Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Political theatre, hydrogen headaches, and crude constraints
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:07the UK energy market, oil, political theatre, hydrogen
- 0:12headaches and pricey oil. That's a lot to speak about if
- 0:15you're just me. Aberdeen features lead Ryan
- 0:17Duff. But thankfully I've got our
- 0:19crack team of reporters with me this week.
- 0:21How are you doing? Michael Baer, renewables
- 0:24reporter. I'm good as always.
- 0:25I like to bring a bit of energy to the the start of the podcast,
- 0:29so I'm excited to sink my teeth into all this oily news.
- 0:34I'm, I'm glad you're bringing energy because myself and news
- 0:37reporter Matt Perry have been on the early shift this morning, so
- 0:39we might be a little bit sleepy. How are you doing today, Matt?
- 0:42You've got it in one, Ryan. I am a little bit sleepy this
- 0:44morning but someone's got to get up and, you know, scan the
- 0:48headlines and all the news coming through early days.
- 0:50And Floyd, our NW correspondent, you've been thinking about all
- 0:54things hydrogen this week, but what's been happening outside of
- 0:57that? Yeah.
- 0:57So lots of stuff really. But I feel like I'm in the
- 1:00middle of energy levels between Matt Ryan and Michael.
- 1:04So yeah, maybe I'm a bit not as up as Michael, but yeah, not as
- 1:09mellow as Matt, I probably say is where I am.
- 1:11In the Goldilocks. Yeah, exactly that.
- 1:14Well, let's, let's have let's have Michael burn some energy in
- 1:17the opening segment. And I want to speak to you about
- 1:20Westminster. This week we saw the Commons
- 1:23reject A proposed bill from the Conservatives that would have
- 1:29resulted in more drilling in the North Sea.
- 1:32You had a really interesting take on this when we were
- 1:35chatting yesterday. I'd like to hear hear your kind
- 1:38of two cents on the situation. Yeah, it's it's an interesting
- 1:41one. Now it's hard to tell this now
- 1:42that we all know the ending because this kind of broke over
- 1:46the the weekend. We had some conservative
- 1:49politicians, we had Claire continue and Andrew Bowie
- 1:52obviously big into the, you know, as the shadow edit energy
- 1:56cabinet that they were basically saying, right, we're going to
- 2:01force a vote in Parliament to amend The King's Speech to do 2
- 2:05things. One approved two of the the big
- 2:09bugbear oil and gas fields, Jackdaw and Rosebank, and also
- 2:14to allow additional drilling licenses to be issued across the
- 2:19North Sea. Now I think the the question we
- 2:22had was right, does this actually stand a chance?
- 2:25Is this actually going to to go through or is it just political
- 2:30theatre? Let's just take a vote.
- 2:31I mean also knowing how this ends, who?
- 2:34Who says it actually had a chance?
- 2:36Well, I think, I think the Tories know that they're,
- 2:38they're not, you know, they're not sort of beating out the, the
- 2:41Labour vote in the Commons anytime soon really.
- 2:44You know, we've, we've seen sort of political upheaval over the
- 2:47past few days, a few weeks, but that was that was all at a
- 2:51council level or in a holy rood and the Senate and the Wales.
- 2:56So we, I, I don't, you know, the, the state of the state of
- 3:00Labour's grasp on the, the, the Westminster decision hasn't
- 3:05changed, although there has been some flux in in the party, I
- 3:09think is a polite way to describe it.
- 3:11But yeah, I feel like this was more this was more Cami bed Knox
- 3:16approach to try and sorry, solidify and maybe try to almost
- 3:21make good on the the comments that she's been making since
- 3:24offshore Europe last year of, you know, we should be drill,
- 3:26baby drill kind of mentality. And that's that, you know, like
- 3:30maybe this was the part and in time to do that after the energy
- 3:34futures bill announced that would essentially ban any
- 3:37exploration licenses being handed out.
- 3:39So, yeah, I don't think they they would have really consider
- 3:43that it would have went through. But I think in these things, you
- 3:45kind of just have to take a punt and see what happens, right?
- 3:48Yeah, I mean, let's be fair. If they were going to do it, now
- 3:50is probably the time because obviously we've had, like, you
- 3:54see, political upheavals. Labour is looking a little shaky
- 3:57at the top. And to be fair, we have seen
- 3:59dissent in Labour's ranks over its clean energy focus policy.
- 4:04You know, there are plenty of people who've come out and said,
- 4:06yeah, we should be backing the North Sea.
- 4:10But again, we know how it ended. It ended in a Conservative
- 4:13defeat quite considerably, a majority of 215.
- 4:17And I think perhaps, you know, there's is it a bad habit to try
- 4:22and read too much into the results because obviously we
- 4:24have, we saw the SNP abstained, but we also saw quite a few
- 4:28reform MPs decide to to join them.
- 4:32So I don't know if that was kind of trying to give the finger to
- 4:36the Conservatives and say, right, we're not on your side.
- 4:39We're the we're the new Conservative Party.
- 4:41We're not following. Your well, I think it's
- 4:43interesting, isn't it? There is always party
- 4:45politicking, you know, whenever we're speaking about anything
- 4:50like this. But then with the SNP in
- 4:52particular, it's an interesting point because right now we kind
- 4:57of don't know their stance. You know, they, they've get, you
- 5:00know, they've said they want to be sort of, you know, sort of
- 5:02engaging with the oil and gas industry, you know, and it's
- 5:05like a case by case basis is kind of how they have said they
- 5:08would determine oil and gas licenses.
- 5:12So that's slightly different, I guess to the, the current
- 5:15situation with, with Labour, which is just no exploration at
- 5:18all and it's just our near field Timex and so on and so forth.
- 5:22However, we don't actually know if that's the case.
- 5:25Just this morning I was writing about how OUK were sort of
- 5:30demanding that the the Scottish Government know that they're
- 5:34fully formed would be it would be delivering, it should be
- 5:38delivering its three-year delayed energy strategy.
- 5:43If if you remember in 2023, January 2023 of all time, it was
- 5:49it was sort of announced that this draft strategy where they'd
- 5:52essentially under Nicola Sturgeon had said they'd have
- 5:55this quote, presumption against new oil and gas operations.
- 5:59Now over the campaign trail for the holy rood elections, John
- 6:03Swinney did kind of soften that. And we've obviously seen someone
- 6:07who you could argue might be, might be up for taking Gillian
- 6:10Martin's role as energy secretary.
- 6:12And, you know, that would be Stephen Flynn, who's my local MP
- 6:17in Aberdeen S MSP in Aberdeen S sorry.
- 6:20He, you know, he said there'd be no greater champion for the oil
- 6:23and gas industry than him and Hollywood.
- 6:26So they were getting mixed signals.
- 6:28We're not really sure where they stand.
- 6:31And maybe, you know, the this is this was an opportunity to put
- 6:34their money where their mouth was and they just didn't.
- 6:36Yeah, I feel like they're not ready to to come down.
- 6:39They, I think we don't know where they stand.
- 6:42They don't seem to know where they stand.
- 6:44I think that, you know, we, we say the softened, I think it
- 6:47was, you know, I got into a huddle with John Swinney and all
- 6:49anyone wanted to ask him was so the presumption against oil and
- 6:53gas and it by the sense of it, it's gone back into consultation
- 6:56or consideration. So it's gone from a firm to OK,
- 7:01it's we're considering it. So, yeah, no idea.
- 7:05But I think, you know, the big question now is sort of, well,
- 7:09what were the Conservatives going to achieve with with this
- 7:12vote? Because it does feel like it was
- 7:14resoundingly defeated. They probably went into it
- 7:16without really a hope. Was it to a certain extent them
- 7:21trying to create a rod for for Labour to be like Luke?
- 7:24We were definitely the ones backing oil and gas.
- 7:27They had the opportunity and they said no.
- 7:30I mean, yeah, it could definitely be building again.
- 7:32I mentioned offshore Europe last year and Kimmy Bad Knock and and
- 7:36Michael Shang's both showed up in the first day and Aberdeen
- 7:39for that conference last year. And you know, the way that that
- 7:44was set up, you know, Michael Shanks kind of gave like quite a
- 7:48standard speech that we, you know, anyone who goes to these
- 7:50conferences has probably heard a similar kind of thing.
- 7:53Oh, it was. A beautiful.
- 7:55I'm just going to interrupt. It was beautiful because he'd
- 7:57obviously had the standard speech.
- 8:00Kenny spoke first with her very bold pro oil and gas.
- 8:03And you were like, you could just imagine him sitting
- 8:06backstage, like scribbling notes.
- 8:07OK, we got to react to that. We got to react.
- 8:09To that well, that's it and Kimmy but Kimmy Badenoch almost
- 8:11came out like a like a rock star like she she came out and I
- 8:15don't say that lightly. I don't think many people have
- 8:19ever described Kimmy Badenoch as that.
- 8:21She's she's far from far from a, you know, a rock band front
- 8:25front woman. But she did kind of, you know,
- 8:29come out and sort of go, you know, essentially, you know, we
- 8:32love you guys to the oil and gas industry.
- 8:35And this was after she'd she'd had a media get together at the
- 8:39Port of Aberdeen. She'd she'd scrambled from
- 8:43airport of Aberdeen over to the PNG live in time for the start
- 8:46of the conference. Yeah, it felt a little bit like,
- 8:50you know, that that was, you know, that was her dividing line
- 8:54for Scotland at least maybe I mean, and probably north of
- 8:57England as well. Thought you could jump in on
- 8:59this. But it feels like, you know,
- 9:01that they're how they're trying to win votes and let's face it,
- 9:04regions that they don't typically secure very many is by
- 9:09begging up the we are losing, you know, hundreds of jobs a
- 9:13week. So the the the data that were UK
- 9:15and such have sort of put forward and saying, you know,
- 9:19we're against this, we're in, we're all for oil and gas.
- 9:22Do you see that as there's the sort of strategy that the Tories
- 9:26are trying to follow in north of England as well for it?
- 9:29A little bit maybe not so much oil and gas because like unlike
- 9:32the Aberdeen folk like the North Sea feels like 1,000,000 miles
- 9:36away from the northwest. Like obviously people understand
- 9:39like the the need for more oil and gas exploration.
- 9:44So, so that debate's there, but it's more to talk about energy
- 9:48security more than jobs itself because I'm not sure how like
- 9:54talking about Aberdeen jobs or North Sea jobs will like land,
- 9:57you know, in maker field where I am.
- 9:59So I think it, it's the the same conversation but with, with a
- 10:03slightly different angle Talking about energy security.
- 10:07Yeah, not sure how it how it lands overall, because obviously
- 10:10we've got high net in the Northwest, which is like the
- 10:12main jobs thing. So people kind of like are quite
- 10:17positive towards, you know, CCS infrastructure and other
- 10:20technologies. But it goes back to that just
- 10:23conversation of abundance. Like why can't it be both?
- 10:26Like why can't we invest in hydrogen and CCS, but also
- 10:30invest in the North Sea and a lot more drilling?
- 10:33Like it seems to be like a pretty British conversation
- 10:37where it's kind of just like we've got to have one or the
- 10:39other. So then that's where the
- 10:40battlegrounds are on the on the regional level, but you're.
- 10:43Right in the heart of it now, Floyd, because the the, you
- 10:47know, being in Makersfield, the the political fate of the UK, or
- 10:50at least for the next couple of years, is now in your hands.
- 10:53Yeah, it's amazing. Like everyone door knocking
- 10:56yesterday I was like up and down all day and it's like by
- 10:59elections are normally so boring but it's crazy to be in the
- 11:02constituency which is probably the biggest by election in like
- 11:05British history. Like with the fate of the UK in
- 11:10in the hands of like a few thousand people in Makerfield is
- 11:13kind of funny but also kind of scary.
- 11:16My next door neighbour's got a massive reform sign like hanging
- 11:20out of his Bush and it kind of looks like it's on my drive.
- 11:22So. So yeah, I might have to take
- 11:24that down in the dead of night, but but yeah, interesting times
- 11:27that. Well, who are you going to
- 11:29replace it with? Floyd?
- 11:30Come on, let's put you on the spot.
- 11:31I don't. Know maybe just like a big
- 11:34upside down picture of Andy Burnham.
- 11:36So it's not necessarily an endorsement, but more of like a
- 11:38a cover up of of the reform banner.
- 11:41Well, there we go. So I mean, we're, we're, we're
- 11:44talking a talking on sort of oil and gas policy and that and
- 11:47thing I feel like if you keep mentioning like the and other
- 11:50energy sources, you might end up getting one of those T-shirts
- 11:53from over UK because they do, they do love trotting out the
- 11:56oil and gas and wind and hydrogen and CCS T-shirts.
- 12:01So maybe you'll get one of those.
- 12:02But we will stick around on the diversified nature of UK energy
- 12:08after this break because we still don't know what we're
- 12:10doing with hydrogen. Hello, I'm Andrea, the editor of
- 12:14E Ford. E Ford is a membership community
- 12:17that brings together the entire UK energy supply chain, every
- 12:21hub, every sector, every stage. Our aim is to deliver growth to
- 12:25the energy sector, working with industry and policy makers to
- 12:28unlock the UK's opportunities and advantages.
- 12:32This is the movement to secure increased investment, improved
- 12:35policy making and better collaboration by providing our
- 12:38members with visibility, influence and access.
- 12:41Join me forward today. So Floyd, you mentioned high net
- 12:50just before the break that obviously has a massive hydrogen
- 12:52component as well. Where you were at Hydrogen week
- 12:56this this week. You, you know, you had some
- 12:58interesting things to share when you came back to the desk.
- 13:01What's the, what's the vibe? What's happening?
- 13:05Well, there's, there's lots to uncover really, because first of
- 13:08all, it was is quite a good event in terms of honest
- 13:11conversations, but it wasn't as pessimistic as some of the other
- 13:14events I've been to recently as in Teesside a few months back.
- 13:17And I think like everyone left the room probably assuming like
- 13:20they're going to lose their job within a year because the
- 13:22hydrogen economy is just going to flop.
- 13:24But this one was a bit more of a fairer assessment.
- 13:26And I think that kind of shows how high net is probably like a
- 13:30lot more further along the process than maybe the Northeast
- 13:34is, which is probably what the main theme of the event was.
- 13:38But it was kind of a tale of two halves.
- 13:40It had that the the typical where's the hydrogen strategy?
- 13:46Where's the updated business models, like when's hard to win
- 13:49is going to be announced. When's half three, all that
- 13:51stuff. Will Knight was there and he
- 13:54actually stayed all day and he was just getting peppered with
- 13:56those questions and no one would ask him anything positive in the
- 13:59yeah, his ears were like bright red from like the first minute
- 14:02to the end of the day. I ended up feeling quite bad for
- 14:05him but obviously the the sector are going to ask him those
- 14:08questions. Well, do you know how he gets
- 14:10those questions to stop? We get hydrogen strategy and we
- 14:14get hard to. Pretty simple really, but yeah,
- 14:19but but there was a lot of optimism ET looking at getting a
- 14:24final investment decision at the Stanley Refinery for blue
- 14:27hydrogen production this year, which will kick off a lot of
- 14:30like more positive hydrogen stuff for the for the high net
- 14:34hydrogen aspect, but also just for hydrogen more widely in the
- 14:39sector. There's loads of other hydrogen
- 14:40projects happening outside of high net and ET get in this fit.
- 14:45Just it just brought a little bit more optimism in the room in
- 14:49terms of the fact that there will be some kind of hydrogen
- 14:52economy, maybe not 2022 hype cycle levels, but you know it is
- 14:56actually going to going to happen in the.
- 14:59Northwest, we've seen some positive news.
- 15:00I've been Scotland in the on the hydrogen in front of the last
- 15:03week, we saw stragglers managed to offload its Scottish green
- 15:08hydrogen development portfolio, which includes its flagship
- 15:12Cromity hydrogen project that was sort of focused on
- 15:15decarbonizing whiskey distilleries in the Highlands.
- 15:17And it was one of the, you know, three Scottish projects to
- 15:21secure support in the first hydrogen allocation round.
- 15:23But there's been sort of a real step back in the last year on
- 15:27kind of that initial enthusiasm. We saw Scottish Power as kind
- 15:31of, you know, they, they pulled out of the Cromartie hydrogen
- 15:35project last year. They've also, you know, paused
- 15:38their development, the Whiteley hydrogen project to South of
- 15:42Glasgow. And so it was a real kind of a,
- 15:45you know, I think similar to what you were saying, Floyd, a
- 15:47real kind of a reckoning last year in Swedish green hydrogen
- 15:50of how exactly, you know, big is this opportunity going to be and
- 15:54when where's the, the demand coming from?
- 15:57And I guess so Prodium, which is a london-based hydrogen
- 16:02developer has snapped up strike is Scottish green hydrogen
- 16:05portfolio. And so I guess you know, the
- 16:09Surrega was flogging it for very cheap.
- 16:10There wasn't a a price tag on the the deal, but you know, at
- 16:16least there is some enthusiasm and Prodiums got some already
- 16:20projects in development in South Tees and Wales which was
- 16:22shortlisted and hired to. So they're they're not coming
- 16:25into this with with no pedigree whatsoever.
- 16:27So it's, yeah, I guess positive on the up here north of the
- 16:30border as well. I mean, is it a very British
- 16:32problem that we have? Because I know that people at
- 16:35all energy, we're talking about Scotland.
- 16:37We've obviously seen a few, you know, offshore winds project
- 16:42coming through Scotland kind of failing, falling by the wayside,
- 16:46getting kind of indefinitely shelled.
- 16:48And I think it was clear Mac currently and not so long for
- 16:53Scottish renewables, the she was saying, look, Scotland was
- 16:57incredibly ambitious that we knew there was going to be a
- 17:01symmetrician. Is there a sort of weird
- 17:02psychological thing in Britain where we'll go very big on
- 17:05something? For example, you know, we'll get
- 17:07a really enthusiastic for hydrogen in, in the kind of
- 17:10assumption that, look, we're, we know we're going big.
- 17:13We know that certain products are going to fall by the
- 17:15wayside. But then the moment that
- 17:17happens, what I've done, it's over, it's feeling.
- 17:20Which is the natural British pessimism going going there,
- 17:24that's what that is. But.
- 17:26We have plated by being too optimistic at the start and then
- 17:29the moment things fall apart, the pessimism.
- 17:31Comes back or is it, is it pessimism from the start in the
- 17:34sense that it's like, well, if we allocate loads of this stuff,
- 17:37then at least one of them is going to get delivered, surely,
- 17:40right. But yeah, I mean, I thought that
- 17:43was quite an interesting, interesting comment that Claire
- 17:46made. And you know what it was?
- 17:48It was echoed by Gillian Morrison from Crown of the head
- 17:52of wind development at Crown Estate Scotland, which is the
- 17:56the sea, the sea bed landlord up here.
- 17:59You know, she was saying a similar kind of thing of there's
- 18:01always attrition in, in licensing rounds regard, you
- 18:05know, and that's, you know, we see that in oil and gas.
- 18:07And that was part of the reason why we're pivoting to these
- 18:09transitional energy certificates with the North Sea is because
- 18:13essentially the past couple of licensing rounds haven't
- 18:16delivered as much as, you know, you would expect.
- 18:19So when it comes to that, Floyd, when, you know, when we're
- 18:22calling for hard to winners and we've seen the the issues with
- 18:26hard one. Do you think that's maybe like
- 18:29that pessimism of ah, yeah. But see, everything's already
- 18:31kind of knackered. Do you think that's causing
- 18:35these delays? You're not something that's
- 18:36maybe disrupting, yeah. A little bit, I guess, but like
- 18:41just to just to go to back to what we was talking about just
- 18:44then, like RWW, we were saying very much the same thing Mike's
- 18:47just mentioned like things are going to fall off, but things
- 18:50will like things will come through.
- 18:52And obviously they work across Europe.
- 18:54And I spoke to life a couple weeks back as well and they were
- 18:57saying like the for British people, like the grass is always
- 19:00greener. Like they think that France and
- 19:02Germany have the best hydrogen strategies, but people in
- 19:05Germany and France look at the allocation round one for
- 19:09hydrogen and wish that they had it.
- 19:10So I think that adds to the pessimism.
- 19:13But I think people are just impatient.
- 19:15And I think the the 2022 hype cycle of hydrogen was so high
- 19:20that like the come down is always gonna be massive from
- 19:22that. And I think that's why there's a
- 19:24lot of pessimism. Like I can't, I can't remember
- 19:26whose presentation it was, but they had like a timeline of how
- 19:29they see the hydrogen economy in the UK and they had that the
- 19:33hydrogen strategy comes out in Q2 this year.
- 19:36And like two or three people in the audience like laughed and
- 19:39sniggered, which I thought was quite funny seeing as it was a
- 19:42room of like hydrogen enthusiasts and hydrogen
- 19:45workers. So I think that there's that
- 19:48optimism, but the underbelly of pessimism is just so much
- 19:51stronger it seems in the energy sector at the moment that I feel
- 19:56like that's what kind of takes control, if that makes sense of
- 19:59the of the narrative, but also. I think there's sort of a
- 20:03difference between the pessimism and optimism, between the
- 20:06industry and the sort of the policy makers.
- 20:09So a lot of time there's a lot of enthusiasm on the industry
- 20:12side. They just are waiting for things
- 20:14like a hydrogen strategy to be published in time.
- 20:17And then when the government sets these massive targets, you
- 20:21know, we're going to have 10 gigawatts of hydrogen, you know,
- 20:24by this year. And then I guess then they they
- 20:27laid to sour on that when they realized potentially how much
- 20:30that that might cost, you know, so and they seem to be never In
- 20:35Sync with each other because I guess I'm speaking to some of
- 20:39the people at All Energy. Last week there was still, you
- 20:42know, a lot of enthusiasm for some hydrogen projects in
- 20:44Scotland, but just, you know, very hard for businesses to make
- 20:48those final investment decisions without certainty on what the
- 20:52transport and storage mechanisms are going to be.
- 20:55Still, you know, so there's just a lot of uncertainty, which I
- 21:00think is contributing to that. Yeah.
- 21:04And I put a similar question to Will Knight on one of his panels
- 21:08because he was saying about how when the strategy comes, it'd be
- 21:12great and that like, you know, your Wes, your cadence and that
- 21:16are ready and waiting. So then that will be when
- 21:18there's some synergy. So I asked him what about the
- 21:20Tier 2 and Tier 3 companies? Because I've often spoke to
- 21:24people on the like the lower level of the supply chain and
- 21:27and they're getting funding at the moment to service debt
- 21:30rather than like make stuff, fund innovation, fund research.
- 21:33So I said, I put the question to him of do we risk losing the
- 21:37supply chain that's going to help the RW, ES and Cadence
- 21:40build the build this hydrogen infrastructure before we even
- 21:43begin And naturally got the wishy washy answer of like
- 21:48nothing to be to be frank. But that is, I mean, the, the
- 21:52supply chain engagement is something that we're hearing
- 21:54across the breadth of the energy sector, right.
- 21:57And if the, if we aren't delivering projects, that is
- 22:00something that has a real, can have a real impact on our
- 22:03potential to deliver these projects that are in the
- 22:06pipeline that are likely to go through.
- 22:08So I think the very valid question difficult one for a man
- 22:12in his position to to answer the but I guess I did.
- 22:16I did want to ask you didn't wasn't there a vote that you
- 22:19told me about at this this event?
- 22:22That I really want I'd. Really like you to share.
- 22:25So it was really awkward actually.
- 22:27Like so they had this like myth busting session, which I thought
- 22:31was really cool. So basically the panel host gave
- 22:36the panelists all 5 minutes to kind of try and myth bust
- 22:41something on the hydrogen sector.
- 22:42So one was that like EVs are better for long haul hydrogens,
- 22:48like too dangerous to have in homes, stuff like that right?
- 22:52And then basically they would pitch for 5 minutes trying to
- 22:55myth bus, which I thought was it was a cool idea, but it was
- 22:58weird in a room full of hydrogen people.
- 23:00So I just assumed that everyone vote yes.
- 23:02This myth preaching to the. Choir kind of thing.
- 23:05Yeah, exactly. So on the first one the the lady
- 23:12was talking about Ev's been better for heavy goods vehicles
- 23:17and when the vote came in people voted that she hadn't busted the
- 23:22myth, which I thought was quite funny considering it was a room
- 23:26full of hydrogen people. I was one of those, and I don't
- 23:32want to be mean or come across offensive, but like before, I
- 23:36thought that Ev's would be better, but her argument was
- 23:38kind of so bad that it convinced me the other way around.
- 23:43So. So yeah, it was really awkward.
- 23:46And that was the first myth. So we'd kind of just set this
- 23:49really awkward tone afterwards because the woman had obviously
- 23:53prepared for everyone to say yes, I'd be really happy with
- 23:55herself, but she had to sit on stage for another like 20
- 23:58minutes. So yeah, kind of felt bad.
- 24:00But yeah, it was really awkward and quite fun.
- 24:03And then I'm not sure we got time, but I had another awkward
- 24:06interaction where like a pro high knot, which is like the
- 24:11fans of the podcast will know the the NIMBY group that I
- 24:14always bash. I got accosted by one of the
- 24:17high knot advocates and he'd let me know how bias energy voice
- 24:21was because it didn't fit into his worldview of CCS.
- 24:24So had to listen to that for a while.
- 24:26Well, there we go. So I mean, if you if you do want
- 24:28to to file complaints, Floyd will be a show floor near you
- 24:31and you can tell him all about how you you disagree with what
- 24:35you said on the podcast. But stick around because after
- 24:38this break, you might be saying more that you disagree with.
- 24:40Who knows? Be the first to hear breaking
- 24:43energy news through the energy voice app, available to download
- 24:48for free. You get features like saving the
- 24:51articles you want to return to access to the energy voice
- 24:55supplement. You can read exclusive E Forward
- 24:58content and even listen to the Energy Voice Out Loud podcast.
- 25:02If you work in the UK energy sector.
- 25:05Stay in the loop by saving the Energy Voice app to your home
- 25:08screen. Download the app through the
- 25:10Apple App Store or Google Play for breaking energy news on the
- 25:15go by searching Energy Voice app.
- 25:18Looking at the the the price of oil this morning, it's, it's
- 25:22back up to climbing, isn't it? It's, it's not the the $100 plus
- 25:27they used to be $88 touching 89 at the time of recording.
- 25:33Matt, you've been speaking a little bit about how ongoing
- 25:37conflict in the Middle East is been impacting the state of the
- 25:42global, global energy market, right?
- 25:44Yeah. Well, Wood McKenzie has put out
- 25:46a scenario analysis this week on, I guess, a few different
- 25:52scenarios on how long the Strait of Hormuz will remain closed
- 25:56for. And I guess the headline for
- 25:58that is, you know, came out of it is oil prices could reach
- 26:03$200 per barrel, but there's a big emphasis on there that could
- 26:08there. So that's under the worst case
- 26:11scenario. So currently that Wood McKenzie
- 26:15said that more than 11,000,000 barrels per day of Gulf crude
- 26:18and condensate is currently curtailed.
- 26:21And, you know, it's also affected more than, I think, the
- 26:24kind of the rate of 80 million tons per annum of LNG supply
- 26:28that's we all know, equivalent to around 20% of the global
- 26:31market. So if this remains closed for
- 26:35for much longer, we've seen what Kennedy is saying, that this
- 26:38would become far more than an energy crisis because it's, you
- 26:41know, we're already seeing protests across parts of Africa.
- 26:44We're seeing a lot of, you know, inflation and energy challenges
- 26:48in places like the Philippines and Sri Lanka.
- 26:51And so I guess the longer the disruption persists would
- 26:54because you said the greater the impact on not just energy
- 26:56prices, but industrial activity, trade flows, economic growth.
- 27:01So I guess we'll go through the the three different scenarios
- 27:05under the most optimistic, which is what they call the quick
- 27:08peace scenario. See a workable settlement is
- 27:11reached in the near term and the straight reopens by by June.
- 27:14It's quite, quite an optimistic one, but we'd all we like to see
- 27:17that. I was a way to say that feels I,
- 27:20I guess when you're doing these modelling scenarios, you've got
- 27:22to go from the most optimistic you can be in like the, in like
- 27:27the first scenario to like the most pessimistic you can be in
- 27:30the last and then kind of strike a balance in the middle, right?
- 27:33That's kind of the approach. Yeah.
- 27:35So in that scenario, you know, we'd see the global economy
- 27:37broadly returning to its pre war trajectory by the fourth quarter
- 27:41of 2026. You know, dated Brent crude
- 27:43would ease to around $80 a barrel by the end of the year,
- 27:46maybe soften to 65 per barrel through 2027 as the oil market
- 27:50returns to oversupply. And we'd see global GDP growth
- 27:55slowing to around 2.3% in this scenario, which would see
- 28:00recession confined to the the Middle East, kind of the mid
- 28:04range scenario, which they've called the summer settlement.
- 28:07And that kind of assumes A ceasefire hold.
- 28:09But you know, negotiations extend into late summer around
- 28:12August or so with the straight remaining close until September.
- 28:16And in that scenario, we'd see oil and LNG shortages persisting
- 28:20through the third quarter, which would kind of drive a shallow
- 28:23global recession in the second-half of the year and
- 28:26global GDP growth falling below 2%.
- 28:30With Wood McKinney describing the resulting resulting economic
- 28:34scarring is modest but permanent, which is a, you know,
- 28:39not not great phrasing, but it's really the the most severe
- 28:42scenario, which which gives a bit of A cause concern.
- 28:46And, you know, often you see these kind of like oil could
- 28:48reach $200 per barrel. And you see a lot of people out
- 28:50there saying like, oh, they said this last time or they've said
- 28:53this before. And it's, I think people, you
- 28:55know, reading those headlines as if it's a prediction of what is
- 28:58absolutely going to happen, which of course is impossible to
- 29:02do. As we all know in this world,
- 29:04we've all tried hardest to to predict things.
- 29:07And there's plenty of evidence on this podcast of us getting it
- 29:09very wrong. I mean, I've said before that I
- 29:11don't like even writing stories about oil prices because by the
- 29:15time you publish you're already wrong.
- 29:17So I mean, I don't, I do not envy these guys when they do
- 29:21these sort of long form predictions, especially when at
- 29:25least one side of the conflict is always on social media really
- 29:29changing our outlook. I do feel that, you know, I
- 29:33don't want to accuse any of these report writers of
- 29:36including very attention grabbing predictions to lure in
- 29:40unsuspecting journalists to make them our headlines.
- 29:43I feel, I feel like everyone of them have got look, we can't
- 29:48discount the possibility of a meteor strike.
- 29:50So oil and gas could go down to 0 when the when humanities wiped
- 29:54out. We can't rule that one.
- 29:55I look forward to you starting your own energy consultancy.
- 29:58I'd like to formally apologise to our friends at Wood
- 30:03Mackenzie. For the.
- 30:05The comment made there. No, I'm joking, But no, it's,
- 30:07yeah, I think it's it's it's an interesting point, isn't it?
- 30:10Because it was an entirely a really punchy headline you had
- 30:14this week, Matt. It was, yeah.
- 30:16But I guess to to outline what situation would and the wood
- 30:21Mackenzies scenario would lead to potentially with us seeing
- 30:25$10 per barrel. So that's assuming that the
- 30:27straight over moves rate remains largely closed right through the
- 30:30end of 26. So that's it not really opening
- 30:33bar as we've seen, you know, maybe the odd Chinese or Indian
- 30:36flags tanker getting through, you know, and we're seeing
- 30:40recurring tensions. You know, we saw Donald Trump
- 30:43saying just the other day that he'd been within an hour of
- 30:47relaunching strikes. So it's assuming that these sort
- 30:49of like stop start negotiations continue and there's, you know,
- 30:55maybe occasional flare ups or a drone striking the UAE nuclear
- 30:59plants like just happened the other the other day as well.
- 31:01So was wonder this in outcome? That's when Wood McKenzie
- 31:06projects Brent crude approaching $200 per barrel by the end of
- 31:09the year, even as global oil demand falls by 6,000,000
- 31:13barrels per day year on year, you know, as the price goes up.
- 31:16And we'd also see global inventories would continue to
- 31:20decline with demand for refined products, including gasoline and
- 31:23jet fuel falling sharply in response to high prices.
- 31:27And under this scenario, Wood Mackenzie reckons the global
- 31:30economy could contract by as much as 0.4% in 2026, which
- 31:35marks the third global recession in this century.
- 31:38So joy for us millennials on the the panel.
- 31:40That's number three, one per decade I'm averaging at the
- 31:44moment. And but the regional economic
- 31:47impact would of course be pretty severe and uneven with the the
- 31:50Middle East potentially seeing its GDP contract by 10.7%.
- 31:55And I think what McKenzie said, the 27 EU member states would
- 32:00see their GDP contract by 1.44 by 1.5% in 2026 in a further
- 32:06half percent 2027. You know, these sound like
- 32:10small, small numbers, but of course, I guess the the last Ng
- 32:15oil crisis shock we had following Russia's invasion of
- 32:18Ukraine. If you look around the world,
- 32:20you see countries like Bangladesh, you see countries
- 32:23like Sri Lanka that had these massive upheavals with these
- 32:26overthrows of, of government and things like that.
- 32:28And, and you know, there's no direct cause and effect.
- 32:31You can't just immediately go in out there and say, oh, this,
- 32:35this government was overthrown because oil prices shut up.
- 32:38But it's certainly, you know, as we talk about this podcast,
- 32:41energy underpins every single aspect of the economy, a very
- 32:44single aspect of modern life. So it's when people see prices
- 32:48rise and they can't afford to heat their homes, feed their
- 32:51families, get to work, that's when anger builds and we start
- 32:54seeing these political upheavals all across the world.
- 32:58And so under these scenarios, you know, it's not just economic
- 33:02figures that we're we're talking about it.
- 33:04You know, we would would see under this, you know, worst case
- 33:08scenario, probably a lot of political upheaval, particularly
- 33:11I think it around places like Southeast Asia, South Asia and,
- 33:16you know, other areas that are so reliant on the the Middle
- 33:18East for oil and gas supplies. And I think it was mentioned in
- 33:21a Commons committee hearing, like in the UK, we talk about
- 33:23oil prices rising, but at the end of the day, the UK is AG7
- 33:27country. They'll always be able to pay
- 33:30the higher price. So that supply, you know, won't
- 33:33be lining up for rations in the streets so much as as what's
- 33:37happening in in Cuba and the places it will be those
- 33:40countries like the Philippines and, you know, Sri Lanka that
- 33:44will and the poll that will, will will suffer the the the
- 33:48harshest consequences of of this scenario, which is a very
- 33:51perfectly cheerful note to sort of be ending the podcast on.
- 33:56But we I guess we all hope that it doesn't reach that scenario.
- 33:59But you know, it's certainly concerning to think about.
- 34:04Yeah. And it, it feels like, you know,
- 34:08we've, we've been speaking about this sort of like in a news
- 34:10cycle sense of, you know, in the past and about, you know, you
- 34:14mentioned the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
- 34:16You know, the sort of shock that has.
- 34:18I think when, when things, when things like this go on, we, we
- 34:23have a tendency to sort of forget about them almost like,
- 34:27you know, I mean, we spoke about how a lot of the, OR a lot of
- 34:31other news organizations maybe haven't been, you know, kind of
- 34:35dropped their live blogs and stuff for, for the, the NBA, the
- 34:39war in the Middle East. But it's still a very, you know,
- 34:42it's still very much top of the agenda in terms of global energy
- 34:47markets. Even if you know it's it's you
- 34:51know, not from the outside looking in.
- 34:53Maybe not much is happening that's still creating an issue.
- 34:56Yeah, we're in this weird Phase I think at the moment where
- 34:59you're only really aware of the the issues if you're keeping up
- 35:03with the news. I think if you go around, you
- 35:04might have noticed, you know, your diesel prices or you're
- 35:07filling out the cars gotten a little bit more expensive.
- 35:09But we're still in the phase of the the lot 1 of the largest
- 35:13ever, I think the largest ever emergency reserves released by
- 35:19the International Energy Agency, right.
- 35:20So we're still within that window of, of, of soaking up the
- 35:23buffers, but now we're starting to see decisions like the UK
- 35:26government. On Russia.
- 35:27Delaying sanctions on Russian oil and, and, and I think we're
- 35:32you know the the war broke out in the end of February.
- 35:36I think it took until close to the end of March or midway
- 35:40through April, can't remember exactly when, but for the
- 35:41tankers that had just gotten out to reach their destination.
- 35:44So it's something that, you know, these, these effects are
- 35:49going to are taking a while to come through.
- 35:51So we're now in the period where that supply has been cut off.
- 35:54You know, all the tankers that left, they pretty much left all
- 35:56the ones that are getting out, you know, they're not, they're
- 35:58probably ones that were just sitting there.
- 35:59They're not, you know, it's not a new flow of rush of oil coming
- 36:02out of the Gulf during the ceasefire.
- 36:05And we're now into the eating up the reserves period.
- 36:09And if things don't go back to normal, as Wood, McKinley is
- 36:12saying, pretty quick, smart, and there's going to be
- 36:15consequences. So.
- 36:16Yeah, and it's, it's, it's important to remember as well
- 36:18that like you said, Matt, we, we're in a relatively cushy
- 36:22position. You know, being in the in the UK
- 36:24here, the these effects are already being felt.
- 36:28You know, it's just, it's not evenly distributed.
- 36:32It's definitely that feeling is what I've got, is that are we
- 36:35just kind of forgetting that there might be this massive
- 36:38economic crisis just kind of heading towards us at A at an
- 36:41oil tankers pace? Well, do you know what that is?
- 36:44Definitely a cheery way to end the episode.
- 36:48But yeah, it's, it's an important conversation to have
- 36:50and definitely one that we'll be continuing to, to sort of follow
- 36:55as, as the weeks and potentially if, if Wood Mackenzie's most
- 37:00gloomy scenario rings true, months and months and months to
- 37:04follow. But yeah, thank you very much
- 37:07for for listening. Thank you, Matt, Michael and
- 37:09Floyd for depressing me This this Friday morning.
- 37:12And I'll and if you want to see hear more from us, well, we'll
- 37:16be back same time, same place next week.