Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Advent Calendar-Dec 4th-Concordia
Transcript
- 0:13From the kitchen of the cabin. We look the best games of all time
- 0:17according to board game Geek in Ben and Steve's advent calendar. I'm so jealass.
- 0:27Well no, you see, So for the listeners, we have a
- 0:31list of these games, and I've apportioned one to each of us because if
- 0:36we haven't played the game, we get to choose the substitute game we talk
- 0:40about. But sust say my game, said my game. We're both talking
- 0:45about this and this. You don't own it. I do own it.
- 0:50You don't even know I own all of it. I own the base game
- 0:53Venus, I own Salsa, I own the rom maps. I've got photos
- 0:57of myself with Mac Gertz. He likes mes garreter garretts. I get I
- 1:02get it wrong every single mat. Are you sure it's a n right?
- 1:06It does? So? Yeah. He fucking chatted you up about his fucking
- 1:10bicycle trip the Arctic, and I'm just like, Mark, would you please
- 1:12sign my copy of the World Reports. But I'm telling you now what I'm
- 1:22thinking. Lahava signed, well done for for jumping in on the dead air
- 1:26the fucking Rondel's Lahava side Rondel's then there's no Rondel's in this game. Concordia,
- 1:33Concordia. It's Rodel, doesn't it. No, what am I thinking
- 1:37of? You're thinking of Anti kjell Anti k I'm thinking every other, every
- 1:42other. But I'm just thinking about Marc Garrett, Mac mac Gerts right now.
- 1:48I'm thinking about mac here boy. I haven't had a couple of blue
- 1:49vines, have I? So I think laharva aside, this is the best
- 1:55eurogame. It was just whoa wow, this this game is simply astonishing best
- 2:02eurogame. You're gonna get some fucking people are gonna make some hay over that
- 2:07remark on this this game is I think this game is flawless, absolutely flawless.
- 2:13I agree, And and what's so wonderful about it is that when a
- 2:16eurogame is really good, and I think why people so I think why eurogames
- 2:21tend to get ranked higher than ameritrash games is because I think that eurogames are
- 2:28more prone to initiating the flow state than amer trash games, because eurogames are
- 2:36engines that you start that then continue to run. That's a very good take,
- 2:40Ben, Yeah, there are so so this is why I love perfecting,
- 2:45though I love prefect. This is why, this is why I lament
- 2:50the complication in modern eurogames, because I think once you have the rules explained
- 2:55to you and you do a round of the game, you never need to
- 3:00go to the rule book again. Only on the most egregious of educators.
- 3:04Just fucking do what the card says. So so, why is concord it
- 3:07brilliant? There is one reason concord it your your card and you do it,
- 3:10do what it says. How amazing you could perfect that ship? You
- 3:14perfected prefect? Take those resourcescting, I like the what's the one where you
- 3:21copy everyone else? Umm? I don't remember, but brilliant, So so
- 3:29I think I think they were. So I remember, I remember that I
- 3:34was listening to the Secret Cabal and they were talking about this back when it
- 3:38came out, and they said it had been recommended them to them by Rodney
- 3:43Smith and they tried it and they just went, this is amazing. And
- 3:47I bought it, and I remember the first time I played it, and
- 3:51I wasn't that struck, to be honest, because you didn't fucking perfect that
- 3:55ship fucking profect. And then there was a seminal game money. There was
- 3:59a seminal game which I talk about a lot, not not a game covenancy,
- 4:02thank you, I mean this game though, well indeed that was me,
- 4:08There was you, There was our former friend Simona oh no, blessed
- 4:15hate up, and someone else I can't remember. And we played a non
- 4:18entity appearally and we played a game of Concordia and we finished the game.
- 4:25And we finished the game and then we just we sat there in silence,
- 4:30and then we just stood up in silence and for I mean, it seems
- 4:33like ours now, but it would have been about ninety seconds. I guess
- 4:36just look to the board in that sort of you know, in that in
- 4:44that sort of nothing needed to be said. When a game is really good,
- 4:48you have this communal mental experience that explains everything. Who is in one?
- 4:56I have no idea, right, we don't know, Okay, it
- 4:58is it is that that is the most magic circle board game experience I've ever
- 5:04had. And it was almost as if we were telepathic. Yeah. And
- 5:08the thing is there are some dickheads the way they play games. They like
- 5:12are so obsessed in like with winning and sort of they don't care if they
- 5:15ruined everybody else's good time that they they like missed the forest for the trees
- 5:20right exactly for the way for for for for game playing. It's like you,
- 5:25you, uh, sacrifice that experience for the experience of like me me
- 5:30me me, me, me me ye, my game, my victory,
- 5:32your bad time, I made it happen. The point is. The point
- 5:34is gaming is about sitting around the table with like minded people and playing in
- 5:44the brain of the designer. You know the thing about Concordia, I've never
- 5:47been good at it, Like I know, like you're supposed to like collect
- 5:51sets of the gods on the car, like, yeah, yeah, never
- 5:55fucking do it. No. It's definitely one of these games where I just
- 5:58sort of do it feels right and in turn out however it turns out,
- 6:00And I'm sure I could play it in such a way to get better at
- 6:02it. Haven't yet, And yet I still love it. I still think
- 6:05it's brilliant. It is it is still by every map for some reason.
- 6:09Yeah, and this is the thing. I think there are there are great
- 6:12eurogames out there. I think Hans Chetonika is fantastic. I think many of
- 6:17Rosenberg games are fantastic. I think I don't actually interestingly, I don't think
- 6:24Ryan can needs here is the many eurogames to be honest, No, I
- 6:27guess not. I think his games exist in an a sphere. Yeah,
- 6:30he's his own thing, and but there is just none none, None of
- 6:33the top twenty five, right, none of the top twenty five, which
- 6:36is insane, right, But I spoke to Matt Gutz about it. We
- 6:43could do the top twenty five Rander Knisier games next year. Yeah, maybe
- 6:46all that'd be good. We could do the top twenty five, right or
- 6:48kanasia games in each category of game for the next ten years. The top
- 6:53twenty five games set into Egypt by Ryan Kinitzia. But speaking to start with
- 6:57a speaking to Matt Gertz, my friend Mac, Yeah, and he was
- 7:01saying, it's by far his most successful game, and he's signed some brilliant
- 7:05games. All of them are brilliant as far as I'm concerned. Watching my
- 7:10flager that's brilliant, that's great. And I can't even remember the fucking game.
- 7:13I don't know the one where you're backing the powers. Imperial, Imperial,
- 7:17That's what I haven't played. Imperial is fantastic. I really liked our
- 7:21game with Auntie k Duello. Yeah, Anti k Duello is great. I
- 7:25really liked Crossing Oceans. Yeah, they're very unfortunately named Crossing Oceans. Yeah,
- 7:30great too. And what is interested of matcha Pichi is very good.
- 7:35What is interesting at having Matt Gertz is his games very much reflect him as
- 7:41a person. They're very put together, they're very straight, they're very earnest,
- 7:46and there's not a lot of mischief in his games. But what they
- 7:50are is perfectly organized. But of all the Matt Gertz games I've played,
- 7:57there's only one that I think and sends into magic, that that has that
- 8:03indefinable thing when you play it that you just go this is this is a
- 8:07truly transformative experience. And that's Concord. And he figured something out. I
- 8:13don't think he did, you see, I don't think he did. This
- 8:16is the problem with great art is the So there's a very famous anecdote with
- 8:20Laurence Olivier when he was playing a fellow in the sixties. He was in
- 8:26black face, but he was okay in the sixties and he did this performance.
- 8:30So Olivier was considered the greatest theater actor of like two generations, right,
- 8:35I mean, until you came along until I came along, and then
- 8:39he did. He did this one performance right that was so fucking unbelievable.
- 8:46Was it recorded? And no, they did do a film in it,
- 8:48and it's really bad. Even if we watched it today, we would find
- 8:52it like I watched I've watched the film of that production, and it's got
- 8:56this brilliant bit where Desdemona dies and Maggie Smith played Desdemona and there's a young
- 9:01Maga Smith and uh Olivier's got oh Desdemona and he lifts his head and like
- 9:09his makeups all over a white things of the film version is terrible, but
- 9:15he did this. He did this amazing performance, so amazing that the entire
- 9:22cast gave him a fucking thing of honor as he came off stage. You
- 9:26know, whether you honor? What's what's it called like a legion of honor
- 9:31where everyone stands in two lines and they just clap you as you go through
- 9:35it. I don't know. This seems a bit pretentious to me, but
- 9:37he was so brilliant. The cast just spontaneously did this, and Olivier stormed
- 9:41through this legion of honor with a face like fucking thunder and Frank Finlay,
- 9:48who played into it. So Frank Finlay, who played the argo, was
- 9:52the only one senior enough to go and speak to Olivier and see why he
- 9:56was so pissed off. People didn't understand why he was so annoyed. Door
- 10:01leer, I said, come in, and he said, that was amazing,
- 10:03because I know, and because the why you're so angry And he said,
- 10:07because I don't know how I did it, dickhead. And so the
- 10:13point is, I know, but the point is I don't know I did
- 10:16it. But the point is right, I think if you play that goods
- 10:20games, the top level the top level games, but if you play Concordia,
- 10:24I bet if you think if you think he doesn't know how he did
- 10:26it, no, I don't know. I don't think he would be able
- 10:30to tell you how the alchemy of Concordia makes it as great as serious.
- 10:35I mean, that is some hell of a kind of praise. I almost
- 10:41respect you for being willing to give a board game designer that kind of praise,
- 10:45for being like, if you really truly believe that board games are art,
- 10:50then I guess you have to believe that the product is somehow ineffable.
- 10:56The mechanisms by which it comes into being cannot be explained by like mac Garrett
- 11:01sitting down and very carefully putting it together and being able to explain, here's
- 11:03how I did it exactly. Like there must be some kind of like aspect
- 11:09of I don't know. We will call it like the spark of the divine
- 11:11like it's it's the famous Gabrielle the genius, right, it's the famous Gabrielle
- 11:16Garcia Marquez. He he liked it better in English, really, that's what
- 11:22he said. Past nice, he preferred it in English translation. But it's
- 11:24the famous story about Gabrielle Garcia Marquez is that a teacher was teaching Marquez's son,
- 11:31I was talking about the one hundred years of whatever it's Goslitude, and
- 11:35he talked in the book about how whenever there is death there is a cockrel,
- 11:43and that the cockrel symbolizes the presaging of death. We love shit,
- 11:48that symbolizes shit. And then the son of and the son of Marquez had
- 11:54to write an essay on his dad's book and he ended up getting a failing
- 11:58grade. Can you imagine having to be the son of Marquez and having to
- 12:01write an essay on his book and the Sungle of Failing Grade, because he
- 12:05went home and asked his dad, that's like fucking Bob Shakespeare exactly, and
- 12:11he said, he said, what does what does the cock crew mean in
- 12:13the book? And he went, I don't know. I just put a
- 12:16cockrell in there. And that's what he wrote in the essay. And so
- 12:18the point is, if you're a Roland bart fundamentalist, as i am,
- 12:24I don't care if Matt Gertz could explain to me how good the game is.
- 12:31It is our collective appreciation of that game that makes it what it is.
- 12:35We we can ourselves explain the sort of like complex and matrix of cultural
- 12:41cultural influences that produce us and our ideas and also mechanical, original mechanical interactions
- 12:48that just results in this. And this is the great ineffable thing great games.
- 12:54This is why, this is why a great artist and I include who's
- 12:56Rosenberg, Matt Gertz, Rani Canitzia. This is why they don't do it
- 13:01every time because you can never fucking know, right, you can never know
- 13:07to some degree the creation of great art is rolling a die? Is it?
- 13:11Senator? Well? Is it? Senator? Where you copy the action.
- 13:16Oh yeah, maybe it's senator. Yeah, I've been thinking about people.
- 13:20They're gonna tell us, They're gonna tell us. And so I love
- 13:26the thing is what I love about it. So like mac Gertz like emitted
- 13:30this game, Like he came into the world and he gathered all of the
- 13:33resources of game making channeled through him. The thing is, it's not like
- 13:37a tabula rasa and no, I mean he could only create this game on
- 13:41the back of the great games he had created. He stood at the nexus
- 13:46of the cultural forces of board gaming at that time, combined it with like
- 13:50his historical like he he was. He was the one who stood at the
- 13:54at the at the at that nexus point and was able to create this game
- 13:58by gathering together like the inputs to do it. Yes, his influences,
- 14:03his previous work, the previous work, his his pedetic interest in history.
- 14:07Every work of art, Every work of art is essentially a reference to everything
- 14:13that has ever existed. Which is why which exactly what he thinks exactly it
- 14:20doesn't and it doesn't know. This is like art is so fundamentally humor is
- 14:24because it pulls upon every aspect of human culture since we were able to remember.
- 14:31I mean, why is it set in the Roman Empire? Like,
- 14:35it doesn't need to be. It's like an abstract game. It could be
- 14:37if it doesn't. I think in the modern day it's probably best because people
- 14:43known about the deaths of certain people closest to us in historical thing. But
- 14:48it's it's I mean, you could you could make it a completely abstract game
- 14:52and have it not have a setting. It doesn't have a geographical But there
- 14:56is something about this, And this is why I don't like playing prototypes in
- 15:00the same way that I like playing completed games, because there is something about
- 15:03the theme, even if it's as thin as fuck, that draws you in.
- 15:09Right. I seem to really enjoy games that are set in the ancient
- 15:13Mediterranean, and I will typically play them just because they are right. Concordia
- 15:16might be the one game that I enjoy like in spite of the fact that's
- 15:22set in ancient Rome in the ancient Mediterranean. So okay, I'm gonna show
- 15:26you now on my phone, like I would like it anyway. I think
- 15:28it's brilliant anyway, the fact that it's set in ancient Rome is just like
- 15:31a bonus from me. I'm gonna show you now the top twenty five on
- 15:35Board Game Geek as of the day I compiled it, yep, okay,
- 15:41and I'm gonna vamp ale you read it. Okay. I want you to
- 15:43tell me whether you think this is the best game on this list? All
- 15:48right, so let me see here. I think it's definitely better than the
- 15:52ones we've already discussed, absolutely going down the list. Okay, So I
- 15:58shouldn't mention them or no, just just say just look at it. I
- 16:00mean it's everyone can access it, but still just say, just look at
- 16:04them and tell me whether you think it's the best? Is it the best?
- 16:07Is it the best? Okay? I'm just thinking how how much can
- 16:12I compare it to all of them? Is the question? I mean,
- 16:18there are definitely a few where there's like no question whatsoever. Okay. I
- 16:22think that there are games on this list that people would argue are better.
- 16:27There's sort of one where I would have a conversation about it, and the
- 16:32rest of them, to me, there's no questions. I think there's one
- 16:34game that's better. I think I think there's only one guy. I think
- 16:38I know which game you think. I know which game you think is better.
- 16:41Yeah, I'm actually surprised that there's another one that you don't think is
- 16:45better. No, absolutely not. No, No, I think I think
- 16:48because because you're just like a cuck for this game. But I think this
- 16:51is probably the best hero game apart from The Harbor, ever made. And
- 16:55the fact I wasn't prepared for this statement on this December, the fact that
- 16:59it's Herd December fourth four, the fact that the fact that it's not this
- 17:07game is not a euro game. What makes it a eurogame? What makes
- 17:11a Euro's Historically it's historically based. It is economic leveraging a low level of
- 17:18randomness, It doesn't have a Rondel, there's very little sort of explicit the
- 17:25designer's European. Yeah, there's very little explicit confrontation. It's very much.
- 17:30Yeah, it is. It is fucking brilliant. I mean, it's got
- 17:33such staying power, Like why don't we play it more often? Like we're
- 17:37so captivated by the cult of the news, and yet like you could play
- 17:41this game over and over again, and and I would argue, not tire
- 17:44of it. We should do a fucking Concordia like map marathon, because but
- 17:48all the maps, now what we ought to do is what we want to
- 17:52do when we can find seven days. Well, we do so many things.
- 17:55We could do a Concordia. Let's do it doing a Bower Paul every
- 18:00day. You know what, we have the best ideas. Thank you for
- 18:07listening. You can support the show at Patreon dot com, forward slash five
- 18:11gfi D and join the discord by going to five g fd dot com.
- 18:15Have a very merry Christmas.