Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / The Crunch with JJ McCullough: Does Internet popularity equal political success?
Transcript
- 0:02Check Podcasts. Welcome back to This is Van Color. We're gonna wrap things
- 0:10up tonight by launching a brand new segment involving a Van Color fan favorite.
- 0:16And this segment is going to be dedicated to offbeat discussions about Canadian culture and
- 0:20politics, with a particular I for what's happening online. It will be driven
- 0:25by my friend, a political commentator and YouTuber based right here in Vancouver with
- 0:29nearly a million subscribers. He is JJ McCullough. And this is the Clunch
- 0:39JJ, So nice to see you man, glad to be back. Thanks,
- 0:42Thanks for being a regular contributor to the show. This is going to
- 0:45be a lot of fun. You and I are chronically online. Yes,
- 0:49how much of the realities of the online discourse actually reflect the offline discourse and
- 0:56what people are talking about at their kitchen table. I think think that the
- 1:00most relevant way that sort of the online discourse permeates into the sort of the
- 1:03normal person's life is just simply that elites seem to be grossly overrepresented in terms
- 1:08of online discourse. Right, So, people like you and me, right
- 1:11like, we are terminally online, and so as a result of the elites,
- 1:15we are the elite, right, Because no, it's true, because
- 1:18it's like, you know, we have access to a sort of you know,
- 1:19large audience, you know, through our shows and YouTube channels and whatever,
- 1:23your newspaper columns what have you, right, and so the kind of
- 1:26things that we perceive to be the sort of the top issues facing the nation,
- 1:30you know, that does trickle down in the sense that this is the
- 1:32kind of stuff that we'll be talking about through our forums, and then the
- 1:34public sort of engages with it on that level. But I do think that
- 1:38at the same time, some of these like hyper kind of like niche internal
- 1:42debates about debates, like meta commentary on what other people have to say about
- 1:46the meta commentary, right, Like that does start to be pretty irrelevant.
- 1:49So I think it can be useful in terms of setting the tone, but
- 1:53not always more in the sort of like the hyper niche kind of nitty gritty
- 1:56because I think about it in a way, in terms of the conversation online
- 2:00line is driven by people like you and I who are chronically online, yes,
- 2:04and demographically that also seems to skew towards millennials gen Z some gen xers,
- 2:10not as much boomers, who are actually the most reliable, you know,
- 2:14voting base in Canada. And so I feel like the online conversation is
- 2:17actually skewed just based on generations. Do you think there's any truth to that?
- 2:21I think generation, I think social class as well. Like I think
- 2:25that I've noticed that people comment a lot that there's like a certain perception of
- 2:30the economy that you hear a lot from the terminally online is often very reflective
- 2:35of the unique sort of economic anxieties felt by kind of like over educated people
- 2:38in their late twenties, early thirties, you know. And so like that
- 2:43in turn was sort of like that's a very narrow niede. What acts of
- 2:46the economy do you mean? Well, it's like people like who feel that
- 2:49they're not making as much money as they should be making, that it's harder
- 2:52to find a job, you know, Like some of these kind of conserted
- 2:53like the affordability kind of stuff. Like these are sort of tensions that tend
- 2:57to face people at a certain phase of life life that may not be reflective
- 3:00of the sort of the phase of life or the economic situation of say the
- 3:04boomer generation, right right. I just feel like that is a conversation that
- 3:07is happening offline certainly with my my circle of friends. And again there's a
- 3:10bias there because they're mostly millennials, where people are talking about affordability, and
- 3:15so the online discourse in some ways is quite reflective of the offline discourse.
- 3:20No, No, I think that's true. I mean I do think it
- 3:22also comes down to, like again what I said before, like sort of
- 3:24setting the agenda, right, Like if you think of sort of like the
- 3:29hyper online community sort of talking amongst themselves and sort of formulating amongst themselves what
- 3:32are the top issues facing us? And then I think that sort of infiltrates
- 3:37the sort of the broader discourse through access to sort of the forums that we
- 3:40have in order to sort of articulate what we perceive to be the most pressing
- 3:44political issues of our time. Right now, does popularity online translate into popularity
- 3:50offline? Because I have a case for both. Right, there was a
- 3:53while there where jug Meet Singh was kind of the hottest Canadian politician online,
- 3:58particularly on TikTok, didn't really result in a lot of ector electoral success,
- 4:02and I would say, you know, he underperformed electorally. But then you
- 4:05have a guy like pure Palyev, who is clearly now the hottest politician online.
- 4:10Everyone likes to see his views, love him or hate him. He's
- 4:13getting a lot of engagement, and offline he seems to be polling quite high
- 4:16as well. We'll find out obviously when their next election comes. So he's
- 4:19an example where you know, maybe it does kind of reflect the popularity where
- 4:24do you see it. Does online popularity mean that you're going to be successful
- 4:28in the real world. I think there's kind of a sweet spot. And
- 4:30I was actually kind of like looking at some of the poll numbers in anticipation
- 4:32of this, because jug Mat Singh did has actually gone up with young people,
- 4:38Like the NDP is doing better with young people than it was before he
- 4:42came onto the scene. But the problem is the NDP is doing worse overall.
- 4:46So it's like you can say that he has an appeal to like young
- 4:49people that he's emphasized by doing TikTok dances and all this kind of stuff,
- 4:53but maybe there is a certain price to that as well. Maybe that makes
- 4:56him come off as a kind of like unserious politician to other older voters,
- 5:00and maybe that's why the NDP is sort of suffering overall, while they're doing
- 5:03worse in the polls overall, even though they're doing better with young people.
- 5:06Whereas Pierre has been good online in a way that is maybe a little bit
- 5:10more broadly accessible, Like he makes memorable you know, Twitter videos, Instagram
- 5:14reels and this kind of stuff that aren't quite as juvenile but are still a
- 5:17good example of good effective communication through the medium of social media. So maybe
- 5:21that allows him to have a sort of like broader resonance. One thing that
- 5:26I found in my own commentary is ABC Vancouver and Mayor Ken sim the Mayor
- 5:30of Vancouver, very divisive online and in fact get a lot of criticism,
- 5:35particularly on Twitter. But when I go out and talk to people who live
- 5:39in the city of Vancouver, people who voted for Ken Sim, they seem
- 5:44to really like him, and they actually he's actually seems to be quite popular
- 5:46in real life. And so you know, I'm trying to breadge this divide
- 5:50of like why we don't see that same kind of popularity offline, you know,
- 5:56or online I should say, you know what I mean, I think
- 5:58that again, like in the same way that I think the sort of the
- 6:00social media twitterati elite kind of disproportionately reflects a certain age and social class demographic.
- 6:06I think that there is a sense that sort of the twitterati elite sort
- 6:10of lean's more left than the broad sort of public does. And that's why
- 6:13I think that like, for example, like Bernie Sanders as well, like
- 6:15he seemed to be such a phenomenon online in a way that didn't really seem
- 6:19like was ever born out by voting patterns. And I think it's the same
- 6:23thing like somebody like Ken sim you know, who's like right coded and thus
- 6:27is sort of unfashionable to a certain scene, but might still be broadly popular
- 6:30with a different scene that isn't as reflected in the sort of the hellowed halls
- 6:34of the what we used to call the blue check mark crowd. But we
- 6:36can't say that, yeah, that's a completely different crowd. Now, when
- 6:41when political strategists or even people like you and I who co comment on politics
- 6:46look at social media, how important is social media, the Twitter presence,
- 6:50the Facebook presence for actual election campaigning do you find? I mean, I
- 6:56think it's very important in the sense that I think that like, as more
- 7:00and more people are not watching conventional media, as more and more people you
- 7:04know, are not listening to the radio, turning on the TV. I
- 7:06think that you have to think, like how is the message getting out there?
- 7:10And I mean, you know, social media, the Internet is just
- 7:12the dominant communications medium of our time. So I think that, like,
- 7:15you know, I think we're beyond the point where we can think of this
- 7:17as even sort of like a new or novel way of campaigning. I think
- 7:20that the tactics within it, like are you doing it on TikTok or are
- 7:24you doing the TikTok dances or whatever, Like that's a conversation worth having.
- 7:28But I think, you know, the train is out of the station as
- 7:30far as like the essential nature of communicating and sort of propagandizing online if you're
- 7:34trying to campaign for public office, this has to be scary for political parties
- 7:39and politicians because in a lot of ways they're giving giving away control. Right,
- 7:43people like you and I can go viral with some commentary that really hits
- 7:47politicians quite hard, and it happens all the time. And you know,
- 7:50certainly I know in my experience when I put out a video about a politician
- 7:56who is in a zoom meeting, yes it did change the election. I'm
- 8:00not saying it changes the results, but it affected the election in a way,
- 8:03and so that that's quite scary as well, right, Like they're quite
- 8:05politicians are more vulnerable than ever? Well are they more vulnerable than ever?
- 8:09I mean this, if it wasn't for you sharing it online in a previous
- 8:11generation, you know, you would have been on the nightly news sharing it,
- 8:15right like I, or it would have been an investigative report in the
- 8:18newspaper. Right. I think that this is kind of a lot slower,
- 8:20though it is slower, and maybe in that sense that sort of scandals and
- 8:24outrages kind of come and go quicker, but that that can also work to
- 8:28your advantage if you're a politician, right, something that's blowing up on Twitter
- 8:31might be forgotten by Friday. So it's just a slightly different media environment that
- 8:37we're all sort of having to inhabit in sort of our democratic society. I
- 8:41think it's hard to say if it's objectively worse or better. It's just it's
- 8:45different. But it's also the reality that's here to stay. You know,
- 8:48it's not going to be forgotten about on Friday. What JJ McCullough, JJ,
- 8:52this is a pleasure thanks so much man, I appreciate it absolutely,
- 8:56folks, thank you so much for watching, and of course thank you to
- 9:00Addy SeaBus of SeaBus Memes and JJ McCullough for tonight's show. We're in dream
- 9:03guest territory next week. I don't even want to jinx it if you think
- 9:07you know who I'm talking about. Predict next week's guest by emailing the team
- 9:13at Checkmedia dot Ca. For now, though, this is Van Coller and
- 9:16I'm mo Emir telling you that in a province where you can be anything,
- 9:20be color for peace