Latest / Sages, Icons & Heretics / A Conversation with Greg Adkins
Transcript
- Sages Icons and Heretics A Conversation with Greg Adkins Mix: All right. Welcome to the first episode of the Stages, Icons, and Heretics podcast, where we explore voices from the world of management consulting. So for our first episode, I'm welcoming Greg Atkins. Greg and I have known each other or known of each other since the early nineties when we were both at Deloitte later in the nineties and stuck around for 14 years. After that, he went on. Twice to follow former partners into new ventures, where Greg rose to the ranks to become a partner and selling out both times when he did it. So first four years with one firm, and then finally 14 years with Calypso, where we've worked together for over a decade. Earlier in his career, Greg was a manufacturing engineer at IBM, went on to become a financial analyst and technical sales rep for Exxon. And prior to that was a chemical engineering major at Kentucky and went on to get an NBA from UNC Chapel Hill. And I think happily now Greg is retired with his wife Corey in Golden Colorado. And I think, Greg, you've become a traveler investor might be your title now. Is that right? I think, Steve, I think that's that's fair to say. Do a lot of traveling and also a lot of skiing and hiking. Two of our favorite activities in Colorado. Well good. Well I was looking forward to this conversation because I in your years at Calypso, your reputation became that of of being Yoda-like or being a Yoda for Calypso, the voice of reason, the grounding in management consulting. You were the, I think, voted on the inaugural executive committee and were the only one re-elected to the executive committee because of that, that stature in the firm. I always loved seeing you lead a bunch of different accounts for the firm across life sciences and CPG and retail footwear and apparel and doing it the right way. So I'm hoping we'll dive into a little bit about management consulting and get your get your wisdom about that. That sounds great. I had 32 years invested in it. So I hopefully drew a little bit of wisdom out of those 32 years. Cool. Okay. Well I just want to start off with why and how did you even get into consulting? Yes. Actually when you describe my background, it it says a little bit why I did. So I came out of graduate school. as an MBA and I was considering the traditional pathways for MBAs, banking and and consulting were two two of the primary ones. I didn't have a lot of work experience coming out of graduate school. So I didn't meet some of the criteria that some of the larger firms were looking for in terms of four or five years of work experience prior to getting an MBA. So I actually decided to go into industry for a few years. And over the course of that time in industry I had three different positions in in in about four years. And you couple that with the manufacturing engineering experience I had at IBM, I I had finance, marketing, sales, and manufacturing experience all within that period of time. I began to consider consulting and I went to work actually for Touch Ross, which is the predecessor for Deloitte. I went for went to work for Tuschros in 1989 as a senior consultant. And I really was excited about it and thought it would would really take advantage of the diverse background I had. So it's interesting. It was intentional. So you had the gleam, I guess, even as coming out of undergrad, this is something you might want to pursue. Yeah, I did. I interviewed with a couple of firms in grad school, Arthur Young. going back many years to some of the firms that predated people like Arthur Anderson and Ernst and Young, but I just didn't feel like I had the the experience. And some of them didn't think I did either. So industry made a lot of sense for a few years. And then when I had an opportunity to join Touche Ross, I was pretty excited about it. I thought it was a great place to start. It had a great culture. It had a history of being one of the better consulting firms in the audit, tax, and consulting field. And it worked out that way for me too, once I joined them. Great. So I mean, reflecting back, what was at the time the particular attraction about consulting? What was the gravitational pull that had you pursue this? Well, the one trait I have that's probably been with me since I was a young kid. was problem solving. I love problems. I love solving problems and just the nature of consulting, always addressing a new challenging problem, a new environment, a new set of factors to consider. That really made it very interesting to me. I think also just the fact that if you stay in consulting, you eventually gravitate toward a mature into more of a selling role. And I had a sales background at at Exxon and I enjoyed selling too. So it really combined a lot of the factors that I found interesting. And that's probably the primary reason. The other reason personally was that at Exxon, they had a program where if you were going to to move up in the ranks at Exxon, you moved, you physically moved about every two years early in your career. And I I moved twice in the four, four years or so I was with Exxon. So I was really looking at a future of constantly moving as I moved up the ranks. And I Didn't really want to do that with my family. So I I found consulting to be a really nice option where I could travel, but my family could stay s seated in one place. And and and my kids could go through a school system with kids that they knew and they grew up with. And I found that pretty attractive from a personal standpoint. So consulting a answered a lot of different questions for me. Great. Okay. So next I'm going to probe on a bit is the core of our profession is the core consulting process. It's based a bit in the problem solving you talked about. So what to you, what is the consulting process and what does it mean to the work and what we do for clients? I think if you talk to two or three different people in the business, you'll get different answers, what the consulting process is. But to me, it's a kind of a structured approach to consulting projects that help. Take not only the consulting team, but the client through the the process of the project. I mean, to me, it's four major stages of it. The first one is what I what a lot of people call the current stage, which is in essence problem identification, problem definition, includes a lot of analysis and diagnosis. So it's really the piece of it, the very early piece when you're really indoctrinating yourself with what the issues are that the client is really facing. How deep and broad are those issues? What are the root causes of those issues? What are the potential business benefits of being addressed those issues in different ways? That to me is the first stage. The second stage is then taking that information, that diagnosis, and beginning to develop a a future state. What is the future going to look like? What is the solution for the issues that you identify during the current state? To me, that's a a state that includes solution design and development. And that includes multiple elements that make up the solution. And the principal ones in consulting have historically been process people and technology and weaving together those elements to help deliver business value and business change. And then the third step, once you've developed a future state solution design and development is implementation, which is really where the rubber meets the road. Does the solution really deliver the business value that that you expect it to? And again, around those elements of process, people and technology, implementing those elements together to provide the client a solution, an implemented solution. And then lastly, after that, to me, it's a solution is only good if it's sustainable. If the solution is sustainable and business value can be drawn out of it over a long period of time. And so the last stage to me is really building a sustainable increase in organizational effectiveness, primarily through change leadership, but also tweaking the solution over time as new improvements can become apparent. So to me, those are the kind of the first the four stages of the consulting process. And then you can develop a lot of detail under each of those stages as you develop. the approach to in the individual project. It also becomes the fundamental structure by which consultants build these tools called methodologies, which are the detailed instruction set for how a consultant or a con a team of consultants would take a client through a particular project. It's the step-by-step to-do list, if you will, of how you conduct the project. Got it. So how did you learn this consulting process? Did you have any memorable project leaders or mentors and why were they memorable? Yeah, the two primary ways you or I did, and I think it just about everybody learns consulting and the consulting process. There's two ways. And I think most of the big firms leverage both these ways pretty effectively. The first one and the most basic one is just simply most firms provide classroom and online training that help new consultants learn what the consulting process is, what are the types of steps you work through, what are you looking for in each step, and what are the tools that some of the consulting firms use during different stages of the project. That's one, that gives you the basic ground rules of it. But the biggest step and the biggest way of learning it is what I call apprenticeship. And that is working close to the side of and hand in hand with really experienced consulting leaders. on projects, it's really on the job training. There's no better way classroom training and online training can do so much. But then you've got to really you've really got to try it out and you have to have be under the tutelage of experienced professionals in the business who've done it for many years who kind of know the the trade offs and the ins and outs. So I would say it's 90% apprenticeship and 10% something else. Okay. Yeah. I mean, was there a point in time where it like a memorable point where you realized how different consulting was than Exxon or IBM, or did it just sink in over time? It hit me pretty quickly because I think the first thing you notice in consulting is that it it's particularly hard balancing the requirements of the job and the balancing of the requirements of your personal life because there's so much travel involved. And over the years, I was in consulting thirty two or thirty-three years. Travel became Less of an issue as I went through my career. Early on in my career, I was on the road basically five days a week, almost every week, on client sites, sometimes Sunday night, almost always no later than Monday morning, and then staying typically all the way through Friday. And you can imagine doing that and trying to raise a family and take care of all the other things that you've got to take care of in your personal life. It hit me pretty quickly within a matter of months. And it was very different from what I was used to in in business. And it's good to see that over the decades that I was in consulting, first probably in the nineties, when the concept of three, four, five came into play, where people basically were not only traveling Monday through Thursday and spending Friday either in the office or in some cases at home, and beginning to take less burden of the travel. had the impact travel had on personal life. And then more recently with the pandemic and other factors involved, you see a lot of a lot more consultants who don't travel to sites and nearly as much as I did early in my career and may only travel to sites a a couple days a week, if that much in some cases, a lot more remote work. So to me, the travel was the biggest single impact. And then the second biggest impact early on was just the intensity of the work. You're always setting a cross the table from a client who knows that you're being paid handsomely to do what you're doing and they expect you to deliver and the expectations are pretty high and the clock's ticking from the day you the moment you step on side. So it's a kind it's a combination of pressures. It's personal pressure and it's also just the professional pressure of being a service provider to in most cases executive level people at a client. Great. So reflecting on that, was there a particular project in your formative years where you felt like you really learned a lot and it really projected you forward into mastering this profession? Yeah, definitely. I spent the first few years of my consulting career doing a lot of a lot of financial consulting, a lot of work in areas that provide that took advantage of my financial background that I had working at Exxon and my MBA was a finance MBA. Not as much. But then I got into large scale enterprise transformation. So in the nineties, the phenomenon that really drove consulting was the the use of large ERP solutions like SAP and Oracle to drive not incremental change, but but huge change in the way companies operated. And they provided the technical backbone to let companies work a lot more efficiently and effectively. And then on top of that, there was a phenomenon of reengineering where companies were Following the Michael Hammer School of Reengineering and really wholesale changing the way they they conduct their business and do work and looking more end to end in in terms of how to measure work and measure the performance of the outcome of work. So during that period of time in the mid 90s, when I got involved with that, the projects went from modest size when I was doing mostly financial consulting to huge size. One I worked on in particular was a It was a $200 million consulting project with somewhere in the neighborhood of two to 250 consultants on it for a company about 25 billion in in sales. And we were using SAP as a technology enabler. And we had we were given considerable latitude to really tackle a whole multitude of business problems across almost every single aspect of the company from product development to sales and marketing. To operations, to manufacturing, to supply chain, to finance. So we had a huge swath of scope. And being such a big complex project and such a big project to the firm we were with that had a lot of eyeballs on it and a lot of, I learned a lot. I got a chance to learn a tremendous amount. And there was a lot of great consultants on the project, and many of which became my personal friends over the years, and I still have relationships today with. That one was one that. Probably there's a before that project time for me and then there's a after that project time for me. That was the that was the birth of a different phase of my consulting life. I'm gonna shift gears a little bit. So I think about we were talking about the consulting process and how it works. It it hadn't changed that much since when you and I were senior consultants and maybe even the partners we grew up under, it probably looked pretty similar when they were senior consultants. So why do you think the this consulting process is Stood the test of time. Well, it was well founded, I think, because it it was really created by the founders of consulting back in the days of when there were only two or three firms that really did much consulting, McKenzie, BCG, and and Bain. But but when you really look at it, I think it's a it's an approach that's been that's really survived years of testing and refinement. And it's also a process that's been used by pretty much all the major consulting firms. And it's been the foundation for large scale change for decades. So I think there's just a purification process that's gone through, a hardening process that's just really made it proved its value. And I think also when you think about it, how many talented contributors over most industries and organizations contributed to it over the years too. It's just a it's just something that's been refined and refined and the thought process behind it is is pretty sound and been tried pretty thoroughly. Great. Okay. Can you think of I don't know, a client anywhere along the way where you really got to apply the consulting process end to end, it really worked like reinforce your reason for being in the profession. Is there any project that stands out? Well, I would go back to the one I was telling you about before because the reason the re one of the reasons it was a watershed for me that w it was because it was so successful and it was really it was really surprising. For me to see something that big and with that many moving parts and that many people involved and that much scope be that successful. And to me, that opened my eyes in a lot of different dimensions. I mean, number one, we had tremendous executive level commitment from the client. The change imperative was well thought out. The scope was broadly defined. And they put the most senior leaders in the firm on it from the client side, which that's the asset test. To measure how serious somebody is about a project. And when you follow that up with some of the tools we brought to the table, we used a a common uniform approach across the entire project. 200 consultants used the very same approaches for everything they did based on the same methodology. So we were all working uniformly together. And the funnest part of the funnest part was the current state, which I define I told a little bit about earlier as the first stage. We did a huge current state analysis around the world. So we were traveling as teams with client with our client counterparts around the world to different operational areas of their company and doing a a very detailed analysis of how they did business and how they did it differently than other parts of the the same company. And from that we were able to develop a a very stout business case to help drive and track the business change. So when you really look at that, the fact we were Doing all this on a global basis across probably 12 to 15 different countries in different country sites, and then coordinating that across the client team and the consulting team, it just taught me a lot. It gave me an opportunity to see how you do things on a big scale in this business. And I really came to appreciate what it took to make a project of that nature really run smoothly and really deliver the change you want to deliver. And I think the other last point is. We really changed the way that the client measured work, how they rewarded people for doing a good job, how they measured the effectiveness of their business, looking more end to end in terms of how the businesses were performing. It just taught me how you run a business the right way. And so that totally changed the way I looked at consulting and also taught me a lot about business simultaneously. Great. So I wanted to touch a little bit on the role of technology. in large consulting engagement. You as you mentioned, ERP was a big shift, you know, in our careers where technology played a more prominent role in the change that was the client was seeking. And now beyond ERP, there's just been an explosion of technologies in the latter part of your career. How do you think, you know, the possibilities of the role of technology know, impacts the consulting process or impacts what the range of options are for solving the problems you you talked about before. Well tremendously. initially back in the nineties when the answer was principally ERP and CRM, which customer relationship management, those tended to go hand in hand. Those were large scale common platforms used across the company. And they were very very formal in the way you use them. And if you try to to deviate very much from that formality and customize the system, it typically caused problems for the client. They may think they can benefit from those customizations, but the customizations come with a an evil side when you try to upgrade the software or change the software. I think that when you go to the late 90s with the advent of of the web and online services and then people beginning to use that to begin to not implement applications, but to implement software as a service in the 2000s and then now to the role of digital capabilities and particularly artificial intelligence. The time to decisions is getting faster and faster. The ability to anticipate future issues is getting better and better. And the ability to learn from the past to avoid problems in the future is getting better too. So you think faster smarter, more more productive. It just speeds up business. It speeds up the possibility of technology to solve business problems. And also you see a another angle too, which developed in the last 10 years, and that is using software to help solve social problems and help address social issues. And you begin to see that come up as technology becomes more sophisticated and artificial intelligence and capabilities like that come on Come online. So I just think I don't think there's an end to this. I think it's just you we just go through evolutional waves and we're just bigger and better at everything. With it, there comes some evils that we all know about and try to anticipate. And governments are trying to anticipate some of those potential problems downstream. It's a bit of an unending evolution, and it's certainly changed tremendously in my career. Well, when I was at Exxon, I was the first. person in our division to get what was called a compact luggable computer. It was about the size of a pretty large suitcase. And that was my computer. And it had a little orange screen in the corner. And I would carry that home from work. And then I was also one of the first when I was in sales, I was the first salesperson to carry a laptop and be able to to to do call reports and stuff electronically. You think now that is such a trite thing to do. compared to what we use technology for now. But I when I first started out in business, those were considered changing things, the world changing capabilities. So it's only gonna get faster and and brighter. Yeah. I remember lugging those orange screen compact things on the plane on Mondays. Yeah, trying to find a place to put them, you know, in the seat in front of you. Yeah, they're they were huge. And it's just it's hard to imagine when you did that. Just gives you an idea of how over thirty years how much things can change. So I'm next topic I want to move on to is just talking about people that do consulting. So when you over the years went you sold a project and you went to go staff it, what were the attributes of the consultants you were looking for, regardless of level, when you were going to the schedule and beginning to identify potential people to stuff on your projects? What are those key attributes you've looked for over the years? Yeah, I think they're probably the Same key attributes I look for when I was recruiting people too on campus or or in experienced hires. The basics are you have to be pretty analytical. You have to be reasonably intelligent. But I think going beyond those, there's certain key elements of someone's personality that I think really play an important role. I think you need to be a good listener. There's a lot to glean from a client, and you have to be able to ask good questions, and particularly to draw information out of a client and have to be a good listener to do that effectively. You have to, I think, have a service orientation or service mentality. And in other words, if you're in a service business, it's more about who you're serving, less about you. And if you have to be able to not let your ego get in the way or your emotions get in the way of ensuring you're serving the client properly. I think some other ones that are important, you've got to be hard working because the hours are long, the work is intense, the expectations are high, like I discussed earlier. You need to be able to really focus and cut through the noise. There's gonna be lots of noise in consulting, a lot of information, a lot more information that is not very useful than there is that is useful. But being able to focus and cut through that. And I think lastly, just you have to be easy to work with. More consultants I worked with that if I were to say why people failed in the business, it was not because they weren't smart or they weren't hardworking. It's because they just were difficult. They couldn't put themselves in a in the role and become easy to work with and really focus on serving the client as their top priority. It's not about their image. It's not about their exposure. It's about serving the client's needs and meeting the client's expectations or exceeding them. And lastly, you gotta enjoy the work. Everyone in consulting it tends to be similar in a lot of ways. there's certain strains of characteristics that are kind of common. But it truly enjoying the work, you've got to enjoy the work or your lack of enjoyment will come through and it'll be apparent to everyone in a it won't lead to good things. So those are kind of things I I look for. Yeah, that that makes sense. I you just can't do this profession for any length of time if you don't truly enjoy what you're doing. Yeah, I think I always felt like you can answer those questions in about two or three years. When I was with the Lloyd, I think we we measured the average length of a consultant's life from the time they hired there until the time they left. And turnover is always pretty high in consulting 'cause the personal demands are pretty high, but I think the average career is about four years. I think in two or three years if you really have an interest in making a career of this or whether this is just a another stop on a journey somewhere else. But the great part of it is the relationships you make with your colleagues as well as in the client with the client organizations are are relationships you can nurture and and maintain throughout your life, both professionally and and personally. So Even the turnover is is beneficial in lot of ways because those folks go into industry in a lot of cases and become VPs and presidents and CEOs of companies and you can draw upon those relationships that you may have made a lot earlier in your career. Well, great. I wanna we're getting a little bit more philosophical here, so I want to run with that. How has the consulting profession impacted your life? The consulting profession gets a bad rap sometimes, but how has it impacted your life and maybe how has it impacted the broader world. Yeah, I think I take the broader world first because the how it's impacted me is is probably a a good way to wrap up. But how it impacts the world to me is I think that you have an opportunity not only to effect change in a in an organization that you consult to, you can impact the career projectory and change the success rate of the individual client people you work with as well as the consultants on your team. And lastly, one of the things you really can appreciate a consulting over a period of many years is the impact that large consulting projects, particularly when you're really involved implementing leading industry practices, is how those leading practices and that business change ripples through the entire industry. I mean, you can see waves of change in life sciences or waves of change in communications industry or high tech or retail. You can see waves of change occur in industries that you play a role in because a lot of times the early, the early adopters to to business change, whether it be technology driven or non-technology driven, are sometimes some of the most aggressive and ambitious companies in those industries. And then the rest of the industry follows suit over time. And it's just tremendous to see the ripple effect of how those industries change. not only in one industry, but across industries over time. So I think that's probably the biggest thing that I observed that and and the personal change I saw in people I worked with and seeing how that that benefited them in their career going forward. But I think also just being able to learn in in in my case, the two big ones were how technology can drive business change, whatever that tech technology is, whether it be something that's as elementary as some of the things I did early in my career to some of the things that are being done now with digital technology, how that can drive business change, but also how you personally learn how to manage change and lead people and companies through change. And I think those are are some of the things that I learned a lot about over my career. And then lastly you'd mentioned personally, I go back to the one project I described early on. And the personal relationships I had. So a lot of the colleagues that I worked with on that project were colleagues that ended up starting Calypso. The two starting founding partners of Clipso were on that project and were peers of mine on that project. And then there were also additional people at Clipso and senior leadership positions that were on that project too. So that project not only taught me a lot, but it also set the foundation for a totally different direction for my own career. when I joined Clipso after I left a few years after I left Deloitte and being able to work with those same people again and then help grow Clipso into the entity that then ended up being bought by Rockwell and now is a major contributor to Rockwell's success. So it's just tremendous to see to establish those lifetime relationships and just see see where they go. And I'm still friends and even in retirement now, I I'm still friends with many of the people I worked with. Over the years. Yeah. You just can't seem to get rid of us now, can you? It's hard to. I tell you what. It is tough. Yeah. Well, our time is starting to wind down. I have one last question for you. If you were what's your best advice for someone who's in the very their very first year of consulting, maybe right out of undergrad or they've transferred over from corporate America, or maybe they've got a a graduate degree. And what's your best advice for them in that first year? My best advice is finding a mentor. Because the one thing that just about anyone in consulting needs, whether you're in a small firm or a big firm, is you need a mentor or men or multiple mentors, people who really will look out for you and help coach you through your career. And some of that is is can be technical coaching around the aspects of consulting, but a lot of it's personal coaching around around how to to work through an organization, how to solve problems, how to get yourself positioned to be able to be successful in in large, complex organizations that a lot of these service these service firms are. But I think really locating a mentor early in your career or mentors is one step that's real important. And the second one I would say is stay in contact with with past clients and past consulting colleagues throughout your career. And some of the very best advice I got was on my very first project. I was working for a senior partner at Deloitte. And we had just finished up the project. And he looked at me and said, Greg, we had Rolodexes back then, not contactless on computers. But he said, now you have your first entry to your Rolodex, stay in contact with the the client at least every 60 to 90 days. Call them, stay in touch with them. send them information. Basically they are gonna be part of now your network. Your networking consulting is tremendously important to your success long term, particularly as you become a a partner. So I think that what I'm going to is you see two aspects of relationships, finding a mentor or mentors, and then building your network and maintaining your network over time. And those two things come together to to lead to success in consulting if all the other things fall in place, working hard. In all the other aspects. Well, in true Yoda fashion, that was great advice, Greg. I I wanna thank you for a great podcast here. And I really appreciate you being the first victim. So thanks again. I really appreciate it. Steve, anytime. And I appreciate you inviting me. And I've I've enjoyed talking with you today. Thanks.