Latest / Journey to the Fringe / The epoch of its time: The Falun Gong part 1 of 3
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:11Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, where we are constantly striving to penetrate
- 0:17the two cosmic extremes.
- 0:18We are your spiritually enlightened host, Taylor and Chelsea.
- 0:22That will pay off later in the episode, I promise.
- 0:24And today, we take a look at a group that has a lot to do with the world.
- 0:28We currently inhabit it, as well as some of the fringy topics.
- 0:31It's on the edge of a few episodes that we've done already.
- 0:35This will be a two-parter episode.
- 0:37If you only have time for one of the two, I would highly recommend the second half.
- 0:42Just because if you only listen to the first half, you're going to get a very bad idea
- 0:46of what this whole topic is, because I'm doing the two extremes in the episodes.
- 0:51Should I just meet you back in the second episode?
- 0:52For those of you who are listening now, you are obligated yes to listen to this episode
- 0:56and the next episode.
- 0:57For those of you who have not started listening to it and somehow can foresee this part of
- 1:02it, please only listen to the second episode.
- 1:05But Chelsea, today our topic is the Falun Gong.
- 1:09Have you ever heard of this?
- 1:11Nope.
- 1:12Okay.
- 1:13Not one sweet idea.
- 1:14I actually have, because you said it, but I specifically didn't look into it and just
- 1:18ignored what you said completely.
- 1:19Well, that's good, because it left this episode completely open as a surprise.
- 1:23Chelsea, you've seen in parks groups of Chinese people doing their little flowy dances, very
- 1:29nice and slowly.
- 1:30Okay, hold on.
- 1:31There's a guy that does it like literally out in my courtyard every day.
- 1:35So what they're practicing there is some sort of Chi exercise, which at the end of the
- 1:41day is what the Falun Gong is all about.
- 1:44I'm going to start this off in a strange place, but I think this is backstory that needs to
- 1:50be included so that we can connect it to episodes that I've talked about something along these
- 1:54lines in the past.
- 1:55There is foreshadowing way back there in another episode, but I don't expect you to
- 1:59know it.
- 2:00For those of you who do catch on, it's really good payoff at the end here.
- 2:03Okay.
- 2:04Can I just ask a quick question?
- 2:05Yeah.
- 2:06When do I find out if I need to be suspicious of the guy that I see practicing these flowy
- 2:10movements?
- 2:12Next week.
- 2:13Oh no.
- 2:14Is it good or bad?
- 2:15I really couldn't tell you on this specific guy.
- 2:18Okay.
- 2:19Well, I'm going to be suspicious of him until I figure it out.
- 2:21And that's the weird thing because that form of exercise is not just part of this group.
- 2:28It has an entire cultural significance to Chinese people.
- 2:31Okay.
- 2:32Tai Chi is a thing Asians in general will practice, which is a form of exercises and
- 2:37movements to help the flow of Chi throughout the body.
- 2:40Okay.
- 2:41And the entire grouping in itself is called Chi Gong, or I believe that's the flow of
- 2:46energy is what it like directly translates to or the wheel of energy.
- 2:49Okay.
- 2:50We're going to start in the late seventies.
- 2:52This article comes from a website called MadeInChinaJournal.com.
- 2:56I thought it gave a good summary and the article is called on ufology with Chinese characteristics
- 3:02and the fate of Chinese socialism.
- 3:04I will begin by noting a specific discontinuity whose reality is absolutely indisputable.
- 3:09There was no public ufology in China before the reform period and Chinese ufology and
- 3:14the reform period began at almost the exact same time.
- 3:17Chelsea, I don't expect you to know what the reform period is.
- 3:20Basically there was the Chinese revolution after World War II.
- 3:24There was a lot of cultural destruction because they basically got rid of the entire upper
- 3:29class of China.
- 3:30The reform period is bringing four modernizations industry, agriculture, military and science.
- 3:36And this is brought up out by Deng Xiaoping.
- 3:38It's usually called Dengism, what Deng Xiaoping did during his time.
- 3:42And it's D-E-N-G dot D-U-N-G.
- 3:44Dengism.
- 3:45Okay.
- 3:46Basically, we need to push these things forward.
- 3:49They also really like to push Chinese characteristics.
- 3:52They talk about socialism with Chinese characteristics a lot.
- 3:55The science that they're looking at sometimes is science with ancient Chinese attachments
- 4:01as well.
- 4:02So during the first wave of the major reforms and the deepening distribution of the problems
- 4:07associated with the four modernizations, the China UFO enthusiast liaison office was
- 4:12established at Wuhan University on September 20th, 1979.
- 4:16And by 1980, it had grown considerably and became the China UFO Research Association
- 4:21with branch organizations in several major cities.
- 4:24The following February began publishing the Journal of UFO Research and by the mid 1980s
- 4:29had more than 40 branch organizations around the country and thousands of members.
- 4:33In and at this point, unrelated development.
- 4:36In 1981, the All China Qigong Science Research Association, which is this movement of Qi
- 4:42through the body that we were just talking about, was established under the All China
- 4:47Association of Chinese Medicine for research and Qigong practice with hundreds of member
- 4:51organizations.
- 4:52They called the Qigong Science Research Association the QSRA.
- 4:56It immediately became the central locus for paranormal research in China.
- 5:00Extrasensory perception, telekinesis, ghosts, and so on.
- 5:03Like it all ended up falling under the idea of the Qigong Research Center.
- 5:08That's very interesting.
- 5:09Yeah.
- 5:10Basically, everything that you would consider like just kind of outside science falls under
- 5:14the idea of Qi flowing energy.
- 5:17The extraordinary powers that Qigong practice was supposed to engender according to the
- 5:21QSRA were not exactly coexistent with the domain of the paranormal, but in seeking to
- 5:25develop and theorize these powers, continuous reference was made to these fields of study
- 5:30and especially to scientific experiments in these areas in western countries.
- 5:34Between 1986 and the early 1990s, the organization changed its name in minor ways and fell from
- 5:39time to time under the supervision of different ministries.
- 5:41And by 1993, it operated as a state-level social organization under the Ministry of
- 5:46Health and Civil Affairs.
- 5:48All of this occurred in exactly the period where the previously uncommon phrase with
- 5:52Chinese characteristics was driven into public discourse.
- 5:55After Deng Xiaoping had used the phrase socialism with Chinese characteristics in his opening
- 5:59speech at the 12th National Congress of the Chinese Communist Party on September 1, 1982,
- 6:04it quickly became a central element in the discursive rearrangements that occurred through
- 6:08the 1980s around the problems associated with the dismantling of many of the social and
- 6:13economic modes of organization that had characterized the socialist development period, opening
- 6:17social life to new forms of knowledge and culture from the advanced capitalist countries,
- 6:22developing an advanced culture and economy and so on.
- 6:25There's little doubt that this had a great deal to do with the end of official Chinese
- 6:29socialist internationalism and the redirecting of attention and desire towards the capitalist
- 6:33world but the problem of Chinese characteristics also became an important site in which struggles
- 6:39over the legacy and worth of Chinese socialism would take place.
- 6:42By the early 1990s, then, the period immediately following the crushing of the 1989 social movement
- 6:48and the subsequent dismantling of the institutional and discursive resources that pertained to
- 6:52certain forms of protest against the process of reform, the broad project of combining
- 6:57Chinese traditions like Qigong and high level science and technology in the interest of
- 7:01economic development was well established.
- 7:03And Chelsea, I don't know if you know what the 1989 social movement is talking about,
- 7:09it's the Tiananmen Square massacre.
- 7:11Okay, I do know that.
- 7:12I didn't know that it would by that other name though.
- 7:15Especially in China, you really can't talk about it in specific terms.
- 7:19Because it's a significant movement against the government and it's something they don't
- 7:22want to talk about.
- 7:23It intersected with and developed alongside the popular mass movement known as the Qigong
- 7:28Fever, which among other things, charismatic Taoist masters would distribute their healing
- 7:32Qi to their followers via electronically mediated speeches at rallies of thousands or even
- 7:38tens of thousands of people, many of whom fell into collective trances or healed injuries
- 7:43or ailments, traditional Chinese medicine, acupuncture, moxibustion, which I don't know
- 7:47what that is, and others had occupied a fairly stable and prestigious place in the apparatus
- 7:52of socialist public health since the 1950s, but recuperating the religious discourse it
- 7:57had developed with historically and bringing it into relation with the fourth modernization
- 8:02as the QSRA did, created all kinds of new possibilities under the general problem of
- 8:06the organic combustion combination of Eastern Qi Gong culture with Western modern science.
- 8:12The condensation of previously and perhaps properly separate vocabularies and commsets
- 8:17and those single texts would not in and of itself have seemed very strange within the
- 8:22terms of Qi Gong discourse in the 1990s, and the China UFO Research Association had
- 8:27been affiliated with the QSRA since 1988 as a second level study society, and by this
- 8:33route had acquired legal standing as an organization, but this led to all kinds of internal contradictions
- 8:39between the materialist ufologists and the Qi Gong tendency.
- 8:42This came to a head in the Cura's fourth national chondrous in Beijing in May 1992,
- 8:49at which time many members became frustrated by the infiltration of pseudoscience leading
- 8:54to the organization to reiterate his commitment to the dialectical materialist guiding principles.
- 8:59I really just wanted to bring in the idea of Qi Gong, Tai Chi, the movement of Qi,
- 9:05is inexorably linked to ufology in Chinese history because it began being studied at
- 9:11the same time, and because of this, there's much more intermingling in Chinese cultural
- 9:16significance and its study between these two topics than you would see in most of the
- 9:21rest of the world.
- 9:22And I just ask, is it because they're both technically fringy ideas?
- 9:28Well, it's not only that they're linked because of that, they both began getting studied at
- 9:32the exact same time, so inexorably you're going to end up with a different link than,
- 9:37say, something that's always been studied and something else popping up later on.
- 9:42Within a two-year period, these things are both being studied and they're put into the
- 9:45same faculty to be studied, like it's all under the top of the QSRA, the Qi Gong Research
- 9:51Society.
- 9:52Okay, and so it's because they're just like not, they're kinda outskirts of things that
- 9:57they're kinda thrown into the same thing?
- 9:58I wouldn't say it's because they're outskirts, I think the big difference here is this is
- 10:02something that neither of these could be studied for a long time because they were outside
- 10:07of progression and specifically, Chinese culture up until the 1970s had a real conflict with
- 10:13this past culture because they were always worried about an overthrow of the Communist
- 10:18Party of China.
- 10:19The cultural significance is that wealthy people have a connection to these things to
- 10:24the past and especially when you see a push for a conservative movement against socialism,
- 10:29it's usually a push to tradition.
- 10:31This being tradition, it was kinda forbidden even to be looked at and when it was opened
- 10:35up, science was opened up to something that could be looked at in the 70s.
- 10:38UFOs and Qi Gong are just allowed to be looked at and then therefore connected.
- 10:43Okay, I was gonna say it's not because they're actually like connected, connected.
- 10:48Not necessarily, you could say there's a connection just because it's like the spiritual side of
- 10:52it or the parrot.
- 10:53Yeah.
- 10:54The above normal top.
- 10:55It's not because like a UFO beamed down and gave us Tai Chi.
- 10:59I would say yes.
- 11:00It did?
- 11:01No, I would say that you're right, nobody did that.
- 11:03Some Qi Gong groups definitely are not of that opinion.
- 11:07Okay, I just wanted to make sure the barrier of what we're looking at here with their connection.
- 11:13With that all done, we need to take a look now at a man who we're going to be talking
- 11:19a lot about.
- 11:20His name is Li Hongzhi.
- 11:21You'll see a lot of people pronounce his name Li Hongzhi, but that is because most people
- 11:26who are saying his name don't have a background in reading Pinyin.
- 11:30When you see a Chinese word, if you see a Z and an H, it makes a J sound.
- 11:34If you see an I after that, it makes an R sound or an O sound.
- 11:38So okay.
- 11:39So Li Hongzhi is how we're going to say it from here on out, okay?
- 11:43There, we all learned a little something about Chinese.
- 11:46Oh good.
- 11:47I just probably won't say it.
- 11:50You can just call him Li because I call him Li basically.
- 11:52Okay, okay, I can do that.
- 11:54I can pronounce Li correctly.
- 11:56Li is born in the 50s.
- 11:58There's a bit of dispute about that.
- 12:00We will talk about it in the next episode.
- 12:02He comes on the scene.
- 12:03He claims to be tutored by a variety of Buddhist and Taoist masters who, according to his
- 12:08spiritual biography, imparted with him practice methods and moral philosophies that become,
- 12:12as we know it, Falun Gong.
- 12:14But that's not where we're going to start.
- 12:15We're not starting with Falun Gong.
- 12:16We're starting with just Li Hongzhi and his movement through life.
- 12:201970, Li is working for the military on a horse farm in northeast China.
- 12:25In 1972, he works as a trumpet player with a division of the provincial forestry police.
- 12:31He kind of disagrees with this.
- 12:33This is what the actual government's history of him is.
- 12:36That is a super strange history with the government.
- 12:41In the early 1980s, because he was born during the Cultural Revolution, he didn't actually
- 12:45complete high school.
- 12:46So he completes high school through correspondence just because that was the way to do it.
- 12:51And then Li begins studying and observing a variety of Qigong disciplines.
- 12:55Only in preparation for establishing and publicizing his own Qigong system.
- 12:59This is the mid-1980s.
- 13:00By 1985, the Chinese authorities created the national organization to oversee the great
- 13:04variety of Qigong disciplines that were proliferating across the country.
- 13:08And the China Qigong Scientific Research Society was established in 1985 and convened its first
- 13:14meeting in Beijing in 1986.
- 13:16The organization counted among its leadership several eminent members of the former members
- 13:20and former members of the Politburo and National People's Congress, as well as former ministries
- 13:26of health and education.
- 13:27And in 1989, Li begins private instruction of what becomes known as Falun Gong to very
- 13:33select students.
- 13:34In 1982, he officially found what he calls Falun Gong.
- 13:39Now Falun Gong in Chinese means the wheel of law.
- 13:43You will also see it called the Falun Dafa.
- 13:46I'm not really sure the significance between the two names.
- 13:49I also don't know the translation of Falun Dafa.
- 13:52It's something to do with law because Gong means wheel.
- 13:55I don't know what Falun means.
- 13:56Falun Dafa, Falun Gong are interchangeable in my mind for what we're talking about here,
- 14:02okay?
- 14:03So Falun Gong publicly founded in spring of 1992.
- 14:07And it's near the end of what's known as China's Qigong Bu.
- 14:11It's a period which saw the proliferation of thousands of disciplines.
- 14:15Li Hongzhi and his Falun Gong became an instant star of the Qigong movement and were welcomed
- 14:21into the government-administered China Qigong Scientific Research Society.
- 14:25From 1992 to 1994, Li travels throughout China giving 54 lectures and seminars on the practices
- 14:32and beliefs of Falun Gong.
- 14:34Seminars typically lasted 8 to 10 days and attracted as many as 6,000 participants per
- 14:39class.
- 14:40The practice group rapidly based on its purportive efficacies and improving health and its moral
- 14:44and philosophical elements, which were more developed than those of other Qigong schools.
- 14:49And these are part of the teachings that I want to talk about in the first half of this
- 14:53two-part series.
- 14:54What are the teachings?
- 14:55So Falun Gong differentiates itself from Buddhist monistic traditions in that it places great
- 15:00importance on participants in the secular world.
- 15:03Falun Gong practitioners are required to maintain regular jobs and family lives and to observe
- 15:09the laws of the respective governments and are instructed to not distance themselves
- 15:13from society.
- 15:14An exception is made of course for Buddhists who are permitted to continue a monastic lifestyle
- 15:18while practicing Falun Gong.
- 15:20As a part of its emphasis on ethical behavior, Falun Gong's teachings prescribe a strict
- 15:25personal morality for practitioners with three key principles.
- 15:29They are Zhen, Shan, and Ren, which are truth, compassion, and forbearance.
- 15:35Those are the three fundamental words of Falun Gong.
- 15:38What was the last one?
- 15:39Forbearance.
- 15:40Kind of like an internal strictness.
- 15:42Okay, thank you.
- 15:44They are expected to do good deeds and conduct themselves with patience when encountering
- 15:48difficulties.
- 15:49For instance, Li stipulates that a practitioner of Falun Gong must quote, not hit back when
- 15:54attacked, not talk back when insulted, end quote.
- 15:57In addition, they must also abandon negative thoughts and behaviors such as greed, deception,
- 16:03jealousy, and the teachings contained in junctions against smoking and the consumption of alcohol
- 16:07as these are considered addictions that are detrimental to health and mental clarity.
- 16:12Doctors are also forbidden to kill living things, including animals for the purposes
- 16:17of obtaining food.
- 16:18Though strangely enough, they are not required to adopt a vegetarian diet.
- 16:22I'm not quite sure how that works.
- 16:24It just means they can't actually hunt for it, maybe?
- 16:27No, this is one of the contradictions we'll talk about later on, but I think it's one
- 16:30of those things that we're not going to tell you to do something, but the rules don't really
- 16:34allow you to do other things.
- 16:36Basically like we're not going to say you can't eat meat, but you can't have things
- 16:39die to eat it.
- 16:41In addition to these things, practitioners of Falun Gong must abandon a variety of worldly
- 16:45attachments and desires.
- 16:46In the course of cultivating your practice, the students of Falun Gong aim to relinquish
- 16:50the pursuit of fame, monetary gain, sentimentality, and other entanglements.
- 16:54Lee's teachings repeatedly emphasize the emptiness of material pursuits, although practitioners
- 16:59of Falun Gong are not encouraged to leave their jobs or rescue money.
- 17:02They are expected to give up the psychological attachment to these things, not the things
- 17:06themselves.
- 17:07Falun Gong doctrine also cancels against participation in political or social issues.
- 17:11We'll talk about that again later.
- 17:14Excessive interest in politics is viewed as an attachment to worldly power and influence,
- 17:18and Falun Gong aims for transcendence of such pursuits.
- 17:21According to Hu Ping, quote, Falun Gong deals only with purifying the individual through
- 17:26exercise and does not touch on social or national concerns.
- 17:30It has not suggested or even intimated a model for social change.
- 17:35Many religions pursue social reform to some extent, but there is no such tendency evident
- 17:40in Falun Gong.
- 17:41End quote.
- 17:42Okay.
- 17:43That's just to give you a little idea of the philosophy behind all.
- 17:46At the end of the day, it is just movements, but there are technically it spreads a little
- 17:50more to kind of the overall lifestyle of somebody who's in Falun Gong.
- 17:54Does that make sense so far?
- 17:55I mean, yeah, I'm curious to see where this is going.
- 17:59Okay.
- 18:00With that, we're going to kind of continue on that timeline.
- 18:03May 13th of 1992, Li begins public teachings of these philosophies of Falun Gong at the
- 18:08number five middle school in Chengchun, Jilin Province, lecturing to a crowd of several
- 18:12hundred.
- 18:13The seminar ran for nine days at a cost of 30 yuan per person.
- 18:16In June, Li is invited by the Chinese Qigong Scientific Research Society to lecture in Beijing.
- 18:22In September, Falun Gong is recognized as a Qigong branch under the administration of
- 18:26the state run China Qigong Scientific Research Society, and Li has formally declared a master
- 18:31of Qigong by the CQRS, the China Qigong Research Society.
- 18:36Right.
- 18:37Right.
- 18:38And he receives a permit to teach Qigong nationwide.
- 18:41Li and several Falun Gong students participate in the 1992 Asia Health Expo in Beijing from
- 18:47December 12th to 21st, and the organizer of the health fair remark that Falun Gong and
- 18:52Li, quote, received the most praise of any Qigong school at the fair and received very
- 18:57good therapeutic results, end quote.
- 18:59The event helped cement Li's popularity in the Qigong world and journalistic reports
- 19:04of Falun Gong's healing powers spread.
- 19:06By the end of the year, Li had given five week-long lecture seminars in Beijing, four
- 19:10in Chengchun, and one in Taiyun and one in Shandong.
- 19:14In 1993, the first major instructional text by Li Hongzhe is published by Military Yuan
- 19:21Press in April.
- 19:22The book sets forth an explanation of Falun Gong's basic cosmology, moral system, and
- 19:27exercises.
- 19:28The highest edition is released in December of the same year.
- 19:30In the spring and summer of 1993, a series of glowing articles appear in Qigong magazine's
- 19:35nationwide, lauding the benefits of Falun Gong.
- 19:38Several feature images of Li Hongzhe on the cover and argued the superiority of the Falun
- 19:43Gong system.
- 19:44The Falun Xiong Lian, DAFA Research Society, is established as a branch of the Chinese
- 19:49Qigong Research Society on July 30th of this year.
- 19:53In August, an organization under the Ministry of Public Security sends a letter to the CQRS
- 19:59thanking Li Hongzhe for providing his teachings to police officers injured in the line of
- 20:03duty.
- 20:04The letter claimed that of the hundreds of officers treated by Li, only one failed to
- 20:08experience obvious improvement in their health.
- 20:11So there's a real big link between the government as a whole and Falun Gong.
- 20:16I'm noticing that.
- 20:17Like Li is literally helping the police in this, and they are pushing it hard.
- 20:22Not only that, but they gave him a permit, correct?
- 20:25Yeah, to practice this as a whole.
- 20:27Yeah, I mean, everything seems on the up and up for Li right now.
- 20:30Everything seems like it's on the up and up for Li.
- 20:32There's a real good relationship between him and the government, like they're pushing
- 20:36it, everything is going great.
- 20:37They're putting him in with the police precincts to help people who are injured in the job.
- 20:41On September 21st of 1993, the People's Public Security Daily of Publication of the Ministry
- 20:46of Public Security commenced Falun Gong for, quote, promoting the traditional crime fighting
- 20:51virtues of the Chinese people, in safeguarding social orders and security, and in promoting
- 20:55rectitude in society, end quote.
- 20:58Li again participates in the Asia Health Expo in Beijing from December 11th to 20th.
- 21:02This time is a member of the organization committee.
- 21:05He wins several awards at the event and is proclaimed as, quote, the most acclaimed Qi
- 21:09Gong master.
- 21:11Falun Gong also received the, quote, special gold award and award for advancing frontier
- 21:16science, end quote.
- 21:18In 1994, the Jilin Province of Qi Gong Science Research Association proclaims Li Hongjue
- 21:22as a grandmaster of Qi Gong, and Li gives two lectures of on Falun Gong at the Public
- 21:28Security University in Beijing and contributes profits from the seminars to a foundation
- 21:33for injured police officers.
- 21:35On August 3rd, the city of Houston, Texas, declares Li Hongjue as an honorary citizen
- 21:40for his unselfish public service for the benefit and welfare of mankind.
- 21:45And as revenue from his sales of his publications grew, Li ceased to charge fees for his classes
- 21:50and thereafter insists that Falun Gong must be taught free of charge.
- 21:54The last full seminar Falun Gong practice and philosophy takes place from December 21st
- 21:59to 29th to December in the city of Guangzhou in 1994.
- 22:03In 1995, the complete teaches of Falun Gong is published in January by the China Television
- 22:08Broadcasting Agency Publishing Company.
- 22:10A publication ceremony is held in the Ministry of Public Security auditorium on January 4th.
- 22:16In February, Li is approached by the Chinese National Sports Committee, Ministry of Public
- 22:21Health and the CQSRA to jointly establish a Falun Gong Association.
- 22:26However, Li declines this offer.
- 22:28This is where things start to change.
- 22:30Official attitudes towards the Qi Gong movement within some segments of the government began
- 22:34to change as criticism of the Qi Gong begin to appear in the state-run press.
- 22:39From here, Li announces that he was finished teaching his practices in China and Li Hongjue
- 22:45begins teaching his practices in Europe, Oceania, North America, and Southeast Asia.
- 22:49In 1998, Li relocates permanently to the United States.
- 22:54As the practice continues to grow within China, tensions emerge between Falun Gong and Chinese
- 22:58authorities.
- 22:59In 1996, Falun Gong withdraws from the China Qi Gong Scientific Research Society and thereafter
- 23:04finds itself the subject of growing scrutiny and criticism in the state-run press.
- 23:09Their practice becomes a subject of high-level debates within the government and CCP, with
- 23:13some ministries and government authorities expressing continued support for the practices
- 23:17and others becoming increasingly wary of the group.
- 23:24There were criticisms before the withdrawal, and I'm going to be perfectly honest, we'll
- 23:29never get a full answer as to what happens between him being asked to start a Qi Gong
- 23:35Sports Research Facility and their withdrawal from Chinese life.
- 23:41Neither party will give you a straight answer.
- 23:45The tension also plays out in the media as some outlets continue to laud the effects
- 23:49of Falun Gong while others criticize it as pseudo-size.
- 23:52Tensions continue to escalate over this period, culminating in a demonstration, which we'll
- 23:56talk about later on here.
- 23:58So that's just to give you an overview of this next little bit.
- 24:01In 1996, the book Zhuang Falun is listed as a bestseller by Beijing Youth Daily in January,
- 24:06March and April.
- 24:07Falun Gong files for withdrawal from the China Qi Gong Research Society in March of 1996
- 24:11and Lee later explains that he had found the state-run CQRS to be more concerned with profiting
- 24:16from Qi Gong than engaging in genuine research.
- 24:19They had also apparently rejected a new CQRS policy that mandated all Qi Gong practices
- 24:24created CCP branches within their organization.
- 24:27Falun Gong is left entirely without government oversight or sanctions at this point.
- 24:31At least direction, administrators of the Falun Gong Research Association of China apply
- 24:37for registration with three other government organizations, including the Buddhist Association
- 24:41of China and the United Front Work Department.
- 24:45All applications are denied though.
- 24:46The first major state-run media article criticizing Falun Gong appears in the Guangming Daily
- 24:52newspaper on June 17th of 1996.
- 24:56The article writes that Falun Gong represents a manifestation of feudal superstition and
- 25:00that its core text, Zhuang Falun, is a work of quote, pseudo-science that swindles the
- 25:06masses.
- 25:07Falun Gong practitioners responded to the article's publication with a letter writing
- 25:11campaign to the newspaper and the National Qi Gong Association.
- 25:14Several Buddhist journals and magazines start to write articles criticizing Falun Gong as
- 25:18a heretical sect as well at this time.
- 25:20And on July 24, Falun Gong books are banned from further publication by the China News
- 25:26Publishing Bureau, a branch of the CCP Party.
- 25:29The reason cited for the ban is that Falun Gong is spreading superstition.
- 25:33Hired in copy versions, however, of the Falun Gong books proliferate with Li Hongjue's
- 25:37approval.
- 25:38Li begins another lecture tour in the summer of 1996 traveling to Hong Kong, Sydney, Bangkok,
- 25:43Houston, New York, and Beijing.
- 25:45And the China Qi Gong Scientific Research Society issues a resolution on the cancellation
- 25:50of Falun Gong's membership with the society.
- 25:52The resolution stated that although practitioners of Falun Gong had, quote, attained unparalleled
- 25:57results in terms of fitness and disease prevention, end quote, Li Hongjue propagated theology and
- 26:04superstition and failed to attend association meetings and departed from the association's
- 26:08procedure.
- 26:09That's 96.
- 26:1097 comes around.
- 26:11I love that statement.
- 26:12I know you guys are getting excellent results, but the guy is not good.
- 26:16But he's not showing up.
- 26:18Yeah, excellent results aside.
- 26:23The Ministry of Public Security launches an investigation in 1997 into whether Falun
- 26:28Gong should be deemed Xi'e Jia, which is a theoretical religion.
- 26:32The report concludes that no evidence has appeared thus far.
- 26:35From 1997 to 1999, criticism of Falun Gong escalates in state-run media.
- 26:39With the encouragement of Li, Falun Gong practitioners respond to criticism by peacefully
- 26:44petitioning outside media offices, seeking redress against the perceived unfair reporting.
- 26:50The tactic succeeds frequently, often resulting in the retraction of critical articles and
- 26:55apologies from the news organizations.
- 26:57Not all media coverage, however, was negative in this period, and articles continue to appear
- 27:01highlighting Falun Gong's health benefits.
- 27:04And this is a weird little middle area where there's a little bit of criticism that's
- 27:07starting to come out in the media, and Li tells people, go protest outside of these places.
- 27:12Do it peacefully, but you'll have tens of thousands of people sitting outside of a
- 27:15new station, just sitting there for a day's on end, because they wrote something bad about
- 27:20this group.
- 27:21On January 13th of 1998, the Chinese Buddhist Association held a meeting on how to react
- 27:25to Falun Gong, and on July 21st of the same year, the Ministry of Public Security issues
- 27:29document number 555, which is, quote, notice of the investigation of Falun Gong, end quote.
- 27:35The document asserts that Falun Gong is an evil religion and mandates that another investigation
- 27:39be launched to seek evidence of this conclusion.
- 27:42Security agencies began monitoring and collecting personal information on practitioners.
- 27:47Falun Gong sources reported authorities were tapping, phone lines harassing and tailing
- 27:51practitioners and ransacking homes and closing down Falun Gong meditation sessions.
- 27:56According to Falun Gong sources, Chao Shui, the former chairman of the National People's
- 28:00Congress, led his own investigation to Falun Gong, and concluded that Falun Gong has hundreds
- 28:05of benefits for the Chinese people and China and does not have one single bad effect.
- 28:13I would really like to stress the beginning of that sentence though.
- 28:17According to Falun Gong sources, Chao Shui said this.
- 28:20The Chinese government also said that it had excellent results.
- 28:25China's National Sports Commission launches its own investigation of May 98, and the Commission's
- 28:30medical professionals conduct interviews of over 12,000 Falun Gong practitioners in Guangdong
- 28:36province.
- 28:3797.9% of respondents say Falun Gong improved their health.
- 28:40I don't understand what the problem is here right now.
- 28:43Everyone's saying it's excellent.
- 28:45I would also like to emphasize the question is, do you think Falun Gong has improved your
- 28:50health?
- 28:51Yeah.
- 28:52There's not actually like any research into it.
- 28:55It's just them asking them.
- 28:56Yeah.
- 28:57They're as good as judges any.
- 29:02And by October, the investigation concludes noting, quote, work in Vince, the exercises
- 29:06and effects of Falun Gong are excellent.
- 29:08It has done an extraordinary amount to improve society's stability and ethics.
- 29:12And this should be duly affirmed, end quote.
- 29:14I'm convinced.
- 29:15At this time, the State Sports Commission suggests that upwards of 60 to 70 million
- 29:20people are practicing Falun Gong in China.
- 29:23Holy crap.
- 29:24Wow.
- 29:25He already has China.
- 29:26That's why he leaves.
- 29:27I'm going to go find more.
- 29:28Well, and there's plenty of people that will spread it on his behalf there as well.
- 29:32Yeah.
- 29:331999, Lee Hongjue continues to teach Falun Gong internationally with occasional stops
- 29:37in China.
- 29:38And by early 1999, Lee had lectured in Sydney, Bangkok, San Francisco, LA, Hong Kong, Taipei,
- 29:43Frankfurt, Toronto, Singapore, Geneva, Houston in New York, as well as in Changchun in Beijing.
- 29:48Wu Xiaozhu, an official from China's National Sports Commission, says in an interview with
- 29:53US and World Reports on February 14 that as many as 100 million people may have taken
- 29:58up Falun Gong in other forms of Qigong.
- 30:00Wu notes that the popularity of Falun Gong dramatically reduces health care costs and
- 30:04quote, premier Zhu Rongzhu is very happy about that end quote.
- 30:09Yeah.
- 30:10That's just another tick in the column for good.
- 30:13How great.
- 30:14Falun Gong.
- 30:15It's doing pretty good things.
- 30:16Yeah.
- 30:17In April, physicist Hedzuo Xu from the Chinese Academy of Sciences publishes an article in
- 30:23Tianjin Normal Universities, you three.
- 30:26That's a great name for university.
- 30:30You gotta love translations.
- 30:32Yeah.
- 30:33The Tianjin Normal University.
- 30:34Okay.
- 30:35I love that.
- 30:36He publishes an article criticizing Falun Gong as superstitious and potentially harmful
- 30:41for youth and stating he knew someone who died because of it.
- 30:44At that time, some countries near China had people practicing like Vietnam.
- 30:48Tianjin Falun Gong practitioners respond to this article by peacefully petitioning in
- 30:52front of the editorial offices and the editors initially agreed to publish a retraction of
- 30:57this article.
- 30:58Wait.
- 30:59Okay.
- 31:00First of all, they're publishing a retraction because there's a protest there, right?
- 31:03Yeah.
- 31:04There's probably just so many people there.
- 31:06Second, someone died.
- 31:07He says somebody died practicing it.
- 31:10Yes.
- 31:11Okay.
- 31:12Okay.
- 31:13In TV.
- 31:14On April 23rd, some 300 security forces are called in to break up the ongoing Falun Gong
- 31:18demonstrations.
- 31:1945 Falun Gong practitioners are beaten and detained, which at the end of the day is actually
- 31:24a fairly, I don't want to downplay it, but this is a controlled response, like, compared
- 31:30to what happened 10 years prior to people protesting.
- 31:33Huh.
- 31:34Okay.
- 31:35Yeah.
- 31:36And you know, I was just thinking the same thing.
- 31:37If they wanted to shut it down like proper, they probably could have.
- 31:39They had the power to.
- 31:41They called in 300 security forces.
- 31:43It was a peaceful protest.
- 31:44So was Tianjin Square at the time, though.
- 31:46They're probably thinking how many people are in this thing now if they're wanting to
- 31:50shut it down and they're protesting everything.
- 31:53In response to this, Falun Gong practitioners petition Tianjin City Hall for the release
- 31:57of the detained practitioners.
- 31:59They are reportedly told that the order to break up the crowd and detain protesters came
- 32:03from the central authorities in Beijing and that further appeals should be directed at
- 32:06Beijing.
- 32:07April 25th, somewhere between 10 and 20,000 Falun Gong practitioners quietly assemble
- 32:13outside the central appeals office.
- 32:16They are now adjacent to the Zhongnan High leadership compound in Beijing.
- 32:20Five Falun Gong representatives meet with Premier Zhu Rongji to request official recognition
- 32:26and an end to the escalating harassment against the group.
- 32:29Zhu agrees to release the Tianjin practitioners and assures the representatives that the government
- 32:34does not oppose Falun Gong.
- 32:36The same day, however, Jin Zemin issues a letter stating his intentions to suppress
- 32:41the practice.
- 32:43On April 26, Jin Zemin convenes a meeting of the Politburo Standing Committee to discuss
- 32:49the Falun Gong demonstration.
- 32:51Some Politburo members reportedly favor to conciliatory position towards Falun Gong,
- 32:56while others, such as Jiang and the security leader Luoguan, favor to decisive suppression
- 33:01of the group.
- 33:02Authorities start to increase the surveillance of Falun Gong from here, tapping telephones
- 33:06of practitioners and monitoring practitioners in several cities.
- 33:09I would like to emphasize this information provided by Falun Gong.
- 33:13One party in this, not the Chinese Communist Party.
- 33:15May I please interject and ask a question?
- 33:18Yes.
- 33:19Am I missing something?
- 33:20Like what happened here that they want to shut it down so much?
- 33:23We will never get a straight answer.
- 33:26Both parties will have to answer.
- 33:27I did ask that, didn't I?
- 33:28You already told me this.
- 33:29I'm very confused as to why this is happening.
- 33:32We will never know for sure why this happens.
- 33:35We can only speculate and the speculation will happen in the second episode.
- 33:39Okay, okay.
- 33:40I just keep coming around to why do we hate the Falun Gong and we just don't know.
- 33:44It seems like out of nowhere, right?
- 33:46It's just like, yeah, everybody's getting along great.
- 33:49And then, nope, nope, some bad articles, protests.
- 33:52We're going to crack down on the protests.
- 33:54The leader leaves the country.
- 33:55I really feel like I'm missing some sort of information, but I'm not.
- 34:00I might ask it again because I did ask it already.
- 34:03It just makes me more curious about it.
- 34:05Do they not know that?
- 34:07Okay, okay, okay.
- 34:09That's not satisfying, but okay.
- 34:12May 2nd, 1999, Lee Hong-Jue gives a press conference to journalists in Sydney, Australia.
- 34:17When asked by a reporter whether he believed the government would kill or imprison his
- 34:20disciples to maintain social order, Lee responds that, quote, Falun Gong practitioners will
- 34:24never go against the law.
- 34:26In terms of the scenario you described, I don't think it will happen since the economic
- 34:29reform and opening up of the Chinese government has been quite tolerant in this respect, end
- 34:34quote.
- 34:35Right, that's what they're known for.
- 34:36May and June of this year, just as preparations are quietly underway for a crackdown, Falun
- 34:41Gong practitioners continue their public meditation sessions.
- 34:45The Far Eastern Economic Review wrote, quote, in a park in Western Beijing, 100 or so Falun
- 34:50Gong practitioners exercise under a bold yellow banner proclaiming their affiliation.
- 34:55They are far from running scared, end quote.
- 34:58On June 2nd, Lee purchased space in several Hong Kong newspapers to publish an article
- 35:02defending Falun Gong and urging Chinese leaders not to, quote, risk universal condemnation
- 35:08and waste manpower and capital, end quote, by antagonizing the group.
- 35:12On the 3rd of June, 70,000 practitioners from Jilin and Liaoning traveled to Beijing in
- 35:18an attempt to appeal to authorities.
- 35:20They are intercepted by security forces sent home and placed under surveillance.
- 35:25On June 7th, 1999, Jiang Zemin convened a meeting of the Politburo to address the Falun Gong
- 35:31issue.
- 35:32In the meeting, Jiang described Falun Gong as a grave threat to CCP authorities, quote,
- 35:37something unprecedented in the country since its founding 50 years ago, end quote, and
- 35:40ordered the creation of a special leading group within the party's central committee
- 35:44to, quote, get fully prepared for the work of disintegrating the Falun Gong, end quote.
- 35:49On June 10th, the 6-10 office was formed to handle day-to-day coordination of anti-Falun
- 35:53Gong campaign, and Luo Gan was selected to helm the office, whose mission at the time
- 35:58was described as studying, investigating, and developing a unified approach to resolve
- 36:02the Falun Gong problem.
- 36:04The office was not created with any legislation, and there are no provisions describing its
- 36:08precise mandate.
- 36:09On June 17th, 1999, Jiang Zemin declared in a Politburo meeting that Falun Gong is, quote,
- 36:15the most serious political incident since the June 4th political disturbance in 1989.
- 36:21The 6-10 office came under the newly created central leading group for dealing with Falun
- 36:26Gong, headed by Li Lanqing.
- 36:28Both Li and Luo were members of the Politburo Standing Committee, and the four other deputy
- 36:34directors of the central leading group also held high-level positions in the CCP, including
- 36:39ministers of the Ganon Department.
- 36:41On June 26th of 1999, 13 Falun Gong exercise sites in public parks are shut down by Beijing
- 36:48Security Council, and that's basically where it's outlawed.
- 36:52From here onwards, I'm going to go to a description of what takes place.
- 36:57This comes from a website called the Friends of Falun Gong, so I just want to emphasize
- 37:01this is going to be a very one-sided view of what takes place from June 26th onwards
- 37:08to today.
- 37:09The CCP's persecution of Falun Gong is a comprehensive nationwide effort that encompasses
- 37:13many different forms of cruelty in humanity.
- 37:16Whether in an attempt to get Falun Gong practitioners to renounce their beliefs or to simply intimidate
- 37:20and attack them, the harshest and most painful forms of torture have been employed.
- 37:24The scope of the torture is very large, and the number of cases documented by the government
- 37:28of human rights organizations is well into the tens of thousands.
- 37:32The US Department of State, Amnesty International, the United Nations, Human Rights Watch, and
- 37:36other sources and investigations all corroborate the basic facts about the CCP's widespread
- 37:42torture of Falun Gong practitioners.
- 37:45Countless first-hand accounts of torture have also been recorded.
- 37:48Some of the most common forms of torture involve beating, shocking with electric batons, piercing
- 37:53with sharp objects often under fingernails, sleep deprivation, injections with toxic substances
- 37:59being physically restrained in painful positions, and being submerged in sewage in a dark chamber.
- 38:04What?
- 38:05Is Falun Gong the bad guys in the story?
- 38:09So far as this episode has led us to believe?
- 38:12No, they are without reason being personified.
- 38:15That makes me think we might learn new information on the next one.
- 38:19Okay, I'm just trying to figure out what to do with my thoughts.
- 38:23They're not organizing well here.
- 38:26I get that, and to be fair, this first episode is to give one particular viewpoint of what
- 38:32the Falun Gong is in its history.
- 38:35And to give it history.
- 38:36Financial incentives are used to extract confessions and encourage the renunciation of the practices
- 38:40from Falun Gong prisoners.
- 38:42When the torture of Falun Gong practitioners is taken too far, it can lead to the death
- 38:45of the victim.
- 38:46The communist regime will often involve family members as part of the torture.
- 38:50Sometimes they will get family members to cooperate by getting them to beg and plead
- 38:53with the victims to sign confessions or to give up their beliefs.
- 38:57It can also involve threatening and attacking loved ones or even torturing them in the presence
- 39:01of the victim.
- 39:02The CCP has killed numerous Falun Gong practitioners.
- 39:05It is very difficult to access the information needed to determine how many have been killed
- 39:09because the information is highly protected by the CCP regime and people responsible for
- 39:13the killing try and keep it a secret.
- 39:15Frequently, relatives are told that their loved ones have committed suicide or died from
- 39:19an accidental illness, but that bodies of the victims are cremated before they can be examined
- 39:23for evidence.
- 39:24Of the cases that have been verified, an unusually high percentage are people who died of their
- 39:29injuries shortly after being released from prison.
- 39:31As of May 2015, there are over 3500 cases of this confirmed.
- 39:35Two separate independent investigations about organ harvesting of Falun Gong prisoners
- 39:40concluded that over 60,000 Falun Gong practitioners were killed in the process of extracting their
- 39:45organs for transplants and that only encompass the period between 2000 and 2008.
- 39:50These numbers are including the number of confirmed deaths since the bodies are not
- 39:54available for examination.
- 39:56One of the most common forms of persecution is putting practitioners in prison.
- 39:59The CCP does not follow any rule of law and it can simply imprison Falun Gong practitioners
- 40:04at will without trial.
- 40:06Practitioners are routinely denied access to lawyers or the lawyers may face their own
- 40:10persecution if they have the courage to represent the practitioners.
- 40:14Whether it is prisons, labor camps, or brainwashing centers, hundreds of thousands of Falun Gong
- 40:18practitioners are estimated to be imprisoned at any given time and millions have faced
- 40:22prison over the course of their persecution.
- 40:25Various forms of detention facilities are used to hold and carry out abuses against
- 40:29practitioners and these are the locations where the torture brainwashing rate, forced
- 40:33slave labor, and other forms of abuse have been carried out.
- 40:37One of the apparent goals of the CCP in their persecution of Falun Gong practitioners is
- 40:41to give up their beliefs.
- 40:42This put the practitioners in a dilemma where they are greatly encouraged to either give
- 40:46up their beliefs or lie and say that they have given up their beliefs.
- 40:50However, lying goes against the principles of Falun Gong so many practitioners resist
- 40:55to give in.
- 40:56If they are forced under pressure to sign a statement slandering Falun Gong and promising
- 41:00not to practice, they can be rewarded by reducing their sentence, receiving better treatment,
- 41:04or better treatment for their families as examples.
- 41:06The prisoners who sign the statements are then often forced to transform other prisoners.
- 41:11If the prisoners refuse to sign the statement, then they can be threatened with additional
- 41:15punishment such as extended sentences, torture, or mistreatment of their family members.
- 41:20The method of brainwashing range from threats and cruelty to slander and forced study sessions.
- 41:25The prisoners are forced to watch videos or listen to recordings of material produced
- 41:30by the CCP intended to slander the Falun Gong, using any means of lying and deception to
- 41:34make their points.
- 41:36This is similar to the propaganda produced by the state-controlled media that is designed
- 41:40to attack Falun Gong with lies and slander and co-opt the general populace into supporting
- 41:44their vicious campaign.
- 41:46Another form of abuse the CCP carries out against Falun Gong practitioners is to fire
- 41:50them from their jobs, refuse to pay them for their work or pensions, or simply steal from
- 41:55them.
- 41:56Many times when the Falun Gong practitioners are arrested, the police simply take and keep
- 41:59their belongings, including very expensive or difficult to replace items such as computers,
- 42:04printers, bank cards, and IDs.
- 42:06Other times practitioners are fired from their jobs simply because of their beliefs, or their
- 42:10companies refuse to pay their salaries or their pensions.
- 42:13Frequently practitioners become homeless and destitute because they fled from their homes
- 42:18in an attempt to escape persecution.
- 42:20The CCP has integrated this slander and propaganda into all levels of school curricula so that
- 42:24children are indoctrinated with hatred towards Falun Gong.
- 42:28In addition, students are forced to agree with the slanderous answers in order to pass exams,
- 42:33including exams required to get into college.
- 42:35Therefore students who refuse to answer questions in a way that violates their beliefs can be
- 42:40denied the chance to advance in schools or receive the education they would otherwise
- 42:44have access to.
- 42:45Everyone taking the exam is forced to choose to agree with the CCP propaganda against Falun
- 42:49Gong in writing or lose points on their exam.
- 42:53The majority of citizens in western nations think of China as a nation that supplies cheap
- 42:57labor for a myriad of manufactured products.
- 43:00This narrative about China takes up more of the attention of the mainstream media.
- 43:04People who know more about the history of the CCP remember that they are carrying out brutal
- 43:08genocidal campaigns since they took control of the nation in 1949.
- 43:12Whether it was by the landowners, the business owners, religious leaders, intellectuals,
- 43:16or democracy activists, the CCP has engaged in systematic assaults on its own people that
- 43:21result in the murders of tens of millions of people as a matter of state policy.
- 43:25Just because this tendency has become less active since its peak in the 70s during the
- 43:29Great Cultural Revolution does not mean it had left the DNA of the CCP.
- 43:33The regime's capacity for suppression and violence came alive again during the Student
- 43:38Democracy protests in 1989 and it remains a threatening, subliminal, undercurrent hidden
- 43:43in the minds and hearts of the Chinese people.
- 43:45Many of whom witnessed the violence or heard stories of it from their family members.
- 43:50Indeed, Jiang Zemin, the main architect of the persecution against Falun Gong, was one
- 43:55of the leaders that directly ran the campaign in 1989.
- 43:58Since the CCP came to power through a revolution rather than an election, it always has to
- 44:03face the fact that it does not have the support, approval, or legitimacy of mainland China.
- 44:09This undercurrent can be found throughout the propaganda efforts of the CCP.
- 44:13The CCP uses censorship and its great firewall to make sure Chinese citizens don't have
- 44:18access to any information that it cannot control.
- 44:21This alone proves that the CCP fears its own citizens and it knows that it is not legitimate.
- 44:25Therefore, no powerful group or groups that could potentially become powerful are allowed
- 44:29to exist inside of China that are not directly overseen by the CCP.
- 44:34To this day, the CCP does not allow any larger powerful group to exist within China without
- 44:38being directly in control of it and it has never allowed anything close to a political
- 44:43competitor.
- 44:44And that is why it says Falun Gong believes it became too powerful and the CCP perceived
- 44:48it as a threat.
- 44:49Yeah, that's what I gathered from that very last sentence.
- 44:52And that's I think where I'm going to kind of cut it off here.
- 44:55It is still very persecuted in China.
- 44:59Li Hongjue, still very much so alive, he lives in New York State.
- 45:03Falun Gong is practiced worldwide.
- 45:06And in the next episode, we're going to talk about some of the things that got a little
- 45:10overlooked in this episode.
- 45:11Yeah, I'm excited to see where it goes because I'm assuming you took the viewpoint of Falun
- 45:17Gong on this.
- 45:18A little bit of the viewpoint of Falun Gong and we're going to take a look at the negative
- 45:22side of Falun Gong in the next episode.
- 45:24Okay, I feel like that's what I'm missing.
- 45:27So I'm looking forward to that, especially since this episode was not required because
- 45:33people were going to skip to the next one.
- 45:37Unless they started this episode.
- 45:39Yeah, in which goes why would they even know to skip to the next one?
- 45:43Okay, I'm excited because I feel a little lost right now.
- 45:47And I should also say because the Qigong Institute also had the interaction of the
- 45:51UFO group, like it's under the same heading of the government, banning of Falun Gong also
- 45:57leads to basically a banning of ufology.
- 46:00Didn't they leave that group?
- 46:02They did and we're going to get into why Falun Gong being persecuted in the next episode
- 46:08led to a banning of UFO research.
- 46:10Okay, I'm assuming it'll all come together for me.
- 46:13It will make a lot more sense in the next episode.
- 46:16Yes, that's okay, I'm begging on it.
- 46:18But for now, do not take this all as there's nothing wrong with the Falun Gong, they're
- 46:23being persecuted for no reason.
- 46:24The next episode will make a lot of sense of the things that are missing from this episode.
- 46:29No, I feel like there's definitely some gaps.
- 46:32Okay, until that time, I have been Taylor here with Chelsea.
- 46:35We are a journey to the fringe.
- 46:37Thank you all for listening and we'll see you next week.
- 46:38Oh, no, there's one more thing I wanted to add before we end this episode.
- 46:42Chelsea, I need you to go to the general chat because remember Falun Gong is based off
- 46:46of Qigong and Falun Gong has five specific movements for Qigong.
- 46:50So they're there.
- 46:51And Chelsea, I want you to look at them and I want you to tell me the names of them starting
- 46:55in the bottom middle.
- 46:56Falun standing stance.
- 46:58Let's go up to the top left.
- 47:00Falun heavenly circulation.
- 47:02The bottom left.
- 47:03Buddha showing a thousand hands.
- 47:06The top right, which is the only sitting position.
- 47:09Strengthening divine powers.
- 47:11And the bottom right.
- 47:13Penetrating the two cosmic extremes.
- 47:15Yes.
- 47:16Wow, that's a powerful dance.
- 47:18And those last two movements with very strange names are definitely going to allude to a
- 47:22lot of the things that get talked about in the next episode.
- 47:25Okay, good.
- 47:26So I think this is a good way to leave it off just because this starts to show some
- 47:30of the things.
- 47:31And also I got the payoff of my intro with that.
- 47:34Exactly.
- 47:35And now we just actually end it right here.
- 47:38Okay, sounds good.
- 47:40Bye.
- 47:41Thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe.
- 47:43If you have liked what you have listened to, please like, share, subscribe or follow,
- 47:49depending on what venue you are listening to us through.
- 47:52Also please, if possible, leave a five star review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 47:58Should you wish to interact with us, please check us out on your social media of choice.
- 48:03I bet you we are there.
- 48:05And if you really want to communicate with us and give us ideas for new episodes or tell
- 48:09us that we're wrong and terrible, either way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe.com.
- 48:16For now, I'll see you in the next episode.