasn't been doing that well, like within like scoring, but she's still generating a lot of assists. She's still And I think to it this all kind of comes back to that flagrant foul that ⁓ Alyssa Thomas committed on Caitlin Clark. And at the end of the day, was that a flagrant foul? Yes. But also was that just basketball? Also, yes. Like you if you watch that video and you don't watch it in that like really speed that everyone's been showing it at. Keeping this Vacros team together. Cause you I feel like the Gabby Williams, Veronica Burton combination is extremely good defensively as well, not just offensively. So overall, yeah, I think she's a pretty big snub just because the backers have been doing so good and to only have one all-star on that team is insane because they might end up being first in the standings after this week. Like, who knows? She accidentally went like this. Like it wasn't malicious. And the fact that this has been overblown to this proportion is insane. All these conversations are happening. Caitlin Clark herself has come out and said this was a flagrant foul, but that is basketball. And I I don't want any other conversations surrounding this to happen. And she hasn't addressed this letter either, probably for the same exact reason, because holy, this is this is not what Alyssa Thomas was trying to do. And of these players are trying to do that intentionally to Caitlin Clark. And Ria Abraham: hoping And then did you have any other all-star snaps? Medha Sunkara: I think for me, one all-star, I know the fire aren't doing that good, but Carla Late, please. Carla Late has been playing really good. So from going from, I think, unprotected by the Dallas Wings, she ⁓ she gets stolen by the Valkyries, she has a decent season with the Valkyries, and then she gets picked up by the fire, she was unprotected again. And ⁓ my god, she is leading that franchise. I think if you saw her in the 4 OT game, she was insane. The fact that all these people are like infantilizing her and going like, everyone steps out on that court and as soon as they play the fever, like they are blah blah blah blah blah. Like that's just insane to me. And the fact that congressmen have now gotten involved calling this like a violation of civil rights, it's just just too much. Ria Abraham: It's just overall an upsetting response and yeah, it's pretty disappointing to see people come out and say things and twist situations like this and use power that could be used for good in strange ways to protect certain groups of people. Medha Sunkara: ⁓ she's really good in the pick and roll. I think she's I don't know how many assists she's averaging, but it must be like a lot 'cause I I always see her like orchestrating everything on the floor for. Ria Abraham: Feels like she's part of everything that happens on the court, the scoring, everything it feels like she is leading that team. And I guess we saw we saw one expansion All Star in Marina Mabry, I would argue we should have seen two from the tempo. And the Flyer definitely I would I think we would both argue that Carla Lay is our best player and has been having an all star season, even though the Fire have been struggling lately. But sometimes she's the only one doing stuff. Medha Sunkara: I mean, these congressmen have better things to do. Like, there are so many other issues right now in the US, and we're choosing to zero in on this not even it's not even like really an issue. Like, sure, physicality is a problem in the league. But the fact that they zero in on this white woman and they're like, ⁓ people have been attacking her, like blah blah blah. Like you have better things to do. Like this is like there are people dying. Like Yeah, Carla Leite honestly has been one of my favorite players this season. I think she's a pretty good candidate for MIP, along with like Kaitlyn Chen, Jessica Shepard, all those people. Like she's up there with them. I think she should have gone a nod or at least more votes or something like that. Because honestly, she it just kind of breaks my heart a little bit that she wasn't there, but she'll get it next year. I think if she improves with the trajectory, she'd definitely be there for sure next year. And This isn't the best thing you have to do with your time. I think another more controversial player that wasn't on the All-Star, and I literally saw Twitter break over this was Azzi Fudd. Ria Abraham: Yeah, Azzi Fudd has definitely been having a great season and I think she was definitely in the running for this. And I guess maybe it makes sense that she was falling a little bit short of the list. But she definitely has been I think she's the wings second or third, I think third leading scorer at behind Paige Bueckers and Jessica Shepherd. So she's been I like doing really great for them. You know, we had that slow start where she was coming off the bench and kind of but I guess that's just getting adjusted, getting playing in a new league, so that totally makes sense to me. And she's definitely been playing really great. And I think I think she's gonna make all star next season. But and maybe this wasn't her year. I I can see that I think some of these other players better than her, but But I definitely think she's right there on the cusp because she's been doing pretty good. Medha Sunkara: Yeah, I with Azzi Fud. She's been Dallas' defense, so I kind of understand people being a little upset that she didn't make it because she's like her stocks man. Like she is a guard who just blocks everything. She's not even that tall. She gets so many blocks, so many stuff. Ria Abraham: She's Saniya Rivers of this year. Saniya Rivers. Medha Sunkara: Yeah, for sure. No, she actually is like the best defensive rookie. It's not even close. So I definitely understand people feeling like she got snubbed there, but also who would you take off your like the current all-star list? And who would you replace Azzi Fudd with? Because I can't really think of anyone. I think that while she's been good in her own respect and pretty good for a rookie, ⁓ I think there have just been so many players this year performing at such a high caliber, it's kind of hard to put her in there when I there definitely have been players that have been playing better than her. And yes, next year, if she like, you know, keeps up that sophomore curve for a lot of the players second year, make a pretty good jump, she'll definitely be making it. Because a lot of her problems right now are kind of within like losing confidence to shoot, not shooting when she's open, things like that. That probably will be fixed second year. So I d I do expect her to make it several many, so many All star teams in the future, but I think this year just wasn't it for her.