Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Innovation Spotlight: AI Utah K-12 Education
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:03and you're listening to the EALA Innovation Spotlight, a quick dive into the
- 0:07ideas and innovations shaping the future of inclusive education.
- 0:12Today, we're thrilled to spotlight the Utah State Board of Education's AI for
- 0:17K-12 Innovation, a program that's scaling AI innovation to transform education
- 0:22and empower future-ready learners.
- 0:24Joining us today is Matt Winters, the USBE AI Specialist. It's so great to have
- 0:30you here today, Matt. Thanks for joining us.
- 0:32So happy to be here, Aurora, and to talk about what's happening here in Utah
- 0:35and how we can support all learners at all stages of their development.
- 0:39Awesome. So kick us off. What sparked this idea? What sparked the AI for K-12
- 0:44Innovation Initiative?
- 0:46Yeah, so this program comes out of some great work that came through the agency,
- 0:52the Utah State Board of Education, over the last about two years.
- 0:55So I was formerly at a place called Utah Education Network.
- 0:59We were one of the first training groups in a statewide capacity to roll out
- 1:03AI training right in, I think it was May 2023, so just over two years ago.
- 1:09And at the same time, Utah State Board of Education was doing some great work
- 1:12internally to understand how AI would affect, and we're talking generative AI,
- 1:17how generative AI would affect Utah learners, Utah educators,
- 1:20the parents, all the systems that we have here in education.
- 1:24And so one of our great, one of my great colleagues here at the agency,
- 1:28Sarah Young, she applied for a grant through Intermountain Healthcare,
- 1:31which is a group of hospitals here in the state of Utah and around the Intermountain West.
- 1:36And they were happy to fund the initiative to quite a bit of cash.
- 1:41And it's taken some time to get that in play, mostly because we want to make
- 1:44sure we have the right initiative here at the agency.
- 1:46And so what this program is, is we recognized through some wonderful work with
- 1:52our community members here in the state of Utah, we, one of the first things
- 1:56I did when I jumped over to USB was run a series of AI summits.
- 2:01Now, a lot of states are doing AI summits. Ours were a little different.
- 2:04Our focal point was actually collaborative conversations first, presentations second.
- 2:10And so we came into a lot of these training or these summits over the course
- 2:16of a couple of weeks last fall and asked our participants,
- 2:20which ended up being between 700 and 900 people across the state of Utah to
- 2:24share what they thought about a series of questions.
- 2:27And these questions were things about how is AI changing education?
- 2:31What are you seeing in terms of how it's changing your individual constituency?
- 2:36What should we be paying attention to in terms of accessibility?
- 2:40How should we be, what should we be thinking about in terms of how this affects
- 2:43our parents, our students, our teachers.
- 2:45And we took all that data and plugged it into an AI, which was really,
- 2:48really helpful. And it synthesized them to a couple of points.
- 2:51And two of the big ones that stuck out were one.
- 2:54Teachers across the state of utah can see how ai is going to affect education
- 2:59it's pretty straightforward that generative ai is going to change what we're
- 3:02doing and we're seeing the ramifications of that happening in real time across
- 3:06k20 not just in k12 but also in higher ed.
- 3:11Yeah i haven't heard that one before k20 like yeah k20 or i usually say k to
- 3:15gray which is also one of my favorite terms and we're also seeing in preschool
- 3:20as well and so So when we've seen the, we're seeing these shifts,
- 3:23but the problem is, is that the teachers can't see themselves in that shift.
- 3:27So they needed, they need content area guidance from experts in the field.
- 3:31And so that was one of the big asks that we got from the community.
- 3:34The other side of it was ongoing professional development. It can't just be a one and done.
- 3:38We come out, do a one-time training program and teachers are good.
- 3:43First of all, that never worked. Yeah, right.
- 3:45But second of all, it really doesn't work with a conversation around something
- 3:49as dynamic and visceral as AI.
- 3:52So those are the two big asks from our community. And so when we had this money
- 3:55in play, we designed a program where the teachers would go through a one hour
- 4:01professional development anywhere in the state. So we will go out and we're
- 4:04doing this all this summer.
- 4:05Our goal is to hit between two and three thousand teachers over the next few months.
- 4:10And we've rolled this out starting on April 1st and we've already gotten about
- 4:13700 teachers through the program,
- 4:14which is really amazing they do one hour
- 4:17in in person in their school and the
- 4:20focal point is three things really one is
- 4:23what is ai and why is it affecting education two what
- 4:28are the safety procedures around artificial intelligence including things like
- 4:32student data privacy and how do i keep myself safe and what's a hallucination
- 4:37what's biased those sorts of things and then getting into what tools are available
- 4:41in their individual constituencies and how to use some of the basic tool types.
- 4:46Like we talk about chatbots, RAG databases, and multimodal AIs,
- 4:51which is really, really helpful for the teachers.
- 4:53Then they're added to a course, an online course, where they can collaborate
- 4:57further for a couple more hours to meet teachers from all of the state,
- 5:01learn more about how to engage AI in their classroom.
- 5:04And at the end, they built a lesson plan that is in their content area and grade
- 5:07level that either teaches students with AI or teaches students about AI.
- 5:13So you might have a lesson that is teaching students about fractions using an
- 5:17AI that makes recipes and fractionalizing the recipe up for one person or 10
- 5:22people or whatever it might be.
- 5:23And then the other side is they might have an ELA teacher, an English language
- 5:28arts teacher, who develops a procedure in their class for using AI appropriately
- 5:33on a research project. And that could be a lesson there.
- 5:35All those lesson plans, once they're finished up and wrapped through,
- 5:39will be available through an OER commons worldwide.
- 5:43This fall, which we're very excited about to get that shared out and have that ready to go.
- 5:47Thanks to the grant, we're able to pay every teacher who gets their lesson plan
- 5:50turned in $200 through DonorsChoose and get them prepared to use that funding
- 5:55for whatever they need for their classroom.
- 5:57So it's a win-win-win for everyone. So what kind of response or impact have you seen so far?
- 6:02I mean, you mentioned there's been a huge outpouring of interest.
- 6:05Any other insights into response or impact?
- 6:09It could be educators, even students or families.
- 6:12You know what's what's what's it what's been like so far yeah
- 6:16we've there's been some amazing things that have come out with over
- 6:19the past year so well just starting off
- 6:22i'll hit three big things so the first one is our community here in utah is
- 6:26massively collaborative i love working with the educators and their technology
- 6:32directors their superintendents across the state of utah i have never been in
- 6:36a community that is so welcoming and so excited to ask questions and challenge.
- 6:42And so one of the big things that came out of that while I was at my,
- 6:45my other post before I moved over here to USB at UEN was that there came a call
- 6:49for, from our technical technology directors community. Hey, we want technology.
- 6:55Cheap, safe, effective AI tools available on consortium pricing.
- 6:59And so over about a year ago, we were able to negotiate through Utah Education
- 7:04Network, statewide consortium pricing for three AI tools for any publicly funded
- 7:09school charter or public district throughout the entire state of Utah.
- 7:14And it was the first of its kind consortium pricing available. And
- 7:18so that one has created some digital
- 7:21equity and an open doors to allow
- 7:24districts to really start bringing these tools into the space alongside
- 7:28of that utah already had several tools that
- 7:31were in the what we call the common good legislatively purchased and so things
- 7:38like adobe nearpod they were already in our statewide systems for free and they've
- 7:42added ai components and so what's great is now i can go to any publicly funded
- 7:48school here in the state of Utah.
- 7:49And I know they have at least two to three tools available to them that have AI in them.
- 7:53And if not, they've already purchased other ones available to them as well.
- 7:58And so that's been a huge shift and it's helping teachers to start integrating
- 8:03these and asking questions and interrogating the process, but also knowing that
- 8:08there's support there from all different layers.
- 8:11The second thing, we did an alpha program to
- 8:14help support what we needed for this larger program before it
- 8:17rolled out through a great program here in utah called
- 8:20the utah stem action center and they offered some funding and we
- 8:23came up with a program we've done that with three cohorts it's about 150 teachers
- 8:27100 150 teachers across the state and we've done programmatic evaluation on
- 8:33on the results from that training now that was a longer training it was two
- 8:36days the teachers really dug into what ai is and but the same end result write a lesson plan.
- 8:43And the, the results from the first two cohorts came in about a month ago, a month and a half ago.
- 8:49And what we see is a full, two full standard deviations up.
- 8:54On their, their growth on every single measure.
- 8:58And that's, that shows that a training works and teachers need that depth,
- 9:03but then also we're seeing an incredible growth in how teachers are perceiving
- 9:08that if they're trained up appropriately.
- 9:10And so we're working with some groups out in the larger community to write that
- 9:14into some research papers so we can share it out with other constituencies as well.
- 9:19The third area is that we've seen really interesting growth is with our higher ed partners.
- 9:25So one of the interesting side notes about what happened with our summits in
- 9:31the fall was that we had higher ed partners come out from across the state,
- 9:35join those summits, and they were asking the same questions at the same time
- 9:38about AI and generative AI as our K-12 teachers were.
- 9:43It was incredible to see that. And so what we've been building on is that partnership
- 9:47of how higher ed needs training, we can support some of them doing that,
- 9:52but also research partnerships and working with them as thought leaders.
- 9:58And last week we had a first of its kind AI leadership summit,
- 10:01Utah Valley University, and we had over, I think it was about 70 to 90 stakeholders
- 10:07from across the state, higher ed, lawmakers, national lawmakers. Yeah.
- 10:12Nonprofits, students, teachers, all of them come into a room and ask some really
- 10:17deep questions around what is AI, how is it affecting educational systems,
- 10:22and where do we want to be in three to five years?
- 10:25And those are sorts of leaps and bounds where we can take that.
- 10:29And I'll show you, sadly, it's a podcast meeting, but I have a whole stack of
- 10:33post-it notes that are feedback from groups that we're going to use AI to synthesize
- 10:37and see where we can actually take actionable items moving forward.
- 10:41So there's been some really amazing things that have happened over the last
- 10:44couple of months, thanks to the work that's happening here in Utah.
- 10:47Listening in from the ELO audience perspective, I know a lot of us are wondering,
- 10:52how can we use this work, or how does this work translate to or benefit all
- 10:58students, including those with learning disabilities or learning differences,
- 11:02or really anybody with a barrier to education?
- 11:06You know, how does the AI innovation support or benefit all students?
- 11:11Such a good question and something that's been on my forefront of my mind for a long time.
- 11:16I mean, I think one of the easiest leaps that people can make when we talk about
- 11:20Gen AI is how this will help personalized learning.
- 11:23I mean, you see it on so many AI websites and there's been so many articles written about it.
- 11:29We forget that personalized learning has been around as a concept for decades
- 11:33and it's a difficult, you know, or we We can talk about project-based learning,
- 11:38any of these like in-depth teacher procedures, they take time,
- 11:43they take effort and AI is a way to maybe speed that up and really get to a
- 11:47place where we can actually have those things happen.
- 11:49But what we forget is that the progression that we see with AI adoption is largely three areas.
- 11:56First is the speed at which you can do things. So it's this like.
- 12:02Hey, I can, I can make a lesson plan faster. I can kind of speed things up for
- 12:06me doing the administrative actions that I need to do in my classroom.
- 12:10I can write an email faster, those sorts of things.
- 12:13If it stops there, Gen AI is, is null and void.
- 12:17I mean, it's, it, it stops being something that is really interesting and unique
- 12:20in our educational system.
- 12:21And it just becomes another tool to speed up things that have never really pushed
- 12:27the needle on education.
- 12:28The second layer is creativity. And so
- 12:31we need to start shifting and I'm starting to see a shift across different constituencies
- 12:35of how AI can be used as a tool for creativity in our classrooms and encouraging
- 12:41teachers to really think through how can I use or use AI to make really interesting
- 12:47decisions in my classrooms.
- 12:49Like, for instance, I have this wonderful teacher in the cohort from the STEM
- 12:52action center, who she said, I'm going to create an AI generated comic book
- 12:57with my students to read a book.
- 12:58And I went, that's really, really cool. Now the book was Harry Potter when she
- 13:02was like, I'm reading at the end of the year, this comic book idea sounds really cool.
- 13:06And I said, well, I, it's been like decades since I've read Harry Potter.
- 13:09I'm not one of those Harry Potter people, but I do know one thing about Harry
- 13:14Potter is that they have a thing called a sorting hat.
- 13:16What if you were to make an AI sorting hat? um
- 13:19through a chat bot and she went could i do that and i
- 13:22went i don't know i love that you have
- 13:25time today for two hours to just try it out two hours
- 13:29later she had gone to i think she was on iteration 10
- 13:328 or 10 re-read redesigning the constitution reprogramming it trying it out
- 13:37and then she had almost every person in that room play test it and see if it
- 13:41actually worked if she walked away with this sorting hat that was actually functional
- 13:45in her classroom really really cool thing but that's creativity,
- 13:49seeing the possibilities,
- 13:51looking at this as a tool that can help us do things that we would never have been able to do before.
- 13:57The third layer, though, and I think this is the most important one for me right
- 14:00now, and I think it's going to be for a long time, is inclusivity.
- 14:05How can AI be leveraged as a tool to meet the needs of populations that have
- 14:10been traditionally underserved in our educational system?
- 14:13So whether that's a student with a disability, a multilingual learner,
- 14:17or gifted and talented, I always
- 14:20think about them as well, because I was a student in an English class.
- 14:23That if you, you know, if I finished a project earlier, I was tutoring another
- 14:27student and that didn't help me.
- 14:28It helped the other student, but AI can be a pathway to give those students
- 14:32extension activities that would really benefit them.
- 14:35So what we've been doing, I'm not
- 14:36an expert on any of those three areas or inclusivity in education periods.
- 14:40So I think what's important, those of us who are AI experts or ed tech experts,
- 14:46is starting to look at the communities in which we exist, whether it's your district,
- 14:50your school, in my case, statewide educational systems, and finding the experts
- 14:56who are doing the work on those things and asking them,
- 14:58what does the tools look like when we think about Gen AI in those kind of classroom
- 15:03environments for those particular types of students?
- 15:06And then also asking the companies who make tools to think through looking at
- 15:12those different populations as well and looking for ways to encourage those
- 15:16and so encourage better use.
- 15:18So I've been looking at a lot of tools that are doing specialized things for
- 15:21like speech language pathology or for multilingual learners to do live translations
- 15:27in the classroom from student to educator, educator to student,
- 15:31and then doing really cool extension activities with our gifted and talented.
- 15:36And so here in Utah in the fall, we're working on a couple of projects that will support.
- 15:41Teacher professional development on those items, as well as working with those
- 15:47experts to see where the gaps are so we can inform the companies on,
- 15:51hey, this is what we might need in those particular systems to support those students.
- 15:56And so, again, I think the progression from productivity to creativity to inclusivity
- 16:02is very important with AI, and we need to be cognizant in thinking through all those layers.
- 16:06So if there are other state leaders or school systems out
- 16:09there who are exploring ai and education i know
- 16:12there are a lot of lessons learned along the way can you think of
- 16:15maybe like one lesson that you've learned that
- 16:18you want to share with other state leaders or school system
- 16:21leaders that are exploring ai and education
- 16:24where do you begin yeah yeah so for me it goes back to it's not about the technology
- 16:31it's about the community in which you live so in utah like i said earlier we're
- 16:36very like collaborative like
- 16:37i know at least one person in every district I can go to and say, hey.
- 16:42You know we've met let's have a conversation about
- 16:45what you need or multiple people and and i
- 16:48can really dig into what they their their needs are a
- 16:51lot of the charter schools are the same way i know at least one person where i can work
- 16:54that through now utah geographically is massive
- 16:57but population wise it's smaller we have 41 public school districts soon to
- 17:01be 43 and about 130 charter schools which just comparison point for audiences
- 17:07there's i was recently in massachusetts i had a conversation in Ohio and I had
- 17:12a conversation in Texas and we're looking at 400,
- 17:15600 and 1200 districts in those, those individual states.
- 17:18And so it's harder when you have that massive amount of people or the again,
- 17:23geographic differences.
- 17:25And so I would say, look for collaborative systems though, find your key people
- 17:29in areas and start having conversations with that, with them.
- 17:33We have a once a month meeting here in Utah with all of our
- 17:35coaches and technology directors where we get together and talk through the
- 17:39needs not just around ai but ed tech in general and we learn together and learn
- 17:44from each other and we share i think that's super valuable and is underrated
- 17:49when we talk about any large-scale chain initiative change initiative let alone
- 17:54artificial intelligence.
- 17:56There the other two things are that kind of
- 17:59go along with that are number one you you need
- 18:02to have a a system and encourage
- 18:05a system in which expertise is
- 18:08shared fluidly and dynamically so you
- 18:12may have expertise on a particular ed tech tool or
- 18:15a thought process for you know going back to my last example students with disabilities
- 18:20or multilingual learners and being able to step up and say i do have expertise
- 18:24here's what i know let's share that and so here in utah i've been and very lucky
- 18:28with AI because we have great teams across the state, not just in education,
- 18:33that are great in policy and legislative action.
- 18:38People who are really good in data privacy. We have people who are really exceptional,
- 18:42in understanding students with disabilities.
- 18:44And so I can go to those teams and ask my questions and really understand what's
- 18:48going on. And that should be a large part of the larger community.
- 18:54And so when we dig into AI and change-making and people who are in statewide
- 19:00or school-less system leaders,
- 19:02look for those collaborative situations, look for expertise being shared,
- 19:06and encourage that in your system because that way you're including everyone
- 19:10and you're going to learn a lot along the way.
- 19:13That's what I've learned is I've learned that I only knew so much and now I've
- 19:18known a little bit more, but I can, I have a community that I can rely on,
- 19:21which is the most important part.
- 19:22I love that. It all comes back to community. Yep. That's great.
- 19:25Where can folks, we're almost out of time for today. So where can folks head
- 19:29to learn more, stay connected with your work, with the Utah State Board of Ed?
- 19:34You know, how can folks stay, stay involved and get engaged?
- 19:37Yeah, absolutely. I'm on LinkedIn, me personally. So just look at Matthew when
- 19:40he's, he's the one with the beard and the white streak and it's pretty easy to find.
- 19:45And then for anything that's happening with Utah State Board of Education,
- 19:48you can go to schools.utah.gov.
- 19:50We have a lot of AI work that's going to be posted over the next couple of months.
- 19:54We've, I've kind of been backlogging projects and I'm excited to get some of
- 19:58them out into the public over the next few months, just because, you know.
- 20:01I want to make sure we're doing the right actions as well as there's lots of
- 20:05great things happening at Utah State Board of Education, things like our Portrait
- 20:07of a Graduate Project that was finalized a few years ago, the work around personalized
- 20:12competency-based learning, which ties in right now, right in with personalized learning,
- 20:16our digital teaching and learning program. So if you're interested,
- 20:18you can always reach out.
- 20:20My email is matt.winners at schools.utah.gov, and I'm always happy to collaborate.
- 20:24I love that. Well, thank you so much for joining us today, Matt.
- 20:27It was really great to learn about this incredible work you're doing.
- 20:29Thanks for joining us. Absolutely.
- 20:33All right. That's it for us today, folks. Thank you to my guest, Matt Winters.
- 20:37I'm Aurora from EALA, and this was an Innovation Spotlight with the Utah State Board of Education.