Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Cars vs. Hydrogen vs. E-fuel Efficiency
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Dee dive today. Well, we're trying to sort
- 0:03through all the different ideas about cleaning U Rd. transport.
- 0:06Mm Hmm. We've got this report looking at
- 0:08electric cars, hydrogen ones and those E fuel vehicles.
- 0:13Right, the synthetic fuels. Exactly.
- 0:15So the mission really is to figure out which one actually
- 0:18makes the most sense from an energy perspective based on what
- 0:21this analysis says. Yeah, and it's not just about,
- 0:24you know, which technology sounds coolest.
- 0:26We're looking at well to wheel. OK, explain that quickly.
- 0:29It means tracing the energy right from the source.
- 0:32Could be wind, solar, whatever. All the way through production,
- 0:36transport and actually making the wheels turn.
- 0:39Got it. So the whole journey of the
- 0:40energy. Precisely.
- 0:41It gives you the real picture of the energy cost and the
- 0:45environmental side too, OK. So let's dive in.
- 0:47What's the headline finding? Is there a clear winner on
- 0:50efficiency? Well, yeah, the report points
- 0:53pretty strongly towards battery electric vehicles EVs, right?
- 0:57Their efficiency range is pretty impressive, somewhere between 70
- 1:01and 90%. 70 to 90, that sounds really high.
- 1:04It is, especially when you compare it, think about your
- 1:07standard gasoline car, OK, It's overall efficiency is like maybe
- 1:1113 percent, 13. Wow, OK, so most of the energy
- 1:15in petrol is just wasted. Pretty much mostly as heat, so
- 1:19EVs right off the bat. They're just in a different
- 1:21league for using the energy effectively.
- 1:24That's a huge baseline difference.
- 1:26OK, so EVs are way out front. What about hydrogen then?
- 1:30The report mentions them too. It does hydrogen fuel cell
- 1:33vehicles. They come in lower.
- 1:35The range given is about 25 to 35% efficient. 25 to 35 S quite
- 1:41a bit less than half of them EV potentially.
- 1:43Yeah, exactly. Though they do note it might get
- 1:45a bit better, maybe up to like 42% by 2050 with improvements.
- 1:50Little big gap though. Well, why is hydrogen so much
- 1:52less efficient? Where's the energy going?
- 1:54OK, so there are a few steps. First, you've got to the
- 1:56hydrogen, if we're talking green hydrogen using renewables.
- 2:00Which is what we want, right? Clean hydrogen.
- 2:01Ideally, yes. That process, electrolysis,
- 2:04splitting water, it takes quite a bit of energy itself.
- 2:07You lose about 24% of your starting energy right there.
- 2:10Just making it before it even gets near a car.
- 2:12Yep, just turning electricity and water into hydrogen gas
- 2:15costs you almost 1/4 of the energy.
- 2:18OK. And then while hydrogen is
- 2:20tricky stuff, it's a tiny molecule, hard to contain, likes
- 2:23to leak. Transporting it isn't easy or
- 2:26efficient either. OK.
- 2:28So more losses there. Yeah, the report estimates
- 2:31another roughly 8% loss just in getting the hydrogen to where it
- 2:35needs to be like a filling station, so.
- 2:37Add that up 24 + 8, yeah, that's 32% gone already, you.
- 2:43Got it. Over 30% of the initial energy
- 2:45is lost before you even pump it into the vehicle.
- 2:48That's. Quite something, and I guess the
- 2:50fuel cell inside the car isn't 100% efficient either.
- 2:53No, definitely not the fuel cell stack itself where the hydrogen
- 2:56reacts to make electricity. That process also has its own
- 3:00inefficiencies that contributes to the overall lower number
- 3:04compared to just charging a battery directly.
- 3:06Right. Makes sense.
- 3:07Multiple steps, multiple places to lose energy.
- 3:09OK, so that covers hydrogen's challenges.
- 3:11What about the third option mentioned, E fuels?
- 3:15The report had a pretty stark comparison there, didn't it?
- 3:17It did. It said an EV can go about five
- 3:21times further than an E fuel car on the same amount of energy.
- 3:24Five times. That's huge.
- 3:27That would mean a massive difference in running costs for
- 3:29you, the driver. Absolutely massive.
- 3:31And the reasons, while they sound a bit familiar after
- 3:34talking about hydrogen. Oh, have so.
- 3:37E fuels are synthetic. You basically need to make
- 3:40hydrogen first, again, ideally green hydrogen with those
- 3:43efficiency losses. Right step one is the same.
- 3:46Then you need to capture carbon dioxide, CO2 from the air or
- 3:50maybe industry that takes energy too.
- 3:52OK, another energy input. And then you need a complex
- 3:54chemical process to combine the hydrogen and the CO2 to actually
- 3:58synthesize the liquid fuel. So even more steps than
- 4:01hydrogen. Essentially, yes.
- 4:02Each step needs energy and each conversion loses some.
- 4:05It's what the report calls nodes to be solved.
- 4:08Just lots of places where the energy gets dispersed.
- 4:11A bit like a leaky pipe, but for energy across multiple stages.
- 4:15That's a decent analogy, yeah. And on top of the poor
- 4:18efficiency, yes, the report also points out that making E fuels
- 4:21at any large scale just isn't really possible right now.
- 4:25So it's not just inefficient, it's also not scalable.
- 4:28Yet not for mass market cars, no.
- 4:30And the costs extremely high. OK.
- 4:33So for cars, the verdict on E fuels seems pretty clear.
- 4:37Too inefficient, too expensive, not ready for prime time.
- 4:40For private road transport, yes, that seems to be the conclusion
- 4:44from this analysis. All right.
- 4:46So it sounds like for cars, EVs are leading the pack by quite a
- 4:49margin in efficiency terms. But the report didn't totally
- 4:54dismiss hydrogen and E fuels, did it?
- 4:56It mentioned other areas. No it didn't.
- 4:58It's adjusted. They might actually be really
- 5:00important for sectors where batteries face bigger
- 5:03challenges. Think heavy duty long distance
- 5:05stuff. Like what?
- 5:06Trucks. Ships exactly long haul shipping
- 5:09aviation. Those are really tough to
- 5:11electrify directly with current battery tech.
- 5:14The energy needed is just enormous, but.
- 5:16You can't just plug in a giant container ship easily.
- 5:18Not yet, anyway. So for those areas, hydrogen or
- 5:22maybe E fuels could offer a pathway to decarbonize where
- 5:26batteries might take no much longer to become viable.
- 5:29And biofuels were mentioned too, weren't they?
- 5:31Fuels from plants or waste? Yes, biofuels too, derived from
- 5:35agriculture or biodegradable waste.
- 5:38They have their own issues of course around sustainability and
- 5:40land use, sure, but they could also be part of the mix for
- 5:43those difficult sectors, maybe as a transition fuel or
- 5:46alongside the others. OK, so possible niches for
- 5:50hydrogen, E fuels, biofuels and things like planes and ships,
- 5:54but for cars the message seems consistent.
- 5:57It does. Bringing it back to Rd.
- 5:59Transport, The analysis concludes that synthetic fuels,
- 6:01biological fuels, they're just less energy efficient.
- 6:05And more expensive. And more expensive, yes, and
- 6:07generally have a bigger overall impact compared to just
- 6:09electrifying cars directly. So the bottom line from this
- 6:12report, for cars at least, is that battery electric is the
- 6:16most efficient route we currently have for cleaner
- 6:18driving. That sums up the core finding
- 6:20regarding energy efficiency, yeah.
- 6:22This has been really clarifying. Actually, just laying out the
- 6:25energy losses step by step makes a big difference.
- 6:28It does help to see the whole chain.
- 6:30And for anyone listening who wants to, you know, really get
- 6:32into the weeds, the data, we put links in the description.
- 6:36There's stuff from the International Energy Agency,
- 6:38Bloomberg, the Italian Ministry of Infrastructure, lots of
- 6:43detail there. Definitely worth a look if you
- 6:45want the full picture and the policy context.
- 6:47They provide a lot more depth. Great.
- 6:49So just to wrap it up then, based on this analysis we've
- 6:53looked at, battery EVs seem to hold the efficiency crown for
- 6:58decarbonizing cars. For now, yes, based on well to
- 7:01wheel efficiency. Which leads to a bigger thought,
- 7:04I guess, if the efficiency differences are that big, what
- 7:09does that really mean for us, you know, for planning our
- 7:11energy grid, building charging stations versus hydrogen
- 7:14stations, the whole infrastructure question?
- 7:17That's the multi trillion dollar question, isn't it?
- 7:19It has huge implications for policy and investment going
- 7:22forward. Definitely something to chew on.
- 7:25And hey, if you found this deep dive helpful, if it cleared
- 7:28things up for you, yeah, we'd really appreciate it if you hit
- 7:31that like button it it helps other people discover this kind
- 7:34of analysis. It does helps get the info out
- 7:36there. So thanks for joining us on the
- 7:39Deep Dive.