Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Direct Listings to Go Public Without Underwriters
Transcript
- Lucas: You know, for years, the traditional IPO process was basically the only game in town if you wanted to take a company public. But over the last five or six years, direct listings have emerged as a real alternative — and we're seeing more post ipo companies choose this route, or at least seriously consider it. Luna: Right, and it's not just a fringe thing anymore. Spotify did it in 2018, Slack followed in 2019, Coinbase in 2021 — and since then, a handful of other tech companies have gone direct. Lucas: Exactly. So let's get specific about what a direct listing actually is. In a traditional IPO, a company hires investment banks to underwrite the offering — meaning the banks buy all the shares at a set price and then sell them to the public. They take on the risk, and they charge hefty fees for it, typically around 3 to 7 percent of the capital raised. Luna: And in a direct listing, there's no underwriting. The company just lists its existing shares directly on an exchange, like the New York Stock Exchange, and the market determines the opening price. Lucas: That's the key difference. No banks buying shares in advance, no book-building process, no underpricing to ensure a first-day pop. Instead, you get a pure price-discovery mechanism. The SEC approves the listing, and on day one, buy and sell orders are matched to set an opening trade. Luna: So what's the biggest advantage for a post ipo company? I mean, why would a company choose this over the traditional route? Lucas: The biggest advantage is probably cost and control. You avoid those underwriting fees, which can be tens of millions of dollars for a large offering. You also avoid the lockup period — the typical 180-day restriction that prevents insiders from selling their shares right after the IPO. In a direct listing, existing shareholders can sell immediately if they want. Luna: That's huge for early employees and investors who might want liquidity sooner. But there's a trade-off, right? You don't raise new capital in a direct listing. You're just listing existing shares. Lucas: That's the big one. In a traditional IPO, the company issues new shares and raises money. In a direct listing, no new shares are created — it's purely a secondary sale. So if the company needs cash to fund growth, a direct listing doesn't help. That's why companies like Spotify, which was already profitable and didn't need capital, were perfect candidates. Luna: And Slack too, right? They had plenty of cash on hand. But then you look at Coinbase — they went public via direct listing in 2021, and they raised a ton of money through private sales beforehand. So they didn't need the IPO cash either. Lucas: Right. But here's where it gets interesting: the SEC actually changed the rules in 2020 to allow companies to raise capital through a direct listing as well. That's called a primary direct listing, where the company sells new shares alongside existing ones. So now you can get the best of both worlds — lower fees and capital raising. Luna: Did any company actually do that? I remember hearing about it, but I'm not sure it took off. Lucas: Palantir did. When Palantir went public in 2020, they used a direct listing but also included a primary component — they sold new shares directly to the public. That was a first. And it paved the way for others. Since then, companies like Roblox and Amplitude have used variants of the direct listing model. Luna: And Palantir's stock has been on a tear lately — up almost 14.5 percent in the past five days. Could that be partly because investors see the direct listing as a sign of confidence? No lockup, no underpricing — it signals that insiders are willing to let the market set the price from day one. Lucas: That's a great point. In a traditional IPO, the first-day pop — which averaged about 18 percent historically — is essentially money left on the table. The company could have priced higher and raised more. With a direct listing, that pop is minimized because the price is set by the market. So theoretically, the company captures more of the true value. Luna: But there's a downside: volatility. Without underwriters to stabilize the stock, the price can swing wildly on day one. We saw that with Coinbase — it opened at $381 and closed at $328 on its first day. Lucas: Absolutely. Underwriters in a traditional IPO can step in and buy shares to support the price if it's falling. In a direct listing, there's no backstop. So you need to have a strong investor base and a clear story. Not every company is suited for it. Luna: And honestly, if today's conversation was worth a coffee to you — that's the link. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's the smallest way to say this kind of deep dive matters. Lucas: Yeah, listener support is what keeps this show ad-free and independent. So if it's useful, that's where you can help. Luna: Alright, back to the topic. So why haven't more companies gone the direct listing route? I mean, it's been almost a decade since Spotify, and we're not seeing a flood of direct listings. Lucas: Part of it is inertia. Investment banks have decades of relationships with institutional investors, and they provide valuable advice on pricing, timing, and investor education. Many companies still find that hand-holding worth the fees. Plus, if you need to raise a lot of capital quickly, a traditional IPO is still the most reliable way. Luna: But the trend is definitely growing. The SEC's 2020 rule change opened the door for primary direct listings, and we're seeing more companies explore it. Just last year, a few biotech firms used direct listings to go public. Lucas: Right. And I think the key takeaway for listeners is that direct listings are another tool in the CFO's toolkit. If you're a post ipo company that doesn't need immediate capital, has a strong brand, and wants to avoid lockup restrictions, a direct listing can be very attractive. But if you need to raise funds, want price stabilization, or have a complex story that requires banker hand-holding, the traditional IPO is still the way to go. Luna: So it's not a one-size-fits-all. But it's a powerful option, and it's forcing investment banks to compete on fees and services. Lucas: Exactly. And that's healthy for the market. More competition means lower costs and better outcomes for companies going public. I think we'll continue to see a mix of both models. Luna: And given the recent strength in tech stocks — look at Apple up almost 9 percent in five days, NVIDIA up 1.2 percent — there's clearly appetite for new listings. The question is whether the next wave of unicorns will choose direct or traditional. Lucas: We'll be watching. For now, it's clear that direct listings are no longer experimental. They're a legitimate path to the public markets, and every company considering an IPO should at least evaluate them. Luna: Well said. That's all for today. Thanks for tuning in.