Latest / Guardians of Care / Leading from the Middle: What Makes Medicaid Work
Transcript
- Karen Shields (00:00) I guess I am an optimist. I don't believe we're going to fail. I believe we're going to get stronger. But we have to be persistent, we have to collaborate, and we have to stay in the middle because that's where the most powerful energy exists. And we have to have everybody in the room. We don't have time to build this plane one piece at a time. We actually have to all be building the plane together. Peter (00:24) Welcome to Guardians of Care, we're the podcast that highlights the people, the programs, and partnerships that make Medicaid work. I'm your host, Pete Justen. In each episode, we speak with leaders and change makers from across the Medicaid ecosystem to share the successes, challenges, and practical lessons behind their work. One of the things we hope to do is demystify this $900 billion program and teach people how it works and why it's important. Now, my guest today has done something that very few people in American healthcare can claim. She's worked at the highest levels of federal health programs across multiple administrations, Republican and Democrat. And she's come out on the other side with something really rare in Washington, and that's a perspective that doesn't belong to either party. Karen spent decades inside the machinery of American healthcare. She oversaw Medicaid and chip operations at CMS, programs touching the lives of tens of millions of Americans over 900 billion in federal funding annually, one of our biggest federal programs. She also led operations for healthcare.gov during the ACA rollout, one of the most scrutinized technology launches in government history. After her federal career, she moved to the private sector. She was the Chief Client Engagement Officer at Gainwell Technologies, working across thirty different states. And today she runs K Shields Health Tech Consulting. Karen's been in the rooms where programs get designed, where they go right, where they go wrong, and where the people who have built them have to live with the consequences. Peter (01:52) So Karen, welcome to the show. Karen Shields (01:54) Thank you. Thank you for having me. That's quite the introduction. I wasn't exactly bouncing around by myself in the halls of those administrations. There was you know, tens of thousands of people helping me do all of this work, but thank you so much for the introduction. Peter (02:07) Well, the speed of the leader determines the rate of the pack, right? Karen Shields (02:10) Unfortunately, yes. Peter (02:11) I'm gonna start off with a good question for you, Karen. if you had a T shirt, what would you put on it? What would it say? Karen Shields (02:16) If I had one that represented my learnings for the most part across all of those administrations is that the smartest people in the country lead from the middle. Peter (02:25) Wow. That's a really good place to start this. And that's not Karen Shields (02:28) Yeah. Peter (02:29) so common. You know, we see so often in government that, especially with someone like a background as yours at the highest levels, have such opinions cast in stone, no matter where it is, but they're cast in stone. So you're saying the middle is the best spot? Why is that? Karen Shields (02:42) Everything that we've ever done, even if you look at that picture behind you, everything that we have ever done that was game changing and sustainable happened in the middle. And most of it didn't start that way, right? All the bipartisan things that we have done have always been some of the biggest, most important things we've ever done because most of it has been really hard to say no to, right? But I think that when we find ourselves stuck in a corner that's either left or right, it's really hard to make long term sustainable change that doesn't just bounce back and get done, undone, and redone across administrations. The sustainable stuff happens in the middle. Peter (03:21) And it's the important stuff. You know, Medicaid is a program. If you look back on it from President Johnson signing it sixty six years ago, you know, it has helped hundreds of millions of people. I love this program. You know, Karen Shields (03:32) Yeah. Yeah. Peter (03:34) I I learned a lot about it when I put my mom on Medicaid a number of years ago. And then the more I got into it, the more I understood it, I thought, This is a phenomenal program. getting a lot of bad press these days, but that's one of the reasons I wanted to talk with you because you have such a a great understanding of it and you bring so much gravitas to the issues. Karen Shields (03:51) Yeah, I seem to find myself magnetized to all of the lightning rod issues in the last twenty years of my career. I don't know if that's intentional or kismet, but I will tell you that I didn't start out knowing about Medicaid or really being all that in love with it. I mean, I just didn't have enough information to have an opinion, but I was on Medicaid when my son was born. I needed Medicaid to help me with prenatal care and to make sure at a time when I was working to make it through and struggling, I needed a hand up. And Medicaid was that hand up. I wasn't on it for very long, but it was important. It was the definition of a personal safety net for me. And so fast forward, you know, almost 40 years later when the son that I had that took all of those prenatal vitamins that I got while I was on the Medicaid program is now an amazing husband and father. Medicaid when it works well is a personal and a social investment in people and our society and all of the upward mobility that we claim is a part of Americanness, right? And the whole concept that, you know, Medicaid should only be given to people who, you know, can pull up their own bootstraps. Everybody has a different timeline for the bootstrap pulling, right? But I think what I fell in love with about Medicaid comes in two parts. And the first part is all the things I just talked about, about it being there for people when they are vulnerable. But the other one is the way it was built, right? That whole compromise that was made that the federal government would have the governance, you know, and the match oversight and the state would do the implementation. It just reminds me of, you know, one of my favorite plays, which is Hamilton and how Jefferson and Hamilton fought and their whole concept not just of the way the government should be run, but what this country needed in order to survive was a combination of states right and federal oversight and safety net. So that you could blend goodness across the states. When one was struggling, the other could help and I think that One of the things that we lose is that concept. When I was at CMS and even when I was at Gainwell, I would say we need to remind ourselves that we are a nation of 50 states and territories. And when I visited them when I worked at Gainwell they were like 30 different countries in the most amazing and beautiful way. And having respect for that is one of the reasons why I believe Medicaid is such a really amazing construct. Peter (06:15) That's a really interesting middle of the road approach that you have. You know, most people don't understand the background of Medicaid and why it came about to begin with and what the original purpose was. And let's talk about because I don't think most people know how it is constructed. So unpack that a little bit. Karen Shields (06:30) Yeah, first of all, I worked at CMS for a really long time and I served CMS as a contractor for a long time. And it took me a long time to make sure that when I was talking about the program, I knew the difference between Medicare and Medicaid. And so Medicare, the easiest way to explain it is it's the program that you age into, 65 and over. There's other ways to qualify for it besides being 65. And then Medicaid is pretty much the safety net, and there's an income requirement for it. But there's all kinds of things about Medicaid that cover babies, mothers, seniors, all of our seniors who age out of their income and need this and need to stay for long-term care. There's a lot of places where Medicare cuts off and Medicaid picks up, but people don't understand that. But the biggest thing I think that people don't understand about the Medicaid program is that CMS does not run the whole program. The states run the program and CMS has oversight and governance and regulatory authority to just make sure that the rules are being followed. And that forces a collaboration that I believe is unique and very, very special. Peter (07:35) So what do think people think of when they hear Medicaid? Karen Shields (07:39) Poor people handouts. And it's not everybody. But when they learn what it is, right, and they learn that covers seniors and it helps new mothers and it helps babies and the highest percentage of people enrolled in the program are children, you know, under a certain age, their eyes go wide. I didn't know that. People should say that more. People should tell me that more. Like It's everybody's responsibility when they want me to be annoyed by something to make sure I understand what I'm actually being annoyed by. So I think that the explanation and the onus is upon all of us actually to help people understand why it's so important. Peter (08:10) Such a fascinating program. I think the last number I saw was I think about sixty percent of Medicaid recipients are children. Does that sound Karen Shields (08:17) Yes. Yes. Peter (08:18) about right? Karen Shields (08:19) That sounds about right. Yeah. Peter (08:20) Yeah, it's just not for low income. And the other thing you said that I really resonated with is that Medicaid is a hand up, not a handout. Karen Shields (08:28) Yes. Yes. It is. Sticking with that home middle of the road theme, every program, right? Entitlement program, finance program, government program, private program has parts to it, right? So there's parts to Medicaid, just like parts to every other place. So are there parts in Medicaid where there are people who have not graduated? Right? Yes. I mean I personally know people who have not graduated. for all kinds of reasons that have nothing to do with the fact that they're just lazy and don't want to graduate, right? I was reading a book by Dr. Marcury last week called The Price We Pay, and he made a statement that stuck with me that says, There are so many injustices. And sometimes you know, you get a little overwhelmed by them. But the truth is One of the reasons why I love the Medicaid program is that it has the opportunity to be a mechanism for remediating some of those, right? And so there are people who like me, you know, personally, who needed it as a hand up, who needed it to help me deliver a healthy baby and then get off of it and grow from there, right? But who knows what have happened if I didn't have it, if I didn't have that opportunity. You know, my grandmother who said, you know what you should do? You should go and apply and see if you can get some help with your health care. she was basically a referral for me. Who knows what would happen if it's not there? And I think that when we start talking about what Medicaid is not, it's kind of like, you know, what's the movie that comes out at Christmas every year where the guy finds out what life would be like without him. It's Peter (10:01) It's a wonderful life. Karen Shields (10:02) a wonderful life. What would our country be like without it? Peter (10:06) Boy, that's a great question. I guess we would be like a lot of other countries who don't care as much for their citizens. Karen Shields (10:13) On purpose, right? it would be hard to say that wasn't intentional if we keep trying to figure out a way to make it less valuable. Peter (10:18) Mm-hmm. let's talk about the public perception on Medicaid a little bit because it's in the news every day. Every time I read something in the news, it's always, it's awful. it's this, it's oh, the fraud. Let's talk about that, the program integrity a little bit. because I think the bad like most other things, the bad press gets the news, right? And the Karen Shields (10:37) Yeah. Peter (10:37) success stories, the Karen Shields who needed a hand up. Got it and went on to have a spectacular career. I mean, I don't think those stories come out enough. Karen Shields (10:47) Yeah, I'm grateful for that. I'm grateful for the trajectory, and I'm grateful for all of the people who encouraged me to continue to move through the system and learn and reinvest in this country in that way. But I will tell you that I am a big fan of program integrity. I am a big fan of enrollment, I'm a big fan of access, I'm a big fan of coverage. I'm a big fan of Medicaid and I'm a big fan of making sure Peter (11:12) Yeah. Karen Shields (11:14) it's doing all of those things. And just like anything else that we have, you have to get to the middle to manage it so that it actually does all those things. because every program, every dollar that we have should be optimized, right? So that it can help the most. And it seems to me like a program that's supposed to help our most vulnerable should be the most optimized. Right? Like those dollars should go further than any other dollars because they need to do things in ways that me who needs to go out and you know buy like the really good chicken at the Whole Foods don't need. My dollar needs to be optimized, but not as much as the Medicaid dollar needs to be optimized. In order to optimize the Medicaid dollar, you have to optimize the program. And you have to have respect for the fact that it needs both attention to the front door and attention to the side and the back doors. right? So believing that you don't need to have program integrity be a top priority in a Medicaid program to me is disrespecting all of the things that matter about optimizing that dollar. It goes along with the responsibility of delivering a service. You need to make sure that this service is delivered well. And that you've optimized the delivery. Now, I think what we are experiencing is something that is not new to us as a society. It's not new to humans. You know, it's historical. I call it the boat, where everybody gets in the boat on this side. And then when somebody looks over and sees, there's a little bit of smoke at the other end, then everybody goes to the other side of the boat. And so then you've got this boat that really has no balance. It's got no middle. It's got no optimization. It's just got a whole lot of emotion and energy on both sides of the boat. But again, in the middle, balance is how you actually optimize this program, which means that every time you decide to open the door and give a new benefit or service, the people in the room who are responsible for making sure that there are no leaks in the boat should be in the conversation. Right? Sustainability of that boat requires people who are responsible for the right people being in the boat, people even getting in the boat, but also making sure that there's no leaks in the boat. If you put everybody in the boat and then you try to find the leaks, yeah, that's not optimization. That's a sunk boat that you have to pick back up and do all over again. And that's the most expensive way to run a program. I am now A big believer in program integrity, but I can tell you that is a learning that I came to over my career. Peter (13:55) Is that from your experience with ACA? Karen Shields (13:58) It was. My first experience at the executive level of a government agency was during the Obama administration and I came to the ACA work really not knowing that much about the ACA, number one. And number two, really not understanding all of the ways, like how complicated delivering healthcare was, not just the back end and the technology, but the policy and the negotiations and all the stakeholders and plans and navigators and advocates and community health centers and all the different stakeholders who had equity, real equity, that were in that boat, right? And it took so much of my personal energy to focus on recovery of the technology systems that I did not make enough room for the program integrity conversation, right? So when the program integrity people came and said, we've been given, you know, direction to figure out how to I I feel like we were already all in the boat by that time, right? And they were kind of sniffing around going, we want to put some patches here and patches here. I was like, I I just need you guys to go away right now. I just need you to go away. But the truth is that was the wrong leadership energy and it was the wrong thing to do. Peter (15:13) Interesting. Karen Shields (15:14) We definitely should have had way more conversations in the beginning, in the middle, and in the end with the program integrity folks, so that we could have put ourselves in a position to be a little bit more predictive. of any leakage or risk. Peter (15:28) What changes would you make if you were doing it again tomorrow? Karen Shields (15:33) The changes that I encourage a lot of my clients to make today, it's such a simple thing, but it is so hard to do. Have conversations early with all the people responsible for the health of the boat, using that analogy. Before you decide to open the boat, open a new service, develop a new anything, talk about how you can protect it, talk about what risk exists, with lack of optimization or any leakage of funds, right? And have the people in the room having that conversation. Now, I'm going to tell you what I have seen is the impediment to this collaborative, you know, round table of August bodies who want to talk about this new thing that you want to roll out. And that is the fear that they're going to come in with this policing energy that says, no, no, no to everything. That sounds scary. You shouldn't do it. And I think the onus is upon the people who are responsible for program integrity to be actually a little bit aware of that and come in with a listening ear to learn the program and learn what outcomes are supposed to be created so they can understand how to protect it. So let me give you an example of why it just seems so smart that you should do that. If the president says he wants to come to downtown Baltimore and do a great big event at the Baltimore Harbor. You're not gonna not involve the police. You're gonna involve the Secret Service, you're gonna involve all the people responsible for transportation. You're gonna have them in the room because you want it to go well. The worst thing you could do is have it and then have them come and figure out how to keep it safe. That's just not how you run a program. Peter (17:11) Gotta have the guardrails, right? Borders on the page. Like you talked about, right? You gotta have both sides, but staying in the middle to be able to service all the guardrails. Karen Shields (17:20) That's right. And if your question is, what would you do if you had to do it all over again? I'd have them in the wrong way earlier. A conversation with listening ears. Listening ears. Not just perfunctory. Okay, they were at the meeting. We included them. You know, I've been guilty of that before when they say, Did you engage? Engage, not necessarily. Were they invited to the meeting and were they listening? Yes. You know. But engage them to make sure that their equities and what they need in order to keep the program safe. That's the cultural change that has to happen with these programs in order for it to be baked in. Peter (17:56) Keep the operations in the room, right? Karen Shields (17:58) That's right. Operations, program integrity, advocates like, you know, my. Peter (18:03) What what a radical thought for a government program. let's set this up the right way to make the most sense. You know, policy Karen Shields (18:08) Ha. Peter (18:09) is only as good as the implementation, right? you know, I always say that Washington is a land of unintended consequence, right? So when you've got what sounds like a really good idea and it becomes policy, but if it doesn't have the right implementation for the policy, Affordable Care Act is a great example. Who doesn't want to get everybody covered? How do we do Karen Shields (18:23) Mm. Mm-hmm. Peter (18:25) that? How do we implement a great idea? so it works. So it's affordable, so it's sustainable, so it reaches people that it needs to reach. That implementation is just, you know, just so critical. Karen Shields (18:36) Sylvia Burrell was the Secretary of Health and Human Services under the Obama administration. She came in towards the latter half. And I would go to meetings when we were briefing her on a new service or something new that was about to roll out. And I vividly remember her asking all the great questions and then she would end with, So who's not gonna like it? How are the providers going to feel? How are the hospitals going to feel? How are the plans going to feel? How are the advocates going to feel? And if you ask that question often enough, people will come to you having already asked. She trained us to be better listeners and more inclusive. And I'll never forget that. I have done the best I Can in my career to use that to say who are the winners and who are the losers, and what's the remediation for anybody who, you know, doesn't win with this policy. The hardest thing about being at the federal level or any level that is over a body of constituents who get impacted by your decisions is that there's no such thing as a solution that's great for everybody. You have to be brave enough to own the knowledge of who, like you said, what the unintended consequences are. But you have to ask and you have to dig and you have to do that research. Peter (19:56) Karen, that is phenomenal advice. What a wonderful perspective that is. Are you running in the for president in a couple of years? I'll vote for you if you do, because I would love to have you there sitting in that office. Karen Shields (20:06) I'm still working on getting my grandma game right, so Peter (20:08) All right. How many grandkids? Karen Shields (20:11) Six. Peter (20:12) Wow. Wow. That's Karen Shields (20:14) Yeah. Peter (20:14) that's a whole posse you're on the holidays. there you go. Karen Shields (20:16) It's work. I'm a professional, so trying to be good at that is is where I'm focused. Peter (20:23) That's a great focus. I have thirteen, so I understand your focus. Yeah. Karen Shields (20:25) Ooh. Wonderful. Peter (20:27) Yeah, we're really blessed. Let's finish up a little bit on where do you think Medicaid's headed? Where are we going? Karen Shields (20:33) So I want to preface that answer by saying that the last thing that I think people underestimate about the power of the Medicaid program is it's innovation. It's healthcare innovation. And a lot of people don't put Medicaid and innovation in the same space because they believe that, you know, that's the program is so intense and it's It works so hard to serve so many people that it's hard to test. But it is the test bed, especially with 1115 waivers, with all of the flexibilities that exist within the program and those pilots. You get to see what works on this population in ways that actually have long and and sometimes very powerful consequences on either what you should or shouldn't keep doing. And so I believe that. Two things are gonna happen. The first thing is what is beginning to happen now, which is long overdue, and they fall in a couple of buckets. One is that everyone who is involved in the outcomes of Medicaid is going to have to roll up their sleeves over the next couple of years and figure out ways to optimize this program. That includes vendors who do systems, that includes health plans who have managed care. plans community organizations. And I have empathy for the fact that they're all probably saying right now, we have all been doing that. But I think Medicaid is calling upon us right now to add on 10 more pounds to our weight. Right. At an RPE of like twelve, right? I guess I am an optimist. I don't believe we're going to fail. I believe we're going to get stronger. But we have to be persistent, we have to collaborate, and we have to stay in the middle because that's where the most powerful energy exists. And we have to have everybody in the room. We don't have time to build this plane one piece at a time. We actually have to all be building the plane together. Peter (22:32) That's Karen Shields leading from the middle. I like that. Karen Shields (22:34) Mm. Peter (22:35) that'll be your campaign slogan. I'll be your first donor. How's that? Karen Shields (22:38) Hey, leading from the middle. Peter (22:40) Karen, is there any other message you want to get out? Where we think we'll have some Medicaid directors listening to this or Medicaid applicants. Our whole goal is to, sort of pull Medicaid down out of the clouds and help people to understand what it really is, how it really works, how good it really is, how many people it has helped over the last sixty six years, I think it is. Is there one more message you want to get across to people? Other Medicaid directors or Karen Shields (23:03) Yeah, really important. This program needs to be protected. It needs to be optimized, but it needs to be protected. And we can do both. We can do both. We we need to do both. We owe doing both. Peter (23:14) do better. We can do better, we should do better, we will do better. That's a message for Medicaid directors and the folks up on the hill. Karen Shields (23:20) Yeah. All of us. Yeah. Peter (23:22) Excellent. Well, Karen, thanks for spending us time today on Guardians of Care. again on Pete Justen. You know, every conversation on this podcast reminds me that behind every Medicaid application there's a human story. Yours, great example. It's Karen Shields (23:35) Yeah. Peter (23:36) a hand up when somebody needs it. that's why I like the program. You know, every hospital, every state program, every policy decision, that there are real people who were lives are impacted behind this every day. Karen Shields (23:47) That's right. Peter (23:47) And the hundreds of millions of people, that number sticks in my head. Hundreds of millions of people over the last 66 years led better lives, longer lives, healthier lives. Their children were born well and are doing well now. Great example in front of us. And that's kind of why we created the show, right? I wanted to share the good stories, the good aspects of this massive federal program that takes heat every day that really shouldn't. it's unfair that it takes this much heat. So we wanted to share the stories, the challenges, the successes, the good stuff, the bad stuff, and get everybody back to the middle. So if you want to catch future progress on the show, Visit GuardiansofCarePodcast.com. And if you enjoyed today's conversation, I'd appreciate it if you send it along. If you didn't enjoy it, reach out to me directly and we'll fix the next one. Karen, thank you so much. You were an excellent, excellent interview. Karen Shields (24:38) Thank you for having me, sir. Peter (24:40) Anytime, anytime.